Professional Documents
Culture Documents
10 5923 J JNPP 20190902 01
10 5923 J JNPP 20190902 01
10 5923 J JNPP 20190902 01
DOI: 10.5923/j.jnpp.20190902.01
1
Plasma Physics Research Center, Science and Research Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran
2
Department of Medical Nanotechnology, Faculty of Advanced Sciences and Technology, Tehran Medical Sciences,
Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran
Abstract This research is studied the nonlinear interaction of underdense plasma by high intensity laser pulse regard to
ohmic heating and effect of ponderomotive force. The nonlinear ponderomotive force was depended on particle oscillation in
laser pulse that resulted to electron charge and electron density oscillation in plasma. The oscillation of heterogeneous electric
field was imported to plasma electrons. Using the solutions of Maxwell's and hydrodynamic equations were investigated
electron density, magnetic and electric field during plasma. Also Maxwell's equations were obtained through plasma and
laser interaction by MATLAB programming language and fourth method of the Runge-Kutta. Based on results, increase of
intensity of laser pulse was resulted to decrease of wavelength of magnetic and electric field. At the same time, oscillation of
electron density was sharply peaked. Also temperature oscillation was increased and wavelength was decreased.
Keywords Nonlinear, Underdense plasma, High intensity laser pulse
[17]. Also, the ions motion and the nonlinear ohmic heating
1. Introduction of the electrons were neglected in underdense collisional
plasma by a laser pulse [18].
The production of high energy electron was considered in The effect of magnetic field was showed on waves in
laboratory scale with high-power lasers as very active field plasma [19-21]. The high magnetic field was played an
of research [1-4]. Recently, the application of plasma was essential role in particle transport, propagation of laser pulse,
separated as new common method [5-6]. The acceleration of laser beam self-focusing, and penetration of laser radiation
electron has important applications in various domains in the into over dense plasma. The plasma electron density was
interaction of a high-intensity laser beam with plasma [7]. In increased in the presence of the external magnetic field [17].
underdense plasma, the propagation of high intensity laser The effect of external magnetic field was characterized on
pulse as many important researches caused to the relativistic electron density distribution and electromagnetic field in
plasma wave [8-14]. In last decade, the nonlinear interaction interaction of laser pulse with plasma [22-23]. The increase
of high intensity laser was the subject of many important of laser intensity was caused the decrease of the wavelength
researches in underdense plasma [15-16]. of electric and magnetic field oscillations and the increase of
Recently, the nonlinear propagation of intense laser pulse the electron density, the oscillations amplitude of electron
was studied through underdense magnetized plasma. The temperature, and the oscillations amplitude of the effective
Maxwell equations were used to achieve the nonlinear permittivity [18]. The collision of nonlinear electromagnetic
equation for the electric field in plasma. The plasma plasma was created the nonlinear ohmic heating in plasma
wave is generated by the ponderomotive force (Fp ) as a [24-25]. The plasma density and laser energy were affected
nonlinear force from regions of high intensity laser in an on the stability of laser monoenergetic electron beam [7].
inhomogeneous oscillating electromagnetic. The equation of Theoretical studies of plasma wave propagation are
electron motion was taken into the average ponderomotive importance for a vast range of problems. The Maxwell's
force per unit volume acting on the plasma electrons. Since equations were studied the collision effect in heating of
the ion mass is much greater than the electron mass, the underdense plasma by high intensity laser. The Maxwell’s
effect of the ponderomotive force was neglected on the ions and hydrodynamic equations were used for propagation of
nonlinear wave in hot plasma [26]. The hydrodynamic
* Corresponding author: equations were calculated electron density distribution and
fereydoon.ataei@gmail.com (Fereydoon Ataei)
Published online at http://journal.sapub.org/jnpp
field profile in magnetized underdense plasma in theoretical
Copyright © 2019 The Author(s). Published by Scientific & Academic Publishing section [27]. In the present work, the nonlinear interaction of
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution International high intensity laser pulse was studied with underdense
License (CC BY). http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ plasma using Maxwell's and hydrodynamic equations. The
44 Fereydoon Ataei and Negar Motakef-Kazemi: Nonlinear Underdense Plasma by High Intensity Laser Pulse
changes were investigated for wavelength, intensity of laser π is constant number and E is electric field. The relation of
pulse, density and temperature of electron, electric and ponderomotive force for electron relative ion is as follows:
magnetic field. F pi m 𝑒𝑒
= (5)
F pe m 𝑖𝑖
Which Fpi and Fpe are ponderomotive force for ion and
2. Theoretical Model and Formulation electron respectively. Also mi is ion mass. Based on the
The electron can be generated electric field in uniform result, the ponderomotive force had poor effect with larger
filed of ion to protection neutral plasma. In this case, electron mass. The electron density by considering potential
electrons were oscillated by specified frequency that called (φ) and electron temperature (Te ) is as follows:
eφ
plasma frequency (ωp ). When magnetic field is zero (B=0), ne = exp( ) (6)
Te
product of Boltzmann constant (k) and temperature (T) is
zero (KT=0), ions are resident, plasma dimension is When ω is electromagnetic wave frequency, electron
g g
unlimited and electrons are moved in x-direction, ωp is as density is 1020 3 and critical density (nc ) is 1021 3 ,
cm cm
follows: W
and laser flux is in order of I = 1017 2 . According to the
cm
1/2
ne e2 initial assumptions, parameter of focal point qatar (d) is 0.8
ωp = � � (1)
ε0 m e micrometer and laser pulse length 0.12 micrometer and
Which ne is electron density, e is electron charge, ε0 radiation effects were ignored. The intensity of laser pulse
eA
is electric constant, and me is electron mass. The was increased according to the formula 2 ≅ 0.73 where
m oe C
ponderomotive force is as follows:
A is number vector potential and moe is base electron mass.
Fp = 9 �ne (2) Also, intensity of electromagnetic wave (P) is as follows:
In the above equations, the plasma was depended on 15.89 ω 2
P = (7)
electron density. The interaction of laser with plasma has two ω 2pe
r
general forms that depended on ( 0 ) function where r0 and The laser pulse was spread during Z direction in plasma.
Cs
Cs are laser pulse and sound speed respectively [28]. If The nonlinear propagation was considered for high intensity
r laser pulse through collision of non-magnetic underdense
τ < 0 where τ is length of laser pulse, the laser radiation
Cs plasma at the area Z> 0. Based on the assumptions, the ion is
effect can be ignored on ions in plasma and ions were heavily and immovability in plasma. The geometry of
considered resident. The gas particles were ionized by laser coordinate system was shown for laser pulse in figure 2.
pulse (Fig. 1), and caused ponderomotive force.
1 ∂B
∇×E=− (12) By division of the relation of 22 to electron temperature,
C ∂t
1 ∂B the relation is as follows:
∇×B=
C ∂t
− 4Cπ e neV (13)
e 2 B 0 E x 𝑧𝑧 e 2 E 2x ne
Which V is electron speed and the amount of ∇ × E and − − = ln (27)
C i ω m e Te m e ω 2Te n 0e
∇ × B were assumed zero as the result electron speed is zero iω 4π
in y and z direction for wave propagation in z direction. So −By = − Ex . z − e ne Vx z (28)
C C
∂ ∂ iω 4π e2Ex z
∇= − and = −iω. −By = − Ex . z − ne (29)
∂z ∂t C C i ω me
∂B 𝑦𝑦 iω 4π
− =− E𝑥𝑥 − e ne Vx (14) Ex . z = −By (
C i me ω
) (30)
∂z 𝐶𝐶 C m e ω 2 −4 π e 2 C n e
Which E𝑥𝑥 and B𝑦𝑦 are electric filed in x direction and
That the amount of 4 π e2 C ne is discarded, the relation is
magnetic field in y direction respectively and Vx is electron as follows:
speed in x direction. For electric field in plasma, differential
By C i me ω
equation is as follows: Ex . z = − (31)
me ω2
∂2 Ex i ω ∂B y ∂B y C ∂2Ex
− = → =− (15) By replacement relation of 31 to relation of 27, the relation
∂z 2 C ∂z ∂z i ωdz 2
C ∂2 Ex iω 4π ∂ 2 E 𝑥𝑥 𝜔𝜔 2 is as follows:
= E − e ne Vx → + E𝑥𝑥
i ω ∂z 2 𝐶𝐶 𝑥𝑥 C ∂z 2 𝐶𝐶 2 e2B0Ey C i m e ω e 2 E 2x ne
− − = ln (32)
4πiω C i ω m e Te m e ω2 m e ω 2Te n 0e
= e ne Vx (16)
C e2B0Ey
ne e 2 E 2x e2
In plasma collision, the equation of electron motion is as ln =− − = (Ex2 − B0 Ey ) (33)
n 0e m e Te ω2 m e ω 2Te m e ω 2Te
follows: e2
ne = n0e exp � (Ex2 − B0 Ey )� (34)
∂V e V e ×B m e ω 2Te
me ne � + (Ve . ∇)Ve � = −e ne E − e ne
∂t C
The maximum of electron density is n0e when magnetic
−e ne ∇∅ − ∇Pe (17) and electric filed are zero ( Ex = By = 0 ). Nonlinear
That Pe = ne T is electron pressure. The mean differential equation of electromagnetic field in plasma is as
ponderomotive potential (∅) is as follows: follows:
∅ = Ex . A ∂2Ex ω2 4 π e 2 n 0e e2
(18) + �1 + exp �− �Ex2 − B0 Ey �Ex ��
∂z 2 C2 me ω2 m e ω 2Te
Which oscillation domain of electron (A) is as follows:
e Ex
= 0 (35)
αmax = (19)
me ω2 The calculation of plasma conductivity coefficient is as
And the maximum of electron oscillation acceleration is follows:
1 ∂
as follows: ∇×∇×E=− (∇ × B) (36)
C ∂t
2 F 2 eE 2 1 ∂
αmax = Aω → = Aω → = Aω (20) ∇�∇. E� − ∇2 E = − C ∂t (∇ × B) (37)
me me
The ponderomotive force was affected on plasma By derivative from time, the relation is as follows:
electrons in unit of volume, so the overall relation is as ∂ 1 ∂2E 4 π ∂J
(∇ × B) = (− ) (38)
follows: ∂t C ∂t 2 C ∂t
that calculated for isotropic magnetic plasma. Using first Which electron conductivity is σ. The electric constant is
order approximation, the motion equation is as follows: as follows:
∂V x K2C2 ω 2pe ω c m 0e C 2
me = −e E𝑥𝑥 (22) ε=− =1− (1 − ) (40)
∂t ω2 ω2 ω Te
e B0Vx e ∂∅ 1 ∂P e nω e B0
− − − =0 (23) That k = is cyclotron frequency and ωc = is
C ∂z n 0e ∂z C m 0e C
2 2
Which B0 is base magnetic field and n0e is base refractive index of material. So me C = 0.5 me V ,
∂
electron density. When = −iω, Vx is as follows: Te = 10Kev and ωpe ≥≥ ω and the change of ε is always
∂t positive.
eE x
−me i ω Vx = −e Ex → Vx = (24) ω 2pe ω c m 0e C 2
i ω me ε=1− (1 − ) (41)
ω2 ω Te
e E2
e2B0Ex ∂( x� )
m e ω2 1 d(n e T e ) The plasma is considered non-isothermal and collision is
− −C = (25)
C i ω me ∂z n 0e dz
changed during laser radiation into plasma electron
e 2 B 0 E x 𝑧𝑧 e 2 E 2x ne temperature. With regard to collisions, the result of electron
− − = Te ln (26)
C i ω me me ω2 n 0e
46 Fereydoon Ataei and Negar Motakef-Kazemi: Nonlinear Underdense Plasma by High Intensity Laser Pulse
vibrational motion is as follows: length (Z) for intensity of various laser pulses (Fig. 3 and
e Ex i ve Fig. 4). Based on the result, the longitudinal section of
vx = (1 − ) (42)
i meω ω electric field is increased by increasing of laser pulse
The ohmic heating is produced in plasma therefore: intensity in plasma.
eE x v x e2E2ve
= (43)
2 2 m e ω2
I = 2.5 × 1015 W/cm2 The critical density, base electron density and electron
temperature are as follows:
I = 1.0 × 1015 W/cm2
nc = 1.7 × 1021 cm−3
I = 0.1 × 1015 W/cm2
n0e = 1.0 × 1021 cm−3
The critical density, base electron density and electron
temperature are as follows: Te = 10 Kev
nc = 1.7 × 1021 cm−3 The change of electron density ratio is shown as the
function of plasma length (Z) for various magnetic fields
n0e = 1.0 × 1021 cm−3
(Fig. 8) and the oscillation of electron density is increased.
Te = 10 Kev
The change of electric field is shown as function of plasma
length (Z) for various magnetic fields (Fig. 6). Based on the
result, the wavelength oscillation of electric field is had little
change by increasing of magnetic field in plasma.
Te = 10 Kev plasma length (Z) for electron various temperatures (Fig. 11)
The change of electric field is shown as the function of and the longitudinal section of magnetic field and the ratio of
plasma length (Z) for various electron temperatures (Fig. 9) effective magnetic field are increased.
and the wavelength oscillation of electron temperature is
decreased.
Figure 11. Changes in magnetic field as the function of plasma length (Z)
a
for electron various temperatures ( = 1: dotted line - a/√δ = 2: bold
Figure 9. Changes in electric field as the function of plasma length (Z) √δ
dotted line - a/√δ = 4: line)
for electron various temperatures (𝑎𝑎/√𝛿𝛿 = 1: dotted line - a/√δ = 2: bold
dotted line - a/√δ = 4: line)
The laser pulse intensity is as follows:
The laser pulse intensity is as follows: I = 1.0 × 1015 W/cm2
I = 1.0 × 1015 W/cm2 The electron temperature is as follows:
The electron temperature is as follows: Te = 20 Kev
Te = 15 Kev
Te = 20 Kev
Te = 10 Kev
Te = 15 Kev The critical density and base electron density are as
Te = 10 Kev follows:
The critical density and base electron density are as nc = 1.7 × 1021 cm−3
follows: n0e = 1.0 × 1021 cm−3
nc = 1.7 × 1021 cm−3 The change of magnetic field is shown as the function of
n0e = 1.0 × 1021 cm−3 plasma length (Z) (Fig. 12) and the oscillation of magnetic
The change of electric field is shown as the function of field is increased.
plasma length (Z) (Fig. 10) and the oscillation of electric
field is increased.
density is decreased since electric constant is increased. magnetic influence. Based on the physical phenomenon, the
created ohmic changes are caused the decrease of the
electron wavelength that this subject is increased length
section of magnetic electric and field for non-sinusoidal and
r
nonlinear. In this article τ < 0 , and radiation effect of laser
Cs
pulse is ignored on ions via consideration of created ohmic
heating by the interaction of laser and plasma. The Maxwell's,
hydrodynamics, energy equations are indicated that
oscillation wavelength of electric field, wavelength of
electron temperature oscillation domain and oscillation
domain of magnetic influence is reduced.
4. Conclusions
In this study, high intensity laser interaction with
Figure 13. Changes in electron density ratio as the function of plasma
length (Z) for electron various temperatures (𝑎𝑎/√𝛿𝛿 = 1: dotted line - underdense plasma was investigated by Maxwell's and
a/√δ = 2: bold dotted line - a/√δ = 4: line) hydrodynamic equations, ponderomotive force, electron
ohmic heating, the longitudinal section in the electric and
The laser pulse intensity is as follows: magnetic field, oscillation and density of electron. The
I = 1.0 × 1015 W/cm2 oscillation wavelength of the longitudinal section was
The electron temperature is as follows: decreased and the oscillation was increased. The increase of
intensity of laser pulse was strongly peaked the effective
Te = 20 Kev
magnetic permeability, temperature and electron density
Te = 15 Kev oscillation because of the nonlinear ohmic heating effect. At
Te = 10 Kev same time, the wavelength was simultaneously decreased.
The critical density and base electron density are as In length section of electric and magnetic field, the
follows: oscillation wavelength was reduced but oscillation
expansion was increased. The increase of intensity of laser
nc = 1.7 × 1021 cm−3
pulse was dramatically increased density, temperature and
n0e = 1.0 × 1021 cm−3 effective magnetic permeability for electron in plasma. Also
they were reduced because of the ohmic heating effect of the
field.
3. Result and Discussion
The theoretical pattern was studied for interaction of
underdense plasma. Based on the results, interaction of high
intensity laser pulse is strongly nonlinear equation and there REFERENCES
is no analytical solution. The fourth method of Runge-Kutta
and MATLAB programming language were used to solve [1] J. Faure, C. Rechatin, A. Norlin, A. Lifschitz, Y. Glinec, and
the equation in the numerical form. The interaction of high V. Malka, “Controlled injection and acceleration of electrons
in plasma wake fields by colliding laser pulses,” Nature., vol.
intensity laser pulse was decreased oscillation wavelength. 444, pp. 737-739, Nov. 2006.
The increase of laser pulse intensity was resulted to the
increase of oscillation, the decrease of electron density, and [2] S. Fritzler, E. Lefebvre, V. Malka, F. Burgy, A.E. Dangor, K.
the increase of electric constant. The oscillation wavelength Krushelnick, S.P.D. Mangles, Z. Najmudin, J.P. Rousseau,
and B. Walton, “Emittance measurements of a laser-wake
of plasma was reduced by the decrease of electron density. field-accelerated electron beam,” Phys Rev Lett., Vol. 92, pp.
And the electron wavelength was decreased by the increase 165006, Nov. 2004.
of electric constant. The longitudinal section of field was
shown nonlinear and non-sinusoidal because of the current [3] S. Saha Ray, “New double periodic exact solutions of the
coupled Schrödinger–Boussinesq equations describing
increase of laser energy. The laser pulse intensity and physical processes in laser and plasma physics,” Chinese
electron density were increased as the function of plasma Journal of Physics., vol. 55, pp. 2039–2047, Nov. 2017.
length along the z axis in images.
The laser pulse duration is greater than plasma thickness [4] S.P.D. Mangles, C.D. Murphy, Z. Najmudin, A.G.R.
Thomas, J.L. Collier, A.E. Dangor, E.J. Divall, P.S. Foster, J
therefore the increase of dielectric constant is caused the
G. Gallacher, C.J. Hooker, D.A. Jaroszynski, A.J. Langley,
decrease of electron density in plasma. This physical subject W.B. Mori, P.A. Norreys, F.S. Tsung, R. Viskup, B.R.
is increased size of magnetic and electric field oscillations. Walton, and K. Krushelnick, “Monoenergetic beams of
Also the changes of laser pulse intensity are caused the relativistic electrons from intense laser–plasma interactions,”
increase of electron density oscillations, temperature and Nature., vol. 431, pp. 535-538, Nov. 2004.
50 Fereydoon Ataei and Negar Motakef-Kazemi: Nonlinear Underdense Plasma by High Intensity Laser Pulse
[5] E.A. Benkhelifa, and M. Djebli, “Plasma expansion [17] M. Mahmoodi-Darian, M. Ettehadi-Abari, and M. Sedaghat,
dynamics in the presence of a relativistic electron beam,” “The effect of external magnetic field on the density
Laser and Particle Beams., vol. 33, pp. 273-277, Nov. 2015. distributions and electromagnetic fields in the interaction of
high-intensity short laser pulse with collisionless underdense
[6] M.K. Guttal, and A. Sharief, “Evaluation of thermal plasma,” J Theor Appl Phys., vol. 10, pp. 33-39, Nov. 2016.
properties and life time of multilayered thermal barrier
coating obtained from suspension plasma spray,” Asian [18] M. Etehadi Abari, and B. Shokri, “Nonlinear heating of
Journal of Science and Technology., vol. 8(1), pp. underdense collisional plasma by a laser pulse,” Phys
4078-4083, Nov. 2017. Plasmas., vol. 18, pp. 053111, Nov. 2011.
[7] S.P.D. Mangles, A.G.R. Thomas, O. Lundh, F. Lindau, M.C. [19] I.V. Timofeev, “Two-dimensional simulations of nonlinear
Kaluza, A. Persson, C.G. Wahlstrom, K. Krushelnick, and Z. beam-plasma interaction in isotropic and magnetized
Najmudin, “On the stability of laser wake field electron plasmas,” Phys Plasmas., vol. 19, pp. 042108, Nov. 2012.
accelerators in the monoenergetic regime,” Phy Plasmas.,
vol. 14(5), pp. 056702, Nov. 2007. [20] A.N. Erokhin, N.N. Zolnikova, and N.S. Erokhin, “Analysis
of the dependence of surfatron acceleration of electrons by
[8] S. Abedi, D. Dorranian, M. Etehadi Abari, and B. Shokri, an electromagnetic wave in space plasma on the particle
“Relativistic effects in the interaction of high intensity momentum along the wave front,” Plasma Physics Reports.,
ultra-short laser pulse with collisional underdense plasma,” vol. 42(1), pp. 32-37, Nov. 2016.
Phys Plasmas., vol. 18, pp. 093108, Nov. 2011.
[21] G.V. Ostrovskaya, V.S. Markov, and A.G. Frank, “Influence
[9] Z.Y. Chen, S. Chen, J.K. Dan, J.F. Li, and Q.X. Peng, of the initial parameters of the magnetic field and plasma on
“Analytical model for electromagnetic radiation from a wake the spatial structure of the electric current and electron density
field excited by intense short laser pulses in an unmagnetized in current sheets formed in helium,” Plasma Physics Reports.,
plasma,” Phys Scr., vol. 84(4), pp. 045506, Nov. 2011. vol. 42(1), pp. 1-13, Nov. 2016.
[10] M.A. Bari, M. Chen, W.M. Wang, Y.T. Li, M.Q. He, Z.M. [22] M.S. Sodha, A. Sharma, and S.K. Agarwal, “Focusing of
Sheng, and J. Zhang, “Ion acceleration in the interaction of electromagnetic beams in collisional plasmas, with finite
an intense laser pulse with structured plasma,” Phys Scr., vol. thermal conduction,” Phys Plasmas., vol. 13, pp. 083105,
77(6), pp. 065502, Nov. 2008. Nov. 2006.
[11] A.R. Niknam, M.R. Jafari Milani, B. Bokaei, and M. [23] M. Manouchehrizadeh, and D. Dorranian, “Effect of
Hashemzadeh, “Weakly relativistic and ponderomotive obliqueness of external magnetic field on the characteristics
effects in interaction of intense laser beam with of magnetized plasma wake field,” J Theor Appl Phys., vol.
inhomogeneous collisionless and collisional plasmas,” Wave 7, pp. 43-48, Nov. 2013.
Random Complex., vol. 24(1), pp. 1-18, Nov. 2014.
[24] V.B. Pathak, and V.K. Tripathi, “Propagation of terahertz
[12] K. Hajizadeh, M. Etehadi Abari, Y. Ahmadizadeh, and B. electromagnetic wave in plasma with inhomogeneous
Shokri, “Collisions effect in the heating of underdense collision frequency,” Phys Plasmas., vol. 14(2), pp. 022105,
plasma by a high-intensity short laser pulse,” Phys Scr., vol. Nov. 2007.
85(5), pp. 055501, Nov. 2012.
[25] V.N. Tokarev, E.A. Cheshev, V.V. Bezotosnyi, V. Yu
[13] X. Xia, Z. Quin, B. Xu, and Z. Cai, “Dielectric constant and Khomich, S.I. Mikolutskiy, and N.V. Vasilyeva,
laser beam propagation in an underdense collisional plasma: “Optimization of plasma effect in laser drilling of high
effects of electron temperature,” Phys Scr., vol. 84, pp. aspect ratio microvias,” Laser Phys., vol. 25(5), pp. 056003,
015508, Nov. 2011. Nov. 2015.
[14] L.M. Gorbunov, P. Mora, and R.R. Ramazashvili, “Laser [26] V.G. Dorofeenko, V.B. Krasovitskiy, and V.A. Turikovc,
surface wake field in a plasma column,” Phys Plasmas., vol. “Parametric decay of an extraordinary electromagnetic wave
10, pp. 4563, Nov. 2003. in relativistic plasma,” Asian Journal of Science and
Technology., vol. 41(3), pp. 286–293, Nov. 2015.
[15] A.R. Niknam, M. Hashemzadeh, and B. Shokri, “Weakly
relativistic and ponderomotive effects on the density [27] R. Sadighi-Bonabi, and M. Etehadi-Abari, “The electron
steepening in the interaction of an intense laser pulse with an density distribution and field profile in underdense
underdense plasma,” Phys Plasmas., vol. 16(3), pp. 033105, magnetized plasma,” Phy Plasmas., vol. 17(3), pp. 032101,
Nov. 2009. Nov. 2010.
[16] M. Amina, S.A. Ema, A.A. Mamun, “Higher order nonlinear [28] X. Nitikant and A. K. Shamra, “Resonant second-harmonic
dust-acoustic waves in a dusty plasma with dust of opposite generation of a short pulse laser in a plasma channel,” J.
polarity,” Chinese Journal of Physics., vol. 55, pp. 619–629, Phys. D., vol. 37, pp. 2395-2398, Nov. 2004.
Nov. 2017.