Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Antioxidants Diabetic Neuropathy
Antioxidants Diabetic Neuropathy
T
Antioxidant enzymes are reduced in peripheral nerves he twin problems of chronic hyperglycemia and
and are further reduced in diabetic nerves. That lipid endoneurial hypoxia result in excessive oxidative
peroxidation will cause neuropathy is supported by evi- stress (1), which may be important in the patho-
dence of the development of neuropathy de novo when genesis of diabetic neuropathy. If this is so, antiox-
normal nerves are rendered et-tocopherol deficient and
by the augmentation of the conduction deficit in dia- idants could be particularly important in the prevention and
betic nerves subjected to this insult. Oxidative stress treatment of diabetic neuropathy.
appears to be primarily due to the processes of nerve This discussion will be focused on answering the follow-
ischemia and hyperglycemia auto-oxidation. The ing five questions: 1) What are the free radical defenses of
indexes of oxidative stress include an increase in nerve? 2) Is there increased oxidative stress in experimental
nerve, dorsal root, and sympathetic ganglia lipid diabetic neuropathy? 3) What are the best indexes of
hydroperoxides and conjugated dienes. The most reli- increased lipid peroxidation in nerves? 4) Does lipid perox-
able and sensitive index, however, is a reduction in idation cause neuropathy? 5) Do antioxidants work?
reduced glutathione. Experimental diabetic neuropathy
results in myelinopathy of dorsal roots and a vacuolar FREE RADICAL DEFENSES
neuropathy of dorsal root ganglion. The vacuoles are
mitochondrial; we posit that lipid peroxidation causes Peripheral nerves have a number of cytosolic and lipophilic
mitochondrial DNA mutations that increase reduced antioxidants, which are often subdivided into preventive and
oxygen species, causing further damage to mitochon- chain-breaking antioxidants (2). Preventive antioxidants
drial respiratory chain and function and resulting in a block chain initiation. Chain-breaking antioxidants suppress
sensory neuropathy, a-lipoic acid is a potent antioxidant free radical chain oxidation by molecular oxygen and com-
that prevents lipid peroxidation in vitro and in vivo. We prise water-soluble and lipid-soluble antioxidants. The key
evaluated the efficacy of the drug in doses of 20, 50, and enzymatic scavengers are superoxide dismutase (SOD), cata-
100 mg/kg administered intraperitoneally in preventing lase, glutathione peroxidase, and glutathione reductase (2).
the biochemical, electrophysiological, and nerve blood
flow deficits in the peripheral nerves of experimental Reduced glutathione (GSH) is particularly important in mem-
diabetic neuropathy, a-lipoic acid dose- and time- brane because it is the main scavenger in the blocking of chain
dependently prevented the deficits in nerve conduc- propagation (2). The cytosolic and membrane antioxidants
tion and nerve blood flow and biochemical abnormali- work in concert in a well-organized, interacting chain. Ample
ties (reductions in reduced glutathione and lipid per- activity of all components is needed to maintain these antiox-
oxidation). The nerve blood flow deficit was 50% (P < idants in their reduced state (3). There is much literature on
0.001). Supplementation dose-dependently prevented free radical biology, but information on peripheral nerves, and
the deficit; at the highest concentration, nerve blood in particular diabetic peripheral nerves, is quite limited.
flow was not different from that of control nerves. Dig- Of great interest is the marked and selective reduction in
ital nerve conduction underwent a dose-dependent
improvement at 1 month (P < 0.05). By 3 months, all antioxidant defenses in rat sciatic nerve. GSH and GSH-con-
treated groups had lost their deficit. The antioxidant taining enzymes scavengers (glutathione peroxidase and
drug is potentially efficacious for human diabetic sen- reductase) in rodent sciatic nerve are only about 10% that of
sory neuropathy. Diabetes 46 (Suppl. 2):S38-S42, 1997 the brain, whereas the activities of other enzymes, such as
SOD, are approximately the same in brain and nerve (4). The
diabetic state results in a reduction in both SOD and glu-
tathione peroxidase. Cuprozinc SOD is reduced, and this
reduction is improved by insulin treatment (5). The very low
activity of nerve glutathione peroxidase is further reduced in
From the Department of Neurology (P.A.L., K.K.N.), Mayo Clinic and Mayo experimental diabetic neuropathy (6). Plasma and leukocyte
Foundation, Rochester, Minnesota; and Asta Medica (H.J.T.), Frankfurt, Ger- ascorbic acid are reduced, and oxidation of this antioxidant
many. is increased (7,8).
Address correspondence and reprint requests to Dr. Phillip A. Low,
Department of Neurology, Mayo Clinic and Mayo Foundation, Rochester, MN
55905. OXIDATIVE STRESS IN EXPERIMENTAL DIABETIC
Accepted for publication 19 December 1996. NEUROPATHY
GSH, reduced glutathione; SOD, superoxide dismutase.
Nothing in this publication is meant to imply that the Mayo Foundation There are a number of potential sources of free radical gen-
endorses the products of ASTA Medica. eration in diabetes: 1) ischemia, 2) hyperglycemia by autox-
S38 DIABETES, VOL. 46, SUPPL. 2, SEPTEMBER 1997
P.A. LOW, K.K. NICKANDER, AND H.J. TRITSCHLER
idative peroxidation, 3) increased mitochondrial leak, 4) cat- other than nerve (e.g., 1,5,21-23). Evidence of increased
echolamine oxidation, and 5) leukocytes. Most of the nerve lipid peroxidation in vivo is now available. Diabetic
research to date has been concentrated on the roles of peripheral nerves have increased conjugated dienes (5,25),
ischemia and hyperglycemia. The concept of increased mito- reduced GSH (25), and reduced glutathione peroxidase (6).
chondrial leak is discussed briefly in the context of our Among the indexes of increased oxidative stress in a chronic
recent findings involving the pathology of vacuolar degener- in vivo situation, malondialdehyde, conjugated dienes, and
ation of dorsal root ganglion neurons. lipid hydroperoxides are increased in the peripheral nerves
in experimental diabetic neuropathy (5,25,26), and the
ISCHEMIA increase is more consistent in lumbar dorsal root and supe-
The suggested pathogenetic scheme has been previously rior cervical ganglia (25,26). The most reliable index of
described (1,9,10). Diabetic neuropathy is a metabolic dis- increased oxidative stress is reduction in GSH (25,26).
order in which the brunt of the insult is borne by the We argued that to demonstrate that oxidative stress causes
microvessels; the endothelial cell is perceived as being a neuropathy, it is necessary to satisfy the following four cri-
dynamic tissue responding to perturbations in nitric oxide, teria: 2) that an increase in lipid peroxidation in previously
endoneurial eicosanoids, advanced glycation end products, normal nerves results in neuropathy; 2) that an increase in
oxidative stress, growth factors, and neurotransmitters/neu- lipid peroxidation in diabetic neuropathic nerves further
romodulators. Endoneurial hypoxia is secondary to a reduc- worsens function; 3) that antioxidant therapy improves or
tion in nerve blood flow and increased endoneurial vascular prevents neuropathy; and 4) that this improvement or pre-
resistance (9,11), which begins by the 1st week of diabetes vention is associated with a reduction or improvement in
(12) and affects the cell body as well as the axon (13). The sug- the indexes of lipid peroxidation of peripheral nerve.
gested scheme can be briefly summarized. The major meta- To approach the first question of whether increased oxida-
bolic effect of hyperglycemia in chronic progressive diabetic tive stress causes neuropathy in previously normal nerves, we
neuropathy is suggested to be on microvessels. Hyper- undertook the experimental depletion of tissue a-tocopherol
glycemia acts via rheological mechanisms, advanced glyca- in previously normal nerves (25). Weaned rats were fed an a-
tion end products (14,15), and a reduction in nitric oxide tocopherol-deficient diet. Plasma a-tocopherol became
(16), resulting in impaired microvascular tone and reduced immeasurable. Endoneurial lipid peroxidation resulted, as
nerve blood flow and endoneurial hypoxia. A vicious cycle indicated by a reduction in GSH and increased conjugated
supervenes in which a reduction in nitric oxide and certain dienes and lipid hydroperoxides. These findings were associ-
eicosanoids (especially a reduction in the prostaglandin: ated with the development of a sensory neuropathy in previ-
thromboxane Ag ratio) (17), leukotrienes, advanced glycation ously normal nerves (25). A second line of evidence derives
end products, and oxygen free radicals and continued rheo- from the worsening of neuropathy in experimental diabetic neu-
logical mechanisms are important. Insulin per se may also ropathy (25) associated with an increase in lipid peroxidation.
have an atherogenic role (1,18). The progressive microvas-
cular and macrovascular pathology is suggested to result in LEUKOCYTES AND CATECHOLAMINE OXIDATION
the nerve-fiber pathology of multifocal fiber loss. The roles of the leukocyte and catecholamine oxidation is
The effects of oxidative stress depend on balancing oxida- uncertain. Leukocytic infiltration is not a feature in most
tive stress, pro-oxidant status, and free radical defenses (19). cases of diabetic neuropathy. In human diabetic neuropathy,
Changes in all three areas occur in diabetic peripheral there are some indications of an immune-mediated process,
nerves. Diabetic pro-oxidant status is increased, since diabetic as suggested by the presence of iritis and inflammatory infil-
sciatic nerve has increased polyunsaturated fatty acids with trates in sympathetic ganglia (27-29). Some forms of dia-
excessive lipolysis (20). It has also been suggested that met- betic neuropathy, such as acute autonomic neuropathy and
als, especially copper, might be increased (21,22). the subacute proximal neuropathies, might be associated
with round cell infiltration (30).
HYPERGLYCEMIA GLYCATION/OXIDATION
Chronic hyperglycemia per se results in autoxidative glyca- ROLE OF MITOCHONDRIAL LEAK
tion/oxidation and lipid peroxidation (21-23). Hyper- We have completed a study on the neuropathology of chronic
glycemia results in increased arachidonic acid flux and mal- (12-18 months) experimental diabetic neuropathy (13).
ondialdehyde formation. We have recently demonstrated Changes are most prominent in the nerve roots and lumbar
that hyperglycemia per se will cause lipid peroxidation of dorsal root ganglion. The changes in ventral root seem to be
peripheral nerve in vitro (24). We undertook studies of in vitro an exaggeration of the aging process causing a vesicular
lipid peroxidation of brain and sciatic nerve using an in vitro myelinopathy. There are more pronounced changes, how-
lipid peroxidation model with an ascorbate-iron-EDTA sys- ever, in the dorsal root ganglion and dorsal root. The dorsal
tem. When we used an incubation medium containing 20 root shows myelinopathy, and the dorsal root ganglion
mmol/1 glucose, lipid peroxidation increased fourfold, indi- shows pronounced vacuolar degeneration of dorsal root gan-
cating that hyperglycemia causes rapid and marked lipid glion cells. The vacuoles are almost entirely degenerating
peroxidation (24). mitochondria (Fig. 1) associated with excessive lipofuscin
deposition.
LIPID PEROXIDATION AND NEUROPATHY The vacuoles observed in our study may be related to dys-
Oxidative stress is part of the price mammals pay for breath- functional mitochondria (31). Oxidative stress has been sug-
ing oxygen. There is good evidence that oxidative stress is gested to be a major pathogenetic mechanism of aging, and
increased in the diabetic state. Most studies in human and the mitochondrion is a selective focus of its action (32,33).
experimental diabetes have been done on plasma or tissue Mitochondrial DNA is unusually susceptible to oxidative
DIABETES, VOL. 46, SUPPL. 2, SEPTEMBER 1997 S39
OXIDATIVE STRESS AND ANTIOXIDANTS IN NEUROPATHY
minor improvement.
One percent butylated hydroxytoluene for 2 months com- Con Con50 STZ STZ20 STZ50 STZ100
pletely prevented the conduction deficit in experimental dia-
betic neuropathy (38). Carvidilol, an antioxidant and
P<0.05
vasodilator, is reported to be efficacious (39). Cameron and r25
Cotter (40) have reported improvement in both nerve blood
flow and nerve conduction in experimental diabetic neu- Nerve
ropathy following treatment with the iron chelator desfer- vascular
resistance
roximine. (mm Hg/mL/100 g/min)
While these important studies in experimental diabetic
neuropathy have shown improvement of the electrophysio- Con Con50 STZ STZ20 STZ50 STZ100 CA-H
logical deficit following treatment with antioxidants, in none
of these studies were measurements of lipid peroxidation FIG. 2. Nerve blood flow and nerve vascular resistance of control
done, so it is not known if these agents actually reduced (Con), streptozotocin-diabetic neuropathy (STZ), and animals sup-
neural lipid peroxidation. Some of these antioxidants have a plemented with lipoic acid at doses of 20 mg/kg (STZ20), 50 mg/kg
(Con50; STZ50), and 100 mg/kg (STZ100). Lipoic acid supplementation
number of non-antioxidant actions that could also affect results in normal nerve blood flow and nerve vascular resistance.
peripheral nerve function. From Nagamatsu et al. (26).
I 8H T T
2
Q.
a
T T T FIG. 3. Sciatic nerve GSH concentrations
"5 in controls (Con) and on restricted
caloric intake (Con[R])( streptozotocin-
I »H diabetic (STZ), a-tocopherol-depleted (-)
and supplemented with lipoic acid at 20
X
mg/kg, 50 mg/kg, and 100 mg/kg. Lipoic
U) acid supplementation resulted in a dose-
Con Con[R] ConlOO Con[-] Con[-]100 STZ STZ20 STZ50 STZ100 dependent prevention of GSH.
exogenous insulin on normal and diabetic peripheral nerve. Am J Physiol 33. Wilson PD, Franks LM: The effect of age on mitochondrial ultrastructure and
266:E980-E985, 1994 enzymes. Adv Exp Med Biol 53:171-183, 1975
19. Halliwell B, Gutteridge JM: Free Radicals in Biology and Medicine. Oxford, 34. Kalyanaraman B, Darley-Usmar VM, Wood J, Joseph J, Parthasarathy S: Syn-
Clarendon Press, 1985 ergistic interaction between the probucol phenoxyl radical and ascorbic acid
20. Yao JK, Low PA: Improvement of endoneurial lipid abnormalities in experi- in inhibiting the oxidation of low density lipoprotein. J Biol Chem
mental diabetic neuropathy by oxygen modification. Brain Res 362:362-365, 267:6789-6795, 1992
1986 35. Cameron NE, Cotter MA, Archibald V, Dines KC, Maxfield EK: Anti-oxidant
21. Wolff SP: Diabetes mellitus and free radicals. Br Med Bull 49:642-652, 1993 and pro-oxidant effects on nerve conduction velocity, endoneurial blood flow
22. Wolff SP, Jiang ZY, Hunt JV: Protein glycation and oxidative stress in diabetes and oxygen tension in non-diabetic and streptozotocin-diabetic rats. Dia-
mellitus and ageing. Free Radic Biol Med 10:339-352, 1991 betologia 37:449-159, 1994
23. Baynes JW: Role of oxidative stress in the development of complications in 36. Karasu C, Dewhurst M, Stevens EJ, Tomlinson DR: Effects of anti-oxidant treat-
diabetes. Diabetes 40:405-^12,1991 ment on sciatic nerve dysfunction in streptozotocin-diabetic rats; comparison
24. Nickander KK, Low PA, Tritschler H-J: a-Lipoic acid: antioxidant potency with essential fatty acids. Diabetologia 38:129-134,1995
against lipid peroxidation of neural tissues in vitro, and implications for dia- 37. Bravenboer B, Kappelle AC, Hamers FPT, van Buren T, Erkelens DW, Gispen
betic neuropathy. Free Radic Biol Med 21:631-639,1996 WH: Potential use of glutathione for the prevention and treatment of diabetic
25. Nickander KK, Schmelzer JD, Rohwer DA, Low PA: Effect of a-tocopherol defi- neuropathy in the streptozotocin-induced diabetic rat. Diabetologia
ciency on indices of oxidative stress in normal and diabetic peripheral nerve. 35:813-817,1992
JNeurolSci 126:6-14,1994 38. Cameron NE, Cotter MA, Maxfield EK: Anti-oxidant treatment prevents the
26. Nagamatsu M, Nickander KK, Schmelzer JD, Raya A, Wittrock DA, Tritschler development of peripheral nerve dysfunction in streptozotocin-diabetic rats.
H, Low PA: Lipoic acid improves nerve bloodflow,reduces oxidative stress, Diabetologia 36:299-304, 1993
and improves distal nerve conduction in experimental diabetic neuropathy. 39. Cotter MA, Cameron NE: Neuroprotective effects of carvedilol in diabetic rats:
Diabetes Care 18:1160-1167, 1995 prevention of defective peripheral nerve perfusion and conduction velocity.
27. Duchen LW, Anjorin A, Watkins PJ, Mackay JD: Pathology of autonomic neu- Naunyn Schmiedebergs Arch Pharmacol 351:630-635, 1995
ropathy in diabetes mellitus. Ann Intern Med 92:301-303, 1980 40. Cameron NE, Cotter MA: Neurovascular dysfunction in diabetic rats: poten-
28. Gilbey SG, Hussain MJ, Watkins PJ, Vergani D: Cell-mediated immunity and tial contribution of autoxidation and free radicals examined using transition
symptomatic diabetic autonomic neuropathy. Diabetic Med 5:845-848,1988 metal chelating agents. J Clin Invest 96:1159-1163,1995
29. Guy RJ, Richards F, Edmonds ME, Watkins PJ: Diabetic autonomic neuropa- 41. Busse E, Zimmer G, Schopohl B, Kornhuber B: Influence of a-lipoic acid on
thy and iritis: an association suggesting an immunological cause. Br Med J intracellular glutathione in vitro and in vivo. Arzneimittelforschung
289:343-345, 1984 42:829-831,1992
30. Low PA, Pascoe M, Windebank AJ, Litchy WJ: Subacute diabetic proximal 42. Murase K, Hattori A, Kohno M, Hayashi K: Stimulation of nerve growth fac-
motor neuropathy (Abstract). Neurology 46:A447, 1996 tor synthesis/secretion in mouse astroglial cells by coenzymes. Biochem Mol
31. Shigenaga MK, Hagen TM, Ames BN: Oxidative damage and mitochondrial Biol Int 30:615-621, 1993
decay in aging. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 91:10771-10778, 1994 43. Dimpfel W, Spuler M, Pierau F-K, Ulrich H: Thioctic acid induces dose-depen-
32. Richter C, Park JW, Ames BN: Normal oxidative damage to mitochondrial and dent sprouting of neurites in cultured rat neuroblastoma cells. Dev Pharma-
nuclear DNA is extensive. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 85:6465-6467, 1988 col Ther 14:193-199, 1990