Professional Documents
Culture Documents
IET Power Electronics - 2021 - Varma P C - Grid Integrated Solar Energy Transfer System With A Two Layer Complex
IET Power Electronics - 2021 - Varma P C - Grid Integrated Solar Energy Transfer System With A Two Layer Complex
IET Power Electronics - 2021 - Varma P C - Grid Integrated Solar Energy Transfer System With A Two Layer Complex
See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
Received: 5 August 2021 Revised: 16 November 2021 Accepted: 2 December 2021 IET Power Electronics
DOI: 10.1049/pel2.12224
1
Department of Electrical and Electronics Abstract
Engineering, Government College of Engineering
In this paper, a novel control strategy for grid-integrated solar energy transfer system
Kannur, A P J Abdul Kalam Technological
University, Thiruvananthapuram, India (SETS) is proposed which enhances the grid power quality along with active power injec-
2
Advanced Power and Energy Center, EECS
tion. Some of the conventional grid synchronization controls face problems due to imper-
Department, Khalifa University, Abu Dhabi, UAE fect estimation of fundamental active load current during both grid-side and load-side dis-
turbances. The proposed two-layer multiple-complex coefficient filter control improves
Correspondence the performance of SETS by accurately estimating the fundamental active load current
Renuka Varma P C, Department of Electrical and
at adverse operating conditions. One layer extracts the fundamental positive sequence of
Electronics Engineering, Government College of
Engineering Kannur, A P J Abdul Kalam Techno- the sensed three-phase grid voltages and derives the unit in-phase voltage templates for
logical University, Thiruvananthapuram 695016, grid currents reference generation to achieve unity power factor operation. The second
India.
layer evaluates the average active fundamental component of the load currents, and finally
Email: renukavarma96@gmail.com
derives the reference amplitude of three-phase grid currents. The two-stage SETS con-
Funding information sists of a quadratic boost DC-DC converter to extract the maximum solar array power
TEQIP and Centre of Excellence in Systems, Energy forming an interface between PV array and inverter. It also provides high voltage gain
and Environment; Khalifa University of Science and and decreases the length of the PV array string while maintaining a low DC-link voltage
Technology, Grant/Award Number: CIRA-2019-049
ripple, extending the service life of the SETS. The effect of a nonlinear unbalanced load
is nullified and therefore the grid current’s waveform quality is maintained in compliance
with the IEEE-519 standard during the dynamic operating conditions. The SETS provides
sinusoidal, balanced, and steady grid currents at unity power factor withstanding adverse
operating conditions such as distorted grid voltages, varying irradiance and varying unbal-
anced nonlinear load currents. Due to its flexibility to operate in such adverse conditions,
the proposed control based SETS is suitable for grid-connected applications. Simulations
are carried out in MATLAB/Simulink and results validate the performance of the SETS.
The hardware prototype of the proposed SETS is developed and rigorously tested under
various operating conditions to validate the proposed claims.
This is an open access article under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is
properly cited.
© 2021 The Authors. IET Power Electronics published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of The Institution of Engineering and Technology
boost converter has limitations for switching frequency, gain, computational burden is undesirable in grid-connected
duty ratio, etc. A magnetically modular coupled converter systems.
reported in [2] has a cascaded connection of boost converters Under abnormal grid conditions, unbalanced AC signals are
with inductors magnetically coupled to each other. But, the use analyzed by their symmetrical components which is essential
of coupled inductors has risks of electromagnetic interference for stability studies, fault detection, etc. Fundamental positive
(EMI) and increases size. A switched-capacitor based converter sequence components (FPSC) are the balanced components
in [3] gives an appreciable gain of 30 but the use of a higher rotating at the same phase as that of the input quantity. There-
number of capacitors makes the system bulky. fore, in control algorithms without extraction of FPSC during
To overcome the problems due to complexity, EMI issues, an unbalance, maloperation is expected as the grid currents per-
and reduced efficiency in conventional boost converters, the sist unbalance. During an unbalance in grid voltages, control
scope of quadratic converters is studied in [4]. A comparison of positive and negative sequence components is reported in
between cascaded boost converter and conventional quadratic [19], without utilising the unbalanced load currents. For gener-
boost converter (QBC) concludes that the cascaded boost con- ating grid reference currents, information of active load current
verter has better efficiency at the same operating conditions. is important. In a damped second-order generalized integrator
Moreover, in terms of the number of components used, switch- (SOGI) based control algorithm [20], the fundamental active
ing stress, frequency, and gain, the quadratic converter is a better component of load current is extracted using a damped SOGI
option. A conventional QBC uses only one switch to obtain a filter in each phase. In three-phase systems, the use of damped
gain of four, while some other QBC-derived topologies have SOGI in each phase make the control tedious. Sequence filter
additional features like lesser capacitor voltage stress, inductor (SF) built by integrators extracts fundamental sequence com-
current reduction , output voltage ripple reduction [5]-[6]. Some ponents of a distorted signal. A second-order sequence filter
of the QBC-derived boost converters in [7], [8] are found to (SOSF) reported in [21] estimates the active load current for
have a higher number of components and complexity. A mod- the shunt compensator in an universal active power filter. It is
ified QBC (MQBC) in [9] aiming for lesser output voltage rip- found that SOSF has better attenuation than SF above funda-
ple gives higher efficiency using less number of components. mental frequency and is sensitive to sub-harmonics and DC off-
MQBC is found to have a lesser output voltage ripple, lesser sets [22].
voltage stress across the capacitor, and maximum efficiency of Guo et al. have reported a multiple complex coefficient filter
95.8%. Duty ratio control of MQBC can be estimated by incre- (MCCF) in [23] for sequence component and harmonic content
mental conductance (INC) algorithm based maximum power extraction. This concept can be extended to any order by adding
point tracking (MPPT) technique [10]. It is simple to implement more complex coefficient filter (CCF) units. Transient response
with less computational burden and control complexity while analysis of MCCF reported in [24] prove its ability to with-
compared to advanced MPPT techniques. stand unbalanced load conditions. Under unbalanced fault con-
In the practical distribution network, different types of ditions, the presence of nonlinear harmonic loads at the PCC
AC loads such as harmonic loads, reactive loads, unbalanced leads to distortions in voltage wave shape, so a selective har-
loads, etc. are connected at the point of common coupling monic compensation using MCCF is implemented in [25]. Gen-
(PCC). Due to these nonlinear loads, there are high chances of erally, MCCF inputs are 𝛼 − 𝛽 components, while in [26], abc
distortion in the grid power quality. The control algorithm plays components are taken to obtain fundamental positive and nega-
a vital role to enhance power quality at the PCC and enables tive sequence components using each filter at each phase which
any grid-connected SETS to withstand adverse operating makes it more complex. MCCF for grid voltage sequence com-
conditions. Graphical analysis of the decoupling process for ponents extraction and SOGI for load active current extraction
a decoupling controller consisting of inner current and outer is reported in [27]. In [28], MCCF filters out the sequence com-
voltage loops is reported in [11] for standalone voltage source ponents of grid voltages under polluted grid conditions, and
inverters (VSIs). The use of more than one abc-dq0 transfor- an improved SOGI based technique is used at each phase to
mation slows down the response of the controller. Robust extract in-phase and quadrature components of load current
control of a grid-connected inverter is reported in [12] in which which makes the system bulkier. Active load current component
the control gains of the current controller is found through a extraction in a three-phase grid-connected PV system, based on
discrete linear quadratic regulation. A control algorithm based a frequency adaptive MCCF reported in [29] shows that the sys-
on an enhanced adaptive filter technology is employed in [13] tem exhibits overshoots in the grid currents waveforms at sud-
for a single-phase grid connected voltage source converter. It den changes.
generates orthogonal sequence component which ensures high In this work, a two-stage grid integrated solar energy trans-
disturbance rejection capability, but phase-locked loops (PLLs) fer system is presented. The circuit configuration consists of a
and a higher number of abc-dq0 transformations reduces the high gain modified quadratic boost converter as the first power
speed of response. Extraction of fundamental component is conversion stage to extract the maximum power from the PV
possible through some advanced control techniques such as array. A voltage source inverter is used to synchronize the PV
the least mean square (LMS) technique [14], techniques based power with the distribution network forming the second stage.
on adaptive notch filter (ANF) [15], adaptive linear element A sequence component extraction unit based on a two-layer
(ADALINE) [16], wavelet transformations [17], [18] etc. These CCF is used for the grid integration. The major features of this
advanced techniques have higher accuracy but an increased work include:
17554543, 2022, 2, Downloaded from https://ietresearch.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1049/pel2.12224 by University of Engineering and, Wiley Online Library on [21/11/2022]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
170 VARMA ET AL.
∙ A two-stage solar energy transfer system is presented here to employing a high gain, highly efficient DC-DC converter is
integrate the solar PV array power with the grid. appropriate. High gain is commonly found in most of the boost
∙ A fundamental positive sequence components extraction unit converter topologies which comes with either a higher num-
is used for the sensed voltages to withstand the grid side volt- ber of components or auxiliary boosting circuit arrangement.
age fluctuations. The fundamental frequency of the grid is MQBC has less voltage ripple at the output, gives quadratic gain
tracked for the MCCF’s corner frequency selection, and also even for a low duty ratio, and voltage stress on capacitors is min-
used for unit template generation. imum for MQBC.
∙ A fundamental positive sequence components extraction unit
is used for the sensed load currents and the reference grid
currents are estimated. 3 CONTROL APPROACH
∙ A PV feed-forward term is incorporated in the reference grid
currents generation to improve the dynamic performance at Two independent controls are used for two stages, one is the
irradiance variations. INC MPPT technique in which switching of the converter
∙ The maximum power point tracking is realized by the incre- is controlled to operate at maximum solar power. Maximum
mental conductance algorithm which controls the quadratic power point is chosen by the INC MPPT control by sensing
converter. the PV array voltage (Vpv ) and current (I pv ), and the duty cycle
∙ During PV side and grid side variations, the system exhibits is varied. Once the duty cycle is derived from MPPT, it is com-
fast response without any overshoots and oscillations. pared with triangular reference to achieve PWM pulses for the
∙ The high gain DC-DC converter gives high efficiency owing switches as shown in Figure 3. Along with the high gain, the
to a fewer number of components and also reduces the out- converter facilitates maximum power operation with the INC
put voltage ripple, which increases the service life of the sys- algorithm. INC MPPT algorithm is highly efficient in maximum
tem components. power point tracking during dynamic variations in irradiance
without any perturbations [10]. At MPP, the rate of change of
This paper is organized as follows: Section 2 explains the sys- power (P) with respect to voltage (V) is zero in INC MPPT.
tem configuration and Section 3 discusses the inverter control
approach, Section 4 gives the design equations for SETS, Sec- 𝛿P
tion 5 illustrates the results and discussion. Section 6 explains = 0, (1)
𝛿V
the experimental results and its analysis, Section 7 explains the
comparison study of different control algorithms and conclu- 𝛿I I
sions are listed in Section 8. =− . (2)
𝛿V V
FIGURE 2 Block diagram of a two layer complex coefficient filter based grid integration control algorithm
gain at the fundamental frequency and attenuates components where 𝜔c is the cut-off frequency and 𝜔0 is the desired fre-
below and above the fundamental frequency. The transfer func- quency. According to CCF(s), the gain plot resembles a low pass
tion of the CCF is given as [23], filter as shown in Figure 4. When the grid voltage’s fundamental
frequency goes beyond the design frequency, the fundamental
𝜔c component gets attenuated. Similarly, at low grid frequencies,
CCF (s) = , (3)
s − j 𝜔0 + 𝜔c the filter performance gets deteriorated. Therefore, the desired
17554543, 2022, 2, Downloaded from https://ietresearch.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1049/pel2.12224 by University of Engineering and, Wiley Online Library on [21/11/2022]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
172 VARMA ET AL.
sensed only in two of the phases. Load currents in ‘a’ and ‘b’ is
only sensed and load current in ‘c’ phase is calculated as,
+
vs𝛽 = vs𝛽e dt , (13)
Ql = QSETS ; Qg = 0, (5) ∫
Positive sequence extraction at fundamental frequency Sequence components are finally extracted using CCF along
requires input quantities in 𝛼 − 𝛽 frame. SETS is a three-phase with with fundamental frequency tracking. Positive sequence
three-wire system in which grid voltages and load currents are components of grid voltages are transformed to dq0 frame to
17554543, 2022, 2, Downloaded from https://ietresearch.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1049/pel2.12224 by University of Engineering and, Wiley Online Library on [21/11/2022]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
VARMA ET AL. 173
𝜃= 𝜔dt . (15)
∫
Parameters Rating
where Ppv is the PV array power and Vs is the peak of sensed 4 DESIGN OF SOLAR ENERGY
grid voltage. TRANSFER SYSTEM
Amplitude of reference grid current (Is∗ ) is derived as,
For the proposed grid-supported solar energy transfer system,
Is∗ = Il 𝛼 p + Ispv − I pvg . (21) the following parameters are chosen.
expression for the maximum PV array power is, Selection of DC-link Capacitor
shown. While the sag happens at the PCC, the load currents
decrease as voltage and current are proportional to each other.
Now, the load power and currents are reduced, more power will
be injected into the grid. Therefore, the grid currents increase
during a sag in grid voltages. When the voltages at the PCC rise,
the load currents rise, grid currents decrease to achieve power
balance. The grid currents are maintained sinusoidal, steady and
balanced when dynamic changes occur in grid voltages. Also,
grid currents are out of phase with corresponding grid voltages
indicating injection of power into the grid at UPF. Response
time during dynamic variations in grid voltages is quick without
any overshoots and oscillations.
The performance characteristics when grid voltages ampli-
tude in one of the phases experience sags and swells are shown
in Figure 8. When a sag of 20% is applied in one of the phases,
that is phase ‘a’, the grid currents maintain the sinusoidal,
balanced and steady nature. Even though there is an unbalance
in grid voltages, the grid currents are balanced by the SETS
operation. These results also explain the efficient tracking of
fundamental positive sequence components. Similarly, for a
swell of 20% in phase ‘a’, grid currents magnitude is reduced
to maintain power balance, also they are sinusoidal, balanced,
and steady. Thus, it is clearly understood that even during
FIGURE 9 Performance of SETS at varying irradiation, waveforms of
grid voltages amplitude variations in one or all the phases, Irn , Ppv , vs , is , il , iin j , and VDC
the proposed control has maintained balanced, sinusoidal and
steady grid currents.
formance of SETS is analyzed under rapid irradiation variations.
Power characteristics also changes, so the amount of grid cur-
5.2 Varying irradiation rents and its nature is observed in results. Irradiation level (Irn ),
Ppv , vs , is , il , iin j and VDC waveforms are shown in Figure 9.
As we know that on a normal day there will be variations in Change in irradiation subsequently change the PV array power
solar irradiation intensities at different time intervals, the per- leading to changes in DC-link voltage which is the input for the
17554543, 2022, 2, Downloaded from https://ietresearch.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1049/pel2.12224 by University of Engineering and, Wiley Online Library on [21/11/2022]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
176 VARMA ET AL.
All the given conditions are carried out at highly distorted grid
voltages, harmonics will be certainly present in them. At the 6.1 DC-DC converter
load currents, there are non-linearities and harmonics. So it is
necessary to check if both the grid voltages and load currents Experimental validation of modified quadratic boost converter
affect the grid current characteristics. THD of the grid voltages is discussed in this section. For checking the hardware pro-
is 6.75% as shown in Figure 11a, while the load current THD totype, the duty ratio of 0.7 is selected to achieve a gain of
is 17.7% (Figure 11b). Distortions at the grid voltages and load 10. The dSPACE controller realizes the INC MPPT logic and
17554543, 2022, 2, Downloaded from https://ietresearch.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1049/pel2.12224 by University of Engineering and, Wiley Online Library on [21/11/2022]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
177
Total harmonic distortion and harmonic analysis of (a) grid voltage (b) load current (c) grid current
FIGURE 12
VARMA ET AL.
17554543, 2022, 2, Downloaded from https://ietresearch.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1049/pel2.12224 by University of Engineering and, Wiley Online Library on [21/11/2022]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
178 VARMA ET AL.
FIGURE 13 Waveforms of MQBC (a) Vpv and I pv , VDC and IDC , VL1
and IL1 (b) VC 1 and IC 1 , VL2 and IL2 , VC 2 and IC 2
FIGURE 15 Performance of SETS during excess power injection to the grid: (a) vsab with isa , isb , and isc and Pg (b) vsab with iin ja , iin jb and iin jc , and PSETS (c) vsab
with ila , ilb and ilc , and Pl (d) harmonic spectra of vsab , ila and isa
to analyse how well power is distributed at the PCC. Line voltage the load current THD is 21.3%, but the grid current THD is
vsab is taken as a reference for all the results. Grid phase currents, maintained at a smaller value of 3.8% as shown in Figure 15d.
isa , isb , and isc are shown in Figure 15a. Since there is an injection Even when the grid voltage and load current THD is quite high,
of power into the grid, the currents are out of phase with their the grid current THD is made less. Power spectra of inverter
respective phase voltages resulting in UPF operation. One can (PSETS ), load (Pl ), and grid (Pg ) are shown in Figure 15a–c. In
note that the grid currents are maintained sinusoidal, steady, and injection mode, inverter side power 413 W is shared by the
balanced. Similarly, inverter phase currents, iin ja , iin jb , and iin jc load of 51 W and then excess power of 364 W is injected into
are shown in Figure 15b. Injecting currents are not sinusoidal the grid. Active power at the grid is negative because the grid
as the inverter aids the grid currents to be steady, sinusoidal, is accepting power from the PCC. From the results, it is seen
and balanced. Load currents, ila , ilb , and ilc shown in Figure 15c in Figure 15a that the grid is operating in UPF (power factor
are having non-linearities. THD of the grid voltage is 7.5%, and = -1) as reactive power by the grid is negligibly small. Grid
17554543, 2022, 2, Downloaded from https://ietresearch.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1049/pel2.12224 by University of Engineering and, Wiley Online Library on [21/11/2022]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
180 VARMA ET AL.
FIGURE 16 Response of SETS during sharing of power: (a) vsab with isa , isb , and isc and Pg (b) vsab with iin ja , iin jb and iin jc , and PSETS (c) vsab with ila , ilb and ilc , and
Pl (d) harmonic spectra of vsab , ila and isa
current waveforms are sinusoidal which are not affected by proposed SETS is tested in sharing mode, and the results are
non-sinusoidal load currents and harmonics in the grid voltages. shown in Figure 16 where it is reassuring the ability of SETS
Harmonic spectra show that the grid current THD is within the to manage power demand. Line voltages are taken as a refer-
IEEE-519 standard. Reactive power compensation of the load ence with grid phase currents as shown in Figure 16a where
is by the SETS due to which the grid is operating at UPF. they are in phase indicating UPF operation at the grid. The
load current of 2.051 A is not completely supplied by either
the SETS or the grid. A current of 0.882 A is supplied by the
6.3.2 Sharing of power SETS and 1.448 A is supplied by the grid. The grid currents
are maintained sinusoidal, steady, and balanced during all this
At lower irradiations, both the PV and the grid are support- time. Similarly, inverter phase currents, are illustrated in Fig-
ing the load, therefore it is in sharing mode. If one source fails, ure 16b. While the load currents are nonlinear having harmonics
another source succeeds in meeting the load demand. Here, the (Figure 16c), non-sinusoidal currents are injected by the SETS
17554543, 2022, 2, Downloaded from https://ietresearch.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1049/pel2.12224 by University of Engineering and, Wiley Online Library on [21/11/2022]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
VARMA ET AL. 181
to maintain sinusoidal grid currents. Harmonic analysis in Fig- sinusoidal, balanced, and operating at UPF. Grid currents and
ure 16d shows that the THD of the grid voltage is 7.8%, the voltages are in phase implying that the power is taken from the
load current THD is 25.1%, but the grid current THD is main- grid. The inverter phase currents are shown in Figure 18b which
tained at a smaller value of 4.1%. The THD of grid currents is are non-sinusoidal due to which a sinusoidal, balanced, steady,
maintained within the IEEE-519 standard which improves the and UPF operation is achieved at the grid. Load phase currents
power quality of the grid. The power spectra of inverter, load, with line voltages are shown in Figure 18c. Harmonic analysis
and grid in Figure 16a–c convey that the PV and grid together infers that the grid voltage THD is 5.4%, load current THD is
support the load. From the results, one can observe that the 17.1%, but the grid current is maintained at a THD of 2.6%,
load power of 381 W is the sum of the grid power 269 W and as depicted in Figure 18d. Thus, the proposed control scheme
the inverter power 117 W (loss at auxiliary components is also brings the grid current THD within the IEEE-519 standard.
considered) which is known as sharing mode. It is observed that The power quality of a system is good when the harmonics are
for distorted grid voltages and harmonic loads at the PCC, grid reduced and fundamental is improved. From the power spectra
power quality is not compromised proving efficacy in the pro- shown in Figure 18a–c, it is understood that a small amount of
posed control. active power is supplied by the grid to the SETS. Load power
of 336 W is given by the grid whose power is 374 W, from
which 22 W is used to charge the DC link capacitor through
6.3.3 Load unbalance the inverter. During this condition, the grid supports the load,
and compensate for losses at the inverter, interfacing inductors,
Variations in load currents are observed when one of the and RC filter. It is seen that the shunt active filter is compensat-
phases (phase ‘a’) is disconnected, leading to a reduction of load ing for the reactive power of the load while grid reactive power
currents, and load power. Thus, to observe how load unbal- is nullified. Even when the load is nonlinear with non-sinusoidal
ance affect SETS and grid performance, hardware prototype of load currents, the grid operates at UPF which reassures the aim
SETS in unbalance operation is tested and results are illustrated of the work.
in Figure 17. In Figure 17a, the grid voltages are distorted but From the above steady-state results, it is understood that
do not affect the grid currents as they are maintained steady, the proposed control works well with SETS to achieve bet-
sinusoidal, and balanced. The load power is reduced due to load ter power quality. It is very important to note that the reactive
unbalance, excess power at the PCC is injected into the grid power and harmonics requirements of the load are fulfilled by
therefore, the grid currents and voltages are out of phase. Simi- the SETS alone. In excess power injection and load unbalance
larly, inverter phase currents in reference with grid line voltages mode, SETS injects excess power to the grid at UPF. While in
are depicted in Figure 17b. Inverter injects non-sinusoidal and sharing operation, the active power of the load is supported by
unbalanced currents to meet the harmonics demand of load and both the SETS and grid and reactive power is supported by
thereby improve the wave shape of the grid currents. Load cur- SETS alone. In shunt active filter mode, reactive power and
rents are shown in Figure 17c which are non-sinusoidal due to harmonics requirements of the load are met by the SETS and
the nonlinearities. Harmonic spectra of grid voltages, load cur- active power by the grid. One can observe that in all the above
rents, and grid currents are shown in Figure 17d. There are only conditions, a nonlinear harmonic load at the PCC and distorted
3.7% harmonics in grid currents even if the grid voltage THD grid voltages are not affecting the grid power quality. That is,
is 6.7%, and the load current THD is 9.2%. Power spectra of the grid currents are sinusoidal, steady, balanced, and are at
inverter, load, and grid are shown in Figure 17a–c. Here, the UPF.
load consumes only 31 W from the PCC power of 411 W, the
rest of the power is injected into the grid which accounts for
-375 W power at the grid. During distorted load condition also, 6.4 Dynamic operating conditions
the proposed control has enabled the system to withstand such
adverse conditions. Dynamic conditions such as grid voltage amplitude variations
(sag and swell), varying irradiations, and load unbalances are
tested in the SETS. The transient behaviour of the SETS
6.3.4 Shunt active filter operation during all these conditions is evaluated. The grid voltage vsa ,
grid current isa , load current ila , and injecting current iin ja
In shunt active filter mode, solar irradiation falls to 0 W ∕m2 during dynamic variations are being monitored. During volt-
and the active power demand of the load is supplied by the grid. age sag and swell conditions, dynamic results are as shown
All other demands of the load such as harmonics and reactive in Figure 19a,b. It conveys that when there are variations in
power are supported by the SETS. Power quality improvement grid voltages, then grid currents, load currents, and injecting
through reactive power compensation is validated in this sec- currents vary their magnitude to maintain the power balance.
tion. For this operation, a charged DC-link capacitor is required When there is a voltage sag at the PCC, load current reduces
for which active power is supplied from the grid. The shunt as they are directly proportional. The grid current which is
active filter operation of the SETS is tested in the hardware pro- out of phase with the voltage increases to maintain power
totype and results are depicted in Figure 18. Grid currents are balance, that is more power injection to the grid. When there is
obtained as shown in Figure 18a, they are maintained steady, a voltage swell at the PCC, load current rises as they are directly
17554543, 2022, 2, Downloaded from https://ietresearch.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1049/pel2.12224 by University of Engineering and, Wiley Online Library on [21/11/2022]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
182 VARMA ET AL.
FIGURE 17 Performance of SETS during load unbalance: (a) vsab with isa , isb , and isc and Pg (b) vsab with iin ja , iin jb and iin jc , and PSETS (c) vsab with ila , ilb and ilc ,
and Pl (d) harmonic spectra of isa , ila , and vsab
proportional, while grid current is decreasing to maintain power also, the MPPT at the input side ensures the power injec-
balance. tion to the grid with sinusoidal, steady, and balanced grid
During irradiation variations, results are shown in Figure 20. currents.
While irradiation is varied from 1000 W ∕m2 to 500 W ∕m2 , Dynamic operating conditions of the proposed SETS in its
the amount of power injected into the grid is reduced so the hardware prototype depict that for sudden changes, the pro-
grid current and the compensating current are also reduced. posed SETS achieves steady state values with no oscillations or
Even when the irradiation varies, steady, sinusoidal, and bal- overshoots within a short time interval. Grid power quality is
anced grid currents at UPF are achieved. In the case of load not compromised and sinusoidal, balanced, and steady grid cur-
unbalance shown in Figure 21 where phase ‘a’ is disconnected, rent operating at UPF is obtained for all dynamic adverse oper-
the load current and load power are reduced leading to an ating conditions. Therefore, experimental results convey that
increase in the grid current. In such an unbalanced condition the proposed SETS entitles the desired performance.
17554543, 2022, 2, Downloaded from https://ietresearch.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1049/pel2.12224 by University of Engineering and, Wiley Online Library on [21/11/2022]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
VARMA ET AL. 183
FIGURE 18 Behaviour of SETS during DSTATCOM mode: (a) vsab with isa , isb , and isc and Pg (b) vsab with iin ja , iin jb and iin jc , and PSETS (c) vsab with ila , ilb and ilc ,
and Pl (d) harmonic spectra of vsab , ila and isa
Based on the complexity, computation time, and performance, A two-layer complex filter-based positive sequence extraction
some of the control techniques are compared in Table 2. Pro- controlled solar energy transfer system has been proposed in
posed control takes less time to compute, easy to formulate, this work. The first layer equipped for fundamental positive
frequency tracking without using PLL. During load current sequence extraction of sensed grid voltages has empowered the
and grid voltage unbalances, the proposed control maintains system to maintain the grid power quality, especially during har-
grid current quality because of sequence component extraction. monic or unbalances in grid voltages. The unit in-phase volt-
The proposed control is comparatively superior to conventional age templates have been derived from the fundamental posi-
control techniques as seen in Table 2. Load active and reactive tive sequence of grid voltages. The second layer is a complex
power compensation, sequence component extraction during filter associated with the estimation of reference grid currents
unbalance, and dynamic operation during disturbances makes which ensures actual grid currents to be in phase with the fun-
the proposed control to be suitable for grid connected applica- damental positive sequence of grid voltages. The system injects
tions. maximum available PV array power to the grid, and also has
17554543, 2022, 2, Downloaded from https://ietresearch.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1049/pel2.12224 by University of Engineering and, Wiley Online Library on [21/11/2022]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
184 VARMA ET AL.
[31] Active power component extraction, simple control with less number
of computations, use of three-phase PLL, no frequency tracking
[32] Instantaneous active and reactive power estimation, involves
mathematical computations, no frequency tracking
[33] Symmetrical component extraction, easy formulation, tedious power
calculation
[34] Simple and robust, higher number of iterations and mathematical
computations, individual calculation for each phase
[35] In-phase and quadrature current extraction, Active load current
estimation, separate computations for each phase
FIGURE 19 Performance characteristics of SETS at varying voltages (a) [36] Phase angle detection, calculation for each phases, not sustainable to
vsa , isa , ila , and iin ja at voltage sag (b) vsa , isa , ila , and iin ja at voltage swell grid voltage unbalance
[37] Iteration based control, faster convergence, per-phase calculation, grid
voltage unbalance problems are not solved
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
nullified the power quality issues caused by the nonlinear local This work was supported in part by the TEQIP and Centre of
loads. A quadratic boost converter has ensured less voltage rip- Excellence in Systems, Energy and Environment, Government
ple at the DC link, thus stabilized the inverter input voltage. The College of Engineering, Kannur, Kerala, India and in part by the
feasibility of the control is proven as the system has attained Khalifa University of Science and Technology under Award No.
sinusoidal, balanced and steady grid currents during dynamic CIRA-2019-049.
operating conditions. The addition of a PV feed-forward term
helped in the faster settling of grid currents to reach the steady- CONFLICT OF INTEREST
state. Since all the estimations were made based on fundamental The authors declare no conflict of interest.
17554543, 2022, 2, Downloaded from https://ietresearch.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1049/pel2.12224 by University of Engineering and, Wiley Online Library on [21/11/2022]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
VARMA ET AL. 185