SCE5471 – Engineers in Society

Content and Irrelevant to or Contains Relevant to and Relevant to and Relevant to and
Structure inappropriate for slightly too appropriate for appropriate for appropriate for the
(25%) - the purpose, much or too the purpose, the purpose, purpose, audience
Address audience and little audience and audience and and setting. Links
context, scope, setting. Content information setting. Covers setting. and connections
goals or contains major with minor main points but between ideas made
contributions inaccuracies. inaccuracies with limited facts clear. Contains right
and few details amounts of accurate,
with minor organised and
inaccuracies. relevant materials.
Statements or
positions
communicated
clearly and strongly
supported with
accurate and
appropriate details.
Visual Aids Not readable and Possible to read Readable and Readable and Highly readable and
(20%) - understandable and understand understandable, understandable. understandable.
Attractiveness but not with a few
explained or put problems.
in context
Questions and Lack of evidence Uses only few Uses only few Uses several Presents arguments
Answer: or relevant argument or argument or arguments and in a logical order.
Content arguments to examples to examples that backs arguments
(20%) - support response support supports the with examples,
Knowledge of to the question. answers. answers in a data that support
subject area logical order. the answers.
Questions and Could not Around half Answered most Answered most All questions
Answer: answer most questions questions but questions. answered with
Delivery questions. answered with with certain accuracy and no
(10%) - Clarity difficulty, and difficulty and difficulty.
of explanation little knowledge lacked clarity.
of the subject
areas.