Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 57

Directional Drilling

By
Prof. Abdel-Alim Hashem
Cairo University
Garib 16/04 – 20/04/2006

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 1

Directional Drilling
• When is it used?
• Type I Wells (build and hold)
• Type II Wells (build, hold and drop)
• Type III Wells (build)
• Directional Well Planning & Design

• Survey Calculation Methods


Directional and Horizontal Drilling 2

1
What is Directional Drilling?
Directional Drilling is the process of directing a
wellbore along some trajectory to a
predetermined target.

Basically it refers to drilling in a non-vertical


direction. Even “vertical” hole sometimes require
directional drilling techniques.

Examples: Slanted holes, high angle holes (far


from vertical), Extended Reach Holes, and
Horizontal holes
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 3

Example Directional Wellbore

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 4

2
Non-Vertical
Wellbore θ, α or I
Inclination Angle
n
li natio Z Axis (True Vertical Depth)
Inc e Y
Plan

North

Direction
Angle φ, ε or A

Direction Plane X
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 5

Plan view of a typical oil and gas structure under a lake showing how directional
wells could be used to develop it. Best locations? Drill from lake?
Lease Boundary

Surface Location for Well No. 1


Surface
Location for
Well No. 2
Bottom Hole Location for Well 2

Houses

Oil-Water
Contact

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 6

3
Top View

NOTE: All the


wells are
directional 5 - 50 wells
per platform

Typical offshore development platform with directional


wells.
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 7

Drilling Rig Inside Building

Developing a field under a city using irectionally


drilled wells.
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 8

4
Why not
drill from Maximum
top of lateral
mountain Displacement ?
?

Drilling of directional wells where the reservoir is beneath


a major surface obstruction.

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 9

Cement Plug Fish Lost in Hole and


Unable to Recover

Sidetracked Hole
Around Fish

Sidetracking
around a fish.

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 10

5
Using an old
well to explore Oil Producing
Well Ready to
for new oil by Abandon
sidetracking
Sidetracked
out of the Out of Casing
casing and
drilling Possible
New Oil
directionally.
Old Oil Reservoir

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 11

Horizontal
Departure
to Target
Type II
Build-hold and Drop (“S Type”)
Type I Build and Build-hold Drop and/or
Hold Type Hold (Modified “S” Type)

Continuous
Type III Build

Major types of wellbore trajectories.

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 12

6
Type I Build and Hold Type

Type II Build-hold and Drop (“S Type”)

Type III Continuous Build


Major types of wellbore trajectories.
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 13

Geometry of the build


section.

Build Section

θ Build Radius:
18,000
r1 =
π * BUR
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 14

7
Build Section:

Length of arc, L1 = r1θ1 1

Vertical depth = C’D’ = r1 sin θ1

Horiz. Depart. = DD’ = r1 (1-cos θ1 )


L1 100
r1 = =
θ1 π
θ1 * 18,000
180 r1 =
rad deg π * BUR
BUR = build rate in deg/100 ft

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 15

Start of r1
Buildup
End of Build
Type II

Drop Off
r2

Target

x3
x4
Build-hold-and drop for the case where:
r1 < x 3 and r1 + r 2 < x 4
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 16

8
Type II
Kickoff
End of Build

Maximum
Inclination
Angle
Build-hold-and
drop for the case Drop Off
where:
Target
r1 < x3 and r1 + r2 > x4

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 17

Projected Well Path


Lead Angle
Surface
Location for
Well No. 2

Target at a
Lake
TVD 9,659
Plan View

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 18

9
Example 1: Design of
Directional Well
Design a directional well with the following
restrictions:

•Total horizontal departure = 4,500 ft


•True vertical depth (TVD) = 12,500 ft
•Depth to kickoff point (KOP) = 2,500 ft
•Rate of build of hole angle = 1.5 deg/100 ft

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 19

Example 1: Design
of Directional Well
This is a Type I well (build
and hold)
2500’
1. Determine the maximum Imax
hole angle (inclination) TVD1
required. 10,000’
2. What is the total
HD1
measured depth of the Imax

hole (MD)? 4,500’

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 20

10
Type I: Build-and-Hold

2500’
Imax
TVD1 12,500’
10,000’

HD1 Imax
4,500’ BUR = 1.5 deg/100 ft

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 21

0’
Uniform 1o 30’
Increase in
Drift per 100 ft
of hole drilled

o
10,000’ Try Imax = 27 ??
Vert.
Depth

4,500’ Horizontal
Directional Deviation
and Horizontal Drilling 22

11
1,734

27o
416
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 23

Solution
Type I Well 1.5 deg/100’
2500’ Available depth
= 12,500 - 2,500
Imax
TVD1 = 10,000’

10,000’
From Chart,
o
Imax Try Imax = 27

HD1
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 24

12
Build Section
From chart of 1.5 deg/100’, with Imax = 27o
In the BUILD Section:
MD1 = 1,800’ (27/1.5)
Imax
TVD1 TVD1 = 1,734’
HD1 = 416’
8,266’ Imax Remaining vertical height
HD1
= 10,000 - 1,734 = 8,266’

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 25

Solution
Horizontally:
416 + 8,266 tan 27o = 4,628
We need 4,500’ only:
27o Next try Imax = 25’ 30 min
8,266’
MD2 = 1,700’ (25.5/1.5)
TVD2 = 1,644’
4,212’
HD2 = 372’

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 26

13
1,644

27o
372
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 27

Solution:
Remaining vertical depth = 10,000-1,644
= 8,356 ft.
Horizontal departure = 372 + 8,356 tan25.5
= 4,358 ft. { <4,500 }
27 + 25.5
= 26.25
Approx. maximum angle = 2
4,628 + 4,358
What is the size of target? = 4,493
2

…within 7 ft
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 28

14
MD = MDvert + MDbuild + MDhold

8, 266
M D at 27 o = 2, 500 + 1, 800 +
cos 27 o
= 13,577'

8,356
M D at 25.5 o = 2,500 + 1,700 +
cos 25.5 o
= 13,458'
∴ M D ≅ 13,520'
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 29

Type II Pattern

Given: KOP = 2,000 feet


TVD = 10,000 feet
Horiz. Depart. = 2,258 feet
o
Build Rate = 2 per 100 feet
o
Drop Rate = 1 30’ per 100 feet

The first part of the calculation is the same


as previously described.
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 30

15
Procedure - Find:
g a) The usable depth (8,000 feet)
g b) Maximum angle at completion of
buildup (e.g., try 18o)
using 2o/100 ft chart
g c) Measured depth and vertical
depth at completion of buildup
(M.D. = 900 ft. and TVD = 886)
g d) Measured depth, horizontal
departure and TVD for
1.5o/100 ft from chart.
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 31

Solution
g For the distances corresponding to
the sides of the triangle in the middle:

g Add up the results.


g If not close enough, try a
different value for the maximum
inclination angle, Imax

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 32

16
Horizontal
N View

Vertical
View
We may plan a 2-D well, but we always
get a 3D well (not all in one plane)

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 33

Bottom Hole Location

Direction : N 53D E
Distance : 2,550 ft
TVD : 10,000
E = 2,550 sin 53 D
= 2,037 ft
N = 2,550 cos 53 D
= 1,535 ft
Closure = 2,550 = E2 + N2
⎛E⎞
Closure Direction = tan -1⎜ ⎟ = 53o
⎝N⎠
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 34

17
Survey Calculation Methods

1. Tangential Method
= Backward Station Method
= Terminal Angle Method

Assumption:
Hole will maintain constant
inclination and azimuth angles,
IB and AB , between survey points.

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 35

A
Known : Location of A
Distance AB
IA Angles IA , IB
Angles A A , AB
IB Calculation : VAB = AB cos IB
HAB = AB sin IB

B
Poor accuracy!!
IB
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 36

18
Average Angle Method or Angle
Averaging Method

Assumption: Borehole is parallel to the


simple average drift and bearing
angles between any two stations.

Known: Location of A, Distance AB,


Angles I A , IB , A A , A B

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 37

A
Average Angle Method

IA (i) Simple enough for field use


(ii) Much more accurate than
IB “Tangential” Method

IAVG ⎛ I + IB ⎞
I avg = ⎜ A ⎟
⎝ 2 ⎠
B
⎛ A + AB ⎞
A avg = ⎜ A ⎟
IAVG ⎝ 2 ⎠
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 38

19
A Average Angle Method
Vertical Plane:

IA
⎛ I + IB ⎞
I avg = ⎜ A ⎟
IB ⎝ 2 ⎠

IAVG V AB = AB cos Iavg

B H AB = AB sin Iavg

IAVG
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 39

Average Angle Method


N Horizontal Plane:

AB H AB = AB sin Iavg
B
∆ E = AB sin Iavg sin A avg
AAVG AAVG ∆N ∆ N = AB sin Iavg cos A avg
AA ∆ Z = AB cos Iavg

∆E
E
A
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 40

20
Change in position towards the east:
⎛I +I ⎞ ⎛ A + AB ⎞
∆ x = ∆ E = L sin ⎜ A B ⎟ sin ⎜ A ⎟..(1)
⎝ 2 ⎠ ⎝ 2 ⎠
Change in position towards the north:
⎛I +I ⎞ ⎛ A + AB ⎞
∆ y = ∆ N = L sin ⎜ A B ⎟ cos ⎜ A ⎟..( 2 )
⎝ 2 ⎠ ⎝ 2 ⎠
Change in depth:
⎛I +I ⎞
∆ Z = L cos ⎜ A B ⎟ ..( 3 )
⎝ 2 ⎠
Where L is the measured distance
between the two stations A & B (∆MDAB).
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 41

Example - Average Angle


The coordinates of a point in a wellbore are:
x = 1,000 ft (easting)
y = 2,000 ft (northing)
z = 3,000 ft (depth)

At this point (station) a wellbore survey shows that


the inclination is 15 degrees from vertical, and the
direction is 45 degrees east of north. The
measured distance between this station and the
next is 300 ft….
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 42

21
Example
The coordinates of point 1 are:
x1 = 1,000 ft (easting)
o
y1 = 2,000 ft (northing) I1 = 15
o
z1 = 3,000 ft (depth) A1 = 45
L12 = 300 ft

o o
At point 2, I2 = 25 and A2 = 65

Find x2 , y2 and z2

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 43

Solution
⎛ I + I ⎞ ⎛ 15 + 25 ⎞
I avg = ⎜ 1 2 ⎟ = ⎜ ⎟ = 20
⎝ 2 ⎠ ⎝ 2 ⎠

⎛ A + A 2 ⎞ ⎛ 45 + 65 ⎞
A avg = ⎜ 1 ⎟=⎜ ⎟ = 55
⎝ 2 ⎠ ⎝ 2 ⎠
H12 = L12 sin Iavg = 300 sin 20 = 103 ft
∆E = H12 sin Aavg = 103 sin 55 = 84 ft
∆N = H12 cos Aavg = 103 cos 55 = 59 ft
∆Z = L12 cos Iavg = 300 cos 20 = 282 ft

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 44

22
Solution - cont’d

∆E = 84 ft
∆N = 59 ft
∆Z = 282 ft

x2 = x1 + ∆E = 1,000 + 84 ft = 1,084 ft
y2 = y1 + ∆N = 2,000 + 59 ft = 2,059 ft
z2 = z1 + ∆Z = 3,000 + 282 ft = 3,282 ft
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 45

Directional Drilling
• Tool-Face Angle

• Ouija Board

• Dogleg Severity

• Reverse Torque of Mud Motor

• Examples

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 46

23
I1 = 16 deg Problem
I2 = 12 deg
∆A = 12 deg
Solution Tool Face (γ)
β = 5 deg
γ = 152 deg

Graphical Ouija Analysis.


Directional and Horizontal Drilling 47

Over one short drilled interval


GIVEN:
o
1. α = 16
2. ∆ε = 12
o Tool Face (γ)
Solution
o
3. αΝ = 12

o
2
l i nat i on = 1
nc
New I ∆ε = 12o

γ=?
o o
Initial Inclination = 16
β=?
o

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 48

24
Ouija Board
1

3 4&5

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 49

γ = 151
o
Ouija
Board β = 5.0

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 50

25
Basis of chart
construction is a
trigonometric
β relationship
α illustrated by two
intersecting planes
αΝ

To calculate
β = dogleg angle
∆ε
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 51

Problem 1

Determine the new direction (εΝ)


for a whipstock set at 705 m (depth)
with a tool-face setting of 45o right of
high side for a course length of 10 m.

The inclination is 7o and the direction is


N15W. The curve of the whipstock will
cause a total angle change of 3o/ 30 m.
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 52

26
Problem 1

o
α=7 (inclination)
o
ε = 345 (azimuth - N15W)
γ = 45
o
o
γ = 45 (tool face angle)
L = 10 m (course length)
o
δ = 3 / 30 m (dogleg severity)

εΝ = ?
o

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 53

Solution to Problem 1- Part 1


I. Calculate β. The dogleg severity,

δ β 3o β
= =
i L 30 m 10 m

3 D ∗ 10 m
∴β =
30 m ∴ β = 1o

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 54

27
Solution to Problem 1- Part 2

2. Calculate the direction change, ∆ε.

⎛ tan β sin γ ⎞
∆ ε = arc tan ⎜ ⎟
⎜ sin α + tan β cos α cos γ ⎟
⎝ ⎠
⎛ tan 1D sin 45 D ⎞
∆ ε = tan −1 ⎜ ⎟
⎜ sin 7 D + tan 1D cos 7 D cos 45 D ⎟
⎝ ⎠
New direction = 3450 + 5.30 = 350.30
∆ ε = tan − 1 0 . 092027 ≅ 5 . 3 D
εN = N9.7W
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 55

Problem 2

o γ
Determine where to set the tool face angle,
foroa jetting bit to go from a direction of 10 to
30 and from an inclination of 3o to 5o. Also
calculate the dogleg severity, assuming that
the trajectory change takes 60 ft.
α = 5D
α=3 o N

ε = 30 D
ε = 10o N

L = 60 ft
Find γ and δ
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 56

28
Solution to Problem 2- Part 1
1. Find β using Equation 8.53
β = cos − 1 [ cos ∆ ε sin α N sin α + cos α N cos α ]

∆ ε = 30 o − 10 o = 20 o

β = cos −1 [ cos 20 o sin 5 o sin 3 o + cos 5 o cos 3 o ]


−1
= cos 0 . 999116
Dogleg Angle β = 2 .4097 o
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 57

Solution to Problem 2- Part 2

2. Now calculate γ from equation 8.48.

−1 ⎡ cos α cos β − cos α N ⎤


γ = cos ⎢ ⎥
⎣ sin α sin β ⎦
⎡ cos 3 0 cos 2 . 4097 0 − cos 5 0 ⎤
γ = cos −1
⎢ ⎥
⎣ sin 3 0 sin 2 . 4097 0 ⎦
γ = cos − 1 0 .7052

Dogleg Angle γ = 45 .15 o


Directional and Horizontal Drilling 58

29
Solution to Problem 2- Part 3

3. The dogleg severity,

β
o
2.4097
δ = (i) = ∗ 100
L 60

δ = 4.01o / 100 ft

Alternate solution: Use Ouija Board


Directional and Horizontal Drilling 59

Solution to Example 6.

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 60

30
Problem 3

Determine the dogleg severity following a jetting run


o o
where the inclination was changed from 4.3 to 7.1 and the
direction from N89E to S80E over a drilled interval of 85
feet. 1. Solve by calculation.
2. Solve using Ragland diagram

α = 4 .3 o L = 85 ft α N = 7.1 o

ε = 89 o
ε N = 100 o

∆α = 7.1 - 4.3 = 2.8. ∆ε = 100 - 89 = 11


Directional and Horizontal Drilling 61

Solution to Problem 3- Part 1a

1. From Equation 8.55


1/ 2
⎡−1 ∆α ∆ε ⎛ α + αN ⎞⎤
β = 2 sin ⎢ sin 2 + sin 2 sin 2 ⎜ ⎟⎥
⎣ 2 2 ⎝ 2 ⎠⎦

1/ 2

−1 2 .8 11 ⎛ 4 .3 + 7 .1 ⎞ ⎤
β = 2 sin ⎢ sin 2 + sin 2 sin 2 ⎜ ⎟⎥
⎣ 2 2 ⎝ 2 ⎠⎦
β = 3.01o
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 62

31
Solution to Problem 3- Part 1b

From Equation 8.43,


the dogleg severity,

β 3 . 01
δ = (i) = ∗ 100
L 85

δ = 3 . 54 o
/ 100 ft
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 63

Solution to Problem 3- Part 2


2. Construct line of length α (4.3 units)
Measure angle ∆ε (11o )
Construct line of length αN (7.1 units)
Measure length β
(Measure angle γ) 4.3 γ
o
Ragland Diagram 11 β
β = 3 , γ = 17
o o 7.1
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 64

32
Some Equations to Calculate β

Eq. 8.53 β = 2.99305897 deg


β = arc cos(cos ∆ ε sin α N sin α + cos α cos α N )

Eq. 8.54 β = 2.99305897 deg 2.99305897

cosβ = cos∆ε sinα N sin α + cos ∆α − sin α sin α N

Eq. 8.55 β = 3.00506938 deg


⎛ ∆α ⎞ 2 ⎛ ∆ε ⎞ 2⎛ α + αN ⎞
β = 2 arc sin sin 2 ⎜ ⎟ + sin ⎜ ⎟ sin ⎜ ⎟
⎝ 2 ⎠ ⎝ 2 ⎠ ⎝ 2 ⎠

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 65

Overall Angle Change and Dogleg


Severity
Equation 8derived by Lubinski is used to
construct Figure 32, a nomograph for
determining the total angle change β and
the dogleg severity, δ.

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 66

33
Fig. 32: Chart
for determining
dogleg severity
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 67

(α+αΝ)/2 = 5.7o
αΝ − α = 2.8o

β = 3o

∆ε = 11o

δ = 3.5o/100 ft

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 68

34
(α+αΝ)/2
= 5.7o
(4.3+7.1)/2

∆ε = 11o
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 69

αΝ − α = 2.8o
(7.1 – 4.3)

β = 3o
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 70

35
β = 3o

L = 85 ft δ = 3.5o/100 ft
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 71

(α+αΝ)/2 = 5.7o
αΝ − α = 2.8o

β = 3o
∆ε = 11o

δ = 3.5o/100 ft

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 72

36
Fig. 35
Example of
Desired Direction high side of
wellbore
Direction showing
of Hole
S48W
Right how it
Left corresponds
to a Ouija
Low Side
diagram.

High Side of High Side, γ = 0o


Hole S48W
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 73

N53W = 307o
o
S48W = 228
∆ε = ?
o

o o
307o - 228 = 79

o
∆ε = 79

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 74

37
εΝ = 307
o

∆ε = 79
o

ε = 228
o

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 75

Example 8.10

Design a kickoff for the wellbore in Fig. 8.35.


ε = S48W = 228o εN = N53W = 307o

α = 2o L = 150 ft αN = 6o

∆ε = 79o Find β, γ and δ

ο ο
From Ouija Board β = 5.8 , γ = 97
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 76

38
New Where to Set the Tool Face
Direction
ο
β = 5.8
ο
γ = 97

High
Side
Present Direction
Fig. 36: Solution for Example 8.10.
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 77

Dogleg Severity
From Equation 8.43
the dogleg severity,

β 5 .8
δ = (i) = ∗ 100
L 150

δ = 3 . 87 o
/ 100 feet
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 78

39
o o
With jetting bit: 325 345
θM = 20
o
o
307

Fig. 36:
Solution for
Example
o
8.10. 228

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 79

Tool Face Where to Set the Tool Face


Setting
Compensating for Reverse
New Torque of the Motor
Direction

High Present
Side Direction

High
Side

Fig. 36: Solution for Example 8.10.


Directional and Horizontal Drilling 80

40
Problem 4 - Torque and Twist

1.Calculate the total angle change (twist) of


3,650 ft. of 4 1/2 inches (3.826 ” ID) Grade E
16.60 #/ft drill pipe and 300 ft. of 7” drill
collars (2 13/16” ID) for a bit-generated
torque of 1,000 ft-lbf.
Assume that the motor has the same
properties as the 7” drill collars. Shear
modules of steel, G = 11.5*106 psi.
2. What would be the total angle change if
7,300 ft. of drill pipe were used?
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 81

Solution to Problem 4

From Equation 56,


⎛ ML ⎞ ⎛ ML ⎞ ⎛ ML ⎞
θM = ⎜ ⎟ +⎜ ⎟ +⎜ ⎟
⎝ GJ ⎠ motor ⎝ GJ ⎠BHA ⎝ GJ ⎠ drillstrin g

for Pipe, J =
π
32
(
OD 4 − ID 4 =
π
32
) (
4.5 4 − 3.826 4 = 19 .22 in 4)

for Collars, J =
π 4
32
(
7 − 2 . 813 4 = 229 . 6 in 4 )
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 82

41
Solution to Problem 4, cont.
M ⎡⎛ L ⎞ ⎛L⎞ ⎤
∴ θM = ⎢ ⎜ ⎟ + ⎜ ⎟ ⎥ radians
G ⎢⎣ ⎝ J ⎠ collars ⎝ J ⎠ pipe ⎥⎦
in
1,000 ft − lbf ∗ 12
= ft ⎡ 300 ∗ 12 in + 3 ,650 ∗ 12 in ⎤
⎢ 4 4 ⎥
6 lbf ⎢ 229 . 6 in 19 . 22 in ⎥⎦
11 . 5 ∗ 10 ⎣
in 2

= 0 . 001043 [15 . 68 + 2 ,279 ] = 2 . 394 radians


180 deg
∴ θ = 2 . 394 rad ∗ = 137 . 2 o
π rad
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 83

Solution to Problem 4, cont.

If Length of drillpipe = 7,300 ft.,


θM = 0.001043 [15.68 + 2 * 2,279 ]

180 deg
= 4.77 radians *
π rad

θ M = 273 .3 o ~ 3/4 revolution!

{ 137.2 * 2 = 274.4 }
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 84

42
Directional Drilling Survey
Calculation Methods and
Terminology

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 85

Bulletin on Directional Drilling Survey


Calculation Methods and Terminology

h20 Different surveying techniques



h6

h4 +
hThe important equations from this Bulletin
are summarized at the end of Lesson 11.
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 86

43
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 87

Example: Model Wellbore


Unidirectional Wellbore

Direction -- Due North


o
Buildup Rate -- 5 /100 feet
o
Terminal Angle -- 60
Total survey Depth -- 1,200 feet

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 88

44
Example: Model Wellbore
• Note: In the following tables, a 15 foot
survey tool length was assumed, with
measured angles appropriately backed off
for this distance. All methods, except
Mercury*, assume a zero length survey
tool or that the depth was adjusted so that
measured depth and actual record depth
coincided.

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 89

25’ Survey Interval

Calculation Method TVD* North


Displacement
Tangential 986.10(-6.29) 583.76(+10.8)
Balanced Tangential 992.35(-.04) 572.94(-.02)
Minimum Curvature 992.39(0) 572.96(0)
Radius of Curvature 992.39(0) 572.96(0)
Mercury* 992.45(+0.6) 572.84(-.12)
Average Angle 992.41(+.02) 572.97(+.01)
( ) Difference from “Actual”
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 90

45
100’ Survey Interval
Calculation Method TVD* North
Displacement
Tangential 966.76(-25.63) 615.90(+42.94)
Balanced Tangential 991.76(-.63) 572.59(-.37)
Minimum Curvature 992.39(0) 572.96(0)
Radius of Curvature 992.39(0) 572.96(0)
Mercury* 991.86(+.53) 572.76(-.20)
Average Angle 992.71(+.32) 573.14(+.18)
( ) Difference from Actual
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 91

200’ Survey Interval


Calculation Method TVD* North
Displacement
Tangential 939.87(-52.52) 658.11(+85.15)
Balanced Tangential 989.87(-2.52) 571.5 (-1.46)
Minimum Curvature 992.39(0) 572.96(0)
Radius of Curvature 992.39(0) 572.96(0)
Mercury* 989.97(-2.42) 572.01(-.95)
Average Angle 993.65(+1.26) 573.69(+.73)
( ) Difference from Actual
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 92

46
Example: Model Wellbore

hAll methods are pretty good except for


the tangential method.

hDiscrepancy depends on survey


interval; 25 feet, 100 feet, 200 feet ...

hMinimum curvature vs. radius of


curvature
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 93

Definitions

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 94

47
Wellbore Survey Calculation Methods...

Refers to the mathematical methods and


assumptions used in reconstructing the path
of the wellbore and in generating the space
curve path of the wellbore from inclination
and direction angle measurements taken
along the wellbore.
These measurements are obtained from
magnetic or gyroscopic instruments of either
the single-shot or multi-shot type.
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 95

Acceleration Method
Utilizes the angles at the top and bottom of
the course length and from these generates
a curve on the assumption that the measured
angles change smoothly from top to bottom
of the measured course as though under the
influence of a constant force of acceleration.
The results obtained are the same as the
“Balanced Tangential”, “Trapezoidal” and
the “Vector Averaging” Methods.
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 96

48
Average Angle Method

Uses the angles measured at both the top


and bottom of the course length in such a
fashion that the average of the two sets of
measured angles is the assumed inclination
and direction.
The wellbore survey is then calculated
tangentially using these averaged angles
over the course length.
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 97

Backward Station Method

Refer to “Tangential Method”.

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 98

49
Balanced Tangential Method
Uses the inclination and direction angles at
the top and bottom of the course length in a
manner so as to tangentially balance the
two sets of measured angles over the
course length.
Results obtained are the same as the
“Acceleration” ,“Trapezoidal” and
“Vector Averaging” Methods.

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 99

Circular Arc Method


Uses both sets of measured angles
associated with each course length to
recreate the wellbore path as a sequence of
circular arcs constrained by the measured
angles to pass through the end points with
inclination and direction angles as
measured.

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 100

50
Compensated Acceleration
Method:
Refer to “Mercury Method”.
Combined Method:
Refer to “Mercury Method”.
Great Circle Method:
Refer to “Minimum Curvature
Method”.
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 101

Mercury Method
A combination of the “Tangential” and the
“Balanced Tangential” Methods, so as to
treat that portion of the measured course
defined by the length of the measuring tool
as a straight line (tangentially) and the
remainder of the measured course
trapezoidal.
Also, refer to “ Compensated Acceleration
Method” and “Combined Method.”
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 102

51
Minimum Curvature Method
Uses the sets of angles measured at the
top and bottom of the course length to
establish coordinate velocities through
which a space curve (which represents the
calculated path of the wellbore) passes in
a manner that minimizes its total
curvature.

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 103

Quadratic Method
A method in math modeling considering
the wellbore as a curve; the projections
into three vertical planes are quadratic
functions.

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 104

52
Radius of Curvature Method
Uses the sets of angles measured at the
top and bottom of the course length to
generate a space curve (representing the
wellbore path) that has the shape of a
spherical arc passing through the
measured angles at both the upper and
lower ends of the measured course.

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 105

Secant Method
Has been used with two different
meanings:

1) Meaning the “Trapezoidal Method”

2) Meaning the “Average Angle


Method”

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 106

53
Simpson’s Rule Method
Uses as many measured angle values as
are available (a minimum of three sets) to
recreate the wellbore path through
Simpson’s rule for numeric integration,
which approximates by passing a parabola
through three points.

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 107

Tangential Method

Uses only the inclination and direction


angles measured at the lower end of the
course length. the wellbore path is
assumed to be tangent to these angles
throughout the course.

This method is not recommended.

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 108

54
Terminal Angle Method:
Refer to “Tangential Method”.

Three Dimensional Radius


of Curvature Method:
Refer to “Minimum Curvature
Method”.

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 109

Trapezoidal Method

Uses of the measured inclination and direction


angles at both ends of the measured course in a
fashion that recreates the wellbore path. This is
done by a sequence of trapezoidal integration
segments using the measured angles as constraints
on the integral over the measured course.
Results obtained are essentially the same as the
“Acceleration,” “Balanced Tangential” and
“Vector Averaging” Methods.

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 110

55
Vector Averaging Method

Uses inclination and direction measurements at


both ends of the measured course to establish
vector space directions. It is then assumed that
each of these two vectors is projected for one-half
the course length in creating the wellbore path.
Each “half-course length” segment can be treated
tangentially. Results obtained are essentially the
same as the “Acceleration”, “Balanced
Tangential” ,
and “Trapezoidal” Methods.
Directional and Horizontal Drilling 111

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 112

56
THE END

Directional and Horizontal Drilling 113

57

You might also like