Professional Documents
Culture Documents
68637-Article Text-142764-1-10-20110805
68637-Article Text-142764-1-10-20110805
00
Printed in Uganda. All rights reserved ©2010, African Crop Science Society
ABSTRACT
Nitrogen fertilisation and carbofuran applications impact plants, yet few studies examine their general impact on
plant performance and plant susceptibility to insect pests and diseases when applied together. The performance
of okra (Abelmoschus esculentus L. Moench) and infestations by flea beetles in relation to nitrogen and carbofuran
applications were, therefore, evaluated under a humid tropical environment. Treatments comprised of combinations
of four rates of 2, 3-dihydro-2, 2-dimethylbenzofuran or carbofuran (0.0, 0.5, 1.0 and 1.5 kg ha-1) and four levels of
N- fertiliser (0, 40, 80 and 120 kg ha-1). The presence of Podagrica uniformis was recorded much earlier on the
plants than Nisotra sjostedti. The population of either flea beetle remained lower throughout the vegetative than
the reproductive phase. While N fertilisation resulted in higher insect count than where no N was added, carbofuran
at 1.0 kg ha-1 and above significantly (P<0.05) depressed the flea beetle populations up to 5 weeks after planting.
Differences in the carbofuran and N interaction had no statistical significance on insect count. All cases of applied
carbofuran and nitrogen increased earliness to maturity, plant height, total fruit number, fruit weight, fruit yield and
net marginal returns. Higher doses of carbofuran in combination with nitrogen significantly increased earliness to
plant maturity, fruit number per plant, fruit yield and net marginal returns. The best fruit yield was attained by
combining 1.0 kg ha-1carbofuran with 80 kg N ha-1, while the best economic return was achieved by combining 0.5
kg ha-1carbofuran with 80 kg ha-1. Incidence of mosaic disease was suppressed with increasing doses of carbofuran
or decreasing doses of nitrogen.
RÉSUMÉ
La fetilisation azotée ainsi que l’application du carbofuran affectent les plantes, mais peu d’études examinent leur
impact sur la performance et la susceptibilité des plantes aux pestes et maladies, lorsque les deux sont appliqués
ensemble. La performance d’Okra (Abelmoschus esculentus L.Moench) et des infestations par des coléoptères
en relation avec l’application de l’azote et du carbofuran étaient ainsi évaluées sous un environnement à climat
humide tropical. Les traitements comprenaient une combinaison de quatre doses de 2, 3-dihydro-2, 2-
dimethylbenzofuran ou carbofuran (0.0, 0.5, 1.0 et 1.5 kg ha-1) et quatre niveaux d’ engrais N (0, 40, 80 et 120 kg
ha-1). La présence de Podagrica uniformis sur les plantes était observée un peu plus tôt que le Nisotra sjostedti.
La population de coléoptères était restée plus basse dans la phase végétative que dans la phase reproductive. Alors
que le nombre d’insects était plus élevé dans les traitement sous fertilization azotée que dans le contrôle, la dose de
plus ou moins 1.0 kg ha-1 de carbofuran avait significativement (P<0.05) réduit les populations de coléoptères
jusqu’à cinq semaines après le semis. Aussi, il n’yavait pas eu de difference significative en terme d’interaction
entre le carbofuran et d’azote appliqués. Dans tous les cas, le carbofuran et l’azote avait eu un effet sur la matura-
tion précoce, la hauteur de plants, le nombre total de fruits, le poids de fruits, le rendement en fruits ainsi que sur des
bénéfices marginaux nets. La combinaison de doses élevées de carbofurant et d’azote avait affecté significativement
la susceptibilité de la plant à la maturation précoce, le nombre de fruits par plant, le rendement en fruits et les
bénéfices marginaux nets. Le meilleur rendement en fruit était realisé par la combinaison de 1.0 kg ha-1 de carbofuran
98 B.C. ECHEZONA et al.
avec 80 kg N ha-1, alors que la combinaison de 0.5 kg ha-1 de carbofuran avec 80 kg ha-1 d’azote était la meilleure
du point de vue de la rentabilité économique. L’incidence de la maladie de mosaïque était controlée soit par
l’augmentation des doses de carbofuran ou par la diminution des doses d’Azote.
Weeks after planting Carbofuran rates (kg ha-1) Nitrogen levels (kg ha-1) Mean
0 40 80 120
3 5 7 9
LSD0.05 for comparing 2 carbofuran or nitrogen means = NA 0.7 NS NS
LSD0.05 for comparing 2 carbofuran x nitrogen means = NA NS NS NS
NA = Not analysed
week later than P. uniformis. Except for a lower ha-1 with 1.0 - 1.5 kg a.i. of carbofuran generally
value at 8 WAP, the population of N. sjostedti reduced the number of days to flowering than
was always more abundant than P. uniformis. combinations of low rates of carbofuran and N
Generally, the flea beetle count was fertiliser.
relatively low at the vegetative stage of okra, but All cases of applied carbofuran did not differ
increased progressively through the flower, fruit from each other in their effects on plant height,
set and fruit harvest stages. It peaked at the but produced significantly (P > 0.05) taller
senescence stage. plants than where no carbofuran was applied.
The number of days to 50% flowering was Nitrogen generally produced significantly (P <
progressively reduced with increasing rates of 0.05) taller plants than the control. Differences
carbofuran application (Table 2). All cases where in plant height among treatment combinations
carbofuran was applied had significantly less were not significant. However, there was an
days to flowering than where no carbofuran was evident trend of taller plants with combinations
applied. Where 1.5 kg a.i. of carbofuran was of higher rates of carbofuran and nitrogen than
applied attained 50% flowering in significantly their lower rates.
(P < 0.05) less okra days than where only 0.5 a.i. The incidence of mosaic symptoms were
was applied. progressively depressed by application of
Application of fertiliser N progressively carbofuran, while application of nitrogen
depressed the number of days taken to attain 50% significantly increased the incidence of the
flowering. Combinations of 80 to 120 kg N disease. The disease incidence was always more
Nitrogen and carbofuran effects on flea beetle populations and okra yield 101
Vegetative
Flowering
Fruit set
Harvesting
Senescence
prevalent where no carbofuran or the rate of 0.5 trends as their effects on weight per fruit. Fruit
kg a.i. was applied, especially where high rates of yield and economic return improvements did not
nitrogen were used. The combination of 80 N go beyond the rates of 1.0 kg a.i. of carbo furan
ha-1 and 1.0 or 1.5 kg a.i. of carbofuran showed or 80 kg N ha-1. Combined applications of 0.5 –
a better control of the okra mosaic disease. 1.5 kg a.i. of carbofuran and 80 kg N ha -1
Application of higher rates of carbofuran appeared to produce the best yield and economic
produced more (P < 0.05) fruits than where no return.
carbofuran or 0.5 rate was applied (Table 3).
Nitrogen treated plants also produced more fruits DISCUSSION
than untreated plants. Combinations of 80 –120
kg N ha-1 with 1.5 kg a.i. ha-1 carbofuran produced The greater preponderance of flea beetles during
the highest fruit numbers. Application of the reproductive phase of the plant compared
carbofuran progressively increased the fruit with the vegetative phase could be attributed to
weight of okra per fruit. Application of 1.5 kg a.i. the increasing abundance of food sources. Such
ha-1 showed no difference with application of 1.0 food sources on okra plant may include flower
kg a.i. ha-1. However, 80 kg N ha-1 significantly buds, flowers and pods that were more in
increased fruit weight over the N control or at 40 abundance at the reproductive stage of the plant
kg N ha-1. Weight per fruit appeared highest with compared with the vegetative phase. This result
a combination of 1.5 kg a. i. ha-1 of carbofuran supports the thesis of greater insect aggregations
and 80 kg N ha-1. The effects of carbofuran and N with more sources of food supply (Egwuatu and
application on fruit (kg ha-1) followed similar Taylor, 1976). The choice of flower buds,
102 B.C. ECHEZONA et al.
TABLE 2. Effect of carbofuran and nitrogen on days to 50% flowering, plant height at 50 days after planting and incidence of okra
mosaic disease in Nigeria
Parameter Carbofuran rates (kg ha-1) Nitrogen levels (kg ha-1) Mean
0 40 80 120
Okra mosaic disease incidence 0.0 13.3 23.3 48.3 96.7 45.4
0.5 13.3 20.0 15.0 66.7 28.8
1.0 3.3 3.3 10.0 16.7 8.3
1.5 3.3 3.3 0.0 13.3 5.0
flowers, succulent pods as well as matured pods periods that may arise as a result of repeated
for food by the flea beetles has been documented applications.
by Schippers (2000). Promotion of plant growth as recorded in
The relative abundance of Nisotra sjostedti this study with carbofuran or nitrogen treatment
over Podagrica uniformis in all the sampling could account for the significant yield
period suggests a stronger preference for okra improvement achieved by the two treatments.
plant parts by N. sjostedti than P. uniformis. This According to Ceccon et al.(2004) and Van
may have accounted for the eventual relative Hezewijk et al. (2004), carbofuran and other
displacement of the latter by the former. This systemics are known to promote growth and
displacement might be due to interspecific enhance the yield of the affected crops.
competition between the two species. The Similarly, Groot et al. (2003); Van Hezewijk et
relative abundance of these species, however, al. (2008) and Prvulovic et al. (2010), recorded
may be an important response in elucidating their that nitrogen fertilisation promotes growth and
feeding behaviours as well as their biology. yield of some crops at some levels of
The differential efficacies of carbofuran rates application. Taller plants could mean more
on flea beetle control up to 5 weeks after planting internodes and nodes for possible pod
(WAP) was attributed to the powerful systemic attachments and, therefore, better chances for
mode of action of the soil applied insecticide. more fruit yield. Although there was a
This action appeared to wane down after 5 WAP progressive trend of heavier fruits with
and, thereafter became ineffective. On tropical increasing combined doses of carbofuran and
soils, the half-life of carbofuran ranges between nitrogen, significant differences were only
30 and 60 days (Anon, 1972). With carbofuran, detected among these traits for both.
Egwuatu (1982) recommended that a single dose The non-production of significant desired
at planting holes would be most meaningful. Such synergistic effect on crop growth and fruit weight
single dose application is expected to obviate by the combined applications of nitrogen and
possible residue problems during the fruiting carbofuran might be attributed to the
Nitrogen and carbofuran effects on flea beetle populations and okra yield 103
TABLE 3. Effect of carbofuran and N fertiliser applications on okra yield components and net margin
Parameter Carbofuran rates (kg ha-1) Nitrogen levels (kg ha-1) Mean
0 40 80 120
Weight per fruit (g) 0.0 22.2 24.7 34.6 29.1 27.7
0.5 30.5 27.5 34.5 35.0 31.9
1.0 31.5 35.9 42.6 43.5 38.4
1.5 35.8 37.3 44.9 42.1 40.0
Total fruit yield (t ha-1) 0.0 8.9 9.9 13.6 11.7 11.0
0.5 12.6 11.0 13.8 14.0 12.9
1.0 12.6 14.4 17.1 17.5 15.4
1.5 14.3 15.3 18.0 16.1 15.9
uncomplimentary effect of the treatment stages of crop growth. Marchie (1993) reported
combinations. The possession of different that okra mosaic virus OKMv infection at six or
metabolites and/or mechanisms by the two more weeks after planting did not significantly
treatments possibly affords them different affect okra yield. Fajinmi and Fajinmi (2010),
metabolic pathways especially when applied also reported that inoculation of okra plants with
together. The different pathways may possibly OKMv 14 and 21 days after emergence (DAE)
result in the no-significant plant growth and fruit significantly reduced the weight of fruits per plant
weight improvement effect that resulted when compared with those inoculated 28 DAP or non-
both were applied together. The growth inoculated control. They, however, concluded that
metabolites of carbofuran are carbofuran phenol flea beetles have been seriously implicated in the
and 3-hydroxyl carbofuran (Trevisan et al., 2004), transmission of okra mosaic virus to okra plants
while the growth mechanism in nitrogen is by in the field.
protein synthesis and carbohydrate utilisation The progressive increase in the incidence of
(Andrew et al., 2007). insect pests and mosaic disease expression with
The significant reduction in the mosaic increased N fertilisation was attributed to the
symptom expression on the carbofuran treated increased hydration and succulence of the plant
plots, even with the in-undated populations of tissues. Draycott and Christenson (2003) reported
the flea beetles recorded after 5 WAP, suggests that excessive application of N increases tissue
that control of disease vectors at the early plant hydration and succulence and could therefore
growth produces a better yield and suppression predispose such organs to more pest and disease
of disease incidence than control in the later attack.
104 B.C. ECHEZONA et al.