Republic of the Philippines

NATIONAL POLICE COMMISSION

ISABELA POLICE PROVINCIAL OFFICE
CAUAYAN CITY POLICE STATION
CAUAYAN CITY, ISABELA

MEMORANDUM

FOR  Provincial Director

Isobelo Police Provinciol Office
Boli$oton,Ilo$on,Isobelo
%Attn Invest Bronch&

FROM Chief Of Police

SUB(ECT Spot Report on Shooting Incident

)ATE  NOVEMBER *, + 15

1/ Reference Blotter Entr0 No/ 1112 3ote3 Nove4ber * +15/

+/ Pleose be infor4e3 thot on or obout 25 p4 of this 3ote thot o shootin$ inci3ent tronspire3
ot the Boron$o0 6oll of Minonte 1 Couo0on Cit0 Isobelo 7here in the victi4 7os i3entifie3
os
Ro$er Pol4o 0 Recto,55 0eors ol3, 4orrie3, tric0cle 3river on3 o resi3ent of Minonte +
Couo0on Cit0 Isobelo, 7hile the ot suspect 7os i3entifie3 os SPO+ MANUEL REYES Y
PE)RO, 51 0eors ol3, 4orrie3, presentl0 ossi$ne3 ot Lo Union Police Stotion on3 o
resi3ent of Minonte 1 Couo0on Cit0 Isobelo/

5/ Investi$otion con3ucte3 3isclose3 thot on the soi3 3ote,SPO+ MANUEL REYES Y PE)RO 7ent
to the house of RO8ER PALMA to o3vice to stop thot the lou3 4usic of vi3eo9e but Pol4o
on3 his co4ponion 3i3 not po0 ottention thot resulte3 to 4isun3erston3in$ 7herein SPO+
Re0es soi3 this stote4ent : ;opo$ 3i 9o0o titi$il, boborilin 9o 9o0o</ Therefore Ro$er Pol4o
soi3 thot he 7ill report to the boron$o0 but SPO+ Re0es soi3 : hin3i o9o nototo9ot
so boron$o0= Mo$re9lo4o 9o0o=< Thus, Ro$er Pol4o 7ent to the boron$o0 holl to os9 for
ossistonce 7ithout 9no7in$ thot SPO+ Re0es follo7e3 hi4 ultere3 these 7or3 to
>uote o$oinst the victi4
:PAPATAYIN ;ITA WALA YA;A=< on3 shot Ro$er Pol4o in his heo3 thot couse3 his
instont 3eoth/ The suspect 7os orreste3 on3 recovere3 fro4 his 3irect possession on3
control is one
%1& 244 beretto pistol 7ith seriol nu4ber ABC 1+5@5 on3 one %1& 4o$oine loo3e3 7ith 1+
live o44os on3 i44e3iotel0 brou$ht to the police stotion for in>uest procee3in$/
 

@/ For infor4otion/

MANIN G VENEZUELA
Police Senior Inspector
REPUBLIC OF T6E P6ILIPPINES/&
PROVINCE OF ISABELA/& S/S
CITY OF CAUAYAN//&

A$$IDAVIT O$ ITNESS

I, NESTOR % ANDRES, 55 0eors ol3, 4orrie3, boron$o0 9o$o7o3 on3

presentl0 resi3in$ ot Minonte 1, Couo0on Cit0 Isobelo ofter hovin$ been 3ul0 s7orn to in
occor3once 7ith the lo7, 3o hereb0 3eposes on3 stote

Thot on Nove4ber *, +15 ot obout 25 in the ofternoon 7hile con3ucte3 40 3ut0 on
our Boron$o0 6oll I so7 the victi4 Ro$er R 0 Pol4o to$ether 7ith the suspect Spo+ Monuel
Re0es 0 pe3ro livin$ 7ith the conversotion ultere3 these 7or3s to >uote o$oinst the for4er
PAPATAYIN ;ITA WALAN8 YA;A=/

Thereot I so7 the victi4 shot b0 the soi3 suspect on3 sustoine3 $un shot 7oun3 on
his heo3 on3 7os rushe3 to Couo0on Speciolist 6ospitol but pronounce3 3eo3 on orrivol
b0 )r/ To4os Nicolos III otten3in$ ph0sicion/

Thot I eecute3 this offi3ovitDstote4ent to ottest the verocit0 of ofore4entione3 focts

on3 to support file chor$eDs in court o$oinst the suspect/

IN WITNESS W6EREOF, I hove hereunto offie3 40 si$noture this * th 3o0 of Nove4ber

+15 ot Couo0on Cit0 Isobelo/

Ne&tor % Andre&

SUBCRIBE) AN) SWORN TO before 4e this * th 3o0 of Nove4ber +15 ot Couo0on Cit0,
Isobelo/

 A34inisterin$ Officer 
 Republic of the Philippines
NATIONAL POLICE
COMMISSION P6ILIPPINE
NATIONAL POLICE
Civil Securit0 8roup
Fireor4s on3 Eplosives
Office
Co4p Cro4e, ueon Cit0

Control No/112111+1+15*
MEMORANDUM

FORPCINSP MANIN G VENEZUELA

Chief of Police
Couo0on Police Stotion
Couo0on Cit0, Isobelo

FROMC, F EO

SUB(ECT  $irearm Record& Verification Report

)ATENOVEMBER *, +15

1/ Reference  Me4o fro4 thot office Nove4ber *, +15 7ith subject so4e os obove/

+/ ICOW the obove reference, be infor4e3 thot per verificotion fro4 recor3s of this office, one
%1& SPO+ Monuel Re0es 0 Pe3ro of Boron$o0 Minonte 1, Couo0on Cit0, Isobelo is o
license3Dre$istere3 fireor4 hol3er of coliber 244 beretto pistol 7ith seriol nu4ber ABC 1+5@5
os of this 3ote/

5/ Further be infor4e3 thot os of this 3ote, coliber 244 beretto pistol 7ith seriol nu4ber
ABC 1+5@5 is o license3Dre$istere3 fireor4 per verificotion fro4 recor3s of this office/

@/ For infor4otion/

FOR T6E C6IEF, FEO

ARNOLD CANADA VILLANUEVA

Police Senior Inspector
 Asst/ Chief, Recor3s Section, FL)
 Republic of the Philippines
NATIONAL PROSECUTION SERVICE O$
$ICE O$ T(E PROVINCIAL PROSECUTOR
Couo0on Cit0, Isobelo

People of the Philippines Cri4inol Cose Nr

Plointiff
 
1versus1 For

Monuel Re0es 0 Pe3ro, resi3ent

Of Br$0/ Minonte 1, Couo0on Cit0, Isobelo MURDER
  Accuse3
1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

CRIMINAL COMPLAINT

The un3ersi$ne3 Chief of Police of Couo0on Police Stotion, Couo0on Isobelo, un3er
ooth, occuse Monuel Re0es 0 Pe3ro of the cri4e of MUR)ER, 3efine3 on3 penolie3 un3er
orticle +@H of the Revise3 Penol Co33e, co44itte3 os follo7s

:Thot on Nove4ber *, +15 ot obout 25 in the evenin$, o cell phone coll
receive3 b0 personnel of Couo0on Police Stotion fro4 Br$0/ ;o$o7o3 Nestor B/ An3res
of Minonte 1, Couo0on Cit0 thot SPO+ Monuel Re0es 0 Pe3ro, 51 0eors ol3, 4orrie3,
presentl0 ossi$ne3 ot Lo Union Police Stotion on3 o resi3ent of Br$0/ Minonte
1, Couo0on Cit0 shot Ro$er R/ Pol4o in his heo3 thot couse3 his instont 3eoth 7ith the
use3 of colibre 244 ot the boron$o0 holl of the soi3 ploce/ Upon receipt of the report,
teo4 le3 b0 the COP procee3e3 ot the soi3 ploce on3 upon orrivol thereot, soi3 teo4
to$ether 7ith the soi3 Br$0/ ;o$o7o3 so7 SPO+ Monuel Re0es 0 Pe3ro in the
Boron$o0 holl on3 orreste3 hi4/ Recovere3 fro4 his 3irect possession on3 control is
one %1& 244
Beretto pistol 7ith seriol nu4ber ABC 1+5@5 on3 one %1& 4o$oine loo3e3 7ith 1+ live
o44os/ Soi3 suspect to$ether 7ith the recovere3 ite4s 7os brou$ht ot Couo0on Cit0
Police Stotion/<

CONTRARY TO LAW
Couo0on Cit0, Isobelo, Nove4ber *, +15

MANIN G) VENEZUELA
Police Chief Inspector
Chief of Police
 
EJ6IBITS
:A<1 Picture of one %1& colibre 244 beretto 7ith seriol nu4ber ABC 1+5@5 on3 one %1&
4o$oine loo3e3 7ith 1+ live o44os/

WITNESS

1/ PO1 Bobb0 A$ustin K Couo0on Cit0 Police Stottion, Couo0on Cit0, Isobelo
+/ PO1 Chorlton Estobillo (o0 1 13o
5/ Br$0/ ;o$o7o3 Nestor B/ An3res K Br$0/ Minonte 1, Couo0on Cit0, Isobelo

SUBSCRIBE) AN) SWORN to before 4e this  th 3o0 of Nove4ber +15 ot Couo0on Cit0,
Isobelo, Philippines/ An3 thot I hereb0 certif0 thot I hove personoll0 eo4ine3 the herein
offiont thot I o4 full0 convince3 thot he voluntoril0 eecute3 on3 un3erstoo3 their cri4inol
co4ploint/
 REPUBLIC OF T6E P6ILIPPINES/&
PROVINCE OF ISABELA/& S/S
CITY OF CAUAYAN//&

*OINT A$$IDAVIT O$ ARREST

We PO+ AGUSTIN %O%%Y PO+ CAPO-UIAN *ERON A N) PO+ ESTAVILLO

C(ARLTON *AY, le$ol o$es on3 presentl0 ossi$ne3 ot Couo0on Police Stotion Isobelo
ofter  hovin$ been 3ul0 s7orn to in occor3once 7ith the lo7, 3o hereb0 3epose3 on3
stote the follo7in$

1/ Thot on or obout 25 PM of Nove4ber *, +15 o cell phone coll receive3 b0 personnel of
Couo0on Police Stotion fro4 Br$0/ ;o$o7o3 Nestor B/ An3res of Minonte 1, Couo0on Cit0 thot
SPO+ Monuel Re0es 0 Pe3ro, 51 0eors ol3, 4orrie3, presentl0 ossi$ne3 ot Lo Union Police
Stotion on3 o resi3ent of Br$0/ Minonte 1, Couo0on Cit0 shot Ro$er R/ Pol4o in his heo3 thot
couse3 his instont 3eoth 7ith the use3 of colibre 244 ot the boron$o0 holl of the soi3 ploce/
Upon receipt of the report, teo4 le3 b0 the COP procee3e3 ot the soi3 ploce on3 upon orrivol
thereot, soi3 teo4 to$ether 7ith the soi3 Br$0/ ;o$o7o3 so7 SPO+ Monuel Re0es 0 Pe3ro in
the Boron$o0 holl on3 orreste3 hi4/ Recovere3 fro4 his 3irect possession on3 control is one
%1& 244 Beretto pistol 7ith seriol nu4ber ABC 1+5@5 on3 one %1& 4o$oine loo3e3 7ith 1+
live o44os/

+/ Thot 7e %PO1 Bobb0 A$ustin, PO1 (eron Copo>uion on3 PO1 Chorlton (o0
Estovillo& i44e3iotel0 orreste3 the suspect on3 thereofter infor4e3 hi4 of his constitutionol
ri$hts in lon$uo$e on3 3iolect 9no7n b0 hi4 in the presence of Boron$o0 Electe3 Officiols/

5/ Thot 7e brou$ht the suspect to the Police Stotion for further investi$otion on3
proper  3isposition

@/ Thot 7e ore eecutin$ this offi3ovitDstote4ent to ottest the verocit0 of the ofore4entione3
focts on3 to support the filin$ of oppropriote chor$eDs in Court o$oinst the orreste3 person/

IN WITNESS W6EREOF, We hereb0 offie3 our si$notures this  3o0 of Nove4ber
+15 ot Couo0on Cit0, Isobelo/

PO+ %O%%Y AGUSTIN PO+ *ERON CAPO-UIAN PO+ C(ARLTON *AY ESTAVILLO
 Affiont Affiont Affiont

SUBCRIBE) AN) SWORN to before 4e this 3o0 of Nove4ber +15 ot Couo0on Cit0, Isobelo

MANIN G VENEZUELA
Police Senior Inspector
Chief of Police

CERTIFICATION

T6IS IS TO CERTIFY thot I hove personoll0 eo4ine3 the offionts on3 I o4 full0 sotisfie3 on3
convince3 thot the0 voluntoril0 eecute3 the fore$oin$ offi3ovit on3 un3erstoo3 the
contents thereof/

MANIN G VENEZUELA
Police Senior Inspector
Chief of Police
 NATIONAL POLICE COMMISSION ISA
%ELA POLICE PROVINCIAL O$$ICE
CAUAYAN CITY POLICE STATION
CAUAYAN CITY, ISABELA

MEMORANDUM

FOR  The Chief and Explo&ive Office

Co4p Cro4e, ueon Cit0
%Attn C, Recor3s Section, FL)

FROMCOMP AC C o44on3er 

SUB(ECT  $irearm& Verification Re/0e&t for

)ATENOVEMBER , +15

1/ Reference  Spot report 3ote3  

+/ Re>uest con3ucts verificotion to the person SPO+ Monuel Re0es 0 Pe3ro, 51

0eors ol3, 4orrie3, presentl0 ossi$ne3 ot Lo union PS on3 o resi3ent of boron$o0 Minonte 1,
Couo0on Cit0, Isobelo 7hether the person is fireor4 license hol3er or of on0 9in3 of fireor4s in
0our office
ofter confiscote3 fro4 his 3irect possession on3 control one %1& 244 coliber pistol beretto 7ith
seriol nu4ber ABC 1+5@5 on3 one %1& 4o$oine loo3e3 7ith 1+ lives A44os/ on3 li9e7ise to
3eter4ine the i3entit0 of the re$istere3 o7ner/

5/ Further re>uest furnish this office o cop0 of the result of 0our verificotion/

Thon9 0ou for 0our usuol cooperotion on this 4otter/

FOR T6E C6IEF OF POLICE

MANIN G) VENEZUELA
Police Senior Inspector
 Province of I&a1ela
Ca0a2an Speciali&t
(o&pital
San $ermin, Ca0a2an Cit2
I&a1ela Tel/ No/ %H& *@+1*5
P6IL6EALT6 ACCRE)ITE)

MEDICAL CERTI$ICATE
This is to certif0 thot SPO3 MANUEL REYES 2 PEDRO, 4+ 0eors ol3, male,
No4e of P otient A$e Se

 ma rried 7ith stote3 resi3ence of Minante +, Ca0a2an Cit2, I&a1ela

Moritol Stotus Co4plete A33ress

7os eo4ine3 on3 treote3 in this hospitol os OUT PATIENT on

Novem1er 56, 35+7  7ith the follo7in$ i4pressionsD3io$nosisDfin3in$s

)ote of Eo4inotionDtreot4ent

Ph2&icall2 and mentall2 fit

This certificotion is issue3 upon re>uest of the intereste3 port0 for 7hotsoever
le$ol on3 le$iti4ote purposeDs it 4o0 serve hi4Dher

8iven this *th 3o0 of Nove4ber +15 ot Couo0on Speciolist 6ospitol, Couo0on

Cit0, Isobelo Philippines/

IZA C) TA%AO, MD
 Medical Officer III
Licen&e No) 8 5+34976
 POLICE %LOTTER

On or obout 25 PM of Nove4ber *, +15 o cellphone coll receive3 b0 this

Police Stotion fro4 Boron$o0 ;o$o7o3 Nestor B An3res on3 reporte3 thot o
shootin$ inci3ent tronspire3 ot the Boron$o0 6oll of Minonte 1, Couo0on Cit0
Isobelo/ Upon receipt of the report, the teo4 le3 b0 COP Veneuelo procee3e3
ot the soi3 ploce on3 upon orrivol thereot, soi3 teo4 to$ether 7ith the
soi3
Boron$o0 9o$o7o3 so7 the victi4 l0in$ 7ith his bloo3 i3entifie3 os Ro$er Pol4o
0 Recto, 55 0eors ol3, 4orrie3, tric0cle 3river on3 o resi3ent of Minonte
1, Couo0on Cit0, Isobelo 7hile the suspect i3entifie3 os SPO+ Monuel Re0es
0 Pe3ro, 51 0eors ol3, 4orrie3, presentl0 ossi$ne3 ot Lo union Police Stotion
on3 o resi3ent of Boron$o0 Minonte 1, Couo0on Cit0 Isobelo/ Initiol
investi$otion 3isclose3Dcon3ucte3 thot SPO+ Monuel Re0es 0 Pe3ro 7ent to
the house of Ro$er Pol4o 0 Recto to o3vice to stop the lou3 4usic of vi3eo9e
but Pol4o on3 his co4ponion 3i3 not po0 ottention thot resulte3 to o
4isun3erston3in$ 7herein SPO+ Re0es soi3 the stote4ent :9opo$ 3i 9o0o
tu4i$il, boborilin 9o 9o0o< therefore Ro$er Pol4o soi3 thot he 7ill report to the
boron$o0 but SPO+ Re0es soi3 this stote4ent : hin3i o9o nototo9ot= Mo$re9lo4o
9o0o= Wolon$ boron$o0 boron$o0 so o9in=< thus, Ro$er Pol4o 7ent to boron$o0
holl 7ithout 9no7in$ thot SPO+ Re0es follo7e3 hi4 on3 shot Ro$er Pol4o in
his heo3 thot couse3 his instont 3eoth/ SPO+ Re0es 7ere orreste3 on3
recovere3 fro4 his 3irect
possession on3 control is one %1& 4o$oine loo3e3 7ith 1+ live o44os/
The suspect 7os orreste3 on3 brou$ht ot Couo0on Police Stotion to$ether 7ith
the recovere3 ite4s for proper 3isposition/
 Republic of the Philippines
NATIONAL POLICE COMMISSION
Philippine Notionol Police
Isobelo Police Provinciol Office
CAUAYAN CITY POLICE STATION
Couo0on Cit0, Isobelo

Nove4ber *, +15

The 6onoroble Cit0 Prosecutor

Notionol Prosecution Service
Cit0 Prosecution Office
Couo0on Cit0 Isobelo

Sir,
I hove the 6onor to sen3 to 0our $oo3 office the ottoche3 recor3s of inves$otion for o
cose of MUR)ER 7herein the victi4 7os one Ro$er Pol4o 0 Recto, 55 0eors ol3 4orrie3,
tric0cle 3river on3 o resi3ent of Minonte 1, Couo0on Cit0, Isobelo/ The suspects 7ere

SPO3 MANUEL REYES 2 PEDRO, 51 0eors ol3, 4orrie3, presentl0 ossi$ne3 ot Lo

Union Police Stotion on3 o resi3ent of Br$0/ Minonte 1, Couo0on Cit0, Isobelo %un3er orrest&/

%ATLAR8E)&

 ATTAC6MENTSDENCLOSURES

1/ S7orn Stote4ent of Co4ploint

+/ S7orn Stote4ent of
Witness 5/ Affi3ovit of Arrest
@/ )ocu4entor0
Evi3ence o& Spot
Report
b& )eoth Certificote on3 Autops0DNecrops0 Report of
Victi4 c& Copies of Photo$rophs on3 S9etch of the Cri4e
Scene 3& Copies of Photo$rophs of the Victi4
e& Copies of Photo$rophs of the Pieces of Evi3ence Recovere3 on3 Seie3 on3

$ACTS O$ T(E CASE8

On or obout 25 PM of Nove4ber *, +15, o cell phone coll receive3 b0 personnel of
Couo0on Cit0 Police Stotion fro4 Br$0/ ;o$o7o3 Nestor B/ An3res of Minonte 1, Couo0on Cit0
thot SPO+ Monuel Re0es 0 Pe3ro, 51 0eors ol3, 4orrie3, presentl0 ossi$ne3 ot Lo UniBon
Police Stotion on3 o resi3ent of Br$0/ Minonte 1, Couo0on Cit0 shot Ro$er R/ Pol4o in
his heo3 thot couse his instont 3eoth 7ith the use3 of coliber 244 ot the Boron$o0 holl of
soi3 ploce/ Upon receipt of the report, teo4 le3 b0 the COP procee3e3 ot soi3 ploce on3 upon
orrivol thereot, soi3 teo4 to$ether 7ith the soi3 Br$0/ ;o$o7o3 so7 SPO+ Monuel Re0es 0
Pe3ro in
the Br$0/ 6oll on3 orreste3 hi4/ Recovere3 fro4 his 3irect possession on3 control is one %1&
244 beretto Pistol 7ith Seriol Nu4ber ABC 1+5@5 on3 one %1& 4o$oine loo3e3 7ith 1+ live
o44os/ Soi3 suspect to$ether 7ith the recovere3 ite4s 7os brou$ht ot Couo0on Cit0 Police
Stotion/

On occount of the fore$oin$, o cose of MURDER is bein$ referre3 o$oinst the suspect
for proper 3isposition/ Further, 0our o3viceDreco44en3otion on the 4otter sholl be
hi$hl0 oppreciote3/

Ver0 trul0 0ours,

MANIN G) VENEZUELA
 NATIONAL POLICE COMMISSION
Philippine Notionol Police
Isobelo Police Provinciol Office
CAUAYAN CITY POLICE STATION
Couo0on Cit0, Isobelo

CYNI)MS

MEMORANDUM

FOR  T(E C(IE$

  Rurol 6eolth Unit
  Couo0on Cit0

FROM Chief of Police

SUB(ECT  Re>ues t of Police

)ATEN o ve4ber ,+ 15

1/ Re>uest con3uct outops0 eo4inotion to the co3over of Ro$er Pol4o 0 Recto, 55 0eors ol3,
4orrie3, tric0cle 3river on3 o resi3ent of Minonte 1 Couo0on Cit0 Isobelo 7ho 7os shot to 3eoth
b0 SPO+ Monuel Re0es 0 Pe3ro/ The co3over 7os 4ove3 ot Soint Peter Funerol ho4e ot Son
Fer4in Couo0on Cit0 Isobelo/

+/ In this re$or3, the un3ersi$ne3 7oul3 li9e to re>uest to 0our $oo3 office the oforesoi3 cose for
proper 3isposition/

5/ Your usuol cooperotion on3 pro4pt oction re$or3in$ this 4otter is ver0 4uch oppreciote3/

@/ Further re>uest oc9no7le3$e/

ANGELIE T) VILLAGANTOL
Police Superinten3ent
   CITY O$ CAUAYAN

Rep01lic of the
Philippine&

City Health Office

 Province of I&a1ela

POST MORTEM E:AMINATION

Nove4ber H, +15

NAME RO8ER PALMA Y RECTO, 55 0eors ol3, 4ole, 4orrie3

 A33ress Minonte +, Couo0on Cit0 Isobelo
)ote M Ti4e of Eo4inotion Nove4ber H, +15 AM
Re>uestin$ Officer AN8ELIE T/ VILLA8ANTOL
 Police Superinten3ent
 PNP Couo0on Cit0 Isobelo

Fin3in$s

1/ 1 c4 J 1 c4 $unshot 7oun3, occipitol oreo, left

+/ No other si$nificont fin3in$s note3/

FELIA E/ MORLA, M/)/

Cit0 6eolth Officer
 Republic of the Philippines
NATIONAL POLICE
COMMISSION P(ILIPPINE
NATIONAL POLICE CAUAYAN
CITY POLICE STATION
Couo0on Cit0, Isobelo

CAUAYAN CITY
POLICE
STATION IPPO

Ca&e Title8 MURDER

Complainant;Victim8 Roger Palma 2
Recto S0&pect&8 Man0el Re2e& 2
Pedro
IS No8 II<56<INVIZE< 3497 Date8
Pro&ec0tor8 Prov);Cit28
CC No8 Date8
Pre&iding * 0dge8 Co0rt8