Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Comparative Analysis of Financial Statements To Assess Financial Performance in Fashion Retail Companies Listed On The Indonesia Stock Exchange
Comparative Analysis of Financial Statements To Assess Financial Performance in Fashion Retail Companies Listed On The Indonesia Stock Exchange
Group 5:
ACCOUNTING DEPARTMENT
D-IV MANAGEMENT ACCOUNTING PROGRAM STUDY
STATE POLYTECHNIC OF MALANG
2021
CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION
1.1 Background
At the end of 2019 the world was shocked by the emergence of Corona Virus
Diseases 2019 or can be called Covid 19. Covid 19 was first confirmed in the city
of Wuhan, China in December 2019. Covid 19 is a virus that infects the
respiratory system in humans with mild to severe symptoms. weight that can lead
to death. This virus attacks anyone such as the elderly, adults, children, babies and
even pregnant and lactating women. Transmission of the virus through sprinkling
of phlegm (droplets) from the respiratory tract or through the air in a dense closed
room with poor air circulation makes the spread of the virus quite fast. Covid 19
has touched more than 26.8 million cases and reached 880 thousand deaths
(Worldmeter, 06/09/2020). This condition is quite alarming considering the
number and coverage of the outbreak area which has almost touched all corners of
the world. Indonesia was not spared from the spread of the corona virus,
according to data released by the Task Force for the Acceleration of Handling
COVID-19 of the Republic of Indonesia, the number of confirmed positive cases
as of August 6, 2021 was 3,568,331 people with a death toll of 102,375 people.
The case fatality rate due to COVID-19 is around 2.9%.
In suppressing the spread of COVID-19, a number of countries have made various
efforts, such as lockdowns, regional quarantines to large-scale social restrictions.
Access in and out of flights, land and sea transportation between countries,
provinces and cities and districts has begun to be restricted in many countries.
Several industries, shopping centers, schools, and even tourist attractions had to
be disbanded to limit community interaction. Of course this has a global impact in
almost all countries. This condition makes economic activity also affected.
The Covid-19 pandemic has had a major impact on the economic sector in
Indonesia. The first impact that is very obvious and easy to see is the weakening
of household consumption or the weakening of people's purchasing power. Until
now people have experienced a very significant decline in purchasing power. The
policy of implementing Community Activity Restrictions (PPKM) which was
followed by various tightening rules on human interaction restrictions made the
community unable to carry out economic activities. The inhibition of economic
activity has made tightening regulations in various sectors of PPKM regulations
have an impact on the ups and downs of the economic sector. The second impact
that is very visible as an inseparable part of the national economy is the decline in
investment in various business sectors. Uncertain things in the midst of a
pandemic have caused many people to hesitate to start investing. On the other
hand, entrepreneurs also feel the same doubt in starting a business. This hesitation
in investing has resulted in the business world not turning as expected. The third
impact is the weakening of the regional and national economy due to a decrease in
tax revenue due to a decrease in public income.
This economic downturn certainly changes people's behavior in the consumption
of daily necessities. To optimize the income obtained by the community for
primary needs such as rice and other food, of course, priority is given to
secondary and tertiary needs. The chaotic economy due to the pandemic has made
consumers cut spending on fashion. This affects several large companies in
certain fields. One of the areas most affected are companies engaged in the
fashion retail sector.
During the pandemic, the fashion industry is in danger of going bankrupt. Industry
leaders must rack their brains for new strategies and business models to survive.
In the midst of this pandemic situation, this industry is indeed quite aggressive in
carrying out various strategies to keep the business growing. In the end, bitter
choices were inevitable, ranging from closing thousands of outlets around the
world, firing employees, to canceling fashion shows.
In Indonesia, there are many fashion companies that have gone public and have
fluctuating financial reports such as PT. Matahari Department Store Tbk, PT.
Ramayana Lestari Sentosa Tbk, PT. Mitra Adiperkasa Tbk. In this research, we
aim to find out what the impact is on the financial performance of three large
retail companies in Indonesia due to Covid-19.
The analysis carried out can describe the financial condition of PT. Matahari
Department Store Tbk, PT. Ramayana Lestari Sentosa Tbk, PT. Mitra Adiperkasa
Tbk before and during the pandemic whether they were in good condition or
otherwise. So that the financial statements can be taken into consideration in
making decisions, as well as determining better policies in the following years.
Ratio analysis used in this study includes analysis of the ratio of Liquidity,
Solvency, and Profitability. The liquidity ratio is useful for measuring the
company's short-term liquidity ability by looking at the company's current assets
against its current liabilities. The company's solvency ratio measures the
company's ability to meet its long-term obligations. While the company's
profitability ratio measures the company's ability to generate profits at a certain
period level.
Financial statements are a tool to obtain information about the financial position
and results of operations that have been achieved by a company. This information
will be used as material for consideration in making decisions made by the
company's management and external parties. Financial statements are not only to
evaluate the work of the accounting department but also as a basis for determining
or assessing the company's financial position.
Financial statements will be useful if the information presented is easy to
understand and understand as a reference for the company going forward. To help
users of financial statements to understand and interpret financial statements,
financial statement analysis can be made. Financial analysis can help understand
and evaluate financial statements, how to use financial information for decision
making
1.2 Research Question
The research question in this study are:
3. The purpose of this research is to find out which company has the best
financial performance for the 2016-2020 period, it is seen from the
liquidity ratio, solvency ratio and profitability ratio
2. These study variables are fashion retail companies listed on the Indonesia
Stock Exchange in 2016-2020
3. The research object was only the financial statements of fashion retail
companies listed on the Indonesia Stock Exchange in 2016-2020
LITERATURE REVIEW
RESEARCH METHOD
In this Research using Secondary data, Secondary data is data that comes from
books, company reports, journals, the internet, and so on. Secondary data in this
study were collected Financial Statement audited of public companies on fashion
retail companies listed on the Indonesia Stock Exchange in 2016-2020 during
before and after the pandemic.
The data collection method in this study used a Financial Statement audited of
public companies on fashion retail companies listed on the Indonesia Stock
Exchange in 2016-2020 before and after the pandemic. This was chosen because
the author use secondary data,
what data/information needs to be collected based on the research purposes;
where you can find the trustable data sources; how long the data time period;
whether you can access the data; how much the cost to get the data (if any); the
reliability and validity of data.
TABLE 1
Current Ratio PT. Matahari Department Store
2016 – 2020
Year Current Assets Current Liabilities Current Ratio
(on millions of Rupiah) (on millions of
Rupiah)
2016 2.947.052 2.588.354 87,83%
2017 2.973.794 2.610.824 87,89%
2018 3.014.408 2.739.811 90,89%
2019 2.748.781 2.597.839 94,51%
2020 1.610.213 2.856.300 177,39%
Source of data: processed IDX data
TABLE 2
Quick Ratio PT. Matahari Department Store
2016 – 2020
Year Current Assets Inventories (on Current Quick
(on millions of millions of Liabilities Ratio
Rupiah) Rupiah) (on millions of
Rupiah)
2016 2.947.052 995.276 2.588.354 75,41%
2017 2.973.794 1.005.484 2.610.824 75,39%
2018 3.014.408 1.290.570 2.739.811 62,92%
2019 2.748.781 1.098.516 2.597.839 63,52%
2020 1.610.213 889.484 2.856.300 25,23%
Source of data: processed IDX data
TABLE 3
Cash Ratio PT. Matahari Department Store
2016-2020
Year Cash Current Liabilities Cash Ratio
(on millions of (on millions of
Rupiah) Rupiah)
2016 1.712.844 2.588.354 66,18%
2017 1.582.817 2.610.824 60,63%
2018 1.184.080 2.739.811 43,22%
2019 1.172.506 2.597.839 45,13%
2020 523.954 2.856.300 18,34%
Source of data: processed IDX data
TABLE 4
Debt to Total Equity Ratio PT. Matahari Department Store
2016-2020
Year Total Liabilities Total Equity Debt to
(on millions of (on millions of Equity Ratio
Rupiah) Rupiah)
2016 3.003.635 2.588.354 116,04%
2017 3.099.441 2.610.824 118,72%
2018 3.220.568 1.815.828 177,36%
2019 3.086.283 1.746.627 176,70%
2020 5.737.956 581.118 987,40%
Source of data: processed IDX data
TABLE 5
Debt to Total Asset Ratio PT. Matahari Department Store
2016-2020
Year Total Liabilities Total Asset Debt to
(on millions of (on millions of Asset Ratio
Rupiah) Rupiah)
2016 3.003.635 4.858.878 61,82%
2017 3.099.441 5.427.426 57,11%
2018 3.220.568 5.036.396 63,95%
2019 3.086.283 2.084.129 148,09%
2020 5.737.956 6.319.074 90,80%
Source of data: processed IDX data
TABLE 6
Net Profit Margin (NPM) PT. Matahari Department Store
2016-2020
Year Net Profit After Tax Net Sales Net Profit
(on millions of (on millions of Margin
Rupiah) Rupiah)
2016 -20.312 3.402.293 -0,60%
2017 -23.803 3.426.425 -0,69%
2018 48.967 3.487.366 1,40%
2019 33.341 3.592.046 0,93%
2020 44.538 1.694.597 2,63%
Source of data: processed IDX data
TABLE 7
Return on Assets (ROA) PT. Matahari Department Store
2016-2020
Year Net Profit After Tax Total Asset
(on millions of (on millions of ROA
Rupiah) Rupiah)
2016 -20.312 4.858.878 -0,42%
2017 -23.803 5.427.426 -0,44%
2018 48.967 5.036.396 0,97%
2019 33.341 2.084.129 1,60%
2020 44.538 6.319.074 0,70%
Source of data: processed IDX data
TABLE 8
Return on Equity (ROE) PT. Matahari Department Store
2016-2020
Year Net Profit After Tax Total Equity
(on millions of (on millions of ROE
Rupiah) Rupiah)
2016 -20.312 2.588.354 -0,78%
2017 -23.803 2.610.824 -0,91%
2018 48.967 1.815.828 2,70%
2019 33.341 1.746.627 1,91%
2020 44.538 581.118 7,66%
Source of data: processed IDX data
TABLE 9
Current Ratio PT. Ramayana Lestari Sentosa Tbk
2016 – 2020
Year Current Assets Current Liabilities Current Ratio
(on millions of Rupiah) (on millions of
Rupiah)
2016 2.830.496 1.309.610 46,27%
2017 3.093.496 1.397.577 45,18%
2018 3.557.488 1.415.582 39,79%
2019 4.017.659 1.480.893 36,86%
2020 3.200.854 1.566.474 48,94%
Source of data: processed IDX data
TABLE 10
Quick Ratio PT. Ramayana Lestari Sentosa Tbk
2016 – 2020
Year Current Assets Inventories (on Current Quick
(on millions of millions of Liabilities Ratio
Rupiah) Rupiah) (on millions of
Rupiah)
2016 2.830.496 834.400 1.309.610 152,42%
2017 3.093.496 740.993 1.397.577 168,33%
2018 3.557.488 859.767 1.415.582 190,57%
2019 4.017.659 791.194 1.480.893 217,87%
2020 3.200.854 493.436 1.566.474 172,84%
Source of data: processed IDX data
TABLE 11
Cash Ratio PT. Ramayana Lestari Sentosa Tbk
2016-2020
Year Cash Current Liabilities Cash Rasio
(on millions of (on millions of
Rupiah) Rupiah)
2016 603.750 1.309.610 46,10%
2017 751.901 1.397.577 53,80%
2018 1.950.775 1.415.582 137,81%
2019 2.208.119 1.480.893 149,11%
2020 1.554.228 1.566.474 99,22%
Source of data: processed IDX data
TABLE 12
Debt to Total Equity Ratio PT. Ramayana Lestari Sentosa Tbk
2016-2020
Year Total Liabilities Total Equity Debt to
(on millions of (on millions of Equity Ratio
Rupiah) Rupiah)
2016 1.309.610 3.337.399 39,24%
2017 1.397.577 3.494.345 40,00%
2018 1.415.582 3.827.465 36,98%
2019 1.480.893 4.168.930 35,52%
2020 1.566.474 3.718.744 42,12%
Source of data: processed IDX data
TABLE 13
Debt to Total Asset Ratio PT. Ramayana Lestari Sentosa Tbk
2016-2020
Year Total Liabilities Total Asset Debt to
(on millions of (on millions of Asset Ratio
Rupiah) Rupiah)
2016 1.309.610 4.647.009 28,18%
2017 1.397.577 4.891.922 28,57%
2018 1.415.582 5.243.047 27,00%
2019 1.480.893 5.649.823 26,21%
2020 1.566.474 5.285.218 29,64%
Source of data: processed IDX data
TABLE 14
Net Profit Margin (NPM) PT. Ramayana Lestari Sentosa Tbk
2016-2020
Year Net Profit After Tax Net Sales Net Profit
(on millions of (on millions of Margin
Rupiah) Rupiah)
2016 408.479 5.092.752 8,02%
2017 406.580 4.786.508 8,49%
2018 587.105 3.487.366 16,84%
2019 647.898 3.592.046 18,04%
2020 -138.874 1.694.597 29,64%
Source of data: processed IDX data
TABLE 15
Return on Assets (ROA) PT. Ramayana Lestari Sentosa Tbk
2016-2020
Year Net Profit After Tax Total Asset
(on millions of (on millions of ROA
Rupiah) Rupiah)
2016 408.479 4.647.009 8,79%
2017 406.580 4.891.922 8,31%
2018 587.105 5.243.047 11,20%
2019 647.898 5.649.823 11,47%
2020 -138.874 5.285.218 -2,63%
Source of data: processed IDX data
TABLE 16
Return on Equity (ROE) PT. Ramayana Lestari Sentosa Tbk
2016-2020
Year Net Profit After Tax Total Equity
(on millions of (on millions of ROE
Rupiah) Rupiah)
2016 408.479 3.337.399 12,24%
2017 406.580 3.494.345 11,64%
2018 587.105 3.827.465 15,34%
2019 647.898 4.168.930 15,54%
2020 -138.874 3.718.744 -3,73%
Source of data: processed IDX data
TABLE 17
Current Ratio PT. Mitra Adiperkasa Tbk
2016 – 2020
Year Current Assets Current Liabilities Current Ratio
(on millions of Rupiah) (on millions of
Rupiah)
2016 6.616.255 7.479.927 113,05%
2017 6.798.522 7.182.975 105,65%
2018 7.312.798 6.570.485 89,85%
2019 8.160.173 6.566.570 80,47%
2020 8.165.336 11.151.051 136,57%
Source of data: processed IDX data
TABLE 18
Quick Ratio PT. Mitra Adiperkasa Tbk
2016 – 2020
Year Current Assets Inventories (on Current Quick
(on millions of millions of Liabilities Ratio
Rupiah) Rupiah) (on millions of
Rupiah)
2016 6.616.255 3.006.977 7.479.927 48,25%
2017 6.798.522 3.066.187 7.182.975 51,96%
2018 7.312.798 3.230.941 6.570.485 62,12%
2019 8.160.173 3.615.400 6.566.570 69,21%
2020 8.165.336 3.715.202 11.151.051 39,91%
Source of data: processed IDX data
TABLE 19
Cash Ratio PT. Mitra Adiperkasa Tbk
2016-2020
Year Cash Current Liabilities Cash Rasio
(on millions of (on millions of
Rupiah) Rupiah)
2016 1.525.716 7.479.927 20,40%
2017 1.286.372 7.182.975 17,91%
2018 1.412.140 6.570.485 21,49%
2019 1.816.661 6.566.570 27,67%
2020 2.788.102 11.151.051 25,00%
Source of data: processed IDX data
TABLE 20
Debt to Total Equity Ratio PT. Mitra Adiperkasa Tbk
2016-2020
Year Total Liabilities Total Equity Debt to
(on millions of (on millions of Equity Ratio
Rupiah) Rupiah)
2016 7.479.927 3.203.510 239,49%
2017 7.182.975 4.242.414 169,31%
2018 6.570.485 6.062.186 108,38%
2019 6.566.570 7.370.545 89,09%
2020 11.151.051 6.499.400 171,57%
Source of data: processed IDX data
TABLE 21
Debt to Total Asset Ratio PT. Mitra Adiperkasa Tbk
2016-2020
Year Total Liabilities Total Asset Debt to
(on millions of (on millions of Asset Ratio
Rupiah) Rupiah)
2016 7.479.927 10.683.437 70,01%
2017 7.182.975 11.425.390 62,87%
2018 6.570.485 12.632.671 52,01%
2019 6.566.570 13.937.115 47,12%
2020 11.151.051 17.650.451 63,18%
Source of data: processed IDX data
TABLE 22
Net Profit Margin (NPM) PT. Mitra Adiperkasa Tbk
2016-2020
Year Net Profit After Tax Net Sales Net Profit
(on millions of (on millions of Margin
Rupiah) Rupiah)
2016 208.475 12.729.191 1,64%
2017 350.081 14.765.635 2,37%
2018 813.916 17.290.618 4,71%
2019 1.163.507 19.558.025 5,95%
2020 -585.304 14.072.488 -4,16%
Source of data: processed IDX data
TABLE 23
Return on Assets (ROA) PT. Mitra Adiperkasa Tbk
2016-2020
Year Net Profit After Tax Total Asset
(on millions of (on millions of ROA
Rupiah) Rupiah)
2016 208.475 10.683.437 1,95%
2017 350.081 11.425.390 3,06%
2018 813.916 12.632.671 6,44%
2019 1.163.507 13.937.115 8,35%
2020 -585.304 17.650.451 -3,32%
Source of data: processed IDX data
TABLE 24
Return on Equity (ROE) PT. Ramayana Lestari Sentosa Tbk
2016-2020
Year Net Profit After Tax Total Equity
(on millions of (on millions of ROE
Rupiah) Rupiah)
2016 208.475 3.203.510 6,51%
2017 350.081 4.242.414 8,25%
2018 813.916 6.062.186 13,43%
2019 1.163.507 7.370.545 15,79%
2020 -585.304 6.499.400 -0,01%
Source of data: processed IDX data