Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 6

A population-based study of help-seeking for

self-harm in young adults

Shyamala Nada-Raja, Dianne Morrison, Keren Skegg

Objective: To examine help-seeking for self-harm in a population-based sample of young


adults.
Method: Nine hundred and sixty-five participants aged 26 years were interviewed about
help-seeking and barriers to help-seeking for a range of self-harmful behaviours. Self-harm
included the traditional methods of suicide (ICD-9 self-harm) and other self-harmful behav-
iours such as self-battery and self-biting.
Results: Just over half of the 25 in the ICD-self-harm group (based on ICD-9 self-harm
criteria) and one-fifth of the 119 in the other self-harmful behaviour group had sought
professional help. Counsellors, psychologists, and general practitioners were the commonest
sources of help. Most participants rated help received from health services favourably,
however, emergency services were rated less favourably than other health services. Among
77 self-harm participants who did not seek help, just over one-third reported attitudinal
barriers.
Conclusions: To encourage help-seeking by young adults who self-harm, especially young
men who are at high risk for self-harm and suicide, it may be necessary to identify ways to
reduce attitudinal barriers.
Key words: young adults, help-seeking, self-harm, service use, population-based
sample.

Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 2003; 37:600–605

Self-harm is an important public health problem in people who have presented to medical services [3]. Little
New Zealand [1]. In 1998, there were 2596 hospital is known about help-seeking by people who self-harm
discharges coded as non-fatal self-inflicted injury in and are not known to medical services.
New Zealand, which accounted for 6% of all injury- Appleby et al. highlighted the potential value of early
related hospitalizations in that year [2]. Studies of help- treatment for those who repeatedly self-harm [4]. Among
seeking following self-harm are generally based on those not presenting to health services, there may be a
group who could be ‘caught early’, so it is important to
Shyamala Nada-Raja, Principal Investigator, Self-harm Study (Corres- determine their patterns of help-seeking and barriers to
pondence) seeking help. A further gap in current knowledge is
Injury Prevention Research Unit, Department of Preventive and Social related to help-seeking for self-harm that falls short of
Medicine, Dunedin School of Medicine, PO Box 913, University of
Otago, Dunedin, New Zealand. the traditional definition for self-harm. Behaviours such
Email: shyamala.nada-raja@ipru.otago.ac.nz as deliberately hitting oneself (self-battery), although
Dianne Morrison, Assistant Research Fellow often regarded as medically trivial, might repay early
Department of Psychology, University of Otago, Dunedin, New Zealand intervention in the hope of averting more life-threatening
Keren Skegg, Specialist Psychiatrist and Senior Lecturer self-harm. Thus, it is desirable to assess help-seeking
Department of Psychological Medicine, University of Otago, Dunedin, for these behaviours in representative population-based
New Zealand
Received 30 July 2002; second revision 24 July 2003; accepted 25 July
samples, not just in selected groups presenting to
2003. medical services.
S. NADA-RAJA, D. MORRISON, K. SKEGG 601

One reason it is desirable to know about help-seeking sample adequately represents all socioeconomic levels in New Zealand
among people who self-harm is because of the link [17]. Seven percent of the sample self-identified as Mãori.
between self-harm and treatable psychiatric disorder. This
has been found in both hospital [5,6] and community- Measures
based studies [7,8]. Many with mental health problems
do not seek or receive help [9,10]. One route to assessing Participants completed a 20 minute semistructured interview on
self-harm thoughts and behaviours [18]. In face-to-face interviews, the
and treating them is if they seek help in relation to self-
self-harm questions were asked in the context of dealing with mental or
harm, which may be the event that finally brings a
psychological pain, emotions, or stress rather than using the term
person to the attention of medical services. ‘suicide’ initially. At the end of their interviews, all participants
The role of family and friends in providing help has received a list of support services for self-harm and its related aspects.
received some attention for mental health problems, in Most self-harm interviews were conducted by the self-harm research
general [11,12], but little is known about this aspect of team members (including the first two authors), who have postgraduate
help-seeking among those who self-harm. qualifications in psychology and counselling or clinical skills. The
Given the high risk for repetition of self-harm and interviewers were specially trained for the study.
suicide, by those who have made a prior suicide attempt Two categories of self-harmful behaviour reported in the previous
[13], it is important to identify barriers to seeking help year were examined. The first category, ‘ICD-self-harm’, was defined
among those who engage in self-harm. Research into according to methods specified in International Classification of
Diseases (ICD-9) E-codes 950–958 for suicide and self-inflicted
barriers to help-seeking in people with lifetime mental
injury. The second category, ‘other self-harmful behaviours’ or lesser
health problems has shown that they were often attitudi-
forms of self-harm, comprised deliberately hitting oneself or putting
nal (e.g. a feeling that the problem would get better by one’s fist through a wall (i.e. self-battery), denying oneself a necessity
itself) rather than practical. Family or environmental such as food as a means of punishment, exercising excessively to
characteristics such as receiving household public assist- deliberately hurt oneself, and self-biting or wounding. We also exam-
ance have been found to predict service use particularly ined intoxication by alcohol or drugs to deal with emotional pain.
in urban users [10], and low socioeconomic status was For any self-harm behaviours listed above, occurring in the year
found to predict help-seeking for emotional problems prior to the interview, participants were asked if they received help for
[14]. Help-seeking for mental health problems was either physical consequences or other aspects (generally psycho-
found to be less likely among those with lower educa- logical) related to those behaviours. Affirmative responses led to
tional qualifications [15], but there have been conflicting further questions about formal (professional) and informal (family and/
or friends) sources of help consulted or received, satisfaction with help
findings with regards to low income [15].
received from each source, and main reasons for seeking help. Those
The aim of the present study was to examine help-
who had not sought help, but reported self-harm behaviour in the past
seeking behaviours not only for self-harm involving year were asked to indicate barriers to help-seeking from a list of
traditional methods of suicide, but also for other self- potential barriers [9].
harm such as self-battery and self-biting in a represen- Demographic measures from a separate assessment included level of
tative population-based sample of young adults. The educational attainment, employment, and socioeconomic status in the
specific aims were to: (i) determine the prevalence of previous year.
help-seeking for self-harm in the previous year; (ii)
identify sources of help, levels of satisfaction associated Analyses
with help received from each source, and correlates of
help-seeking; and (iii) identify barriers and correlates Chi-square tests or Fisher’s exact tests as appropriate were used to
of barriers to help-seeking. examine associations between help-seeking and self-harm behaviours,
and gender differences.

Methods Results

Sample Of the 965 in the sample with data on self-harm behaviours and help-
seeking for the previous year, 25 (3%) reported one or more episodes
The participants were aged 26 years and belong to a cohort of 1037 of ICD-self-harm. More than half in this group (n = 15) reported an
children born in Dunedin between 1 April 1972 and 31 March 1973 overdose and nine had deliberately cut themselves. A total of 119
[16]. Since their birth they have completed a variety of health, behav- (12%) reported one or more episodes of other (lesser forms of) self-
iour, and background assessments. They were first followed-up at age harmful behaviours in the past year. These comprised deliberately
3 years, thereafter biennially until age 15 years, and later at ages 18, hitting oneself or putting one’s fist through a wall (i.e. self-battery,
21 and 26 years. The present study is based on 965 participants n = 92), denying oneself a necessity such as food as a means of punish-
(471 women and 494 men, representing 95% of the surviving cohort) ment (n = 27), exercising excessively to deliberately hurt oneself
with complete data for self-harmful behaviours and help-seeking. The (n = 8), and self-biting or wounding (n = 4). Of the remainder in the
602 HELP-SEEKING FOR SELF-HARMFUL BEHAVIOURS

sample, 138 (14%) only reported one or more episodes of intoxication consulted, followed by counsellors or psychologists, and emergency
by alcohol or other drugs, specifically to deal with emotional pain. A services. Significantly more women (59%) than men (21%) had con-
total of 683 (71%) reported no episodes of ICD-self-harm, other self- sulted a counsellor or psychologist (χ2 = 5.39, 1 df, p < 0.05), and
harmful behaviours, or intoxication as a way of dealing with emotional significantly more men (53%) than women (18%) had consulted an
pain in the previous year. Of the total number of episodes reported for emergency service (χ2 = 4.76, 1 df, p < 0.05). A total of 7 of the 25 in
each behaviour, suicidal intent was involved in 9% of the 213 ICD-self- the ICD-self-harm group and 6 of the 119 in the other self-harmful
harm episodes, none of the 1573 other self-harmful behaviour episodes, behaviour group (9% overall) had consulted other professional ser-
and 0.2% of the 2296 intoxication episodes. Similarly, an injury was a vices such as social or educational services, government departments
consequence of 11% of the ICD-self-harm episodes, 15% of the other (e.g. welfare services), telephone counselling, self-help or support
self-harmful behaviour episodes, and 0.8% of the intoxication episodes. groups, and religious services.

Help-seeking for self-harm Informal help-seeking for self-harm

A total of 80% of the ICD-self-harm group (7 of 10 women and 13 Informal help (i.e. help received from family or friends) was reported
of 15 men) had consulted and/or received formal (professional) or by 68% (n = 17) of the ICD-self-harm group and 30% (n = 36) of the
informal (from family or friends) help for either physical consequences other self-harmful behaviour group. Combining data for both self-harm
of self-harm or related aspects. This compared with 40% of the other groups, similar proportions had consulted family (22%) or friends
self-harmful behaviour group (23 of 46 women and 24 of 73 men) who (29%). Significantly more women (32%) than men (16%) consulted
had sought help. The proportions of the two groups who had sought family (χ2 = 5.22, 1 df, p < 0.01). Those who reported informal help-
help from any source on more than one occasion were similar (75% of seeking (47%) were significantly more likely than those who did not
the ICD-self-harm group compared with 70% of the other self-harmful (14%) to also report formal help-seeking (i.e, from professional
behaviour group). The main reasons given for seeking help were similar services) (χ2 = 18.65, 1 df, p < 0.01).
for both groups; emotional or psychological aspects related to self-harm
(e.g. depressed mood) was a reason given by 75% (n = 15) of the ICD- Satisfaction with help received
self-harm group compared with 62% (n = 29) of the other self-harmful
behaviour group; specifically for self-harm reported by 30% (n = 6) Participants who sought help for self-harm in the previous year rated
compared with 9% (n = 4); or for an injury following self-harm their satisfaction with the help received from each source on a 4-point
reported by 25% (n = 5) compared with 6% (n = 3). scale of ‘very unhappy’ to ‘very happy’. Results are reported for the
combined two groups of self-harm because few in each group reported
Formal help-seeking for self-harm seeking help from each source. General practitioners (84% or 16 of 19
who had sought help from a GP), psychiatrists (83% or 5 of 6), and
Formal help was defined as help received from health or other psychologists or counsellors (79% or 11 of 14) were rated favourably
professional services. Just over half the ICD-self-harm group (n = 14, by most who had sought help from each source. However, a lower pro-
56%) and 20% (n = 24) of the other self-harmful behaviour group had portion of those attending emergency services (62% or 8 of 13) rated
received formal help in the previous year. Overall, this represented 26% the help they received favourably. Family were rated favourably by
of the combined self-harm groups. 91% (10 of 11 who consulted family) in the ICD-self-harm group and
Table 1 summarizes the types of health professionals consulted by 95% (20 of 21) in the other self-harmful behaviour group. Similarly,
each of the two self-harm groups in the previous year. For both groups, friends were rated favourably by 92% (12 out of 13) and 100% (all 28)
general practitioners were the most common health professional in the two self-harm groups, respectively.

Table 1. Type of health services consulted in the past year by women and men who reported ICD
self-harm and other self-harmful behaviours at age 26 years

Type of service† ICD-self-harm Other self-harmful behaviours


Women Men Women Men
n = 10 n = 15 n = 46 n = 73
Any health service 5 (50%) 8 (53%) 12 (26%) 11 (15%)
General Practitioner 4 (40%) 3 (20%) 7 (15%) 5 (7%)
Psychiatrist 1 (10%) 3 (20%) 0 (0%) 2 (3%)
Emergency Services 1 (10%) 8 (53%) 2 (4%) 2 (3%)
Psychologist/counsellor 2 (20%) 2 (13%) 8 (17%) 2 (3%)
Hospitalized/Intensive care 0 (0%) 2 (13%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%)
No health service 5 (50%) 7 (47%) 34 (74%) 62 (85%)

Participants could report more than one service.
S. NADA-RAJA, D. MORRISON, K. SKEGG 603

Demographic characteristics of formal help-seekers personal questions; or a member of family objected) were reported by
for self-harm 8% (n = 2) of the women and 6% (n = 3) of the men. About 5% in the
group reported that although others thought it necessary for them to
Numbers in each group were too few to enable separate analyses to seek help, they themselves considered it unnecessary.
be conducted for each self-harm group. Formal help-seekers for self- In the intoxication group of 138, 66% reported no formal or informal
harm (i.e ICD-self-harm or other self- harmful behaviours, 17 women help-seeking in the previous year, mostly because they considered it
and 21 men) were compared on demographic characteristics with those unnecessary. The proportions of women (53%, n = 19) and men (38%,
who did not seek formal help (39 women and 67 men). A higher pro- n = 21) who reported attitudinal barriers did not differ significantly.
portion of women formal help-seekers (65%) compared to 36% of those Practical barriers were reported by 14% (n = 5) of the women and 2%
who did not seek formal help were unemployed at the time of their (n = 1) of the men. Fear or stigma-related barriers were reported by
interview, but this difference was not statistically significant. The none of the women and 7% (n = 4) of the men.
groups did not differ significantly in educational achievement or
socioeconomic status. Significantly more men who reported formal Discussion
help-seeking (57%) were from a low socioeconomic status compared to
those who had not sought formal help (28%) (χ2 = 5.81, df = 1, In this population sample of young adults, nearly half
p < 0.05). of those who reported self-harm (i.e. ICD-self-harm or
other forms of self-harmful behaviours) had sought help
Help-seeking for intoxication either from professionals or from family or friends in the
past year. Formal help-seeking was quite common, being
A total of 138 reported intoxication by alcohol or drugs to deal with reported by one in four in the self-harm group as a
emotional pain in the previous year, but none of any of the other forms whole, and half of the ICD self-harm group. It was
of self-harmful behaviours enquired about in the self-harm interview. encouraging to find that many young adults who self-
About one-third (34%) of this group reported formal or informal help- harmed had actively sought assistance from a variety of
seeking. Eleven percent reported formal help-seeking. Almost 1 in 10 professional and other sources. This may have provided
had consulted health services; the commonest sources of help were a an opportunity for receiving advice and treatment and
psychologist or counsellor (9 of 13) or a general practitioner (6 of 13). might even have prevented progression to more serious
Family was consulted by 17% and friends by 31%. Most (81%)
self-harm.
reported seeking help for emotional or psychological reasons rather
Young adults who reported self-harm, which was most
than intoxication per se or associated injury.
All who consulted a counsellor, psychologist, or general practitioner
often minor, were more likely to have consulted general
rated them favourably, as did two of the three participants who had practitioners, counsellors, and psychologists than psychi-
consulted a psychiatrist. The only person who attended an emergency atrists or emergency services. The finding that this group
service rated the service unfavourably. More than 80% of the 46 who of professionals was generally rated favourably supports
consulted family or friends rated the help they received from them the importance of this group in the assessment and
favourably. prevention of self-harm by young adults (e.g. guidelines
recently developed by the Royal New Zealand College
of General Practitioners for the detection and manage-
Barriers to help-seeking
ment of young people at risk of suicide).
Five of the 25 in the ICD-self-harm group and 72 of the 119 in the
Medically serious self-harm is more likely to come to
other self-harmful behaviour group reported not seeking any formal or the attention of emergency services than general prac-
informal help in the previous year. Given the small numbers in the ICD- titioners or counsellors. Thirteen young adults in our
self-harm group, results from the analyses examining potential barriers study, mostly men, reported having attended an emer-
to help-seeking are reported for the two self-harm groups combined for gency service in the past year after self-harm. It was of
women and men separately. Of the 144 in the combined self-harm concern to note that nearly one-third of them, all men,
group, 77 (54%) had not sought any help for self-harm or related behav- rated the help they received unfavourably. No data were
iours. Most (83%) considered it unnecessary to consult anyone. Attitu- collected on the reasons for unfavourable ratings, how-
dinal barriers (e.g. thought should be strong enough to handle problem ever, it may be reasonable to speculate that resource and
on their own; thought problem would resolve itself; did not think
staff constraints of many emergency services and the
anyone could help; or too embarrassed to discuss it with anyone) were
need for triage may result in more dissatisfaction with
reported by 39% each of the women and men (i.e. 10 and 20, res-
pectively). Practical barriers (e.g. lack of time; unable to get to health
the service received from emergency services than from
service; could not afford to pay bill; did not know of any place to go for general practitioners or counsellors. Attendees may be
help; inconvenient hours, or appropriate service did not exist) were more unwell than self-harmers who present to other
reported by 12% of the women (n = 3) and 10% (n = 5) of the men. health services, another factor that may influence the
Barriers indicative of fear or stigma (e.g. afraid of what others may perception of emergency service attendees’ ratings of
think; afraid of being hospitalized; afraid of treatment; hated answering help or support received. The small number reporting
604 HELP-SEEKING FOR SELF-HARMFUL BEHAVIOURS

emergency service use suggests that the above findings need to seek help, perhaps because they recognized the
should be interpreted with caution. self-limiting nature of their problems. This could well
Studies that focus only on formal help-seeking cannot have been true for some who reported self-harm in the
consider the contributions that informal help-seeking can present study. Nevertheless, one-third reported attitudi-
make to support those who self-harm. In the present nal barriers to help-seeking, and it is likely that some
study, just over one-third in the combined self-harm who were in need of help did not seek help, largely
group had consulted family or friends, with friends being because of these attitudinal barriers rather than practical
the preferred source. Furthermore, those who reported ones.
informal help-seeking were significantly more likely to
also report formal help-seeking for self-harm. These Conclusion
findings support those from a study of French adoles-
cents’ help-seeking behaviours for psychiatric problems We agree with Pirkis et al. [22] who commented that
which found that the choice of a confidante was impor- more research is required on the patterns of help-seeking
tant in determining whether a mental health professional by those who engage in self-harm (including suicidal
was consulted [11]. Confiding in a family member or behaviour) to determine if their patterns are unusual and
friend may provide support and encouragement for self- whether they have particular risk factors. Many in this
harming young adults to seek formal help, if required; representative sample of young adults who self-harmed
alternatively, young adults may have a general tendency did not seek help from professional or other sources. To
towards help-seeking [12]. encourage help-seeking, it may be necessary to address
Very few in the present study who had self-harmed attitudinal barriers, raise awareness and recognition of
had sought help from other professional services such as mental health problems and promote appropriate health
telephone counselling or crisis centres. This seemed service use early in the life course.
somewhat surprising given that services such as Lifeline
and Youthline are free and their availability brought to
Acknowledgements
the attention of potential consumers by a variety of
media. Hawton [19] commented that research on the
We are grateful to the study members and their fami-
Samaritans in the UK had not shown a significant impact
lies for their support. The self-harm study was funded by
on suicide rates, possibly because clients who contact the
Project Grant 98/148 from the Health Research Council
Samaritans may be different from patients who attempt
of New Zealand (HRC) to the Injury Prevention Research
suicide.
Unit (IPRU) and a Community Trust of Otago Research
Treating substance use problems, which are known to
Fellowship. We thank Paula Sowerby, John Langley,
be strongly associated with self-harm including suicidal
Richie Poulton, Phil Silva and DMHDS staff. The IPRU
behaviours [20] may be a way of preventing self-harm.
is supported by the HRC and the Accident Compen-
Our finding that about 10% in the intoxication group had
sation Corporation.
sought help from general practitioners, counsellors, or
psychologists, suggests that those health professionals
do get opportunities to address young adults’ substance References
use problems. An Australian prospective study found
that men diagnosed with substance misuse were at high 1. Coggan C. Suicide and attempted suicide in New Zealand:
a growing problem for young males. The New Zealand Public
risk for suicide, but concluded that clinicians found this Health Report 1997; 4:49–51.
particular group difficult to engage in treatment [13]. 2. Wright CS, Langley JD, Allnatt DM. Trends in non-fatal injury:
A limitation of the present study was that even with injury fact sheet number 18. Dunedin: University of Otago,
965 participants, there were too few reporting ICD-self- 2000.
3. Hatcher S. A survey of deliberate self harm services in New
harm in the previous year for barriers to help-seeking Zealand: shouldn’t we be doing better? New Zealand Medical
to be analyzed separately for them. For the combined Journal 1997; 110:74–75.
self-harm group (ICD-self-harm or other self-harmful 4. Appleby L, Warner R. Parasuicide: features of repetition and the
behaviours), just over half had not sought help, with the implications for intervention. Psychological Medicine 1993;
23:13–16.
commonest reason being that it was not considered 5. Haw C, Hawton K, Houston K, Townsend E. Psychiatric and
necessary. This may have been appropriate, particularly personality disorders in deliberate self-harm patients. British
for those engaging in lesser forms of self-harm such as Journal of Psychiatry 2001; 178:48–54.
self-battery. Recent findings from the National Comor- 6. Beautrais AL, Joyce PR, Mulder RT, Fergusson DM,
Deavoll BJ, Nightingale SK. Prevalence and comorbidity of
bidity Survey [21] indicated that most people with less mental disorders in serious suicide attempts: a case control study.
severe or impairing psychopathology did not perceive a American Journal of Psychiatry 1996; 153:1009–1114.
S. NADA-RAJA, D. MORRISON, K. SKEGG 605

7. Andrews JA, Lewinsohn PM. Suicidal attempts among older 15. Leaf PJ, Alegria M, Cohen P et al. Mental health service use in
adolescents: prevalence and co-occurrence with psychiatric the community and schools: results from the four-community
disorders. Journal of the American Academy of Child and MECA Study. Methods for the Epidemiology of Child and
Adolescent Psychiatry 1992; 31:655–662. Adolescent Mental Disorders Study. Journal of the American
8. Patton GC, Harris R, Carlin JB et al. Adolescent suicidal Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry 1996; 35:889–897.
behaviours: a population-based study of risk. Psychological 16. Silva PA, Stanton WR, eds. From child to adult. Oxford: Oxford
Medicine 1997; 27:715–724. University Press, 1996.
9. Hornblow AR, Bushnell JA, Wells JE, Joyce PR, 17. Reeder AI, Feehan M, Chalmers DJ, Silva PA. Some
Oakley-Browne MA. Christchurch psychiatric epidemiology socioeconomic characteristics of a much-studied cohort. The
study: use of mental health services. The New Zealand Medical Dunedin Multidisciplinary Health and Development Study.
Journal 1990; 103:415–417. New Zealand Journal of Educational Studies 1994; 29:209–213.
10. Lin E, Goering P, Offord DR, Campbell D, Boyle MH. The use 18. Nada-Raja S, Skegg KM, Langley JD, Morrison DN,
of mental health services in Ontario: epidemiologic findings. Sowerby PJ. Self-harm behaviours in a population-based sample
Canadian Journal of Psychiatry – Revue Canadienne de of young adults. Suicide and Life Threatening Behaviour 2003
Psychiatrie 1996; 41:572–577. (In submission).
11. Gasquet I, Ledoux S, Chavance M, Choquet M. Consultations of 19. Hawton K. Suicide. In: Paykel ES, Jenkins R, Gaskell eds.
mental health professionals by French adolescents with probable Prevention in psychiatry. London: Royal College of
psychiatric problems. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 1999; Psychiatrists, 1994; 67–79.
99:126–134. 20. Blenkiron P, House A, Milnes D. The timing of acts of deliberate
12. Howard KI, Cornille TA, Lyons JS, Vessey JT, Lueger RJ, self-harm. is there any relation with suicidal intent, mental
Saunders SM. Patterns of mental health service utilization. disorder or psychiatric management? Journal of Psychosomatic
Archives of General Psychiatry 1996; 53:696–703. Research 2000; 49:3–6.
13. De Moore GM, Robertson AR. Suicide in the 18 years after 21. Mojtabai R, Olfson M, Mechanic D. Perceived need and
deliberate self-harm: a prospective study. British Journal of help-seeking in adults with mood, anxiety, or substance use
Psychiatry 1996; 169:489–494. disorders. Archives of General Psychiatry 2002; 59:77–84.
14. Feehan M, Stanton W, McGee R, Silva PA. Parental 22. Pirkis J, Burgess P. Suicide and recency of health care contacts.
help-seeking for behavioural and emotional problems in British Journal of Psychiatry 1998; 173:462–474.
childhood and adolescence. Community Health Studies 1990;
14:303–309.

You might also like