Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Hannon2020 2
Hannon2020 2
ABSTRACT undergo many anatomical, physiologi- boys and girls, with the exception of
cal, and metabolic changes as a result iron, which has been reviewed in detail
Downloaded from http://journals.lww.com/nsca-scj by BhDMf5ePHKbH4TTImqenVA+lpWIIBvonhQl60Etgtdnn9T1vLQWJq3kbRMjK/ocE on 12/13/2020
Copyright © National Strength and Conditioning Association. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Energy and Macronutrient Considerations
Table 1
The main anatomical, physiological, and metabolic differences between young and adult athletes
Growth and increase in body size
Macronutrient requirements are often prescribed relative to body mass (i.e. grams per kilo, g$kg21) to account for individual
differences in size among young athletes. Although fat mass does not seem to significantly change throughout growth and
maturation in young athletes, increases in body mass are primarily derived from an increase in fat-free mass (24). An increase in
stature is the result of skeletal growth and the laying down of bone mineral content (i.e. skeletal tissue). Around 95% of adult
bone mineral content is achieved by the end of adolescence, with ;26% of this accruing during peak bone mineral content
velocity (;12.5 and ;14 years old in girls and boys respectively) (5). Changes in fat-free mass and stature are significantly
influenced by the energy and macronutrient intake of a young athlete during childhood and adolescence (16).
Greater energy cost of movement
Young athletes have a higher (relative) energy cost of movement compared to adults. This may be due to increased stride
frequency, a greater surface area:volume ratio, a more distal distribution of mass in the legs, or because of greater levels of
contraction of the antagonist leg muscles while moving (38).
Adapted from Hannon MP, Unnithan V, Morton JP, Close GL. Nutritional strategies to support young athletes. In: Strength and Conditioning for
Young Athletes: Science and Application. Lloyd RS, Oliver JL, eds. New York: Routledge, 2019. pp. 300–335 by permission.
thermic effect of food (also known as height velocity (the maximum rate of academy soccer players (11–21 years
diet-induced thermogenesis; the growth in stature during adolescence), old) range from 1,347 to 2,382 kcal$d21
energy costs of digestion, transport will influence an individual’s energy re- (24). In this study, as players increased
and absorption, and storage of food quirements, particularly their resting in age (until 14 years of age), RMR also
and drink), and (c) activity energy metabolic rate (RMR). Although increased in a stepwise fashion, which
expenditure from planned sport and RMR is usually the largest component coincided with increases in stature,
exercise and nonexercise activity ther- of energy expenditure in the general body mass, fat-free mass (FFM), and
mogenesis (NEAT) (21). population (54), this is often not the maturity status (Figure 1). However,
During growth, energy is required to case in athletic populations, particu-
once the influence of body size variable
synthesize new tissue and also for larly in young athletes with high train-
(both stature and FFM) was removed
deposition into this new tissue (61). ing loads and subsequent high total
(through allometric scaling), relative
The highly variable rates of growth energy expenditures (49). We have
and maturation between young ath- recently observed that basal energy re- RMR (i.e., kcal$kg FFM$d21) was sim-
letes (36), particularly around peak quirements (RMR) in Premier League ilar between players of all ages (24).
In young athletes, activity energy almost certainly vary day-to-day, mak- [EA 5 (energy intake 2 activity energy
expenditure is often the greatest con- ing it difficult to prescribe exact energy expenditure)/FFM] (34). Chronic low
tributor to total energy expenditure requirements for young athletes. EA (,30 kcal$kg FFM21$d21) may
(49). Activity energy expenditure is Research studies using gold-standard result in impaired growth and matura-
the most variable component of total methods (such as the doubly labeled tion of tissues and organs, reduced skel-
energy expenditure and is influenced water technique) to assess total energy etal bone mineral accrual, increased
by both anthropometric profile (i.e., expenditure provide an insight into risk of stress fractures, increased risk
body size) and locomotion. Thus, the typical expenditures of the specific of osteoporosis later in life, delayed
type, duration, and intensity of exercise young athlete population that was as- sexual maturation, disruption or cessa-
all influence activity energy expenditure. sessed (Table 2). However, although it tion of menstruation, and a suppression
This results in a large interindividual is difficult to prescribe exact energy re- of the immune system (34). Not only is
variability in total energy expenditure quirements for young athletes, it is this likely to have a negative effect on
between young athletes, even those strongly recommended that young ath- young athletes’ performance but also
within the same sport (Table 2). letes are not in a negative energy bal- their long-term physical and psycho-
Therefore, the energy requirements for ance and have sufficient energy logical health. An EA of $45
nonathletic children and adolescents, or availability (EA) for growth. EA is kcal$kg FFM21$d21 is recommended
adult athletes are appropriate for young the amount of energy left for homeo- for adult athletes to maintain normal
athletes. static physiological functions and physiological function (34). Consider-
Considering the many factors that growth once activity energy expendi- ing young athletes have greater relative
contribute to a young athlete’s total ture has been deducted from energy energy demands than adults, $45
energy expenditure, this value will intake and is relative to FFM kcal$kg FFM21$d21 is likely to be
111
Strength and Conditioning Journal | www.nsca-scj.com
Copyright © National Strength and Conditioning Association. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Copyright © National Strength and Conditioning Association. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
112 VOLUME 42 | NUMBER 6 | DECEMBER 2020
Adapted from Hannon MP, Unnithan V, Morton JP, Close GL. Nutritional strategies to support young athletes. In: Strength and Conditioning for Young Athletes: Science and Application.
DLW 5 doubly labeled water; EE 5 energy expenditure; EEB 5 estimated energy balance; EI 5 energy intake; F 5 females; M 5 males; RFPM 5 remote food photographic method.
require; however, further research is
required. Due to the difficultly of accu-
—
—
rately quantifying EA, few studies have
22,460
2484
reported it in young athletes (11).
Koehler et al. (32) reported a mean
EA of 29 and 29 kcal$kg FFM21$d21
in young male and female athletes,
M: 3,609 6 928
M: 3,635 6 828
F: 2,467 6 426
F: 3,100 6 715
respectively (11–25 years old), who
5,589 6 502
3,695 6 449
competed in a range of sports (aes-
thetic, ball, endurance, racquet, and
water sports) at national or interna-
tional level. In English Premier League
academy soccer players, assessed over
a 7-day period, we recently observed
Activity diary
Activity diary
DLW
14 d
3d
5d
7d
3,211 6 566
—
Those engaged in either athletics, soccer, handball, rowing, canoeing, swimming, or triathlon.
Food diary
—
M&
F
required.
;19
;19
;15
CARBOHYDRATE
CONSIDERATIONS
The type of exercise, as well as exercise
duration and intensity, dictates a young
.30–40 wk per year
Miscellaneous sports
Table tennis (47)
Swimmers (62)
Copyright © National Strength and Conditioning Association. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Energy and Macronutrient Considerations
protocols before competition are not than children and adolescents (due shown that the greatest rates of glyco-
likely necessary; however, currently to larger anthropometric profiles and gen resynthesis occur in the first hour
no data on young athletes exist. higher absolute intensities), despite after exercise, and by delaying carbo-
There is also little information on gly- similar rates of absolute exogenous car- hydrate intake by 2 hours, glycogen
cogen utilization during exercise in bohydrate oxidation, adults will have resynthesis is attenuated (28); however,
young athletes, due to the invasive a lesser contribution of exogenous car- no data in young athletes exist. There-
techniques used to assess muscle gly- bohydrate toward energy expenditure fore, advice for young athletes is the
cogen. Muscle biopsy studies under- (30). Therefore, during exercise, carbo- same as adult athletes: 1.2 g$kg21$h21
taken in Scandinavia in the 1970s hydrate recommendations for young of high-GI carbohydrate should be
demonstrated that muscle glycogen athletes are similar to those for adult consumed in the 2 hours immediately
concentrations decreased by ;52% athletes. During moderate-to-high postexercise. High-GI carbohydrates
(from ;304 to 146 mmol$kg21$dry intensity exercise lasting longer than rapidly elevate blood glucose and pro-
weight) after a bout of incremental 60 minutes, young athletes should con- mote glycogen resynthesis and are
cycling exercise to volitional fatigue sume 30–60 g$h21 and should not con- therefore preferred to low-GI carbohy-
in 11- and 12-year-old boys (19). A sume more than 1 g$min21 of drates during this timeframe (29). The
comparative study in adults reported carbohydrate (16). Liquid forms of precise amount of carbohydrate to be
decreases in muscle glycogen concen- high-glycemic index carbohydrates are consumed postexercise is dependent
trations from ;280 to 90 mmol$kg21$- recommended due to the additional on the recovery period until the next
dry weight (;68% decrease) after benefits on fluid consumption. This training session/competition, and also
a similar cycling protocol to volitional should be in the form of a 6% carbohy- the intensity and duration of that next
fatigue (27). Glycogen depletion of drate drink (i.e., a commercial sports training session. Short recovery periods
;36% (assessed through magnetic res- drink) because drinks with a higher car- will require a more aggressive
onance spectroscopy) was observed in bohydrate content (8%) have been approach (i.e., greater amounts of car-
elite young soccer players (;17 year shown to increase gastrointestinal dis- bohydrate), whereas young athletes
old males) during a time-to- comfort in both male and female ado- who compete once a week may not
exhaustion soccer-specific running test lescents (48). Competition rules and require such a high carbohydrate
(43). regulations may dictate when carbohy- intake postcompetition. Fructose (con-
drate (and fluid) consumption can tained in fruit and fruit juices) and
When exogenous carbohydrate is con-
occur. Athletes and practitioners should galactose (contained in dairy products)
sumed during exercise, the oxidation
make both carbohydrates and fluids eas- are more effective than glucose in pro-
rate of exogenous carbohydrate, rela-
ily accessible (e.g., side of a pitch) for moting liver glycogen resynthesis, and
tive to body mass, is higher in children
when competition rules allow. are therefore recommended postexer-
and adolescents compared to adults
(58). As a result, the relative contribu- In addition to sparing endogenous car- cise (15). The consumption of protein
tion of exogenous carbohydrate bohydrate stores (44), exogenous car- alongside suboptimal quantities of car-
toward total energy production is bohydrate consumption during bohydrate has also been shown to
greater in young athletes compared exercise has also been shown to reduce accentuate glycogen resynthesis (6).
to their adult counterparts (58). This the perception of effort during exercise A milk-based fruit smoothie is there-
seems to be more pronounced in less and benefit performance across fore a good option postexercise
mature boys compared to boys who different types of exercise. Research because it contains all the aforemen-
are more biologically advanced (59); has shown that consumption of tioned nutrients.
however, this is not the case in females a 500-mL 6% carbohydrate solution Data from adults have shown that con-
(60). The authors of this study sug- (;35 g$h21 of carbohydrate) during suming carbohydrate before, during, and
gested that estrogen, glucocorticoids, intermittent high-intensity exercise after an acute training session attenuated
or perhaps differences in enzyme activ- improved exercise capacity in 12– markers of bone resorption (i.e., bone
ity within the contracting muscle may 14-year-old boys compared to a pla- breakdown); however, the chronic im-
result in differences in females of differ- cebo (42). Improvements of 40% in plications of this are unclear (i.e., long-
ent levels of maturation; however, a time-to-exhaustion test, performed term morphological changes to bone)
these suggestions were speculative on a cycle ergometer, have also been (23). Given the importance of maximiz-
and require further exploration (60). reported after consumption of a 6% ing bone mineral accrual in young ath-
However, absolute exogenous carbo- glucose and fructose solution (25 letes to maximize peak bone mass and
hydrate oxidation rates (i.e., g$min21) mL$kg21) in 10–14-year-old boys (45). help reduce the risk of skeletal injuries
do not seem different between children After glycogen-depleting exercise, and osteoporosis in adulthood, carbohy-
and adults (30). It has been suggested postexercise carbohydrate ingestion drate intake before, during, and after
that because (absolute) exercising should be consumed to replenish gly- exercise may be warranted to attenuate
energy expenditure is higher in adults cogen stores. Data from adults have bone resorption (22,23). An example of
115
Strength and Conditioning Journal | www.nsca-scj.com
Copyright © National Strength and Conditioning Association. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Energy and Macronutrient Considerations
nitrogen balance still occurred despite increase amino acid availability) and also an inexpensive, quick, and effective way
a protein intake of 2 g$kg21$d21 (1). after exercise. In the absence of postex- to increase protein intake at this meal.
Based on this information, daily pro- ercise protein consumption, whole-body It is recommended that leucine-rich
tein intakes of 1.4–2 g$kg21 are recom- protein balance remains negative in sources of protein including dairy prod-
mended for young athletes. For active 9–13-year-olds (63). However, ucts (milk, yogurts, and cheese), eggs,
example, a young 50-kg athlete would consumption of only 5 g (0.12 g$kg21) meat, poultry, and fish are consumed
require 70–100 g of protein per day (50 postexercise promotes a positive whole- by young athletes, given their impor-
3 1.4–2.0). Research suggests that body protein balance, suggesting that tance in facilitating muscle protein syn-
young male and female athletes across thesis. It is also recommended that
children have an increased sensitivity
a range of different sports are achieving young athletes consume nonanimal sour-
(relatively) to protein feeding in the 3-
these protein targets, with a daily ces of protein include beans, pulses, len-
hours postexercise compared to adults.
intake of ;1.5–2.0 g$kg21 (9,13,41,49). tils, nuts, and seeds; however, it should
Further increases in a positive whole-
Similar to adults, studies in active chil- body protein balance have been reported be noted that these sources lack a number
dren have also shown that timing of pro- following intakes of 10 and 15 g (0.22 of essential amino acids including leu-
tein intake influences whole-body cine. Soy beans are one of the only
and 0.33 g$kg21) in the 6 hours postex-
protein balance. Protein should be con- plant-based sources of protein that con-
ercise, in a dose-dependent manner (64).
sumed at breakfast to shift whole-body tain all essential amino acids (37). Practi-
Protein should also be consumed before
protein balance from a negative into tioners working with young vegetarian
sleep to provide a supply of amino acids
a positive state (31), and moderate doses athletes should closely monitor their pro-
of protein (0.22–0.33 g$kg21 per meal/ to the muscle overnight and promote tein intake to ensure they are consuming
snack) should be consumed every 3–4 increases in muscle mass and strength enough in their diet. Young athletes are
hours throughout the day (64). For (53). A recent study has demonstrated more than capable of meeting their daily
a young 50-kg athlete, this would equate that daily protein distribution is skewed protein requirements through food and
to around 11–17 g of protein (the amount in young soccer players, with lower in- drink sources (given their smaller size),
typically found in 2 eggs or 500 mL of takes at breakfast and higher intakes con- so consumption of protein supplements
milk). Protein consumption is of partic- sumed during the evening meal (40). (e.g., protein shakes) are not necessary or
ular importance before exercise (to Adding a glass of milk at breakfast is advised for this population.
Figure 2. A guide of how to devise an individualized nutrition plan for a young athlete.
Table 3
An example of a young soccer player’s daily energy and macronutrient intake
117
Strength and Conditioning Journal | www.nsca-scj.com
Copyright © National Strength and Conditioning Association. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Energy and Macronutrient Considerations
should aim to eat regularly throughout in adolescent sprint athletes. J Sport Sci activity in young Chinese gymnasts. Pediatr
the day (every 3–4 hours), which Med 10: 362–368, 2011. Exerc Sci 9: 243–252, 1997.
should be planned around their busy 3. Alaunyte I, Stojceska V, Plunkett A. Iron and 15. Décombaz J, Jentjens R, Ith M, et al.
school and training/competition the female athlete: A review of dietary Fructose and galactose enhance
treatment methods for improving iron status postexercise human liver glycogen
schedules. This will help ensure young
and exercise performance. J Int Soc Sports synthesis. Med Sci Sports Exerc 43:
athletes are fueling appropriately for Nutr 12: 38, 2015. 1964–1971, 2011.
training and competition, promoting
4. Astrup A, Dyerberg J, Elwood P, et al. The 16. Desbrow B, McCormack J, Burke LM, et al.
recovery postexercise, stimulating
role of reducing intakes of saturated fat in Sports dietitians Australia position
training adaptations, as well as optimiz- the prevention of cardiovascular disease: statement: Sports nutrition for the
ing their growth and maturation. Where does the evidence stand in 2010? adolescent athlete. Int J Sport Nutr Exerc
Conflicts of Interest and Source of Funding: Am J Clin Nutr 93: 684–688, 2011. Metab 24: 570–584, 2014.
The authors report no conflicts of interest 5. Bailey DA, McKay HA, Mirwald RL, Crocker 17. Eisenmann JC, Wickel EE. Estimated
and no source of funding. PR, Faulkner RA. A six-year longitudinal energy expenditure and physical activity
study of the relationship of physical activity patterns of adolescent distance runners.
to bone mineral accrual in growing children: Int J Sport Nutr Exerc Metab 17: 178–188,
The university of Saskatchewan 2007.
Marcus P. bone mineral accrual study. J Bone Miner 18. Ekelund U, Yngve A, Westerterp K,
Hannon is a PhD Res 14: 1672–1679, 1999. Sjostrom M. Energy expenditure assessed
candidate at
6. Betts JA, Williams C. Short-term recovery by heart rate and doubly labeled water in
Liverpool John from prolonged exercise. Sport Med 40: young athletes. Med Sci Sport Exerc 34:
Moores 941–959, 2010. 1360–1366, 2002.
University. 7. Boisseau N, Le Creff C, Loyens M, 19. Eriksson BO, Gollnick PD, Saltin B. Muscle
Poortmans JR. Protein intake and nitrogen metabolism and enzyme activities after
balance in male non-active adolescents training in boys 11-13 years old. Acta
and soccer players. Eur J Appl Physiol 88: Physiol Scand 87: 485–497, 1973.
288–293, 2002. 20. Eriksson BO, Saltin B. Muscle metabolism
8. Bratteby L-E, Sandhagen B, Fan H, during exercise in boys aged 11 to 16
Graeme L. Samuelson G. A 7-day activity diary for years compared to adults. Acta Paediatr
Close is a profes- assessment of daily energy expenditure Belg 28: 257–265, 1974.
validated by the doubly labelled water
sor of Human 21. FAO/WHO/UNU. Human Energy
method in adolescents. Eur J Clin Nutr 51: Requirements: Report of a Joint FAO/WHO/
Physiology at 585–591, 1997.
Liverpool John UNU Expert Consultation. 2001. Available at:
9. Braun H, von Andrian-Werburg J, Schänzer http://www.fao.org/docrep/007/y5686e/
Moores
W, Thevis M. Nutrition status of young elite y5686e08.htm. Accessed February 2020.
University. female German football players. Pediatr 22. Gordon CM, Zemel BS, Wren TAL, et al.
Exerc Sci 30: 157–167, 2018. The determinants of peak bone mass.
10. British Nutrition Foundation. Nutrition J Pediatr 180: 261–269, 2017.
Requirements. 2017. Available at: https:// 23. Hammond KM, Sale C, Fraser W, et al. Post-
www.nutrition.org.uk/attachments/article/ exercise carbohydrate and energy
James P. 907/Nutrition Requirements_Revised June availability induce independent effects on
Morton is a pro- 2016.pdf. Accessed February 2020. skeletal muscle cell signalling and bone
fessor of Exercise 11. Burke LM, Lundy B, Fahrenholtz IL, Melin turnover: Implications for training adaptation.
Metabolism at AK. Pitfalls of conducting and interpreting J Physiol 597: 4779–4796, 2019.
Liverpool John estimates of energy availability in free-living 24. Hannon MP, Carney DJ, Floyd S, et al.
athletes. Int J Sport Nutr Exerc Metab 28:
Moores Cross-sectional comparison of body
350–363, 2018. composition and resting metabolic rate in
University.
12. Carlsohn A, Scharhag-Rosenberger F, Premier League academy soccer players:
Cassel M, Weber J, de Guzman Guzman A, Implications for growth and maturation.
Mayer F. Physical activity levels to estimate J Sports Sci 38: 1326–1334, 2020.
the energy requirement of adolescent 25. Hannon MP, Parker LJF, Carney DJ, et al.
athletes. Pediatr Exerc Sci 23: 261–269, Energy requirements of male academy
REFERENCES 2011. soccer players from the English Premier
1. Aerenhouts D, Van Cauwenberg J, 13. Coutinho LAA, Porto CPM, Pierucci APTR. League. 2020. In Review.
Poortmans JR, Hauspie R, Clarys P. Critical evaluation of food intake and 26. Hannon MP, Unnithan V, Morton JP, Close
Influence of growth rate on nitrogen balance energy balance in young modern GL. Nutritional strategies to support young
in adolescent sprint athletes. Int J Sport Nutr pentathlon athletes: A cross-sectional athletes. In: Strength and Conditioning for
Exerc Metab 23: 409–417, 2013. study. J Int Soc Sports Nutr 13: 1–8, 2016. Young Athletes: Science and Application.
2. Aerenhouts D, Zinzen E, Clarys P. Energy 14. Davies PSW, Feng J-Y, Crisp JA, et al. Lloyd RS, Oliver JL, eds. New York:
expenditure and habitual physical activities Total energy expenditure and physical Routledge, 2019. pp. 300–335.
119
Strength and Conditioning Journal | www.nsca-scj.com
Copyright © National Strength and Conditioning Association. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.