Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Idealism and Realism - Introduction
Idealism and Realism - Introduction
The terms “idealism” and “idealist” are by no means used only within
philosophy; they are used in many everyday contexts as well. Optimists who
believe that, in the long run, good will prevail are often called “idealists”. This
is not because such people are thought to be devoted to a philosophical doctrine
but because of their outlook on life generally; indeed, they may even be pitied,
or perhaps envied, for displaying a naïve worldview and not being
philosophically critical at all. Even within philosophy, the terms “idealism” and
“idealist” are used in different ways, which often makes their meaning
dependent on the context. However, independently of context one can
distinguish between a descriptive (or classificatory) use of these terms and a
polemical one, although sometimes these different uses occur together. Their
descriptive use is best documented by paying attention to the large number of
different “idealisms” that appear in philosophical textbooks and encyclopedias,
ranging from metaphysical idealism through epistemological and aesthetic to
moral or ethical idealism. Within these idealisms one can find further
distinctions, such as those between subjective, objective and absolute idealism,
and even more obscure characterizations such as speculative idealism and
transcendental idealism. It is also remarkable that the term “idealism”, at least
within philosophy, is often used in such a way that it gets its meaning through
what is taken to be its opposite: as the meaningful use of the term “outside”
depends on a contrast with something considered to be inside, so the meaning of
the term “idealism” is often fixed by what is taken to be its opposite. Thus, an
idealist is someone who is not a realist, not a materialist, not a dogmatist, not an
empiricist, and so on. Given the fact that many also want to distinguish between
realism, materialism, dogmatism, and empiricism, it is obvious that thinking of
the meaning of “idealism” as determined by what it is meant to be opposed to
leads to further complexity and gives rise to the impression that underlying such
characterizations lies some polemical intent.
Realists are divided into three classes based on their view of the essential causes
of interstate conflict. Classical realists believe it follows from human
nature; neorealists attribute it to the dynamics of the anarchic state
system; neoclassical realists believe it results from both, in combination with
domestic politics. Neorealists are also divided between defensive and offensive
realism. Realists trace the history of their ideas back through classical antiquity,
beginning with Thucydides.