Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Equilibrium January 2008 Master
Equilibrium January 2008 Master
S
tart the New Year off structural and civil engineer- the Year in 2000, and has
Treasurer: right and off and attend ing firm headquartered in
Theodore E. Smith served as director and Chapter
the first ever Seattle Seattle, Washington. At president.
Past President: Chapter lunch meeting Tues- MKA Bob manages the
Ade Bright day January 22 at the College structural design of new Project Architect: NBBJ
Club in downtown Seattle. and renovated healthcare General Contractor: Turner
Directors 2006-2008:
and institutional facilities. Construction
Daniel Lake Thanks to a generous grant For the last five years, he has
Peter Somers by Degenkolb Engineers
served as Project Manager
and DCI Engineers, students
Directors 2007-2009: on the Harborview Medical
with current ID are invited
Philip Brazil to attend at no charge. Center expansion, including
Peter Opsahl the new Inpatient Expan-
YMF Representative: sion Building and the seis-
This lunch meeting program mic renovation of the hospi-
Cale Ash will feature the seismic up- tal’s North Wing. Bob has
Administrator: grade of Harborview Medical taught the seismic analysis
M. Lynnell Brunswig Center’s East Hospital/North portion of the SEAW spon-
Wing. This portion of the sored refresher course for
VISIT OUR WEBSITE: hospital is an existing nine-
www.seaw.org the SE Exam, and frequently
story, fully occupied, "Essential lectures at the University of
Facility" serving the region as Washington. He was also
the only Level 1 trauma cen- named SEAW Engineer of
In this issue ter in a five state area. Using
recommended FEMA proce-
From the Board 2
Meeting Recaps 3
dures, the optimum and most
cost effective seismic upgrade
Meeting Information
Meetings/Seminars 4 solution was determined to Date: Tuesday, January 22, 2008
Calendar 4 be fiber-reinforced polymer
(FRP) panels with fiber an- Place: College Club, 505 Madison, Seattle
YMF Corner 5 chors attached to the exterior Parking will be limited: Carpool or use
Opportunities 6 alternative transportation if possible!
face of the existing concrete
Memberships 10 walls. The FRP panels en- Time: 12:00 Lunch served
abled the building to remain 12:15 to 12:30 Business
occupied and functional dur- 12:30 to 1:30 Presentation
ing the renovation, and re- Menu: Halibut Steak Almondine, salad, rice, vegetable,
duced the upgrade cost to dessert
less than a third of the hospi-
Coming in February: tal's original budget. Exten- Cost: SEAW Members $25.00
sive testing of the FRP materi- Non-Members $30.00
ACI hosts our annual als was performed at the Uni- Students (with ID) FREE
joint dinner meeting: versity of Washington to con- Late Registration, add $ 5.00
firm hybrid properties and Reservation Deadline: Thursday, January 17
Wednesday, performance, and a nonlinear
REGISTER ONLINE at www.seaw.org, email seaw@seaw.org
February 13th at analysis was used to verify an or call 206/682-6026. Prepayment is appreciated!
"Immediate Occupancy" per-
McCormick & Schmicks formance level. No Mini-Seminar:
on Lake Union. Due to time limitations there will be no mini-seminar at this
Presenter: lunch meeting
Program by Robert D. Anderson, P.E., S.E.
January Meeting Business:
Cary Kopczynski & Co. Robert Anderson is a Principal A nominating committee will be selected to determine candi-
at Magnusson Klemencic As- dates for the 2008-2009 Seattle Chapter Board.
sociates (MKA), a 170-person
FROM THE BOARD: What A Long Strange Trip It’s Been
A bout five years ago, my friend
Steve remarked to me that
there had been more changes in
from structural engineers
throughout the country. Some
of the impetus behind this has
plexity. The opposite is often the
case. Lengthy text is the conse-
quence of provisions that are well
the codes and standards governing been from the federal govern- written and well coordinated with
the practice of structural engineer- ment through FEMA, which has related provisions.
ing in the past 5 years than in the provided much needed funding
25 years that preceded them. I can’t for the development of the Some of my colleagues have be-
speak for Steve, but I was certainly NEHRP provisions and other moaned the days when material
old enough at the time to know documents that line our office standards were reproduced in the
what he meant and to heartily shelves. UBC. Luckily, that is no longer the
agree with him. In the five years case. They were mostly pale cop-
since that remark, I haven’t detected The third reason is the transition ies of the originals: out of date
any let up in the pace of change. In from a regional to a national and not well maintained. This
fact, it has probably accelerated in consensus in the development practice of extraction was also not
that time and I suspect Steve agrees. of codes governing the built sustainable because of the code
So, why has this been happening, environment with the merging development processes main-
who has been doing this, will it ever of the regional model code tained by the model code organi-
stop and what do we do about it if it organizations (ICBO, BOCAI and zations (and now ICC). They were
doesn’t stop soon? I would like to SBCCI) into a single national and are formal processes struc-
briefly describe what I think are the organization (ICC). This may tured to ensure access for all indi- codes or point fingers at unsus-
three primary reasons for so much appear to have only an indirect viduals who have an interest in pecting academics, but to insist on
change. Then, I will try to explain effect on the practice of struc- participating. This access, how- codes and standards that are
when I believe it will slow down and tural engineering but it has had ever, comes at a cost: code devel- clear, concise and comprehensive.
what we can do to make sure it a profound effect on other de- opment hearings with strict time I can say that, of course, but what
happens. sign professions, especially ar- limits preventing the deliberation difference does it make unless it
chitecture whose practitioners necessary to develop technically actually happens? So, how does it
The first reason is three recent earth- are often our clients. sound standards. This necessary happen, who are those trying to
quakes: Loma Prieta (1989), North- deliberation does occur in the make it happen and what must
ridge (1994) and Kobe (1995). Col- Put these three reasons to- standards development processes they do in order for it to happen?
lectively, they had a profound effect gether and what you get is a of ASCE AISC, AISI, ACI, AF&PA
on how we design structures to tremendous amount of change and the other organizations you The codes and standards develop-
resist the effects of earthquakes and coupled with increases in com- will find in the lists of reference ment process in this nation suffers
taught us how much we still had to plexity, which I suspect many of standards in Chapter 35 of the from a chronic lack of funding. It
learn. Among lessons too numer- us are barely coping with. Will IBC. is largely voluntary, reliant on
ous to mention in this column are this seemingly ceaseless change contributions from individuals
the consequences of locating struc- slow down? Is there light at the I occasionally hear comments motivated to make a difference
tures in liquefaction-prone areas end of the proverbial tunnel? from practicing engineers in other who typically devote a great deal
(Loma Prieta) and the benefits of Yes there is. I see it. It’s dim, but regions of the country that the of their personal time to it with
redundancy (Northridge). it’s there. So, how do we move standards development commit- often little in return but reimburse-
more quickly to that light? tees of these organizations are ment of their travel expenses.
The second reason is the transition dominated by academics and SEAW is fortunate to have many
from a regional to a national con- The stage in which codes and their supposed lack of practical such individuals who have made
sensus in the development of stan- standards are developed is experience is responsible for and are making enduring contri-
dards governing seismic design. much larger now than it was much of the complexity in our butions far in excess of other
Until the mid-1990s, SEAOC was the when Steve and I began our codes and standards. I serve on SEA’s in this nation.
leader. Now, we have participation careers. The development proc- several of those committees. The
ess is more complex and reduc- academics who also serve contrib- Clear, concise and comprehensive
ing complexity within that proc- ute in a reasoned and measured codes and standards don’t just
ess is more difficult. The increas- manner and are not the cause of happen; they are made to hap-
The SEAW Seattle Chapter
Equilibrium is printed monthly ing complexity of codes and unnecessary or overly complex pen. That admittedly dim light I
from September through May standards has much to do with provisions any more than other see at the end of the tunnel could
and is available online at the increasing complexity of the committee members. I have be one of my wild imaginings but
www.seaw.org. Circulation by structures we design, which grown weary of such talk, which I I don’t think so. I believe what I’m
mail: approximately 550 copies. codes and standards must ac- seeing dimly is success, the
Articles, letters, and announce- believe comes from individuals
count for in order to ensure who typically don’t serve on these achievement of which will be in
ments are accepted by e-mail to public safety. These structures
seaw@seaw.org. committees and have little first direct proportion to our willing-
are brought to us by our clients, hand knowledge of the actual ness to make it happen.
Advertising rates (prepaid, architects, which are brought to
please): Help Wanted/Job influence academics have on In case you were wondering, yes, I
them by their clients, owners. them. Something can be said
wanted, $50 ; Display ads: did have a happy holiday season.
Quarter page, $90; Half Page, Are any of us willing to demand about the influence of industry
simplicity by demanding simpler I trust you did as well. Your com-
$120; Full Page $150; inserts, representatives but this column is
pre-printed 8 1/2 X 11 inch flat, buildings to design so that the ments on this column are wel-
getting long and I need to wrap it come.
$150. 10% discount for ads codes and standards governing up. Permit me to save that topic
running two or more months. their design can be simplified?
Deadline is the fourth Friday of for another day. -Phil Brazil, pbrazil@reidmidd.com.
the month. Contact SEAW for Let’s also not forget those les- There is a troubling aspect to this:
an Advertising Order Form. Phil Brazil is a senior engineer
sons learned from previous the results of trial designs by our with Reid Middleton. A member of
Except where noted, opinions earthquakes. Incorporating colleagues from an ongoing initia- SEAW since 1986, Phil is chair of
expressed in this newsletter them into codes and standards tive by SEI, which was recently
reflect those of the author and the Building Engineering Commit-
requires lots of words, some- reported in a column by Brent tee and the Wood Task Group, is
do not reflect or represent the times torrents of them. There
position of SEAW. Portions of Nutall, PE, SE, in the December, an active member of the Earth-
this newsletter may be repro- isn’t necessarily a correlation 2007 edition of Structure Maga- quake Engineering Committee,
duced provided credit is given. between the quantity of text in zine. My answer to this is not to and serves on the Seattle Chapter
code provisions and their com- blame it on the complexity of board.
Condolences
Dave Swanson of Reid Middleton Engineers and Memorial Donations
longtime active SEAW member, tragically lost his
Memorial Donations may be made to two organizations that
13 year old daughter, Emily, who was killed in an helped in Emily's recovery:
avalanche Friday, January 4th. Emily was hiking
with friends near Lake 22 when the avalanche
struck. Everett Mountain Rescue Unit Snohomish County Volunteer
C/O Ken Ohlsen Search & Rescue
SEAW members were notified by email of the me- 5506 Old Machias Road 5506 Old Machias Road
morial service, which was held Saturday January Snohomish, WA 98290 Snohomish, WA 98290
12th at Northshore Christian Church in Everett.
Please keep Dave, his wife Kim, son Bryan and daughter Megan in your thoughts and prayers.
Ben, tell us about your back- are in Portland and Seattle. and optimize the civil structures we also continue to develop
ground. Where did you gradu- to reduce costs; develop pedes- our relationship with both
ate? What types of activities were In my third year with Jacobs trian bridge connections to the Universities.
you involved with during college? Associates, I am currently work- light rail stations, and devise
ing as a staff engineer on the construction sequences for the Any advice for younger engi-
I received my undergraduate civil University Link Light Rail project tunnel and underground station neers considering involvement
engineering degree from Gon- for Sound Transit. My responsi- excavations. in a professional society such
zaga University in 2003, and my bilities include analysis and final as SEAW?
Master of Science in Civil Engi- design of the 3.15-mile under- How long have you been in-
neering from the University of ground light rail extension twin- volved with SEAW and the Fresh out of college, SEAW
Washington in Fall 2007. At Gon- bore soft ground tunnels and YMF? What are some of the and ASCE helped me develop
zaga, I was involved with ASCE underground stations at Capitol YMF outreach activities? key relationships with mem-
student chapter and was first Hill and University of Washing- bers of our profession. My par-
introduced to SEAW by Steve ton. The University Link exten- I attended my first Spokane ticipation in these organiza-
Hawk after working at Coffman sion is expected to be open for Chapter meeting in 2002 and tions helped me fine tune my
Engineers as a summer intern. service in 2016 and Jacobs As- have increased my involvement career goals and provide the
sociates is providing prime de- over the years. Since graduating connections and opportunities
Tell us about Jacobs Associates. sign services, tunnel design, from Gonzaga, I have been to achieve these goals.
How long have you been with station design and geotechnical working in Seattle and started
the firm and what projects are to get involved with the YMF. SEAW has continued to be a
engineering. We make up one- valuable resource with the
you working on? third of the Northlink Transit Last year, I started working as
the YMF outreach representa- design seminars, monthly
Last year Jacobs Associates cele- Partners, a Joint Venture be- meetings and conferences.
tween Jacobs Associates, HNTB tive and plan to double my ef-
brated its 50th anniversary of pro- forts for this new year. Now that I reflect on these
viding engineering and consult- and Earth Tech. I am part of a experiences, I feel compelled to
ing services with a focus on un- team of over 65 technical staff Last year we had tremendous continue my work as the YMF
derground construction. Over the members that perform the in- success hosting two lunches, outreach representative.
years, Jacobs Associates has de- depth analyses required to: one at the University of Wash-
veloped into a specialty firm for configure the tunnel ventilation ington and the other at Seattle Benjamin.piermattei@
heavy construction and tunnel system to meet life safety re- University. Not only do we at- soundtransit.org
engineering. Our local branches quirements, refine rail geometry tract new SEAW members, but
Membership
Membership Applications Applications Approved Dues Reminder
We show the following members unpaid for 2007.
Nathan Gollcher Basri Basri, Professional
The Seattle Chapter Board of Directors voted to
Cary Kopczynski & Co. Associate
BSc 1998 Universidade Federal extend the payment deadline to January 31.
Peter Brown, Associate Please be sure to pay your dues by then to retain
de Juiz de Fora, Brazil
MEng 2000 University of Al- Cheryl Burwell, MEMBER your SEAW membership!
berta, Canada Kit C. Chan, Associate
Licensed PE, Washington Karl Anderson* Michael Fitz Sri Rajah
Class: Professional Associate Erika Hansen, Associate
Douglas Applegate* Chris Frossard Dean Ratti*
Robert Lawson, Associate
Matthew Hopper Ahmad Asili Heather Hirst Gregory Schrader
Cary Kopczynski & Co. Ian Douglas Thomson Michael Bledsoe David Houchin William Shafer
BSCE 2001 Purdue University McQuade, Associate
Tim Carlson John Hutchins Todd St George
Class: Associate Asrade Mengstu, Associate Clint Chapman Jerry Jackson Hillary Stibbard-
Christopher G. LeVan Sarah Ng, Associate Bryan Collons Jon Keiser Terrell
KPFF Consulting Engineers Sabina Shakya, Associate David Cotton David Korpi Edward Thomas
BSCE 2004 Gonzaga University Seth Cutler Hans Lund Mans Thurfjell
MSCE 2005 University of Wash- Sage Shingle, Associate
Alexandre Dehoux Mike Mitchell* Charles Voelker*
ington James E. Stephens, Associate Nancy Devine Khoa Nguyen Jeff Walters
Licensed EIT, Washington Gerald Dorn*
Perry Welch, Associate Craig Nishina Lisa Wipplinger
Class: Associate
Xiao Wu, Associate Kinglsey Drake James Perrault*
Dennis Firth Jack V Peterson
Benjamin Fisher Jacqueline Putt