Professional Documents
Culture Documents
MBR Report Final
MBR Report Final
MBR Report Final
CONSUMER-BRAND
RELATONSHIP: A BRAND HATE
PERSPECTIVE
MBR research report fall 2022
Abstract
Backlash for brands is widely seen among consumers. This research is conducted examine the
model of brand hate so that brands could know the reasons behind these hates. This is done in
this report by considering different variables that are depending to each other also those which
are mediating the relationships. The data is collected from lay-consumers without any biasness.
Then it is tested on SPSS by running different tests to get reliable, valid, and significant results.
1
Table of Contents
Introduction: ................................................................................................................................................. 2
Problem:.................................................................................................................................................... 2
Research objectives: ................................................................................................................................. 3
Research questions ................................................................................................................................... 3
Literature: ..................................................................................................................................................... 3
Theoretical framework: ...................................................................................................................... 3
Conceptual framework: ............................................................................................................................ 3
Variables: .................................................................................................................................................. 4
Brand Hate (BH): ....................................................................................................................................... 4
Negative Brand Experience: ...................................................................................................................... 5
Complaining: ............................................................................................................................................. 6
Hypothesis: ............................................................................................................................................... 7
Methodology: ............................................................................................................................................... 8
DATA COLLECTION .................................................................................................................................... 8
QUESTIONARRE DESIGN ........................................................................................................................... 8
VARIBALES ................................................................................................................................................. 9
RESEARCH DESIGN .................................................................................................................................... 9
SAMPLE DESIGN ........................................................................................................................................ 9
STATISTICAL TECHNIQUE ........................................................................................................................ 10
Results and findings: .................................................................................................................................. 10
Model testing and validity tests:............................................................................................................. 10
Reliability................................................................................................................................................. 12
Convergent and discriminant validity: .................................................................................................... 13
Validity of moderators: ........................................................................................................................... 14
final decision:.............................................................................................................................................. 15
Conclusion:.................................................................................................................................................. 17
Citation: ...................................................................................................................................................... 18
2
Introduction:
The set of human traits connected to a brand is referred to as its brand personality (Aaker, 1997, p. 347).
Overall enthusiasm, competence, sophism, and ruggedness are the five components that make up
personality. On the other hand, negative brand personality (NBP) is described by Haji (2014, p. 24) as "a
set of qualities given to a brand by the consumer to reflect feelings that provoke tension, worry, or
incongruity.” Today we have so many brands for a same product. This allows consumers to
choose the brand according to their affordability and choice. The decision that consumer make
while opting for a brand is mainly based on the brand's advertisement and marketing. And the
phenomena of brand hate starts when the brand fails to fulfil their promises they made in their
advertisement. Consumers have high expectations from the brand and when it does not stand
up to their expectations, that's when the real problem starts. Brand hate is a real threat to
brands. Because once a customer gets dissatisfied, they would never shop from the same brand
again and spread negative reviews about it. Word of mouth is the main source through which a
brand succeeds and if the customers are dissatisfied and are spreading negative review about a
brand, that brand is in real problem.
It is important for brands to understand the human psychology and design their products
according to that. To understand the human psychology, they need to have a high-end grip on
the market trends, current fashion, and what the market demands and then come up with that
product. They also need to stick to their promises they make in their advertisement to gain
loyal customers. If the experience of a customer for a product of a brand isn't good, that will
ultimately create hate in the customer's heart for its other products too. In the gap Previous
research have studied on the brand hate what will have been effect on the negative brand
experience on the sensory, Affective, Behavioural, and Intellectual. And through our
significance we will research on brand betrayal what will effect on the negative brand
experience on the sensory, Affective, Behavioural, and intellectual.
Problem:
Brands heighten the expectations of customers through their advertisement and marketing and
then fail to meet those expectations and generate dissatisfied customers which ultimately
results in brand hate.
3
Research objectives:
1. To identify the antecedents and outcomes of brand hate.
2. To test the impact of multi-dimensional negative brand experience
on brand hate.
3. To identify the antecedents and outcomes of brand betrayal.
4. To test the impact of multi-dimensional negative brand experience
on brand betrayal.
Research questions
1. What are the antecedents and outcomes of brand hate.
2. What will be impact of multi-dimensional negative brand experience
on brand hate.
3. What are the antecedents and outcomes of brand hate.
4. What will be impact of multi-dimensional negative brand experience
on brand hate.
Literature:
Theoretical framework:
Brand hate
Negative brand Consumer
experience
S O R
Conceptual framework:
Sensory Complaining
Brand hate
Affective Private
Intellectual
4
Variables:
Negative brand experience is an independent variable in this situation. Its dimensions are sensory,
affective, behavioral, and intellectual. Through these dimensions we measure our independent variable
negative brand experience that has influence on dependent variable. Here dependent variable is brand
detachment and complaining (including both public and private). The independent variable shows
impact on dependent variable but here is some intervening. The mediation of brand hate and brand
betrayal exists between independent and dependent variables. Its presence plays a vital role in the
relationship of independent dependent variables.
In simpler terms negative brand experience influence brand detachment and complaining through brand
hate and brand betrayal. Implying that negative brand experience serves as independent variable, brand
hate and brand betrayal serve as mediators, however; brand detachment and complaining serve as
dependent variable.
According to Grappi and Dalli (2012), consumers' complaints, brand switching, and
poor word-of-mouth can all be attributed to unfavourable brand-related feelings.
Bryson et al.
(2013) establish the antecedents of brand hatred in the instance of premium brands
as well as define brand hate as an "extremely negative emotional reaction towards
the brand"
Zarantonello et al. (2016) conducted an empirical investigation on the
characteristics, causes, and effects of the phenomena of brand hatred. They hinted at
brand hatred by linking it to unfavourable behavioural consequences including
whining, bad word-of-mouth, protest, and a decrease in or cessation of patronage.
They recognised the notion of "brand hate" as having multiple dimensions and
created a scale to quantify it (Zarantonello et al.,2016).
After that, Hegner et al. (2017) experimentally investigated the idea of brand hatred
and provided a taxonomy of the key causes and results. These scholars contend that
customers' prior bad experiences, ideological incompatibility, and symbolic
incongruity cause brand hatred. These result in three undesirable behavioural
consequences, namely:
Brand avoidance
Negative word-of-mouth and
Brand retaliation
Brands are "intangible and emotional economic indicators," according to Kucuk
(2019a, p. 561), and are at the foundation of consumer decision-making. According
to research, businesses with little social activities and an increase in consumer
complaints would have the most despised brands globally (Kucuk, 2019b).
Zhang and Laroche (2020) indicate recently that brand hatred manifests as hostility,
frustration, and fear.
Sensory
Affective
Behavioural
Intellectual
promotes favourable customer image of the brand, which results in favourable
brand behaviour (Brakus et al., 2009; Iglesias, Markovic & Rialp, 2019; Jhambet al.,
2020).
Previous study has used specific elements with a low resistance from the original
Brakuset al. scale to execute brand experience (2009). However, no study has
applied negative value or ionic to the full scale.
The presence of "negative brand experiences" has commonly been brought up in
numerous studies across a variety of contexts, including consumer anxiety in online
discussion about negative brand experiences (Brandao & Popoli, 2022; Wakefield &
Wakefield, 2018),
defectors' ability to consider the brand for future purchases (Bogomolova &
Romaniuk, 2010),
and anti-consumption and brand avoidance (Lee et al., 2009).
According to Baumeister et al. (2001), more people are likely to share negative
experiences than they are to share equally positive ones.
Negative brand experiences are described as a "unimaginable perception" by
Fournier (1998, p. 355) since they may cause customers to feel uneasy and may
even prompt them to quit.
Complaining:
According to Bearden and Oliver (1985), a comprehensive definition of complaining
includes both personal and public responses.
Romani et al. (2012) discovered that when consumers are angry about a brand, they
are more likely to complain because they are more motivated to seek a resolution.
Zarantonello et al. (2016) describe brand hate as a complicated construct made up
of many unfavourable feelings that lend support to a variety of consequences.
Aggression, according to Bayarassou et al. (2020), is a behavioural result of brand
hatred. However, the metrics they employed to measure reaction can be linked to
7
Hypothesis:
H1 (a) negative brand experience dimension sensory has positive effects on brand hate
H1 (b) negative brand experience dimension affective has positive effects on brand hate
H1 (c) negative brand experience dimension behavioral has positive effects on brand hate
H1 (d) negative brand experience dimension intellectual has positive effects on brand hate
H2 (a) negative brand experience dimension sensory has positive effects on brand betrayal
H2 (b) negative brand experience dimension affective has positive effects on brand betrayal
H2 (c) negative brand experience dimension behavioral has positive effects on brand betrayal
H2 (d) negative brand experience dimension intellectual has positive effects on brand betrayal
H3 Brand hate has positive impact on brand detachment
H4 Brand hate has a positive impact on complaining.
H5 Brand betrayal has a positive impact on brand detachment
H6 Brand betrayal has a positive impact on complaining.
H7 brand hate mediates the relationship of sensory negative brand experience and brand
detachment.
H8 brand hate mediates the relationship of affective negative brand experience and brand
detachment.
H9 brand hate mediates the relationship of behavioral negative brand experience and brand
detachment.
H10 brand hate mediates the relationship of intellectual negative brand experience and
brand detachment.
8
H11 brand betrayal mediates the relationship of sensory negative brand experience and
brand detachment.
H12 brand betrayal mediates the relationship of affective negative brand experience and
brand detachment.
H13 brand betrayal mediates the relationship of behavioral negative brand experience and
brand detachment.
H14 brand betrayal mediates the relationship of intellectual negative brand experience and
brand detachment.
H15 brand hate mediates the relationship of sensory negative brand experience and brand
complaining.
H16 brand hate mediates the relationship of affective negative brand experience and brand
complaining.
H17 brand hate mediates the relationship of behavioral negative brand experience and
brand complaining.
H18 brand hate mediates the relationship of intellectual negative brand experience and
brand complaining.
H19 brand betrayal mediates the relationship of sensory negative brand experience and
brand complaining.
H20 brand betrayal mediates the relationship of affective negative brand experience and
brand complaining.
H21 brand betrayal mediates the relationship of behavioral negative brand experience and
brand complaining.
H22 brand betrayal mediates the relationship of intellectual negative brand experience and
brand complaining.
Methodology:
DATA COLLECTION
An online survey (Google Form) that was disseminated via social media is how we got the data. We had
213 responses from both men and women between the ages of 18 and 45. The people who really use
any brand could fill out the questionnaire because we used random sampling. End users are the target
demographic for our study, allowing us to learn more about their perceptions of the brands they dislike.
This survey assisted us in compiling statistics on how complaints and brand estrangement are caused by
unfavorable brand encounters.
QUESTIONARRE DESIGN
Since this is a quantitative and empirical study, we created an open-ended questionnaire to determine
the effect of bad brand experiences on brand hate and betrayal. With regard to 8 constructs, the Likert
9
scale—strongly disagree to strongly agree—was utilized. This is how our questionnaire is structured. We
obtained their demographics first, followed by their income level (ranging from 50k-200k). Then, we
inquired as to their preferred brand name. We incorporated the evaluation questions to assess various
components that breed brand animosity. The questions revolve around this.
VARIBALES
In our study, we essentially used a variety of factors to assess their impact on bad brand experiences.
Therefore, these dimensions help in our ability to evaluate the impact of an independent variable on a
dependent one. We used about 8 constructs in our empirical study to precisely find the effect of
negative brand experience on brand hatred. Our research method's IV and DV variables are detachment
and complaint, respectively. Basically, we're trying to determine the impact of different factors that
contribute to brand hating, which produces a negative feeling toward a brand and ultimately results in a
bad brand experience. The brands of hatred and betrayal, IV and DV, also exhibit the mediation effect.
RESEARCH DESIGN
We chose convenience sampling when designing the sample for our study. As a result, we focused on
people we could easily and conveniently reach via the internet and social media. Our research is based
on the Positivism research paradigm, which holds that there is only one reality that can be measured.
Our study is a quantitative investigation into the consumer brand relationship, a brand hate perspective.
The study is specifically designed to measure consumer brand perspective, as well as a dislike brand
perspective. The study has been specifically designed to assess consumer brand perception. Aside from
that, our research covers the consumer's dislike for a brand. We used convenience sampling to conduct
an online survey with 213 respondents, and then we tested our conceptual model using empirical data
from the participants' responses.
SAMPLE DESIGN
Our research included people who have internet access and use social media websites to actively follow
their preferred products/brands on various social media websites such as YouTube, Twitter, Facebook,
10
Instagram, and Online Brand Communities and Discussion Forums. However, because every member of
the target population did not have an equal chance to participate in this research by answering these
questions, we used a non-probability-based sampling technique. The number of respondents to our
survey was 213 due to a limited social circle and time constraints. The online survey was sent to 500
social media users. However, due to a small social circle and time constraints, only 213 people
completed our survey. In our survey, men and women were equally represented.
STATISTICAL TECHNIQUE
We stopped receiving responses to our survey once we reached 200+ responses. First, we checked for
missing values after making sure the data was complete, we calculated the averages for each construct.
Then, we downloaded a spreadsheet of our responses from Google Forms and uploaded it to SPSS
software (Statistical Package for Social Sciences) for statistical analysis. On SPSS, we ran various tests to
assess data normality, demographic analysis, reliability of scale items, validity of scale items, correlation
among different concepts, regression analysis for hypothesis assessment, and the goodness of fit test to
validate our conceptual model.
P<0.05
t>1.96
f>3.86
✓ Brand hate is stronger variable in affect as per its b- value in both the cases; when complaining is
the dependent variable and when brand detachment is the dependent variable.
✓ Negative brand experience affective and negative brand experience behavioral are not
significant when they are depending on brand hate.
✓ Only negative brand experience behavioral is insignificant when dependent variable is brand
betrayal.
12
Reliability
The criterion of reliability is that Cronbach Alpha values must > 0.70.
Reliability Statistics
Cronbach's
Alpha N of Items
.897 6
a) Brand betrayal
Reliability Statistics
Cronbach's
Alpha N of Items
.858 3
b) Negative brand experience sensory
Reliability Statistics
Cronbach's
Alpha N of Items
.803 3
Reliability Statistics
Cronbach's
Alpha N of Items
.493 3
Reliability Statistics
Cronbach's
Alpha N of Items
.713 3
Reliability Statistics
Cronbach's
Alpha N of Items
.734 3
13
✓ All the variables except negative brand experience affective are reliable.
and discriminant validity by the criteria that under root on AVE being higher than the correlations.
✓ And all the variables are showing discriminant validity or uniqueness by the criteria that under
root on AVE being higher than the correlations.
14
Validity of moderators:
By using the tables provided below, we check the validity, reliability, and overall relation of all
moderators taking place in the relation of our dependent and independent variables.
p>0.05
t>1.96
f>3.86
confidence interval
variables R square F B t sig upper lower
h7: NBS BH BD 0.415 0.61 -0.035 -0.781 0.436 -0.123 0.053
h8: NBA BH BD 0.356 1.936 -0.073 -1.391 0.166 -0.176 0.03
h9: NBB BH BD 0.354 6.13 -0.118 -2.476 0.014 -0.212 -0.024
h10: NBI BH BD 0.386 3.97 -0.086 -1.992 0.048 -1.7 -0.001
h11: NBS BB BD 0.407 0.849 -0.038 -0.922 0.358 -0.12 0.044
h12: NBA BB BD 0.314 0.247 -0.026 -0.497 0.62 -0.128 0.076
h13: NBB BB BD 0.325 5.05 -0.099 -2.247 0.026 -0.185 -0.012
h14: NBI BB BD 0.359 4.271 -0.087 -2.067 0.04 -0.169 -0.004
h15: NBS BH BC 0.3 0.924 -0.037 -0.961 0.337 -0.113 0.039
h16: NBA BH BC 0.373 0.478 0.028 0.691 0.49 -0.052 0.108
h17: NBB BH BC 0.445 0.001 0.001 0.025 0.98 -0.068 0.069
h18: NBI BH BC 0.486 7.666 -0.086 -2.769 0.006 -0.147 -0.025
h19: NBS BB BC 0.295 1.763 -0.047 -1.328 0.186 -0.118 0.023
h20: NBA BB BC 0.359 2.274 0.059 1.508 0.133 -0.018 0.137
h21: NBB BB BC 0.458 0.153 0.012 0.391 0.696 -0.049 0.073
h22: NBI BB BC 0.47 5.021 0.067 -2.241 0.026 -0.126 -0.008
✓ Relation of sensory negative brand experience with complaining is not mediated by brand hate
✓ Relation of affective negative brand experience with complaining is not mediated by brand hate
✓ Relation of behavioral negative brand experience with complaining is not mediated by brand
hate
✓ Relation of intellectual negative brand experience with complaining is mediated by brand hate
✓ Relation of sensory negative brand experience with complaining is not mediated by brand
betrayal
✓ Relation of affective negative brand experience with complaining is not mediated by brand
betrayal
15
✓ Relation of behavioral negative brand experience with complaining is not mediated by brand
betrayal
✓ Relation of sensory negative brand experience with detachment is not mediated by brand hate
✓ Relation of affective negative brand experience with detachment is not mediated by brand hate
✓ Relation of behavioral negative brand experience with detachment is mediated by brand hate
✓ Relation of intellectual negative brand experience with detachment is mediated by brand hate
✓ Relation of sensory negative brand experience with detachment is not mediated by brand
betrayal
✓ Relation of affective negative brand experience with detachment is not mediated by brand
betrayal
final decision:
H1 (a) negative brand experience dimension accept
sensory has positive effects on brand hate
H1 (b) negative brand experience dimension Reject
affective has positive effects on brand hate
H1 (c) negative brand experience dimension reject
behavioral has positive effects on brand hate
H1(d) negative brand experience dimension Accept
intellectual has positive effects on brand hate
H2 (a) negative brand experience dimension Accept
sensory has positive effects on brand betrayal
H2 (b) negative brand experience dimension Accept
affective has positive effects on brand betrayal
H2 (c) negative brand experience dimension Reject
behavioral has positive effects on brand betrayal
H2 (d) negative brand experience dimension Accept
intellectual has positive effects on brand betrayal
H3 Brand hate has positive impact on brand Accept
detachment
H4 Brand hate has a positive impact on Accept
complaining.
H5 Brand betrayal has a positive impact on brand Accept
detachment
16
Conclusion:
Now we can conclude that:
➢ negative brand experience dimension sensory has positive effects on brand hate
➢ negative brand experience dimension affective has no positive effects on brand hate
➢ negative brand experience dimension behavioral has no positive effects on brand hate
➢ negative brand experience dimension intellectual has positive effects on brand hate
➢ negative brand experience dimension sensory has positive effects on brand betrayal
➢ negative brand experience dimension affective has positive effects on brand betrayal
➢ negative brand experience dimension behavioral has no positive effects on brand betrayal
➢ negative brand experience dimension intellectual has positive effects on brand betrayal
➢ Brand hate has positive impact on brand detachment
➢ Brand hate has a positive impact on complaining.
➢ Brand betrayal has a positive impact on brand detachment
➢ Brand betrayal has a positive impact on complaining.
➢ brand hate doesn’t mediate the relationship of sensory negative brand experience and
brand detachment.
➢ brand hate doesn’t mediate the relationship of affective negative brand experience and
brand detachment.
➢ brand hate mediates the relationship of behavioral negative brand experience and brand
detachment.
➢ brand hate mediates the relationship of intellectual negative brand experience and brand
detachment.
➢ brand betrayal doesn’t mediate the relationship of sensory negative brand experience and
brand detachment.
➢ brand betrayal doesn’t mediate the relationship of affective negative brand experience and
brand detachment.
➢ brand betrayal mediates the relationship of behavioral negative brand experience and brand
detachment.
➢ brand betrayal mediates the relationship of intellectual negative brand experience and
brand detachment.
➢ brand hate doesn’t mediate the relationship of sensory negative brand experience and
brand complaining.
➢ brand hate doesn’t mediate the relationship of affective negative brand experience and
brand complaining.
➢ brand hate doesn’t mediate the relationship of behavioral negative brand experience and
brand complaining.
➢ brand hate mediates the relationship of intellectual negative brand experience and brand
complaining.
18
➢ brand betrayal doesn’t mediate the relationship of sensory negative brand experience and
brand complaining.
➢ brand betrayal doesn’t mediate the relationship of affective negative brand experience and
brand complaining.
➢ brand betrayal doesn’t mediate the relationship of behavioral negative brand experience
and brand complaining.
➢ brand betrayal mediates the relationship of intellectual negative brand experience and
brand complaining.
Citation:
[1] Roy, Sanjit K., et al. “Consumer - Brand Relationship: A Brand Hate Perspective.” Journal of Business
Research, 2022, pp. 1–12., https://doi.org/https://www.elsevier.com/locate/jbusres.