Professional Documents
Culture Documents
7530-Article Text-23248-1-10-20230223
7530-Article Text-23248-1-10-20230223
Rahma Sakina*
rahmasakina06@gamil.com
Masoem University, Sumedang
doi: 10.35706/eltinfc.v5i2.7530
To cite this article: Indrian, S. N. & Sakina, R. (2022). Teaching English speaking using Role-play
technique at a senior high school in Bandung. ELT in Focus, 5(2), 55-66. doi:
10.35706/eltinfc.v5i2.7530
Abstract
The purposes of this study are to: (1) investigate how role-play technique is used in English speaking
class, (2) to find out advantages of using role-play technique in teaching speaking from students’ and
teacher’s perception, and (3) to figure out the difficulties that students and an English teacher
encountered when using role-play technique in the classroom. The method used is qualitative with
observation and interview as data collection techniques. The findings showed that the teacher carried
out role-play technique with several stages such as delivering materials, dividing students into several
groups to make a dialogue, students’ practicing the dialogue in their group, students’ performing the
dialogue in front of the class, and evaluating students’ performance. Role-play technique provided some
advantages. Firstly, it gave students opportunities to practice their speaking ability. Secondly, it
increased students’ confidence to practice speaking in front of the classroom. Then, it improved
students’ interests during the learning process. Fourth, it made students add more English vocabularies.
Finally, students could communicate in English frequently with their friends so they could maintain
their social relation with their peers. When using role-play technique, the students found difficulties
related to pronunciation, word or sentence structure, lack of vocabulary, and memorizing the dialogue.
The teacher found that role-play technique was time consuming, and it was hard to make sure the
suitability of the material to the activities.
55
*Corresponding author
ELT in Focus, Vol. 5(2) December 2022
Copyright © 2022 ELT in Focus
namely speaking. According to Efrizal more choice for the exercise of individual
(2012), speaking is one way to transfer ideas distinction, initiative, imagination, and role
and messages verbally. Brown (2007:4) simulation as well. This means helping
cited in Parmawati (2018) defines speaking students to practice speaking in real-life
as an interactive process of constructing contexts. Of course, physically involving
meaning that involves producing, receiving students in role-playing in class will make
and processing speech of sounds as the main them more effective and build confidence to
instrument. Speaking in English can help be able to perform live. Therefore, it can be
students to express their thoughts and can used as a teaching and learning process
share information with others. It also technique and help students to interact.
becomes an indicator of someone's ability in Therefore, this technique can be an option to
one particular language (Irianti & Muja, be used in learning English.
2017). It can be concluded that speaking is
an important skill used for transferring According to Donn Byrne, there are two
ideas, and it could be an indicator of types of role play, namely scripted role play
someone's ability in one particular language. and unscripted role play. Scripted role play
involves the interpretation of either a
Unfortunately, the ideal conditions textbook dialogue or a reading text in
above are still hampered by a lot of things in spoken form, the main function of the text
many English as a foreign language (EFL) being to convey the meaning of the language
classes, particularly in Indonesia. From in an easy-to-remember manner. The
several observations made in several situation of unscripted play has no different
schools, it is clear that students often feel with the scripted play in any textbook or
less comfortable and less confident to notebook. This role play without script is
participate actively, especially in speaking known as free role play or improv. The
classes. Saurik (2011) identifies that most of students themselves must decide what
students feel shy when they speak English language to use and how the conversation
language because they think they will make should be developed. To carry out this
mistakes when they talk. They are also activity, good preparation of teachers and
afraid of being laughed at by their peers. students is needed.
Meanwhile the expected condition is that
students can participate in English learning There are several previous research
activities without feeling pressured and can findings related to this study, such as Sri
follow them with fun. Of course, in the end Irianti (2011) concluded that role-playing
this became a separate problem among activities can improve students' speaking
English teachers. Therefore, new skills as indicated by the scores they get.
innovations must be made by providing Another previous study was conducted by
more interesting presentation in English Kunto Laksono (2014) and reported the
speaking class, one of which is using role- results of the study showing that the
play technique. application of role-play techniques in the
teaching and learning process of English is
According to Rahman, Yassi, & Arafah effective for improving students' speaking
(2016) "role play permits a lot of students skills. Students can appear more confident.
chance to speak since they are the subject of In addition, their motivation and enthusiasm
learning, through role play students get a lot in learning English also increases. However,
of time to speak". Rahayu (2015) also stated what makes this paper different is the
that role play is a procedure that involves research results, and the research design
students taking on a role and carrying out where the author of this research will
conversations with each person playing their produce a comprehension description of the
part. It is also highly flexible, leaving much
56
ELT in Focus, Vol. 5(2) December 2022
Copyright © 2022 ELT in Focus
57
ELT in Focus, Vol. 5(2) December 2022
Copyright © 2022 ELT in Focus
using role-play technique in teaching Therefore, the teacher didn’t need to re-
speaking based on the perception of explain what and how role-play is. The
students and teacher (3) to figure out the teacher immediately explained the material
difficulties that students and an English briefly and then gives some examples to
teacher encountered when using role-play start the role play activity. Before starting
technique in the classroom. The finding and to create a dialogue, the teacher explained
discussion of the research are explained about the roles that usually appear in
below. conversations with the theme of the
material then invited students to express
their ideas. After that, the teacher discussed
with the students about the topic and started
How role-play technique is used in the discussion by doing brainstorming to
English speaking class get students' ideas related to the
conversation and asking students to write a
The first research question is related to how dialogue together. This activity was carried
role-play technique is carried out by the out about 20 minutes.
teacher in the classroom. This question has
been answered by using data collection The next activity was dividing students
techniques in the form of observation. into several groups of two or three students
Observations are carried out directly in the in which they discussed to make a dialogue
classroom to see the teaching and learning related to the topic. The teacher gave 20
process using role-play technique, student minutes for each group to make the
attitudes, and how students speak in groups. dialogue. During the discussion of
Before the teacher started speaking learning dialogue, the teacher went around the class
activities using role-play technique in the from one pair to another to check students’
classroom, she gave a presentation of involvement. According to Lyman Nurhadi
material to students. Djamarah (Pane, (2005: 120), it is in accordance with the
2017:343) revealed that learning material is class situation where the teacher goes
the substance that will be delivered in the around seeing student discussions in groups
teaching and learning process. Without to make sure all students are involved in
learning materials, the teaching and making the dialogue text. Next, the teacher
learning process will not occur. Therefore, gave instructions to memorize the dialogue
the teacher must have and master the for approximately 40 minutes and when
subject matter that will be delivered to they are ready, they will perform it in front
students. The material discussed at this of the class.
meeting is about "What Are You Going to
Do Today". The delivery of the material The third activity was practicing the
will be carried out by the teacher using the dialogue in their group. After all groups
role-play activity in the classroom. were ready to perform, the teacher invited
the group to perform in front of the class. In
Role-play technique is considered order to create the conducive atmosphere in
suitable because it is in accordance with the class the teacher asked each group to
one of the learning competencies that must pay attention and gave comments to the
be achieved by students, namely students group that performed in front of the class.
able to create short and simple oral and Suharsimi Arikunto (1988: 67) argues that
written interaction texts that involve the act classroom management is an effort carried
of giving and asking for information by out by the person in charge of teaching and
paying attention to social functions, text learning activities or assisting with the aim
structure, and correct linguistic elements of achieving optimal conditions.
context. Role-play technique had been
carried out by students in the last meetings.
58
ELT in Focus, Vol. 5(2) December 2022
Copyright © 2022 ELT in Focus
The final step is the teacher's perception of students and teachers. This
evaluation about the performance of each question has been answered by conducting
role-play group. According to Pane interviews to students and an English
(2017:350) learning evaluation serves to teacher. The students who were interviewed
see the success of students in learning, but were two low achiever students and two
also serves as teacher feedback on the high achiever students. The categories of
performance they have done in the learning low and high achiever students is got from
process. This is also done by the teacher, the evaluation of students’ performance
namely conducting evaluation activities. before.
The activity is carried out in the last 10
minutes at the end of the learning activity. Based on the interview, there are
The activities and steps in all meetings were several advantages that students get from
not much different. What distinguishes was using role-play technique in learning
the material that was delivered. In speaking. First, role-play technique gives
conclusion, the role-play technique carried students more opportunities to participate
out by the teacher in teaching speaking actively in the classroom so that their
included delivering materials by the motivation is also increased. This finding is
teacher, dividing students into several stated by the teacher as follow:
groups and they discussed to make a
dialogue with their group member, Excerpt 1:
59
ELT in Focus, Vol. 5(2) December 2022
Copyright © 2022 ELT in Focus
60
ELT in Focus, Vol. 5(2) December 2022
Copyright © 2022 ELT in Focus
61
ELT in Focus, Vol. 5(2) December 2022
Copyright © 2022 ELT in Focus
62
ELT in Focus, Vol. 5(2) December 2022
Copyright © 2022 ELT in Focus
63
ELT in Focus, Vol. 5(2) December 2022
Copyright © 2022 ELT in Focus
written interaction texts that had to class, one of which is role-play technique.
involve action. So, I think this role This study aims at investigating how role-
activity is appropriate. It's good for play technique is used in English speaking
the material to be studied with the class, finding out advantages of using role-
competencies that students must play technique in teaching speaking based
achieve, maybe like that."
on the perception of students and teacher,
From the statement above, the and figuring out the difficulties that
second difficulty that the teacher felt was students and an English teacher
related to the suitability of the material, the encountered when using role-play
competencies to be achieved, and the use technique in the classroom.
of appropriate technique. According to
Based on the findings, the role-play
Hamzah (2008: 26-28), not all subject
technique carried out by the teacher in
matter can be presented through role play
teaching speaking included several stages
technique. Thus, it is clear that not all
such as delivering materials, dividing
learning activities can use the role play
students into several groups to make a
activity.
dialogue, students’ practicing the dialogue
Based on the explanation above, it can in their group, students’ performing the
be concluded that students encountered dialogue in front of the class, and
some difficulties when they learn speaking evaluating students’ performance.
using role-play technique. The first
In terms of the advantages of using
difficulty is about the pronunciation and
role-play technique, the findings showed
word or sentence structure. Secondly, it is
that it serves a lot of advantages. First, it
related to students’ lack of vocabulary.
gives more opportunities for students to
Finally, students found difficulty in
practice their speaking ability. Second, it
memorizing English texts. In addition, the
increases students’ confidence to practice
teacher found two difficulties during
speaking in front of the classroom. Then, it
teaching speaking using role-play
improves students’ interests during the
technique. First, teaching speaking with
learning process. Fourth, it gives students
role-play technique requires a lot of time.
opportunities to add more vocabularies in
There are many steps that must be carried
English. Finally, students can communicate
out starting from making dialogue texts,
in English with their friends more often, so
understanding content, memorizing texts,
that they can maintain their social relation
performing the dialogue, and evaluating
with their peers.
students’ performance with limited time.
The second difficult faced by the teacher is When using role-play technique, both
that the suitability of the material to the teacher and students encountered some
activity that will be used because not all difficulties. The students found difficulties
speaking learning activities can use role related to pronunciation, word or sentence
play. structure, lack of vocabulary, and in
memorizing the dialogue. Meanwhile, for
CONCLUSION
the teacher the difficulties are that teaching
Speaking is one of important skills that speaking with role-play technique needs a
should be mastered by students to be used lot of time and it is hard to make sure the
for transferring ideas. Unfortunately, some suitability of the material to the activity that
students feel less comfortable and confident will be used in role-play technique. The
to participate actively in speaking classes. results of this study are expected to show
Therefore, a certain technique is needed to better utilization of role-play activities in
encourage students’ participation in the
64
ELT in Focus, Vol. 5(2) December 2022
Copyright © 2022 ELT in Focus
65
ELT in Focus, Vol. 5(2) December 2022
Copyright © 2022 ELT in Focus
Nuranda Isnaini. (2018). The Use of Role Wardani Richa Kusuma, Yesi Elfisa M.Pd
Play Technique to Improve Speaking & Diyan Andriani (2020). An
Ability at Grade X of Senior High Analysis Speaking Ability of Using
School. Journal of English Language Asking and Giving at Eight Grade of
and Language Teaching (JELLT), SMPN 22 Merangin Academic Year
Vol.2, No.1, 2018. 1-6. 2019/2020. English Education
Program Journal, Volume 2 Edition 2
Osuafor, A. M. (n.d.). ROLE – PLAY: An November 2020
Effective Strategy for Teaching and
Learning of Basic Science in Primary Yanto Ari. (2015). Metode Bermain Peran
Schools. (Role Play) untuk meningkatkan
Hasil Belajar Siswa Pada Mata
Paul Rowan, “Building Speaking Skill by Pelajaran IPS. Jurnal Cakrawala
Creating ‘Old the Radio’ show”, the Pendas, Volume I, No. 1 Januari 2015
Internet TEFLS, Journal, vol, VIII, no
1 (January 2007),
https://iteslj.org/Techniques/Rowan-
RadioShow.html (Accessed on 11
July, 2018)
66