IN THE HIGH CO OF MeF mINCIPAL SEAT AT JABIALPlRe

WRIT PETITION NO 2014

PETITIONER e
Dr ARlN KUAARGa

VERSUS

REA2tlDEIlTS S ReDeVaVe JABALPUl 8

OTHERS e

INDEX

SNO Description of docuuentS Annexures Pzge Noe

Ole Idexe 1

020 2
Chronological EventSe
e

03e Writ Petition with Affidavite 3 to

04e List of DocumentSe lo

050 Copyof permission dte14e0702008
e

Pll l1
06e Copy of Degreee Pl2 12
P

07 Copyof dte14e06013 Pl3

notification I3 1
08e of circular dte14e9e060 PI4 1
py 1
09 e COPY Of Application dte27010140 Pl5 e

1
100 49
Copy of order dte14e03020140 16 1
110 Copy of order dte090Ole2014 Pl7 r
r
r
r

120 V akal tn am a e

JABALPl

Dtl PAWKAJ DU3EY

1 ADVOCATEFOR PET IT IONER
299W
C1 V

emI
1 5 APR 2014
e

V
 1

INE HIGH COT OF MP PaDIPAL SEAT AT JABALPR

WRIT PETIT ION NO e 12014

PET IT IONER 1 Dr ARUII KlMAR GARGs

VERSUS

RES PONDENTS e
RaDaVaVe JABALPUi S
OTHERS

ICAL EVENTS
CHRONOLOG

The petitioner has acquired DcctoratelPheOe ln

relevant typic of subject of Journalism Communicatione

His service are exemplaryand has been awarded the

President Gold Medal for good servlcGe The Uliversity

has provided two increments to the staff and employees
O Il PheD Degreee The petitioner had also
acquiringthe
made similar claim however without any justifiction

and discriminatory manner the claim of Ititioner has

been rejected for two on acquiring

grant of increment

PheDe Degree vide the impugnedordere Hence present

writ petitione

J4BALPU

Dtl Pi4IIKAJ OLBE

ADVOCATEFOR PETITIONER

Na

7 lrjP J

1
ee5

APR201

71 J
 1
e

8
1
Il

11
mm 1
1
1
1
1
1
l

Il
j
II

e 9 4
Jo Il

P
TT87T MADIA PRADESH V

Ii

1 IN THE HJSH COURT OF MP e

dRIIPAL SEAT AT JABALPU
8

1 WRIT PETITION NOe

2014
PETITION e
Dre ARiN KUMARGARG

VERSUS

RESFONDENTS 6
ReDaVe JABALPU
8 AND OTHERSe

Ij WR PETIT ION PRTICL6 OF CONSTITUTIONOED

JABALPi
11 Dtl PN

96 ADVOCATE
FOR PET IT IONE

11
 2 2
1
1 1
l w vr
7
1b
9
1

r
1
1 P
t1 1
1
1
1

7
vW9 e e
o0
OVV Vvb90 1V
J
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH PRINCIPAL SEAT AT
OABALPUR

Writ PetitionNOe

t e

PETITIONER Dr ArunKumarGargSlo 1
e 8t
lr
of Mass Media8 CommunicationRani
r
Durgawati
1
1 1
Oabalpur
76
Versus
Prcsetistant 4

RESPONDENTS l Rani Durgawati through

its Registrar
SaraswatiVihar
Jabalpur

2 The Stateof Madhya

Pradesh
the Secretary
Through
11 Education
of Higher
VallabhaBhawan Oabalpur

3 The Deputy Establishment

Registrar
Rani Durgawati Jabalpur
11eP

WRIT PETITION UNDER ARTLE 226 CONSTITUTIONOF INDIA

le PARTICULARS OF THE CAUSEIORDER AGAINST WHICH THE

8 Ill
PETITION IS MADE

1
1 Date of Order
1 2 Passedin Caseand File Noe 14 Ill
Issuedby Respondent NOe3
That the is challenging
petitioner the orderdated 1432014 passedbythe

No the case
rejecting of the petitioner
for grantof 2 increments
ae0

Degreee
4 Subiect mter in brief

5 APR2014 1e
A3
1
8J
 ee

That the petitionerhas Doctorate1 PhD

acquired in relevant topicof

subjectof Journalism8 CommunicationHis setvices are and has

exernplary
been awarded the PresidentGold Medal for goodsetvicee The university
has

two incrementsto the staff and employees

provided on acquiring
the PhD
decree The petitioner
had also made similar claim however without any
and manner the claimof petitioner
hasbeen rejected
for grantof lwo incrementon acquiring videthe impugned
PhD degree order

2 A Declaration that no Proceedinq on the same subiect matter has

been Previouslv instituted inanv Court authoritv or Tribunale If
instituted the status or result thereofe alonq with copv of the
ordere

The petitioners
submitthat no proceeding matter was
on the same subject

IedbeforethisHonble Coutt authority

previously or Tribunale

3 DETAILED OF REMEDIES EXHAUSTED

The petitioner excepttllingof the writ

declarethat has no other remedy
beforethisHonble Court
petition
4 DELAYIF ANYIN FILINGTHE PETITIONER AND EXPLANATION
THEREOF
submitthatthereis no delayin
The petitioner lg the petition

5 FACTS OF THE CASE

5e1 The petitioner

is the citizen of the countryandthereforeis under
protected
enshrinedin the Constitutionof India
the fundamentalrights

52 That the petitioneris an

of the Respondent
ernployee In the
University
year 1986 the petitioner
was appointed
as a LDC the petitioner
was

in the year 1997and UeDeCe

promotedUeDaCeeI II in the year 2000 The

petitioner on the postof Omce

was promoted Iil the year
2008 and since then is working in the
on the aforesaidpostand posted

of Journalismand Communication

5 That the petitioner

has beenawardedwith the PresidentGold Medalfor
Setvices The has vast contributionin publication
petitioner of
hundredof journalsof the University
editorialshipand he is the Secretary
of the PublicationCell The petitioner
is incharge
of the PublicRelations

5A That the petitioneraiwayshas academicinterestand desire for higher

thatfurthereducationshallalso be
studiesknowingly for the
in term of tlnancialbenetlts
petitioner
l I5 1
l r

1
wr r lll l
Ijl
J
 eeeWeem

5S has obtainedMaster Decree in Journlismiee MeJeCe

That the petitioner in

the year 2006

56 That the petitionerwanted to proceedfor further studies in PheD in

Journalismand thereforemovedan application to

for grantof permission
for studiesin PhD
proceed The Respondent
University permission
granted
vide communicationdated 1472008 A copy of the permission
dated
14072008 is Oledherewithto the petitionand markedas an Annexure
Pl

57 That the petitioner his

completed research and in the year

2013he was awardedthe degree

of Doctorof Philosophy1D Copyof
the degreeis tlled herewithto the petitionand markedas an Annexure
P The award of degreeto the petitionerhas been notified by the

respondent vide communicationdated 140602013A copy of

university
notificationdated1462013 is tlledherewithto the petition
and rnarkedas
an Annexure P3

58 Thatthe petitioner
hascontributed service and has never been

or proceeded
punished
59 That the respondent two incrementsto the
has provided
university
of the employee
advantage who have acquired
PheDedegreeof the
and it is hasbeen practices
university as per the availablerules Employees

Dr
namely KK Hoonka Dr SOnl Dr
Rajaram ReP Rawatand Dr Girish

Budholiaare the few employees

who havebeen granted
the beneOtof two
increments on service
PhDedecreeduring
acquiring
circularin this regardCopy
510 That apartthe StateGovernmentalso provided
of circular dated 14092006which is in vogue is filed herewith to the
is markedas
petitioner an Annexure P4

511 That on the basis ofthe beneOtof grantof the incrementsto the other

employees
of the respondent
university
on enquiring and also
PhD degree
Ill
the Iightof provisionsthe petitionerrnoved an application dated
272014 to the respondent university for similar treatment and
entitlementas per Iaw A copy of the application
dated 272014 is Oled

herewithto the petitionmarkedas Annexure Pe5

5e12 That the respondentuniversity

failed to consider the claim of the

4
pitioner in terms of parilyand in terms of entitlement Impugned order
1 e
10 dated 1432014 has been passedrejecting the claim of the petitioner
in
1

1j 1 mechanicalmanner withoutany A copy of order challenged

1
 eee

dated 142014 is tlled herewithto the petition

markedas Annexure P
6

513 That an issue relatedto grantincrement in similarcircumstances hasbeen

decided by this Honble Coutt in WP Noe in the case of Dr

CM Vs Stateof
Kanoriya MP A copy of order dated 912014 is Oled

herewithto the petition

markedas Annexure P70

5 14 That the issuance order is

of impugned and
arbitraty
passedin manner thereforethis petition
on the following

others
amongst
grounds
6e GROUNDSURGED1

6e1 Because the order suffers from illegalityarbitrariness

irnpugned
discriminationand non application
of mind warranting
kind indulgence
of
the Honble Courte

6e2 Because the petitionercannot be put to discriminationas other

employees Dre KK Hoonka
namely Dr Soni
Rajaram Dre RePe Rawat

and Dr Girish Budholiahavebeengranted

the beneOtsof two increments
on PhD degree
acquiring
6e3 Becausethe orderlallenged considerationand IS
to not retlectany Iegal

passedin complete
mechanicalmanner withoutassailing
anyreason the
degree
acquired is in the
bythe petitioner is
of the advantage
ISSue also The impugned
order frustratesthe objectof obtaining
the
PhD degree
6e4 Becausethe petitioner
has a clean recordand numberof achievements
the clenialof grantof two advancelwo incrementsto the petitioner
shall
and thus not sustainablein the eyes of Iaw
renderinjustice

7 RELIEF SOUGHT2

In view of the facts and circumstancesand Ill the Iightof the

subrnissionsrnade in the presentpetitionthe petitioners
therefore
prayfor the following
humbly reliefs

i To the orderchalienged
quash dated1432014 P0
6

To grant two annual incrementsto the petitionerfrom the date of

W

lllll

46
5 APR
1

iii To grantarrears of incrementsfromthe date of bythe petition

application
interest per annum
dated2712014 with 18010

iv To call for the entire recordsof the case

v Anyotherreliefswhichthis Honble Courtdeemsjustand propermayalso

be granted
in favourof the petitioner
with the cost of the Iitigation

8s INTERIM RELIEF IF ANY PRAYED FOR

Nil

9e THE DOCUMENTS RELIED ON BUT NOT IN POSSESSION OF THE

PETITIONER

The petitioners
relyon the documentsas per Iistof documents
100 CAVEA

No notice of partyis receivede

of caveatbythe opposite
dging
An aftldavitin support is 0Iedherewith
of this petition

Placel Jabalpur PankajDubey

Counselfor the petitioner

410

I79I8t

RP

pr f7i
Il Il
i

n
 14

4
1
18

IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH

PRINCIPAL SEAT AT OABALPUR t

IJVP

PETITIONER Arun Kumar Garg

VERSUS
RESPONDENTS StateOf MP 8 others

AFFIDAVIT

I Arun Kumar GargSIOLate Shri N1 GargAgedabout

48 years Rlo MEPB VidyutNagarnear RampurJabalpurMePe do
herebystate on oath underl
as

1 e
That I am the petitioner in the instant petitionas such I am
well conversantwith the facts of the case

2 That the instant petition

has beendraftedand Oled in accordance
with my instructions The contents of the same from paras 1 to
end have been read over and explained to me in Hindi I have
understoodthe same Theyare true and correct to my personal
andbelief
knowledge
are the true copies
3 That the documentannexedwith the petition
of the respective documents
original

r42 4

10 t 12 Il

1 t

f75 1
l C1 l2
kPk
1
1
VERIFICATION
P9V
41 0

I Arun Kumar Garg the deponent named above do hereby

that
verify the contents of paras 1 and 30f the aboveamdavitare true to
my personal knowledgeand belief That it concealsnothing
and that no
partof it is false Verified and signedon this day of Aprilat
Jabalpur 7

0r ArIi
5
4
l
b1j

sI Ic aIe here to aotj CQ

61
 e

IN THE HIGH CO OF MePe IPALSEAT AT JABALPR

RlT PETITION NOn

PET IT IONER Dr ARUIJ KiMAR GARG

VERSUS

RESPONOENTS 2 ReDaVaVaJABALPUt AND

OTHERS e

LIST OF DOCUvENTS

SNo Description of Date of Originall Nuner o f P ac

documents docunents Copy

Ole Copy of 14 e07008 Cl

the Photoeopy
pennlSS100e

O2e Copy of Degreee 10 81

03e Copy of the 14 006013 arc10e 6
notificatione

04e Copy of Circular 14e09e06 do 02

05e Copy of APplne 27001014 do
06e Cop9 of ordere 14003014 do
07e Copy of order 09e01014 do
0
2

JABALP

Dtlm DU3EY
ADVOCATEFOR PETrTIONERe

11
71iPtr
1
1101

e1A 6

G1j

1
 1

P8S0
e
2

T7 1
m9 1915
aUmePUlme ZSP419
CO
1T0081
1
7
7O i 0
1

1
ki j3143 JT
Ol
i rli i
7

Wfcl8 i
32
114n7 8 4 Cl f1 rt301 3rf 4 115 39542068
1 1
C
Jrftr 4PPl 3r3T 4 1
p e

07 1 871318P1
51
3 T 134
i
e

r 4 444U 46
1
rC 200

8 3 8RTr8 4 48T i U4 t9 3117

9
1 3T5T 3T7I t f Wrr
11J

111
Illl P
1

17 0 rrf6Rrrlp
9

l
r
4r00L2 0i l7
rl 5 3T4YZT41
4 r t rl
444li
30TZ 7t
1 U2 sZZtsECiZ Z ZUZc Hz z5 1U
4

611 tt41
4SrT fr4 l
r1
11
2e T5TtR1 r
1
J

1 P
3q
eT

V 1
I
 P Pl r
10 bde Wh
1
1

C CD
iccllrl11 64970
51Il r4l U l cl
f
P 3 lPf
14 chIr4
j cl l
a3
9J
r2t f
4
4E4141 424
2 2013 1

f
r
Il
Il 1 39Ici 3
4211111 19201945

Rani
OF PHILOSOPHY
DOCTOR
Io
cerf II

cri run mar 9ar

as awarclecflederee
6een o

DOCTOR
OF PHILOSOPHY
inle sujecl urmafismo Gommunicalion
lfle
uncfer 20

e Iilfeo Isis is

4 6 14712 1 c 1 34 1C 1A4211 11
19201945 7Il
l

11

S
ProfKeNeSinqh t

30 2013
1 Ccl 141Cl
s
Dated 30th December 2013
 1

by
Prepared
b
Ohecked

1OealingClerk

l DYeRegistrar
Asstte
Exarninatioosl e

r
 r

RANI DURGAVATI VISHWAVIDYALAYA JABALPUR

Notification No ConffTEC12013104 Date 1410612013 4

Itis notifiedfor informationofall concemi thatthe ExecutiveCouncil ofthe University heldon the2910512013
in its meeting

theaward ofthe Degree in thesubjects

ofDoctot ofPhilosophy their name viz
as mentionedagalnst
SN0 Narne ofthe ResearchScholars Title ofthe Thesis Namethe Subject Faculty Dateof
8 Address Supervisors VivaeVoce
1 Shri Mrigendra
Kumar Dwivedi INVESTIGATION ON GENETIC Salma BioChemistry Llfea 20042013
DiSmt
F43 bansagarColonySaman POLYMORPHISM lN HOMOCYSTEINE Khan Science
Rewa M METABOLIZING GENES WITH REFERENCE DrSmt UlC
TO HYPERTENSION AND STROKE Chauhan

SUSCEPTIBILITY
2 Shri Arun KumarGarg 961c6121
ei 31T tcIjrdl Dr Dhtrendra Joumalism
8e Ans 202013
4
NeE92 VidyutNagar 945 Pathak Conlmunication
1 619201
RampurJabalpur
6MP9
Smt Aparna Pathak TEZ Dr GMtshra EducatlOll Educatlon
t3 8E fT t f 2042013

Bhaldarpur f211 c4i c1 4 cb 8T f

Jabalpur
6MPI HTC124ct7d
l T 379034

4 Shri Rain Gulatn DEVELOPMENT OF POLYPYRROLE BASED Dr SmtIJaya ChemiStry Sclence 2042013
122412Asha Vihar Ganga NANOCOMPOSITES AS RADIATION BaJpai
SagarGarha Jabalpur
MP9 SHIELDING MATERIALS

Ku SunitaBaghel 11 17Idcb
C
Dr KlIShukla Sanskrll Arls 24042013
Dharka NagarNear Yograj
f11
Talkies Seoni M
6 1
ShriSukh Dev Singh 1

1 DrSmtlDivya Law Law 204 2013

3f9
Clo RajeshDixit2777 National 3 42 8T 4 311e11411r4cb
1 Chansoria
ColonyShaktiBhavan Rampur 3TEZIl
JabalpurMP

IJ 1 S
1

l Cont
1

1
1

AJ
 2
7 Kuvlanu Sharma A STUDY OF EXPANDING HORJZONS OF DrSmt
646 Napier
Town Opp CYBER Divya Law Law Ol2013
LAWS WITH SPECIAL REFERENCE TO Chansoria
BhavartalWaterTank TNFORMATIONTECHNOLOGY ACT 2000
6MP
Jabalpur
8 Kt Smarika Lal STUDIES ON THE REMOVAL OF FLUORIDE DR
Smtlaya Chcmistry Science 040520 13
135011 IA ChristianColony ION BY ADSORPTION ON NANOPARTICLES Bajpai
Nr MGMchool PostOffice OF CERTAIN NATURAL POLYMERS Dr AKBajpai
VidyutNagarSethiNagar
Jabaur M P 9
9 ShriJeevanLal Jharbare Prof Rajendra Education EducatIon
315 8 072013
Slo Shri Chetoo Jharbare 24 8TT IclEl lei 4 i Vf 117
rl Tiwari
VillageGwara PostSaharan 39 DrSrnl
Beeri Dist Chhindwaravl P 9 IClC Dubey
10 ShriAvinash Gour STUDIES RELATING TO SOME SOIL DR JKeller Electron
tcs SciCnce
12012 Sangam Colony ELECTRONICS 0951013
DEVICES AND CIRCUITS Dr Shiv Prasad
Near Baldeobaoh ALONG WITH THEIR APPLICATIONS fN Kosta
Jabalpur0MP DIGITAL ELECTRONICS
Ij Dr S P Gautam BtotechnoiogvLifee Il 05 2013
Kt Padmini Ramteke SCIENTIFIC VALIDATION OF BIOACTIVE
Dlo Mrvlanik Ramteke COMPOUNDS FROM MEDICINAL PLANTS D Anjana Sharma SCIeIlCe
1No 1042Madan Mahal USED BY BHILS OF JHABUA DISTRICT
JabalpurMPI AGAINST URJNARY TRACT INFECTIONS

12 ShriAmar SinghUddey cb Dr SIl Mishra Ancient Indian Social 11052013

65N9 Rlllh lcleirlUlir9cb
Asstt Prof Gcvl CV College 37E79Il Culture Science
Hislory
Dindori lvlP And
Archaeolog
13 ShrI J itendra Tripathi Dr I M Keller PhySICS Sclence 15052013
STUDIES ON REFRACTIVE INDEX AND
BehindStateBak Market MICROHARDNESS ON RHODAMINE 31 D Das
Branch GandhiGanj DOPED POLYVINYL ALCOHOL
Katni MPI

4 1
1
Cont3

r
 3
1
14 Shri Arunendra Kumar Patel MECHANICAL AND DR Rakesh Bajpai 1
STRUCTURAL Physios ScIenu i2013
2751 Sanjay Nagar ELECTRICAL STUDY OF SOME POLYMER Dr JM Keller
Near TamrakarBanan Palace BIOCOMPOSITE FILMS
Adhartal Jabalpur
6MP I
15 Ku Anu Sharma STUDIES ON CHICKPEA RHIZOBIUM Prot K Arora BiotechnologyLife 152013 7

NBAIM KushinaurMaunath PLASMID AND PLASMID ORIENTED GENES Prof Anjana SClenct

BhanjanJP THROUGH COMPARATIVE GENEMICS Shanna

16 Ms Shachi Vardhan T ProfOilip

r7 Kumar BiotechnologyLife 15052013
DIVERSITY ANALYSIS OF BIOCONTROL
Cee7
CWS ColonyTadali BASED BACILLUS FROM INDOGANGETIC Arora Science

UrgaronChandrapur
oMI PLAINS OF INDlA AND DEVELOPMENT OF Dr AK Pandey
DIAGNOSTIC KIT FOR ITS IDENTIFICATION
17 Shri Bharat Kumar I
71 3T4ET D SubhashSharmaHistory Soctal 16052013
t
Slo Shri GaneshBirha 151741441 1947 1977 5 Sctence
6718Sneh Nagar
NainpurMandlaovlP9 11
18 Smt ManjuMaria Solomon h9 T 8 3 1
Iuieilldcb DrAruna Pathak Historv Soctal 162013
HIJo 112 1 Gorakhpur 7f2f21 1947 1977 7E Science
ChristianCotnpound
Near Rain
Mandir
0lvP 9 GorakhpurJabalpur
1
19
Ms Mukta Bhatele DESIGN AND STUDIES OF LIQUID Dr Prashant Mor Electron
ics
92 Nehru NagarInont ELECTRONIC CIRCUIT Science 16052013
AND THEIR Dr SP Kosta
MedicalCollege APPLICATION WITH RESPECT TO HUMAN
JabalpurM P I BLOOD
20
Snt Shruti Jauhari 1
Drro MUSIC Ans 17052013
Nee Shruti Verma I l
Supriya
Bose
206 Akhilaya Apartments
NapierTown Jabalpur0MP
21
KuNeetu Jat Kanjar Il
T
Ul641 11 DrLokesh Geographv Social 202013
1E f
HVo 203Ward No 17 Kanjar c
Mohalla Belbagh Shrivastava Sctence
jeo
JabalpurM P 9
22 Ku SushmaShukla T
l T
HIlo I 160PerfectHomes 21 GW 14 4411311
1 Dr DDixit SOCiology Social 20052013
Behind RoyalHospital Science
1Iw 4
K1IJ NagarJabalpurvP9
 ConA

23 Ku Mousumi Bhowmik NVESTIGATION OF ABSORPTIVE REMOVAL Dr SK Bajpai Chcrntstry ScIencc 242013

Flat No l l Matri Chaya OF SOME ANTIBIOTIC DRUGS FROM
Complex SIMULATED WATER SAMPLES BY
ManegaonWes5 Land Jabalpur POLYMERIC SORBENTS
24 W2 Bhasin EducatlOll 1011
Educat
Shri VinayKuuIar Diwan 4
j7T f4 fT8 DrSmtI C 2i05 2013
940 Diwan SadonNew 218 3717
7 3 Dr OSmt D
Coloiiy
Jagdamba T
I
l Malviya

Baldeobagh 4
Jabalpur
M P9
1

Registrar
RaniDurgavati
Vishwavidyalaya
Jabalpur

EndtNCon81TEC120131440 Datec
Jabalpur 1410612
0 13

andnecessaryactton
Fonvardcdtor Information
Copy tOl
1 Ali the Headsof thcDepnConcerned
2 All theDcansof FacultiesConcenlcd
3 Ail theChaimlenclftheSubJectsConcerned
4 All lhcSltpervIsors
concemed
5 TheDy Regtstrar lMeetingl7 VV Jabalpur
6 ThcAsttegistra Exam MeetIngDevelopnleni degree Ceill RD VV Jabalpur
7 TheDy ReOistrarOevelopmentl RDI Jabalpur
8 TheSectionOfllcei Exam MectinoDevelopment deoreeCelll RDI Jabalpur
9 TheSecretray U G C Bahadur ShahZaffarMargNew Delhi
10
Ii ofall the Locai as ncws ttem please
l2 The
TheEditors
Librarian Association
for fcvourof publtcatlon
oflndlan Universities A U6 Kotla Marg New Delhi
13 TheSecretary Hjgher Vallabh Bhavan BhopalA1
Educationl
14 The ExaminersConcemed
Thc LibrariaRllV VJabalpur
16 The IS To VCRegistrarRD Jabalpur
17 TheRegistrarofall theUniversity
in lndia
18 DVN Jabalpur to
with a request upload e notiOcation
on thewebsite oftheUnilersity

14

Jabalpur
1
 IV IV V
I 4a

TEZI
I
2007 1 1c 2007
1
iFIwl
14 e

4141 54v v er
U

1 re0
Sne
1
1 J

1 1411 2006 1 1

1
IT 1

r4

2rTET 7T 11 1 T41101
e

2T 111

f4lT
11

65
1 1

r871 1 1
1

9
2rlvtiUl 3Tll 11141rl
2 r
I l

71 WR 1 08
T 261129211II73 e

1973 3081431111315 1975

4401113
33175 f 201975 71T 3331526111375
Cloe 3e1976 lT 2721
1975 911966111375
4901111741976 1
18414871113179
1810e1979 Sli 1331183113187 f 441987 18 121
18111992 73T 2872004
Il114 3 3T
9 l 9 vi
9 4ii
1 i
T c rl
73
19

f 7c t414711
r
iT
317 1
14
es 1T TlT T 3 T f
TT7 11CTE fT 3ICl li cb i

1172 1
f2 11

7 1 3T 217 T Tr
2 3 T4 3 E67T
riC T T SlT I
77 ctll4r1 4t 31
t177t 3 3 1

llEZlT1T
9
41 31141

C
l 111
1 1

3V131

T191114
t 1
 1

3311 cl H6lR
r9
Icl2CllClUlCrl1

0161C1

T 3 TEI

e e
rma
8411t4 rr 1 33f CclelC zOCl
14T 1

r e
231 j4cllio1 tT t314ef I4e1Icb
rm
ShHlcbf120081706
r
1408 T 1 31ilc
1
H6121

Iq4e 12T Iq2cIlcIEIIC14 1

2004Ol3
H6lch21c1 T I 31Iec1 f 4CblTecll 19201945
r
7r2 33
tcbIlecll le C
Cbl c
3T
IT 1
47
1
T 1 iq2c4Ulelel C 27 49 1HleIS R 14411c1330
V
I4e61e 2013 t0 3
r 1 re9 r9
3T T1 Cl4l f 1e1IHTI 49 3Tf lelC I4e1Icb

202013 cilclzcl I

EleCll4 1

rev 1
Iicl1 2710112014 Telf 1

c9cV1JVfl 1 31H 11 114

2
t91ITW 3T2 2I5
3
T
ee Llollef 3TEft
19 19T f l 3TE2T 2r417T
2 f
r r9
f T2T Cl le4C4T4217 49T 014 01
1sTCITCI
t51411

4 CbleltC ee

31 11 C67
F5141WTc1
0 5 S7Cre 3 7 8
r
1 t31eIWlcl t
Vc
C

Olll1
C5

1
 r

tl
4114dljqlEIlc4414414

22 131
6401
71 eeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

1120141
lf
1
1 0
C2
1
iIIl11 f t1

ll illcl jcqjq6110140
l1

t14 0 1

1r 4

ET

Ce 3Tl 31T 20 12 014

r
l3l111 414211 21492006
i
3
3141041311
1123 Zl
3 1 I9Ie 31 I

311

371 tl
Tl
cTr11 t1

1 T4c4i41l
6R
Il

1
 C 11
V57
J unT
0
C
3
e1 9
C
C

IN
HEtGH
PRINCI SEAT AT JABALPUR 1
t4Y
W sl 1

e 11L
0 1 Ii
Ii
Ii
PETITIONER 1
Late Shri i 1
SP Kanoriyaaged about 52 1 j1
Il
j

e
Principa i
Il
1 11
Il
r9
School Galganj Sagar 5
j District S MP l l
1
C
VERSUS C

il

11

RESPONDENTS l State ofMP

jl

Through
Prcipal 1
r 1

11
I
Finance Depatment l

Il
2 jl
Il
Vallabh Bhawan BhopallvlP Il

5 1 14
l
Il1
Il 1
1 r
2 The Treauy 1 1
1 1
and Accounts Sth Floor
ParyawasBhawan Madhya 1
2
PreshBhopalIP
0
ae
3 Il
easuzy 1
and Account S
Division
s

4 P eNeS Joint Director i l

Il
1
Ii
Z
0 Treasury
and A2ounts S 1
e
qtSO
r 4 41 Dln S2g e01
i
1
P
r
II
L I i

e 2IT 1

226 i
I j

e
OF INDL il
1 ji l
I l
1
0 1

11
1

P
 1
L

HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH elt

ORDER SHEET t

CASE N201ee te
1lllt
c

v 2

Ve
416m
1
f1 8l
WaPeNoe366912012
DATE OF THE ORDER
ORDER

91112014
Shri V P Nema learned counsel for

the petitioner
Shri Devashish learned Panel Lawyer
for the respondents
Petitioner is working as a Deputy
Director in the Finance Department and claims
grant of two advance increment On having
obtained a PhD Degree vide Annexure Pl6 on

172007
Grievance of the petitioner is that his
claim has been rejected vide Annexure Pll on

17 2012 on ground that the petitioner can

the
j

get the Degree only after the Circular dated

1 149 2006 is passed Aoerusal of the Circular

dated 1492006 goes to show that certain
1

decision has been taken by the State Govemment

to
granttwo advancement increment to person
Il

who has obtained PhD Degree In the order

dated 1712012 Annexure Pll rejecting the
claim of the petitionerit is indicated that benefit
Il

jj
1S
available only to such of the persons who has
i
obtainedthe PhD Degree after the Circular
i
I dated 1492006 was issued Admitedly
l l

petitionerhad obtained the Degree on 1792007

1

as 1S
indicatedin the order and is evident from
cne
order Annexure Pl6 If the petitioner has
1
1
obtained the on
e
Degree 1792007 it is after
lssuance of the Circular dated 1492006 and j

Il
1
 HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
4

ORDER SHEET

e
o e
lvo
1
1

r
Ie 1
L

1
DATE OF THE WePe
ORD ORDER

therefore rejectlon of the ppcation on the

111
grounds indicated Annexure Pll PIma facie
seems to be unsustainable

11
1 In view of the above order Annexure Pl
is quashed and the matter is reInanded1k to
the Gvernment to reconsider the matter and
e

take a decision afresh within a period of 45 days

from the date of receipt of certified copy of this
order
A6

With the aforesaid thipetition stands

reeo GllOwed and disposedof
1 1

c
e

asoer 17 1
4 1
111
e w
I
Menonl l

2
1
4
Judge
mr 1
5
1 l
t2
1
1

1
tl
01 ee

Il

5
5
1 4
l 14114 e

X
8808jpu el
4

5
5
4
1
2

4
5
1J
1

4
C 1
i
i4 P1
1
4 IerO

rr0
2
e
54 4

9 2
e
2
2
5
r2

1 0el9

s1

0 e
P
P e
O p
 cstlewi
http1117216180A31c0pynean
1
ApplicaUon
No 5527 12014
Ile10
Iap
1 CJ
L
Application
with record
Application or without
with or recordand
without or
for further Applicant
further correct glven Applicant Notice in
Application Applicant Applicant
appeared Icorrect
particulars partioilarS
ifany notice
6rther for glven SroNo t61 Copy Copy Courtefee
or delivered
to readyon
received on told 1 sent to requiredl corrcet
notice
furtherfor or 01
complled on realized
appear on on
Record received partlculars funds on with on
on
Keeperl from the
Deallng Record
Assistant on Keeperl
Dealing
Assistant on

1 2 3e 4 0e 6e 7e 8e 9e 10

17 Ol 2014 20
01
2014 20 Ol 2014 20Ole2014 17eOla2014 24
1 1 1
Copyist
 1
3131
1 0 3o I

r20e554
r22

4W
V 6 94Vee v

VAKALATNAMA S 1 9 S
r2
IN THE HIGH COURT S4

r
I
l NO r
1

r 4
l 1
1 4

VERSUS 1

6
1
U

IlWe 1
0 e l

or

pIead in afesaid cal proces whichshallinclude

for
applicantioil
recall
applicatioil

dOllCbyhiinlthenl
as ifdonebymelus

handto thesepresentthe contents ofwhich

e

t e e e
e O e

HusbandName Email Address NumberStatus

Telephone Thumbs
in the case
1 Ifany
29 39 49 59 06
e e
e

1 e

6 lNo Iv C
e
21 1
4 l 4c l 1

31
04 Nl eelfl OLvl
r

1Llr Dtr b VfVr cll0

5

Accepted Particularsofeach advocateaccepting documents

Vakalatnama
Address
Enrollment eMail Telephone
No for service Address Number Full Signature
In StateBar Council
1 020 3 4
5
1 Pankaj
Dubey MP
HigllCourl 9425800151
9112002
M P Hioh
W
00rrrt 042Q101Cl
7e 1UVV l l

3 VirendraSingh MP HighCourt 9300842711

146412005
4 RakeshShukla MP HighCourt 9827631868
159112004
5 Brajesh
Dubey MP HighCourt 9424359503
405312010
 1
5
2

VV 4
1 b

eev6a0404A

IN THE HIGH COlT OF M eP s PRLCIPSEAABALPlR

m enemmee9wmwWmS

PETITION NO 625812014
r

WR 1

PETITIONER e
Dr A9Ull KUAAR 3
4
4

VERSUS 1
4
1
RESPONDENTS
eewa49e
e
RaDaVeVaAND OTSaI 3
1 5
l40
ION FOR PERMLSS
APPLICAT i0 AMEND IIA l l2

OF THE WRO PETITIONa

0

The petitioner begs to submit underl

le That the petitioner had filed insta writ petition

whereas the param 1 passed ln case not

mentioneddue to typographical mistakee

2e That the mistake is bonafide and deserves to be

to awend in para 1 of the petition in the

interest of justicee

PRAYER

It is therefore prayed thEt the anendment may

and 2ermitted to petitioner to amend

kindlyoeallowed
the para 1 of the petitionz ln the interest of

justicee

JABALPI

Dtl FOR

1l l
11
91
r

ciUsl
1

PoimL