Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Special Relief Act 1963 PDF
Special Relief Act 1963 PDF
PREFACE
After going through this study material, a learner would surely be able to
acknowledge that linking approach is an adequate method to study the basic
fundamental principals of law along with the analysis of relevant sections.
TANSUKH PALIWAL
CAUTION
All posibile care has been taken to present correct legal position in the e-notes. The
author is not in any way responsible for any loss or damage arising to any person
from any inadvertent error or omission in these e-notes.
2
INDEX
विषय-सूची
S.no Topic Page no.
1. Range 4
2. Types of specific relief & preventive relief 5
3. Specific relief act & indian contract act linking 6
4. Specific relief act- bifurcation 7
5. Who can claim specific performance-sec 15 8
6. Eligible plaintiff & eligible respondent 9
7. Difference between section 5 and 6 9
8. Sec. 12 : part of contract -not specifically enforceable 10
9. Sec. 38 : perpetual injunction 11
10. Sec. 41 : when no injunction 12
11. Difference between temporary injunction & perpetual injunction 12
12. Part performance of contract 13
13. Sec. 20 : substituted performance 14
14. Landmark judgments 15-16
15. Preliminary exam questions 17-30
16. Mains exam questions 31-33
3
Range
4
Recovery
Of possession of
property)
Cancellation Rectification
(instrument ) (instrument )
Rescission
(Contract)
Temporary
Injuction
Perpetual
Damages Preventive Injunction
Relief
Mandatory
Injunction
5
Specific Relief Act & Indian Contract Act Linking
SRA 2
Particulars ICA-1872
Sec. 2(e) Definitions - of other words same as Sec. 2
defined under ICA 187
Sec. 3 (a) Savings —right to relief Relief
Sec. 9 Defences
Sec. 21(4) Compensation Sec. 73
Sec. 23 Liquidation of damages / Sec. 74
No bar to specific relief
Sec. 24 Bar of Suit / Suit u/s 73
After dismissal of suit for specific performance
6
Damages/ Indian
Compensation Contract Act
Breach of
contract
Specific SPECIFIC
Performance RELIEF ACT
(Section 1-4)
Specific Relief
Sec (5-35)
Preventive Relief
Sec (36-44)
7
Who can claim specific
performance-----Sec 15
Learning skill,
solvency, personal
quality of party is
ingredient If the contract
is of marriage
settlement
Contract provides-
interest of party
shall not be
assigned Or compromise of
doubtful rights
between members of
same family
Representative in
interest not
entitled to
performance
8
Eligible Plaintiff Eligible Respondent
(Sec. 15) (Sec. 19)
a. Any Party a. Any Party
b. Representative or Principal b. Person claiming under
any party
c. Beneficiary ykHkkfUor c. Claimant (under title)
Marriage settlements displaced by defendant
Family Compromise
d. Remainder man 'ks"kHkksxh
(Contract by tenant for life)
e. Reversioner in possession
f. Reversioner in reminder*
Section 5 Section 6
1. The claim is based on title The claim is based on possession and no
proof of title is required and even rightful
owner may be precluded from showing his
title to the land
2. The period of limitation is 12 The period of limitation is only 6 months
Years from the date of dispossession
9
Sec. 12 : Part of contract Not Specifically Enforceable
( )
Exceptions :
Defaulter is unable to perform whole f
BUT
the UNPERFORMED PART is :-
12(2) 12(3) 12(4)
Small and Big Not compensable Separate
Compensable (Though &
compensable) Independe
nt
f
X X
If plaintiff pays If plaintiff pays whole
consideration for consideration without
performable part any abatement
10
Sec. 38 : Perpetual Injunction( ) when granted ?
Note :
1. If obligation arises out of Contract Apply C. II, SRA Sec. 38(2)
2. Perpetual Injunction, grant plaintiff property
possession
3. For such purpose if it is necessary to compel performance of certain act
------------------------------------->Mandatory Injunction to be granted (Sec. 39)
Section 42-------Contract -
Part 1 Part 2
Affirmative Agreement ( ) Negative Agreement ( )
Court can deny for preventive relief Court can grant preventive relief for
[R/w Sec. 41(e) ] Part-2
11
Sec. 41 : NO INJUNCTION , due to :
3. Nature of Contract ( )
(e) (h)
Not specifically Alternative equally efficacious relief is
enforceable available (except : breach of trust)
4. Malafide Intention ( - )
(f) (ha) : Sec. 20A [R/w 20B /20C ]
Act , not reasonably clear to be Impede / Delay infrastructure
nuisance project
12
Part performance of contract
The General rule is that the court shall not direct specific performance of part of the contract
except in following case-
Where the defaulting The court may direct the And require the other party to – pay
party does not admit party in default to the consideration for the whole of the
to compensation in perform specifically so contract without any abatement
money much of his part of the • relinquishes all claims to the
contract as he can performance of the remaining part of
perform the contract
• Relinquish all right to compensation,
either for the deficiency or for the loss
or damage sustained by him through
the default
Part which cannot be performed is separate and independent from the other part (contract is
divisible) the court can direct performance of the part which can be performed.
13
Section : 20
14
Landmark Cases
I.T.0 - 6
:-
( ) ;
( )
Satish Kumar v. Karan Supreme Court held that the jurisdiction to order specific
Singh, (2016) 4 SCC 352 performance of contract is based on existence of a valid
and enforceable contract. If a valid and enforceable
contract has not been made, the court cannot order
specific performance of contract.
औ
औ ,
Jaswinder Kaur v. Gurmeet Supreme Court held that relief of part performance
Singh, (2017) 12 SCC8 10 cannot be granted where the inability to perform arises
because of plaintiff's own conduct.
15
Joseph john Peter Sandy v. Supreme Court held that rectification under Section 26 is
Veronica Thomas Rajkumar, possible only by the parties to the instrument and no
(2013) 3 SCC 801 one else. This section is applicable only when it is pleaded
and proved that through fraud or mutual mistake of the
parties, the real intention of the parties is not
expressed.
26
औ
औ
,
Kandala Port v. Hargovind Supreme Court held that grant of declaratory decree is
Hasraj, (2013) 3 SCC 182 discretionary in nature. Court may in appropriate cases
refuse to grant declaratory decree.
, 1963 38
,
,
Jagdish Prasad Patel v. In a suit for declaration of title and possession, the plaintiff
Shivnath, (2019) 6 SCC could succeed only on the strength of their own title and
82 not on the weakness of the case of defendant. The burden
is on the plaintiff to establish their title to the suit
properties.
क़औ ,
क़ ,
16
RJS Preliminary Exam Questions
17
property w/o his consent or w/o Specific Relief means the relief
due course of law , after expiry of which an aggrieved party is
6 months from date of entitled. According to section 4
dispossession. Such suit cannot be Specific relief Act can be granted
brought against govt. Also, no for enforcing only individual civil
appeal or review from such order rights and not for enforcing penal
or decree shall be allowed. Law. Because Its main objective is
- 6 , to focus on the rights and if there
is any penal nature of the case, it
, may have to be established for
6 , proving the same and the remedy
ए can be claimed under penal law.
। -
। , ए । 4
ग। ग
ए ग
3. Specific relief under the Specific ए।
Relief Act, 1963 can be granted औ
for enforcing ,
, 1963 ए
औ
: ।
(A) Only individual civil rights./
4. Under section 11 of the Specific
(B) Individual and public civil Relief Act, 1963 a contract made
rights/ by a trustee in excess of his
(C) Only public civil rights/ powers or in the breach of a
trust is :
(D) All of the above./ ।
[a]
Explanation:-
18
, 1963 ,
11 ग
19
6. Rectification of an instrument ।
under the Specific Relief Act is
allowed when Fraud or Mutual ।
Mistake of the parties to a
contract is allowed under 7. Mistake contemplated under
, 1963 Section 26 of the Specific Relief
Act is :
........ , 1963
26 :
(A) Section 26(1)./ 26(1) (A) Bilateral mistake./ ।
(B) Section 27./ 27 (B) Mutual mistake./ ।
(C) Section 22./ 22 (C) Mistake in framing of the
(D) None of these./ instrument./ ।
। (D) All the above./ ।
[a] [d]
Explanation:-As per sec 26, if Explanation:-Instrument may
parties, through fraud or mutual have mistakes of any kind. The
mistake in a contract do not mistakes can be bilateral or
express there real intention, then mutual. Mistakes can also be made
either party or their repr, or in framing of instrument. In such a
plaintiff or defendant may institute case, then either party or their
suit to rectify the instrument, and repr, or plaintiff or defendant may
the court may direct for institute suit to rectify the
rectification of instrument , only instrument.
then the contract may be - ट
specifically enforced. ।
- 26 , । ,
ट ,
, ए ।
ए
ग ग,औ
20
8. The question of title is irrelevant (a) Section 38 of the Specific Relief
in a suit under Section 6 of the Act, 1963 / ,
Specific Relief Act, 1963. 1963 38
This statement is : (b) Section 39 of the Specific Relief
, 1963 Act, 1963/ ,
6 1963 39
: (c) Section 40 of the Specific Relief
(A) True. । Act, 1963 / ,
(B) False. । 1963 40
(C) Partly True. । (d) Section 41 of the Specific Relief
(D) None of the above. Act, 1963/ ,
। 1963 41
[a] [b]
Explanation:-As per sec 6, a Explanation:-As per sec 39, to
person dispossessed of immovable prevent the breach of obligation,
property w/o his consent shall not court may grant injunction & also
be bared from suing to establish compel performance of requisite
his title of property & to recover acts. In addition or in substitution
possession. of injunction, court may also
- 6 , award damages u/s 40( only if
plaintiff have claimed for it). Court
can even refuse to grant injunction
ए, on the grounds mentioned u/s 41.
औ ए - 39 ,
। ए,
औ ए
9. Grant of a mandatory injunction ।
is regulated by- , 40
ए
- ( ग ए )।
41
।
21
10. If the suit for specific 11. Which section of the specific
performance is dismissed then: relief act deals about 'contracts
not specifically enforceable'?
: , 1963
(A) Plaintiff can institute new suit
for compensation./ ए
। ?
(B) Plaintiff cannot file suit for (A) Section 9./ 9
recovery of possession./ (B) Section 14./ 14
ए (C) Section 11./ 11
। (D)Section 16./ 16
(C) Cannot file new suit for specific [b]
performance./ ए Explanation:-As per Sec 14, the
। contract cannot be specifically
(D) All are incorrect./ enforceable ,which are-
। 1. Non-performance of contract
[d] then compensation in money is an
Explanation:-As per sec 24 if suit adequate relief
for specific performance is 2. Nature determinable contract
dismissed then plaintiff shall not 3. Which is so dependent on the
have right to sue for personal qualification.
compensation, but he has right to 4. Performance of continuous
sue for any other relief which he is duty which the court can’t
entitled to. supervise.
- 24 - 14 ,
ए ग
ए , -
ग,
1.
ए ।
2. ,
22
in substitution for injunction. At
3. , ग the same time court may also
refuse to grant the injunction u/s
41.
4. ,
- 39 ,
ए
।
12. To obtain a mandatory
ए ।
injunction under section 39 of
40 ,
the Specific Relief Act, the
।
plaintiff must show that there
41
has been a breach of obligation
।
in the nature of :
, 1963
13. Which type of the following
39
injunction a Court cannot issue?
?
(A) Mulberry injunction./
(A) Legal obligation./
।
(B) It is necessary to maintain
(B) Perpetual injunction./
status quo./ ।
।
(C) None of these./
(C) Temporary injunction.
।
।
(D) Both (A) and (B)./( ) ( ) ।
(D) Mandatory injunction.
(a)
।
Explanation:-As per sec 39, the
[a]
breach of legal obligation is
Explanation:-As per section 36
essential for grant of mandatory
preventive relief is granted at the
injunction. Here court may also
discretion of the Court(i.e.
compel performance of the
temporary or perpetual injunction)
requisite acts. u/s 40, court may
award compensation in addition or
23
while sect 39 provides for due course of law , before expiry of
mandatory injunction. 6 months from date of
- 36 dispossession. Such suit cannot be
( brought against govt. Also, no
) appeal or review from such order
39 or decree shall be allowed.
। - 6 ,
24
is left outstanding./ 2. ग ,
ग
ग ग 3. ,
। ग
(C) That in view of the
circumstances the court considers , 1908
it as reasonable and necessary to ग
cancel the document./
,औ
ट ग ।
ए।
(D) All of the above./ । 16. The provisions regarding
[d] ‘specific performance of part of
Explanation:-As per sec 31 contract are contained under the
,following instruments may be Specific Relief Act in-
cancelled-
1. if it is Void or Voidable
2. Such instruments if left ..
outstanding may cause serious (A) Section 11./ 11
injury (B) Section 12/ 12
3. Court considers it as reasonable (C) Section 13./ 13
and necessary to cancel. (D) Section 14./ 14
If the instrument is registered [b]
under Registration Act, then court Explanation:-As per sec 12, part
will send thee copy of decree to of contract is not enforceable. But
officer in whose office such may direct specific performance of
instrument was registered. Officer part of contract if unperformed
will note the fact of cancellation of part is Small and Compensable,
instrument in his books. Big(Though compensable), Not
- 31 , compensable, Separate &
- Independent. The plaintiff has to
1.
25
relinquishes all claims to the
performance of remaining part. , 1963
- 12 , ?
ग , । (a) Section 34/ 34
ग (b) Section 35/ 35
ग ट (c) Section 36/ 36
, , (d) Section 37/ 37
, । [b]
ग ग ग Explanation:-
Effect of declaration is given under
sec 35 , which provides that a
17. When did Specific Relief Act
declaration made under Chapter VI
came into force.
is binding only on the parties to
the suit, persons claiming through
?
(a) 01/03/1964 them and where parties are
(b) 10/04/1964 trustees, on the persons for whom,
if in existence at the date of the
(c) 15/08/1964
declaration such parties would be
(d) 01/10/1964
trustees.
[a]
Explanation:- The specific relief - 35
ग , - VI
act 1963 came into force on 1st
ग ,
March, 1964. It received
president’s assent on 13th
औ
December 1963.
- 1963
1 , 1964 ग । 13 ए
1963 ।
।
18. Effect of declaration is made
under which section of Specific
Relief Act, 1963?
26
19. Under Section 31 of the Specific 1.
Relief Act, relief may be sought 2. ग ,
for the cancellation of an ग
instrument- 3. ,
31 ग
,
- 20. The specific Relief Act, 1963
(a) By any party to the extends to the
instrument/ , 1963
(b) By any person against whom ?
the instrument is void or (a) Whole of India/सम्पूर्ण भारत
voidable/ (b) Whole of India, except the State
of Jammu and Kashmir/जम्मू-कश्मीर
(c) By any person or party who has राज्य के ससवाय सम्पूर्ण भारत
reasonable apprehension that such (c) Whole of India, except the
instrument may cause him serious States of Assam and
injury / Nagaland/ ग
ग
(d) Whole of India, except the State
(d) All of the above/ । of Jammu and Kashmir, Assam and
[d] Nagaland/जम्मू-कश्मीर, आसाम व
Explanation:- As per sec 31 नागालैण्ड राज्यों के ससवाय सम्पूर्ण भारत।
,following instruments may be [a]
cancelled- Explanation:-The specific Relief
1. if it is Void or Voidable Act, 1963 extends to the Whole of
2. Such instruments if left India. Earlier it extends to Whole of
outstanding may cause serious India, except the State of Jammu
injury and Kashmir but after making
3. Court considers it as reasonable amendment in 2018 it extends to
and necessary to cancel. the whole of India and the word
- 31 , “except the State of Jammu and
- Kashmir” is omitted.
27
- , 1963 । R/w O 20 R 10, O
ग । औ 21 R 31.
ग ,
2018 22. Remedy of rectification of
ग ग औ " औ instruments enshrined under
" ट ग । Section 26 of the specific Relief
Act relates to-
21. Section 7 of the Specific Relief 26
Act deals with recovery of the
specific- ?
7 (a) Mistake or error in the
formation of the contract
(Recovery) ? itself/
(a) Immovable property/ ट
(b) Movable property/ ग (b) Mistake or error in writing the
(c) Cooperative property/ instrument / ग
ट
(d) Cash, currency-notes and (c) Add or substract the terms and
coins/ ग , - ट । conditions of the contract/
[b] औ ट
Explanation:- (d) Such subject-matter which did
As per sec 7, A person who is not attract the attention of the
entitled to the possession of parties/ -
specific movable property may ।
recover it in the manner provided [b]
under CPC. R/w O 20 R 10, O 21 R Explanation:-As per sec 26, if
31. parties, through fraud or mutual
- 7 , ए mistake in a contract do not
ग , express there real intention, then
CPC ए गए either party or their repr, or
plaintiff or defendant may
28
institute suit to rectify the (c) A person who is owner of the
instrument, and the court may property/
direct for rectification of
instrument , only then the (d) A person who has possession or
contract may be specifically control on the property who has
enforced. possession or control on the
- 26 , property, of which he is not the
ट owner/
, ए ।
[d]
ए Explanation:-As per sec 8, in
ग ग,औ following cases, a person who is
। not the owner of movable
property, is entitled to immediate
। possession-
a. if thing claimed is with defendant
23. Under section 8 of the Specific as a agent or trustee of plaintiff
Relief Act, against whom relief b. compensation would not be
may be sought by a person adequate relief for loss
entitled to immediate c. difficult to ascertain the actual
possession? damage
d. thing wrongfully transferred from
(immediate)
plaintiff.
- 8 ,
, ए ग
?
, -
(a) A person who has possession
a.
on the property /
b. ,
(b) A person who has control on
the property/
c.
29
d.
ग ।
30
SRA MAINS Exam Questions
1. विशिष्ट प्रदिशन के संबंध में न्यायालय के स्िवििेक और िशियां क्या हैं और 2018 के संिोधन से क्या
बदलाि आए हैं?
What are discretion (s) and powers of the Court regarding Specific Performance
and what changes are introduced by amendment of 2018? [M.P.CJ 2019]
2. विशिष्ट अनुतोष अधधवनयम, 1963 की धारा 6 के अन्तर्शत एक अचल संपशि के कब्जे के शलए िाद सरकार
के विरूद नहीं लाय जा सकता है। चचाश करें
A suit under section 6 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963 against dispossession from
an immovable property cannot be brought against the Government. Discuss.
[GJS 2020]
3. उस व्यशि के पास क्या उपाय हैं जजसने उस व्यशि से अचल संपशि खरीदी है जजसके पास कोई कब्जा या
अपूर्श हक नहीं है?
What are the remedies to a person who purchased immovable property from a
person who has no title or imperfect title?[M.P. CJ 2017]
4. क्या विशिष्ट अनुतोष अधधवनयम, 1963 की धारा 6 के तहत िाद दायर वकया जाता है और न्यायालय द्वारा
उसकी बखाशस्तर्ी िादी को अपना िाद स्थावपत करने और बाद में कब्जा िापस लेने के शलए िाद दायर करने
से रोकती है? चचाश करें।
Does institution of a suit under section 6 of Specific Relief Act, 1963 and its
dismissal by a Court of law bars the plaintiff from filing a suit to establish his
title and to recover the possession later on? Discuss. [PJS 2015]
5. विशिष्ट अनुतोष अधधवनयम की धारा 5 और 6 के तहत कब्जे के शलए कायों के बीच अंतर के मुख्य बबिंदु क्या
हैं?
What are the main points of difference between actions for possession under
Section 5 and 6 of the Specific Relief Act? [BJS 1984, HJS 1996, 1999]
6. विशिष्ट अनुतोष अधधवनयम, 1963 के तहत एक विशिष्ट चल और अचल संपशि के कब्जे की िसूली से
संबंधधत प्रािधानों की व्याख्या करें।
Explain the provisions relating to recovery of possession of a specific movable
and immovable property under the Specific Relief Act, 1963. [RJS 2014]
31
8. धारा 6 के तहत मुकदमे में सफल होने के शलए िादी को क्या स्थावपत करना है? क्या असफ़ल िादी िाद में
अपने हक के आधार पर घोषर्ा और कब्जे के शलए िाद ला सकता है?
What a plaintiff has to establish to succeed in a suit under Section 6? Whether
the defeated plaintiff later on can file Quit for declaration and possession on the
basis of his title? [M.P. CJ 2013]
9. अनुबंध के वहस्से के विशिष्ट प्रदिशन के बारे में कानून की स्स्थवत क्या है?
What is the position of law regarding specific performance of part of contract?
[M.P. CJ 2018]
10. विशिष्ट पालन का दािा कौन कर सकता है और विशिष्ट पालन कब मना वकया जा सकता है?
Who can claim specific performance and when can specific performance be
refused? [BJS 1980)
12. उन ितों पर चचाश करें जब न्यायालय उपकरर्ों को रद्द करने के रूप में उपाय दे सकती है। उपकरर्ों को रद्द
करने और सुधारने के बीच का अंतर आकर्षिंत करें।
Discuss the conditions when the court may grant the remedy in the form of
cancellation of instruments. Draw the distinction between cancellation and
rectification of instruments. [HJS 2019]
13. अधधवनयम के तहत कब्जे, वििाजन, धन िापसी, आदद के शलए राहत प्रदान करने के शलए कुछ मामलों में
प्रवतकर दे ने के शलए न्यायालय की िशि की व्याख्या करें?
Explain the power of the Court to award compensation in certain cases and
Power to grant relief for possession, partition, refund, refund of earnest money,
etc. under the act? [M.P. CJ 2016]
14. अचल संपशि की वबक्री या पट्टे के शलए अनुबंधों को बचाने के प्रािधानों के बारे में बताएं, जहां अनुबंध के
विशिष्ट पालन को पहले ही शलया र्या है।
Explain the provisions regarding rescission of contracts for the sale or lease of
immovable property, where the specific performance of the contract has been
already decreed.[M.P. CJ 2016]
32
15. विशिष्ट अनुतोष अधधवनयम, 1963 के तहत घोषर्ापत्र की व्याख्या करें। सामान्य शसद्ांत बताएं, जजस पर
न्यायालय इस तरह के धिक्री को लार्ू करता है और ऐसे धिक्री के प्रिाि की व्याख्या करता है।
Explain declaratory decree under Specific Relief Act, 1963. State the general
Principles on which the Court grants such decree and explain effect of such
decree. [HPJS 2019]
17. सामान्य शसद्ांतों को बताते हुए जजसके आधार पर अस्थायी वनषेधाज्ञा दी जाती है, उन पररस्स्थवतयों पर चचाश
करते हैं जजनमें न्यायालय द्वारा स्थायी वनषेधाज्ञा दी जाती है।
Stating the general principles on the basis of which temporary injunctions are
granted, discuss the circumstances in which perpetual injunctions are granted
by the court. [U.P. CJ 2018]
18. वनिारक क्या है? विशिष्ट राहत अधधवनयम, 1963 में ददए र्ए वनिारक राहत से संबंधधत प्रािधानों का िर्शन
करें।
What is Preventive relies? Describe the provisions relating to Preventive relief
as provided in the Specific Relief Act, 1963. [JJS 2017]
19. अस्थायी वनषेधाज्ञा, स्थायी वनषेधाज्ञा और अवनिायश वनषेधाज्ञा के बीच अंतर। वकन पररस्स्थवतयों में वनषेधाज्ञा
से इनकार वकया जा सकता है?
Distinguish between temporary injunction, perpetual injunction and mandatory
injunction. Under what circumstances can an injunction be refused [BJS 1987]
20. क्या एक िाद में एक इंटरलोक्यूटरी एप्ललकेिन पर एक अवनिायश वनषेधाज्ञा दी जा सकती है?
Can a mandatory injunction be granted on an interlocutory application in a suit?
[HJS 2006]
21. वनिारक अनुतोष से आप क्या समझते हैं? यह अनुतोष दे ने िाली िस्तु क्या है? विशिष्ट प्रदिशन और वनिारक
राहत के बीच अंतर?
What do you understand by the preventive relief? What is the object of granting
this relief? Distinguish between specific performance and preventive relief?
[M.P. CJ 2019
33
34