Leonardo: The MIT Press

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 2

Leonardo

Supersensonics: The Spiritual Physics of All Vibrations from Zero to Infinity by Christopher
Hills
Review by: Richard I. Land
Leonardo, Vol. 12, No. 1 (Winter, 1979), p. 74
Published by: The MIT Press
Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/1574102 .
Accessed: 12/06/2014 22:44

Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.

The MIT Press and Leonardo are collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to
Leonardo.

http://www.jstor.org

This content downloaded from 194.29.185.251 on Thu, 12 Jun 2014 22:44:59 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
74 Books

series of chapters he then examines the different techniques used begun in this time'. [cf. Encyclopaedia Britannica, 11th edition
in studying how individuals and groups arrive at their own (1910), vol. 6, p. 115, with referenceto De la baguette divinatoire,
understanding of place. For example, he provides mental maps et des tables tournantes (1864) by Chevreul]. It is a generally held
of varying degrees of complexity, statistical analyses of verbal belief that divining comes under motor automatism-'a non-
descriptions of locations and comparisons of intuitive distance reflex movement of a voluntary muscle, executed in the waking
estimating. These chapters are principally a summary of the state, but not controlled by ordinary waking consciousness' [cf.
researchmethods used, with comments, followed by conclusions above reference, vol. 3. p. 48], which was not considered by Hills.
that at times are startlingly obvious. 'There is certainly a growing What the cues are that a diviner uses has not been explained by
awareness amongst many environmental decision-makers that him or, to my knowledge, by anyone else.
children have different requirements from adults.' I did not find this a useful book. In many instances Hills
He concludes with a confusing chapter of suggestions, confus- presents incorrect technical information. There is no index and
ing, that is to me, entitled Creating a Sense of Place. Here Canter there are no useful references;no quantitative data are offered;
proposes a method to aid designers in their use of images. For proven information is refuted by incomplete subjective obser-
such an important aspect of the work of designers, what is needed vations. I sense that the author wishes to help in the development
by them is not a technical method but imagination to understand of a comfortable community of individuals who have a better
a particular environment, sensitivity to appreciate its historic awareness of their environment and their interaction with it.
pattern and humility in expressing their own aesthetic values.

The Behaviourof Communicating.An Ethological Approach. W.


Supersensonics:The Spiritual Physics of All Vibrationsfrom Zero John Smith. Harvard Univ. Press, Cambridge, Mass., and
to Infinity. Christopher Hills. Univ. of the Trees, Boulder Creek, London, 1977. 545 pp., illus. ?13.65. Reviewed by Gerhard
Calif., n.d. 607 pp., illus. Paper, $15.00 Reviewed by Richard I. Charles Rump**
Land*
Communication studies have, for the greaterpart, not taken into
This large copiously illustrated and pleasantly reading book is account the results of comparative ethology. It is a fairly recent
about divining. The author is convinced that events cannot development that an increasing number of scholars show
happen separately from consciousness and must always happen interest in this fundamental discipline. Until now they had to
within consciousness (p. 41). He therefore presents the physical read through a mass of material not directly linked to their field
world subjectively, and discusses issues in terms of radiation that of study-but this situation has changed with the appearance of
results from vibrations that are associated with matter. The Smith's book, which is a most welcome contribution to human
physics discussed and the author's understanding of the work of knowledge.
Einstein is only partly correct, making most of his discussions In his book, Smith enlarges ethology's perspective on
misleading. His descriptions of divining equipment are detailed communication (and, as I have said, vice versa) by shifting the
but unscientific. Materials are only designated as 'wood', focus of attention away from motivation (what makes birds
'dielectric', 'magnet', but, for example, the kind of wood and if it sing?) to message, that is, the information shared by animals
is dry or not is ignored: conductivity and measurements of through their displays (what information is made available to
radiation response is lacking and strength of magnets is not other birds by song?). Also, the evolutionary processes
given, furthermore, the size of objects used can only be inferred underlying the observed behavioural patterns of animal
from the pictures provided. communication are investigated.
The text, in three parts, blends together without a clear Smith is a very good observer, and so the core of the book is
introduction or conclusions. The first part, Beyond Phenomena: formed by very detailed analyses of observed communicative
The Science of Radiational Paraphysics, deals with The displays and display repertoires together with a theoretical
Perception on Unseen Worlds, Energy, Einstein and discussion of them. A taxonomy and an interpretativeanalysis of
Consciousness, use of pendulums, fields, fluxes, apparatus of messages by formalized behaviour are also developed.
'supersensonics' (including the Hills End-Fire Wave-Guide The most important chapter for the non-ethologist is Chapter
Stimulator and Radiator-HEFIGAR) and Consciousness and 10 on Meanings and Functions, which centres on the pragmatic
Light Energy-The New God-Cosmic Dust. This is followed dimension of communicative behaviour. When signals permit
by chapters on Light and on the Philosophy of Science and the sharing of information, one becomes interested in the uses to
Supersensonic Detectors, the former with a section on color, a which this information is put. Analyzing information alone
mixture of fact and fancy, with some of the facts rather well- provides one with a grasp of neither the meanings nor the
presented, considering the context. Although selected statements functions of displays. Only when dealing with meaning, with the
from a text can be misleading, let me offer a few wild assertions responses to signals, can one begin to understand the process of
from the first chapters. 'This book is ultimately about communicating and 'its potential as a tool of interactional
mechanisms of perception (bringing messages from the environ- behaviour'. And only if we have considered function, that is, the
ment), although we will be researching specific vibrations and 'biologically significant' consequences of acts, 'can we under-
patterns of energy as they appear to our sensations to come from stand why particular meanings are important results of sharing
objects and matter.' 'This volume is a first step because with it information-that is, how these responses enable the evolution
you hold the key to the mystery of your own psychic processes ofinterdependence betweenparticipantsengagedin the behaviour
and, more important, those processes by which the evolutionary of communicating'. Ethologists have so far understood the
intelligences are even now controlling your destiny as a human responses as the crucial components of communicating, as there
being or as a Cosmic Being.' 'If we think we know it all or try to fit is no communication without a response. From this view stems
nature into some preconceived set-up in our consciousness, we the consequent lack of research into the information content of
will be automatically guaranteed failure in all that this volume displays. Smith wants to correct this situation, as he points out
sets out to do. The attitude of the student must be open-minded, that 'there is no single crucial component in communicating;
which means forgetting entirely what you know already and furthermore, 'the study of the responses and functions that
learning something new.' depend on displays is still fragmented'.
I have long been fascinated by dowsing and diviner's rods. For In this context, meaning is defined as follows: 'For a
many years I have experimented with a simple hand held communicator, the meaning of a display in a particular event is
pendulum. While Hills mentions the recent work of Louis the response he expects or intends to elicit by using it . . ., even
Turenne (1920's), he has neglected an earlier Frenchman of though the information provided by the display may sometimes
considerable distinction in chemistry, color theory and divi- fail to have the foreseen effect.' The concept offunction is directly
nation, M.E. Chevreul (1786-1889), who 'was a determined linked to the concept of meaning, as the functions of displays
enemy ofcharlatanism in every form, and a complete sceptic as to depend on their meanings to recipients: 'In the absence of any
the "scientific" psychical research or spiritualism which had
** Ubierstrasse 135, D 5300 Bonn, Bad
Godesberg. Fed. Rep.
*10 Trapelo Rd., Belmont, MA 02178, U.S.A. Ger.

This content downloaded from 194.29.185.251 on Thu, 12 Jun 2014 22:44:59 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

You might also like