Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Study On Remanufacturing Cleaning Technology in Mechanical Equipment Remanufacturing Process
Study On Remanufacturing Cleaning Technology in Mechanical Equipment Remanufacturing Process
net/publication/283271924
CITATIONS READS
20 1,349
5 authors, including:
Hong-Chao Zhang
Texas Tech University
237 PUBLICATIONS 6,326 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Hong-Chao Zhang on 27 October 2015.
Abstract
The cleaning technology plays an important role in product quality during the remanufacturing processing. The availability,
quality, remanufacturing cost and the remaining life of the remanufactured product will be directly influenced by various
cleaning methods and the corresponding cleaning quality. In the meantime, the introduction of cleaning also brings
contamination to the remanufacturing processing, which restricts its engineering application. Therefore, with the study of
cleaning methods those are suitable for remanufacturing process, the fundamental concepts of remanufacturing cleaning
technology were introduced in this paper, and the major cleaning technologies for each stage in the remanufacturing stage
were described, which is beneficial to find out the optimize cleaning method in actual production and realize the real green
remanufacturing.
Keywords:
Remanufacturing; Fouling; Cleaning Technology; Green Cleaning
Worn parts
Intact parts Nonremanufacturable
parts
Scrap Scrap
Qualified
Remanufactured Painting & parts
Product Packing
⑤ Cleaning Test Reassembly ④ Cleaning Test
Cleaning in remanufacturing is an industrial process for the reduction grease, scale deposit, rust, carbon deposition and the paintcoat
of the quantity of contaminations present in or on a component until attached on the surface, and the cleaning after disassembly is
the specified cleanliness level has been reached in remanufacturing convenient for detecting the surface abrasion, micro crack or other
process. The objectives of remanufacturing cleaning in each stage of failure situations in order to make sure if remanufacture can be
the remanufacturing process are different. Firstly, the purpose of core applied and what kind of method can be employed. Thirdly, the
pre-cleaning before disassembly is mainly to reduce the quantity of cleaning processes in other stages, such as the cleaning processes
contaminations outside the products. Secondly, by removing the before reconditioning, reassembly and painting, are performed to
remove surface contaminants (oils, greases, inorganic residues, remanufacturing has a great potential for optimizations and
particulates, etc.) and to prepare surfaces for additional treatment innovations.
prior to subsequent steps. Many cleaning operations are critical to As can be seen from the above analysis, cleaning is an essential
the ultimate performance of remanufactured product. Inadequate or step in the remanufacturing process, which lacks systematic
inappropriate cleaning leads to unacceptable production yields or, understanding yet. Therefore, the main purpose of this paper is to
even worse, to product failure during use. establish a foundation for further study on remanufacturing cleaning,
Remanufacturing cleaning is distinct from cleaning in maintenance about the establishment of knowledge base, process optimization,
or cleaning in new production. Cleaning in maintenance innovations and related standardization.
concentrates on the position of damage before repairing while The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. The
cleaning in remanufacturing is done for the whole mechanical parts fundamental concepts and the basic elements of remanufacturing
in order to make them meet the quality requirement after cleaning technology are introduced in section 2. Section 3 gives a
remanufactured. Cleaning in new production is another case. Firstly, brief introduction about the commonly used cleaning technologies
the cleaning objects in new production process are changeless in that are suitable for remanufacturing process and outlines the
work piece size and material, and the contaminations are mainly the development tendency of remanufacturing cleaning technology. The
residual metal cutting fluid, lubricating oil, antirust oil, polishing paste principle of the selection of the cleaning methods at each stage in
and so on. By contrast, cleaning in remanufacturing is not so easy the remanufacturing is described in section 4, and the final
that the objects are of great many types with different sizes and conclusions are given in section 5.
materials and complex and long-termed surface fouling. Secondly,
cleaning in new production is performed at a high level. Due to high 2 BASIC ELEMENTS OF REMANUFACTURING CLEANING
standards of OEMs (Original Equipment Manufacturers), suppliers
have made great efforts to optimize cleaning processes. Also, the By mechanical, physical, chemical or electrochemical means,
ISO Standard 16232 on technical cleanliness gives recommenda- remanufacturing cleaning removes the grease, scale deposit, rust,
tions for cleaning in new production steps. However, at present, in carbon deposition and the paintcoat attached on the core surface so
strong contrast to the well-defined cleaning in new production that the specified cleanliness level requirements can be reached. Four
processes, cleaning in remanufacturing is mostly performed based basic elements are included for core remanufacturing cleaning:
on the experience of the operator instead of knowledge based and cleaning object, core contamination, cleaning force and cleaning
therefore often results in a lack of efficient solutions. So, cleaning in medium. A synopsis to elaborate the four elements is given as follows.
Scale deposit Cooling system. Calcium salt and magnesium salt, etc. Soluble in acid.
1. Cleaning object, the one which needs to be cleaned in a Taking automobile remanufacturing cores as examples, there are
remanufacturing process. For example, all sorts of machinery varieties of core contaminant, which can be mainly divided into the
parts, electronic components, etc. These parts and electronic following categories as seen in Table 1.
components are mainly made of metal, ceramic (containing
silicon compounds), plastic and etc. Different cleaning methods 3. Cleaning force, the force among cleaning objects,
should be employed, according to different cleaning objects contaminants and cleaning medium, which disperses steadily in
(different materials, shapes, and geometric dimension). the cleaning medium during the cleaning processes to remove
2. Core contaminant, a kind of “unpopular” deposits which are the contaminants away from the part surface. The contaminant
deposited on the core surface because of the long-termed molecules are combined by electrostatic or molecular attraction
effects of physical, chemical or biological during the core’s forces so that they can be removed by overcoming those forces
service time (i.e., before remanufacturing process), or a kind of in the cleaning process. Generally, the cleaning forces can be
fouling (such as residual metal cutting fluid, lubricating oil, classified into five categories, that is, 1) solvency force and
antirust oil, polishing paste, etc.) which is introduced during dispersion force, 2) surface active force, 3) enzyme force, 4)
remanufacturing process. Remanufacturing cleaning is therefore
chemical reaction force and 5) physical force, as described in
a process of contamination removal from the core surface to
achieve the required cleanliness. Table 2.
Solvency force and dispersion Contaminants can be dissolved in water or organic solvent and then steadily dispersed into
force cleaning medium.
Organic contaminants (i.e., grease) can be resolved by hydrolysis reaction accelerated by the
Enzyme force
enzyme (a kind of biological molecule), which then disperse into cleaning medium.
Contaminants can be dispersed by the chemical reaction between chemical agent and
Chemical reaction force
contaminants, which then disperse into cleaning medium.
Contaminants will change their physical properties or decompose by thermal effect, which
Thermal effect
promotes the cleaning process.
Pressure Cleaning force generated by high pressure, medium pressure, negative pressure or vacuum.
Physical Abrasive force The contaminants on the surface can be removed by mechanical force.
force
The contaminants on the surface can be removed by the function of cavitations of ultrasonic
Ultrasound effect
wave in cleaning medium.
Electrolytic force The contaminants on the surface can be removed by electrolytic action
The atoms of organic contamination molecule absorb certain wavelength of ultraviolet light and
Ultraviolet ray
the priming effect causes the decomposition of contaminants molecules.
Solvent Dissolving force and dispersion force. Organic solvent. Oil and grease.
Solid particle Abrasive force, impact force. Various solid particles. Rust, paintcoat, etc.
4. Cleaning medium, through which the cleaning environment is aluminum. Moreover, great amount of energy will be spent
offered and directly contacted with surfaces to be cleaned during electrolytic cleaning process.
during cleaning process. Cleaning medium plays a significant Definitely, there are still other ways to remove contaminants away
role in the cleaning process, which is reflected in transmitting from core surface, such as ultraviolet radiation cleaning [10], plasma
the cleaning force and preventing re-adsorption of the cleaning [11], ion beam cleaning [12], laser cleaning [13],
contaminants which have been detached. The common cleaning supercritical fluid cleaning [14], biological enzyme cleaning [15], etc.
mediums, with great varieties, are listed in table 3.
Current imperfection of remanufacturing cleaning is reflected as
follows in remanufacturing industry. 1) Contamination degree and
3 REMANUFACTURING CLEANING TECHNOLOGY AND type are not classified before the cleaning process. 2) Necessary
DEVELOPMENT TENDENCY cleanliness specifications are not set in advance before processing
the parts. 3) The utilization of cleaning machinery generally bases
3.1 Current Situation of Remanufacturing Cleaning on experience rather than systematic knowledge. 4) Various
Technology technologies (e.g. shot basting, wet cleaning) are not tailored to the
Continuous development and improvement are required for needs of remanufacturing and cost drivers. 5) Cleanliness
remanufacturing cleaning technology, cleaning methods as well as measuring systems, methods or equipment is unknown while the
cleaning equipments, which have few ideas to borrow from new need of remanufactured parts is tightening. 6) Remanufacturing
product manufacturing process. Different techniques and methods cleaning is a bottleneck in the material flow. Dirty parts are gathered
depend on different purposes at different stages. Sometimes a to a large size in order to achieve a high operating ratio of the
variety of methods are used simultaneously or successively. The machine. This, however, works against the trend of decreasing
cleaning technologies which are under consideration for batch sizes. High intermediate storages with correspondingly long
remanufacturing cleaning are briefly introduced as follows. lead-times and high cost of inventory are consequences. 7)
Cleaning is the most environmentally unfriendly process in
1. Organic solvent cleaning technology. By means of soaking remanufacturing as many hazardous cleaning agents are used
the core in organic solvent or spraying organic solvent to the during the process.
object, the contaminations can be removed from the core
surface because of dissolution and chemical reaction [4]. 3.2 Development Tendency of Remanufacturing Cleaning
However, there are some issues with this cleaning technology Technology
such as waste liquid, which must be treated in a lifecycle in Cleaning is one of vital process for remanufacturing of mechanical
manufacturing cleaning when environmental factor is taken into equipment parts. It should follow the principle of high efficiency, low-
account. cost, energy efficiency, low-emissions of pollutants (including waste
2. Jet cleaning technology. According to the mediums, this gas, waste liquor and solid wastes). Presently, cleaning agents like
technology includes classified as high-pressure water jet ozone depleting substance (ODS) and chlorofluorocarbon (CFC) are
cleaning [5], abrasive blasting cleaning [6] and dry ice blast widely used in cleaning industry, both of which have been phased
cleaning [7], etc. The grease, rust and other contaminations can out under the Montreal Protocol because of their negative
be removed from the core surface due to the physical interaction environmental effect. Thus, the study of non-ODS cleaning solvents
of the accelerated mediums by compressed air or high pressure is a development tendency of remanufacturing cleaning technology.
water. However, there are some issues with such approach, The selection principle of non-ODS cleaning solvents is listed as
such as waste liquor treatment during the high-pressure water follows: excellent cleaning abilities, appropriate cost performance
jet cleaning, high cost of the dry ice blast cleaning and dust ratio, non-toxic and environmentally friendly. Consequently,
pollution also in the abrasive blasting cleaning. conventional chemical cleaning methods which use hazardous or
banned cleaning agents become unsuitable for remanufacturing
3. Thermal cleaning technology. By use of high temperature or cleaning because of the environmental contamination. By contrast,
hot stream, oil or grease on the core surface will be evaporated physical cleaning methods and the cleaning methods which use
during the cleaning process. Therefore, this cleaning method is environmentally friendly cleaning agents are widely used in virtue of
suitable for hydrocarbon which does not contain chlorine and their unique advantage of less influence on environment.
fluorine, but not applicable for low melting point or flammable
metal parts. Even though, for this time-consuming and energy- In addition, with increasing demands of large-scale and efficient
mechanical equipment remanufacturing, the demand of low-cost
consuming process, a lot of improvements are still needed.
cleaning system in remanufacturing is also increasing. That greatly
4. The Ultrasonic cleaning technology. Ultrasonic cleaning uses accelerates the application of the latest semi-automatic and full
high frequency (usually from 20-400 kHz) sound waves to automatic cleaning equipments, such as cleaning production line
generate agitation in a liquid [8]. Cavitation bubbles induced by and cleaning robots, etc. Another development tendency of
the agitation will act on contaminants adhering to substrates like remanufacturing cleaning technology is the study of composite
metals, plastics, glass, rubber, and ceramics and cause the final cleaning technology or hybrid cleaning system which is higher level
contaminant detachment. However, it is difficult to choose of automation, less cost and less environmental pollution.
proper cleaning parameters for different contaminants process Moreover, to find the best balance between environmental and
because to some extent surface corrosion will be produced once economical requirements is a major issue for remanufacturing
the cleaning parameters are set improperly. Meanwhile, waste cleaning because cleaning process is one of the main pollution
liquor treatment is needed for environmental account. Therefore, sources in remanufacturing. In recent years, the biological
researches about high power, series and high reliability engineering as a kind of environmental friendly technology has
ultrasonic power are required to optimize the cleaning process. become a new trend in cleaning industry. The enzyme cleaning
5. Electrolytic cleaning technology. Electrolytic cleaning is technology, one of the most common biological engineering in
derived from the release of bubbles [9] and it is not suitable for cleaning, might be used for a wide range of remanufacturing
non-ferrous metals such as copper, bronze, brass, pewter, tin or cleaning applications.
Study on Remanufacturing Cleaning Technology in Mechanical Equipment Remanufacturing Process 647
Apart from the cleaning technologies mentioned above which need of remanufacturing with different purposes for the subsequent
to be improved or innovated, cleanliness detection and analysis process as detection, machining or assemble. It can be seen that
technologies for remanufacturing cores are going to require the remanufacturing cleaning changes in each stage of the
improvement and innovation. This includes the reorganization of remanufacturing process for different objectives.
contaminant degree and type before cleaning process, specification
definitions for technical component cleanliness, and measurement 2) Recognize the core contaminant type and its attachment manner,
of the technical component cleanliness and etc. and then choose the appropriate cleaning method and cleaning
agent.
4 PRINCIPLES OF SELECTION 3) According to the material, quantity, geometric dimensions of the
In remanufacturing cleaning process, several factors such as cores to be cleaned, choose the appropriate cleaning method and
maximum cleanliness, quality, time, cost and environmentally cleaning agent. Meanwhile, make the comprehensive evaluation of
friendly requirements should be taken into consideration when the cleaning agent damages to the part surface as well as cleaning
cleaning methods and technological parameters are determined. efficiency and cost.
Generally, for optimizations in practice, the principles of remanu-
facturing cleaning methods selection at each stage are described as 4) According to the environmental requirements, make an evaluation
follow. of energy consumption, discharge of wastes (including waste gas,
1) Identify cleaning purposes and technical cleanliness wastewater, waste oil and solid wastes) and make sure to decrease
requirements. Table 4 represents five cleaning steps in each phase resource consumption and degrade environment pollution.
Pre-cleaning Deposits on the outside of equipments, Convenient for components and Roughly clean.
before such as dust, silt, grease, etc. parts disassemble and preventing
①
disassembly taking the contaminant into the
workshop.
Cleaning for Grease, rust, Carbon sediment, Convenient for detection of Surfaces of the
components residues of lubrication, scale deposit, remanufacturing properties. components and parts
②
and parts after paintings and etc. can be seen clearly.
disassembly
Cleaning before Residues produced during detection. Guarantee the machining quality of Rather clean.
③
reconditioning the remanufactured parts.
Cleaning before Machining residues such as rust, Guarantee the assemble quality of Very clean.
remanufactured cuttings abrasive material, grease, the manufactured parts.
④
parts assemble antirust oil and dust on standard
components and parts.
Cleaning before Grease and slag inclusions on Guarantee the painting protection Very clean.
⑤ remanufactured remanufactured part surface. of the manufactured parts and Nice
parts painting appearance.
Table 4: The cleaning process and requirements of automobile in each stage of remanufacturing process.
cleaning to be more effective, automated and environmental, which [7] Yang, S. C., Huang, K. S., Lin, Y. C. (2007): Optimization of a
also accelerates the establishment of relevant standards such as pulsed carbon dioxide snow jet for cleaning CMOS image
enterprise standard, national standard or international standard. sensors by using the Taguchi method, in: Sensors and
Actuators A: Physical, Vol. 139, No.1-2,pp: 265-271.
6 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS [8] Niemczewski, B. (2007): Observations of water cavitation
intensity under practical ultrasonic cleaning conditions, in:
The authors thank the financial support offered by the national
Ultrasonics Sonochemistry, Vol.14, No.1, pp: 13-18.
program on key basic research project (973 Program) of China
(Granted No.2011CB013402) and the fundamental research funds [9] Cuthberston J.W. (1995): Electrolytic cleaning and polishing,
for the central universities of China (Granted No.DUT11RC(3)80). in: Journal of the Institution of Electrical Engineers, Vol.1,
No.9, pp: 601-602.
7 REFERENCES [10] Takahagi, T., Nagai, I., Ishitani, A., Kuroda, H., Nagasawa, Y.
(1988): The formation of hydrogen passivated silicon
[1] Bernard, S. (2011): Remanufacturing, in: Journal of single‐crystal surfaces using ultraviolet cleaning and HF
Environmental Economics and Management, Vol.62, No.3, pp: etching, in: Journal of Applied Physics, Vol.64, No.7, pp: 3516-
337-351. 3521.
[2] Ijomah, W. L. (2009): Addressing decision making for [11] Kegel, B., Schmid, H. (1999): Low-pressure plasma cleaning
remanufacturing operations and design-for-remanufacture, in: of metallic surfaces on industrial scale, in: Surface and
International Journal of Sustainable Engineering, Vol.2, No.2, Coatings Technology, Vol.112, No.1-3, pp: 63-66.
pp: 91-102. [12] Razek, N., Schindler, A., Rauschenbach, B. (2007): Ultra-high
[3] Nnorom, I. C., Osibanjo, O. (2010): Overview of prospects in vacuum direct bonding of a p–n junction GaAs wafer using
adopting remanufacturing of end-of-life electronic products in low-energy hydrogen ion beam surface cleaning, in: Vacuum,
the developing countries, in: International Journal of Vol.81, No.8, pp: 974-978.
Innovation, Management and Technology, Vol.1, No.3, pp: [13] Ye, Y. Y., Yuan, X. D., Xiang, X., Cheng, X. F., Miao, X. X.
328-338. (2012): Laser cleaning of particle and grease contaminations
[4] Kikuchi, E., Kikuchi, Y., Hirao, M. (2011): Analysis of risk on the surface of optics, in: Optik - International Journal for
trade-off relationships between organic solvents and aqueous Light and Electron Optics, Vol.123, No.12, pp: 1056-1060.
agents: case study of metal cleaning processes, in: Journal of [14] Della, P. G., Volpe, M. C., Reverchon, E. (2006): Supercritical
Cleaner Production, Vol.19, No.5, pp: 414-423. cleaning of rollers for printing and packaging industry, in: The
[5] Guha, A., Barron, R. M., Balachandar, R. (2011): An Journal of Supercritical Fluids, Vol.37, No.3, pp: 409-416.
experimental and numerical study of water jet cleaning [15] Basketter, D., Berg, N., Broekhuizen, C., Fieldsend, M.,
process, in: Journal of Materials Processing Technology, Kirkwood, S., Kluin, C., Mathieu, S., Rodriguez, C. (2012):
Vol.11, No.4, pp: 610-618. Enzymes in cleaning products: An overview of toxicological
[6] Kambham, K., Sangameswaran, S., Datar, S. R., Kura, B. properties and risk assessment/management, in: Regulatory
(2007): Copper slag: optimization of productivity and Toxicology and Pharmacology, Vol.64, No.1, pp: 117-123.
consumption for cleaner production in dry abrasive blasting, in:
Journal of Cleaner Production, Vol.15, No.5, pp: 465-473.