Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Special Problem Fronda Environmental Quality Monitoring
Special Problem Fronda Environmental Quality Monitoring
Special Problem Fronda Environmental Quality Monitoring
A special problem
By
June 2022
ABSTRACT
It is very important for laboratories to understand the levels of microorganisms within the
surrounding environment and identify them to reduce the risk of contamination. This work aimed
to assess air quality and critical surface area of the microbiology testing laboratory using Swab
Contact Method of (Moberg and Kornacki, 2015) in four different agars depending on the
organisms of interest. Standard count is 10 colonies per plate provided that no pathogenic
microorganism is detected. Confirmation and identification of isolated microorganism was based
on gram stain, and series of biochemical tests. Surface swab from the media preparation room
isolated Staphylococcus aureus which was confirmed with a positive catalase test. The possibility
of having a data on environmental quality could be a useful educational and training tool both for
those responsible for the sanitation procedures, since the results reflect the effectiveness and
suitability of the procedures adopted in order to increase awareness of the effects of a possible
non-adherence to behavioral standards.
These pre-enrichment media are either resuscitation and growth of the target
nonselective or are designed to be microorganism. The liquid version of Baird
moderately selective against competing Parker Agar (Liquid Baird Parker), without
microorganisms. If the media contain any agar, has been successfully used to recover
selective components, these must be Staphylococcus aureus in foods.
balanced to permit the growth of the target
organism and repress the growth of The formulation of the pre-enrichment
competing microorganisms in the food medium will depend upon the level of
sample. A pre-enrichment procedure may competing microorganisms and the ability of
not be necessary when the enrichment the food to inhibit microorganisms. The US
medium has been validated to support the Food and Drug Administration (FDA)
Bacteriological Analytical Manual describes Conversely, food material in a pre-
different pre-enrichment media for the enrichment transferred to a selective
recovery of Salmonella in foods. These enrichment will positively affect media
range from sterile deionized water for efficacy. (Abbiss, 1986) demonstrated that
recovering Salmonella from non-fat dry milk, the presence of food material in buffered
to Brilliant Green-supplemented milk for the peptone water pre-enrichment enhanced the
recovery of Salmonella from chocolate. recovery of Salmonella typhimurium from
These media use either the nutrients from selective enrichments. This improved
the food or contain ingredients (e.g., casein) recovery was due to amelioration of the initial
to neutralize the inhibitory nature of the food inhibitory environment Salmonella
(e.g., chocolate). Lactose is commonly used encounters when transferred to the selective
as the pre-enrichment medium for medium. In the case of Salmonella, neither
Salmonella, even though few species of this tetrathionate nor selenite cystine enrichment
genus are capable of metabolizing this broths alone will support the growth of all
carbohydrate. The presence of lactose is not strains of Salmonella. Therefore, to reduce
directly essential for the recovery of the risk of a false negative, many selective
Salmonella. It has been suggested that some enrichment protocols will employ more than
selectivity of pre-enrichment media one medium following the pre-enrichment.
containing lactose is generated by the
reduction in media pH when the lactose is To ensure the availability of nutrients to the
fermented by the mixed competitor flora. target microorganism, enrichments may be
shaken during incubation. Facultatively
Selective Enrichment anaerobic microorganisms may experience
shortened lag phase and generation times
The pre-enrichment will result in when oxygen is added during the
resuscitation of the target microorganism and enrichment. The oxygen will support an
moderate levels of proliferation. Selective aerobic metabolism that yields higher energy
enrichment furthers the growth of the target than anaerobic metabolism. (Duffy et. al,
microorganism while suppressing or 1994) however, studied the growth kinetics of
inhibiting that of competing microorganisms. L. monocytogenes and found that aeration of
The selectivity of the medium is provided by the selective enrichment did not alter the
agents or conditions which are antagonistic length of the lag phase or the growth rate of
or inhibitory to competing microorganisms. L. monocytogenes.
These selective agents include temperature,
antimicrobials, salts, acids, and metals. The Temperature Control or Management
pre-enrichment step can also serve to dilute
or minimize interfering agents in the food Temperature control is a critical selective or
sample that can impair the selective elective component of many microbiological
capability of the selective medium. Taylor enrichment protocols. The Temperature
and Siliker determined that lactose pre- control is a critical selective or elective
enrichment prior to selective enrichment in component of many microbiological
tetrathionate and selenite cystine increased enrichment protocols. The first step in the
the recovery of Salmonella from albumin. quality assurance process of temperature
Furthermore, direct inoculation of food control is the purchase of the appropriate
samples with large numbers of competing equipment. Most inexpensive gravity flow
microorganisms into selective enrichments connection air incubators can maintain
may result in false negative results owing to incubation temperatures within about ± 3°C
the reduction in the medium’s selectivity. of the desired temperature. For protocols
requiring more stringent control, forced air or
water-jacketed incubators, or shaking or
circulating water baths, should be used.
Incubators and water baths are usually transfer areas, and media preparation and
equipped with temperature controls and sterilization areas. Hands-free wash stations
indicators. These ‘‘built-in’’ devices should should be conveniently located and stocked
never be relied upon as the sole means of with soap. Disposable paper towels should
temperature verification. Incubators can be available.
have hot and cold spots, so a calibration
should be performed annually to establish a Analysts who work with enriched cultures or
relationship between the temperature highly contaminated samples should do this
reading of the internal device and the true only in designated areas that are separated
temperature at key locations within the from other areas, and should wash their
chamber. This can be done using a recorder hands and change their laboratory coats
equipped with thermocouples that have been before entering other areas of the laboratory.
calibrated against a reference thermometer. In short, many procedures for limiting cross-
contamination that are considered good
Thermometers of the proper type (partial, manufacturing practices in the food
total or complete immersion) and of sufficient manufacturing plant should also be applied
accuracy and precision should be to the food microbiology laboratory.
permanently placed within incubators and
water baths. These thermometers should be The air supply for laboratories conducting
calibrated at least once per year against a enrichments and isolations should reduce
reference thermometer whose accuracy is the levels of contamination, lower humidity,
certified to be traceable to a National Institute and control temperature. Airborne
of Standards and Technology (NIST) microbiological contamination should be
thermometer. Large incubators should have controlled by using filters, and the air quality
at least two thermometers, one located should be verified by microbiological
towards the top and one towards the bottom. monitoring (air sampling devices, air settling
If calibration indicates a correction factor is plates, surface swabs). Typically, total
necessary, this correction factor must be bacteria or yeasts and molds are monitored,
used each time the temperature is noted. but monitoring for specific target organisms
NIST-traceable temperature monitoring may be appropriate. Critical work surfaces
devices are now available that monitor the should be routinely monitored for the
temperature continuously. presence of the target organisms being
enriched or isolated. Great care needs to be
Laboratory Environment Management taken when transferring pre-enrichment or
enrichment cultures. Analysts should be
Enrichment techniques are designed to be as trained in the elimination of aerosols and
efficient as possible at detecting extremely microdroplets, and in all aspects of aseptic
low levels of target microorganisms. This technique. A useful technique for training
means that they are extremely sensitive to new analysts is to place brown paper towels
accidental contamination from the laboratory on the laboratory bench during transfer
environment. In addition to meticulous practice exercises. After transfers are
aseptic technique, it is often desirable to complete, the towels can be checked for
have a controlled ventilation system to droplets. Micropipettors should be used only
reduce the potential for contamination. with extreme caution, and the use of
Laboratories should meet the general micropipette tips containing a filter should be
requirements of at least a Biosafety Level 2. considered. Mixing test tube contents by
using a vortex mixer before transfer is not
Laboratories should be designed with necessary in most cases and can be a
physical separation between critical areas source of cross-contamination. Receptacles
such as sample check-in, storage, pre- for contaminated pipettes and micropipettor
enrichment set-up area, enriched culture tips should be located as close as possible to
the operation being performed to reduce the evaluating and reporting equivocal results.
potential for dripping. Strict documentation at every step provides
valuable information for the investigation of
If testing indicates that results may have equivocal results. This documentation
been compromised by the laboratory information may include analyst, enrichment
environment, policies and procedures must time, transfer time, sample order, and rack
be in place that allow for interpreting, order.
Table 1.a. Air sampling: 15 CFU/plate/15 mins. Exposure at Media Preparation Room
Table 3.a. Confirmatory tests of isolated bacteria from Media Preparation Room at 48H Total
Plate Count
Table 1.b. Air sampling: 15 CFU/plate/15 mins. Exposure at Isolation and Incubation Room
Table 3.b. Confirmatory tests of isolated bacteria from Isolation and Incubation Room at 48H
Total Plate Count
Table 3.b showed no pathogenic organism detected from all isolated bacteria with negative result
from catalase, voges-proskauer, and methyl red-reactive tests.
VIII. CONCLUSION AND from 2022 Under the NME ICT
RECOMMENDATIONS initiative of MHRD:
https://vlab.amrita.edu/?sub=3&brch
It is fundamental that the environment =73&sim=703&cnt=2
complies with structural, organizational, and
managerial norms and adequate behavioral Brauniger et.al. (2015). Laboratory Quality
models. The detection of microbial Management Systems. In
contamination through environmental Compendium of Methods for the
monitoring may be the indirect expression of Microbiological Examination of
shortcomings or failures in the above- Foods 5th Edition (pp. 5-6).
mentioned aspects. In terms of prevention, Washington, DC: APHA Press
environmental monitoring certainly APHL.
constitutes a secondary level intervention, Duffy et. al. (1994). The effect of aeration,
mainly aimed at an “early diagnosis” of initial inoculum and meat microflora
environmental unhealthiness, as a on the growth kinetics of Listeria
forewarning of sentinel events. Through monocytogenes in selective
monitoring, indications are given of the enrichment broths. Food Microbiol.
hygienic-sanitary quality not only of that 11, 429-438.
moment (the status quo) but also of the
quality that that environment will always have Kawai, M. (2021). Environmental Monitoring
under the same management and sanitation in a Pharmaceutical Manufacturing
conditions. Moreover, data on environmental Facility.
quality could be a useful educational and
Moberg and Kornacki. (2015).
training tool both for those responsible for the
Microbiological Monitoring of the
sanitation procedures, since the results
Food Procesing Environment. In
reflect the effectiveness and suitability of the
Compendium of Methods for the
procedures adopted in order to increase
Microbiological Examination of
awareness of the effects of a possible non-
Foods (p. 30). Washington, DC:
adherence to behavioral standards.
APHA Press APHL.
Moberg and Kornacki. (2015).
IX. REFERENCES Microbiological Monitoring of the
Food Processing Environment. In
Compendium of Methods for the
Abbiss. (1986). A study of the dynamics of
Microbiological Examination of
selective enrichment of Salmonella.
Foods 5th Edition (pp. 32-33).
The British Food Manufacturing, 1-
Washington, DC: APHA Press
27.
APHL.
Bennett et.al. (2015, June 8).
Sandle, T. (2019). Designing and
Staphylococcus aureus and
Implementing an Environmental
Staphylococcal Enterotoxins. In Y.
Monitoring Program. In T. Sandle,
S. Tortorello, Compendium of
Biocontamination Control for
Methods for the Microbiological
Pharmaceuticals and Healthcare
Examination of Foods 5th Edition (p.
(pp. 159-178).
516). APHA Press APHL. Retrieved