Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 108

UNIVERSITY OF SUSSEX

OFDMA in 4G Mobile Communications

Candidate Number: 130013

Supervisor: Dr. Falah Ali

Submitted for the degree of

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems with Business Management

School of Engineering and Informatics

Department of Engineering and Design

Word count: 11840


DECLARATION

I hereby certify that the attached dissertation is my own work, except where specifically

indicated in the text. I have identified my resources and in particular I have put in quotation

marks any passages, identifying their origins.

I also declare that this dissertation has not been submitted, either in the same or different

form, to this or any other University for a degree.

Fanny Flores – September 2015

II
LIST OF CONTENTS

DECLARATION .......................................................................................................................................... II
LIST OF CONTENTS .................................................................................................................................. III
LIST OF FIGURES ....................................................................................................................................... V
LIST OF TABLES ....................................................................................................................................... VII
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS ....................................................................................................................... VIII
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ........................................................................................................................... XI
SUMMARY .............................................................................................................................................. XII
1 CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................ 1
1.1 AIMS, WORK AND ACHIEVEMENTS .......................................................................................... 1
1.2 MOBILE COMMUNICATIONS EVOLUTION ............................................................................... 1
1.3 LTE-A OVERVIEW ...................................................................................................................... 3
1.3.1 Architecture and Protocol stack........................................................................................ 4
1.3.2 Uplink and Downlink Operation........................................................................................ 7
1.3.3 Frame Structures............................................................................................................... 9
1.3.4 Resource Block in OFDMA and SC-FDMA .......................................................................10
1.3.5 Bandwidth Management ................................................................................................13
1.3.5.1 Carrier Aggregation .....................................................................................................14
1.3.5.2 Spectrum Sharing ........................................................................................................16
1.3.6 Enhanced MIMO .............................................................................................................17
1.3.7 OFDMA and SC-FDMA Parameters .................................................................................18
1.4 DOWNLINK PHYSICAL CHANNELS AND SIGNALS ................................................................... 20
1.4.1 Downlink Physical Channels ............................................................................................20
1.4.2 Signals .............................................................................................................................22
1.5 IFFT AND FFT IMPORTANCE ................................................................................................... 24
1.6 LTE-A PERFORMANCE ............................................................................................................ 25
1.7 SOFTWARE SIMULATION PACKAGE ....................................................................................... 28
2 CHAPTER 2: DESIGN ....................................................................................................................... 31
2.1 OFDMA BLOCK DIAGRAM ...................................................................................................... 31
2.2 SC-FDMA BLOCK DIAGRAM .................................................................................................... 32
2.3 PARAMETERES ....................................................................................................................... 33
2.4 OFDMA 2 USERS (AWGN) ...................................................................................................... 34
2.5 OFDMA 5 USERS (AWGN) ...................................................................................................... 36
2.6 OFDMA 2 USERS (AWGN + Rayleigh Fading) ......................................................................... 37
2.7 OFDMA 5 USERS (AWGN + Rayleigh Fading) ......................................................................... 37

III
2.8 SC-FDMA 2 USERS (AWGN) .................................................................................................... 37
3 CHAPTER 3: SIMULATION SETTINGS .............................................................................................. 43
3.1 OFDMA 2 USERS (AWGN) ...................................................................................................... 43
3.1.1 Transmitter .....................................................................................................................43
3.1.2 Channel ...........................................................................................................................50
3.1.3 Receiver...........................................................................................................................52
3.2 OFDMA 5 USERS (AWGN) ...................................................................................................... 56
3.2.1 Transmitter .....................................................................................................................57
3.2.2 Channel ...........................................................................................................................59
3.2.3 Receiver...........................................................................................................................59
3.3 OFDMA 2 USERS (AWGN + Rayleigh Fading) ......................................................................... 60
3.3.1 Transmitter .....................................................................................................................60
3.3.2 Channel ...........................................................................................................................61
3.3.3 Receiver...........................................................................................................................62
3.4 OFDMA 5 USERS (AWGN + Rayleigh Fading) ......................................................................... 62
3.4.1 Transmitter .....................................................................................................................63
3.4.2 Channel ...........................................................................................................................63
3.4.3 Receiver...........................................................................................................................63
3.5 SC-FDMA 2 USERS (AWGN) .................................................................................................... 63
3.5.1 Transmitter .....................................................................................................................64
3.5.2 Channel ...........................................................................................................................66
3.5.3 Receiver...........................................................................................................................66
4 CHAPTER 4: RESULTS AND ANAYLIS ............................................................................................... 68
4.1 OFDMA 2 USERS (AWGN) ...................................................................................................... 68
4.2 OFDMA 5 USERS (AWGN) ...................................................................................................... 73
4.3 BER RESULTS .......................................................................................................................... 81
4.4 PAPR RESULTS ........................................................................................................................ 84
5 CHAPTER 5: CHALLENGES AND DESIGN IMPROVEMTS ................................................................. 86
5.1 CHALLENGES .......................................................................................................................... 86
5.2 IMPROVEMENTS .................................................................................................................... 87
6 CHAPTER 5: CONCLUSIONSGN IMPROVEMTS ............................................................................... 90
6.1 CONCLUSIONS ........................................................................................................................ 90
6.2 FUTURE WORK ....................................................................................................................... 92
REFERENCES ........................................................................................................................................... 93
APPENDIX A .............................................................................................................................................. A

IV
LIST OF FIGURES

Figure 1.1.: Global mobile-cellular subscriptions [1] ................................................................................ 2


Figure 1.2: LTE-Advanced E-UTRAN architecture [6]................................................................................ 5
Figure 1.3: Protocol Stack [6].................................................................................................................... 6
Figure 1.4: FDM vs. OFDM [7] .................................................................................................................. 7
Figure 1.5: OFDM vs. OFDMA [7].............................................................................................................. 8
Figure 1.6: OFDMA vs. SC-FDMA in Time and Frequency domains [8] .................................................... 9
Figure 1.7: Frame structure type 1 [9]....................................................................................................10
Figure 1.8: Frame structure type 2 [9]....................................................................................................10
Figure 1.9: Resource grid [9], [10] ..........................................................................................................12
Figure 1.10: Channel bandwidth [11] .....................................................................................................14
Figure 1.11: FDD and TDD in CA [12] ......................................................................................................15
Figure 1.12: Carrier Aggregation modes [6] ...........................................................................................16
Figure 1.13: Spectrum sharing scenarios [6] ..........................................................................................16
Figure 1.14: Base station radiation pattern [6] ......................................................................................17
Figure 1.15: LTE-A main MIMO modes [6] .............................................................................................18
Figure 1.16: Cyclic Prefix [13] .................................................................................................................18
Figure 1.17: Overview of physical channel processing [9] .....................................................................20
Figure 1.18: Uplink vs. Downlink Reference signals allocation [14] .......................................................23
Figure 1.19: Mapping of downlink reference signals [9] ........................................................................24
Figure 1.20: IFFT and FFT [15].................................................................................................................25
Figure 1.21: SC-FDMA vs. OFDMA performance with QPSK [16] ...........................................................26
Figure 1.22: PAPR comparison for OFDMA and SC-FDMA [17] ..............................................................28
Figure 1.23: Simulink Library ..................................................................................................................28
Figure 1.24: Simulink Library Browser ....................................................................................................29
Figure 1.25: Simulink New Model...........................................................................................................29
Figure 1.26: Adding blocks and connecting ............................................................................................30
Figure 2.1: OFDMA Transmission and Reception model [18] ................................................................32
Figure 2.2: SC-FDMA Transmission and Reception model [18] ..............................................................33
Figure 2.3: OFDMA 2 Users Design .........................................................................................................39
Figure 2.4: OFDMA 2 Users (AWGN) Diagram .......................................................................................39
Figure 2.5: OFDMA 5 Users Design .........................................................................................................40
Figure 2.6: OFDMA 5 Users (AWGN) Diagram .......................................................................................40
Figure 2.7: OFDMA 2 Users (AWGN + Rayleigh Fading) Diagram ..........................................................41
Figure 2.8: OFDMA 5 Users (AWGN + Rayleigh Fading) Diagram ..........................................................41
Figure 2.9: SC-FDMA 2 Users Design ......................................................................................................42
Figure 2.10: SC-FDMA 2 Users Diagram .................................................................................................42
Figure 3.1: OFDMA 2 Users Transmitter.................................................................................................43
Figure 3.2: Source Block Parameters (OFDMA 2 users) .........................................................................44
Figure 3.3: Integer to Bit Converter / Bit to Integer Converter ..............................................................44
Figure 3.4: Rectangular QAM Modulator ...............................................................................................45
Figure 3.5: Zero constant vectors (OFDMA 2 Users) ..............................................................................45
V
Figure 3.6: Extension of zeros (OFDMA 2 Users) ....................................................................................46
Figure 3.7: Vectors Addition (OFDMA 2 Users) ......................................................................................46
Figure 3.8: Multiport Selector ................................................................................................................47
Figure 3.9: Null subcarriers constants ....................................................................................................48
Figure 3.10: Reference signals constant .................................................................................................48
Figure 3.11: Matrix concatenate (OFDMA) ............................................................................................49
Figure 3.12: IFFT (OFDMA) .....................................................................................................................49
Figure 3.13: Cyclic Prefix Addition ..........................................................................................................50
Figure 3.14: Channel (AWGN).................................................................................................................50
Figure 3.15: AWGN Channel (OFDMA 2 Users) ......................................................................................51
Figure 3.16: OFDMA 2 Users Receiver ....................................................................................................52
Figure 3.17: Cyclic Prefix Removal ..........................................................................................................52
Figure 3.18: FFT (OFDMA) ......................................................................................................................53
Figure 3.19: Frame Conversion ...............................................................................................................53
Figure 3.20: Null subcarriers removal ....................................................................................................54
Figure 3.21: Reference signals removal..................................................................................................54
Figure 3.22: Reference signals terminator .............................................................................................54
Figure 3.23: Users’ data separation (OFDMA 2 Users) ...........................................................................55
Figure 3.24: Rectangular QAM Demodulator .........................................................................................55
Figure 3.25: Error Rate Calculation.........................................................................................................56
Figure 3.26: OFDMA 5 Users Transmitter...............................................................................................57
Figure 3.27: Source Block Parameters (OFDMA 5 users) .......................................................................57
Figure 3.28: Zero constant vectors (OFDMA 5 Users) ............................................................................58
Figure 3.29: Vectors Addition (OFDMA 5 Users) ....................................................................................59
Figure 3.30: Receiver (OFDMA 5 Users) .................................................................................................59
Figure 3.31: Users’ data separation (OFDMA 5 Users) ...........................................................................60
Figure 3.32: Channel (AWGN + Rayleigh Fading) ...................................................................................61
Figure 3.33: AWGN Channel (OFDMA 5 Users) ......................................................................................61
Figure 3.34 AWGN Channel (OFDMA 5 Users) .......................................................................................62
Figure 3.35: SC-FDMA 2 Users Transmitter ............................................................................................64
Figure 3.36: FFT (SC-FDMA Transmitter) ................................................................................................64
Figure 3.37: Multiport Selector (SC-FDMA) ............................................................................................65
Figure 3.38: Null subcarriers constants (SC-FDMA)................................................................................65
Figure 3.39: Matrix Concatenate (SC-FDMA) .........................................................................................66
Figure 3.40: SC-FDMA 2 Users Receiver .................................................................................................66
Figure 3.41: Null subcarriers removal (SC-FDMA) ..................................................................................67
Figure 3.42: IFFT .....................................................................................................................................67
Figure 4.1: TX and RX Integer data (2 Users) Eb/No=30dB (a), 43dB (b), 80dB (c) ................................68
Figure 4.2: Error rate, Errors and Comparisons (2 Users) Eb/No=30dB (a), 43dB (b), 80dB (c) .............69
Figure 4.3: Modulated TX Data (User 1 of 2) ..........................................................................................70
Figure 4.4: Modulated RX Data (User 1) Eb/No=30dB (a), 43dB (b) and 80dB (c) .................................70
Figure 4.5: Modulated TX Data (User 2 of 2) ..........................................................................................71
Figure 4.6: Modulated RX Data (User 2) Eb/No=30dB (a), 43dB (b) and 80dB (c) .................................71

VI
Figure 4.7: Transmitted signal ................................................................................................................72
Figure 4.8: Received signal Eb/No=30dB (a), 43dB (b) and 80dB(c) .......................................................72
Figure 4.9: TX and RX Integer data (5 Users) Eb/No=30dB (a), 43dB (b), 80dB (c) ................................74
Figure 4.10: Error rate, Errors and Comparisons (5 Users) Eb/No=30dB (a), 43dB (b), 80dB (c) ...........75
Figure 4.11: Modulated TX Data (User 1 of 5) ........................................................................................76
Figure 4.12: Modulated RX Data (User 1 of 5) Eb/No=30dB (a), 43dB (b), 80dB (c) ..............................76
Figure 4.13: Modulated TX Data (User 2 of 5) ........................................................................................77
Figure 4.14: Modulated RX Data (User 2 of 5) Eb/No=30dB (a), 43dB (b), 80dB (c) ..............................77
Figure 4.15: Modulated TX Data (User 3 of 5) ........................................................................................78
Figure 4.16: Modulated RX Data (User 3 of 5) Eb/No=30dB (a), 43dB (b), 80dB (c) ..............................78
Figure 4.17: Modulated TX Data (User 4 of 5) ........................................................................................79
Figure 4.18: Modulated RX Data (User 4 of 5) Eb/No=30dB (a), 43dB (b), 80dB (c) ..............................79
Figure 4.19: Modulated TX Data (User 5 of 5) ........................................................................................80
Figure 4.20: Modulated RX Data (User 5 of 5) Eb/No=30dB (a), 43dB (b), 80dB (c) ..............................80
Figure 4.21: Transmitted signal (5 Users) ...............................................................................................81
Figure 4.22: Received signal (5 Users) Eb/No=30dB (a), 43dB (b), 80dB (c) ..........................................81
Figure 4.23: BER Curves for 2 and 5 Users (AWGN) ...............................................................................82
Figure 4.24: BER Curves for 2 Users (a), and 5 Users (b) (AWGN vs. AWGN + Fading) ..........................83
Figure 4.26: PAPR for 2 Users OFDMA (a) vs. SC-FDMA (b) (AWGN) .....................................................84
Figure 4.27: OFDMA Design Proposal.....................................................................................................88
Figure 4.28: OFDMA Diagram Proposal ..................................................................................................88

LIST OF TABLES

Table 1.1: 3GPP Releases Summary [3] .................................................................................................... 3


Table 1.2: SC-FDMA RB parameters [9] ..................................................................................................11
Table 1.3: OFDMA RB parameters [9] ....................................................................................................11
Table 1.4: 3GPP LTE-A OFDMA Parameters [10] ....................................................................................19
Table 1.5: Number of OFDM symbols used for PDCCH [9] .....................................................................21
Table 1.6: Targets for LTE-Advanced as set by 3GPP [5] ........................................................................25
Table 2.1: Simulation Parameters ..........................................................................................................34

VII
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS

ITU International Telecommunication Union


1G First Generation
2G Second Generation
3G Third Generation
4G Fourth Generation
D-AMPS Digital Advanced Mobile Phone System
GSM Global System for Mobile Communications
GPRS General Packet Radio Service
EV-DO Evolution Data Optimized
3GPP Third Generation Partnership Project
LTE Long Term Evolution
LTE-A Long Term Evolution – Advanced
UE User Equipment
EPS Evolved Packet System
EPC Evolved Packet Core
E-UTRAN Evolved Universal Terrestrial Radio Access Network
E-UTRA Evolved Universal Terrestrial Radio Access
RAN Radio Access Network
eNodeB / Enb Enhanced Node B
MME Mobility Management Entity
S-GW Serving Gateway
P-GW/ PDN-GW Packet Data Network Gateway
PDCP Packet Data Convergence Protocol
RLC Radio Link Control
MAC Medium Access Control
PHY Physical layer
RRC Radio Resource Control
NAS Non-Access Stratum
AS Access Stratum
VIII
ARQ Automatic Repeat reQuest
HARQ Hybrid Automatic Repeat reQuest
PDU Packet Data Unit
TDMA Time Division Multiple Access
CDMA Code Division Multiple Access
FDMA Frequency Division Multiple Access
SC-FDMA Single Carrier Frequency Division Multiple Access
OFDMA Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiple Access
FDM Frequency Division Multiplexing
OFDM Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing
PAPR Peak to Average Power Ratio
ISI Inter Symbol Interference
ICI Inter Carrier Interference
TDD Time Division Duplexing
FDD Frequency Division Duplexing
MIMO Multiple Input Multiple Output
SU-MIMO Single-User Multiple Input Multiple Output
MU-MIMO Multi-User Multiple Input Multiple Output
RB Resource Block
𝑈𝐿
𝑁𝑠𝑦𝑚𝑏 Number of SC-FDMA symbols in an uplink slot
𝐷𝐿
𝑁𝑠𝑦𝑚𝑏 Number of OFDMA symbols in a downlink slot
𝑅𝐵
𝑁𝑠𝑐 Resource block size in the frequency domain, expressed as a
number of subcarriers
CP Cyclic Prefix
CA Carrier Aggregation
BER Bit Error Rate
FER Frame Error Rate
SNR Signal to Noise Ratio
QPSK Quadrature Phase Shift Keying
QAM Quadrature Amplitude Modulation

IX
MBSFN Multicast-Broadcast Single-Frequency Network
PDSCH Physical Downlink Shared Channel
PBCH Physical Broadcast Channel
PMCH Physical Multicast Channel
PCFICH Physical Control Format Indicator Channel
PDCCH Physical Downlink Control Channel
PHICH Physical Hybrid ARQ Indicator Channel
CRS Cell-specific Reference Signals
DM-RS Demodulation Reference Signals
PRS Positioning Reference Signals
CSI-RS Channel State Information Reference Signal
ACK Acknowledgement
NACK Negative Acknowledgement
FFT Fast Fourier Transform
IFFT Inverse Fast Fourier Transform
AWGN Additive White Gaussian Noise
TX Transmitter
RX Receiver

X
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

I wish to extend my gratitude to the government of Ecuador and to the University of

Sussex for this opportunity. I would also like to thank my supervisor Dr Falah Ali for his

accurate guide, encouragement and advice.

I would like to take this opportunity to thank my loving parents, Juan and Fanny, without

whom, I would not be able to reach this achievement in my career. Thanks for their constant

support and for being my endless inspiration. Thanks to my siblings, Juan and Evelyn for

supporting me during this process. Finally, I would like to thank Antonio for his unconditional

support and love despite distance.

XI
SUMMARY

This project analyzes, designs and simulates “OFDMA in 4G Mobile Communications”.


The analysis and designs are based on “ETSI TS 136 211 V10.0.0” technical specification,
defined by 3GPP. The simulations have been developed with Simulink of Matlab R2014a.

Chapter 1, “Introduction”, includes a recapitulation of the evolution that mobile


communications has had. Besides, it contains a review of the concepts defined by 3GPP for
LTE-A; including uplink and downlink, frame structures, resources, parameters.

Chapter 2, “Design”, presents block diagrams and the LTE-A parameters that have been
considered for the design. This chapter is organized in five sections, each with a different
scenario. The number of users and the introduction of fading has been considered to create the
scenarios. At the end, the corresponding designs of OFDMA symbol and Simulink diagrams
are presented.

Chapter 3, “Simulation Settings”, describes the settings of each block used in Simulink.
This Chapter consists of five sections, presenting the settings of each scenario described in
Chapter 2. The analysis is based on transmitter, channel and receiver.

Chapter 4, “Results and Analysis”, studies the results obtained in simulations. The
transmitted and received integer data are shown; as well as the Error rate, errors and the
number of comparisons made by the corresponding blocks. Also, the modulated transmitted
and received data and signals are compared. This Chapter also analyses BER curves, and
compares PAPR for SC-FDMA and OFDMA.

Chapter 5, “Challenges and Design Improvements” includes some challenges that LTE-A
faces. Finally, the suppression of reference signals is assessed and suggested as a possible
improvement.

At last, Chapter 6 “Conclusions and Future work” presents the conclusions of the
investigation, analysis, design and simulation carried out in this project. It also contains topics
of interest for future study.

XII
1 CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION

CHAPTER 1

INTRODUCTION

1.1 AIMS, WORK AND ACHIEVEMENTS

This project aims to investigate, design, simulate, analyze results and suggest possible

improvements related to OFDMA in LTE-A.

Initially, research and investigation were necessary in order to learn and understand LTE-

A technical specifications. Besides, the review of previous research was useful. Once the

standard was analyzed, the design of OFDMA was carried out. Then, the design was deployed

in Simulink with the aid of previous simulations to have some guide about the blocks that

execute the required functions. The results of different scenarios were analyzed to finally

suggest possible improvements.

Some achievements of this project include satisfactory simulations, confirming appropriate

designs. Also, the results that were obtained confirm what theory and LTE-A standard denote.

Furthermore, improvements to the current standard were presented based on the results.

1.2 MOBILE COMMUNICATIONS EVOLUTION

According to the ITU, the number of mobile cellular subscriptions has exponentially

increased from 962 million in 2001 to 7,085 million in 2015, which means that 96,8 of 100

inhabitants are currently subscripted to the service [1], as shown in Figure 1.1.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 1 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
This accelerated growth has been the result of the mobile communications evolution in the

last years. As a matter of fact, four generations of mobile communications have been

developed since the 80’s to current days.

Global mobile-cellular subscriptions,


total and per 100 inhabitants, 2001-2015
Mobile-celullar subscriptions (millions)

7,000 100

90
6,000
Subscriptions (in millions) 80
5,000 Per 100 inhabitants 70

Per 100 inhabitants


60
4,000
50
3,000
40

2,000 30

20
1,000
10

- 0
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015*
Note: * Estimate
Source: ITU World Telecommunication /ICT Indicators database

Figure 1.1.: Global mobile-cellular subscriptions [1]

The first generation (1G) was based on analog technology, and its mobiles had limited

functions, as well as considerable size and weight. The multiple access method used by 1G

was FDMA, supporting one user per channel transmitting at the same time.

The second generation (2G) introduced digital technology, and it was based on the

following standards: D-AMPS, GSM and GPRS. TDMA was used in this generation,

supporting multiple users per channel, but transmitting one at a time.

Then, 3G was characterized for introducing CDMA; hence, multiple users with different

codes share the channel while transmitting at the same time. Furthermore, EV-DO allowed the

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 2 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
transmission of larger packets, while technologies as Carrier Aggregation increased

transmission data rates. In order to normalize 3G, seven telecommunications standard

development organizations created the 3GPP [2].

Finally, 4G was introduced by 3GPP as LTE in Release 8 and LTE-A in Release 10. The

purpose of this last generation is to reach very high data rates to satisfy users increasing

requirements associated with web applications and the Internet, in general. New technologies

as carrier aggregation and MIMO are the basis of LTE-A for higher data rates and spectral

efficiency. LTE-A has defined SC-FDMA as the access technique used in the uplink, and

OFDMA in the downlink. Table 1.1 shows a summary of the 3GPP releases from 2003 and

their main characteristics.

WCDMA HSPA HSDPA LTE


PARAMETER HSPA+ LTE
(UMTS) / HSUPA ADVANCED
Max downlink speed
384 k 14 M 28 M 100 M 1G
(bps)
Max uplink speed (bps) 128 k 5.7 M 11 M 50 M 500 M
Less than Less than 5
Latency round trip time 150 ms 100 ms 50 ms
10 ms ms
3GPP releases Rel 99/4 Rel 5/6 Rel 7 Rel 8 Rel 10
OFDMA / OFDMA /
Access methodology CDMA CDMA CDMA
SC-FDMA SC-FDMA
Table 1.1: 3GPP Releases Summary [3]

1.3 LTE-A OVERVIEW

LTE-A is the last generation of mobile communications, characterized by its high network

capacity, high data rate and a myriad of available services. Its technical specification has been

published by the 3GPP.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 3 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
When comparing 3G and LTE-A, one of the main differences between both generations is

the downlink rate. Indeed, it is possible to reach 1 Gbps in LTE-A, while in 3G it was possible

to reach only 20 Mbps [4]. Moreover, the difference in the uplink rate is also considerable

with up to 500 Mbps in LTE-A and 10 Mbps in 3G. [4], [5]

This considerable increase in rate has been necessary to offer new services and

applications that require more resources and are not tolerant to delays; for instance,

multimedia, mobile TV, real time audio and video. Another reason by which it is possible to

use these new services and applications is the reduction of latency round trip time in LTE-A,

which is less than 5 ms. Furthermore, due to the increase of mobile service subscriptions

worldwide, LTE-A is based on a higher network capacity; thus, it is possible to have more

calls per cell at the same time. LTE-A supports up to 8 downlink transmit antennas and up to 4

uplink transmit antennas.

1.3.1 Architecture and Protocol stack

As part of the technical specifications, 3GPP has defined the next generation network,

including its main components: EPC, E-UTRAN and E-UTRA. They correspond to the core

network, radio access network and air interface, respectively. The EPS is responsible for IP

connection between a UE and an external packet data network using E-UTRAN [6]. Figure 1.2

presents the network architecture of E-UTRAN for LTE-A.

The eNB is a logical element, which is the main component in the E-UTRAN architecture.

It provides the air interface with user and control plane protocols towards the UE. X2 is the

interface interconnecting the eNBs.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 4 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Figure 1.2: LTE-Advanced E-UTRAN architecture [6]

The HeNB is an eNB of low cost used to improve indoor coverage. The HeNB could be

directly connected to the EPC or through a gateway if more HeNB have to be connected.

Relay nodes are used for performance enhancement, increased coverage and higher data rates.

The MME is a control plane element used for roaming, handling idle state mobility, selecting

the S-GW and P-GW nodes and executing security tasks, including authentication and

authorization. The S-GW, which is connected to the E-UTRAN through the S1-U interface, is

the termination of the EPC. This element performs packet routing, packet forwarding, inter-

operator charging and it is also in change of mobility. The node that assigns an IP address to

the UE is the P-GW. It also contributes with secure connection between UEs though IPSec

tunnels.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 5 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
As mentioned before, the protocol stack encloses User and Control planes. Figure 1.3

provides an overview of the protocol stack. The user and control planes consist of PDCP,

RLC, MAC and PHY protocols; additionally, the control plane includes RRC protocols.

Figure 1.3: Protocol Stack [6]

(NAS) layer protocols exclusively belong to MME. Some of their functions include,

registration, authentication, location and connection management between UE and the core

network.

(AS) layer protocols are exclusive of eNB. To start, RRC establishes, maintains and

releases RRC connections. Others of its functions include mobility, key, QoS and reporting

management. Second, the PDCP compresses headers, duplicates detection and ciphers data.

Third, some of the functions that RLC has include error detection and correction by using

ARQ, segmentation and in-sequence delivery. Fourth, the MAC protocols functions include

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 6 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
multiplexing and demultiplexing of PDUs, scheduling, error correction through HARQ,

priorization and padding.

1.3.2 Uplink and Downlink Operation

Before defining SC-FDMA and OFDMA, it is convenient to review the differences

between FDM, OFDM and OFDMA. Figure 1.4 shows FDM and OFDM multiplexing

techniques; both allocate users in different frequency slots. OFDM achieves spectral efficiency

by using orthogonal carriers. Due to orthogonality, interference is minimized.

Figure 1.4: FDM vs. OFDM [7]

OFDMA is considered as an extension of OFDM, in which multiple users share resources

efficiently. In fact, in OFDM each user is assigned all the subcarriers during a subframe,

where a subframe is a number of OFDM symbols; while in OFDMA, more than one user is

assigned multiple subcarriers during the same subframe; thus, there is an efficient resource

sharing, as shown in Figure 1.5.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 7 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Figure 1.5: OFDM vs. OFDMA [7]

LTE defines SC-FDMA for the uplink and OFDMA for the downlink. In fact, the main

reason by which SC-FDMA is used in the uplink. This multiple access methodology has lower

PAPR than OFDMA; therefore, in general it is possible to require lower power levels. Indeed,

as that power is provided by the user equipment in the uplink, it is ideal to minimize it in order

to use limited transmit power devices.

OFDMA is used in the downlink with the purpose of exploiting efficiently the frequency

resource by orthogonally accommodating multiple subcarriers in a given band. As shown in

Figure 1.6, OFDMA has lower sensitivity to ISI due to the fact that all the subcarriers at a time

belong to the same symbol, unlike SC-FDMA. Hence, OFDMA is more scalable and suitable

to manage different users’ data at the same time. Furthermore, OFDMA provides immunity to

multi path and frequency selective fading.

First, in the case of the downlink (OFDMA), sub-carriers duration is longer than in the SC-

FDMA case, according to the Time axis in this figure. Also, each sub-carrier in OFDMA is

modulated by different data symbols; hence modulation and symbols have also considerable

time duration.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 8 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Figure 1.6: OFDMA vs. SC-FDMA in Time and Frequency domains [8]

Second, SC-FDMA is used in the uplink; this multiple access technique is actually a multi-

carrier method, but all the sub-carriers in a block are modulated with the same data. As shown

in Figure 1.6, in SC-FDMA all the sub-carriers of the same colour are modulated with the

same data, and their duration is shorter than in the OFDMA case; thus, symbols in SC-FDMA

are also shorter than in OFDMA.

1.3.3 Frame Structures

TDD and FDD are supported by LTE-A, which defines two different frame types based on

TDD and FDD. Frame Type 1 is used in FDD. As shown in Figure 1.7, frame type 1 lasts 10

ms., and it consists of 10 subframes, each lasts 1 ms. Besides, each subframe consists of 2

slots, the duration of each slot is 0.5 ms. Half duplex and full duplex are supported in FDD.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 9 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Figure 1.7: Frame structure type 1 [9]

Figure 1.8 shows frame type 2, which is used in TDD and its duration is also 10 ms. and

consists of 10 subrames. Each subframe has also 2 slots. The difference with frame type 1 is

that subframes in frame type 2 have reserved fixed positions for uplink, downlink and special

data.

Figure 1.8: Frame structure type 2 [9]

1.3.4 Resource Block in OFDMA and SC-FDMA

𝑈𝐿 𝑅𝐵 𝑈𝐿
According to 3GPP, a physical RB is defined as 𝑁𝑠𝑦𝑚𝑏 x 𝑁𝑠𝑐 resource elements (𝑁𝑠𝑦𝑚𝑏

𝑅𝐵
consecutive SC-FDMA symbols in an uplink slot in the time domain and 𝑁𝑠𝑐 consecutive

𝐷𝐿
subcarriers in the frequency domain) [9]. An RB is also defined for the downlink as 𝑁𝑠𝑦𝑚𝑏 x

𝑅𝐵 𝐷𝐿
𝑁𝑠𝑐 resource elements (𝑁𝑠𝑦𝑚𝑏 consecutive OFDMA symbols in a downlink slot in the time

𝑅𝐵 𝑈𝐿 𝑅𝐵 𝐷𝐿
domain and 𝑁𝑠𝑐 consecutive subcarriers in the frequency domain) [9]. 𝑁𝑠𝑦𝑚𝑏 , 𝑁𝑠𝑐 , 𝑁𝑠𝑦𝑚𝑏

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 10 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
𝑅𝐵
and 𝑁𝑠𝑐 are given by Tables 1.2 and 1.3. For SC-FDMA and OFDMA, the resource block

occupies 180 KHz in the frequency domain.

CONFIGURATION 𝑵𝑹𝑩
𝒔𝒄 𝑵𝑼𝑳
𝒔𝒚𝒎𝒃 CONFIGURATION 𝑵𝑹𝑩
𝒔𝒄 𝑵𝑫𝑳
𝒔𝒚𝒎𝒃

Normal Cyclic Prefix 12 7 Normal Cyclic Prefix ∆𝑓 = 15𝑘𝐻𝑧 7


12
Extended Cyclic Prefix 12 6 ∆𝑓 = 15𝑘𝐻𝑧 6
Extended Cyclic Prefix
∆𝑓 = 7.5𝑘𝐻𝑧 24 3

Table 1.2: SC-FDMA RB parameters [9] Table 1.3: OFDMA RB parameters [9]

𝐷𝐿
The number of 𝑁𝑅𝐵 depends on the downlink bandwidth arranged in the cell; such that

𝑚𝑖𝑛,𝐷𝐿 𝐷𝐿 𝑚𝑎𝑥.𝐷𝐿 𝑚𝑖𝑛,𝐷𝐿 𝑚𝑎𝑥.𝐷𝐿


𝑁𝑅𝐵 ≤ 𝑁𝑅𝐵 ≤ 𝑁𝑅𝐵 , where 𝑁𝑅𝐵 = 6 and 𝑁𝑅𝐵 = 110. Also, the number of

symbols in a slot is configured depending on the CP length. [9]

Figure 1.9 shows the relationship between a slot, a resource block, resource elements and

symbols. In this example, the slot consists of 7 symbols in the time domain. The resource

block consists also of 7 symbols in the time domain and 12 subcarriers in the frequency

domain. Each element of the resource block is called resource element.

Appendix A shows an OFDMA full frame, in which the horizontal and vertical axis

correspond to the time and frequency domain, respectively. As shown, each slot consists of 7

OFDMA symbols, in this case. Besides, each RB contains 12 subcarriers. In this example,

there are 180 occupied subcarriers per OFDMA symbol; therefore, each OFDMA symbol has

78 null subcarriers.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 11 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Figure 1.9: Resource grid [9], [10]

“An antenna port is defined such that the channel over which a symbol on the antenna port

is conveyed can be inferred from the channel over which another symbol on the same antenna

port is conveyed. There is one resource grid per antenna port.” 1 Also, the possible

1
3GPP. “ETSI IS 136 211 V10.0.0 (2011-01) Technical Specification”. Release 10. France, 2011.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 12 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
configurations for cell-specific reference signals are one, two or four antenna ports: 𝑝 = 0,

𝑝 ∈ {0,1} and 𝑝 ∈ {0,1,2,3}. [9]

Port 4 is used to transmit MBSFN reference signals. Ports 5, 7, 8 or one or several of 𝑝 ∈

{7,8,9,10, 11, 12, 13 14} are used for user equipment reference signals. Besides, port 6 is used

to transmit positioning reference signals. CSI reference signals are sent through 𝑝 = 15, 𝑝 =

15, 16, 𝑝 = 15, … ,18 or 𝑝 = 15, … ,22. [9]

1.3.5 Bandwidth Management

LTE-A technical specification is based on the use of bandwidths of up to 100 MHz. The

spectrum bands that LTE-A considers include 450-470 MHz, 698-860 MHz, 790-862 MHz,

2.3-2.4 GHz, 3.4-4.2 GHz and 4.4-4.99 GHz [6]. It is advisable to use the lower frequency

bands for demands of high mobility, low capacity and long range; while the higher frequency

bands for low mobility, high capacity and short range.

“Channel bandwidth is the width of the channel in frequency as measured from the lowest

channel edge to the highest channel edge.” 2


As shown in Table 1.4, the number of RB is

directly proportional to the channel bandwidth. Figure 1.10 shows the difference between

Channel Bandwidth, Transmission Bandwidth Configuration and Transmission Bandwidth.

The Transmission Bandwidth Configuration is the maximum number of RB that can be used

in a given channel bandwidth with guard band.

2
ANRITSU. “LTE Resources Guide” Rev 1010. Japan, 2010.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 13 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Figure 1.10: Channel bandwidth [11]

1.3.5.1 Carrier Aggregation

Along with LTE-A Release 10, component carriers can have different bandwidth, without

exceeding 20 MHz. Moreover, it is possible to aggregate up to five component carriers of

maximum 20 MHz for transmission in uplink or downlink; thus, bandwidth of up to 100 MHz

can be reached with CA. For instance, a 60 MHz system can be deployed with three 20 MHz

component carriers, allocated in already exploited bands or in new ones. As a result of

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 14 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
bandwidth optimization, it is possible to reach higher data rates, which is perceived by the end

user.

As shown in Figure 1.11, CA can be deployed with FDD or TDD either in uplink or

downlink transmissions. If the deployment uses FDD, one carrier is used for uplink traffic and

another for downlink traffic. When TDD is used, only one carrier frequency is required.

Figure 1.11: FDD and TDD in CA [12]

It is important to consider that in spite of the fact that LTE-A Release 10 terminals are

compatible with releases 8 and 9, just release 10 terminals support CA.

Due to the fact that there is not a unique standardized schema of bandwidth utilization for

providers, there are three different modes of component carriers’ allocation along the

spectrum, as shown in Figure 1.12. Hence, even in scenarios with complex designs, it would

be possible to deploy CA. Firstly, in intra-band contiguous allocation (a), component carriers

are allocated contiguously one beside the other in a unique bandwidth range. Second, in intra-

band non-contiguous allocation (b), some component carriers in the same bandwidth range

would be separated of each other. Lastly, inter-band non-contiguous allocation considers no

contiguous component carriers in different spectrum bands.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 15 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Figure 1.12: Carrier Aggregation modes [6]

1.3.5.2 Spectrum Sharing

Network and spectrum sharing are supported by 3GPP. When operators share network and

spectrum, they reduce initial investment. There are different spectrum sharing scenarios, as

presented in Figure1.13. For example, three operators in (a) have their own dedicated

spectrum bands, and they are also sharing a specific spectrum band. In (b), the shared

spectrum bands are located between the dedicated spectrum bands. Indeed, the center

spectrum band belongs to operator 2, and the bands next to it are shared between operator 2

and operator 1 and 3, respectively.

Figure 1.13: Spectrum sharing scenarios [6]

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 16 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
3GPP suggests operators to keep shared structure when operating in low density areas,

while deploy a dedicated structure in high density areas.

1.3.6 Enhanced MIMO

Enhanced MIMO is a technology considered in LTE-A which enhances the spectral

efficiency in scenarios with large number of users and high data rates. MIMO is based on the

use of multiple antennas at the transmitter and receiver; thus, MIMO properties are applied for

both the uplink and the downlink.

With the purpose of getting the highest possible gain in the direction of each user, MIMO

technology uses SDMA so that it adapts the radiation pattern of the base station to each user,

as shown in Figure 1.14. Therefore, each base station analyzes the CSI of each UE in order to

allocate resources.

Figure 1.14: Base station radiation pattern [6]

LTE-A describes three main MIMO operating modes, as shown in Figure 1.15. SU-MIMO

is based on a single multi antenna transmitter communicating with a single multi antenna

receiver. In contrast, MU-MIMO consists of multiple users with one or more antennas

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 17 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
communicating with each other. The third mode defined by 3GPP is the Cooperative MIMO,

which is suitable for cell-edge users to improve their throughput by working with different

base stations at the same time.

Figure 1.15: LTE-A main MIMO modes [6]

1.3.7 OFDMA and SC-FDMA Parameters

As presented previously in Tables 1.2 and 1.3, the CP is an important concept in LTE-A. It

is defined as the fragment of the last part of a symbol, which is copied at the beginning of that

symbol in order to increase the separation between symbols, minimizing ISI, as shown in

Figure1.16.

Figure 1.16: Cyclic Prefix [13]

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 18 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
According to table 1.3, when normal CP is used, the RB size is 7x12, and the subcarrier

spacing is ∆𝑓=15kHz; therefore, the bandwidth of an RB is 12x15kHz = 180kHz, as described

in section 1.2.3. If extended CP is used, the RB size could be 6x12 or 3x24, depending on the

∆𝑓 used (15kHz or 7.5kHz); even though, in both cases the bandwidth of an RB is 180kHz.

LTE defines different values to design OFDMA symbols, as presented in Table 1.4. The

current work will be based on the values marked in red. Chapter 2 will cover the designs and

simulations based on these parameters and values. The generation of the SC-FDMA signal is

similar to the OFDMA processing using the same parameters shown in Table 1.4.

PARAMETER VALUE
Channel bandwidth (MHz) 1.4 3 5 10 15 20
Resource Block RB 6 15 25 50 75 110
Occupied subcarriers 72 180 300 600 900 1200
IDFT/FFT size 128 256 512 1024 1536 2048
Subcarrier spacing ∆𝒇 (kHz) 15 or 7.5
CP SIZE
5.21 𝜇𝑠 (first symbol of the slot)
Normal CP (∆𝒇 = 𝟏𝟓 𝒌𝑯𝒛)
4.69 𝜇𝑠 (other symbols of the slot)
Extended CP (∆𝒇 = 𝟏𝟓 𝒌𝑯𝒛) 16.67 𝜇𝑠
Extended CP (∆𝒇 = 𝟕. 𝟓 𝒌𝑯𝒛) 33.33 𝜇𝑠

Table 1.4: 3GPP LTE-A OFDMA Parameters [10]

An OFDMA symbol is made up of null subcarriers (guard band and center subcarrier) and

data (user data and reference signals). The length of the symbol is equal to the FFT size; such

that the occupied subcarriers are part of the RBs, and the remaining subcarriers correspond to

the null subcarriers.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 19 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
1.4 DOWNLINK PHYSICAL CHANNELS AND SIGNALS

1.4.1 Downlink Physical Channels

Six steps are used to define the baseband signal representing a downlink physical channel,

as shown in Figure 1.17. First, the coded bits in each codeword are scrambled. Second,

scrambled bits are modulated in order to create complex-valued symbols. Third, the complex-

valued modulation symbols are mapped into one or more layers. Fourth, complex-valued

modulation symbols on each layer are precoded preparing them to be transmitted on the

antenna ports. Fifth, complex-valued modulation symbols for each antenna port are mapped to

resource elements. Finally, complex-valued time domain OFDM signal is generated for each

antenna port.

Figure 1.17: Overview of physical channel processing [9]

The group of some resource elements with specific information from higher levels is

known as physical channel. There are six different downlink physical channels: PDSCH,

PBCH, PMCH, PCFICH, PDCCH and PHICH [9].

The PDSCH transports user data; thus, it supports high data rates. In order to send cell

specific identification and access control parameters, PBCH is used. The PMCH transports

multimedia information. The PCFICH informs the equipment the number of OFDM symbols

(1, 2 or 3) to be used for the PDCCH in a subframe. The PDCCH is in charge of allocating

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 20 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
resource scheduling, so its value corresponds to the number of symbols to be used for the

PDCCH. Finally, with the purpose of confirming or retransmitting uplink transmissions, the

PHICH transmits ACK/NACKs. The PDSCH and PMCH support QPSK, 16QAM and

64QAM modulation; while the PBCH, PCFICH and PDCCH support QPSK.

A group of downlink subcarriers supporting PDSCH can be configured as MBSFN

subframes. Each subframe has two regions: non-MBSFN region and MBSFN region. The non-

MBSFN region contains the first or two first OFDM symbols in an MBSFN subframe; while

the MBSFN region contains all the OFDM symbols that are not part of the non-MBSFN

region in a MBSFN subframe. Table 1.5 shows the number of OFDM symbols used for

PDCCH.

Number of OFDM symbols Number of OFDM symbols


𝐷𝐿 𝐷𝐿
SUBFRAME for PDCCH when 𝑁𝑅𝐵 > 10 for PDCCH when 𝑁𝑅𝐵 ≤ 10
Subframe 1 and 6 for frame structure
1, 2 2
type 2
MBSFN subframes on a carrier
supporting PDSCH, configured with 1, 2 2
1 or 2 cell-specific antenna ports
MBSFN subframes on a carrier
supporting PDSCH, configured with 2 2
4 cell-specific antenna ports
Subframes on a carrier not
0 0
supporting PDSCH
Non-MBSFN subframes (except
subframe 6 for frame structure type
1, 2, 3 2, 3
2) configured with positioning
reference signals
All other cases 1, 2, 3 2, 3, 4

Table 1.5: Number of OFDM symbols used for PDCCH [9]

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 21 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
1.4.2 Signals

On the other hand, the group of resource elements carrying information that is not

originated from higher layers is called downlink physical signal. There are two kinds of

downlink physical signals:

- Reference signal

- Synchronization signal

Reference signals are used for channel estimation. They are allocated in the first and fifth

symbols if normal CP is used, as shown in Figure 1.18 and Appendix A. In the case of

extended CP, reference signals use the first and fourth symbols. One reference signal is

transmitted per antenna port. There are five types of downlink reference signals:

- CRS

- MBSFN

- UE-specific reference signals or DM-RS

- PRS

- CSI-RS

Synchronization signals are used for frequency and timing acquirement when user

equipment are searching for a cell. They are transmitted on 62 subcarriers of 72 reserved

around DC on the sixth and seventh symbols in slots 0 and 10, as shown in Appendix A. They

use binary sequences of 31 bits and BPSK modulation.

The uplink and downlink reference signals are different, and their transmission allocation

is also different. Figure 1.18 shows the pattern for uplink and downlink reference signals.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 22 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Figure 1.18: Uplink vs. Downlink Reference signals allocation [14]

It is clear that there are exclusive symbols within a slot to transmit only reference signals

in the uplink; while in the downlink, reference signals and data share a symbol within a slot. It

is also clear that the reference signals are not transmitted in all symbols; indeed, only 4

subcarriers are used to transmit reference signals in a RB (7x12) in the downlink.

The current work focuses on the downlink (OFDMA); hence, it is important to consider its

reference signal allocation pattern, as it will be used during all simulations later. However, the

uplink pattern will also be discussed in order to present comparisons between SC-FDMA and

OFDMA.

The mapping of reference signals depends on the number of antenna ports to be used.

Figure 1.19 shows the mapping for one, two and four antenna ports.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 23 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Figure 1.19: Mapping of downlink reference signals [9]

1.5 IFFT AND FFT IMPORTANCE

Unlike TDMA or FDMA, OFDMA and SC-FDMA depend on the time and frequency

domains. Therefore, the use of tools that allow the signal conversion from one domain to the

other is essential. FFT and IFFT are the tools to accomplish this purpose. Figure 1.20 shows

the use of IFFT and FFT.

In the downlink (OFDMA), the transmitter executes an IFFT on the frequency domain in

order to generate the OFDM symbol in the time domain. Then, the receiver performs an FFT

on the OFDM symbol, returning it to the frequency domain.

Besides, FFT and IFFT guarantee orthogonal subcarriers because when these operations

are performed on each subcarrier, the result for the others is zero.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 24 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Figure 1.20: IFFT and FFT [15]

1.6 LTE-A PERFORMANCE

The targets of LTE-A specified in Release 10, in terms of performance, are presented in

Table 1.6.

PARAMETER Downlink Uplink

Capacity (Mbps) 1000 500

Normalized capacity (bps/Hz) 30 15

Average spectral efficiency (bps/Hz/cell) 2.6 2

Table 1.6: Targets for LTE-Advanced as set by 3GPP [5]

As it noted above, OFDMA is used for the downlink transmission and SC-FDMA for the

uplink. Therefore, according to Table 1.6, OFDMA has higher capacity than SC-FDMA; in

fact, it corresponds to the double. Likewise, normalized capacity is also higher for OFDMA

than for SC-FDMA. Also, the downlink has better average spectral efficiency per cell than the

uplink.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 25 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Another important parameter of performance is the BER, which states how reliable the

signal is, in terms of the bits and errors received. Figure 1.21 shows SC-FDMA and OFDMA

FER performance studied in a previous research.

Figure 1.21: SC-FDMA vs. OFDMA performance with QPSK [16]

From the research, some important conclusions were stated. First, OFDMA performance is

highly dependent on the coding rate. For instance, without code or with high coding rates,

OFDMA performance is poor. Nonetheless, when a strong code is employed; for instance, rate

½, OFDMA recovers performance, surpassing SC-FDMA performance.

With regard to the rate capacity, when the number of users is large, the best rate capacity is

achieved with adequate SNR values. “S/N is the ratio of average signal power to average noise

power. While the Eb/No is the ratio of average energy per bit to noise power spectral

density”3.

3
Dr Falah Ali. “Digital Modulation for Wireless Communications” lecture. Mobile Communications module.
University of Sussex, Brighton. 2014.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 26 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
𝐸𝑏 𝑆𝑇𝑏 𝑆 𝑆𝐵 𝑆𝐵
= = = = (1.1)
𝑁𝑜 𝑁𝑜 𝑅𝑏 𝑁𝑜 𝑅𝑏 𝑁 𝑁𝑘𝑅𝑠

𝐸𝑠 𝑘𝐸𝑏
= (1.2)
𝑁𝑜 𝑁𝑜

Formulas 1.1 and 1.2 define the Eb/No ratio in terms of S/N ratio and viceversa, where 3:

Eb : Signal Energy per Bit Es : Energy per Symbol, Es = kEb

S: Average Signal Power No : Noise Power Spectral Density

Tb : Bit Period N0 = N⁄B

R b : Bit Rate, R b = 1⁄Tb N: Noise Power

R s : Symbol Rate, R b = kR s B: System Bandwidth

k: Number of Bits per symbol

Besides, increasing the number of receptor antennas does not increase significantly the

general capacity.

As stated in section 1.2.1, the power constraints at the user equipment imply the need to

use SC-FDMA for the uplink. Figure 1.22 presents a PAPR comparison between OFDMA and

SC-FDMA. It is evident that SC-FDMA has lower PAPR; hence, more efficient. In fact, in

this case, it is approximately 2dB lower than OFDMA.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 27 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Figure 1.22: PAPR comparison for OFDMA and SC-FDMA [17]

1.7 SOFTWARE SIMULATION PACKAGE

Simulink library of Matlab R2014a has been used for simulations in this project. When

opening Matlab, Simulink library is accessible through its button in the Home main menu, as

shown in Figure 1.23 or in the Matlab Command Window by entering simulink,

Figure 1.23: Simulink Library

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 28 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Simulink library is made up of different intern libraries, as shown in Figure 1.24. Each

library has several blocks with different functions. Moreover, it is possible to search for a

specific subsystem or block in the Search toolbox.

Figure 1.24: Simulink Library Browser

In order to start creating a new Simulink model, select File – New – Model, as shown in

Figure 1.25.

Figure 1.25: Simulink New Model

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 29 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Then, drag the required blocks from the Simulink Library to the model window to add

blocks to the model. Connections are established by dragging a wire from an output to an

input, as shown in Figure 1.26.

Figure 1.26: Adding blocks and connecting

By double clicking on each block, it is possible to configure its settings. Once the model is

ready, the Run button starts simulation.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 30 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
2 CHAPTER 2: DESIGN

CHAPTER 2

2. DESIGN

This chapter includes the design of OFDMA in 4G, using 3GPP technical specification as

the main source and basis. As explained in Chapter 1, the multiple access technique used for

the uplink in 4G is SC-FDMA and OFDMA is used for the downlink. The purpose of this

Chapter focuses on the design of OFDMA, as it is the main topic of this project; however, a

simple design on SC-FDMA has also been made for comparison.

2.1 OFDMA BLOCK DIAGRAM

Figure 2.1 shows an OFDMA transmitter and receiver model. The main components in the

transmitter are the Modulator, the Subcarrier mapping, the IFT block and the addition of the

Cyclic Prefix. According to the LTE-A standard, there are three possible modulation schemes

in the downlink: QPSK, 16QAM and 64QAM [9], as explained in Chapter 1. Then, the

subcarrier mapping is performed considering the Resource Block diagram shown in Figure

1.18. Also, the channels and signals allocation presented in Appendix A have to be considered

in order to map the subcarriers.

With regard to the IFT block, it permits the move from the frequency domain to the time

domain, which is necessary after the subcarrier mapping and before adding the cyclic prefix,

also known as guard interval. Finally, the CP is inserted, according to Table 1.4.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 31 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Figure 2.1: OFDMA Transmission and Reception model [18]

The receiver has four important blocks. The removal of the CP eliminates the information

contained in the last part of the OFDMA symbol that was added al the end of the transmitter.

The FT, which permits the move from the time domain to the frequency domain, after

removing de CP and before the Subcarrier mapping. The subcarrier mapping counteracts its

corresponding in the transmitter side, and the demodulator compensates the modulator

processing.

2.2 SC-FDMA BLOCK DIAGRAM

In spite of the fact that SC-FDMA is beyond the scope of this project, with the purpose of

comparing both techniques, its model is presented in Figure 2.2. It is clear that there are two

important differences compared to OFDMA. First, there is an FFT block after the modulator in

the transmitter. Second, there is an IFT block before the demodulator in the receiver.

By adding an FT block between the modulator and the subcarrier mapping in the

transmitter, the subcarrier mapping is executed in the frequency domain, modulating all the

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 32 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
subcarriers with the same data, unlike OFDMA. Consequently, this action has to be balanced

in the receiver with the aid of an IFT block.

Figure 2.2: SC-FDMA Transmission and Reception model [18]

2.3 PARAMETERES

Five different scenarios have been designed during this project. It has been possible to

ascertain the impact of increasing the number of users in OFDMA. Moreover, the impact that

fading has on BER in OFDMA. With the intention of comparing transmitted and received

signals transmitted through a channel configured with different Eb/No values, different

testings have been developed. Also, a comparison between OFDMA and SC-FDMA has been

feasible, in terms of PAPR.

The diagrams developed in Matlab R2014a Simulink, are based on the block diagrams

presented in Figures 2.1 and 2.2. The designs include the simulation of one OFDMA symbol,

based on the LTE-A parameters shown in Table 2.1. Due to space limitations on Simulink

screen, the design is based on FFT=256, which is the size of the OFDMA symbol.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 33 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
PARAMETER VALUE
Resource Block RB 15
𝑅𝐵
𝑁𝑠𝑐 12
𝑁𝑠𝑦𝑚𝑏 7
Maximum occupied subcarriers 180
IFFT/FFT size 256
5.21 𝜇𝑠 (first
Normal CP (∆𝑓 = 15 𝑘𝐻𝑧)
symbol of the slot)
Modulation 16QAM

Table 2.1: Simulation Parameters

2.4 OFDMA 2 USERS (AWGN)

The following scenario is designed for two users in an AWGN environment. As OFDMA

is simulated, which corresponds to the downlink, the transmitters represent the base stations

and the receivers represent the final users. The symbol processing design is presented in

Figure 2.3, and its corresponding diagram in Figure 2.4.

FDD is used in this example, such that 100 of 150 subcarriers are assigned to User 1, and

the other 50 to User 2, as shown in Figure 2.3. Consistent with the standard, there are

maximum 180 occupied subcarriers; therefore, 30 subcarriers are used for reference signals

(180-150), which are allocated according to the first symbol of the pattern shown in Figure

1.18 (downlink).

Before adding the reference signals and the null subcarriers (not occupied subcarriers) to

the frame, it is necessary to join both users’ data. To achieve this, two vectors of size 150 have

been created filling them with the users’ data and zeros. Then, both vectors are added to have

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 34 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
a resulting vector of size 150, the first 100 elements of which correspond to User 1 data, and

the last 50 to User 2.

As the FFT size to be used is 256, there are 76 null subcarriers (256-180), which are

considered as guard subcarriers in both sides of the frame and are filled with zeros with the

purpose of building the Fourier signal walls. 38 of the 76 subcarriers are allocated as left guard

subcarriers, 37 as right guard subcarriers, and 1 remaining subcarrier corresponds to the center

subcarrier, which is not transmitted in the downlink [11].

Finally, in order to calculate the number of subcarriers to be added at the begging of the

symbol as CP, corresponding to 5.21𝜇𝑠, the following estimations have been considered:

1 𝑠𝑙𝑜𝑡 → 0.5 𝑚𝑠 [9]

As 𝑁𝑠𝑦𝑚𝑏 = 7:

0.5 𝑚𝑠
1 𝑠𝑦𝑚𝑏 → = 71.43 𝜇𝑠 (FFT Size = 256)
7

∴ 5.21 𝜇𝑠 → 19 𝑠𝑢𝑏𝑐𝑎𝑟𝑟𝑖𝑒𝑟𝑠

At the receiver, the CP is removed, which corresponds to the information of the first 19

subcarriers of the received symbol. Then, the 76 null subcarriers are removed, including the

left guard subcarriers, right guard subcarriers and the center subcarrier. After removing the

null subcarriers, the 30 reference signals are also removed. Finally, the resulting vector of size

150 is divided into two parts. The first 100 subcarriers correspond to the data that belongs to

User 1 and the remaining 50 to User 2.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 35 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
2.5 OFDMA 5 USERS (AWGN)

The following scenario is designed for five users in an AWGN environment. The symbol

processing design is presented in Figure 2.5, and its corresponding diagram in Figure 2.6.

FDD is used in this example, such that 30 of 150 subcarriers are assigned to each user.

According to the standard, there are maximum 180 occupied subcarriers; hence, 30 subcarriers

are used for reference signals (180-150), which are allocated according to the first symbol of

the pattern shown in Figure 1.18 (downlink).

Before adding the reference signals and the null subcarriers to the frame, it is necessary to

join the data of the five users. For this, five vectors of size 150 have been created, and they are

filled with the users’ data and zeros. As it is shown in Figure 2.5, the first vector has user 1

data at the beginning; the second vector has user 2 data from location 31 to 60, etc. The last

vector has user 5 data at the end. Then, the five vectors are added to have a resulting vector of

size 150, the first 30 elements of which correspond to User 1 data, and the last 30 to User 5.

As the FFT size to be used is 256 and there are 180 occupied subcarriers, there are 76 not

occupied subcarriers, which are the guard subcarriers and the center subcarrier, as in the

scenario presented in numeral 2.1.1. Also, the CP estimation is the same as in the previous

scenario.

At the receiver, as in the last scenario, the CP is removed. Then, the 76 null subcarriers are

removed. After this, the 30 reference signals are also removed. Finally, the resulting vector of

size 150 is divided into five parts. The first 30 subcarriers correspond to the data that belongs

to User 1, the next 30 to User 2, etc. until the last 30 that correspond to User 5.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 36 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
2.6 OFDMA 2 USERS (AWGN + Rayleigh Fading)

The design of this scenario is the same as the described in numeral 2.1.1, but including

fading. The purpose of designing this scenario is to see the effects of fading on BER curves in

an OFDMA scenario for 2 users. The design’s diagram is shown in Figure 2.7.

2.7 OFDMA 5 USERS (AWGN + Rayleigh Fading)

The design of this scenario is the same as the described in numeral 2.1.2, but including

fading. The purpose of designing this scenario is to see the effects of fading on BER curves in

an OFDMA scenario for 5 users. The design’s diagram is shown in Figure 2.8.

2.8 SC-FDMA 2 USERS (AWGN)

The last design is a SC-FDMA scenario, according to LTE-A parameters. As this

simulation corresponds to the uplink, it has to be considered that the transmitters represent

users starting communication and the receivers represent base stations that process the users’

requests. The symbol processing design is presented in Figure 2.9, and its corresponding

diagram in Figure 2.10.

The generation of the SC-FDMA signal is similar to the OFDMA signal processing using

the same parameters shown in Table 2.1 [10]. Even though, there are some differences to

consider. First, reference signals are not transmitted in the following simulation because in

SC-FDMA, the first symbol within a slot is used only to transmit data, as shown in Figure 1.18

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 37 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
(uplink). Also, as the center subcarrier is not transmitted only in the downlink, in this case it

has to be transmitted.

Before adding the null subcarriers, it is necessary to join both users’ data. To achieve this,

two vectors of size 150 have been created filling them with the users’ data and zeros, as in

scenario 2.1.1. Then, both vectors are added to have a resulting vector of size 150, the first 100

elements of which correspond to User 1, and the last 50 to User 2.

The FFT size is also 256 in this case; though, the number of occupied subcarriers is not

considered as the maximum that the standard defines (180). With the purpose of transmitting

the same data in the uplink as the transmitted in the downlink in scenario 2.1.1, the occupied

subcarriers in the uplink is equal to 150 due to the lack of reference signals in the first symbol

of the slot. Thus, there are 106 null subcarriers (256-150), 53 of which are allocated as left

guard subcarriers and the remaining 53 are the right guard subcarriers. In this case, the center

subcarrier is transmitted, for being the uplink, so it is one of the occupied subcarriers. As the

FFT and RB sizes are the same as in the other cases, the CP size does not change.

At the receiver, firstly, the CP is removed. Then, the 106 null subcarriers are removed.

After this, the resulting vector of size 150 is divided into two parts. The first 100 subcarriers

correspond to the data that belongs to User 1 and the remaining 50 to User 2.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 38 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Figure 2.3: OFDMA 2 Users Design

Figure 2.4: OFDMA 2 Users (AWGN) Diagram 4

4
Adapted from: [20], [21] and [22].

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems with Business Management Page 39 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013
Figure 2.5: OFDMA 5 Users Design

Figure 2.6: OFDMA 5 Users (AWGN) Diagram 5

5
Adapted from: [20], [21] and [22].

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems with Business Management Page 40 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013
Figure 2.7: OFDMA 2 Users (AWGN + Rayleigh Fading) Diagram 6

Figure 2.8: OFDMA 5 Users (AWGN + Rayleigh Fading) Diagram 6

6
Adapted from: [20], [21] and [22].

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems with Business Management Page 41 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013
Figure 2.9: SC-FDMA 2 Users Design

Figure 2.10: SC-FDMA 2 Users Diagram 7

7
Adapted from: [20], [21] and [22].

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems with Business Management Page 42 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013
3 CHAPTER 3: SIMULATION SETTINGS

CHAPTER 3

3. SIMULATION SETTINGS

This chapter describes the parameters configured in each block of Simulink for the

different scenarios.

3.1 OFDMA 2 USERS (AWGN)

Figures 3.1, 3.14 and 3.16 are extracts of Figure 2.4, and they correspond to the

transmitter, channel and receiver.

3.1.1 Transmitter

Figure 3.1: OFDMA 2 Users Transmitter

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 43 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Random Integer (User 1), (User 2): As the modulation scheme to be used is 16QAM, the

M-ary number parameter is configured as 16 in both cases. For user 1, 100 samples per frame

are generated (a), and 50 samples per frame for user 2 (b).

(a) (b)
Figure 3.2: Source Block Parameters (OFDMA 2 users)

Integer to Bit Converter and Bit to Integer Converter: These blocks are necessary only to

obtain the BER calculation. As the source generates integers, it would cause confusion or

estimation errors while calculating the BER, which is based on bits; therefore, the change from

integer to bit is used. As the parameters of these blocks depend only on the modulation order,

they are the same for both users.

(a) (b)
Figure 3.3: Integer to Bit Converter / Bit to Integer Converter

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 44 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Rectangular QAM Modulator: According to the LTE-A standard, 16QAM modulation

has been chosen for both users. Besides, Gray constellation ordering is configured.

Figure 3.4: Rectangular QAM Modulator

Constants for Zero extension: As explained in Chapter 2, in order to join the data of both

users, two vectors of size 150 are created, filling them with data and zeros. The constant

created to be used with the data of User 1 is a vector of 50 zeros (b), while the other constant

is a vector of 100 zeros (a), and it will be used for User 2 data.

(a) (b)
Figure 3.5: Zero constant vectors (OFDMA 2 Users)

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 45 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Extension of zeros: Two vectors are created. The first vector contains the 100 samples

created by the Random Integer block for User 1 and 50 zeros originated by one of the constant

blocks. The second vector is created by 100 zeros originated by the other constant block and at

the end by the 50 samples of User 2. Both function blocks have the same configuration, as

shown in Figure 3.6. For this, the Vector Concatenate block was used.

Figure 3.6: Extension of zeros (OFDMA 2 Users)

Addition: The two previous vectors of size 150 are summed up to obtain another vector of

size 150, with User 1 data at the beginning and User 2 data at the end of the vector.

Figure 3.7: Vectors Addition (OFDMA 2 Users)

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 46 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Multiport Selector: The signal entering into this block is divided into 30 groups; each

group contains 5 elements (1:5, 6:10, 11:15…..146:150), as shown in the configuration

parameter in Figure 3.8. This is to prepare the symbol to introduce the reference signals,

according to the pattern of the first OFDMA symbol shown in Figure 1.18 (downlink).

Figure 3.8: Multiport Selector

Null subcarriers constants: As explained in Chapter 2, 38 subcarriers are used as left

guard (a), 37 subcarriers correspond to right guard (b) and one remaining is the central

subcarrier (c), which is not transmitted in the downlink, so the design considers to fill the

subcarrier with zero. All these constants are configured as 38 (a), 37 (b) and 1 zero (c),

respectively, as shown in Figure 3.9.

(a) (b)

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 47 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
(c)
Figure 3.9: Null subcarriers constants

Reference signals constant: Thirty reference signals are generated to complete 180

occupied subcarriers. These signals are allocated one by one after each group generated by the

Multiport Selector block, according to the pattern shown in Figure 1.18. To accomplish the

scope of this project, the reference signals are set with 1, as shown in Figure 3.10; however, in

real scenarios, reference signals contain special information to estimate the channel.

Figure 3.10: Reference signals constant

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 48 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Matrix Concatenate: 63 Inputs enter into this block, as shown in Figure 3.11. First, the

left guard subcarriers; second, a reference signal, then the first block of 5 subcarriers from the

Multiport selector, then another reference signal, etc. until completing the 63 inputs with the

last one, which corresponds to the right guard subcarriers input.

Figure 3.11: Matrix concatenate (OFDMA)

IFFT: Based on the standard, the FFT length to be used is 256 for this simulation. It is

important to note that the FFT length has to be the same as the frame size after the matrix

concatenate block.

Figure 3.12: IFFT (OFDMA)

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 49 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Add Cyclic Prefix: As described in Chapter 2, the last 19 subcarriers of the OFDMA

symbol are copied and inserted at its beginning. As the FFT length is 256, the last 19

subcarriers are from 238 to 256, as presented in Figure 3.13. After specifying the CP, the

remaining symbol has to be transmitted, from 1 to 256. For this, the block Selector was used.

Figure 3.13: Cyclic Prefix Addition

3.1.2 Channel

Figure 3.14: Channel (AWGN)

AWGN Channel: First, with the purpose of comparing how the transmitted signal is

affected by the Eb/No ratio, three different values have been configured Eb/No = 30 dB (a), 43

dB (b) and 80 dB (c). Then, in order to obtain the BER curve, the Eb/No parameter has been

set to Eb/No in general, not a fixed value (d).

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 50 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
(a) (b)

(c) (d)
Figure 3.15: AWGN Channel (OFDMA 2 Users)

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 51 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
3.1.3 Receiver

Figure 3.16: OFDMA 2 Users Receiver

Remove Cyclic Prefix: The Selector block is used to remove the CP. After adding the CP,

the frame size is 275 (256+19); hence, in order to remove the CP, only the subcarriers 20 to

275 have to be transmitted, as shown in Figure 3.17.

Figure 3.17: Cyclic Prefix Removal

FFT: The FFT length to be used is 256 to contrast the effect of the IFFT block in the

transmitter and due to the frame size.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 52 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Figure 3.18: FFT (OFDMA)

Frame Conversion: This block does not make any change to the input, only changes the

output sampling mode. In this case, the FFT block allows the change from the time domain to

the frequency domain; therefore, before removing the null subcarriers, it is advisable to set the

sampling mode to frame – based to avoid any mismatch.

Figure 3.19: Frame Conversion

Remove Null Subcarriers: This Selector block removes the first 38 subcarriers, the center

subcarrier and the last 37 subcarriers of the frame; thus, the null subcarriers.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 53 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Figure 3.20: Null subcarriers removal

Remove Reference signals: This Multiport Selector block removes the reference signals.

The first output port of the block is configured with all the subcarriers to be transmitted: 2:6

8:12 14:18 20:24….176:180. The second output port is used to send the reference signals to be

discarded: 1, 7, 13, 19, 25….175.

Figure 3.21: Reference signals removal

Terminator: This block is used to discard the 30 reference signals configured in the

second port of the Multiport Selector block. This block does not have parameters to be set;

though, it is advisable to terminate the reference signals to avoid any mismatch during

simulation.

Figure 3.22: Reference signals terminator

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 54 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Separate Users data: This Multiport Selector block is used to separate the frame of size

150 into two streams. The first stream corresponds to the first 100 modulated subcarriers, and

the other to the last 50 modulated subcarriers.

Figure 3.23: Users’ data separation (OFDMA 2 Users)

Rectangular QAM Demodulator: The setting of both demodulators is the same. As

16QAM was used in modulation during transmission, 16QAM is also used in demodulation

during reception. Also, Gray constellation is used, as in modulation.

Figure 3.24: Rectangular QAM Demodulator

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 55 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Integer to Bit Converter: The configuration of this block is exactly the same as the Integer

to Bit Converter block shown in Figure 3.3 (a). This block is used to avoid conflicts during the

Error rate calculation.

Error Rate Calculation: The variables maxNumErrs and maxNumBits were defined in the

Matlab workspace to stop the simulation.

Figure 3.25: Error Rate Calculation

3.2 OFDMA 5 USERS (AWGN)

Figures 3.26, 3.14 and 3.30 are extracts of Figure 2.6, and they correspond to the

transmitter, channel and receiver. The following description corresponds to the parameters that

differ from scenario 1 (OFDMA 2 Users AWGN), so all the blocks that are not described in

this section in spite of being in the corresponding diagrams, were configured with the same

parameters of scenario 1.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 56 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
3.2.1 Transmitter

Figure 3.26: OFDMA 5 Users Transmitter

Random Integer (All Users): As the modulation scheme to be used is 16QAM, the M-ary

number parameter is 16. For all users, 30 samples per frame are generated in this example;

however it is possible to design different sizes per user, as in the previous scenario.

Figure 3.27: Source Block Parameters (OFDMA 5 users)

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 57 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Constants for Zero extension: Four constants were included in the design. The first one

generates 120 zeros (a), the second 90 (b), the third 60 (c) and the last one generates 30 zeros

(d), as shown in Figure 3.28.

(a) (b)

(c) (d)
Figure 3.28: Zero constant vectors (OFDMA 5 Users)

Extension of zeros: Five vectors are created. The first vector for instance, contains the 30

samples created for User 1 by the Random Integer block and 120 zeros originated by one of

the constant blocks (a). The generation of the five vectors is shown in Figure 2.5. Two of the

three function blocks concatenate 2 inputs, while the remaining three blocks concatenate 3

inputs.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 58 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Addition: The five vectors of size 150 are summed up to obtain another vector of size 150,

with User 1’s data at the beginning and User 5’s data at the end of the resulting vector.

Figure 3.29: Vectors Addition (OFDMA 5 Users)

3.2.2 Channel

The channel configuration is the same as the previous case with 2 Users.

3.2.3 Receiver

Figure 3.30: Receiver (OFDMA 5 Users)

Separate Users data: This Multiport Selector block is used to separate the frame of size

150 into five streams, each one of size 30.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 59 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Figure 3.31: Users’ data separation (OFDMA 5 Users)

3.3 OFDMA 2 USERS (AWGN + Rayleigh Fading)

Figures 3.1, 3.32 and 3.16 are extracts of Figure 2.7, and they correspond to the

transmitter, channel and receiver. The following description corresponds to the parameters that

differ from scenario 1 (OFDMA 2 Users AWGN), so all the blocks that are not described in

this section in spite of being in the corresponding diagrams, were configured with the same

parameters of scenario 1.

3.3.1 Transmitter

The configuration of all the blocks in the transmitter is the same as the described in section

3.1.1.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 60 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
3.3.2 Channel

Figure 3.32: Channel (AWGN + Rayleigh Fading)

AWGN Channel: In order to obtain the BER curve, the Eb/No parameter has been set to

Eb/No in general, not a fixed value.

Figure 3.33: AWGN Channel (OFDMA 5 Users)

Rayleigh Fading: This block is the main component of this design because its purpose is

to evaluate the impact of fading in the transmission. The parameters shown in Figure 3.34

were configured.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 61 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Besides, the Math function (conj) and a product block were used to combine the effect of

the fading block with the AWGN block. This part of the design was developed and tested

during the Mobile Communications module.

Figure 3.34 AWGN Channel (OFDMA 5 Users)

3.3.3 Receiver

The configuration of all the blocks in the receiver is the same as the described in section

3.1.3

3.4 OFDMA 5 USERS (AWGN + Rayleigh Fading)

Figures 3.26, 3.32 and 3.30 are extracts of Figure 2.8, and they correspond to the

transmitter, channel and receiver. All the blocks were configured with the same parameters of

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 62 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
scenario 2 (OFDMA 5 Users AWGN) in the case of transmitter and receiver, and scenario 3

(OFDMA 2 Users AWGN + Fading) for the channel.

3.4.1 Transmitter

The configuration of all the blocks in the transmitter is the same as the described in section
3.2.1.

3.4.2 Channel
All the channel configuration is the same as the described in section 3.3.2 (2 Users AWGN

+ Fading).

3.4.3 Receiver
The configuration of all the blocks in the receiver is the same as the described in section
3.2.3.

3.5 SC-FDMA 2 USERS (AWGN)

Figures 3.35, 3.14 and 3.40 are extracts of Figure 2.10, and they correspond to the

transmitter, channel and receiver. The following description corresponds to the parameters that

differ from scenario 1 (OFDMA 2 Users AWGN); thus, all the blocks that are not described in

this section in spite of being in the corresponding diagrams, were configured with the same

parameters of scenario 1.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 63 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
3.5.1 Transmitter

Figure 3.35: SC-FDMA 2 Users Transmitter

FFT: It is important to note that in previous versions of Simulink, the FFT length must be

a power of two. In this case, the signal length entering into the FFT block is 150, which is not

a power of two. Hence, it was necessary to use the last version of the software and configure

FFT implementation as Auto, which permits to work with any input dimension, as shown in

Figure 3.36.

Figure 3.36: FFT (SC-FDMA Transmitter)

Multiport Selector: As explained in Chapter 1, Figure 1.6, the first symbol of a SC-FDMA

slot does not contain reference signals, so the configuration of this block is simpler than in

OFDMA because it is not necessary to create groups of five subcarriers. In fact, it could even

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 64 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
be omitted. In this case, it was configured just to show that the data of the users is not divided

in groups and is continuously transmitted without interruption.

Figure 3.37: Multiport Selector (SC-FDMA)

Null subcarriers constants: As explained in Chapter 2, 53 subcarriers are used as left

guard and also as right guard. For the uplink, the central subcarrier is transmitted, so in this

case there is not a null subcarrier in the center as in OFDMA. These constants are configured

as 53 zeros, as shown in Figure 3.38.

Figure 3.38: Null subcarriers constants (SC-FDMA)

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 65 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Matrix Concatenate: There are 4 inputs; two for the null subcarriers and the others for the

data subcarriers, as shown in Figure 3.39.

Figure 3.39: Matrix Concatenate (SC-FDMA)

3.5.2 Channel

The configuration of the channel is the same as case 1 (OFDMA 2 Users AWGN).

3.5.3 Receiver

Figure 3.40: SC-FDMA 2 Users Receiver

Remove Null Subcarriers: This Selector block removes the first and final 53 subcarriers,

respectively.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 66 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Figure 3.41: Null subcarriers removal (SC-FDMA)

IFFT: The input length of this block is not a power of two, so it is configured as Auto, and

“Inherit FFT length from input dimensions”, as presented in Figure 3.42.

Figure 3.42: IFFT

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 67 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
4 CHAPTER 4: RESULTS AND ANAYLIS
CHAPTER 4

4. RESULTS AND ANALYSIS

4.1 OFDMA 2 USERS (AWGN)

Figure 4.1 shows a portion of the integer data transmitted by two base stations (TX1 and

TX2), and a portion of the integer data received by the corresponding users (RX1 and RX2).

Three different values of Eb/No were configured as explained in Chapter 3 Eb/No = 30dB (a),

43dB (b) and 80dB (c).

(a) (b) (c)


Figure 4.1: TX and RX Integer data (2 Users) Eb/No=30dB (a), 43dB (b), 80dB (c)

Twenty samples have been taken of the 100 random integers generated by TX1; as well as

20 samples of the 50 random integers that TX2 generates. In the first case, 30dB (a), RX1

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 68 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
received 2 errors and RX2 received 4 errors. With Eb/No = 43dB (b), both RX1 and RX2 did

not receive any error, as in the last case when Eb/No = 80dB (c).

Accordingly, as the Signal to Noise ratio Eb/No increases, the number of wrong values or

errors decreases. In this case, it was possible to reach no errors from values close to 40dB.

Figure 4.2 shows the Error rate, number of errors and number of comparisons that the block

made for both users. Three different values of Eb/No have been configured Eb/No = 30dB (a),

43dB (b) and 80dB (c) to have these results.

(a) (b) (c)

Figure 4.2: Error rate, Errors and Comparisons (2 Users) Eb/No=30dB (a), 43dB (b), 80dB (c)

From Figure 4.2, it is clear that User 1 is receiving the double of bits compared to User 2,

which is the expected result according to the design. In spite of the fact that both users receive

errors when Eb/No=30dB (a), the highest Error rate value corresponds to the user with the

lowest amount of information. As obtained in the results of Figure 4.1, for Eb/No=43dB (b)

and Eb/No=80dB (c), all the data received is the same as the transmitted for both users, which

is confirmed in the results shown in Figure 4.2, where Error rate = 0 and no errors are detected

in both cases.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 69 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Figure 4.3 corresponds to User 1’s transmitted data after being modulated. Indeed, the

figure shows data modulated with 16QAM, which corresponds to the modulated selected from

the standard. The received data was tested configuring the channel with Eb/No = 30 dB (a), 43

dB (b) and 80 dB (c), and they are presented in Figure 4.4.

Figure 4.3: Modulated TX Data (User 1 of 2)

(a) (b) (c)


Figure 4.4: Modulated RX Data (User 1) Eb/No=30dB (a), 43dB (b) and 80dB (c)

Based on the previous results, it was predicted that the received signal would be very

different from the transmitted when Eb/No=30dB, as it actually is. In the second case,

Eb/No=43dB, even though the symbols are not located exactly at the same position where

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 70 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
were transmitted, the receptor is able enough to detect the correct positions due to proximity;

thus, no errors were detected in Figures 4.1 (b) and 4.2 (b). Finally, Eb/No=80dB is high

enough for the system to receive all the symbols exactly as they were transmitted.

The data transmitted to User 2 is shown in Figure 4.5. The received data is shown in

Figure 4.6, tested in three different scenarios, as with User 1.

Figure 4.5: Modulated TX Data (User 2 of 2)

(a) (b) (c)


Figure 4.6: Modulated RX Data (User 2) Eb/No=30dB (a), 43dB (b) and 80dB (c)

The received modulated signal corresponds to 16QAM. In the first case, Eb/No=30dB (a),

it is not possible to distinguish the received symbols; hence, the number of errors was higher

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 71 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
in that case. In the other cases, it is possible to distinguish the symbols, especially for the last

case, Eb/No=80dB (c), which the received modulated signal is exactly as the transmitted

modulated data.

The signal transmitted in terms of dBW/Hz vs. Hz is shown in Figure 4.7, and Figure 4.8

presents the received signal after passing the channel configured with Eb/No=30dB (a), 43dB

(b) and 80dB (c), respectively.

Figure 4.7: Transmitted signal

(a) (b) (c)


Figure 4.8: Received signal Eb/No=30dB (a), 43dB (b) and 80dB(c)

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 72 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
As the Eb/No value increases, the received and transmitted signals are more alike. In the

first case (a), Eb/No=30dB is not high enough for the system to receive an appropriate signal;

in other words, the difference between the transmitted and received signals is the reason by

which multiple errors were detected and shown in Figures 4.1 (a) and 4.2 (a). When

Eb/No=43dB (b), the received signal is more similar to the transmitted signal than the signal

received with Eb/No=30dB; however, they are still not equal. When Eb/No=80dB (c), the

transmitted and received signals are equal, and this is confirmed in Figure 4.1 (c) and 4.2 (c),

where no errors were detected.

4.2 OFDMA 5 USERS (AWGN)

The transmitted and received random integers for 5 users are shown in Figure 4.9. Three

different values of Eb/No were also used, as in the previous scenario Eb/No = 30dB, 43dB and

80dB. In this case, the display sample size is 10 integers per user; however, it is important to

consider that the total number of integers generated per user is 30, as shown in Figures 2.5 and

2.6. Because of space, only 10 integers of 30 integers per user are considered for analysis.

When Eb/No=30dB (a), in a sample of 10 integers, User 1 receives two errors, User 2 does

not receive errors, User 3 registers one error, User 4 has two errors and User 5 does not

register any error in the first 10 integers.

On the other hand, when Eb/No = 43dB (b) and 80dB (c), as in the previous scenario with

two users, no errors are received in the first 10 integers.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 73 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
(a) (b) (c)
Figure 4.9: TX and RX Integer data (5 Users) Eb/No=30dB (a), 43dB (b), 80dB (c)

Figure 4.10 shows the Error rate, number of errors and number of comparisons that the

block made. These displays confirm that no errors were detected when Eb/No = 43 (b) and

80dB (c). Additionally, in spite of the fact that the five users receive the same amount of data

(30 integers), the number of errors is not the same for each one. Thus, the Error rate values are

different.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 74 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
(a) (b) (c)
Figure 4.10: Error rate, Errors and Comparisons (5 Users) Eb/No=30dB (a), 43dB (b), 80dB (c)

From Figure 4.10, it is clear that when Eb/No=30dB (a), Users 3 and 5 receive the most

errors; thus their Error rate are the highest. User 5 receives the lowest amount of errors, so its

Error rate is the lowest. When Eb/No=43dB (b), no errors are detected for all the users. Also,

when Eb/No=80dB (c) no errors are detected; hence, the Error rate is zero.

Figures 4.11 and 4.12 show the transmitted and received modulated data for User 1..

The transmitted signal corresponds to the modulated OFDMA symbol, so it is clear that

16QAM modulation is used, as stated in the standard. With the purpose of comparing the

transmitted signal with the received signal, it is useful to see that there is not any sample

between 0 and -2 in both axes (Quadrature Amplitude and In-phase Amplitude).

Consequently, at the receiver this range in both axes should also be empty of samples.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 75 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Figure 4.11: Modulated TX Data (User 1 of 5)

(a) (b) (c)


Figure 4.12: Modulated RX Data (User 1 of 5) Eb/No=30dB (a), 43dB (b), 80dB (c)

When Eb/No=80dB (c), it is possible to recover the signal exactly as it was transmitted;

however, when Eb/No=43dB (b), the system can recognize the samples and no errors are

transmitted. When Eb/No=30dB (a), it is not possible to recover a reliable signal; thus, errors

were detected as shown in Figures 4.9 (a) and 4.10 (a)

Figures 4.13 and 4.14 show the transmitted and received modulated data for User 2. Again,

it is clear that Eb/No=30dB (a) does not permit to receive reliable data.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 76 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Figure 4.13: Modulated TX Data (User 2 of 5)

(a) (b) (c)


Figure 4.14: Modulated RX Data (User 2 of 5) Eb/No=30dB (a), 43dB (b), 80dB (c)

The received data of User 3 corresponds to Figure 4.16, and the originally transmitted data

is shown in Figure 4.15. The pattern obtained for the previous users, is repeated in this case;

hence, Eb/No=30dB (a) has low reliability, when Eb/No=43dB (b) the 16QAM symbols have

enough proximity to distinguish the samples and avoid errors, and Eb/No=80dB (c) has the

highest reliability.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 77 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Figure 4.15: Modulated TX Data (User 3 of 5)

(a) (b) (c)


Figure 4.16: Modulated RX Data (User 3 of 5) Eb/No=30dB (a), 43dB (b), 80dB (c)

Figures 4.17 and 4.18 correspond to User 4. The general behavior is repeated for all the

users; however, analyzing each sample and comparing with other users, it is clear that samples

are not the same for all the users, especially with Eb/No=30dB (a) and Eb/No=43dB (b).

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 78 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Figure 4.17: Modulated TX Data (User 4 of 5)

(a) (b) (c)


Figure 4.18: Modulated RX Data (User 4 of 5) Eb/No=30dB (a), 43dB (b), 80dB (c)

Finally, Figures 4.19 and 4.20 show the transmitted and received modulated data for User

5. In the transmitted signal, there is a square in the constellation without any sample.

Comparing the transmitted data with the received, when Eb/No=30dB (a), there is a pair of

samples in the square that is supposed to be empty, so this generates the errors and a high

Error rate value at the receiver.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 79 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Figure 4.19: Modulated TX Data (User 5 of 5)

(a) (b) (c)


Figure 4.20: Modulated RX Data (User 5 of 5) Eb/No=30dB (a), 43dB (b), 80dB (c)

Figures 4.21 and 4.22 show the transmitted and received signals, respectively, in terms of

dBW/Hz vs. Hz. It is evident that the most reliable signal is obtained when Eb/No=80dB (c).

The received signal when Eb/No=30dB (a) is considerably different from the transmitted

signal. With Eb/No=43dB (b), the received signal is still different than the transmitted, but it

is reliable enough to avoid errors, as shown in Figures 4.9 and 4.10.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 80 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Figure 4.21: Transmitted signal (5 Users)

(a) (b) (c)


Figure 4.22: Received signal (5 Users) Eb/No=30dB (a), 43dB (b), 80dB (c)

Despite the fact that the second received signal Eb/No=43dB (b) is not exactly the same as

the transmitted, it does not register errors for users because the system is able to recognize

correctly the 16QAM received symbols, as shown in Figure 4.10.

4.3 BER RESULTS

The Bit Error Rate (BER) is one of the most important parameters to evaluate performance

in digital communications. The BER quantifies the reliability of the entire radio system from

“bits in” to “bits out”, including the electronics, antennas and signal path between [19].

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 81 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
As two scenarios generating an OFDMA symbol were designed, with two and five users,

respectively, the purpose of the following results was comparing the BER curves for both

scenarios, shown in Figure 4.23.

Note: “User 1 of 2”: User 1 performance of 2 User system, “User 1 of 5”: User 1 performance of 5 User system

Figure 4.23: BER Curves for 2 and 5 Users (AWGN)

There are some aspects to consider in order to analyze Figure 4.23. First, (User 1 of 2)

handles the biggest data size, (User 2 of 2) has a medium size of data and the other users have

the lowest data size. Second, the AWGN channel has exactly the same configuration in all the

cases.

Besides, the ideal condition for a given BER value corresponds to the curves located on

the left, so they have the best performance.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 82 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Based on this, (User 1 of 5) has the best performance because at a certain BER value, its

Eb/No corresponding value is the lowest. In other words, the Bit / Error ratio is the same as the

other curves in spite of its low Eb/No value, which means that though less ideal environment

conditions in terms of noise, it has the same BER performance than other curves related with

better environment conditions. Furthermore, it is clear that (User 1 of 2), which is the user

receiving the most data, has a good performance at high Eb/No values. Finally, the five users

of the second design do not have the same BER curve behavior in spite of receiving the same

amount of information. Figure 4.24 shows the BER curves with and without fading for two

and five users, respectively.

(a) (b)
Note: “1 of 2”: User 1 performance of 2 User system, “1 of 5”: User 1 performance of 5 User system

Figure 4.24: BER Curves for 2 Users (a), and 5 Users (b) (AWGN vs. AWGN + Fading)

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 83 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
In the first case, as stated previously, (User 1 of 2) has better performance than (User 2 of

2) approximately from Eb/No = 13dB onwards. Also, the performance for both users degrades

when fading is added to the channel. In the second case, only three of five users have been

analyzed to avoid confusion because of the number of curves. The curves corresponding to the

scenario without fading have better performance compared to those with fading. Indeed, the

user with the best performance in AWGN, has also the best performance in AWGN + Fading.

4.4 PAPR RESULTS

The Peak to Average Power Ratio (PAPR) is the key parameter by which SC-FDMA is

used in the uplink instead of OFDMA. With the purpose of verifying that the PAPR is in fact

lower in SC-FDMA than in OFDMA, the simulation of an SC-FDMA symbol was designed,

as shown in the diagram presented in Figure 2.8. The Spectrum Analyzer block was used in

simulations to measure the PAPR values of the uplink and downlink, as shown in Figure 4.26.

(a) (b)
Figure 4.26: PAPR for 2 Users OFDMA (a) vs. SC-FDMA (b) (AWGN)

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 84 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
In the downlink (a), the PAPR is equal to 9.844 dB; while in the uplink (b) it is equal to

5.833. In other words, in the simulation of SC-FDMA, the PAPR obtained is almost the half of

the PAPR corresponding to OFDMA.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 85 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
5 CHAPTER 5: CHALLENGES AND DESIGN IMPROVEMTS
CHAPTER 5

5. CHALLENGES AND DESIGN IMPROVEMENTS

5.1 CHALLENGES

Despite the efforts of LTE-A to increase the data rate, the excessive growth of users,

makes capacity a key requirement. In fact, in order to guarantee coverage, companies opt to

install more base stations, antennas and radio links, investing heavily sometimes. In addition,

expansion deployment involves other costs such as battery, air conditioning, support, training,

and others. On the other hand, high demand is not a constant pattern for 24 hours a day;

therefore, high investment is not justified in hours of low usage.

As the size of the platform increases, interference becomes more challenging. This directly

affects performance. Even with OFDMA in the downlink, it cannot be possible to guarantee

perfect orthogonal subcarriers because of the uncertainty of the channel, and with more users

it becomes more challenging. Besides OFDMA, LTE-A considers other technologies to deal

with the growing capacity requirement, such as MIMO and Carrier Aggregation. However,

they are technologies that continues being dependent on spectrum, which is unpredictable,

scarce and expensive.

Synchronization is another challenge that LTE-A has because of the unpredictable channel

and unpredictable demand for resources. In fact, synchronization is essential to avoid

interference and minimize errors during transmission.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 86 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
Some user equipment challenges are related to carrier aggregation and MIMO technology.

Carrier aggregation could involve a complex radio environment design. Then, MIMO is based

on the use of a number of antennas; indeed, up to eight transmitters in downlink, requiring

more battery life of devices.

SC-FDMA is used in the uplink with the purpose of minimizing PAPR and ensuring

longer battery life of devices; however, at the cost of BER. Therefore, as BER could not be

affected in the downlink, OFDMA is used instead of SC-FDMA. To sum up, designing a

system with an efficient PAPR implies a BER performance decline, and vice versa.

5.2 IMPROVEMENTS

One of the most challenging tasks in mobile communications is to deal with the

transmission of data and control information without degrading performance, but guaranteeing

proper synchronization and use of resources at the same time. However, it is clear that the use

of resources to transmit control information during data transmission decreases bandwidth

capabilities for users. Thus, a possible improvement is to separate data and control information

to be transmitted using different resources. By doing this, spectral efficiency is achieved

because all the subcarriers within a symbol transmit only user data. To illustrate, the OFDMA

symbol that has been designed and simulated during the current project, has 256 subcarriers,

30 of which are reference signals. Hence, 11.7% of the OFDMA symbol was used to transmit

information that does not correspond to user data.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 87 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
This is not so critical in the downlink, as it is in the uplink. As 3 of 14 symbols within a

subframe are completely used to transmit control information, 21.4% of the subframe is used

to transmit it. Hence, it is a fairly high number considering the excessive cost of bandwidth.

Figure 4.27 presents a design in which the reference signals do not occupy the subcarriers

of the symbol transmitting user data. Figure 4.28 shows the corresponding diagram. Tough, as

their function do not cease to be important and necessary, reference signals should be

transmitted, but through a different resource than frequency.

Figure 4.27: OFDMA Design Proposal

Figure 4.28: OFDMA Diagram Proposal

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 88 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
The simulated and analyzed scenario based on the current standard consisted of an

OFDMA symbol with 256 subcarriers, distributed in 76 null subcarriers, 180 occupied

subcarriers (100 subcarriers assigned to User 1, 50 to User 2 and 30 reference signals). The

proposal aims to eliminate the 30 reference signals, leaving 30 available subcarriers to be used

to transmit more user data. For instance, 120 subcarriers are assigned to User 1, and 60 to User

2. Consequently, the use of frequency is more efficient.

Besides, new software development could improve mobile communications performance

and reduce the dependence on hardware. For instance, the allocation of resources could be

programmable and on demand, optimizing the use of resources in peak hours and off peak

hours.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 89 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
6 CHAPTER 5: CONCLUSIONSGN IMPROVEMTS
CHAPTER 6

6. CONCLUSIONS AND FUTURE WORK

6.1 CONCLUSIONS

In LTE-A the frequency resources are distributed according to the needs of each user; for

instance, the resources provided to a user who is starting a videoconference, uploading a photo

and downloading a .JPEG file outweigh the resources provided to another user who is only

sending a message. On the other hand, as the number of users increases, the available

frequency resources decrease. Consequently, some users may perceive slowness or even signal

loss in environments with high demand. Thus, LTE-A is flexible but remains limited. To

illustrate, two users were widely allocated within an OFDMA symbol in simulations, but five

users had to be closely accommodated within a symbol with limited bandwidth resources.

With orthogonal subcarriers, spectral efficiency is achieved. Indeed, as bandwidth is a

limited and expensive resource, this technique significantly improves the use of spectrum.

Besides, orthogonal subcarriers minimize ICI. Although, filtering, synchronization and

signaling become challenging to conserve orthogonality, avoiding ICI and optimizing the use

of bandwidth at the same time.

The Cyclic Prefix is a portion of the last part of an OFDMA symbol inserted at the

beginning of it. This element provides with more roominess to each symbol in order to avoid

ISI. LTE-A defines two possible values for CP, 16.67𝜇𝑠 and 33.33𝜇𝑠. In the design, the CP is

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 90 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
added just before passing to the channel, and it is removed at the moment when the symbol

reaches the receptor.

Given a low Eb/No value, the user with the most data within a symbol has the lowest BER.

Furthermore, when different users are given the same amount of subcarriers within a symbol,

the BER value is not necessarily the same for each user. Thus, some of them may receive

more errors than others. Given a high Eb/No value, the receptor does not receive errors and the

signal is very similar to the transmitted signal. In spite of the fact that received symbols are not

exactly at the same position of transmitted symbols, proximity is adequate enough for the

receptor to distinguish them.

Regarding Eb/No vs. BER curves, it is clear that when fading induces the channel, the

performance is degraded. Besides, in both designs, with two and five users, the user data

allocated in the first part of the symbol has the best performance compared to the other users.

Hence, as the symbol advances, synchronization and orthogonality suffer a slight decline.

With regard to the results obtained over PAPR, due to the power limitations at the user

equipment, it is ideal to reduce the PAPR to the minimum for the uplink. During this project, it

was possible to find that SC-FDMA has lower PAPR properties than OFDMA; thus, SC-

FDMA is used for uplink transmissions instead of OFDMA.

Considering that bandwidth is a scarce and expensive resource, and due to the fact that the

number of users and theirs needs increase rapidly, the suppression of control data within the

symbols that transmit user data, has been proposed as a possible improvement.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 91 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
6.2 FUTURE WORK

SC-FDMA has been defined as the multiple access technique to be used for uplink due to

its low PAPR, such that the power required from user equipment is minimized. Even though,

this multiple access technique has not been considered for the downlink because the PAPR

reduction involves BER decline. Thus, it would be interesting to work on studying how to

reduce PAPR in OFDMA; thereby, BER and PAPR could be optimized.

Moreover, reducing the dependence on bandwidth requirement would be useful. Despite

the fact that OFDMA contributes with spectral efficiency, this resource continues being scarce

and expensive. Also, it is vulnerable to interference and fading.

As part of the design improvements presented in Chapter 5, the separation of reference

signals and user data will be studied in future. Also, the use of software development to

replace hardware that could reduce costs and facilitate the transmission of reference signals

through means other than spectrum.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 92 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
REFERENCES

1. International Telecommunications Unit (ITU). “Mobile cellular world”, in Global ICT


developments. Access: July, 2015. http://www.itu.int/en/ITU-
D/Statistics/Pages/stat/default.aspx
2. 3GPP. “The Mobile Broadband Standard”, in 3GPP website. Access: July, 2015.
http://www.3gpp.org/about-3gpp
3. Demia Della Penda. “Distributed Uplink Resource Allocation in LTE-A Cellular
Network with Device-to-Device communications”, in Universita Degli Studi di Siena.
Chapter 1, Page 10. 2011.
4. Arnon Friedmann. “Understanding OFDMA, the interface for 4G wireless” in Texas
Instruments for eeTimes. April, 2007. Access: May, 2015.
http://www.eetimes.com/document.asp?doc_id=1275028
5. Takehiro Nakamura. “Proposal for Candidate Radio Interface Technologies for IMT-
Advanced Based on LTE Release 10 and Beyond (LTE Advanced)” in IT-R WP 5D
3rd Workshop on IMT-Advanced. Slides 22 and 23. October, 2009.
6. Ian F. Akyildiz, David M. Gutierrez-Estevez, Elias Chavarria Reyes. “The Evolution to
4G celular systems: LTE-Advanced” in Georgia Institute of Technology. Atlanta,
United States. 2010.
7. 4S Communications. “Modulation & Multiple Access Schemes” in SlideShare. Slides
17 and 18. February, 2013. Acess: June, 2015.
http://www.slideshare.net/ravi4s/modulation-multiple-acces-schemes
8. Yair Shapira. “SC-FDMA vs. OFDMA” in ExploreGate for Youtube. May, 2012.
Access: March, 2015. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dr4YQAfifKA
9. 3rd Generation Partnership Project 3GPP. “ETSI TS 136 211 Technical Specification”.
Version 10.0.0, Release 10. January, 2011.
10. Jerry D. Gibson. “Mobile Communications Handbook” Third Edition, CRC Press.
2013.
11. Anritsu Company. “LTE Resources Guide” Rev 1010. United States of America, 2009.
Access: May, 2015. http://web.cecs.pdx.edu/~fli/class/LTE_Reource_Guide.pdf

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 93 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
12. 4G Americas. “LTE Carrier Aggregation Technology Development and Deployment
Worldwide” October, 2014
13. Stefania Sesia, Issam Toufik, Matthew Baker. “LTE The UMTS Long Term
Evolution”. John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Second Edition. 2011.
14. Frank Rayal. “An overview of the LTE physical layer” Part II. June, 2010. Access:
June, 2015. http://www.eetimes.com/document.asp?doc_id=1278137
15. Keysight Technologies. “Concepts of Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing
(OFDM) and 802.11 WLAN”. Access: July, 2015.
http://rfmw.em.keysight.com/wireless/helpfiles/89600b/webhelp/subsystems/wlan-
ofdm/Content/ofdm_basicprinciplesoverview.htm
16. Cristina Ciochina, Hikmet Sari. “A Review of OFDMA and Single Carrier FDMA and
Some Recent Results” in Advances in Electronics and Telecommunications Vol 1, No.
1 IEEE. April, 2010.
17. Simplest Codings. “LTE”. Access: June, 2015.
http://simplestcodings.blogspot.co.uk/p/lte.html
18. Abdul Samad Shaikh, Khatri Chandan Kumar. “Performance Evaluation of LTE
Physical Layer Using SC-FDMA & OFDMA” in Blekinge Institute of Technology.
Chapter 4, Page 23. November, 2010.
19. High Frequency Electronics. “Bit Error Rate: Fundamental Concepts and Measurement
Issues” in Summit Technical Media. Gary Breed Editorial Director. 2003. Access:
August, 2015.
http://www.highfreqelec.summittechmedia.com/Jan03/HFE0103_Tutorial.pdf
20. Corey McKinney Thacker. “An initial design of an OFDM transceiver” in The
University of Texas. May 2010.
21. Joshua Ayeni. “OFDM for 4G wireless communication systems” in University of
Hertfordshire. September 2010.
22. Zakhia Abichar, Yanlin Peng, Morris Chang. “Basic WiMax System Modeling” in
Iowa State University, IEEE. Chapter 2. August, 2006.
23. Dr Falah Ali. “Digital Modulation for Wireless Communications” in Mobile
Communications module, University of Sussex. Brighton, UK. 2014

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 94 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
24. Qualcomm Incorporated. “The Evolution of Mobile Technologies: 1G, 2G, 3G, 4G
LTE”. United States. June, 2014.
25. Raad Fahood Chisab, C. K. Shukla. “Performance Evaluation of 4G-LTE-SCDFMA
Scheme under SUI and ITU Channel Models” in International Journal of Engineering
& Technology IJET-IJENS Vol: 14 No: 01. February, 2014.
26. Berardinelli Gilberto, Maestro Luis, Simone Rahman, Muhammad Imadur. “OFDMA
vs. SC-FDMA” in Aalborg Universitet, Denmark. IEEE Wireless Communications.
2008.
27. Munish Chhabra. “LTE-A Challenges and Evolving LTE Network Architecture” in
Aricent Group for SlideShare. November, 2013.

MSc. in Digital Communication Systems Page 95 of 95 Candidate Number: 130013


with Business Management
APPENDIX A
OFDMA FULL FRAME
FRAME (10 ms)
SUBFRAME 0 (1 ms)
SLOT 0 SLOT 1 SLOT 2 SLOT 10 SLOT 19
S0 S1 S2 S3 S4 S5 S6 S0 S1 S2 S3 S4 S5 S6 S0 S1 S2 S3 S4 S5 S6 S0 S1 S2 S3 S4 S5 S6 S0 S1 S2 S3 S4 S5 S6
…………… ……………

RB14 RB14 RB14 RB14 RB14


SUBCARRIERS
180 KHz
12

RB13 RB13 RB13 RB13 RB13

RB12 RB12 RB12 RB12 RB12

RB11 RB11 RB11 RB11 RB11

RB10 RB10 RB10 RB10 RB10

RB9 RB9 RB9 RB9 RB10

RB8 RB8 RB8 RB8 RB10


OCCUPIED SUBCARRIERS
FREQUENCY

RB7 RB7 RB7 RB7 RB7

…………… ……………

RB6 RB6 RB6 RB6 RB10

RB5 RB5 RB5 RB5 RB5

RB4 RB4 RB4 RB4 RB4

RB3 RB3 RB3 RB3 RB3

RB2 RB2 RB2 RB2 RB2

RB1 RB1 RB1 RB1 RB1

RB0 RB0 RB0 RB0 RB0

…………… ……………

TIME
Guard Band PDSCH
Reference Signal SS
Center subcarrier PBCH
PDCCH PCFICH
A

You might also like