Professional Documents
Culture Documents
111 State 11 Sda
111 State 11 Sda
in the Philippines
State and Society in East Asia Series
Elizabeth J. Perry, Series Editor
State and Society in the Philippines
By Patricio N. Abinales and Donna J. Amoroso
Sovereignty and Authenticity: Manchukuo and the East Asian Modern
By Prasenjit Duara
The Party and the Arty in China: The New Politics of Culture
By Richard Kraus
Webs of Smoke: Smugglers, Warlords, Spies, and the History of the
International Drug Trade
By Kathryn Meyer and Terry Parssinen
Of Camel Kings and Other Things: Rural Rebels Against Modernity in
Late Imperial China
By Roxann Prazniak
Underground: The Shanghai Communist Party and the
Politics of Survival, 1927–1937
By Patricia Stranahan
State and Society
in the Philippines
∞™ The paper used in this publication meets the minimum requirements of American
National Standard for Information Sciences—Permanence of Paper for Printed Library
Materials, ANSI/NISO Z39.48-1992.
Contents
List of Boxes xi
Preface xv
Philippine Timeline xvii
v
vi Contents
Education 92
Mapping the Peripheries 95
Social Formation and State Response 96
Philippine “Societies” 96
Filipinos 98
5 Nation and States, 1872–1913 102
The Final Years of Spanish Rule 102
Conflict within the Church 103
Struggle against Church and State 104
The Philippine Revolution and the First Republic 109
The Katipunan 109
The Malolos Republic 113
The Philippine–American War 117
The Early Years of American Rule 119
State Building 119
Parallel State Building in the Special Provinces 123
Conservative Nationalism 125
The Continuing Revolutionary Tradition 128
6 The Filipino Colonial State, 1902–1946 134
“Politics” and the Philippine Assembly 134
Filipinization 139
Tammany Hall in Manila 139
Crony Capitalism, circa the 1920s 141
Restraining “Politics” 143
Popular Insurgency 147
The Commonwealth Republic of the Philippines 153
The Origins of Philippine Authoritarianism? 153
Social Changes on the Eve of World War II 157
viii Contents
Glossary 311
Bibliography 315
Index 337
About the Authors 000
Boxes
xi
xii Boxes
This book took some time to write. First, there were frequent debates over
how to frame and interpret state–society relations in different historical peri-
ods and, throughout, the challenge of adjusting to each other’s writing style
and work pace. Our response to the substantive and detailed commentary of
an encouraging anonymous reviewer—to whom we owe many thanks—took
much longer than anticipated. Finally, we waited for the slow canvassing of
votes to determine the winner of the crucial May 2004 Philippine presidential
election and its aftermath.
At last finished, we offer an immediate disclaimer. All too aware that many
issues are not discussed in the depth they deserve, we nevertheless considered
this an acceptable trade-off in our decision to attempt a sustained analysis of
state formation over the course of a millennium. As a result, the book is not
meant to be an exhaustive treatment, but an evolving framework for under-
standing Philippine state–society relations over time.
Here we wish to express our appreciation to colleagues and friends for
egging us on. We are, foremost, grateful to Caroline Sy Hau, for early dis-
cussions exploring alternative perspectives on Philippine political history and
for encouraging us to devote attention to important “outsiders” in the story.
When we began drafting the book in Ithaca, New York, we benefited from
much-needed advice and friendship from Audrey Kahin, Ben Anderson, Ben
Abel, Eveline Ferretti, Vince Boudreau, and Toinette Raquiza. We are also
grateful to Cornell University’s Southeast Asia Program for welcoming us
back, and especially for our friendly reception by Nancy Loncto and Teresa
Palmer.
The revisions were carried out—and carried around—from Kyoto to
Bangkok, Manila to New Jersey. In residence in Bangkok for six months, we
xv
xvi Preface
bounced around ideas with Coeli Barry, Thanet Aphornsuvan, and Alan Fein-
stein, and we imposed our stories on Pasuk Pongphaichit, Chris Baker, and
Viengrat Nethipo. We value their friendship, suggestions, and gracious assis-
tance.
In the Philippines, we enjoyed stimulating discussions with Alvin Batalla,
Maricor Baytion, Karina Bolasco, Sheila Coronel, Tesa Encarnacion, Glenda
Gloria, Edna Labra-Hutchcroft, Paul Hutchcroft, Popo Lotilla, Resil Mojares,
Ambeth Ocampo, Nancy Pe-Rodrigo, Raul Rodrigo, Ed Tadem, Bobi Tiglao,
and Marites Vitug. We appreciate their insights, comments, and criticisms.
The staff of the Philippine National Historical Institute, the Lopez Museum,
the Philippine Center for Investigative Journalism, and Newsbreak magazine
gladly helped us find appropriate photos, and Kiyoko Yamaguchi drew us
wonderful sketches. Finally, we express our gratitude to Susan McEachern of
Rowman and Littlefield for not giving up on us and thanks to the editorial and
production staff. Daghang salamat kaayo.
We dedicate this work to our nephews and nieces on both sides of the
Pacific—Carlo, Charisse, Honey, Myki, and Mia Abinales in Misamis Occi-
dental; Colin and Devon Amoroso in Florida; and Ian, Maddie and Paige
Wills in Pennsylvania.
Philippine Timeline
xvii
xviii Philippine Timeline
1883 Spanish forces invade Sulu and set up a naval station and gar-
rison. Sultan Bada ud-Din II sends a letter of protest to the
British, calling the invasion a violation of the 1877 agree-
ment.
1887 Rizal publishes Noli Me Tangere. A three-man committee re-
ports to the archbishop of Manila that the novel is “heretical,
impious and scandalous . . . anti-patriotic, subversive of pub-
lic order and offensive to the government of Spain.”
1888 Germany, Britain, and Spain sign a new protocol reiterating
recognition of Spanish sovereignty over Sulu and guarantee-
ing freedom of navigation and trade in the region.
1888 The Spanish Civil Code is applied to the Philippines. Filipino
expatriates in Spain establish La Solidaridad and issue their
first fortnightly newspaper the following year.
1891 Rizal publishes El Filibusterismo. His family is removed from
the friar estates they lease. Magindanao datus of Cotabato rec-
ognize Spanish authority after Governor-General Valeriano
Weyler’s military success in adjoining Lanao.
1892 A railroad line connects Manila with Pangasinan province for
the first time. Rizal returns to Manila, organizes La Liga Fil-
ipina, and is exiled to northern Mindanao. Andres Bonifacio
establishes the Katipunan.
1894 Municipal government is reorganized, separating executive
and judicial functions.
1895 The Katipunan network expands and elects Bonifacio its
supremo. La Solidaridad newspaper closes due to lack of funds.
1895 Cuba launches a revolution against Spain.
1896 The Katipunan is discovered and begins an uprising. Rizal is
executed on December 30.
1897 Emilio Aguinaldo replaces Bonifacio as president of the
Katipunan; Bonifacio is arrested and executed. In December,
Aguinaldo and his leadership go into exile in Hong Kong, but
the revolution continues.
1898 The United States declares war on Spain. Aguinaldo returns to
the Philippines and declares independence on June 12. The
Philippine Timeline xxv