Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Endocrinology and Immunology of Acne
Endocrinology and Immunology of Acne
Endocrinology and Immunology of Acne
Christos C. Zouboulis
Accepted Article
Departments of Dermatology, Venereology, Allergology and Immunology, Dessau Medical
Center, Brandenburg Medical School Theodor Fontane, Dessau, Germany
Funding: None
Conflict of interest: C.C. Zouboulis has received thematically relevant honoraria from Bayer
Healthcare and PPM as advisor and conference speaker, from Allergan and Almirall as advisor,
and from Jenapharm as conference speaker, which have no influence on the preparation of this
manuscript.
This article has been accepted for publication and undergone full peer review but has not been
through the copyediting, typesetting, pagination and proofreading process, which may lead to
differences between this version and the Version of Record. Please cite this article as doi:
10.1111/exd.14172
This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved
ABSTRACT
Current experimental research on acne pathophysiology has revealed a more complicated template
than the classically reported four factor etiology. Cells of the pilosebaceous unit, which represent
Accepted Article
the template for the developments of acne lesions seem to be parallelly affected by
endocrinological/metabolic factors as well as inflammatory/immunological ones, which influence
cooperate in sebocyte differentiation/lipogenesis, holocrine secretion and sebum production.
Indeed, the unique programme of sebocyte terminal differentiation and death, the so called
holocrine secretion, is influenced by inflammatory and metabolic (lipid) signaling with common
denominator the selective regulation of peroxisome proliferator-activared receptors. Autophagy
provides substrates for energy generation and biosynthesis of new cell structure proteins
contributing to the normally increased sebaceous gland metabolic functions, which are also
regulated by extracellular calcium signaling, essential lipids and hormones. The ultimate
differentiation product of human sebocytes, sebum, co-regulates the inflammatory sebocyte status.
Sebum composition is controlled among others by Propionibacterium acnes and other bacteria,
sexual hormones, neuropeptides, endogenous opioids and environmental agents, which may
function as endocrine disruptors. Diet may also be an important source of substrate for the
synthesis of proinflammatory and antinflammatory sebaceous lipids. Sebum changes might induce
inflammation and initiate underlying immune mechanisms leading to acne lesions. Current new
therapeutic efforts on acne concentrate on anti-inflammatory/immunologically active concepts,
which are able to regulate sebaceous lipogenesis. At last, current molecular studies based on
published molecular datasets confirmed the major role of inflammation in acne development.
Another hallmark of sebum in acne patients might be its content in lipoperoxides, mainly due to
the peroxidation of the sebaceous gland specific lipid squalene by keratinocytes [31] and a
decrease in the level of vitamin E, a sebum antioxidant [32]. Lipoperoxides and monounsaturated
FA affect keratinocyte proliferation and differentiation, whereas lipoperoxides increase the levels
of pro-inflammatory cytokines and activate PPARα and γ. The resulting ligand-receptor
complexes activate pathways involving sebocyte proliferation, differentiation, lipogenesis,
hormone metabolism and cytokine and chemokine release [14,23,33] (Fig. 3).
Considering that free FA are also a major component of sebum, it is likely that changes in free FA
concentration can affect both the synthesis of sebum as well as the inflammatory response in
sebaceous glands [2,34-36]. Like AA and LA [37,38], palmitic acid was also shown to increase
the levels of sebum lipids that are contained in the sebum in vitro and in vivo [39]. Free FA
become incorporated into wax esters and other neutral lipids, which are synthesized solely by the
sebaceous gland [40]. In addition, free FA significantly increased the levels of proinflammatory
cytokines in human sebocytes [15,36-39]. The increased secretion of IL6 and IL8 after sebocyte
treatment with free FA may be an important link to acne as both these cytokines have been shown
to contribute to the formation of acne lesions [2,15,39-41]. Regulation of stearoyl-CoA desaturase
and fatty acid desaturase 2 expression by linoleic acid and arachidonic acid in human sebocytes
leads to enhancement of proinflammatory activity but does not affect lipogenesis [38]. At last,
Like adipocytes, human sebocytes produce adipokines, which among their functions, also control
lipogenesis [44]. Moreover, current research has detected a large number of new molecules, which
can regulate sebaceous lipogenesis in homeostatic stage and in disease, a fact that makes the
understanding of sebaceous fraction modifications in acne and its background more complicated
than ever [2,45-54].
Regarding sebaceous lipogenesis and inflammation, insulin and IGF1 stimulate the formation of
unsaturated lipids and then the neo-lipogenesis in human sebocytes [66]. Among the mono-
unsaturated fatty acids [67], the acne-associated C16:1 appears to be the most influenced [27].
C16:1 levels are associated with acne severity. Regarding sebocyte proliferation, insulin and IGF1
reduce p21 protein expression and subsequently increase the cell number at the S phase of the cell
cycle. PPARγ, and its target genes ADRP, encoding adipophilin, and angiopoietin-related gene
(PGAR), which regulates lipogenic pathways and sebaceous lipogenesis at protein and mRNA
level, are expressed at lower levels in sebaceous glands in both involved and non-involved skin
from acne patients associated with the increase in endogenous lipid ligands, i.e. eicosanoids [75].
The basal level expression of genes and proteins involved in insulin- / IGF1-induced lipogenesis,
proliferation and inflammation are significantly higher in sebocytes with reduced or abolished
PPARγ expression, suggesting the involvement of this nuclear receptor in the control of cellular
physiological processes [69,70,76]. On the other hand, chronic inflammatory response has a
critical role in the development of acne [1,24]. IGF1 has been shown to regulate in vitro cytokine
expression in professional inflammatory cells and to stimulate TNFα, IL6, and IL8 secretion in
human sebocytes [69,77,78].
Sexual hormones
Several functions of the human skin appear strongly dependent on biologically active sexual
hormones, namely androgens, estrogens, and progestins [79,80]. Human skin is not only the target
of androgens, but sebocytes can also synthesize androgens in situ [58]. Although human sebaceous
glands can produce testosterone by de novo synthesis from abundant serum cholesterol [81],
testosterone synthesized in cultured sebocytes is derived mainly via a shortcut pathway by using
circulating dehydroepiandrosterone (DHEA) [82]. DHEA has a weak androgenic effect but is a
Treatment of sebocytes with IL1β, which results in marked increase of IL8 release, was partially
blocked by co-incubation of the cells with α-melanocyte-stimulating hormone (αMSH) in a dose-
dependent manner [93]. IL6 and IL8 are abundantly expressed in acne-involved sebaceous glands
and might be involved in the development of acne lesions [15]. Their release by sebocytes can be
induced by the upstream hypothalamic neuropepride, corticotropin-releasing hormone (CRH),
through an IL1β-independent pathway [94]. CRH also induces the synthesis of sebaceous lipids in
vitro [95]. Both αMSH and CRH are expressed in sebaceous gland cells in vivo and are
upregulated in acne-involved sebaceous glands, influencing the feedback regulation, which occurs
during the induction of clinical inflammation in early acne lesions [92,96].
P. acnes has been considered over decades to be primarily responsible for the development of acne
and antibiotics were consequently the first line treatment with a series of subsequent problems,
such as bacterial resistance [125]. However, bacterial resistance does not markedly reduce
antibiotic effectiveness in acne, since antibiotics retain their activity by exhibiting anti-
inflammatory para-antibiotic effects [1]. The increased amount of sebum, but especially the
alteration of its composition, stimulates the growth of P. acnes in the follicles [2], which requires
in addition the development of biofilm in order to grow properly [126]. In the majority of P.
acnes-positive acne patients, hair follicles are colonised by P. acnes macrocolonies/biofilms, but
follicular inflammation is not directly linked to cellular immune response [127]. Indeed, P. acnes
induces inflammatory response around the pilosebaceous unit through the secretion of
proinflammatory lipids and various cytokines, mostly leading to disease aggravation. P. acnes,
under environmental conditions that favor fermentation, produces short-chain fatty acids, which
drive inflammatory gene expression in human sebocytes in vitro [128]. Interstingly, exposure of
sebocytes to the stress-inducing catecholamines epinephrine and norepinephrine stimulated the
effect of P. acnes on sebaceous lipogenesis, but did not affect its cytotoxic or inflammatory
potential [129]. In an in vitro acne-like model, P. acnes also induced increased expression of
several proteins, among them the proinflammatory cytokine macrophage-inflammatory protein-2,
fibrinogen, α polypeptide, fibrinogen β chain, S100A9 and the serine protease inhibitor A3K
[130].
Furtheron, stimulation of human sebocytes with P. acnes activates the caspase-1 and leads to
secretion of IL-1β from human sebocytes in vitro [135,136]. The innate immune system
recognizes pathogens via pattern recognition receptors (Fig. 7), such as TLR and Nod-like
receptors (NLRs). Activation of nucleotide-binding oligomerization domain, Leucine rich Repeat
and Pyrin domain containing (NLRP)3, a nucleotide-binding oligomerization domain-like receptor,
by P. acnes in mouse skin and human sebocytes [136], dependent on protease activity and reactive
oxygen species generation, indicates that human sebocytes are important immunocompetent cells
that induce the NLRP3 inflammasome (Fig. 8). NLRP3-deficient mice as well as suppression of
the NLRP3 inflammasome by licochalcone A were shown to display an impaired inflammatory
response to P. acnes [137,138]. An agonist peptide for the protease-activated receptor-2, which
functions as innate biosensor for proteases expressed in sebaceous glands in acne [130,139],
P. acnes does not only exhibit pro-inflammatory properties [144]. It also enhances de novo
intracellular synthesis of triacylglycerols in human and hamster sebocytes in vitro through
activation of 15-deoxy-Δ(12,14)-prostaglandin J2, a cytochrome P450-linked sebaceous lipogenic
factor with anti-inflammatory properties [145]. Moreover, sebum free FA exhibit antibacterial
properties [146-148] and enhance the innate immune defense of human sebocytes by upregulating
antibacterial peptides [149], among them hBD2, cathelicidin as well as superoxide dismutase 3
[35,150,151].
Moreover, sebum FA have been shown to potently induce alternative macrophage activation,
which is the characteristic activation pathway for macrophages involved in tissue homeostasis and
repair functions [152]. They also increased macrophage phagocytosis of bacteria, including P.
acnes and they exhibited a differential effect on the inflammatory response of P. acnes-activated
macrophages [36].
Isotretinoin revisited
Isotretinoin, the most powerful anti-acne drug [155-157], seems to exhibit more complex effects
on the sebaceous gland than initially postulated [158] (Table 2). Among other pathways, protein
domains for collagen and fibronectin were increased, domains for steroid metabolizing enzymes
were decreased, the mRNA levels of cellular retinoic acid-binding protein 2, S100A2, S100A7,
S100A9, and involucrin were affected and pathways linked to lipid metabolism were
downregulated [159,160]. Isotretinoin induces sebocyte cycle arrest and apoptosis by a RAR-
independent mechanism, which contributes to its sebosuppressive effect [161]. Selective
isomerization of isotretinoin to tretinoin in the intracellular compartment of human sebocytes, a
reduced tretinoin inactivation process after isotretinoin administration as compared to treatment
with tretinoin, a retinoic acid receptors-mediated inhibition of sebocyte proliferation and reduction
of sebaceous lipogenesis might the sebocyte-specific activity of isotretinoin and support a pro-
drug/drug relation between isotretinoin and tretinoin [162]. This data has been confirmed by
RNAseq analysis, which supported the pro-drug role of isotretinoin in acne [163]. Interestingly,
isotretinoin activates the PI3K/Akt pathway, decreases the nuclear content of FoxO1 and its
transcriptional activity in sebocytes and reduces the proliferation of IGF1- or insulin-stimulated
sebocytes in vivo and in vitro [67]. On the other hand, an anti-inflammatory effect has been
attributed to isotretinoin through a reduction of MMP in sebum [164] (Fig. 11) and normalization
of exaggerated TLR-2-mediated innate immune responses in acne patients [165]. Neutrophil
gelatinase-associated lipocalin, which is enhanced in acne-involved sebaceous glands [139]
mediates isotretinoin-induced apoptosis of human sebaceous gland cells [166].
The liver exhibits a tremendous capacity to store retinoids. Only huge and chronic daily ingestion
of more than 100,000 IU (33.3 times the recommended daily allowance) of vitamin A for at least 6
months or ingestion of at least 100 times the recommended daily allowance in a period of hours to
days is considered toxic [167]. Retinoid toxicity manifests as intense headaches, due to increased
Although prospective clinical studies did not reveal evidence of isotretinoin-induced depression,
an isotretinoin-sparing regimen – i.e. starting with low-dose isotretinoin and slowly advancing by
titrating the daily dose upwards according to the individual patient’s need and side effects
threshold - may potentially lead to stable remission, prevent acne relapses in patients with mild-to-
moderate acne as well as lead to lower incidence of side effects and lower cumulative costs in
patients with severe acne [171,172] in addition to possibly prevent the above mentioned central
side effects. Otherwise, nothing has practically changed, including the treatment guidelines,
despite initially promising retinoid derivative developments [173,174].
PPARγ modulation
Reduction of sebocyte differentiation, which can be induced by environmental factors [102], leads
to upregulation of the Akt/mTOR pathway, the expression of lipogenic genes and mono-
unsaturated fatty acids synthesis, lipoxygenase activity and inflammatory cytokine production
maintained by normal insulin levels, mimicking acne conditions [44]. Lipid production in acne
sebaceous glands is higher than in healthy sebaceous glands, which suggests that PPARγ might
play a protective role against excessive lipid accumulation and inflammatory responses, which
makes this nuclear receptor a possible therapeutic target in acne [44,76]. Indeed, azelaic acid was
Melanocortins
Working on hypophsectomised rats many years ago, Thody [180] has detected that αMSH
increases preputial gland sebum secretion and skin sebaceous gland lipogenesis, especially wax
ester biosynthesis. Several years later Böhm et al. [93] confirmed the sebotropic activity of αMSH
on human sebocytes in vitro. Due to the parallel suppression of IL1β by αMSH [93] and KDPT
(Lys-D-Pro-Thr), a tripeptide αMSH derivative, in cultured human sebocytes [181], the
superpotent αMSH analogue afamelanotide (Nle(4)-D-Phe(7)-αMSH) administered
subcutaneously led to reduction of the total number as well as the number of inflammatory acne
lesions 56 days after the first injection in a preliminary clinical study with 3 patients [182]. On the
other hand, melanocortin-5 receptor (MC5R) is expressed in human and mouse sebaceous glands
and has been associated with sebocyte differentiation and sebum production [183] and his targeted
disruption gave rise to reduced sebum production in mice [184]. In two multi-center, double-blind,
Leukotriene inhibition
The rate of apoptotic mature sebocytes and, therefore, the sebum released in the follicular canal, is
dependent on proapoptotic caspase cascades, which can be markedly upregulated by AA, an ω6
proinflammatory free FA, which is a Δ6-fatty acid desaturase-2 (FADS2)-induced metabolite of
the essential ω6-free FA LA and precursor of leukotriene-B4 (LTB4) and 15-
hydroxyeicosatetraenoic acid [2,15,47] (Fig. 2). The latter metabolic pathways are regulated by the
enzymes 5-lipoxygenase/leukotriene-A4-hydrolase and 15-lipoxygenase, respectively [185,186].
AA induces LTB4 and IL-6 release and enhances lipid synthesis in cultured human sebocytes
[15,187]. LTB4 is also a natural PPAR ligand [188]. Therefore, inhibition of LTB4 synthesis
through 5-lipoxygenase down-regulation may provide an attractive target for control of
inflammatory processes in acne, as already shown in respective experimental and clinical studies
[188-190]. A phase II clinical study with systemic zileuton has been conducted several years ago
(NCT00098358). Although patients treated with zileuton showed a mean reduction in the total
number of lesions of 25.3, compared to a mean reduction of 16.4 lesions in the placebo group the
overall result was not significant (p=0.085). However, the results were significant in a subset of
patients with more severe acne (baseline inflammatory lesions ≥30). Patients treated with zileuton
(n=26) showed a mean decrease in inflammatory lesions of 41.6% compared to 26.2% in the
placebo group (n=24; p=0.025). No zileuton-treated patient discontinued the study. The compound
was well tolerated with no serious adverse events reported in patients.
Acne vaccination
A secretory Christie-Atkins-Munch-Petersen (CAMP) factor of P. acnes has been detected up-
regulated in anaerobic bacterial cultures [191]. Mutation of CAMP factor significantly diminishes
P. acnes colonization and inflammation in mice, demonstrating a probable essential role of CAMP
factor in the cytotoxicity of P. acnes. Vaccination of mice with CAMP factor considerably
reduced the growth of P. acnes and the production and release of the murine counterpart of human
IL8, MIP-2 [192]. The efficacy of CAMP factor antibodies in the neutralization of the acne
The human sebaceous gland expresses numerous signaling pathways and receptors, which may
lead to disease development but also become appealing pharmaceutical targets [201]. Further
clinical trials against acne mostly concern topical agents that may act via sebosuppressive effects,
antimicrobial properties or anti-inflammatory actions. A topical formulation of olumacostat
Phase 2 studies with systemic anti-acne drugs include finasteride (NCT02502669), biologics and
low dose antiinflammatory antibiotics were rather disappointing, not achieving or announcing any
results yet [205].
CONCLUSION
Endocrinological/metabolic and inflammatory/immunological aspects are correlated closely in the
aetiopathogenic (Fig. 1) and clinical (Fig. 12) initiation and development of acne. The simplified
“triangle” of acne pathogenesis is based on these two cardinal factors (Fig. 13) and it is reasonable
that the majority of future efforts for acne treatment take this concept into consideration (Fig.
14). Indeed, the unique programme of sebocyte terminal differentiation and death, the so called
holocrine secretion, is influenced by inflammatory and metabolic (lipid) signaling with common
denominator the selective regulation of PPAR subtypes. Autophagy provides substrates for energy
generation and biosynthesis of new cell structure proteins contributing to the normally increased
sebaceous gland metabolic functions, which are also regulated by extracellular calcium signaling,
Group Examples
Accepted Article
___________________________________________________________________________
Natural and artificial hormones Phytoestrogens, 3-omega fatty acids, contraceptives, thyroid
compounds
Drugs with hormonal side effects Naproxen, metoprolol, clofibrate
Industrial and household chemicals Cosmetics, phthalates, alkyl phenol ethoxylate detergents,
fire retardants, plasticizers, solvents, 1,4-dichloro-benzene,
polychlorated biphenyls, heavy metals (arsenic, cadmium,
lead, mercury)
Side products of industrial and
house hold processes Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, dioxins,
pentachlorobenzene
* Sebocyte-specific
RAR, retinoic acid receptor; IGF1, insulin-like growth factor 1; CRABPII, cellular retinoic acid-
binding protein II; RXR, retinoid X receptor; MMP, metalloproteases; TLR2, Toll-like receptor 2