Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Venture Debt Report 2023 BCG Trifecta
Venture Debt Report 2023 BCG Trifecta
Trifecta Capital is India’s leading alternate financing BharatPe, Cure.fit, GlobalBees, IdeaForge, Rebel Foods,
platform for startups across their life cycle with tailor- StashFin, Open, Kissht, Ninjacart, Chalo, NoBroker,
made Venture Debt, Growth Equity and Financial Turtlemint, Udaan, Dehaat and Livspace. Trifecta Capital
Advisory Solutions. Trifecta Capital serves market leaders Venture Debt portfolio companies have cumulatively
and category creators across B2B, Consumer Services, raised $13.5Bn of equity and are cumulatively valued
Consumer Brands, E-commerce, Mobility, Edtech, Agritech, at $54Bn.
Fintech and Healthcare. As of February 2023, Trifecta Capital has raised over
Trifecta Capital pioneered the asset class of Venture Debt $600Mn across three Venture Debt Funds and one Growth
Funds in 2015, by launching the country’s first Venture Equity Fund. To support startups, the Firm has also built
Debt Fund. It has since provided over $500Mn of Venture a customized technology and advisory platform with an
Debt to 150+ startups across its three Funds. The Funds’ AUA of over $300Mn. Since inception, Trifecta Capital has
portfolio includes many unicorns and several category invested over $650Mn across Venture Debt and Growth
leading businesses like Big Basket, Pharmeasy, Cars24, Equity and aims to be the financial partner of choice for
Vedantu, The Good Glamm Group, Infra.Market , leading new economy companies in India. It currently has
Dailyhunt, UrbanCompany, CarDekho, Kreditbee, offices in NCR, Bengaluru, and Mumbai.
VENTURE DEBT: SCALING ALONG WITH STARTUPS 3
EXECUTIVE
SUMMARY
The last few years have witnessed record equity inflows into As part of the report, we connected with 40+ startup founders and
the Indian startup ecosystem, primarily led by macroeconomic, one of the key themes that stood out was the limited awareness of
technological, and geopolitical tailwinds. During the same period, Venture Debt as a form of financing. This has been one of the major
Venture Debt has also gained popularity among Indian startups that deterrents in the growth of this asset class. Founders have been
are looking to raise capital. Since CY19, the Indian Venture Debt highly dependent on their existing networks to get introduced to debt
market has grown at 22% CAGR with almost $1Bn invested in CY22. options. Even today, Venture Debt is predominantly recommended
Its journey in India is beginning to mirror the trajectory of this asset and routed through equity investors. However, founders who have
class observed in developed markets. taken Venture Debt expressed numerous benefits such as deal
execution speed, availability of larger amounts of capital, flexibility
As founders get more financially sophisticated, startup balance
of repayment terms and wider eligibility for credit.
sheets are now being designed to include debt as a form of financing.
This has also been enabled by a higher number of debt providers There are predominantly five use cases of debt financing that have
and introduction of a variety of product offerings. This is evidenced become popular in Indian startups:
by the fact that despite the recent funding winter, Venture Debt is
•
1 Growth: Expand into new geographies, deepen footprint in
still in high demand among startup founders.
existing geographies, launch new products or new businesses.
We are at a crucial inflexion point today. While the immediate
•
2 M&A Financing: Boost inorganic growth by acquiring firms
funding slowdown can be an acid test for debt investments, it
operating in existing or complementary businesses.
also brings with it an opportunity for founders to choose the right
investors and for investors to consolidate investments. Macro •
3 Capex and Project Financing: Meet capex requirements such
trends indicate that Indian Venture Debt investments are set as purchase of new warehouses or manufacturing facilities,
to grow to $6Bn by CY30. Additionally, with a more nuanced risk machinery upgrades, strengthening existing supply chain, etc.
return profile, increased investor interest in debt instruments and
•
4 Working Capital Financing: Address working capital
higher participation from varied capital providers, the Venture Debt
requirements of operational expenses such as purchasing raw
market can potentially leapfrog to $10Bn by CY30. This would imply
materials, financing receivables, etc.
a 10% share of projected VC investments, which is closer to the
Venture Debt penetration seen in more developed markets such •
5 Onward Lending: Provide funds to Fintechs operating in the
as the US. lending space to build out their loan portfolio.
In this report, we delve into the Indian Venture Debt journey so far, Recognizing this opportunity, banks have also forayed into providing
prevalent use cases, insights from the startup ecosystem on debt banking solutions and services customized to the needs of startups.
financing and the road ahead.
4 VENTURE DEBT: THE RISING TIDE OF CREDIT IN THE NEW ECONOMY
In addition, banks are gradually getting into offering some forms of The following levers of demand and supply will propel the next wave
credit to startups as well including select products such as working of growth in Venture Debt.
capital loans. Regulatory support to enable flexibility in underwriting
Enablers for growth in demand
and repayment norms can help drive further participation of banks
into India’s Venture Debt ecosystem. • Increased awareness: Higher awareness among startup
founders, venture capital providers about product features, use
Interest for private credit and alternative investments has also
cases and accessibility.
increased among different categories of investors in the last 5 years.
Predictable cash flows, an attractive risk-return profile and potential • Product innovation: Tailor-made solutions to solve for specific
for equity upside has led to a sizable allocation of Venture Debt financing needs of a startup, beyond traditional debt.
within alternative investment portfolios. As of today, the preferred
• Increased collaboration: Deeper relationships of Venture Debt
mode of engagement for most individual and institutional capital
providers with other investors such as Venture capital firms,
providers is through specialist funds.
Banks, NBFCs, Private Credit funds, etc. to leverage each others'
Venture Debt investments cater to different kinds of limited partners strengths in distribution, cost of capital, etc.
in different ways:
Enablers for growth in supply of capital
•
1 Insurance companies: Predictable returns and regular cash
• Broadened investor pool: A wider array of investors in Venture
flows from Venture Debt supports forward-looking estimation
Debt, such as global institutions, will help to fulfill increasing
for insurance companies.
capital needs of the ecosystem.
•
2 Endowment funds: Regular cash flows provided by Venture
• Increase in allocation: A steady track record of performance of
Debt investments help manage operational expenses of
Venture Debt funds across vintages will power higher portfolio
endowment funds.
allocations towards Venture Debt.
•
3 HNIs and family offices: Venture Debt enables risk
With the above enablers and continued regulatory support, Venture
diversification in the alternate investment portfolio of family
Debt is well placed for an exponential growth trajectory. It is an
offices. It also helps traditional business houses in exploring
asset class whose time has well and truly come in India.
investments in new-age businesses.
•
4 Development Finance Institutions: It aligns with the objectives
of these institutions to expand the availability of credit to
the startup ecosystem that has largely been under-served by
traditional lenders.
•
5 Banks: Present underwriting models do not align with startup
business models. Venture Debt helps build startups’ credit
history, thereby making them gradually eligible for bank loans.
As both global and domestic investors consider increasing their
portfolio allocation towards private credit, Venture Debt has
emerged as one of the leading segments driving these investments.
TABLE OF
CONTENTS
VENTURE CURRENT THE NEXT
DEBT: SCALING LANDSCAPE HORIZON:
ALONG WITH AND UNLOCKING THE
STARTUPS PERCEPTIONS FULL POTENTIAL
VENTURE DEBT:
SCALING ALONG
WITH STARTUPS
How credit is becoming
mainstream for Indian startups
8 VENTURE DEBT: THE RISING TIDE OF CREDIT IN THE NEW ECONOMY
Indian Venture Debt investments
rapidly growing to reach $1Bn p.a.
Venture Debt investment
Over 100 deals closed in CY22
has grown at 22%
Deal Average ticket
Amount in ($Bn) 3 key factors for
count size in $Mn
rapid growth
2% R 0.87
+2CAG 0.80–0.85 CY22E 100–120 7–7.5 Secular growth:
Increase in YoY
venture capital
equity investments
0.46 CY21 94 9.3
Cyclical growth:
COVID-19 impact Equity slowdown from
Q2 of CY22 onwards
0.26 led to higher adoption
CY20 58 4.5
of alternative
financing options
CY19
Demand Supply
76 6.1 Growth:
CY19 CY20 CY21 CY22E
Increased awareness
and access to non-
dilutive sources
When we started out in the early 2000s, there were of financing
no avenues for new independent businesses in India — Rajeev Agrawal,
to raise debt in any form. However, as a founder, I am Founder, Innoviti
glad to note that this has changed completely today.
Note: Data comprises ~380 disclosed deals comprising debt disbursements by prominent domestic and foreign
investors; excludes $860Mn in debt funding raised by Oyo Rooms CY21
CY22 data estimated basis deal activity by top 4 Venture Debt funds
Source: Venture Intelligence; Tracxn; BCG-Trifecta Founder Interactions; BCG analysis
VENTURE DEBT: SCALING ALONG WITH STARTUPS 9
A variety of startups considering debt to optimize cost of capital
StashFin • This included several debt providers across Venture Debt players,
NBFCs and even global pools of debt in the form of ECB lines
Top 5 Sectors
Fintech/Insurtech
Consumer goods /
Consumer Tech • 63% of players are
66% willing to substitute
Healthtech >20% of their next
fund raise with
SaaS Venture Debt
• 23% players want
Logistics to raise $10–20Mn
in debt
Source: BCG-Trifecta Venture Debt Survey with Founders 2022 (N=35); BCG-Trifecta Founder Interactions;
BCG analysis
VENTURE DEBT: SCALING ALONG WITH STARTUPS 11
US Venture Debt has scaled substantially in the last decade
Venture Debt penetration at 17% of VC investments by value and 19% by deal count,
averaged over the last 5 years
Investments in $Bn Deal count
400 - - 4,000
342
3,036
300 - 2,780 2,618 - 3,000
2,683
2,415
2,139 2,048 2,176
200 - 238 - 2,000
1,714 167
1,406 145 146
1,184
86 83 89
100 - 73 - 1,000
42 50
33 34 33 32
17 26
7 8 11 15 15
0 - - 0
CY12 CY13 CY14 CY15 CY16 CY17 CY18 CY19 CY20 CY21 CY22
% of VC
By Deal Value 18% 16% 16% 20% 18% 17% 18% 23% 20% 10% 13% 17%
By Deal Count 15% 14% 16% 19% 20% 19% 20% 22% 21% 17% 17% 19%
Venture Debt deal count Venture Debt investments ($Bn) Venture Capital investments ($Bn) Average (CY18–22)
CY21: Venture Debt penetration dropped as VC flows Venture Debt deals with ticket size > $100Mn have
hit a historical high at $342Bn; doubling from CY20 grown 2x since CY20 and 5x since CY18
Pitchbook definition
Venture Debt Provider: Banks, a Venture Debt fund, or any other type of investor that provides debt-financing to a venture-backed company
Venture Debt User: Venture-backed companies, that have completed at least 1 VC deal and have not subsequently undergone an IPO/PE Buyout/Acquisition
Source: PitchBook-NVCA Venture Monitor 2022; BCG analysis
12 VENTURE DEBT: THE RISING TIDE OF CREDIT IN THE NEW ECONOMY
US Venture Debt investments see greater
traction in growth stages
Average Venture Debt ticket size for growth & expansion stage firms
($Mn)
% respondents
Early stage (up to series A) Risks at this stage often include
27% concept risk, best funded by equity
One of our most important financial decisions, that we took early, was to optimize
our capital structure with Venture Debt. At first, it served as an additional buffer
to meet unexpected contingencies like demonetization, while later we found — Anuj Srivastava,
specific use cases which were structurally best financed with debt. Its terms also Founder, Livspace
allowed us to retire the obligation at the appropriate time in our growth journey.
Source: BCG-Trifecta Venture Debt Survey for Founders (N=35), BCG analysis, BCG-Trifecta Founder interactions
14 VENTURE DEBT: THE RISING TIDE OF CREDIT IN THE NEW ECONOMY
Venture Debt in India is led by Fintech, Consumer segments
The Good
Consumer product Atomberg
& services
29% Glamm Group
Stashfin Paperboat
Healthcare 12%
CURRENT
LANDSCAPE AND
PERCEPTIONS
Use cases & value proposition
2A. Venture Debt Use Cases 2D. Perspectives: Investors
2B. Venture Debt Value Proposition 2E. The Evolution of Venture Debt in India
2C. Perspectives: Banks
Convertible debt
• Assets and IP
Collateral Cash Flows Assets/IP • Cash collateral in the form
of FD or Mutual fund
• Working cap: Yearly renewal
Maturity period 6–24 months 18–36 months • Capex: 2–3 years
• Banks: 9–12%
Interest rate Effectively 20–25% 13–15%
• NBFCs: 13–15%
Equity
Not mandatory Typically 8–12% of debt amount None
Participation
• Amortizing with or Working capital: Flexible drawdowns
Repayment Predefined funding timelines &
without moratorium & monthly interest payment
structures shared alignment towards growth
• Revolving credit facilities
1 2 3
Growth M&A Capex & Project
Use case Expand to new geographies, new offerings
financing financing
G.O.A.T. Curefoods
Brand Labs
Builder.ai Livspace Furlenco BOX8
GlobalBees Ixigo
For example Cars24 Cuemath Innoviti BigBasket
The Good Glamm Group
• Expansion in existing and new • Create “digital HUL” style • Set up new warehouses and
geographies across the world consortium of brands processing facility for fruits
• Capital needed for • Timely acquisitions of & vegetables
maintenance of used car complementary firms; • Strengthen the cold-chain
inventory at various locations realize marketing &
Strategic rationale pan-India, typically as distribution synergies
working capital
• Raised $800Mn+ in Acquisitions: • Ramped up supply chain
subsequent equity capital • Content platforms: PopXO, infrastructure; helped
• Present in 5 countries ScoopWhoop, Miss Malini, service the demand surge
across the globe Winkl & Vidooly during multiple COVID
• Personal care: St. Botanica related lockdowns
Result & Organic Harvest,
MomsCo, BabyChakra
Source: Trifecta analysis
22 VENTURE DEBT: THE RISING TIDE OF CREDIT IN THE NEW ECONOMY
5 key use cases of Venture Debt are prevalent in India
4 5
Use case Working capital financing Onward lending
B2B platform with full stack Credit led fintech company; offers
Infra. instant loans to individuals &
managed marketplace for Kissht
Market small businesses; forayed into
construction materials
Deep dive payments & insurance
• Low-cost capital better for working • Other debt providers were slower and offered
capital intensive business smaller amounts of debt
• Procurement of construction • Post COVID growth goals:
materials & financing of receivables » Scale the NBFC book
to supplement the rapid growth » Collaborate with more providers;
Strategic rationale achieve 2x leverage
% share % share
Product development/
new product launch
71% Growth financing 38%
Personnel and
Team expansion
40% M&A financing 8%
30%+ firms
Working capital
financing
34% Operational expansion 4% used funds
for growth
55–70% and working
Capex and Project firms used VCs were not willing/able to capital needs.
financing
26% invest at that point of time
4%
funds for Optimizing
new product dilution
launch, during an
M&A financing 17% operational equity round
expansion also an
and branding important
Onward lending 6% activities reason
Source: BCG-Trifecta Venture Debt Survey with Founders (N=35), BCG analysis
24 VENTURE DEBT: THE RISING TIDE OF CREDIT IN THE NEW ECONOMY
Innovative reasons to raise Venture Debt are emerging
Funds are deployed in growth Invest in revenue Leverage Venture Debt for
opportunities while there is generating assets/ business expansion to
high cash reserves i.e. higher businesses to augment enhance valuation, with
ability to repay repayment capacity limited dilution
Capital
requirement Identifying need for debt, Introduction to debt providers
identification specific use case & their selection
5–6
Weeks
Deal Evaluation Evaluation & due Negotiation Documentation
& Execution diligence by investor of terms and funding
2 Weeks 3–5 days 3–4 Weeks
Venture Debt is emerging as an asset class and an umbrella term for — Rahul Khanna,
different private credit solutions. Venture Debt firms will continue to innovate Managing Partner,
on structured finance products as needed by the startup community. Trifecta Capital
Reasonable cash runways are preferred when evaluating companies for Venture Debt
• At Series A, startups have higher runways as their 1st institutional capital has been raised
but their spends have not yet ramped up
• This dips in Series B, but increases again in later stages as the investment sizes increase
Sectors that attract more Venture Capital, also see higher flows of Venture Debt investments
• 70% of Venture Debt investments in last 5 years in 4 sectors – Fintech, Consumer
products, Consumer services & enterprise
• Fintech and consumer services were amongst the top funded sectors in CY22, accounting
for more than $6Bn in equity funding across 300+ deals. In addition, these sectors
showcase strongest Venture Debt use cases across onward lending, fulfilling working
capital needs & deploying capital for growth
42%
31%
23%
Source: BCG-Trifecta Venture Debt Study Survey 2022 (N=35), BCG analysis
30 VENTURE DEBT: THE RISING TIDE OF CREDIT IN THE NEW ECONOMY
Increasing product awareness is a key enabler for growth of
Venture Debt investment flows
Never considered
36% First time founders feel Venture Debt is a
raising debt
nascent ecosystem
Actively considering
raising debt Limited awareness of Venture Debt investors
Source: BCG-Trifecta Venture Debt Study Survey for Founders 2022 (N=35), BCG-Trifecta Interaction with Founders & Investors, BCG analysis
CURRENT LANDSCAPE AND PERCEPTIONS 31
Founders are dependent on their existing network for choosing
Venture Debt
57% Got introduced to their Venture Debt investment term sheet, we discuss with
investor via existing network our founders about pros and cons of
Venture Debt, and introduce them to
our partner Venture Debt funds.
— Prayank Swaroop, Partner, Accel
Source: BCG-Trifecta Venture Debt Study Survey for Founders 2022 (N=35), BCG-Trifecta Interactions with Founders & Investors, BCG analysis
32 VENTURE DEBT: THE RISING TIDE OF CREDIT IN THE NEW ECONOMY
Founders prefer debt providers offering better economics
Source: BCG-Trifecta Venture Debt Survey for Founders 2022 (N=35), BCG-Trifecta Interactions with Founders & Investors, Investors, BCG analysis
CURRENT LANDSCAPE AND PERCEPTIONS 33
BCG + Trifecta Capital
2C. PERSPECTIVES:
BANKS
Pre-approved Escrow
OD management
2D. Perspectives:
Investors
Endowment Funds
• Downside risk protection is of paramount importance
for endowments
• Equity upside further helps to make this asset class
more attractive than typical debt products
• Regular cash flows for endowment funds helps with
managing opex due to the need to fund their P&L
• Periodic cash flow distributions are more favorable
compared to venture capital cash flows which follow a
steeper J-Curve pattern
As the broader Venture ecosystem has matured and awareness on Venture Debt has
— Nilesh Kothari,
increased, we've seen several categories of investors allocate towards Venture Debt.
Managing Partner,
While there is a significant potential to deepen penetration within existing capital
Trifecta Capital
pools, tapping into new capital pools, including global capital is a large opportunity.
$1,302Mn
$1,102Mn
$407Mn
$213Mn
$76Mn
CY15 CY18 CY19 CY21 CY22
TRIFECTA CAPITAL ALTERIA CAPITAL TRIFECTA CAPITAL TRIFECTA CAPITAL STRIDE VENTURES
Launch of Launch of Venture Debt Fund II Venture Debt Fund III Venture Debt Fund II
Trifecta Capital Alteria Capital $144Mn $250Mn $200Mn
Venture Debt Fund I Venture Debt Fund I
$76Mn $137Mn
ALTERIA CAPITAL
Venture Debt Fund II
$245Mn
Note: The cumulative Venture Debt fund data comprises of funds raised by Trifecta Capital, Alteria Capital, Stride Ventures and Innoven Capital
Source: BCG-Trifecta analysis
44 VENTURE DEBT: THE RISING TIDE OF CREDIT IN THE NEW ECONOMY
Trifecta Capital acting as a catalyst in further expanding product
offerings across a startup's lifecycle
2015 onwards 2020 onwards 2021 onwards
Financial Advisory
Venture Debt Fund Growth Equity
Services
1st player in Indian startup Started financial advisory & other Gradually progressing into growth
ecosystem to offer Venture Debt service offerings equity funding for startups
to startups
• 40+ startups leveraging • 1st fund of $250Mn raised
• Over $500Mn Venture Debt Treasury Management & invested in Dailyhunt,
fund raised till date services Livspace, Cars24, etc.
• Portfolio of 150+ companies • Access to leading members of • Targeted towards growth or
across industries the startup investor ecosystem late-stage tech-based startups
The Good
Atomberg BharatPe Atomberg Bizongo Ixigo Glamm Group
VC as %
0.4% 1.2% 0.9% 1–2%
of GDP
VC investments as
GDP $22,996Bn $3,084Bn percentage of GDP in
India came close to the
US benchmarks in 2021,
a record-setting year
for investments across
VC investments $342Bn $38.5Bn both geographies
(% of GDP) (1.5%) (1.1%)
1. As on August 24th 2022; Startup criteria used: Backing status - VC/Incubator/Angel, Ownership status - privately held
Source: Preqin, Pitchbook, Oxford Economics, Venture Intelligence, Tracxn; BCG analysis
48 VENTURE DEBT: THE RISING TIDE OF CREDIT IN THE NEW ECONOMY
THE NEXT HORIZON: UNLOCKING THE FULL POTENTIAL 49
Growth enablers: Demand
Strengthen presence in
Broaden the investor pool existing investor groups
As the industry matures, expanding the While investors are considering Venture Debt
array of investors participating in Venture as a part of their overall portfolio, increased
Debt funds will fuel the growing capital awareness will driver higher allocation
requirements. This includes building towards this asset class. This will be further
investment vehicle structures that can draw aided by demonstrating a successful track
global institutional capital such as multi- record of Venture Debt investments across
family offices, pension funds, sovereigns, sectors and ticket sizes, over the next
endowments, etc. to Venture Debt. economic cycle. Vintage of experienced
fund managers is also expected to provide
additional comfort to investors and drive
further allocations.
ATUL SATPATHY
Associate, Trifecta Capital
Atul.Satpathy@trifectacapital.in
Acknowledgements
This report is a joint initiative of Boston Consulting Group (BCG) and Trifecta Capital India.
We are thankful to Mihir Vora, Pankaj Dinodia, Sriram Mahadevan, Rajeev Ahuja, Gautam Sehgal, Prayank
Swaroop, Rajat Agarwal, Rahul Taneja, Amit Kulkarni, Sameer Brij Verma and Abhilash Sethi for their valuable
insights to enriching this report.
We thank the 40+ founders we connected with over the BCG-Trifecta Venture Debt Survey for Founders,
2022 and 1-on-1 interactions for their contribution towards the enrichment of this report.
We extend our sincere appreciation to Jasmin Pithawala, Komal Mohan and Sucheta Desai for marketing and
communications support and to Saroj Singh, Sujatha Moraes, Subhradeep Basu, Soumya Garg, Nitesh Tirkey,
Naman Arora, and Dinkle Thakker for their extensive design and report production support.