Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Cecil Rose and His Skullduggeries
Cecil Rose and His Skullduggeries
few months back, I bought a book titled To any dedicated stamp collector, such (and
Ten Under Cat (Figure 1) by one Cecil other) statements sound incredulous, many of
Rose. I had never heard of its author his facts and especially his numbers, which
and had little idea of its contents, apart from often went into many tens of thousands of
the fact that it was the memoirs of a stamp pounds (the value of one pound then equates
dealer; I love such books! It turned out to be a to about 25 today), sound fictitious. To top it
quick read and I finished its 160 or so small all, Rose relates some dubious transactions
format pages within a few hours. with great relish; if some of them indeed took
place, why should he publish them and risk
First, a bibliography of the book: getting into trouble?
Rose, Cecil, and Edward Lanchbery. Ten Under So, I went online to read more about the man.
Cat: Reminiscences of a Stamp-Dealer. London: And I realized that Rose was a much more
Cassell & Company Ltd, 1958. 159 + (1) pp, colorful character than the average stamp
numbered in Roman numerals till v, then a blank dealer! And, trouble did eventually catch up
page, and then 7-159. Hardbound in dark green with him; in 1960 as he approached his late
cloth with gilt lettering on spine. Dustjacket.
Price 10/6 on dust jacket front panel. years, he was arrested, tried and jailed.
1 of 10
Figure 1. Front Cover of Ten Under Cat (1958) along with
the dust jacket inside panels giving a synopsis of its
contents.
stamps in bulk.
2 of 10
was returning to his country, held the lease.
Rose bought the lease and opened his shop
near the end of 1945.
3 of 10
Figure 4. A 1953 Coronation first
day cover from Australia, where
Collegiate’s address is shown as
123, High St., Eton, Windsor.
Source: eBay (item no.:
284058764986, seller: fahlagoon).
Accessed January 10, 2023.
4 of 10
Figure 5. The Jubilee Jamboree commemorative stamps (Scott 334-336). Source: https://www.gbstamprolls.com/
queen-elizabeth-ii/boy-scout-jamboree. Accessed January 10, 2023.
Mayflower Stamp Co. Ltd. (Mayflower) be the official first day covers in 12 designs, four of
sole distribution agent of (official) first day which were used for the Jamboree. Themes
covers for the Jubilee Jamboree. Mayflower included the (a) Jubilee Jamboree (gathering
was specifically created for this purpose. Rose of Scouts), (b) Jubilee Rover Moot (gathering
was one of the five directors, the managing of Rover Scouts), (c) Jubilee Indaba Camp
director in fact, while the other four were (gathering of Scout leaders), and (d) Brownsea
“names which would add distinction to any Island (the first Scout camp). The covers were
board.” To bring about legitimacy to the cancelled with the special postmark slogan
venture, Rose cleverly invited respected “Jubilee Jamboree – Sutton Coldfield” and
gentlemen to the board, one of whom was the from the Jamboree Camp Post Office.
Marquess of Donegall to become the
chairman. The Marquees was told that Mayflower advertised the offering of the
Mayfair was a partly charitable, partly profit- first three designs widely, both via flyers as
making concern; he was even induced to well as advertisements in the print media
invest £500 in the company! (Figure 7). The former, circulated among
Scouting groups and others, mentioned that
There was disquiet in the post office regards the cancellations applied to the covers would
to this arrangement. On November 3, 1956, make them “unique” and that should cause
the assistant postmaster general discussed them to “increase in value from the date of
the proposals regarding the Mayflower
arrangement with Sir John Wilson, keeper of
the Royal Philatelic Collection (Figure 6). Sir
John had strong opinions about releasing
stamps outside the Post Office before the
issue date so that Mayflower could affix them
on covers.8 He also viewed involvement with
the Mayflower with great concern.
5 of 10
Figure 7. Advertisement of
Mayflower Stamp Co. in The
American Philatelist, April 1957.
Rose opened a New York office to
deal with American orders.
Interestingly, while the British flyers
(and presumably advertisements)
showed the designs (a), (b), and (c,)
this advertisement shows (a), (c),
and (d). For some reason, the Rover
Moot design was substituted by the
Brownsea Island one in America.
6 of 10
investors are kept happy until such time as
they begin to wonder if they will ever see their
money,” Shaw said.
Figure 8. John Astor (1923-1987). Hugh Astor, who was also the deputy
Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ chairman of The Times Publishing Co. Ltd.,
John_Astor_(1923-1987). said that he paid £217, 10 shillings for some
Burma stamps, being assured that in three
months they should be worth double.
charge alleged the fraudulent conversion of However, he never received any money from
£315 worth of St. Helena stamps from Waldorf either Rose’s company or from the man
Astor. himself.
Four more charges involved alleged A customer named John Arnold testified
agreements or fraudulent conversion of that he made Rose’s acquaintance when he
stamps belonging to Sophie Germaine Gasner. walked into his Eton shop in 1954 to make a
A further charge alleged the fraudulent simple purchase. By September, he had
conversion of £600 worth of Jubilee Jamboree invested £2,200. Over time he joined
stamps from vice admiral Sir (Cecil) Charles Collegiate as a part-time salesman and later
Hughes-Hallett (Figure 9) in London three assisted at the firm’s Strand shop. In
years earlier. November 1954, Arnold was made a director o
Initial Hearings
On June 9, 1960, opening the case for the
prosecution, Sebag Shaw, counsel for the
Board of Trade, accused Rose of operating his
business “with the object of filching large
sums of money from people whom he
persuaded to buy stamps, not in the ordinary
way of stamp collecting but as an investment.
He said that the accused was “conducting a Figure 9. (Cecil) Charles Hughes-
bucket shop, except that his stock-in-trade Hallett by Walter Stoneman,
was not securities in the ordinary way, but February 1949. (Courtesy National
stamps.” “The pots are kept boiling and the Portrait Gallery, London.)
7 of 10
Collegiate, but he never attended a board 20 charges. He pleaded “not guilty” to all of
meeting or took part in the company’s them. On November 28, 1960, the trial opened
business. Over three years and before he left and lasted three weeks.
the company in 1958, he handed over nearly
£24,000 to the company, including by The Queen’s counsel, Neville Faulks,
borrowing money from his bank by providing brought all of Rose’s trickeries into the open.
as collateral rent from property he held. He He clarified the three types of Rose’s frauds.
got, in return 5,000 shares in a stamp
company; those shares were now worthless. The “investment fraud” was getting people
to buy stamps as investments by making
Yet another conned investor, Hughes- reckless statements and promising false
Hallett said that in the beginning of 1957 he promises concerning the extent to which
invested £600 in Boy Scout stamps having stamps would likely increase in value within a
received an assurance that he would get back short time. The “fraudulent conversion” was
a minimum of £850. Rose had told him that he the practice of inviting the public to invest in
would make a probable profit of 200 percent stamps that Rose would retain and sell for
from handling the Jubilee Jamboree first day profit at an opportune time. This was the
covers. When his solicitors wrote to Rose, fraud most people fell for. The third type of
Hughes-Hallett received payments for £100, fraud concerned the Boy Scouts Jamboree,
£50, £25, and £10 (note the sums declining wherein Rose collected £40,000 but failed to
with time likely as money ran out), the last return most of it.
coming in a few weeks earlier.
The jury took four and a half hours to find
Another witness, Major Martin Gubbins, him guilty on 12 counts involving fraudulent
company director of Trevor Wood, Ascot, said conversions, false pretenses, and carrying on
that in 1956 he had two successful business when an undischarged bankrupt. He
transactions with Rose. Later Rose told him of was found not guilty on 8 charges of recklessly
his Mayflower venture, which the major making misleading or deceptive forecast and
thought he might make a killing in. He of fraudulent conversion.
invested £500, and his two sisters £250 each.
Apart from a check for £25 received 12 On December 19, 1960, Judge Aarvold
months prior, he had received nothing except sentenced him to 6 years jail and barred him
“further promises.” from management of any company for five
years after the end of his sentence. He told
Ronald Gardner, acting on behalf for Mr. H. Rose, “There was a fraud of which you were
Sawbridge, said he had paid Rose £8,000 to well aware when you committed it. … It was
buy stamps. Of this, only £2,000 was repaid varied in its design and prolonged in its
and in October 1956, Gardner had threatened operation … It involved obtaining the trust of
proceedings. In November 1957, Sawbridge your victims and then avoiding discovery by
received a check for £6,911 which was falsehoods, evasions and false promises. … It
postdated to March 1958. This wasn’t is obvious to anyone that you are a man in
accepted as it was dated so far ahead and by whom it is extremely dangerous to place any
then no more money was forthcoming. trust or reliance.” Further, with reference to
the Boy Scouts Jamboree, he said, “… you did
The Marquess of Donegall, appearing as a not hesitate to use the fair name of the Boy
witness, said that he accepted an invitation Scouts Association to further your frauds.”
from Rose to become the chairman of
Mayflower but that he had nothing to do with Epilogue
its day-to-day administration. While £50,000
was promised to the Boy Scouts Association, Philatelic rascals and ruffians of all sorts
the Marquess said he believed some have been recorded since the beginnings of
installments were paid but the reminder was stamp collecting in the 1860s. Rose was not
not because there was no more money . the first, and certainly not the last, who tried
to scan and defraud the unsuspecting. So long
Other witnesses included Arthur Robin Hill, as (even supposedly sophisticated and
who said he lost £9,000, and Sophie Gassner, shrewd) people get carried away by greed and
who invested £2,600 but recovered only too-good-to-be-true schemes, conmen such
£1,000. as Rose will be around to dip their hands into
victims’ pockets.
Trial and Sentencing
After the trial, one does not hear of Rose. He
Rose was committed to trial at Old Bailey on
8 of 10
seems to have vanished into obscurity. If
anyone has any further information, please “‘Stamp Dealer could Charm Birds out of
get in touch with the editor or me. Trees’ Q.C.” The Daily Mail. November 29, 1960.
9 of 10
Endnotes
1
At the time of his trial in 1960, newspapers reported
his age at either 56 or 57. I haven’t been able to find
the exact date of his birth; or death, for that matter.
2
This equates to more than £6 million in today’s
numbers.
3
Reviews of the book were published in the popular
press late January 1958. Since the copyright page of
the book mentions the year of publication as 1958,
this implies that the book came out in the beginning
of January 1958.
4
The reader is directed to articles by Page and Walker
and the website of GB Stamp Rolls for further
information on the stamps and FDCs of the Jubilee
Jamboree.
5
A Scout Jamboree, Scoutersʼ Indaba (meeting) and
Rover Moot was held from August 1-12, 1958 in
Sutton Park, a natural park of 2,400 acres, in Sutton
Coldfield, Warwickshire. The Jamboree marked dual
milestones as it was both the 50th anniversary of the
Scouting movement since its inception Brownsea
Island and the 100th anniversary of the birth of
Scouting's founder Robert Baden-Powell. About
33,000 Scouts from 90 countries camped for 12 days.
6
More than £8 in today’s money; a significant sum for
one FDC. These official FDCs are available on eBay for
a few pounds / dollars to this day.
7
This is a huge sum; about £1.3 million in today’s
equivalent.
8
In a meeting dated October 24, 1956, between the
Boy Scouts Association, Mayflower, and the Assistant
PMG, Mayflower requested that the three stamps be
given to them in advance so that they could affix them
on the 6 million covers. The post office was very
averse to the idea since it was impossible to guarantee
that, of the 18 million stamps, none went astray.
Finally, stamp affixing machines made by Vacuumatic
Ltd. was purchased for this purpose.
9
The Post Office sold first day covers for 2 shillings
each, but orders needed to be for no fewer than 60
covers. This meant that the only buyers would be
dealers. The covers had to be provided by the
customer bearing their full postal address and had to
be of one of three specified sizes. Many “unofficial”
FDCs were thus created.
10
Page (1992) quotes the Stanley Gibbons Specialised
Catalogue, which states that 60,632 covers were
“serviced.” Does this number apply only to the
Mayflower FDCs or to both the Mayflower and the Post
Office ones?
11
This number was revealed during Rose’s trial.
Nodder (1961), however, mentioned the amount as
£700.
12
In July 1958, the provisional account of the Jamboree
showed a net loss of £96,500; it is not known whether
this loss included the amounts not received from
Mayflower. The loss could have been lower had
Mayflower paid the Boy Scouts Association the
minimum amount of £50,000 it has earlier guaranteed.
10 of 10