Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Writer - April 2023
The Writer - April 2023
Plus!
20 20
To the future
and beyond
Fidelity to science,
technology, and certain
conventions will make
your sci-fi stories fly.
By Kerrie Flanagan
26
Circle of poets
Community, support,
accountability, and high-
quality work: These are
some of the benefits of
being in a good poetry
group. Here’s how to
go about finding the
right group for you –
or starting your own.
By Deborah Straw
32
True stories
Why dramatic technique is
not enough to write great
creative nonfiction: You
need an unwavering blend 3 Prologue 38
of hard-won facts and the 4 Editor’s Letter
drive to find them. 5 The Write Stuff
By T.J. Murphy 6 Writing Essentials
8 Contest Winner
38 11 Broadening the
Bookshelves
Advice from Getting to know
the frontlines Jewish literature.
COVER: TITHI LUADTHONG/SHUTTERSTOCK
WRITERMAG.COM 1
T.J. Murphy, Editor;
Toni Fitzgerald, Copy Editor
Operations
Laura Randall, Operations Coordinator; Tou Zong Her, Client Services Manager & Media
Analyst; Andrea Palli, Senior Client Services & Operations Lead; Darren Cormier, Client
Services Associate; Amanda Joyce, Controller; Tina McDermott, Accounts Payable Associate;
Wayne Tuggle, Accounts Receivable Associate
Digital Operations
Mike Decker, Senior Digital Designer; David Glassman, WordPress Developer
Executive
Jeffrey C. Wolk, Chairman & Chief Executive Officer;
Courtney Whitaker, Chief Operating Officer; Jason Pomerantz, Vice President, Consumer
Marketing; Matt Martinelli, Vice President, Content
Newsstand Distribution
Weekly Retail Service
To sell The Writer magazine in your store: Contact KPS
Phone: 888-999-9839; Email: RetailServices@kable.com
Submissions
Read our submission guidelines: writermag.com/the-magazine/submission-guidelines
Please include your name, mailing and email addresses, and telephone number with any correspondence. Return postage must
accompany all manuscripts, drawings, and photographs submitted if they are to be returned, and no responsibility can be
assumed for unsolicited materials. All rights in letters sent to The Writer will be treated as unconditionally assigned for
publication and copyright purposes and as subject to unrestricted right to edit and to comment editorially.
The Writer (ISSN 0043-9517) is published monthly by Madavor Media, LLC, 35 Braintree Hill Office Park, Suite 101,
Braintree, MA 02184. Periodicals postage paid at Boston, MA and at additional mailing offices. Postmaster: Please send
changes of address to The Writer, P.O. Box 460700, Escondido, CA 92046.
The title The Writer is registered in the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office. Contents copyright © 2023 by Madavor Media,
LLC. All rights reserved. Contact our official partner, Wright’s Media, about available usages, license fees, and award seal art-
work at madavormedia@wrightsmedia.com.
Contact us:
The Writer, Madavor Media, LLC
35 Braintree Hill Office Park, Suite 101, Braintree, MA 02184
WRITERMAG.COM 3
Prologue » Editor’s Letter
No fear
I FIRST THOUGHT ABOUT WRITING
a novel back in high school. It’s decades
later, and although I’ve written plenty
of nonfiction in my career as a mag-
azine editor, I haven’t written a single
paragraph of a novel.
If you and I, fellow writers, were
having coffee or a beer together, I’d re-
veal why. Fear.
Like Frank Herbert wrote in Dune:
“Fear is the little-death that brings total
obliteration.”
I’ve let fear obliterate any action on
my part to write a novel. Obliterate
might not be the right word. The image
that comes to mind is being bound in a
straitjacket.
Not long ago, I gained some insight
into this problem when I interviewed
Eric Potterat, Ph.D., for a magazine ar-
ticle. Dr. Potterat is a clinical psycholo-
gist who specializes in performance.
“It’s a threat mindset,” Potterat de-
clared, explaining fears that stall or kill mindset typically creeps into life when is a challenge, and it isn’t a threat, and
action. “A threat mindset occurs when we’re past the age of 5. I want to go beyond my comfort zone
we face obstacles and barriers, whether “When kids get socialized, they just a little bit. So I’ll think of each ap-
they’re real or imagined.” tend to vector into a threat mindset,” proaching obstacle as a challenge – and
A threat mindset, he added, can pro- Potterat said. “But before this socializa- an opportunity to get out of my com-
duce fears with varying levels of intensity. tion process, the challenge mindset is fort zone and see what I can do.’”
“Those of us who are really going to natural to them.” He paused, then added: “That’s it.”
have a hard time with a threat mindset Weirdly enough, I am given an ex- That’s it! I’m in. Time to get out of
are those who perceive an obstacle or ample in real time – thank you, uni- my comfort zone and write a first novel.
adversity as a threat to their reputation. verse! – while writing this column from And I could use some help: If you’d like
They don’t want to take risks because the observation deck of a kids’ gymnas- to join forces with me and go beyond
they’re worried about their ego.” tics program. My daughter, Maddie, your writing comfort zone this year –
“No kidding?” I replied, knowing he who is 5, just launched into a hand- whether it’s a novel, a play, a memoir,
just diagnosed me. stand, propped upside-down against a an essay – send me an email, and we’ll
A threat mindset’s opposite, Potter- cushioned wall. She’s amidst dozens of start our own online support and ac-
at said, is the challenge mindset. other kids, her coaches, and a bunch of countability group. We’ll get some
“A challenge mindset is like, ‘Hey, gawking parents pressed up against a work done and have some fun doing it.
I just want to do this new thing. It’s a big window. She had no fear at all. All
QUIETBITS / SHUTTERSTOCK.COM
4 APRIL 2023
» The Write Stuff
Charlotte
Brontë 1
2
3. Pajama Set
For lounging or sleeping,
pre-shrunk 100-percent
cotton literary pajamas.
$46.79, cafepress.com
4. Blanket of Words
For your bed, your couch, or you,
a throw blanket designed with a
book cover.
$61.45, redbubble.com
5. Cocktail Glasses
Perfect for a toast to the
completion of a writing project.
A set of two 11-ounce glasses. 5
6
One includes text from Jane Eyre,
the second (bonus!) text from Jane
Austen’s Pride and Prejudice.
$30, uncommongoods.com
6. Writing Gloves
Fingerless gloves to keep your
arms warm (and inspiring)
while you write.
$29, etsy.com
WRITERMAG.COM 5
Prologue » Writing Essentials
Flash Characterizations
Excerpted from his new book, The Art of Brevity,
NaNoWriMo’s Grant Faulkner shows you how to push your
characters to the hilt when you’re writing flash fiction.
By Grant Faulkner
“I love the idea that every character the more you’ve conjured into the story.
you ever write has a secret they’re In flash fiction, we see characters only
whispering to you. Sometimes those in “fleeting profile,” according to Irving
secrets are revealed to the reader.” Howe. We likely won’t know where
—Sherrie Flick they were born, if they went to college,
or whatever neurosis they might have
developed due to a childhood trauma
CHARACTERIZATION PRESENTS A because we know them only in the sei-
challenge in writing flash fiction, es- zure of a moment, not in a dramatically emotions – perhaps one, such as happy
pecially if you’re the sort of writer who arching plot line. We hear a line of their or sad – and they are not in psychologi-
likes to delve into a character’s back- flute solo but not the orchestra they cal conflict.” Fairy tale characters break
ground, assemble lists of character play in. Forster’s rule of round characters, but
traits, and put your character through It’s important to realize that a char- this flatness is desirable, Bernheimer
personality tests. E. M. Forster laid out acter doesn’t have to necessarily be a says, because it “allows depth of re-
the conventional ground rules for such simulation of a person in real life in sponse in the reader.”
characterization in his famous book As- flash fiction – they just have to suggest National Book Award finalist Car-
pects of the Novel. “Round characters” a full person through hints and the men Maria Machado notes how flash
are fully dimensional, nuanced, and ca- most telling of details. The Unbearable fiction borrows from this style of
pable of surprise, he said, whereas “flat Lightness of Being author Milan Kunde- characterization. “It is, by definition,
characters” are two-dimensional and ra says a character need only to fill “the short; it leaves things out, it relies on
relatively uncomplicated. whole space of the situation” and in the inference. It doesn’t necessarily have
“Round characters” are deemed nec- case of flash fiction, that situation is a psychological flatness, per se – though
essary in a novel, in particular, because situation within a situation, you might it can look like that, sometimes, de-
the reader wants to have the full sense say – the situation can be a single mo- pending on the story – but possesses
of a character, to know their inner and ment, a single burst. Instead of thinking missing details (the right missing de-
outer lives. Our general reverence for about characterization through con- tails) and flatness (the right kind of
psychological realism in fiction plac- ventional window dressing, we need to flatness) that creates a vacuum that
es a heavy burden on characterization. only think about getting to the bottom begs to be filled.”
A writer tends to be expected to give of a character’s existential crux, in other Still, while flat descriptors might
a maximum amount of information words. To their essence. work for some pieces, other pieces need
about a character – showing how the In fact, flash characters can even ex- more illustration and “roundness” to
character walks and talks and how the ist more toward the flatter end of For- work. One way to get to the heart of a
past contains the motives for all pres- ster’s characterization spectrum. In her quick, telling characterization is to con-
ent-day behavior. essay “Fairy Tale is Form, Form is Fairy sider what is different about your char-
Because of the condensed space of Tale,” Kate Bernheimer talks about the acter and how that difference is crucial
flash fiction, though, the idea of a fully function of “flatness” in the tradition- to the storyline (it’s best not to expand
rounded character is not viable. A de- al fairy tale. “Fairy-tale characters are into anything extraneous just for the
tailed backstory is an anathema to flash silhouettes, mentioned simply because sake of characterization). Instead of go-
because you’ll be tempted to stuff all of they are there. They are not given many ing for the surface description of telling
6 APRIL 2023
what the character looks like or how vital character trait to tell the story 1) It serves as practice for capturing a
the character walks, find that piercing, you’re writing? character through dramatic traits, and
revealing detail that tells the essence of 2) It helps you work at building a story
their character. Flashpoint: You’re the kind through character details.
We all feel singular in some way. I’ll of person who . . . So, think of a character. Brainstorm
venture to say that we all feel apart to I once listened to an episode of the some character traits. Push them to the
varying degrees, no matter how much WTF podcast with Marc Maron, and hilt. Write seven sentences, each one
we might try to belong. So if you’re when his guest, David Cross, came on, beginning with, “She/He/They is the
writing the story about a vampire, what he started giving Maron a hard time by kind of person who _____.” See if each
is it that makes your vampire differ- building a farcical and damning char- character trait can surprise in some
ent from other vampires (and differ- acterization of Maron by riffing on way. You’ll not only end up with sev-
ent from vampire stereotypes)? How the phrase, “You’re the kind of person en piercing character observations, but
does your vampire want to belong (or who _____.” He repeated the phrase, you might also end up with a story if
not belong)? Perhaps your vampire each time filling in the blank with a each line escalates to the next, building
bites their fingernails. Or perhaps your damning characterization that made a narrative.
vampire mumbles and slumps their Maron seem more and more pathet-
shoulders. Cutting against the grain of ic and questionable (humorously so). Grant Faulkner is the executive di-
expectations to reveal a character’s es- Each repetition of “You’re the kind rector of NaNoWriMo. The article is
sence is one way to capture the fleeting of person who _____” provided the excerpted from his new book, The Art
profile of your character. opportunity to reveal something out- of Brevity: The Art of Crafting The
So nurture an irreverence of banal- side our expectations and experience Very Short Story, published by Uni-
ity, a disdain for the ordinary. Don’t of Maron. So, ironically, the “kind of versity of New Mexico Press. His works
be complacent. A complacent author person” frame really served to show include Pep Talks for Writers: 52
creates complacent characters, char- how Maron was his own kind of sin- Insights and Actions to Boost Your
acters content to exist in generalities, gular mess. Creative Mojo and Brave the Page, a
cliches, and stereotypes. Does anyone I thought this would make a good teen writing guide. For more info, visit
in the world feel their existence as a ste- characterization exercise for two reasons: grantfaulkner.com.
reotype? Don’t we all feel ourselves as
unique, as somehow apart from others,
as a being unto ourselves, full of nuanc-
es and contradictions and secrets and
impulses and . . . the wonderful and Who is Ron Doe and will he ever awaken?
sometimes horrible messiness of being
a human? tŚĞŶĂƐĞĐƌĞƟǀĞŶĞǁĐŽƌƉŽƌĂƚĞĐůŝĞŶƚ
It takes effort to unveil a hidden ƐĞĞŬƐŚĞůƉĨƌŽŵŵĞŵŽƌLJƚŚĞƌĂƉŝƐƚ
truth, to bring a reader face-to-face ŽĐƚŽƌ^ƚĞĸ ůĂŬĞƚŽƉƵůůŽŶĞŽĨƚŚĞŝƌ
with an arresting or even dangerous ĐŽůůĞĂŐƵĞƐŽƵƚŽĨĂƉƌŽĨŽƵŶĚĐŽŵĂ͕ƐŚĞ
ŚĞƐŝƚĂƚĞƐĂƚĮƌƐƚ͘dŚĞĐŝƌĐƵŵƐƚĂŶĐĞƐĂƌĞ
encounter. A writer of brevity has to ŚŝŐŚůLJƵŶƵƐƵĂů͗ƚŚĞƉĂƟĞŶƚŝƐŝĚĞŶƟĮĞĚ
paint characters in deft brushstrokes, ŽŶůLJĂƐ͞ZŽŶŽĞ͟ĂŶĚƚŚĞLJŽīĞƌŚĞƌ
with the keenest of images in such lim- ĂĨŽƌƚƵŶĞŝĨƐŚĞƐƵĐĐĞĞĚƐ͘ZĞǀŝǀŝŶŐĂ
ited space, in order to capture their ĐŽŵĂƚŽƐĞƉĂƟĞŶƚďLJƐƟƌƌŝŶŐƵƉĚŽƌŵĂŶƚ
essence. You’re not mirroring life so ŵĞŵŽƌŝĞƐǁŽƵůĚďĞŐƌŽƵŶĚďƌĞĂŬŝŶŐ͕ƐŽ
much as showing life. Your character’s ƐŚĞĂĐĐĞƉƚƐͲͲĂƐŵƵĐŚĨŽƌƚŚĞƉƌŽĨĞƐƐŝŽŶͲ
background, all that makes them who ĂůĐŚĂůůĞŶŐĞĂƐƚŚĞŵƵĐŚͲŶĞĞĚĞĚĐĂƐŚ͘
ƵƚĂƌĞǀŽůƵƟŽŶĂƌLJŶĞǁƚĞĐŚŶŽůŽŐLJƚŚĂƚ
they are, matters less than their imme- ůĞƚƐŚĞƌƐĐĂŶƉĞŽƉůĞƐ͛ŵŝŶĚƐĂŶĚĚŝƐƉůĂLJ
diate impact on the reader in that dash ƚŚĞŵĞŵŽƌŝĞƐŽŶĂƐĐƌĞĞŶƐŽŽŶĚƌĂǁƐ
of words on the page. This book is available from ŚĞƌĂŶĚŚĞƌĂƐƐŽĐŝĂƚĞƐŝŶƚŽĂůĂďLJƌŝŶƚŚ
If story is character and character Amazon in both Kindle and ŽĨŝŶƚƌŝŐƵĞ͕ĚĞĐĞŝƚ͕ĂŶĚŵƵƌĚĞƌ͘ŶĚ
is story, ask yourself what is the most paperback versions. ƚŚƌŽƵŐŚŽƵƚĂůůƚŚŝƐ͕^ƚĞĸ ŝƐƚƌLJŝŶŐŚĂƌĚƚŽ
cwirwinbooks.com ƌĞĐŽǀĞƌŚĞƌownůŽƐƚŵĞŵŽƌŝĞƐ͙
WRITERMAG.COM 7
Prologue » Contest Winner
Dog Tags
Read the grand-prize winner of our
500-Word Essay Contest.
By Michelle Y. Green
TONIGHT, I FOUND MY FATHER’S In his last days, Dad put me behind South, he told me to “sting the gun!”
dog tags. the wheel of his Porsche and asked me We smelled coal dust and whispering
I’d stolen a dusty keepsake box from to take him to Kentucky one final time. pines in six hours.
my mother’s house. The tags lay tangled When I was 16, he had taught me to There was nothing left of Holler
beneath yellowed newspaper clippings, “slide into fifth” on Lackland’s flight Number Five. The state had cleaved
forgotten tie-tacks, and a large-caliber line. For mere mortals, the trip to Jen- his mountain home to make a new
bullet. What surprised me was that I kins would have been an eight-hour highway. We were unaware that we
did not cry. drive – especially through the wind- would witness the ribbon cutting.
Hewn from the coal mining moun- ing mountain roads behind overload- As my father mourned, I looked high
tains of Kentucky, Dad had boarded a ed coal trucks. But when we got to 81 into the mountaintop to see a single
bus to Tuskegee with $3 in his pocket
to become a colored flyer.
“We had a job to do, so we did it. We
called ourselves The 100 Percenters.”
Hollywood and presidents have
extolled the deeds of these extraordi-
nary men. But my memories are in the
quiet things.
Dad shaved with a straight-edged
razor from Daddy John, who, covered
with coal dust, cut hair on the side.
I loved to watch Dad lather his face,
cut around the cleft of his chin, and
then – the splash of Old Spice. Whis-
tling, he dabbed the waxy polish from
the Kiwi tin and spit-shined his shoes
until he could see his face in his shoe
tops. He complained that the seams
on his socks hurt his toes yet pinned
on his many-colored ribbons, adjusted
his hat, and left for the day.
I did not cry when I found his dog
tags, but I have cried many times since.
World War II, Korea, and Vietnam took
PHOTOS COURTESY OF MICHELLE Y. GREEN
8 APRIL 2023
tire, painted in white. It was Daddy effects, running the gauntlet of govern-
John’s custom to paint white tires to ment red tape, and tear-soaked pillows
decorate the mountainside behind to feel ready.
their house. I am writing his story. My deep-
Dad took the wheel and unbur- est regret is that, although I hear his
dened himself on the trip home. He voice clearly, he will not be here to
knew I would write the truth when the read it.
time came – about the body snatches,
the kill counts, the stalking Special Ops Michelle Y. Green is a graduate of the
For information on how to
Groups, the comrades absent from the enter one of our contests, Johns Hopkins Master of Arts in Writ-
black marble wall back home. scan the QR code above or ing program and author of A Strong
It has taken me years of mining visit writermag.com/ Right Arm: The Story of Mamie “Pea-
memories, combing through personal the-writer-contests. nut” Johnson. michelleygreen.com
WRITERMAG.COM 9
WRITE WELL
GET PUBLISHED
WIN CASH
Enter our writing contests for a chance to win
$1,000 and publication in our magazine!
LEARN MORE AT
writermag.com/the-writer-contests
Broadening the
Bookshelves
This month, we’re focusing on Jewish literature.
By Yi Shun Lai
WRITERMAG.COM 11
B → B Jewish Literature
12 APRIL 2023
questions around it: Is it a religion? this, wanting to emphasize that we be-
Is it an ethnicity? Is it a culture? The long in that conversation as a margin-
truth is that it’s all of them. So that’s alized group as a tiny minority group,
why you get some very clearly religious really. We are about 6 million Jews in
or theological books, and clearly that’s the United States, which is about 2%
very religiously oriented. But then you of the population. And that we also are
could also have a Jewish cookbook, a very diverse group within that 6 mil-
[and] then you get into the question lion. There’s a way in which seeing Jews
of, are the recipes all kosher. And so as so-called white [is] lumping us with
you have the religion element there,
too. But that’s clearly more of a cultural
“The adjective majority culture.”
I feel a certain dismayed thump in
thing. There’s not always consensus or ‘Jewish’ also has my chest as I hear Dreifus nail down
agreement, both in the outer world and exactly my sentiment about my blonde-
within the Jewish community. And I a lot of questions haired, blue-eyed Jewish school friend.
think that because there is so much ar- I remember distinctly feeling that my
gument and debate within the Jewish around it: friend already belonged, without ever
community writ large on everything, having to work for it. “It feels inaccurate
discussions about Jewish books are pe- Is it a religion? to so many of us, even while we may and
rennial and never-ending,” she tells me.
“The other thing is that just because
Is it an ethnicity? do acknowledge that we have over more
recent years in some circles benefited
there are such varied viewpoints in
American culture, mostly, you know,
Is it a culture? from being able to appear and present
as white and the privileges that go along
where Jews belong in the multicultural The truth is that with that,” she says. “But at the same
conversation. [There are some] librar- time, the far right doesn’t see us as white
ians who I’ve seen really engage with it’s all of them.” for sure. I think it’s a concern about rep-
resentation, like other people want to be
represented and want to have their sto-
ries told. I mean, I didn’t grow up with
a lot of mirror books [a work that lets a
child see a representation of themselves]
or, like, almost any mirror books, really.
There’s really nothing super influential
for me in that sense. It’s important be-
cause, especially in the kid lit communi-
ty, [there is] the desire to provide mirror
and window books that are Jewish. Be-
cause even within our community, be-
cause of all of our diversity, our books
can serve as simultaneously mirrors and
windows, even for us.”
Dreifus reminds me of the many dif-
ferent ethnicities within the Judaic eth-
nicity: Sephardic Jews (from the Iberi-
an peninsula); Mizrahi Jews (from the
Middle East); Ashkenazic Jews ( Jews
JODY CHRISTOPHERSON
WRITERMAG.COM 13
B → B Jewish Literature
MFA IN CREATIVE
WRITING
6HDWWOH3DFLƇF8QLYHUVLW\œV low-residency MFA program is for apprentice writers
She stymies me even as I’m shaking
my head vehemently. “That’s my point
about the Jewish writer,” she says. “So if
a Jewish writer chooses to write charac-
ters that aren’t Jewish and isn’t writing
who want to pursue accomplishment in the craft of writing, and care about the
relationship between faith and literature. about Jewish culture, then why is that a
Jewish book? It’s a Jewish writer, but it
&25()$&8/7< GENRES
Poetry
doesn’t mean it’s a Jewish book.”
Bryan Bliss
Mark S. Burrows Fiction
Scott Cairns &UHDWLYH1RQƇFWLRQ Yi Shun Lai teaches in the MFA pro-
Robert Clark Spiritual Writing gram at Bay Path University and is the
Jennifer Maier author of two books. Her next book, a
David McGlynn /($51025(
Gina Ochsner VSXHGXPID YA historical novel, is due out in 2024
Mischa Willett 800-601-0603 from Atheneum Books.
Lauren Winner
14 APRIL 2023
Talk to the
Practitioner:
Kathleen Alcalá
nonfiction; Spirits was reissued by Raven Chron- Jews – doing the research helps to ground me in a time and
icles Press in 2021; The Flower in the Skull, place, and it makes these people more real for other people.
Alcalá’s second novel, will also be reissued by So that’s where I start, is doing that research and trying to
Raven Chronicles Press in 2023. We sat down to figure out how an individual would make their way across
talk about her process and her writing life. this landscape.
WRITERMAG.COM 15
B → B Jewish Literature
[I don’t just do] book or online about.” And in particular, for a Jewish anymore. With great upheaval comes
research but travel and in-person identity, the notion of hidden Jews great change and new stories, or a
interviews. Although we think we in Mexico was something that was reframing of old stories. (From La Llo-
can recall what a place is like, it is quite alien to most mainstream Jews rona to a new translation of Beowulf by
always surprising to me how much who I met in the United States. And Maria Dahvana Headley to Braiding
detail we miss or take for granted. they were kind of shocked by the Sweetgrass by Robin Wall Kimmerer.)
When those details are left out, the whole idea that there might be Mexi- [And] in the last 20 years, there has
plot, the story, and characters seem can Jews. That just didn’t match with been a lot of discussion and more open
unmoored, drifting in this odd space. their idea of the world. So that’s where discussion about [Crypto-Judaism].
Then I try to develop characters along having specific detail really makes a Plus, scholars have gotten interested in
the way. Sometimes it is a deliberate difference because I have to ground it. So a lot has gotten documented that
process, like having students fill out a these stories in a world that other peo- was not before.
biographical form for their characters, ple recognize.
but for me, more often, it is starting Most of the people who identify TW: Are works like your novels part of
with a few things I know about the as Sephardic Jews have ancestors who that awakening?
person/character and launching them left Spain during the Inquisition for
into action to see what they do, how friendlier countries, such as Turkey, KA: It was very much a part of that.
they feel about other characters, how Greece, other European countries. My And once people saw that there was an
they solve problems. Finally, when I ancestors hid their identities to im- audience for it, a lot of other people
have a general idea of what the book migrate to Mexico, which was still a decided that they would write about
is about, how it will unfold, I compile Spanish colony. They did such a good it. I did all the research for Spirits of
a fake table of contents that helps me job of hiding that most European and the Ordinary pre-internet and went in
return again and again to what the Sephardic Jews did not know they person to a lot of these places, includ-
book is really about. You might call it existed, but that is changing. Spirits of ing my uncle’s library in Chihuahua,
a synopsis, but it is something cruder, the Ordinary is based roughly on that Mexico. He ran a private school there
more basic than that, designed to re- aspect of my family history. for many years, and so he had quite a
mind me of the specific details I want I also identify as Mexican, Chicanx, nice library about the Jews of northern
to include. and Native American, from another Spain in that area.
branch of the family. The second novel
TW: But the group – the Crypto-Jews – in the family trilogy, The Flower in the TW: Are you finding many more folks
is also a group you identify with per- Skull, is based on my Ópata ancestors. wanting to “jump on the bandwagon”
sonally. Which came first? Was it more I used to think that our mixed heri- to write about Crypto-Judaism?
the idea that you needed to tell a story tage was unusual, but I don’t think so
about something or more like, this is a KA: Absolutely. I’m not going to tell
part of my identity, I need to tell a story anyone what to write or how to write
about that? Or even was it that every- about it, but there is a certain amount
body needs to know about this particu- of romanticization that has taken
lar group of people? place. People seem to think it’s charm-
ing to be chased by the Inquisition.
KA: It was, here are a set of stories I’ve And, of course, it was terrifying. It was
never heard anywhere else outside of horrible. I’ve learned a little bit more
our family, and I think that they are about my specific ancestors and, really,
interesting enough that other people the man from whom we were descend-
would want to hear about them. I ed just got out of Spain by the skin of
started out thinking, well, this is just his teeth. And his parents were killed
another set of stories in the world. by the Inquisition. So, you know, it
And people looked at me like, “Well, was not fun. But in retrospect, people
we have no idea what you’re talking seem to – I don’t know. Why is that
16 APRIL 2023
any more romantic than leaving Ger- And one of the stories here are the Vargas and The Dead Naturalist, that
many because you’re the fourth-born Japanese Americans who were incar- dips a toe into this notion of the fan-
son, and you’re all going to starve to cerated during World War II simply tastic, the more than real. There are
death if you stay? because they were Japanese Ameri- all these different terms for it – like
cans. There is a family in particular slipstream fiction, which goes back
TW: A lot of the things you’re de- that came back to the island after- and forth between fantastic and real-
scribing rings true to me in terms wards and started a grocery store that’s istic. It’s just a fun way to tell stories.
of memoir. You write essays, but is part of a now-very-successful chain. Something else I’ve been working
there at some point room or a de- But what’s remarkable about the on is an anthology coming out that
sire to write memoir with regard to people in this family is they hold no I co-edited with Norma Cantú, who
Crypto-Judaism? grudges. They’re here. They’re work- is a professor at Trinity University in
ing. They’ve made lives for themselves. Texas, and it’s about La Llorona, who
KA: I’ve written articles to that extent So what would be the point, and what is the most famous character in Mexi-
that get published in specialty mag- more could they want, really, except can folklore. Three years ago, I started
azines, like HaLapid, which is the acknowledgment of that? calling for papers, calling for stories
publication for the Society for Cryp- about La Llorona. And I was thinking
to-Judaic Studies. They had a meeting TW: For a while, you were also working of it as primarily fiction at that point.
in Pueblo, Colorado, in the late 1990s, in Latinx futurism. What draws you to But I asked Norma to join the pro-
and I met all these other people who that field? gram as a co-editor, and she brought
were both scholars and individuals in many of her former students and
who felt this was part of their back- KA: I think the stories told in Mexi- other researchers. It’s now a combi-
ground. It’s kind of a safe place. co and from this sort of background nation of fiction and nonfiction and
don’t really make a distinction be- poetry and just all of the stories that
TW: Do you think this is a field of that tween realistic stories and stories that have come out of La Llorona story. It’s
requires a safe space right now? embrace the fantastic. My first book called Weeping Women, and it will be
was a collection of short fiction, Mrs. presented at AWP.
KA: It’s easy to appropriate these
stories, and there has been a history
of that since we started talking about
it. If you’re not a writer and you tell
your story, and then somebody goes
out and writes a novel who doesn’t
have this background, but it’s your
story, how are you supposed to feel
about that?
WRITERMAG.COM 17
Nightstand
Heidi Rabinowitz is host of the long-running The institution) in Mosul. “It’s sort of a
Book of Life podcast, which discusses Jewish biography. It’s also sort of historical fic-
children’s literature, and she is the children’s tion because it’s from such a long time
librarian at B’nai Israel Synagogue in Boca Raton, ago. You don’t have really clear records,
Florida. Rabinowitz provided us with books that are and there’s all this kind of mystical
stuff mixed in,” Rabinowitz says. “But
appropriate throughout a reader’s childhood all the
this book showcases a historical figure
way up through adulthood, and even in our brief conversation, I learn
that was basically unheard of, a strong,
more about the Jewish people than I had ever known before. smart Jewish woman role model.” The
book was a Junior Library Guild se-
lection and won the Canadian Jewish
Literary Award.
ask Rabinowitz why it was noting that the titles of the books are
important for a synagogue in Ladino, the language of the Sephar-
to have a librarian. “They dic Jews. “The Sephardim are a very The Unfinished Corner by Dani
have several hundred pre- small percentage of Jewry as a whole, Colman, illustrated by Rachel “Tuna”
schoolers who spend morn- which is already a small group. There’s Petrovicz (2021); How to Find What
ing, noon, and night there,” not that much representation in the You’re Not Looking For by Veera
she says. “I don’t have to tell you how literature. This is very exciting, espe- Hiranandani (2021).
important reading is and how im- cially at that very young level, to get Rabinowitz’s selections for middle
portant modeling a love of reading that. And because she’s a singer, she grade are, respectively, a graphic novel
is. Then, of course, in a synagogue, it has a wonderful music video that goes in the fantasy vein and a realistic
also brings in the element of Jewish with Shabbat, Shabbat Shalom, which middle grade novel, but Hiranandani’s
learning and modeling the specific is just so joyful and adorable.” offering pushes the envelope in an-
Jewish value of the love of learning I ask Rabinowitz how she pushes other way: it’s written entirely in the
as well. So it’s important for the books like this out to a broad reader- second person. The title won 2022’s
synagogue to have its own library ship. “The world perceives that books Sydney Taylor Book Award, an award
to support the preschool and also [about minorities] are just for those that honors Jewish literature. Drawing
to support the religious school and folks. And that’s absolutely incorrect,” on Hiranandani’s family history (she
the older children. I provide books she says. is half Indian and half Jewish), the
for the kids, I provide books for the book explores the concept of inter-
teachers and for the families. I also racial marriage in the era of Loving
help the teachers do their jobs better. Osnat and Her Dove: The True Story of v. Virginia, the landmark Supreme
I get books that support the curric- the World’s First Female Rabbi by Sigal Court case that ruled that laws ban-
ulum as well as things that are just Samuel, illustrated by Vali Mintzi (2021). ning interracial marriage violate the
going to excite the kids.” This picture book is about a historical Equal Protection Clause. “The book
We started with board books. figure who “wasn’t even well known represents a recent trend in that it’s
among the Jewish community,” says exploring Jewish identity. And there
Buen Shabat, Shabbat Shalom by Sarah Rabinowitz, although she allows that have been more books just recent-
Aroeste, illustrated by Ayesha L. Rubio among Mizrahi Jews ( Jewish people ly where the characters are actually
(2020); Mazal Bueno by Sarah Aroeste, from the Middle East), Osnat Bar- thinking about their Jewish identity
illustrated by Taia Morley (2023). zani might be better known. Barzani and what it means to them and how
Aroeste is a Sephardic Jew (her fami- was a Kurdish woman born in 1590 they want to embody their own Jew-
PHOTO COURTESY OF HEIDI RABINOWITZ
ly’s origins are in the Iberian Peninsu- whose father insisted that his only ishness,” says Rabinowitz.
la) and a singer/songwriter. Her two daughter continue her studies in the Rabinowitz praises the artwork in
board books, written for the youngest Torah after she was married. Upon the The Unfinished Corner, but she also
children, show “Sephardic people death of her husband, she became head calls out the book’s diversity – its
just living their life,” says Rabinowitz, of the Yeshiva (a Jewish educational four main heroes are a Jew of color,
18 APRIL 2023
a Sephardic Jew, and two Ashkenazi humor and clarity in his book “about
“Within Jewish Jews – and its “dynamic folklore.” why modern progressives embrace and
children’s “This book doesn’t just give us the support so many minorities but tend
folklore we hear about over and over,” to remain hostile to Jews – or not even
literature, 50% she says. “There are so many stories necessarily consciously hostile, but
about the golem and twists on the reluctant to include Jews in progressive
of the books are golem. But there’s a huge tradition support for minorities,” Rabinowitz
Holocaust-related. of folklore and legends that doesn’t says. “He argues that there is a hierar-
get looked at very much. This au- chy of racisms which wrongly excludes
We’ve counted. thor found other bits and pieces that antisemitism; that antisemitism is, if
nobody had been incorporating into not exactly the same as racism, defi-
It’s this sort of their stories and made them fit to- nitely related to racism.”
vicious cycle gether and made them interesting and Dara Horn’s provocatively titled
relevant for today.” work is “a collection of essays about
because publishers the disturbing fascination that the
world has with dead Jews and how
say, ‘Oh, well, When the Angels Left the Old Country this attention shapes the treatment
that sells. by Sacha Lamb (2022). of living Jews.” I ask Rabinowitz if
Rabinowitz calls her young adult pick this sentiment isn’t in tandem with
We’ll do some “the Jewish Good Omens,” referencing the vast number of books about
Terry Pratchett and Neil Gaiman’s Judaism or Jewish people out there
more of that.’” retelling of the birth of Satan and the that are centered on the Holocaust.
coming of the End of Times. “It’s sort “I purposely didn’t choose a Holo-
of a queer historical fairy tale,” she caust book for this list, but just to
says, starring “a Jewish demon and make you aware, within Jewish chil-
a Jewish angel who are Torah study dren’s literature, 50% of the books are
partners. Hilarity ensues. They have Holocaust-related. We’ve counted.
amazing adventures as they emigrate It’s this sort of vicious cycle because
to America through Ellis Island. They publishers say, ‘Oh, well, that sells.
get involved in the labor movement. We’ll do some more of that.’ And then
It has been described as the queer they put their resources towards it and
lovechild of Philip Roth and Sholem produce a great book because they put
Aleichem.” [Ed. note: Aleichem’s the money into it, the backing, and
book Tevye the Dairyman is the basis the marketing. Of course, the topic is
for Fiddler on the Roof.] Lamb is a compelling and exciting in a disturb-
2018 Lambda Literary Fellow. When ing way, and we should never forget.
the Angels Left the Old Country is But at the same time, it means less
their debut novel. of the resources are promoting other
books that could use the attention,
and it means that people are getting
Jews Don’t Count, David Baddiel a skewed view of what it means to be
(2021) and People Love Dead Jews: Jewish. I’m not saying we need less
Reports from a Haunted Present, books on the Holocaust. I’m saying we
Dara Horn (2021). need more of the other books because
For adults, Rabinowitz picked two the balance is off.”
nonfiction works that she feels pair Horn’s book also has a compan-
Listen to The Book of
Life podcast at well together. Comedian David ion podcast, called “Adventures with
bookoflifepodcast.com. Baddiel treats a serious subject with Dead Jews.”
WRITERMAG.COM 19
TO THE
FUTURE
Fidelity to science, technology, and certain
AND
By Kerrie Flanagan
BEYOND
20
Science fiction transports readers
through time to outer space,
introducing new societies. Authors
like Mary Shelley, H.G. Wells, and
Jules Verne paved the way for this
genre that centers around science
and technology. Readers love
being taken on these futuristic
adventures, but there are certain
conventions and expectations to
remember when writing sci-fi.
21
storyline wove in then-current cultural that deal more with human behavior. writing hard or soft sci-fi; the world
fears and issues. This opened the door Star Wars and Ready Player One fall you build must be an integral part of
for other sci-fi writers. into this category because although sci- the story. Sci-fi readers want to escape
The turn of the century saw the birth ence and technology are a part of the to a new world that has ties to what
of pulp magazines where many early story, they are not what drives the plot. they understand from the “real” world.
sci-fi writers got started. These maga- These delve more into the relationships Falls says to do this, the setting must
zines were seen as “low-brow” writing of the characters and just happen to be more than just a backdrop against
and not respected in the literary com- take place in a futuristic world. which action takes place. “It should be
munity, but they were popular because Tchaikovsky’s books are considered an integral piece of the narrative, more
they could be purchased for a few cents hard sci-fi, and he believes this term has like another character than a prop, of-
and provided great entertainment. a different meaning to different people. fering obstacles and commenting on
Writers were paid by the the story’s theme. Charac-
word, and some well-known ters interact with and are
authors wrote for these mag- challenged – externally and
azines under a pseudonym Even if you create internally – by all aspects of
and reserved their real names the world.”
for their literary work. The a new weapon, Richards believes logic
1920s and ’30s were the and self-consistency are the
golden era of the pulp maga- travel through space, most important elements of
zines. Many respected writers sci-fi worldbuilding. “Un-
contributed to these maga- or create a new universe, like fantasy, science fiction
zines, including Mary Rob- worldbuilding requires ties
erts Rinehart, H.P. Lovecraft, there must be some basis back to what is known about
and Isaac Asimov. reality. It requires the author
Hugo Gernsback, a writ- in our current science to start with a set of logical
er and author, is credited rules, no matter how wild or
for coining the term science and technology. far out. Astonishing feats of
fiction. In 1926, he created imagination can then ensue,
the magazine Amazing Sto- but at no point should the
ries. It was dedicated to what he called “For me, it’s SF where at least some of author violate the rules or create huge
at the time Scientifiction stories, which the focus relates to scientific and tech- gaps in logic.”
he defined as “a charming romance in- nological processes and principles,” he Even though your world may be fic-
termingled with scientific fact and pro- says. “Because you’re drawing on re- tional, include tethers to what readers
phetic vision.” A few years later, the al-world science, this tends to increase know and understand. This allows them
term became science fiction. Gernsback the amount of research – even if you’re to make connections to their current life
continues to be a voice in sci-fi. The going to deviate from our current un- experiences and provide some ground-
prestigious Hugo Award bearing his derstanding of the universe, you still ing in reality. Falls suggests incorporat-
name has been given to the best pub- need to get your head around what that ing your expertise into the story. “A hob-
lished science fiction novel each year understanding is.” by, skill, or experience – something you
since 1953. When it comes to deciding which can write about with complete authori-
direction you want to go with your ty, even if it’s simply what it’s like to own
Different Approaches book, Kat Falls, author of the YA se- a dog. If small details ring with authen-
Although all sci-fi must have some ba- ries Inhuman and the Dark Life series ticity, your readers will be more willing
sis in science, there are two different for middle grade readers, encourages to suspend disbelief in other areas.”
approaches. One is “hard” sci-fi, where authors to try to incorporate research
there is a strong focus on natural scienc- that excites them. “By definition, sci- → Creating characters
es like physics, astronomy, chemistry, ence fiction is fiction infused with sci- Building an incredible futuristic or
and astrophysics, which are an integral ence, so investigate what interests you. fictional world is important, but you
part of the plot. Movies that illustrate Your passion for the subject will excite need great characters who face chal-
this include The Martian, 2001: A Space the reader, and, again, they’ll be more lenges and wrestle through quirks and
Odyssey, and Gravity. Science and tech- willing to suspend disbelief.” flaws. This cast of characters allows
nology are a main focus in these films. your reader to connect to the events
The other is “soft” sci-fi, which leans Worldbuilding happening in your story. Jamie McFar-
more on the social sciences, like sociol- In sci-fi, the vast universe is at your fin- lane, author of The Junkyard Pirate se-
ogy, psychology, and anthropology, gertips, but it doesn’t matter if you’re ries, says if a reader can’t see themselves
22 APRIL 2023
in the story, they’ll struggle to engage. that stuff we learned in kindergarten, You may know your theme before
“Believable faults for protagonists are or what I suggest is basic human mo- you start writing, or it may emerge af-
critical, and I fight against fixing those rality.” The other aliens, who he refers ter a few drafts. Falls says that regard-
faults as the story progresses.” to as kindergarten dropouts, are the less of your process, at some point you
Your story centers around your pro- ones who don’t have those basic skills must identify your story’s theme and
tagonist, but without a villain to go of sharing or working together and explore it through metaphor, setting,
up against your main character, there who don’t mind taking away another’s action, imagery, and even word choice
wouldn’t be a story. McFarlane finds free will (and have the power to do it). if you want your work to have dimen-
great joy in building rich antagonists. “That’s good stuff,” he says, “a la Inva- sion and resonance.
“I want an antagonist that isn’t simply sion of the Body Snatchers. Or consider She comes up with the story con-
evil but has understandable, if immoral, Starship Trooper’s bugs who just want to cept first – before plot or character. “If
goals. I spend equal time contemplat- get all stabby because another, more in- an idea sparks an emotional response
ing my antagonists and their motiva- telligent bug says it’s the right thing to in me, I’ll start journaling to figure out
tions as I do my heroes.” do. For me, it’s the moral variance from why,” she says. “That’s usually when the
As with any story, you have the pow- baseline humanity which energizes the theme becomes apparent. For example,
er to create great characters, but in sci- value of a well-thought-out alien.” in my YA novel Inhuman, I started off
fi, you can also get to create aliens. Mc- interested in viruses that carry animal
Farlane finds that the challenge and joy → Theme DNA, like swine flu, etc. I played with
in creating new alien species is balanc- A story that resonates with readers ‘what if ’s’ and created a story premise
ing their alienness against human mo- goes beyond creating a unique world, about humans turning into ‘manimals.’
rality. He asks himself two questions: interesting characters, and page-turn- After chewing over the speculative fic-
How are they like humans? How are ing plot. To add depth and substance, tion metaphor, I realized I was most
they different? This is related more to be aware of the theme in your story. interested in a teen girl, conditioned
their personalities, morals, and values, Falls describes this as the issue or sub- to be polite and respectful, getting in
not so much how they look. ject that’s being explored in the story touch with her fierce side.”
He says it’s the similarities that make through dramatization. This could be
them relatable. “If I’m building a species time travel, artificial intelligence, fu- → Weapons
that I expect to work well with humans, turistic societies, gender…many themes In your sci-fi adventure, there may
they need to share a good portion of could be explored. come a time when your characters must
WRITERMAG.COM 23
→ Craig Martelle whilst this is also some- both. While writing, I
SCIENCE “Taking the issues of thing that can be done didn’t realize the space-
FICTION today and discussing with fantasy fiction, I ship was going to take off
them ‘in secrecy’ within think it works most effec- until my crew was inside.
AUTHORS the sci-fi backdrop. I can tively with SF because of Few genres allow for this
change the world to ad- the implicit convention kind of freedom. Fur-
SHARE dress how I think things that ‘this could happen in ther, I love exploring how
WHAT THEY will play out or create an
alien world where we can
the future’ that SF tends
to bring with it. Things
people or aliens thrive in
extreme environments.
ENJOY explore the results of dif- can feel more real.” What have they adapted
ferent histories. We are to overcome the dangers
MOST the decisions we make, → Jamie McFarlane of rogue asteroids if they
and so are the aliens.” “Writing science fiction live in an asteroid belt,
ABOUT gives writers license to or where do they get
WRITING → Adrian Tchaikovsky explore grandiose ideas. their water or fuel? How
“Giving spaceships funny I once buried a massive have these environmen-
SCI-FI. names and then explod- spaceship and had it tal changes shaped the
ing them. Seriously, wake up and unbury itself characters, both good
though, aliens, uplifted with my characters inside. and bad? The troubles
earth species, non-hu- I write by outline and by are endless, just as are
man points of view. And the seat of my pants, the solutions.”
defend themselves or go after the vil- can understand. “Then you have to
“Unlike fantasy, lains. They will need weapons, and you add likable characters who don’t share
get to construct them. Richards creates all their secrets up front. They have is-
science fiction future weaponry for his novels, which sues that they’re working on. The sus-
are extrapolated from current science, tainable part of the series is how the
worldbuilding making them plausible, but he does cau- world and characters grow with each
tion authors not to rely on the weapons new volume. The readers have to stay
requires ties to save their main characters. “No mat- on board because it’s interesting. The
ter how remarkable the weaponry, I try secret is that the first book has to be
back to what to always have my protagonists prevail, a great story.” Some of the story ele-
not due to superior forces or weaponry ments wrap up, but there are overarch-
is known about but due to superior guile and creativity. ing themes and storylines that contin-
Even in the future, even with fantastic ue with each book.
reality... weapons, a fight/battle scene is always Writing science fiction allows you
better when the protagonists outwit and to boldly go where no human has gone
At no point outthink their enemies rather than out- before as you create stories that blend
gun them.” science, technology, unique characters,
should the author and intriguing storylines. May your
Writing a great sci-fi series books live long and prosper.
violate the Sci-fi readers enjoy getting immersed
in a series. Think about the popular- Kerrie Flanagan is an author, writing
rules or create ity of Star Wars, The Mandalorian, consultant, and freelance writer from
Star Trek, and other television shows Colorado with over 20 years’ experience
huge gaps in and movies. The same thing happens in the industry. She is a frequent con-
with readers; they get caught up in the tributor to The Writer and the author
logic.” world and care about what happens to of WD Guide to Magazine Article
the characters. Writing along with 19 other books. She
Craig Martelle, author of the Bat- moonlights in the world of sci-fi/fantasy
tleship Leviathan series, says that to with a coauthor under the pen name
write a great series, you must build a C.G. Harris (cgharris.net). Learn more
world the audience is interested in and about her at kerrieflanagan.com.
24 APRIL 2023
1
BUT WAIT,
THERE’S
MORE
For bonus articles, contest alerts,
writing prompts, and industry news,
subscribe to our free newsletter!
Bit.ly/thewriternl
BIBADASH/SHUTTERSTOCK
26
Community, support, accountability,
and high-quality work: These are some of the
benefits of being in a good poetry group.
Here’s how to go about finding the right
group for you – or starting your own.
By Deborah Straw
27
it were not for my writing
group of 20 years, I most
likely would not have
completed dozens of poems. No one
would have been as well equipped to
read them carefully and diligently before
I considered sending them out into
the world of publishing: a competitive
and sometimes discouraging place for
writers. I might not have completed two
nonfiction books nor finished my essays
and short stories. Without editorial
deadlines for much of my work, I needed
a self-imposed deadline, i.e., my group,
to keep creating, writing, and revising. I
am often a slow writer. I need feedback.
The group was invaluable to me. BIBADASH/SHUTTERSTOCK
28
Writers may create in solitude, but all our small group of four, everyone had a The more you share in common
writers, of poetry or prose, need readers. chance to share at each meeting. with your writers’ group, at least in
Almost no first draft is final. Poet Gal- Should you decide on a larger num- terms of enjoying writing and reading
way Kinnell, a one-time Vermont state ber of members, maybe half would read some of the same genres or authors, and
poet (1989-1993) who received a Pulit- and receive feedback at one meeting being absolutely committed to contin-
zer Prize and was co-winner of a Nation- and half at the next. Don’t rush through ue to write, the better it is to move for-
al Book Award, admitted that he did up the process. This is serious business. Ev- ward and stay on track. Outside similar
to l00 revisions on some of his poems, ery word, every line break, every stanza, interests are useful – movies, other cul-
often a word or a line at a time. Know- every paragraph matters. tures, politics, equality, or animals.
ing when to finish, deadline or not, is Writers’ groups are most useful When I decided I needed a group
often the most challenging part of the when writers are at about the same to critique my work (I was doing more
work of creation. Readers can help. level of writing skill. If you are a pub- creative writing, less journalism), I
Aside from diaries or journals never lished writer, you want other published searched my acquaintances for pro-
meant for publication sharing, every- writers to first critique your work. Un- spective members. Two of these peo-
thing else you produce is waiting for an ple were former friends and colleagues.
audience. We all need readers to make One was a poet; the other was a non-
sure our work is clear and at its best. fiction writer. I taught writing and lit-
In On Writing, Stephen King fa- erature for 30 years at a community
mously penned, “Writing is a lonely college and at various other venues,
job. Having someone who believes in
One of the including at the local correctional cen-
you makes a lot of difference.” primary reasons ter. These are the places I met these two
If you don’t have writers in mind to women – at college and at the local arts
form a group but want to create one, for a longstanding council that funded courses at the jail.
read local papers for writers’ names you group whose The fourth member, a woman 15
admire. See if there are ads in public years older than the rest of us, was some-
media for existing groups. Put up a sign members know one I greatly admired, a very good writer
at a bookstore or a food co-op. Check for a daily paper who I knew had more
out or advertise on your local Craig-
your work and your talent than she was showing the world.
slist if such exists in your community or worth is just that: She loved poetry and novels and always
state. Ask writing friends whose work received the assignments of interviewing
they admire. If you take a writing or to keep you on high-profile visiting poets and novelists.
literature class, reach out to classmates track and to help Much to my delight, she accepted
whose work shows promise. Alterna- my invitation, and we soon met as a
tively, your city or state arts council you improve. group and set up tentative rules.
may have a writers’ organization with a All members must bring something
list of names that you can peruse. every time, even if it’s a tiny poem or a
For a poetry group, it is undeniably couple of reworked paragraphs. Don’t
ideal to include only poets. That said, hesitate to bring back the same manu-
you don’t have to be a poet to critique less you’re forming a beginning poet- script if only slightly changed.
poems. But you do have to have a good ry group, you don’t want to hem and If someone has the dreaded “writer’s
ear, understand language, and have read haw over grammar, trite cliches, or the block” or has been too busy to squeeze in
quite a lot of poetry. If your group has placement of commas and periods. writing time, assign a prompt each of you
non-poets, be sure to explain various Groups work well if the members will write about for the next meeting:
forms of poems – haiku, sestina, sonnet, are fairly similar in age. I prefer a female death, hands, dogs, flowers, loss, porches.
ballad, and so forth – if that is what you group because they represent my intend- Limit the length of manuscripts –
write. Prose writers might not know ed audience. If there is a much younger two or three poems or l0 pages of prose,
these terms and their requirements. person in the group, or much older, keep for example. Generally speaking, in my
Writers’ groups work best when they in mind that you may need to define group, we had work we initiated on
are small and when meetings and mem- some time periods or events in history, our own, and some were assignments
bership are consistent. I found four or song titles, or other terms. I have found from a newspaper, magazine, or jour-
five members work well. Sometimes one different generations of writers have dif- nal with deadlines.
person would be absent (two people are ferent interests and tastes in style, and Once you’re physically meeting, if
not a group). Also, we wouldn’t have had men and women often read quite dis- you have time, read the other members’
time for any more writing during our parate things. That said, these consider- manuscripts through once without pen
two- to three-hour meetings. Within ations may not matter whatsoever. in hand; then read again to add written
WRITERMAG.COM 29
praise and make suggestions. Read si-
lently. With poetry, the poet also reads
aloud. Read thoroughly so you don’t Recommended Reading and Listening:
have to ask embarrassing questions that
have been addressed in the manuscript
but which you may have missed if read-
ing too quickly. Once everyone has had
the time to read, which takes everyone
a different amount of time, discuss the
work in the group.
Always remember, this is not a proof-
reading or editing group. If one writer
needs a lot of editing, send them back to
their computer or even, more drastically, Stephen King: Mary Oliver: May Sarton: Writers
reconsider their appropriateness in your On Writing, 2020, A Poetry Handbook, on Writing, 1980 (in
group. Group members want to be able reissue 1994 particular, see her
essay, “Revision as
to read smoothly without taking a pen Creation”)
to every sentence, stanza, or paragraph.
After about three years, my group
decided to try out another woman as
a group member. Although she was
an excellent writer, her subject matter,
mostly scholarly religious research, did
not mesh with our concerns or styles.
These were the conditions we fol-
lowed for 20 years: we agreed to meet
at regular intervals, to each bring a piece
each time (revisions were fine), to pho- Poets on Poetry Under Discussion The Slowdown, a
(book series), (book series podcast of the
tocopy or print out the work for the oth- press.umich.edu/ of reviews and Poetry Foundation,
er three, and to give ample notice if not browse/series/ essays about slowdownshow.org
able to attend a scheduled meeting. We UM31 individual poets),
press.umich.edu/
also agreed to meet at alternating houses browse/series/
and not to drink wine or other alcohol- UM34
ic beverages, which does not help cre-
ative collaboration. We generally had tea
and cookies or iced tea and cheese and Start gently; give praise where praise is a poem takes its own directions. Your
crackers, depending on the season, and due. Taking feedback often requires cour- group members may see this before you
we generally met for two to three hours age, especially if readers don’t understand do; try out their suggestions. You can
once every two or three weeks. We al- or care for your newest work. always return to your original draft.
most always had a cat in attendance as Give honest feedback, and if you Don’t be afraid to say, “I don’t un-
well, a comfort many poets share. don’t know what to say, admit it. Al- derstand.” If you don’t, some other
We had no TV or music on in the ways offer kind, positive comments first. readers won’t, either.
background, and we turned off our There ought to be no biases re: topics. We sometimes shared the names of
phones. We generally avoided slipping That said, if someone’s writing (topic or editors or agents who were looking for
into gossip (unless it was about a diffi- language) consistently makes you un- new work. Great teachers, local and on-
cult or fabulous editor, useful informa- comfortable, the group needs to discuss line, were recommended, too.
tion) or discussion of favorite books, this and see if the two of you can work While you’re in a writing group, it’s
films, or recipes. together. I learned I was uncomfortable always important to keep reading. If
When we critiqued each other’s with a woman member, with us for a you’re a poet, of course, you’ll be read-
works, we would start out with the posi- while, who dominated the meetings ing the latest work and perhaps restudy-
tive points, leaving “negative” criticism or and wrote about her open marriage. ing the classics. Encourage your other
questions and misunderstandings to later. You do not need to take all sugges- members to read some of the work you
I learned never to use a red pen in gradu- tions. Use what makes sense to you love or bring some to share. My group
ate school as it looks too much like blood or what two or more members agree occasionally attended local readings to-
on the page. We writers are a sensitive lot. doesn’t work or is unclear. Sometimes, gether: I distinctly remember Kinnell,
30 APRIL 2023
Ruth Stone, and Mark Doty, all re- connect to or form a new group on many ands (not used in much poetry).
nowned poets. Zoom and other platforms. However, Other members can help suggest titles,
Try to continue to meet as a group for me, a bit of a Luddite and a former too. And your readers indicate wheth-
for at least a year. Although you may be- classroom teacher, seeing the writers er something is clear or ambiguous.
come busier in your lives, if you carve out in person is always preferable, more You may forget to define something or
time for your writing, you will begin to intimate, and somehow more genuine someone, or you may use words or im-
understand each other’s styles and con- than seeing people on a small screen. ages that just don’t fit.
cerns more truly. If you are serious about Meeting outside the home takes more Giving feedback, listening, is also
writing, and publishing, your meetings energy and time than sitting down at good for you. You learn about new
deserve to remain a commitment. your familiar computer and signing on. worlds, new perspectives, maybe even
One of the primary reasons for a Now that the incidence of COVID has new words or concepts. You understand
longstanding group whose members lessened, you can also hug a colleague how critical your comments are to your
know your work and your worth is just in congratulations or empathy, not just other members, who may have initially
that: to keep you on track and to help say “good work” with a smile. Also, the been reticent or even afraid to share.
you improve. King’s “someone(s) who risk of staying at home for an online Writers’ groups are there for you:
believes in you” makes a huge difference group may make you feel you ought to they listen to your work, they read your
in your journey to becoming a better be doing other things when the meet- work, they believe in your work, they
writer and not giving up. Share successes ing comes around (walking the dog, keep you on track, and they help you
and rejections. Few except working writ- doing laundry, preparing dinner), thus grow, as a writer and as a person.
ers understand the often-long process of causing you to miss more often.
submitting, being rejected, or being ed- In my two-decades-long group, Deborah Straw publishes essays, poems,
ited and then published and being paid aside from helping me start and finish articles, and book reviews. She has also
or not, sometimes after a very long time. a lot of work, I learned that my poetry published two nonfiction books and
If the idea of an on-the-ground was sometimes too repetitious in mean- taught writing and literature at the col-
group meeting doesn’t appeal, you can ing (not in language) and included too lege level for 30 years.
WRITE
YOUR MFA
FUTURE CREATIVE
WRITING
Low Residency Program
Summer 2023 Residency: July 14 - 22
Nationally recognized faculty authors:
Sharbari Ahmed William B. Patrick
Rachel Basch Jennifer Vanderbes
Kate Clark RECENT GUEST WRITERS:
Carol Ann Davis Ayad Akhtar
Celeste Doaks Billy Collins
Shelley Evans Marlon James
Sonya Huber Sigrid Nunez
Eugenia Kim Tracy K. Smith
Phil Klay Zadie Smith
Dinty W. Moore Natasha Tretheway
Susan Muaddi Darraj
Now offering fellowships
Karen Osborn
to qualified veterans
Adriana Páramo
Why dramatic technique is
not enough to write great
creative nonfiction:
You need an unwavering
blend of hard-won facts
and the drive to find them.
By T.J. Murphy
33
lthough demanding, Gutkind succinctly argues that the
creative nonfiction “creative” in creative nonfiction refers
is rich territory for to literary craft, not yarn-spinning
writers. It’s attrac- fabrication.
tive to journalists “In some ways, creative nonfiction
and fiction writers is like jazz,” Gutkind writes. “It’s a rich
alike, a place to exercise strengths – like mix of flavors, ideas, and techniques,
the research skills of a reporter or the some of which are newly invented and
dramatic technique of a novelist – and others as old as writing itself.”
build skills you don’t currently have. He continues: “The goal of creative
Or, if you’re willing to do the work, nonfiction is to make nonfiction stories
you just make creative nonfiction your read like fiction so that your readers are
thing from the start by taking classes, as enthralled by fact as they are by fan-
attending workshops, or pursuing an tasy. But the stories are true.” Any belief
appropriate MFA. that the word “creative” gives the writ-
Creative nonfiction is a broad cate- er license to “make up facts and embel-
gory, chock full of an array of subcat- lish details” is, Gutkind states sharply,
egories. Memoir and essays, of course, “completely wrong.”
but also (it’s a long list) writing about
things like food, travel, crime, mu- Fact versus fiction
sic, and history. A subgenre can be In his book, Gutkind explores one of
broken down further. For example, the more sensational episodes of the
under travel/adventure, you can find debate, when Alex Heard, longtime
disaster nonfiction: think Into Thin editorial director of Outside magazine,
Air, Jon Krakauer’s terrifyingly vivid, found certain anecdotal stories in the
detailed journalism from the top of books of David Sedaris beyond belief.
Mount Everest. He was a fan of Sedaris, but his editor’s
The controversy long dogging cre- sensitivity to the implausible tripped
ative nonfiction (a.k.a. literary non- an alarm. Heard proceeded to don a
fiction, narrative nonfiction, narrative fact-checker hat and went about inter-
journalism, etc.) is in its defining prop- viewing Sedaris’ friends and relatives.
erties. As Lee Gutkind, founding ed- And Sedaris himself. There was a there
itor of Creative Nonfiction magazine, there, and Heard’s work culminated in
PASEVEN/SHUTTERSTOCK; NEO GEOMETRIC/SHUTTERSTOCK
described in his 2012 book, You Can’t a 2007 piece for The New Republic, en-
Make This Stuff Up: The Complete Guide titled “This American Lie.”
to Creative Nonfiction – From Memoir Heard started off with the following:
to Literary Journalism and Everything “‘The events described in these
In Between, one of the chief complaints stories are real,’ humorist David Se-
about the term “creative nonfiction” is daris wrote in the introductory note
that the word “creative” must suggest to Naked, his 1997 collection of non-
that “making things up” is OK. fiction essays. The New York Times
34 APRIL 2023
was convinced: When Naked hit the nonfiction – with a “fleet of e-mails and
best-seller list, it categorized the book idiotic-sounding cold calls to dig deep-
as nonfiction.” er.” Some out-there stories, to Heard’s
One story from Naked that Heard surprise, turned out to be true. But he
fact-checked was Sedaris describing also uncovered a number of “outright
how, when he was 13, he volunteered fabrications” that “collapsed like a
at a mental institution and ultimate- shaky Jenga tower.”
ly was bit by an elderly patient. In his Sedaris admitted to Heard that he
research, Heard talked to a registered sometimes made stuff up – that it’s all
nurse who would have been working about telling “good stories.” Sedaris jus-
at the hospital at the time and faxed tified his position by saying if he were
her a copy of the story. “He’s lying to find out that Frank McCourt’s Pu-
through his teeth!” she said back to litzer Prize-winning memoir Angela’s
Heard, listing a number of factual er- Ashes had been cooked up, he wouldn’t
rors in the story. care because he liked the story so much.
Spurred by the nurse’s revela- To which Heard responded, “OK,
tions, Heard drove on with the proj- but last time I checked, you’re supposed
ect, checking on other stories within to call that fiction.”
the Sedaris canon – each presented as
No free pass
As you can imagine, the New Republic
story sparked debate about what the
boundaries are or should be for humor-
ists like Sedaris. Should humorists – in
the interest of presenting larger truths –
be granted more latitude than other cre-
IMMERSION AND THE ative nonfiction writers when it comes
CREATIVE NONFICTION LIFE to facts?
“Real stories, factual stuff, report-
A good creative nonfic- (132 hours), and cellphone ed accurately and skillfully, can evoke
tion writer goes well be- video recording (28 hours) many emotions, from humor, to trage-
yond Google search when to capture scenes and
dy, to fear,” writes Gutkind in his anal-
researching a story. For a dialogue. Any reporting
powerful example, read An- that she didn’t witness ysis. “It doesn’t follow that humorists
drea Elliott’s 2022 Pulitzer firsthand she corroborated alone should receive a free pass – and a
Prize-winning Invisible Child: by interviewing sources shortcut to larger truths.”
Poverty, Survival & Hope in present. To check matters For my part, I agree with Heard
an American City. like tone and accuracy, she and Gutkind, if only for my own en-
Starting in 2012, El- read passages of the book joyment as a reader. The first (and sec-
liott followed an 11-year- out loud to Dasani.
ond) time I read “Ticket to the Fair”
old child named Dasani An additional layer of
growing up poor and often book research included by David Foster Wallace, his hilarious
homeless in New York City. reviewing 14,325 records account of the 1993 Illinois State Fair
Elliott immersed herself in from government agencies for Harper’s Magazine, I loved it – in
the daily life of Dasani and and the like. The book part, I imagine, because I grew up in
her family (including seven contains 50 pages worth Iowa and once spent a week at the Iowa
siblings). As the New York of end notes to support her state fair, selling magic tricks for a mag-
Times described it, Elliott reporting. “The reporting
ic supplies store. I was 15 at the time,
spent eight years “follow- has an intimate, almost lim-
ing Dasani and her family itless feel to it,” continues and it remains one of the weirdest ex-
virtually everywhere: at the NYT. “The result of this periences of my life, from seeing what
shelters, schools, courts, unflinching, tenacious re- was then called a “freak show” to be-
welfare offices, therapy porting is a rare and power- ing around “carnies” to going to a Styx
sessions, parties.” ful work whose stories will concert (this was in 1978). Still, some
Elliott’s reporting used live inside you long after of the stuff in “Ticket to the Fair” was
notetaking, audio recording you’ve read them.”
so funny it was hard not to wonder if
Wallace the novelist couldn’t help him-
self. That said, I wanted his anecdotes
WRITERMAG.COM 35
to be real because this is what fueled
the humor. Unfortunately – for me
anyway – my suspicions were at least
partly confirmed when I read D.T.
Max’s biography on Wallace. This is
when I initially found out that one of
the characters in Wallace’s story – re-
ferred to as “native companion” – was
not his high school prom date as told
in the story but a manufactured ver-
sion of a woman Wallace had been dat-
ing at the time. From then on, I wasn’t
sure what to believe and what not to
believe in Wallace’s nonfiction.
(By the way, Josh Roiland does an
impeccable job of analysis on the sub-
ject of Wallace’s role in creative nonfic-
tion in his study, “I’m Not a Journal-
ist – I’m More Like a Novelist With a
Tennis Background.”)
How exactly do you get on the
right path with creative nonfiction?
This was my key question when I
reached out to the nonfiction editor
at the Newfound Journal, who teaches Ploi Pirapokin
for the Creative Nonfiction Founda-
tion. Ploi has an MFA in creative writ-
ing from San Francisco State and is
accomplished both in fiction and non-
fiction. She also teaches classes at the featuring Thai Power Rangers at a ra- in any way, shape, or form that speaks
University of Hong Kong, the UCLA men restaurant in Oakland. I was able to you based on the facts that were
Extension writers program, and Writ- to see, in real time, how journalists col- researched or given. Readers enter
ingWorkshops.com. lected evidence and worked with the your nonfiction work with the belief
restaurant to write their story within that what you say happened, which is
••• 24 hours. why you have the responsibility as the
Here’s what I learned: Don’t lie voice to your story to be held account-
As both a writer and a teacher, about checkable facts. When in doubt, able for shining a light to it.
how do you define creative leave it out. Admit what you did in-
nonfiction? What kind of page in off-record interviews, to your Can you describe your path into
boundaries are there? editor; hell, even admit in your writ- the nonfiction work you do? Were
To quote Creative Nonfiction maga- ing that your memory is fallible. The there particular writers or teach-
zine, creative nonfiction is “True sto- draw of nonfiction is that it’s true, and ers who inspired you to build the
ries, well told.” I had an amazing press you had access to that truth and lived skills you use?
BRANDON ESPY
run with journalists last year for a viral to tell it. You always have the free- The allure of being a fiction writer, es-
Twitter thread about witnessing a fight dom to present and express the story pecially if you’re marginalized in any
36 APRIL 2023
way, is that everything that you write prostrating oneself to hordes of strang-
that appears believable and sincere – es- ers you know will judge you, unfortu-
pecially if it features your culture, eth- nately, is not sustainable – that’s how
nicity, any autobiographical informa- you become bitter or resentful.
tion, gender, or sexual identity – will be When teaching, my main objective
considered nonfiction. is to create a community of humility
When I started submitting my short and acceptance. If we can practice com-
stories over 10 years ago, sometimes passion, vulnerability, and patience in
panelists, jurors, and editors would ask workshop, it will show up in our writ-
me if I was writing nonfiction, which ing, and we’ll feel freer to bloom on
inspired me to try it. At the time, I
wrote from a place of wanting to prove
“Readers enter the page. More than anything, we learn
to be more compassionate and patient
that my fiction was equal to my nonfic- your nonfiction with ourselves, in our reflections, in
tion in craft, heart, and intention. Over how we want to remember things, and
time, nonfiction became my playful re- work with how we may want to be remembered as
prieve from fiction that supplemented
my creative practice, but that’s when
the belief that full human beings.
I saw that nonfiction is more egalitar- what you say What advice do you have for the
ian of a genre to write in than fiction new writer who is embarking into
and much more accessible to the public happened, which creative nonfiction?
than short stories.
It’s normal to wonder if an author
is why you have Separate a writing career from the actu-
al writing. Writing is a process, and we
can write such an accurate and honest the responsibility only catch the highlights of someone’s
story without having endured the ex- career when they are on the up and up.
act situation themselves, but does in- as the voice to No one is on your radar when they’re
vestigating into the parallels between
the writing and the author’s life really
your story to be hibernating to write a book for 15 years
or if there’s a personal life matter they
satisfy our search for the truth? What held accountable must attend to.
happens after you’ve found that truth? What alleviates the pressure for me
What can you do with it? for shining a is as writers, there are hundreds of au-
I found personal essays, memoirs,
and lyric essays freeing to construct,
light to it.” thors (your worldwide, global co-work-
ers and colleagues) and published ex-
given that I already had themes, re- amples you can draw inspiration from
search, and experiences I wanted to ex- to help guide or shape your work – as a
plore, and my desire to connect and be template, as a launching pad. Your first
in conversation with others has always essential to our real, off-the-page lives draft may make zero sense to anyone
outshone my desire to simply be seen and for a better world. but yourself. That doesn’t mean you
or recognized. should never write again. If you keep
Coming from Asia, aka “The Cul- When you teach a class in cre- revising, you’ll discover new approach-
tural Pioneers of Gaslighting,” it was ative nonfiction, what kind of key es to language, structure, and tone that
profound when Vievee Francis [a poet objectives do you have in mind? could better express what you’re trying
and professor at Dartmouth Col- I’m drawn and connected to nonfiction to say.
lege], one of the first authors I shared that features our humanity. There’s sadly no shortcut to writing
my nonfiction with, said my feelings We lie. Make mistakes. Respond in something that stands the test of time
were valid. [Author of Lamdba Liter- petty ways. Cause unintentional and and has its own life once it has left your
ary Award nominee Boy Erased] Gar- intentional harm. Have blind spots, fingertips. Rewriting, re-remember-
rard Conley inspired me to stand up coping mechanisms, and flaws that ing what happened, and repositioning
for what I write – no opposition to contextualize our intentions, behaviors, where you are writing from (your dis-
my truth will ever feel as destructive as actions, and even regrets. tance to the subject matter, the story)
erasing myself again. That gave me the Naturally, we avoid sharing our takes time, and you deserve to give
courage to react and participate with worst selves on the immortal page and yourself that space to dream.
contemporary writers who push on wish that the act of confessing and the
form and structure to extend the pos- sensational content of our perceived T.J. Murphy is the editor of
sibilities of nonfiction and who con- sins will be enough for our writing The Writer. Follow him on Twitter
stantly show us that our imagination is to resonate with others. Hiding and @tjmurphywriter.
WRITERMAG.COM 37
Against everything from gig economics
to ChatGPT, how do you make it in the
STONEPICTURES/SHUTTERSTOCK
39
tracks. First, the opportunities that too. That’s why I enrolled in Colum-
lend you credibility – ones that may bia Journalism School right after I re-
not involve writing your dream project ceived my bachelor’s degree. About
but allow you to work with a thought- six weeks later, I dropped out. Not
ful editor or get your words seen by because journalism school is bad or
more people or, very importantly, put because Columbia’s specifically is bad
you in a better position to pay the bills. or anything like that; but it just wasn’t
Second are the ideas that you just can’t right for me. I didn’t feel as though I
get out of your head, that you feel driv- was getting those answers that I came
en to pursue even if everyone thinks for – quite possibly because those an-
they sound stupid. swers don’t exist.
I know my work has always had The only place I could find that
these two components from the begin- would take me on as a writer was a ever to rely on freelance work to
ning – honestly, whether I’ve had a staff Caribbean music blog, some distance survive. Ultimately, you have to de-
role or not. But if you have never had away from my interest in jazz and cide what makes writing worth it for
anything published, it probably sounds American popular music but a chance you and, specifically, which gigs are
like unusable advice. You want to know to write (for free) all the same. My ed- worthwhile. When I was starting out,
how to pitch, how to network with edi- itor there was invested in my work and I wrote a lot for free and worked as a
tors, what makes a piece salable. I think gave me chances to learn and experi- bartender. That’s a lifestyle that can be
always keeping both considerations in ment. This led to my first paid clip, a tenable when you’re 23 (as I was) but
mind, though, helps those things fall review of a dancehall album for NPR. may feel a lot less practical at 33 or 43.
into place. I would put my work there in the first Writing is real work, and it takes time.
On my path to becoming a writer, I category, in that it helped me get my Churning out rote blog posts for $20
was looking for those concrete answers, footing as a writer – and yet it was tied a pop just so that when you Google
to the kind of historically grounded, your name something comes up may
well-contextualized work I wanted not take long to feel more draining
to do in other relatively niche music than rewarding.
genres. At the same time, I was able There’s no shame in enabling your
to leverage those clips into chances to writing with a day job, and unless
write for an affiliated jazz site (also for you’re doing a pretty specific kind of
free), staying grounded in what got journalism and ignoring direct con-
me into writing about music in the flicts of interest, no shame in doing
first place. the same with copywriting/marketing/
If I were starting again, I would tell public relations work. For me, the lat-
myself to lean into that even more with ter is something like my day job, de-
a personal blog or newsletter. If you care spite the fact that it’s all freelance. The
about telling a story – care in the deep- less I’m interested in the project, the
est, most personal way, not because it’s more I charge – a necessity, after all,
trendy or seems like it will find an au- because it’s harder to invest in some-
dience – other people will care about thing you don’t care about as much,
reading it. It is undoubtedly a hustle and writing, as I mentioned, is deep-
trying to tell those stories while you’re ly personal even when you’re doing
working on just getting something pub- something as mechanical as typing up
lished, but that is the part of the hustle a press release. That work allows me to
that will pay dividends. take on projects I really care about that
might pay less.
Get used to constantly Of course, you’re always searching
reevaluating your personal for that dream assignment – the pitch
Creative Writing time/money equation. you’ve been working on for ages land-
Talking about “hustling,” of course, ing at a visible publication that pays
Classes leads us to “hustle culture,” which you more than you expect. But it’s a
Online, Remote, is incredibly easy to fall victim to lot easier to hold out for that, and to
& NYC as a freelancer. Many rates haven’t stay energized to keep chasing it, if you
changed since the ’90s (and in some don’t constantly feel like you’re pouring
GOTHAMWRITERS. COM
cases the ’70s), making it harder than your heart out into a black hole.
40 APRIL 2023
Find your niche (and make it style, your in-depth knowledge of a responsiveness to edits and emails. Es-
obvious). niche industry or your knack for writ- pecially if you’re in journalism, you
One of the reasons that I felt so out ing short stories with a particular bent. want to be an editor’s first call when a
of place in journalism school was that Don’t limit yourself, but get specif- story breaks and they need a time-sen-
my interests lie mostly in what’s con- ic – and advertise your niche, wheth- sitive follow-up, and the only way to
sidered “soft news” – entertainment er on your website or newsletter or on earn that trust is by meeting those
writing and criticism, as opposed to social media. Of course, Twitter and bare-minimum standards the first and
the “hard news” of, say, politics, com- Instagram are double-edged swords every time.
merce, or systemic inequality. Of and deserve plenty more caveats than I know as well (better?) than any-
course, there’s never been a clean di- recommendations. But I don’t think I one what a bugbear procrastination
vide between these two things, and would be writing about sports profes- can be, how deep the anxiety that fu-
the further along I got as a writer, the sionally if I hadn’t tweeted about them, els it (especially when writing about a
more I found myself needing some of a lot. It comes back to being true to topic you care about) goes. But done,
the basic “hard news” skills to write my what you care about; people can suss as is so often said, is better than per-
“soft news” stories – just as “hard news” out clout-chasing a mile away. Post as fect – your editor can’t do their part of
journalists sometimes struggle to write you write, with the intention of helping helping improve the piece and clarify-
about cultural context that might flesh people better understand what exactly ing your points if they don’t have any-
out their stories. you’re about. thing to work with.
But if I had continued in journal- The basics bring us back to that ini-
ism school and wound up starting my Don’t forget the basics. tial point, of making the foundation of
career in a more traditional way – as If you are not responsive, timely, and your work the ideas and projects you
a cub reporter at a local paper or TV professional as a freelancer, you won’t care about. Especially as a freelancer,
affiliate – I might not have been able get called again – and that makes it you’ll work way too hard to afford to
to hone in as easily on the things that nearly impossible to begin a career in get cynical about the work. If you can’t
fascinated me, the passions that now the field. It’s of a piece with the afore- find a seed of joy in the process, wheth-
lead plenty of editors to my inbox be- mentioned advice about becoming an er it comes from sating your curiosity
cause they know that I am a reliable editor’s go-to for a topic. Another way through research, speaking to people as
voice on, for example, jazz, women’s to an editor’s heart is clean copy in by a reporter, or the craft of writing itself,
college basketball, and country music. (or before!) a deadline, coupled with it’s just not worth doing. Tapping into
I didn’t start out as an expert on all your wildest flights of fancy, the most
those things, and, in fact, have come to random rabbit holes, and most creative
the latter two over my years as a writ- perspectives is the fruit of your labor –
er. But because I jumped into all of the byline is just a nice bonus.
them headfirst, often fighting against
skeptical editors every step of the way, Natalie Weiner is a Dallas-based free-
I’ve been able to give my name a kind lance writer whose work has appeared
of associated shorthand. You just want in the New York Times, the Washing-
an editor to have something, anything, ton Post, Rolling Stone, Billboard,
where their knee-jerk response is, “Oh, and NPR, among other publications.
we need [your name] for this.” Maybe A selection of her work can be found at
it’s because of your location or your natalieweiner.com.
WRITERMAG.COM 41
Before you can approach an editor or publishing house, it’s a good
idea to seek agent representation. The following agents are a small
sampling of what the industry has to offer. Find more listings at
writermag.com.
Kingstown, RI, celebrating diverse Kingsolver was born on this day veteran authors and agents Scrabble. Not that rainy?
children’s literature. in 1955. while taking breaks to visit the Get outside for a while.
weareallreaders.com majestic coastline. Then break out the Scrabble.
montereywritersretreat.com
42 APRIL 2023
Literary Agents
Information in this section is provided to The Writer by the individual markets and events;
for more information, contact those entities directly.
F N Barbara Braun Associates F N Y B.J. Robbins Literary Agency F N Chalberg & Sussman
See website for all categories. Send que- See website for all categories. See website for all categories. Submit
ries by email only. Contact: B.J. Robbins Literary Agency. queries by email only.
Contact: Barbara Braun Associates, 7 E. robbinsliterarysubmissions@gmail.com Contact: Chalberg & Sussman.
14th St., #19F, New York, NY 10003. bjrobbinsliterary.com See website for individual agents’ email
bbasubmissions@gmail.com addresses.
barbarabraunagency.com F N C Blue Ridge Literary Agency chalbergsussman.com
See website for all categories. Submit a
C Y Barry Goldblatt Literary synopsis and the first three chapters by F N The Cheney Agency
Represents authors of picture books, email. Submit a query by email or by regular
chapter books, middle-grade books, and Contact: Blue Ridge Literary Agency. mail with a SASE.
WRITERMAG.COM 43
Contact: The Cheney Agency, 39 West and specific agents’ interests. Query by nonfiction. See website for specific
14th St., Suite 403, New York, NY 10011. email only. agents’ interests and email addresses.
submissions@cheneyliterary.com Contact: The Doe Coover Agency, P.O. Contact: Dystel, Goderich & Bourret LLC,
cheneyassoc.com Box 668, Winchester, MA 01890. 1 Union Square West, Suite 904, New
info@doecooveragency.com York, NY 10003.
F N C Y Cooke McDermid doecooveragency.com dystel.com
See website for all categories. Email que-
ry only. No attachments. F N Don Congdon Associates F N C Y Einstein Literary Management
Contact: The Cooke Agency, 320 Front St. Represents authors of fiction and nonfic- Founded in 2015. See website for all
W #1105, Toronto, ON M5V 3B6, Canada. tion. Check website for individual agents’ categories. Email queries and first 10
admin@cookemcdermid.com interests. Accepts queries by email or pages only.
cookeagency.ca regular mail. Contact: Einstein Literary Management.
Contact: Don Congdon Associates, 88 info@einsteinliterary.com
F N Cornerstone Literary Agency Pine St., Suite 730, New York, New York einsteinliterary.com
See website for all categories. 10005.
Contact: Cornerstone Literary, 4525 dca@doncongdon.com F N Emilie Stewart Literary Agency
Wilshire Blvd., Suite 208, Los Angeles, doncongdon.com Specializes in literary and commercial fic-
CA 90010. tion and nonfiction. Query by email only.
info@cornerstoneliterary.com F C Y Donald Maass Literary Agency Contact: Emilie Stewart Literary Agency.
cornerstoneliterary.com Welcoming authors of nonfiction and all info@emiliestewartagency.com
genres of fiction: science fiction, fantasy, emiliestewartagency.com
F N C O Curtis Brown mystery, thriller, women’s, literary, and
Represents adult and children’s authors middle grade and YA. Only email queries F N Emma Sweeney Agency
of all genres, including illustrators. Not ac- accepted. Handles general fiction, historical fiction,
cepting plays, screenplays, or musicals. Contact: Donald Maass Literary Agency, and narrative nonfiction. Submit query
Contact: Attn: Agent’s name, Curtis 1000 Dean St., Suite 252, Brooklyn, NY via email only.
Brown, Ltd., 228 East 45th St., Suite 11238. maassagency.com Contact: Emma Sweeney Agency, 245 E.
310, New York, NY 10017. 80th St., Suite 7E, New York, NY 10075.
info@cbltd.com curtisbrown.com F N Y Doug Grad Literary Agency queries@emmasweeneyagency.com
Represents fiction and narrative nonfic- emmasweeneyagency.com
F N Y Darhansoff & Verrill Literary Agents tion, including memoir, thrillers, mysteries,
Most interested in literary fiction, narra- historical fiction, romance, military, and F N C O The Ethan Ellenberg
tive nonfiction, memoir, sophisticated theater. Query via email before submitting. Literary Agency
suspense, and both fiction and nonfiction Contact: Doug Grad Literary Agency. See website for all categories. Submit by
for younger readers. Submit via email. doug.grad@dgliterary.com regular mail or email.
Contact: Darhansoff & Verrill, 275 Fair dgliterary.com Contact: Ethan Ellenberg.
St., Suite 17D, Kingston NY, 12401. agent@ethanellenberg.com
info@dvagency.com dvagency.com F N C Y Dunow, Carlson & Lerner ethanellenberg.com
Handles literary and commercial fiction,
F N Y David Black Agency narrative nonfiction, children’s, and YA F N Fairbank Literary Representation
Represents fiction and nonfiction for fiction. Submit queries by email or reg- See website for all categories. Query by
adults and young adults. Check website ular mail (include SASE with adequate email or postal mail.
for agents’ individual interests, email postage for return of materials). Contact: Fairbank Literary Representa-
addresses, and submission instructions. Contact: Dunow, Carlson & Lerner Liter- tion, 21 Lyman St., Waltham, MA 02452.
No paper queries. ary Agency, 27 W. 20th St., Suite 1107, queries@fairbankliterary.com
Contact: David Black Agency, 335 New York, NY 10011. fairbankliterary.com
Adams St., Suite 2707, Brooklyn, NY mail@dclagency.com
11201. davidblackagency.com dclagency.com F N Y FinePrint Literary Management
Seeks fiction and nonfiction for adults
F N Doe Coover Agency F N Dystel, Goderich & Bourret and young adults.
See website for categories represented Represents authors of fiction and Contact: FinePrint Literary Management,
44 APRIL 2023
207 W. 106th St., Suite 1D, New York, Submit queries via email per website books of all subject areas. Send queries
NY 10025. instructions. via regular mail with SASE for reply.
info@fineprintlit.com Contact: Hartline Literary Agency. Contact: Gene Brissie, James Peter
fineprintlit.com See website for agents’ email addresses. Associates, Inc., P.O. Box 358, New Ca-
hartlineagency.com naan, CT 06840.
C Y Flannery Literary gene_brissie@msn.com
Fiction and nonfiction for middle grade F N C Y Harvey Klinger Literary Agency writersservices.com/reference/
and young adults, all genres. Email que- See website for all categories. See web- james-peter-associates-inc
ries only. site for specific agents’ interests and
Contact: Flannery Literary. email addresses. F N Y Jane Rotrosen Agency
jennifer@flanneryliterary.com Contact: Harvey Klinger Literary Agency, See website for all categories. Submit via
flanneryliterary.com 300 W. 55th St., #11V, New York, NY email or snail mail; no attachments.
10019. Contact: Jane Rotrosen Agency, Attn:
F N Frances Goldin Literary Agency queries@harveyklinger.com Submissions, 318 East 51st St., New
See website for all categories. harveyklinger.com York, NY 10022.
Contact: Frances Goldin Literary Agency, info@janerotrosen.com
214 W. 29th St., Suite 1006, New York, F N Y Helen Heller Agency janerotrosen.com
NY 10001. Represents authors of commercial and
agency@goldinlit.com goldinlit.com literary fiction, nonfiction, and YA fiction. F N C Y Jean V. Naggar Literary Agency
Submit through email. See website for Represents authors of commercial and
F N Y The Friedrich Agency specific agents’ interests and email literary fiction, nonfiction, and YA/chil-
See website for all categories. Submit via addresses. dren’s books. Check website for agents’
email only. No attachments. Contact: The Helen Heller Agency. specific interests. Query via website
Contact: The Friedrich Agency. info@thehelenhelleragency.com submission form.
Check website for agents’ email address- thehelenhelleragency.com Contact: Jean V. Naggar Literary Agency,
es. friedrichagency.com 216 E. 75th St., Suite 1E, New York, NY
F N C Y HG Literary 10021. Email from website. jvnla.com
F N Gelfman Schneider Literary Agents See website for all categories. Check
See website for all categories. website for agents’ interests and email F N C Y John Hawkins and Associates
Contact: Gelfman Schneider Literary addresses. Email submissions only. See website for all categories. Submit
Agents, 850 Seventh Ave., Suite 903, Contact: HG Literary, 6 West 18th St., queries via email.
New York, NY 10019. Suite 7R, New York, NY 10011. Contact: John Hawkins and Associates,
mail@gelfmanschneider.com See website for agents’ email addresses. 80 Maiden Ln., STE 1503, New York, NY
gelfmanschneider.com hsgagency.com 10038. jhalit.com
WRITERMAG.COM 45
F N Liza Dawson Associates F N Y C Park & Fine Literary and Media and textbooks. See website for submis-
Represents authors of literary and com- Represents fiction and nonfiction au- sion instructions and email addresses.
mercial fiction and nonfiction. thors, as well as graphic novels, middle Contact: Salkind Literary Agency.
Contact: Liza Dawson Associates, 121 grade, and YA. Check website for each info@studiob.com
W. 27th St., Suite 1201, New York, NY agent’s specific interests. Submit que- studiob.com/salkindagency/agents.html
10001. ries by email only. No attachments.
lwu@lizadawson.com Contact: The Park Literary Group, 55 F N Y Sarah Jane Freymann
lizadawsonassociates.com Broadway, Suite 1601, New York, NY Literary Agency
10006. Seeking nonfiction: self-help and spiri-
N Marcil O’Farrell Literary & info@parkfine.com tual books, cookbooks, narrative nonfic-
Denise Marcil Literary Agency parkfine.com tion, memoir, lifestyle, and multicultural
See website for all categories. issues. Also seeks literary, commercial,
Contact: Anne Marie O’Farrell, 86 Dennis F N C Philip G. Spitzer Literary Agency and YA fiction. Prefers email submissions
St., Manhasset, NY 11030. Specializes in general fiction, mystery, Contact: Sarah Jane Freymann Literary
annemarie@marcilofarrellagency.com thriller and suspense, sports, politics, Agency.
marcilofarrellagency.com children’s, and African American. See submissions@sarahjanefreymann.com
website for specific agents’ interests and sarahjanefreymann.com
F N C Y Marsal Lyon Literary Agency email addresses.
See website for all categories. Contact: Philip G. Spitzer Literary Agen- F N C Scovil Galen Ghosh Literary Agency
Contact: Marsal Lyon Literary Agency cy, 50 Talmage Farm Ln., East Hampton, Represents fiction and nonfiction for
LLC, PMB 121, 665 San Rodolfo Dr. 124, NY 11937. adults, young adults, and middle grade.
Solana Beach, CA 92075. kim.lombardini@spitzeragency.com Email queries preferred.
See website for agents’ emails. spitzeragency.com Contact: Scovil Galen Ghosh Literary
marsallyonliteraryagency.com Agency, 276 Fifth Ave., Suite 708, New
F N C Y P.S. Literary Agency York, NY 10001. sgglit.com
F N McCormick Literary Represents fiction and nonfiction in
Represents authors of literary and com- literary, commercial, romance, women’s F N Y C Serendipity Literary Agency
mercial fiction and nonfiction, including fiction, LGBT, YA, middle grade, picture Represents adult, children’s, and YA
memoir, history, narrative, biography, books, mystery, thriller, science fiction, fiction and adult nonfiction. Submit query
cookbooks, humor, and essays. memoir, business, politics, health, well- from website form only.
Contact: McCormick Literary, 150 West ness, sports, humor, pop science, pop Contact: Serendipity Literary Agency,
28th St., Suite 903, New York, NY psychology, pop culture, design, and 305 Gates Ave., Brooklyn, NY 11216.
10001. lifestyle. Query by email only. info@serendipitylit.com
queries@mccormicklit.com Contact: P.S. Literary Agency, 2010 serendipitylit.com
mccormickwilliams.com Winston Park Dr., 2nd Floor, Oakville,
Ontario, L6H 5R7 Canada. C Y Sheldon Fogelman Agency
F N C Y Mendel Media Group info@psliterary.com psliterary.com Represents authors and illustrators for
See website for all categories. Submit by all genres of children’s and YA books.
email only. N Regina Ryan Books Contact: Sheldon Fogelman Agency, 420
Contact: Mendel Media Group LLC, See website for all categories. Query E. 72nd St., New York, NY 10021.
P.O. Box 5032, East Hampton, New online only. 212-532-7250.
York 11937 (Note: Agency is using this Contact: Regina Ryan Books. submissions@sheldonfogelmanagency.com
address only during pandemic; check queries@reginaryanbooks.com sheldonfogelmanagency.com
website for changes). reginaryanbooks.com
query@mendelmedia.com F N Sheree Bykofsky Associates
mendelmedia.com F N Sagalyn/CAA See website for all categories. Email que-
Represents authors of upmarket nonfic- ries only. No attachments.
F N Movable Type Management tion, business books, and mainstream Contact: Sheree Bykofsky, 4326 Harbor
Represents authors of high-quality fiction. Submit queries by email only. Beach Blvd., PO Box 706, Brigantine, NJ
commercial fiction and nonfiction with Contact: Raphael Sagalyn. 08203.
archetypal themes, stories, and charac- query@sagalyn.com sagalyn.com submitbee@aol.com
ters, especially if they have strong film/ shereebee.com
TV potential. F N Y C Sandra Dijkstra Literary Agency
Contact: Movable Type Management, Interested in literary and commercial Y C Stimola Literary Studio, Inc.
244 Madison Ave., Suite 334, New York, fiction and nonfiction, including YA, Represents preschool through YA fiction
NY 10016. middle grade, and picture books. Check and nonfiction, including picture books,
achromy@movabletm.com mtmgmt.net website for individual agents’ interests novels, and graphic novels. Check web-
and email addresses. See website for site for current interests. Submit via
F Y C Nelson Literary Agency details on how each agent prefers to website form.
See website for all categories. Submit receive queries. Contact: Stimola Literary Studio.
queries by email only. No attachments. Contact: Sandra Dijkstra Literary Agency. info@stimolaliterarystudio.com
Contact: Nelson Literary Agency, 1732 queries@dijkstraagency.com stimolaliterarystudio.com
Wazee St., Suite 207, Denver, CO 80202. dijkstraagency.com
303-292-2805. F N The Talbot Fortune Agency
info@nelsonagency.com N Salkind Literary Agency See website for all categories. Query by
nelsonagency.com Seeking general nonfiction trade books email with first five pages of manuscript.
46 APRIL 2023
No attachments. F N Y Vicky Bijur Literary Agency
Contact: Talbot Fortune Agency.
queries@talbotfortuneagency.com
See website for all categories.
Contact: Vicky Bijur Literary Agency.
Classifieds
talbotfortuneagency.com queries@vickybijuragency.com
vickybijuragency.com READERS: Use caution when entering into any
legal contract with a literary service offering
F N Tessler Literary Agency LLC agenting-type assistance or publishers who
Full-service boutique agency representing F N C Y Victoria Sanders & Associates charge for publication. If you have any con-
nonfiction, including narrative, popular Represents authors of memoir, commer- cerns regarding the advertiser’s commitment or
science, memoir, history, psychology, cial women’s fiction, thrillers, humor, mys- claims, please contact the advertiser directly.
business, biography, food, and travel and teries, high-concept fiction, books for kids, ADVERTISERS: We do not accept ads from
literary, women’s, and commercial fiction. self-help, and YA. Query with first three agents or businesses that charge a reading or
No genre fiction or children’s books. chapters via email only. No attachments. marketing fee. For our private records, please
Submit queries from website. Contact: Victoria Sanders & Associates, provide us with a street address and contact
telephone number. The Writer reserves the
Contact: Tessler Literary Agency, 27 440 Buck Rd., Stone Ridge, NY 12484. right to reject or cancel any advertising which
W. 20th St., Suite 1003, New York, NY queriesvsa@gmail.com at its discretion is deemed objectionable, mis-
10011. tessleragency.com victoriasanders.com leading, or not in the best interest of the reader.
WRITERMAG.COM
Gigi
Will Know
Why are you wanting to write a POV
character drastically different from yourself ?
Dear Gigi,
I am hoping you will be able to help me with a question I have about
making mention of celebrities in fictional writing. Would I need to get
permission from the celebrity or their estate if they have passed on?
Thanks in advance,
—PERMISSION SEEKER
Dear Gigi,
Any tips for writing a POV character who is drastically different from
yourself?
—JUST CURIOUS
advice? Email your queries serve the narrative over your own ego. not, and you still want to go ahead,
to tweditorial@madavor.com
with the subject line “Advice
(Something like, “It’s easier to get pub- then start there.
Column.” We can’t wait to read lished if my character is Black, Asian, or Stay curious,
your questions! disabled” won’t fly, for instance.) —Gigi
48 APRIL 2023
GE T
$20 OFF
OUR CRITIQUE
SERVICE!*
Become a member of
The Writer today
Whether you’re just beginning your writing journey or have several
published books to your name, becoming a member of The Writer will
help you seamlessly take your ideas from initial inspiration to final
publication, granting you exclusive access to all the resources, tools,
advice, and expert webinars you’ll need to successfully publish your
work, market your writing, and stay ahead of the curve in the
fast-changing publishing industry.
*The $20 discount for our Critique Service is available only for The Writer Member Plus and The Writer VIP Member tiers.
Self-publishers need a trusted printing partner
and outstanding results.
With 48 Hour Books, you get both.
Not to mention...