Professional Documents
Culture Documents
An Economic Analysis of Anemia Prevention During Infancy
An Economic Analysis of Anemia Prevention During Infancy
An Economic Analysis of Anemia Prevention During Infancy
MARCUS SHAKER, MD, MS, PAMELA JENKINS, MD, PHD, CHRISTINA ULLRICH, MD, MPH,
CARLO BRUGNARA, MD, BAO TRAM NGHIEM, BA,
AND HENRY BERNSTEIN, DO
Objective To compare the cost-benefit profile of reticulocyte hemoglobin content (CHr) with hemoglobin (Hb) alone and
Hb as a component of the complete blood count (CBC) for detection and treatment of iron deficiency in 9- to 12-month-old
infants.
Study design Cohort simulations were used to compare CHr with Hb from a societal perspective. Assumptions included a
9% prevalence of iron deficiency and testing characteristics/costs of CHr, Hb, and CBC (CHr <27.5 pg: sensitivity 83%,
specificity 72%, $11; Hb <11 g/dL: sensitivity 26%, specificity 95%, $5; CBC Hb<11g/dL, $15), as well as cost of iron therapy
($61 for established anemia). Sensitivity analyses were performed.
Results Under current market conditions, the incremental cost to diagnose and treat iron deficiency, compared with
diagnosing and treating anemia by Hb, was only $22 per patient screened ($440 per case of anemia prevented; number needed
to treat ⴝ 20). With a 10-year time horizon incorporating risks and costs of neurocognitive delays associated with untreated
iron deficiency, the cost of the CHr strategy was $280 per case of anemia prevented.
Conclusions CHr is an affordable strategy to prevent anemia in infants with possible iron deficiency. (J Pediatr 2009;154:44-9)
ron deficiency is the most common nutritional deficiency in the United States.1 Infants are at risk for iron deficiency from
I insufficient dietary iron, variable absorption, and rapid growth. Iron deficiency, with or without anemia, may impair mental
and motor development during infancy2-9 and result in impaired neurocognitive development, with lower behavioral,
cognitive, and motor scores during critical time periods.10
Hemoglobin (Hb) is the most commonly used screening test for anemia, but iron deficiency in infants may be present for
several months before it results in a decrease in the blood hemoglobin. Reductions in reticulocyte hemoglobin content (CHr)
reflect iron deficiency before anemia develops.10-12 A CHr of ⬍ 27.5 pg is a more accurate indicator of iron deficiency than
anemia, defined by a Hb ⬍ 11 g/dL, in healthy 9- to 12-month-old infants.13 Screening for iron deficiency with CHr can help
prevent iron deficiency anemia during infancy; however, the economic consequences of anemia prevention with CHr are
uncharacterized.
The objective of this analysis was to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of anemia
prevention during infancy with CHr screening. We performed economic modeling of
diagnostic strategies using CHr and Hb to diagnose iron deficiency. We sought to
determine the cost-effectiveness of CHr versus Hb testing and threshold costs for anemia From the Children’s Hospital at Dart-
prevention. mouth, Lebanon (M.S., P.J., H.B.), The Cen-
ter for the Evaluative Clinical Sciences (M.S.,
P.J.), Dartmouth College (B.N.), Hanover,
METHODS NH, the Dana Farber Cancer Institute
(C.U.), Children’s Hospital (C.B., H.B.), Bos-
Description of the Model ton, MA.
The authors have no conflicts of interest to
We used a computer-based mathematical model (TreeAge Pro 2005 Suite, Wil- declare.
liamstown, MA) to perform cohort simulations of competing diagnostic strategies used to Submitted for publication Dec 11, 2007;
evaluate iron deficiency (Figure 1). The model follows hypothetical cohorts of patients at last revision received Apr 28, 2008; ac-
cepted Jun 24, 2008.
risk for iron deficiency. In cohort simulation, transitions are experienced by the proportion
Reprint requests: Marcus Shaker, MD,
of persons in each state corresponding to transition probabilities. Monte Carlo micro- Dartmouth-Hitchcock Medical Center, De-
simulation allows individual patients from hypothetical cohorts to cycle through transi- partment of Pediatrics, One Medical Cen-
ter Dr, Lebanon, NH 03756. E-mail:
marcus.shaker@dartmouth.edu.
ARR Absolute risk reduction NNS Number needed to screen 0022-3476/$ - see front matter
CBC Complete blood count NPV Negative predictive value Copyright © 2009 Mosby Inc. All rights
CHr Reticulocyte hemoglobin content WTP Willingness to pay reserved.
Hb Hemoglobin
10.1016/j.jpeds.2008.06.038
44
Table I. Baseline assumptions and probabilities
Name Value
Costs*
CHr screening test15 $11
Hb screening test15 $5
Complete blood count15 $15
Treatment cost of anemia (3 month course)* $61
Treatment cost iron deficiency (3 month course)* $61
Treatment cost of iron deficiency for (1 month $20
course)*
Probabilities
CHr screening test ⬍ 27.5 pg13
Sensitivity 83%
Specificity 72%
Hb screening test ⬍ 11 g/dL13
Sensitivity 26%
Specificity 95%
Additional Assumptions in 10 year time horizon
Figure 1. Decision model: decision tree to evaluate competing diagnostic Second test probability (independent testing 60%
strategies for iron deficiency. characteristics, Hb test performed)17
Annual attributable risk of neurocognitive disability
requiring services
tional probabilities14 and was used to estimate variance from Untreated anemia7 10%
stochastic uncertainty (n ⫽ 1000 per cohort). Strategies were Treated anemia 0%
Annual (transient) charges of services† for $500
modeled over 3-month and 10-year time horizons. The ref-
neurocognitive delays, if required
erence population for this model was 9- to 12-month-old
*Local cost estimates.
infants. The prevalence of iron deficiency for the reference
†Costs of cognitive delay were derived from local charges18 published by the
population was estimated at 9%.1 Dartmouth-Hitchcock Medical Center (Lebanon, NH) of physician visits (CPT 99213
charge $118 per visit) and potential developmental assessment (CPT 99243 charge $335
per visit or 99244 charge $412 per visit).
Diagnostic Strategies
Definitions and Assumptions
We examined 3 potential approaches in the evaluation
Effectiveness was defined by the number of patients in
of iron deficiency. Diagnostic accuracy of each strategy and
whom early CHr detection and treatment of iron deficiency
response rates were extracted from published literature. An
prevented subsequent anemia. This was calculated with the
approach with CHr and subsequent treatment was modeled
absolute risk reduction (ARR) in missed diagnosis between Hb
against a screening approach for anemia with Hb alone or as
and CHr (negative predictive value [NPV]CHr ⫺ NPVHb). The
part of a complete blood count (CBC). Three-month courses number needed to screen (NNS) to prevent 1 case of anemia
of iron therapy were prescribed both for subjects with a CHr was calculated with the inverse of the ARR (1/ARR). Cost per
⬍27.5, as well as for established anemia. Diagnostic accuracy case of anemia prevented was then calculated by the product of
was modeled from published sensitivity and specificity of the the difference in per-patient screening cost (CHr ⫺ Hb) and the
CHr ⬍27.5 (sensitivity 83%, 95% CI 61%-95%; specificity NNS. The market costs of anemia diagnosis and treatment
72%, 95% CI 65% to 78%).13 Ullrich et al demonstrated that were calculated per correct diagnosis with the product of the
a CHr of less than 27.5 pg without anemia at initial screening per-patient screening cost (Hb) and the inverse of the positive
was associated with subsequent anemia on re-screening in the predictive value (PPV)Hb (1/PPVHb). Costs of repeated physi-
second year of life (risk ratio 9.1, 95% CI 1.04-78.9, P ⫽ cian visits and downstream costs, including developmental
.01).13 Published literature on accuracy of Hb less than 11 effects from delayed diagnosis of iron deficiency, were not
g/dL in the diagnosis of anemia in this age cohort was used included in the short-term model, but costs of subsequent
(sensitivity 26%; 95% CI 10%-48%; specificity 95%, 95% CI neurocognitive delay were considered in the long-term model.
91%-98%).13 Market costs (current dollars) were estimated Progression from iron deficiency to anemia was assumed.
from a societal perspective with the laboratory fee schedule Costs were discounted at 3% per annum to reflect the average
from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services15 (CHr annual consumer price index for all goods and services in the
⬍27.5 pg: $11; Hb ⬍11 g/dL: $5; CBC: $15). Local esti- long-term model.16
mates were used for the costs of iron therapy ($20.30 per
month). Baseline variables are shown in Table I. The cost of Sensitivity Analyses
each strategy was defined as the total costs for diagnosis and In each cohort baseline parameters were varied within a
treatment. clinically reasonable range to evaluate the preferred diagnostic
proached $3.50, the cost of anemia prevention fell below the Figure 3 depicts the 3-way sensitivity analysis of second test
current market value of treatment (Figure 2). probability, risk of disability, and cost of disability. In further
sensitivity analyses with the 10-year time horizon, the cost of
Long-Term Model, Base Case CHr was $10 per case of anemia prevented, when a short
Incorporating downstream costs of disability over a 10 treatment course (1 month) was prescribed for iron deficiency
year time horizon was associated with lower incremental cost detected by CHr and compared with a 3-month treatment
of CHr screening ($55 per patient screened; 95% CI $46.80- course for Hb.
$63.20) when compared with Hb ($41 per patient screened
(95% CI $31.85-$50.15)). With a 10-year time horizon in- DISCUSSION
corporating risks of neurocognitive delays, the cost of the Our analysis suggests that in healthy 9- to 12-month-
CHr strategy was $280 per case of anemia prevented. old infants, CHr is an affordable screening strategy to prevent
anemia, costing approximately $440 per case when a short-
Long-Term Model, Sensitivity Analyses term time horizon is used and $280 when a 10-year time
Sensitivity analysis demonstrated that CHr was a less horizon in used. Because earlier diagnosis of iron deficiency
expensive initial screening method than Hb when the annual may allow shorter treatment courses than for established
cost of therapy for neurocognitive delay exceeded $1180. anemia, the cost may actually be closer to $180 per case of