Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Case Viettire 10 1108 - EEMCS 05 2017 0092
Case Viettire 10 1108 - EEMCS 05 2017 0092
strategy in Myanmar
Sang Kim Tran and Le Ngoc Hoang Yen
DOI 10.1108/EEMCS-05-2017-0092 VOL. 8 NO. 3 2018, pp. 1-29, © Emerald Publishing Limited, ISSN 2045-0621 EMERALD EMERGING MARKETS CASE STUDIES PAGE 1
outside Vietnam. And I think Myanmar will be a good match for our extension. As I have
mentioned in the invited email, I hope that this meeting can bring us outstanding strategies
for the company’s development”. Mr Huy, Planning Manager said: “At this stage, due to the
very little knowledge about Myanmar market so I think that starting at the first basic step is
understand the market demand and customer responses”. “What do you think about
exporting strategy?” The meeting becomes exalted with this idea. While the Marketing
Manager stands up with her idea: “Agree about the issue of big cost, insufficient local
information, and risk we are considering about Myanmar market, but we should take a risk
and make a commitment. I think we should find out the trustable and potential trade so that
we can offer them to become our oversea dealer by licensing strategy. With this strategy,
later on, we still can open the representative office in Myanmar and develop it for the
long-term”. Mr Hoang and another manager again discuss this idea and they all feel very
excited about the expansion of many imagined picture in their mind. After a couple of
minutes, Mr Hung, Co-owner said: “Why don’t we directly open a store there. We can still
manage by ourselves and keep the opportunity with us”. They all start to raise the evidence
to protect their idea and develop it. The meeting was a great brainstorming session, but it
created headaches for Mr Hoang, as he was still reluctant on choosing a strategy for
entering Myanmar.
Myanmar is a big pie for investors and businessmen to open and develop their business
ideas. The market is very potential but risky when there are too many outsiders looking to
enter it. Expansion in this market will help Viettire reach a new level. However, the following
questions are raised: “Should Viettire enter the Myanmar market or not? and How?” In the
following sections, this paper shall clarify this issue with three options:
1. Option 1: Exporting, find local distributors and sell products directly to them.
2. Option 2: Licensing, look for a strong dealer who can satisfy Viettire’s standard and in
regards, both parties have same benefits.
3. Option 3: Wholly owned subsidiary, open a new business there.
If he applies one in three, then, how will he allocate resources to implement it. The rest parts
of this paper will analyze three possible options for this dilemma.
2. Company background
2.1 Company overview
Established in 1987 with the original name “THAI HUNG TIRE TRADING LTD. Co.”, Thai
Hung specialized in distributing domestic tire and other types of automotive spare parts at
that time. With longtime experience and reputation in the tire industry, on January 6, 2008,
the company name was officially changed to Viettire Joint Stock Company and called
“Viettire” under the management of ten members of a family, and is developing till now (see
Exhibits 1 and 2). With strong collaboration between these founders, at the moment, Viettire
has seven branches such as Toan An, Phu Loi, An Phu, Thai Hung, Thai An, Nhu Ngoc and
Song Toan located in Ho Chi Minh City and other provinces, 300 dealers around the
country, mostly in the south. The total staff is around 200 people. The headquarters is
located at 18 Ha Noi Highway, Binh Thang Commune, Di An District, Binh Duong, and the
main office is at 190 Bach Dang Street, Ward 24, Binh Thanh District, Ho Chi Minh City,
Vietnam.
Initially, Viettire clearly defined its vision and mission in accordance with the needs of its
stakeholders. In Viettire, there are seven main stakeholders; each has some certain
expectations from Viettire (Table I):
Vision: “to be a top distributor for tires in Vietnam”. Not only provide high-quality
products, Viettire also wants to bring customers convenience from value-added
services that should be found in the Viettire distribution network. This prompted Viettire
to keep raising its chain store establishment, giving more strength and confidence to
reach the setting vision.
Mission: “Let’s us save your cost”. Viettire understands how important saving cost is to
customers, especially in today’s fast-changing global environment. Viettire is proud of
its best after-sales services align with the best machines and equipment.
Core value: Bring the best comfort value, satisfaction and trust to stakeholders. With
customers, Viettire commits to deliver high-quality products at a reasonable price.
Products in Viettire are top brand names having an obvious origin chosen carefully and
given a thorough warranty. The price of goods offered is fixed. With business partners,
in the spirit “with a tire, we are in one”, Viettire defines that Viettire and manufacturers
have the same benefits, same customers; thus, when cooperating with Viettire,
business partners will gain absolute satisfaction. With employees, Viettire tries to create
a good working environment for people to grow, give them opportunities for
demonstrating their capabilities to get promoted. With society, Viettire commits to
follow the legal regulation, meet society’s demand and fulfill its responsibilities.
1. Option 1: Exporting, find local distributors and sell products directly to them.
2. Option 2: Licensing, look for a strong dealer who can satisfy Viettire’s standard and in
regards, both parties have same benefits.
3. Option 3: Wholly owned subsidiary, open a new business there.
If he applies one in three, then, how will he allocate resources to implement? The rest of this
paper will analyze and discuss three possible options for this dilemma. The
recommendation will provide a solid framework for the decision-makers of the company to
follow in order to get success.
3.2. Methodology
To address the aims, a case study was undertaken based on a dilemma of Viettire. Since
then, we have used various types of models such as Porter’s five forces, S.W.O.T analysis
competitive advantage to analyze the primary data to find and propose a suitable strategic
decision-making for this emerging market. We worked closely with the Finance Department
to collect primary data. To exploit maximum information for the study, some other methods
and techniques have been used as follows.
Interviews: We conducted an interview with Mr Hoang, CEO, to understand the company’s
situation and to clarify the dilemma with Mr Cuu, CFO, and Mr Mori Yang, Director of Maxxis
representative office in Vietnam, to get their opinions on choosing criteria for each option.
Observation: One of the team members of our group is now working for this organization.
She is responsible for marketing development and has a chance to go to Myanmar for
researching information on this project. Therefore, she knows the progress well (Trading,
2004; Caillaud, 2016).
We collected and searched information from various sources such as Viettire company
profile, Viettire website, the internet, textbooks and its chapters in Essential Strategic
Management (Hill and Jones, 2012).
We used online Skype chat, email and Viber to discuss with the CEO, Chairman, etc. (as
it is really necessary) and relevant staffs during our consultant. We constructed a mind map
to brainstorm our next course for this consulting to minimize the effect.
4. Results
4.1 Porter’s five forces analysis
Porter’s five forces Model is another tool used to analyze the external factors affecting the
tire industry (Hill and Jones, 2012). First, the intensity of rivalry among established firms is
low because car spare parts are mostly small distributors and retail shops. There is only
one Japan Tire Services Company Limited that provides sales support for Bridgestone tires
in Myanmar, and no leading automobile manufacturer except Suzuki, Toyota and Mitsubishi
has set up or appointed authorized agents to provide service centers and supply original
spare parts directly. Second, bargaining power of suppliers is low, as suppliers are
1. Efficiency: Viettire has been a Maxxis’ strategic partnership for a long time and is an
exclusive distributor in Vietnam of this 9th largest tire manufacturing company, from
2011. This generates many core advantages for Viettire. It has full control of
consumption and delivery of Maxxis tire for the whole country except in the north. More
specially, Maxxis has offered a chance to Viettire to become their exclusive distributor
in Myanmar which other rivals hardly gain. The annually increasing revenue is a good
evidence of the customer loyalty, with a turnover of more than US$50m in the previous
year. It is proved how Viettire operates effectively.
2. Quality: Maxxis is already well-known and highly regarded by the public. Providing a
larger variety of products and always monitoring the quality of the products and
services. Viettire has been known by many Vietnamese customers with a high
reputation chain store as a result of this consequence. In every aspect of a business,
Intensity of rivalry among established firms (⫺) Low. Most current distributors for car spare parts were very small retail shops
Bargaining power of suppliers (⫺) Low. Suppliers wanted to collaborate with Viettire since they could meet their
criteria
Bargaining power of buyers (⫺) Medium. The supplier was strong at high quality and affordable price while
customers were price sensitive
Risk of entry by potential competitors (⫹) Medium. New entrants needed strong financial capital and large-scale integration
Threat of substitutes (⫺) Low. It was very hard to substitute for tire products
Efficiency in operation and long-term strategy The exclusive distributor for Maxxis in Vietnam
Having trademarks license for entering Myanmar market
Turnover keeps increasing (see Appendix 3)
Innovation in serving customer need Vary and unique service
High quality Premium quality and suitable products
Align with customer demand
Global brand name recognition
Customer responsiveness Loyal customer
Trustworthy brand name
to the quality of its products, its ability to market those products and the fit of its
products with Viettire. The company must also be able and willing to make a financial
commitment that includes an advance payment of an annual minimum guaranteed
royalty and periodic royalty payments based on a percentage of sales. The company
must also carry general liability and other appropriate insurance with respect to its
business operations and activities.
Where: Maxxis products will be delivered from Viettire’s warehouse in Binh Duong,
Vietnam.
When: After the agreement between Viettire and the other Myanmar side is signed.
Whom: We will sell in bulk directly to the dealer.
How: Do a market research to understand the market and find a suitable dealer.
The advantage of this option is exploring new customers and giving the brand to the new
market and make customer recognize this brand name gradually. Viettire can monitor the
quality of products and services that are delivered to the end users. In this way, Viettire can
get customers’ feedback in order to improve its offering. In addition, it can help Viettire
realize the economy of scale based on sales volume. The most important factor is that this
is potential for company long-term strategy if setting up a new company here in the future.
Taking time to find a partner, establishing a relationship and lowering of profits are its
disadvantages.
5. Conclusion
Basing on the charts we have drawn above and the criteria collected from the stakeholder,
we analyzed the following:
In the Branding factor: From the criteria asked from the stakeholder, this one is the most
important in the expansion campaign because developing the Viettire brand is the vision of
the CEO of the company for Myanmar market individually. He wants as many customers as
possible to know and acquaint themselves with Maxxis, the exclusive distributor. In this
field, we can recognize that the best results are Option 2 (Licensing) and Option 3 (Wholly
owning) when they can bring Viettire brand directly to the Myanmar market and customer.
Exporting is the smallest one and this is its weakness because it just plays a supplier role
in this field which supplies Maxxis product for detail seller in Myanmar.
About the Expense: We can see that Exporting will have the smallest cost because it does
not need a big operation cost. It just requires an amount of advertising fee, while the other
two required the investment of more revenue for training (Licensing) and an even larger
operation costs (Wholly owning). In this field, Option 1 (Exporting) will grant the biggest
advantages for choosing.
In the Customer Satisfaction factor: Similar to the Branding factor, in this field, Licensing
and Wholly owning will have a big advantage because they can decorate and design their
store to match with customer need and import as well as control directly the operation
process. Exporting is the worst because they just export from the parent company without
any management of the goods flow in Myanmar.
In the Controllable/Management factor: We have to agree that if we want to develop the
brand, store and future plan, we have to have the right to manage and control how it should
be. Therefore, this is a critical reason to decide which option we should choose. Exporting
takes the lowest score owing to its lack of brand management. Licensing is very good in
this field when they achieve 8/10 points. However, the best one belongs to Wholly owning
when they get 9 points for their brand management.
In Low Risk: It means that when you run a business, is there any risk from the government
or industry or local company to harm you and your company. With a stable balance and use
of partner knowledge about the market and law, Licensing takes the first prize in this case.
Next is the Wholly owning and the last is Exporting. Although Exporting is less documentary
6. Recommendations
As the recommendation on company’s entering strategy is option 2 (licensing), and the new
emerging economy with political, economic and social reform on the process, that makes
doing business in Myanmar so uncertainty and unpredictable circumstances so the
emergent strategy which implies that an organization is learning what works in practice, is
suitable approach (Hill and Jones, 2012; Kotabe and Helsen, 2010; Luthans and Doh,
2009). In addition, at Viettire, there are various ideas among leaders and senior staffs.
Hence, Viettire should take into account human resource management. In so far, there were
many mixed opinions relevant to the theme of “one person government official, all their
Step 1: Find a suitable partner Establish a research team combined company’s staffs and consultants from Myanmar who are
knowledgeable in this industry to search for a potential partner who satisfies all requirements and
is willing to cooperate with the company in mutual benefit and equally share risk. Then the
contract between both sides will be signed
Step 2: Transfer technology and After that, this partner will follow strictly the process and design from Viettire. That means Viettire
design assigns an expert to teach this partner all the technology and design exactly from the parent
company to build the initial image’s identity on customers
Step 3: Testing This is due to the fact that Myanmar market is new for our company, a quality team from Vietnam
should be appointed testing the customers’ responsiveness for 6 months for our products and
services which is useful to make a change or enhance our system to match customers’ need
Step 4: Improve quality Based on the results of testing, Viettire will deliberate with a partner what action to take to tackle
the drawbacks and improve what we are good at. To implement this step, Viettire will send the
experts which are full-trained skills and many experiences to make a better improvement with
regard to market’s demand and competing to rivals
Step 5: Expand After all above steps have been done, Viettire will ensure the adequate system to apply in
Myanmar market. That makes Viettire easily access new market and gain market share later on. If
the appropriate system is applied, potential growth of the company is so huge
Bhalla, V., Caye, J.M., Dyer, A., Dymond, L., Morieux, Y. and Orlander, P. (2011), “High-performance
organizations”, Own the Future: 50 Ways to Win from the Boston Consulting Group, pp. 171-177.
Caillaud, R. (2016), “Myanmar: opportunities and challenges for businesses”, FTI Journal, FTI
Consulting, available at: www.ftijournal.com/article/myanmar-opportunities-and-challenges-for-
businesses
Falzon, D. (2016), “The opportunities and risks of investing in Myanmar”, British Chamber of
Commerce Singapore, available at: www.britcham.org.sg/static-pages/o47-feature-opportunities-
risks-investing-in-myanmar, (accessed 25 December 2017).
Guthridge, M., Komm, A.B. and Lawson, E. (2008), “Making talent a strategic priority”, McKinsey
Quarterly, Vol. 1, p. 48.
Hill, C.W. and Jones, G.R. (2012), Essentials of Strategic Management, South-Western/Cengage
Learning, San Francisco.
Investinmyanmar (2009), “How difficult is doing business in Myanmar?”, available at: www.
investinmyanmar.com/difficulty-of-doing-business/ (accessed 2 May 2016).
Kaplan, R.S. and Norton, D.P. (1996), The Balanced Scorecard: Translating Strategy into Action,
Harvard Business Press, New York, NY.
Kotabe, M. and Helsen, K. (2010), Global Marketing Management, John Wiley & Sons, New York, NY.
Kotler, P. and Keller, K.L. (2006), “Marketing Management 12e”, New Jersey.
Lazarova, N. (2015), “Myanmar’s accelerating automotive aftermarket growth”, available at: www.
mmbiztoday.com/articles/myanmar-s-accelerating-automotive-aftermarket-growth; (accessed 25
December 2017).
Luthans, F. and Doh, J.P. (2009), International Management: Culture, Strategy, and Behavior,
McGraw-Hill Irwin, New York, NY.
Trading, M.A.P. (2004), “History of rice marketing in Myanmar”, MAPT, Ministry of Commerce, the
Union of Myanmar (Yangon), p. 273.
Viettire (2016), “About Viettire”, available at: http://viettire.com/ (accessed 24 December 2017).
Yen, H. (2015), “Myanmar-a potential export market (Thi truong xuat khau sang Myanmar day tiem
nang)”, available at: https://baomoi.com/thi-truong-xuat-khau-sang-myanmar-day-tiem-nang/c/16637
745.epi (accessed 3rd Jan 2018).