Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Impact of Colonization and Western Assimilation On Health and Wellbeing of Canadian Aboriginal People
The Impact of Colonization and Western Assimilation On Health and Wellbeing of Canadian Aboriginal People
Audrey Steenbeek
Dalhousie University, Canada
This paper offers a perspective that does not characterize Aboriginal people and
communities individually or collectively as dysfunctional and pathologic,
or “ignore the historical resilience and resistance of Aboriginal peoples in the
face of adversity brought on by European colonization”.4 Instead, it highlights the
need to review the impacts and effects of colonization and assimilation on
the health, socio-economic welfare, access to services, and the effects on the culture
of Aboriginal people living in Canada through the lens of a non-Aboriginal nursing
researcher/clinician using a post-colonial feminist theoretical perspective. A post-
colonial feminist theoretical perspective not only provides direction for under-
standing how the past (i.e., legacy of colonialism and assimilation) shapes the
present context of health and health inequities for Aboriginal people, but also offers
a theoretical perspective for decolonizing research.5 A recent PhD research study
“exploring Aboriginal women’s experiences with Pap smear screening in Nova
Scotia” will also be used to highlight some of these impacts. A brief discussion
on the implications of gender and status on Aboriginal women’s health will also
be presented.6
Within the Canadian context colonization resulted in the loss of many of the
traditional ways of knowing, language, cultural practices, and medicines for many
Aboriginal peoples.18
Battiste asserted that “colonization was a system of oppression rather than
a personal or local prejudice”19 bringing disorder to the lives of Aboriginal people
by impacting their language, traditions, social relations, and “ways of thinking”,
feeling, and interacting in the world. Essentially, colonization had a devastating
impact on all aspects of the health of Aboriginal peoples, particularly the physical,
emotional, mental, and spiritual dimensions.20 Henderson maintained that
400 years of rule over Indigenous people created systematic colonialism and
racism in which Indigenous peoples were alienated from their “beliefs, languages,
families, and identities; that deprived Indigenous peoples of their dignity,
their confidence, their souls, and even their shadows”.21
Throughout the colonization process, Indigenous peoples of North America were
portrayed as barbarians without laws, or governance who needed to be assimilated
into the value systems and ways of the colonizers.21 Governments and hierarchies
were created by the colonizers that acknowledged Europeans as being far superior
to Indigenous people, forcing the assimilation of Indigenous peoples into European
society, education systems (i.e., residential schools) and government policies.21,22
Elders.32 With the loss of traditional medicine and healing practices, Aboriginal
people were forced to accept foreign medicines and to rely upon patriarchal
healthcare systems that:
medicalize social problems as arising from individual lifestyles, cultural differences or
biological predisposition - rather than from impoverished social and economic
circumstances, marginalization and oppressive internal colonial politics.33
and roots that were edible and used in traditional Aboriginal healing practices.41
For many Aboriginal people, the land was not only a source of food and medicines,
but a symbolic connection with ancestors, and ties with the landscape, earth, soils,
minerals, water, and air.41 The loss of land altered the identity of Aboriginal peoples
creating a loss of socio-economic status, and thus creating a reliance on the colonial
system for survival.42
Canadian government monies. Alfred maintains that even today Canada’s financial
agreements with First Nations are framed within government policies that do not
really consider First Nation’s needs or objectives and do not provide an
autonomous means to generate revenue or support self-determination.50
Other treaties did not include the acquisitions of traditional land or resources.
For example, there were peace and friendship treaties like those in Eastern Canada
that were signed with Mi’kmaq, Maliseet, and Passamaquoddy First Nations
intended to end hostilities and foster cooperation between the British and First
Nations peoples. Mi’kmaq and Maliseet First Nations continue to have treaty rights
to hunt, fish, and gather for maintaining their livelihood in the Maritimes.48
However to this day, the Canadian Government has yet to reconcile the legislation
regarding the constitutional provisions of Aboriginal rights and treaties. Therefore,
the upholding of Aboriginal rights and treaties has been assumed by courts due to
the unwillingness to change bureaucracy and embedded neocolonial attitudes.49
Unemployment rates for Canadian Aboriginal people are another socio-
economic hardship. The average employment rate for Aboriginal people in 2009
was 57.0%, compared with 61.8% for non-Aboriginal people, with the
employment gap widening to 4.8 percentage points from 3.5 percentage points in
the previous year. The unemployment rate increased for Aboriginal people from
10.4% in 2008 to 13.9% in 2009, while the rate for non-Aboriginal people rose
from 6.0% to 8.1%.51 Given that there are few employment opportunities on
Aboriginal reserves/communities, Aboriginal people were forced to leave their
homelands and migrate to urban centres to find low-paying work. This situation
was further compounded by lack of formal education, and job market
discrimination.52 The poor socio-economic status of Aboriginal people in Canada
is a direct consequence of colonization and government assimilation policies and
treaties. The loss of lands, lack of education, cultural genocide, and job market
discrimination have not only caused Aboriginal poverty, but have contributed to
the marginalization of Aboriginal people in Canada.53
Access to services is further impacted by the lack of basic health facilities such as
health clinics and hospitals, specifically in remote and rural areas of Canada.82
Remote and rural communities rely primarily on non-Aboriginal healthcare
workers for medical and non-medical services. Additionally, many Aboriginal
people must be evacuated from their communities in order to obtain healthcare
services and medical treatment, and often encounter culturally insensitive care,
racism, and discrimination in treatment facilities.83 Moreover, there is a frequent
turnover of healthcare professionals, particularly in remote areas of Canada, which
dramatically affects medical management, the range of services offered, and access
to services. It also results in client disengagement in services, illness exacerbation,
and an additional burden of care for families and the community, which translate
into poor health outcomes.84
Conclusion
Despite differences in diversity and lifestyles, Aboriginal peoples nationally and
internationally continue to experience historical trauma resulting from coloniza-
tion and assimilation. All aspects of Aboriginal health and lifestyles, traditional
roles, culture, socio-economics, and access to services were disrupted as a result of
colonization and assimilation practices. Further, the key determinants of health,
gender and social status are factors further compounded by the effects of
assimilation on Aboriginal people. Aboriginal women, in particular, have
experienced poorer health, with gender compounding the affects of assimilation
on Aboriginal women’s health. To gain an understanding of how to promote equity
in health care for Aboriginal people, a critical examination of the root causes of
health and healthcare inequities must be viewed from historical, economic, and
socio-political contexts by using a post-colonial feminist perspective. Consequently,
the impacts of colonization and assimilation on the health, socio-economic
conditions, access to services, and the effects on the traditional cultures of Canadian
Aboriginal people were discussed. It is essential to understand the distinct impact of
colonization and assimilation policies and practices to gain an understanding of the
IMPACT OF COLONIZATION ON HEALTH AND WELLBEING OF CANADIAN ABORIGINAL PEOPLE 43
devastating and lasting implications that these processes had, and continue to have,
on all aspects of Aboriginal people’s lives and health.
Acknowledgements
Thanks to Atlantic Aboriginal Health Research Program (AAHRP); Psychosocial
Oncology Research Training (PORT) Fellowship; Electa MacLennan Scholarship,
Dalhousie University; Canadian Nurses Foundation AstraZeneca Rural Scholarship.
Notes
1
“Aboriginal Peoples” is a collective name for all of and Gail Guthrie Valaskakis, eds. (196– 220).
the original peoples of Canada and their descen- Vancouver: UBC Press, 2009, p. 241.
5
dants. Section 35 of the Constitution Act of 1982 See, for example, J.M. Anderson, “Lessons for a
specifies that the Aboriginal Peoples in Canada Postcolonial-Feminist Perspective: Suffering and a
consist of three groups – Indian (First Nations), Path to Healing”, Nursing Inquiry 11 (2004):
Inuit, and Métis. It should not be used to describe 238 –46; A.J. Browne, V.L. Smye and C. Varcoe,
only one or two of the groups. Although in this article “The Relevance of Postcolonial Theoretical
“Aboriginal people” is a general term, in some Perspectives to Research in Aboriginal Health”,
instances related to treaties and land claims specific Canadian Journal of Nursing Research 37, no. 4
bands, tribes, or Nations will be distinguished. (2005): 16–37; R.J.C. Young, Postcolonialism:
2
See, for example, Naomi Adelson, ‘The Embodi- An Historical Introduction (Oxford: Blackwell,
ment of Inequity: Health Disparities in Aboriginal 2001).
6
Canada”, Canadian Journal of Public Health 96 C. MacDonald, “Exploring Mi’kmaq Women’s
(2005): S45 – S61; Marie Battiste, Reclaiming Experiences with Pap Smear Screening in Nova
Indigenous Voice and Vision (Vancouver: Univer- Scotia”, Unpublished PhD Diss., Dalhousie
sity of British Columbia Press, 2000); Annette University, Halifax, Nova Scotia, 2013.
7
J. Browne et al. ”Access to Primary Care from the L.T. Smith, Decolonizing Methodologies:
Perspective of Aboriginal Patients at an Urban Research and Indigenous Peoples (Dunedin,
Emergency Department”, Qualitative Health New Zealand: Otago University Press, 1999).
8
Research 21 (2011): 333–48; Madeleine Dion Ibid.
9
Stout, “Ascribed Health and Wellness, Atikowisi J. Sherwood, “Do No Harm: Decolonizing Abori-
miýw-āyāwin, to Achieved Health and Wellness, ginal Health Research”, Unpublished PhD Diss.,
Kaskitamasowin miýw-āayāwin: Shifting the Para- University of New South Wales, Australia, 2010.
10
digm”, Canadian Journal of Nursing Research 44, Examples of this approach include Young, Postcolo-
no. 2 (2012): 11 –14; Bernard Guerin, “A Frame- nialism; S.R. Kirkham and J.M.Anderson, “Postcolo-
work for Decolonization Interventions: Broad- nial Nursing Scholarship: From Epistemology to
ening the Focus for Improving the Health and Method”, ANS 25, no. 1 (2002): 1–17.
11
Wellbeing of Indigenous Communities”, Pı́matı́sı́- Smith, Decolonizing, 98; C. McConaghy, Rethink-
wı́n 8, no. 3 (2010): 61 –83; Wayne Warry, Ending ing Indigenous Education: Culturalism, Colonial-
Denial: Understanding Aboriginal Issues (Peter- ism and the Politics of Knowing (Brisbane,
borough, ON: Broadview Press, 2007); National Australia: Post Pressed, 2000), 268. See also
Aboriginal Health Organization, Ways of Know- Stout, “Ascribed Health and Wellness”.
12
ing: A Framework for Health Research (Ottawa, Smith, Decolonizing; A. Browne and V. Smye,
Canada: Policy Research Unit, 2003). “A Post-Colonial Analysis of Healthcare
3
National Aboriginal Health Organization, Ways Discourse Addressing Aboriginal Women”, Nurse
of Knowing; Anne MacMurray, “Health and its Research 9, no. 3 (2002): 28 –41; A.J. Browne,
Socio-ecological Determinants”, in Community V.L. Smye and C. Varcoe, “The Relevance of
Health and Wellness: A Socio-ecological Approach Postcolonial Theoretical Perspectives to Research
(Sydney, Australia: Mosby, Incorporated, 2007). in Aboriginal Health”, in Women’s Health in
4
Caroline L. Tait, “Disruptions in Nature: Disrup- Canada: Critical Perspectives on Theory and Policy,
tions in Society: Aboriginal Peoples of Canada and ed. M. Morrow, O. Hankivsky and C. Varcoe
the ‘Making’ of Fetal Alcohol Syndrome”, in (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2007);
Healing Traditions: The Mental Health of Abori- C. MacDonald, “Exploring Mi’kmaq Women’s
ginal Peoples in Canada, Lawrence E. Kirmayer Experiences with Pap Smear Screening in Nova
44 CATHY MACDONALD and AUDREY STEENBEEK
47 60
Warry, Ending Denial; T. Sable and B. Francis, The E. LaRocque, “The Colonization of a Native Scholar”,
Language of this Land, Mi’kma’ki (Sydney, Nova in Women of the First Nations: Power, Wisdom and
Scotia, Canada: Cape Breton University Press, Strength, ed., C. Miller and P. Chuchryk (Winnipeg:
2012); D. Smith et al., “Rethinking Nursing Best The University of Manitoba Press, 1994), 13
61
Practices with Aboriginal Communities: Informing R.L. Bourque Bearskin, “A Critical Lens on Culture
Dialogue and Action”, Nursing Leadership 22, no. in Nursing Practice”, Nursing Ethics 18 (2011):
4 (2012): 24 –39. 548-59; J.M. Anderson et al., “Inequities 14 in
48
For details see “Peace and Friendship Treaties”, Health and Healthcare Viewed Through the Ethical
Aboriginal Affairs and Northern Development Lens of Critical Social Justice: Contextual Knowl-
Canada, https://www.aadnc-aandc.gc.ca/eng/ edge for the Global Priorities Ahead”, Advances
1100100028589/1100100028591; Youngblood, in Nursing Science 32, no. 4 (2009): 282–29;
”Generis and Treaty Citizenship”. L.J. Kirmayer et al., “Rethinking Resilience from
49
J.S. Youngblood Henderson, “Sui Generis and Indigenous Perspectives”, Canadian Journal of
Treaty Citizenship”, Citizenship Studies 6 (2002): Psychiatry 56, no. 2 (2011): 84 –91.
62
415–440, 420. Warry, Ending Denial, 33.
50 63
G.T. Alfred, Colonialism and State Dependency. Warry, Ending Denial, 34.
64
JAH, Nov (2009): 42 –60. Reeves, “Honouring Womanhood”.
51 65
“Aboriginal People”, Statistics Canada, Govern- Browne et al., “Access to Primary Healthcare”; J.J.
ment of Canada, http://www.statcan.gc.ca/pub/ Azetsop and S.S. Rennie, “Principlism, Medical
11-402-x/2011000/chap/ap-pa/ap-pa-eng.htm. Individualism, and Health Promotion in Resource-
52
J. Kendall, Circles of disadvantage: Aboriginal Poor Countries: Can Autonomy-Based Bioethics
poverty and underdevelopment in Canada. ARCS Promote Social Justice and Population Health?”,
2001, 31(1/2): 43 –54; M. Mendelson, Aboriginal Philosophy, Ethics, and Humanities in Medicine 5,
people in Canada’s labour market: work and no. 1 (2010): 1 – 10. Native Women’s Association
unemployment, today and tomorrow. The Cale- of Canada, Social Determinants of Hhealth
don Institute of Social Policy. Mar, 2004. Ottawa. and Canada’s Aboriginal Women: Submission by
53
T. Sable and B. Francis, The language of this land, the Native Women’s Association of Canada to the
Mi’kma’ki (Sydney, Nova Scotia, Canada: Cape World Health Organization’s Commission on the
Breton University Press, 2012): D Smith, N Social Determinants of Health (Ottawa, Canada:
Edwards W Peterson, et al., “Rethinking nursing Native Women’s Association of Canada, 2007).
66
best practices with Aboriginal communities: Stout, “Ascribed Health and Wellness”; Browne and
informing dialogue and action”. Nursing Leader- Stout, “Moving Towards Nahi”; C. Loppie Reading
ship 22 no. 4 (2012): 24– 39. and F. Wien, Health Inequalities and Social
54
L. Morgan and J.L. Wabie, “Aboriginal Women’s Determinants of Aboriginal Peoples Health (Prince
Access and Acceptance of Reproductive Health George, British Columbia, Canada: National Colla-
Care”, Pimatisiwin 10, no. 3 (2012): 313 –25. borating Centre for Aboriginal Health, 2009); A.
55
A. Reeves, Honouring Womanhood: Understand- Vukic, D. Gregory and R. Martin-Misener, “Indi-
ing the Conceptualization and Social Construction genous health research: theoretical and methodologi-
of Young Adult First Nation Women’s Sexuality in cal perspectives”. CJNR 44, no. 2 (2012): 146–161.
67
Atlantic Canada, Master’s thesis (Canada: Dal- Stout, “Ascribed Health and Wellness”; S. Barton,
housie University, 2008). “Discovering the Literature on Aboriginal Diabetes
56
Morgan and Wabie, “Aboriginal Women’s Access in Canada: A Focus on Holistic Methodologies”,
and Acceptance of Reproductive Health Care”; Canadian Journal of Nursing Research 40, no. 4
C. Kenny, A Holistic Framework for Aboriginal (2008): 26–54; A. Vukic et al., “Aboriginal and
Policy Research (Ottawa, Canada: Status of Western Conceptions of Mental Health and
Women Canada, 2004). Illness”, Pimatisiwin 9, no. 1 (2011): 65–85.
57 68
P. Moore, “Na-Dene”, in Aboriginal Peoples of R.L. Bourque Bearskin, “A Critical Lens on Culture
Canada: A Short Introduction, ed., P.R. Magocsi in Nursing Practice”, Nursing Ethics 18, no. 4
(Toronto, Canada: University of Toronto Press, 2002). (2011): 548-59; J.M. Anderson et al., “Inequities
58
E. Haug and S.T. Prokop, “Aboriginal Women and in Health and Healthcare Viewed Through the
Home Care in Saskatchewan”, Saskatchewan Ethical Lens of Critical Social Justice: Contextual
Notes 3, no. 1 (2004): 1 –4; D. Kinnon and Knowledge for the Global Priorities Ahead”, ANS.
S. Swanson, Finding Our Way: A Sexual and Advances in Nursing Science 32, no. 4 (2009):
Reproductive Health Sourcebook for Aboriginal 282 – 29; L.J. Kirmayer et al., “Rethinking
Communities (Ottawa, Canada: Aboriginal Resilience from Indigenous Perspectives”, Canadian
Nurses Association of Canada and Planned Journal of Psychiatry 56, no. 2 (2011): 84–91.
69
Parenthood Federation of Canada, 2002). Browne, Smye and Varcoe, “The Relevance of
59
Battiste, Reclaiming Indiginous Voice. Postcolonial Theoretical Perspectives to Research
46 CATHY MACDONALD and AUDREY STEENBEEK
Notes on contributors
Cathy MacDonald, RN, PhD, is Associate Professor at the School of Nursing, Saint
Francis Xavier University, Antigonish, Nova Scotia, Canada.
Audrey Steenbeek, RN, PhD, is Associate Professor and Assistant Director of
Graduate Programs at Dalhousie University, Nova Scotia, Canada.
Correspondence to: Cathy MacDonald. Email: cmacdon@stfx.ca