Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Tesco - Every Little Helps
Tesco - Every Little Helps
A Report on Tesco.com’s
Online Grocery Retail Business in UK
Recommendations to Sustain Growth in Recession
Table of Contents
1. Introduction...........................................................................................................................3
2. Online Grocery Retail Market in UK......................................................................................3
2.1 Advent of Technology in Grocery retailing..............................................................3
2.2 Use of Broadband....................................................................................................3
2.3 Current Economic State of UK.................................................................................4
2.4 Market Players.........................................................................................................5
2.5 SCP Model................................................................................................................6
2.6 Porter’s Five Forces Model......................................................................................7
3. Tesco.com............................................................................................................................10
3.1 Strategic Positioning..............................................................................................10
3.2 Competitive Advantage.........................................................................................11
4. Recommendations...............................................................................................................11
5. Conclusion...........................................................................................................................13
6. References...........................................................................................................................13
7. Bibliography.........................................................................................................................14
8. Appendix..............................................................................................................................15
1. Market Share...........................................................................................................15
2. SWOT of Tesco.com.................................................................................................15
3. Online Consumer Spending data in UK...................................................................16
4. Broadband Usage Table...........................................................................................16
5. Growth Story Chart..................................................................................................16
6. Financial Performance of Tesco.com.....................................................................17
Page | 2
Economic & Global Context - MNP058N - MBA Mukesh Kumar
1. INTRODUCTION
This report attempts to gain an insight into the online grocery retail market in UK and
its biggest player “Tesco.com”, in order to investigate & analyses the market using
SCP model and Porter’s five forces model (Porter, M. E., 2004). Statistical data is
used wherever necessary to substantiate the claims made. Recommendations are
made with respect to the current ‘Competitive Advantage’ (Porter, M. E., 1998) and
‘Strategic Positioning’ of Tesco.com in the light of current economic recession, and
the resultant change in consumer behaviour & shopping preferences. SWOT analysis
of Tesco.com and other market data is also provided in the Appendix.
The UK online grocery market is part of the overall grocery market, and is a little
more than a decade old. Online retail market began with the dotcom boom in 90s
and is in its second phase after dotcom bust of 2000. Online retailing is entirely
dependent on a few factors of success in the online market, most importantly
Technology & Physical Distribution. (Key Note, 2007).
Total estimated size of online grocery market in UK is £4.2 billion of which Tesco.com
controls about 60% share alone (Mintel, 2009).
Technology is the key driver of online grocery retail business in UK. Companies are
using websites and IT infrastructure to support & manage orders, payments, and
distribution of goods. Sophisticated systems are used to gather consumer
intelligence by analyzing the patterns of consumer spending and buying based on
numerous parameters. RFID systems are used for stock-picking & replenishments of
stocks (Datamonitor, 2008a).
Page | 3
Economic & Global Context - MNP058N - MBA Mukesh Kumar
Declining GDP
Inflation
Annual inflation rates - 12 month percentage change
Page | 4
Economic & Global Context - MNP058N - MBA Mukesh Kumar
Source: http://www.statistics.gov.uk/cci/nugget.asp?id=19
The largest upward pressure on the CPI annual rate came from food and non-
alcoholic beverages (ONS, 2009). The largest individual factor was the price of
vegetables which rose by more than a year ago. There were smaller upward
pressures from fruit, mineral waters, soft drinks and juices, bread and cereals, and
meat, partially offset by coffee, tea and cocoa where prices fell this year but rose a
year ago (ONS, 2009).
In online grocery retail market Tesco.com has been the leader in UK (Datamonitor,
2008a) ever since the dotcom revolution, followed by other big online retailers
namely Ocado, Sainsbury’s, ASDA, and Waitrose.
Initially, Tesco.com had about 80% of Online Grocery retail market in the year 1996,
which has declined to about 60% in 2006 (Datamonitor, 2008a).
Only top 5 supermarkets namely Tesco.com, Ocado, Sainsbury’s, ASDA and Waitrose
dominate the online grocery retail market, accounting in 2006 for an estimated
(Concentration Ratio) 90.5% of total online sales (Key Note, 2007). Ocado does not
have retail stores unlike others.
Total UK online grocery market trend by value (£ millions) at current prices years
ending December 2002-2006
£ Million
Total market size of online grocery retail market was about 1800 million pounds in
2006. Tesco.com has been the leader so far Datamonitor (2008a).
Page | 5
Economic & Global Context - MNP058N - MBA Mukesh Kumar
CONDUCT
STRUCTURE
Firms rather match their PERFORMANCE
Oligopolistic prices than lower them Moderate margins
Competition
price leadership concept Huge profits due to
5 top players with
Some differentiation of huge sales
90.5% of market
share (Key Note, groceries by own labels Huge employment
2007) etc. creation
Page | 6
Economic & Global Context - MNP058N - MBA Mukesh Kumar
Threat of New
Entrants (Very
Limited)
Threat of
Substitutes (Low)
Market Concentration: 5 big players with majority market share viz. Tesco.com,
Ocado, Sainsbury’s, Waitrose, and ASDA have Intense competition amongst them.
One company intends to grow by capturing other’s market share, nearly 90% of
market share owned by big 5 companies. (Datamonitor, 2008a).
Rate of Growth of Market: High growth so far, new entrants like Ocado have come
up, and existing companies have increased the coverage area of their delivery
services. Companies grow at the expense of each other (Mintel, 2008).
Cost conditions: Huge economies of scale enjoyed by existing players, thus there is
cut-throat competition among competitors to capture market share only at the
expense of other. High storage cost of grocery and it’s highly perishable nature leads
to intense competition among companies to sell their products and generate cash.
At times companies sell products at loss to cut competition in a particular product
segment (Mintel, 2008).
Page | 7
Economic & Global Context - MNP058N - MBA Mukesh Kumar
Exit barriers: relatively high costs of exiting the market as the distribution model and
technology used for online retailing is customised and every other online retailer has
different distribution model and technology. Integration of technology is a challenge
in itself and carries huge costs, and thus impels companies to compete and stay in
the market (Key Note, 2007).
Existing economies of scale and huge start-up capital/fixed costs requirement deter
new entrants in the market (Datamonitor, 2008b).
Groceries are nearly homogeneous but somewhat differentiated, and there are only
5 big companies dominating the market, that have differentiated and branded their
groceries creatively (premium, value, own brands etc.) to carve a market share for
themselves in the highly brand conscious market (Key Note, 2007).
Technology gives the competitive advantage to existing players, for example the
RFID systems for stock picking & replenishment. Implementing technology takes a lot
of time and new entrants are likely to lag behind (Key Note, 2007).
These factors lead to huge barriers of entry. However, companies who do not have
online grocery retail platforms like Morrisons, Somerfield, LIDL, ALDI, are watching
the market and planning to invest in technology and distribution systems to tap the
online grocery retail market (Rowley, J., 1998).
Power of Buyers
Consumers are price sensitive and they check for lowest prices online. This
intensifies the rivalry among companies to charge lowest prices (TNS World Panel,
2009).
There are only 5 major companies selling groceries online with control of about 90%
market share leaving less room for choice for buyers (Key Note, 2007).
Daily use non-differentiated grocery items, leaves customers with less choice of
substitutes.
There is no switching cost involved other than loosing on the loyalty card benefits
that arise from repeat purchases.
Page | 8
Economic & Global Context - MNP058N - MBA Mukesh Kumar
All this means that consumers have only very limited power to affect a company’s
business as all the companies keep matching prices with one another and some offer
loyalty benefits to existing customers like Tesco.com club-card.
Power of Suppliers
The companies are huge brands compared to many suppliers, though there are
many big brand companies like Parle & Coca Cola whose products are sold by
Tesco.com. These are huge brands and in such a case both the supplier and retailer
enter into mutually beneficial contracts of business so that no one suffers due to
competition in market.
The huge size of companies and huge number of supplier means companies enjoy
power and often squeeze the supplier’s margins by contracting and/or bulk buying
(Key Note, 2007).
There are low switching costs and retailing companies have introduced own brand
labels for products comparable to those of big brands like coca cola and Parle under
their own brand labels.
If retailers collude and do not sell a particular supplier’s product for eg. Coca-Cola
then it’ll be difficult for Coca-Cola to find alternative for that loss of sales and
integrate forward as well; also, competitors of supplier will capture that market
share quickly by contracting with the retailer as the retailer is in possession of
physical retail store in high street where millions of consumers shop everyday.
Threat of Substitutes
Every company responds back to the differentiation attempts of another and sells a
similar grocery product, for example, the recently successful, value for money “own
brand labels”.
Companies know there is no real switching cost involved for customers other than
loosing the loyalty benefits and thus always match products and prices with each
other (TNS Super Panel, 2009).
Page | 9
Economic & Global Context - MNP058N - MBA Mukesh Kumar
All this makes it very difficult for consumers to decide if buying the same grocery
from another retailer will benefit them or not especially when there are loyalty
points to be gained whilst repeating purchases from the same retailer. In fact
companies are growing at the expense of one another.
3. Tesco.com
The UK’s (and worlds) largest online grocery business was started in 1996, and
launched its website i.e. www.Tesco.com in 2000. Tesco.com’s annual online sales
exceed 2.5bn (Datamonitor, 2008b), which is almost more than half the online
grocery market size in UK. It has more than a million active customers and more
than 250,000 orders completed every week (Key Note, 2007).
Tesco.com controls over 60% of UK online grocery market, and makes profits of
more than 100 million. In UK, 6 in every 10 pounds spent by consumers on online
grocery shopping is at Tesco.com (Mintel, 2008).
2. Tesco.com has also opened its first dot-com-only store situated in Croydon; it
enables the company to meet the demand for its home-shopping service that the
local stores are unable to meet. This store is not open for sale to general public
but only handles the online orders (Mintel, 2008).
3. Apart from this Tesco.com has effectively used the loyalty (Rafiq, M., and
Fulford, H., 2005) club-card to retain the huge customer base despite not being
the cheapest retailer in the market. Online grocery retailing is a loyalty business,
build it and maintain trust with customers (Tanskanen, K. Yrjola, H., and
Holmstrom, J., 2002 ).
4. Delivery Systems
Tesco.com has about 1900 delivery vehicles, 300 stores and 9,000 pickers for
online grocery shopping business, and has a separate subsidiary company that
Page | 10
Economic & Global Context - MNP058N - MBA Mukesh Kumar
owns and operates its distribution systems. Such a division leads to efficiency of
operations, cost savings, and financial performance improvement for Tesco.com
as a group of companies (Key Note, 2007).
Only Ocado is still using the warehouse model. Tesco.com has taken the lead in
online grocery retailing market primarily due to technology advantage it had and the
unique non-warehouse business model of distribution (Datamonitor, 2008b).
Tesco.com is a bulk buyer and has been able to keep its prices lower than most
rivals. Use of better technology and least investment in warehouses also enabled
Tesco.com to keep its costs lower compared to rivals (TNS Super Panel, 2009).
Distribution Model
Club-card
Tesco.com launched it’s club-card in 1995, since then it has grown to become the
largest loyalty card in the UK with about 14 million club-card holders (Datamonitor,
2008b). It has been successful to some extent in retaining the customer base of
Tesco.com. Despite not being the lowest cost grocer, Tesco.com has been successful
in utilizing its club-card to retain customer and maintain lead over rivals
(Datamonitor, 2008b).
4. Recommendations
The unprecedented rise in Grocery Inflation this year (ONS, 2009) has made an
impact on shopper behaviour. As a result the prices of almost all groceries have gone
up considerably between 2007 and 2008 (TNS Super Panel, 2009). Over time grocery
retailers will not be able to charge a premium on top of the already inflated grocery
Page | 11
Economic & Global Context - MNP058N - MBA Mukesh Kumar
prices, and consumers will be less willing to pay more. Already, consumers have
shifted more towards discount retailers and low-priced groceries (Mintel, 2008).
Due to recession there will possibly be radical changes in the consumer behaviour
(ref. Appendix 3), and thus, characterizing a different mindset, mood and psychology
of consumers (Ramus, K., and Asger Nielsen, N., 2005). This will be in stark contrast
to the characteristics of consumers in boom time. All this suggests that the market
will not see the kind of growth it has been through, and Tesco.com should prepare
proactively to fight the possible meltdown of the market and achieve growth in the
recession times (TNS World Panel, 2009).
In the short-run in 2009, online grocery retail market may see a sudden rise in
demand, especially for low priced groceries, primarily due to increasing number of
unemployed customers and increasing grocery prices & inflation (ONS, 2009).
Afterwards, the market may begin to stabilize; also, low cost rival ASDA is set to
encroach on the market share of Tesco.com (Key Note, 2007). Ocado is another
player that have snatched a considerable share of market, though it sells niche
products from Waitrose stable (Key Note, 2007).
Sell more low-cost-value for money products, expand the variety of grocery
within low-cost category available online, and put marketing efforts for low-
cost products, invest more in developing own-brand-Labels
Tesco.com should not invest huge cash in buying land for warehouses or
other logistics as the property market is in downturn
Tesco.com should now think of becoming the lowest priced retailer in the
market and compete with ASDA on price. Cost-cutting measures will help
Tesco.com.com to increate profit margin.
Tesco.com should source more of its products from local producers and
farmers in order to reduce costs associated with currency exchange linked
with imported groceries.
Page | 12
Economic & Global Context - MNP058N - MBA Mukesh Kumar
Tesco.com should invest in alternative energy sources link wind & solar
energy to power its technology data warehouses and save on significant
costs.
5. Conclusion
Tesco.com has been a very successful leader in the market so far, and its strategy
including dotcom only stores, RFID technology, and loyalty card has been a huge
success so far. Tesco.com has been able to capture a lion’s share of the market
mainly due to its strategic positioning (Mintel, 2008). However, every successful
company has to maintain the lead and invest strategically to keep the momentum
going. Tesco.com should be cautious of recession, and make efforts to retain and
grow its market share and revenues.
6. References
Clift, P. (2009), “Estates Gazette” [online], issue. 912, p.18, available at:
http://0-web.ebscohost.com.emu.londonmet.ac.uk/ehost/detail?vid=1&hid=16&sid=07b2372a-e0e3-4254-
8c26-fbba70ca705d%40sessionmgr2&bdata=JnNpdGU9ZWhvc3QtbGl2ZQ%3d%3d#db=buh&AN=37601035
Datamonitor (2008a), “Food Retail in the United Kingdom” [online], in Datamonitor, July
2008 Industry Profile, available at:
http://0-web.ebscohost.com.emu.londonmet.ac.uk/ehost/pdf?vid=1&hid=5&sid=ba0cbf8e-dcc0-4472-9c34-
327cf0aec172%40sessionmgr8
Datamonitor (2008b), “Online Retail in the United Kingdom” [online], in Datamonitor, June
2008 Industry Profile, available at:
http://0-web.ebscohost.com.emu.londonmet.ac.uk/ehost/pdf?vid=1&hid=3&sid=ed1720a7-2f3d-4789-a90c-
b15f7e7ded62%40sessionmgr2
Datamonitor (2009), “Tesco Plc” [online], in Datamonitor, 22 Jan 2009 Company Profile,
available at:
http://0-web.ebscohost.com.emu.londonmet.ac.uk/ehost/pdf?vid=1&hid=13&sid=3f949bd6-7650-46f0-9a90-
618dec77a081%40SRCSM1
Hackney, R., Grant, K. and Birtwistle, G. (2006), “The UK grocery business: towards a
sustainable model for virtual markets”, International Journal of Retail & Distribution
Management, Vol. 34 No. 4/5, pp. 354-368
Key Note (2007), “E-Commerce: The Internet Grocery Market” [online], in Griffiths, J. (Ed.),
2007 Market Report, 5th ed., available at: http://www.keynote.co.uk/kn2k1/CnIsapi.dll?
nuni=67312&usr=10948srv=01&alias=kn2k1&uni=1240925069&fld=J&Jump=ViewPDF
Mintel (2008), “Food Retailing – UK – November 2008” [online], available at: http://0-
academic.mintel.com.emu.londonmet.ac.uk/sinatra/oxygen_academic/display/id=280627/display/id=426896?
select_section=280627
Page | 13
Economic & Global Context - MNP058N - MBA Mukesh Kumar
Mintel (2009), “Home Shopping – UK –March 2009” [online], available at: http://0-
academic.mintel.com.emu.londonmet.ac.uk/sinatra/oxygen_academic/search_results/show&/display/
id=395647
Porter, Michael E. (2004), “Competitive Strategy: techniques for analysing industries and
competitors”, New York; London: Free Press
Rafiq, M., and Fulford, H. (2005), “Loyalty Transfer from Offline to Online Stores in the UK
Grocery Industry”, International Journal of Retail & Distribution Management Vol. 33 No. 6,
pp. 444-460
Ramus, K., and Asger Nielsen, N. (2005), “Online Grocery Retailing: What do Consumers
Think”, Internet Research Vol. 15 No. 3, pp. 335-352
Rowley, J. (1998), “Internet Food Retailing: the UK in Context”, British Food Journal, Vol.
100/2, pp. 85–95
Tanskanen, K. Yrjola, H., and Holmstrom, J. (2002),“The way to profitable internet grocery
retailing – six lessons learned”, International Journal of Retail & Distribution Management,
Vol. 30 No. 4, pp. 169-178
TNS Super Panel (2009), “Market Watch Report” [online], available at:
https://www.tnsinfo.com/TNSInfo/Doc/0/FERAEDLQPOQ4P3HFNAVNPG7K8F/P2009%2004%20New
%20Market%20Watch%20Report.XLSS
TNS World Panel (2009), “Consumption in a Recession” [online], in Pandirla, S. (Ed.), 2009
World Panel Hot Topic, available at:
https://www.tnsinfo.com/TNSInfo/Doc/0/IL3CA3RLDFKKP7PKGI0L1KID30/14175_Hot_topics_nov08.html
7. Bibliography
Delaney-Klinger, K., Boyer, K.K. and Frohlich, M. (2003), “The return of on-line grocery
shopping: a comparative analysis of Webvan and Tesco’s operational methods”, The
TQM Magazine, Vol. 15 No. 3, pp. 187-96.
Tesco (2008), “Annual Review and Summary Financial Statement 2008” [online], available
at: http://www.Tesco.comreports/areview08/downloads/Tesco_annual_review_08.pdf
http://www.Tescocorporate.com
8. Appendix
1. Market Share
Page | 14
Economic & Global Context - MNP058N - MBA Mukesh Kumar
Market share (%) of companies in online grocery retail sector in UK, years ending December 2002-2006
Tesco.com’s market share has been declining since 2002 when Ocado started its
business, however, the revenues generated by Tesco.com have been ever increasing and
it remains the market leader, but with a lowered market share year-on-year (Key Note,
2007).
Strengths Weaknesses
Opportunities Threats
Page | 15
Economic & Global Context - MNP058N - MBA Mukesh Kumar
Household expenditure fell 1.0 per cent and is now 0.8 per cent lower than the
fourth quarter of 2007. Consumer expenditure is falling due to unemployment and
recession combined with high grocery prices.
% Change year-on-year
- 128.7 96.8 61.6 31.4
Note: includes residential and small and medium-sized enterprise (SME) connections.
Source: Key Note 2007 Report on - E-commerce: Internet Grocery Market
5. Growth Story
In 1994, online grocery retailing was in nascent stage, by 2000 there were scores of
online retailers selling all possible products under the sun. There was huge hype and
fanfare associated with online retailing, with the tampering down of dotcom market
this hype and fanfare had sobered down, as a result only a few serious players
remained to dominate the market. The market began its journey in mid 90s and is
most likely in the maturity phase currently. This may indicate that the online grocery
market may squeeze in near future due to current economic downturn and political
reasons before it starts to rise again.
Page | 16
Economic & Global Context - MNP058N - MBA Mukesh Kumar
Given the current economic downturn and challenges faced by online payment systems due
to increasing number of online frauds, the market may see a swift decline in online grocery
retailing as consumer’s preferences may shift back to conventional local area retail shops.
This may also be affected by the financial weaknesses faced by large online retailers due to
credit crunch, and the incentives given to small retail shops by the government. More
importantly, consumers in UK have a propensity to prefer locally produced grocery in local
retail shops than the imported and cheap groceries of big online retailers.
6. Financial Performance
As evident from Tesco’s overall performance, its revenue has increased marginally,
whereas profits have steeply declined. Fall in profits is primarily due to fall in the
prices of groceries due to inflation pressure and increasing price competition in the
market. Every other retailer is offering discounts o customers in the current
recessionary times. Tesco.com cannot afford to loose customers by not giving them
discounts and matching competitor’s prices Datamonitor (2008b).
Page | 17