Ghorbani 2021

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 8

Received: 24 May 2021 | Revised: 1 August 2021 | Accepted: 16 August 2021

DOI: 10.1111/nuf.12644

RESEARCH MANUSCRIPT

Explaining nurses' experience of stresses and coping


mechanisms in coronavirus pandemic

Azam Ghorbani PhD1 | Mahboobeh Shali PhD2 | Pegah Matourypour PhD1 |


3 4
Ehsan Salehi Morkani BS | Mohammad Salehpoor Emran MS |
Alireza Nikbakht Nasrabadi PhD1

1
Department of Medical Surgical Nursing,
School of Nursing and Midwifery, Tehran Abstract
University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran
Introduction: Nurses face several stresses during a pandemic. Therefore, it seems
2
Department of Critical Care Nursing and
Nursing Management, School of Nursing and
necessary to use appropriate adaptation and coping methods to reduce the de-
Midwifery, Tehran University of Medical structive effects of physical and psychological stresses. This study aimed to explain
Sciences, Tehran, Iran
nurses' experience of stresses and coping methods used for care of patients with
3
Isabn‐e‐Maryam Hospital, Isfahan University
of Medical Sciences, Isfahan, Iran Covid‐19.
4
Department of Community Health Nursing, Method: A qualitative approach with descriptive phenomenological method was
School of Nursing and Midwifery, Tehran applied in this study. Sixteen nurses working in hospitals were selected by purposeful
University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran
sampling. Through in‐depth, individual and semi‐structured interviews, the nurses
Correspondence shared their experiences in caring for Covid patients. The transcripts of recorded
Alireza Nikbakht Nasrabadi, PhD, School of
interviews were typed verbatim and then analyzed based on Colaizzi's method.
Nursing and Midwifery, Tehran University of
Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran, Tehran Results: Four main categories and 12 subcategories, which were named conceptually
University of Medical Sciences, Tohid Sq,
based on their nature were shaped. The main categories included; self‐support in the
1419733171 Tehran, Iran.
Email: Nikbakht@tums.ac.ir midst of crisis, sheltered by family from distance, hospital influence in the
environment, and social support on both sides of infinity.
Funding information
Tehran University of Medical Sciences and Conclusion: Although healthcare workers have accepted the exposure to Covid‐19
Health Services : 99210048398 as part of their profession, provision of quality care in crisis situations is not possible
without supporting the healthcare workers and paying attention to their mental
health. It is recommended to take a precise approach to predict, recognize and
manage psychological harms of healthcare workers.

KEYWORDS
adaptation, Covid‐19, nurse, phenomenology, stress

1 | INTRODUCTION and sleep disorder, as well as other physical and mental problems like
occupational stress.
The coronavirus has now become a major global health problem, Occupational stress imposes high costs on employees and or-
which affects all nations, all continents, and all races.1 Healthcare ganizations, and is associated with poor organizational efficiency,
workers bear the main burden of pandemics, and unfortunately many increased resignation, occurrence of various physical and mental
of them become infected and die from the disease, and this increases disorders, frequent sick leave, increased work accident, poor staff
their psychological stress.2 Studies have shown that nurses who deal performance, and reduced job satisfaction.8,9 If the occupational
3 4,5 6 7
with emerging diseases such as SARS, MERS, Ebola, H1N1 stress is not identified in nurses and no measure is taken to prevent it,
suffer from problems like loneliness, isolation, anxiety, fear, fatigue, it will have irreparable consequences. These tensions and stresses

Nursing Forum. 2021;1–8. wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/nuf © 2021 Wiley Periodicals LLC | 1


2 | GHORBANI ET AL.

affect the relationship between clients and the nurses and sometimes and presumptions, key questions were asked during the interview.
increase treatment costs and, most importantly, cause job burnout in The interview questions included: “What does come to your mind
nurses. 10
Therefore, in the process of pandemics, multidimensional when you hear the word stress in a pandemic”? “What does stress in
social support, cognitive evaluation, provision of guidance for posi- caring for a patient with Covid‐19 mean to you”? “Do you remember
tive coping strategies and stimulation of positive emotions, and the cases of your stress while caring for covid patients”? “When you
adaptation to new conditions caused by pandemics are important were experiencing stress, what mechanisms did you used to cope
measures that can be taken to promote the nurses' mental health.2 with the stress”? “What factors do you think have influenced or could
Adaptation, in the general sense, refers to all strategies for have influenced the situations you have experienced”?
managing stressful life situations, both real and unreal threats, in Exploratory questions such as “Can you explain more?” and
which a person uses his power and support of others11 to strengthen “What do you mean?” were also used during the interviews. The
his physical and mental health.12 Therefore, getting acquainted with duration of each interview was between 45 and 70 min and the first
methods of coping with and overcoming stress can help promote researcher personally conducted all the interviews to increase the
mental health and increase the effectiveness and productivity of data integrity.
human resources. Colaizzi's seven‐stage method was used to analyze the data. At
Given the fact that nurses' experiences and perceptions are the first stage, each interview was recorded, transcribed verbatim,
formed as a result of constant exposure to real‐world situations, and reviewed several times to get a sense of the whole. At the
understanding their feelings and experiences in regard to job stress second stage, important sentences were extracted by underlining
and their methods of adaptation to these stresses, particularly during method. At the third stage, the initial codes were extracted. At the
the Covid‐19 pandemic, is very important and necessary. In fact, by fourth and fifth stages, the developed concepts were divided into
studying these experiences and elucidating their obvious and hidden sub‐concepts and the results were turned into main themes, re-
aspects, it is possible to analyze them. To reach such an under- spectively. At the sixth and seventh stages, a comprehensive and
standing, specific research methods, such as qualitative approach, are unambiguous description of the phenomenon was developed, and
needed in nursing that allow for a comprehensive review and analysis then validated by presenting some of the results and extracted
of personal experiences. Also, since in this study, the research team concepts to the participants (member check) to be confirmed by them
had experience working with covid patients and had dealt with these and in a case of ambiguity, some corrections were made.14 In quali-
tensions closely and tangibly, the topic of this study was the subject tative studies, the process of data validation is obtained by providing
of interest for them. Therefore, this qualitative study was conducted the participants with some of the extracted codes and classes for
to explain the stresses and coping mechanisms used by nurses in conformation.14 The coding was done simultaneously and in-
caring for covid patients using their lived experience and work culture dependently by first and second authors, and 90% agreement was
in the current situation, as they work at the front line of fight against reached between them. Finally, the codes, categories and themes
Covid‐19 pandemic. obtained by the research team were discussed in group discussion
and finalized. Data were analyzed by MAXQDA software version 10.
Considerations of rigour and trustworthiness were addressed
2 | M E TH O D by adopting Guba and Lincoln's (1985) guidelines.15 Credibility was
established using member and peer‐checking, reviewers' pro-
According to the main research question, which is related to the longed engagement with data, and maximum variance in partici-
nurses' lived experience of stresses and coping mechanisms, philo- pant selection. Regarding member‐checking, part of the interviews
sophy and phenomenological method were used as an appropriate and codes were also presented back to the participants for review
13
and selective approach for this study. This study was conducted to ensure that the data reflects the real experiences and percep-
during December to March 2020. The research environment con- tions of the participants. For peer‐checking, the interrater agree-
sisted of teaching hospitals affiliated to University, and the place of ment between reviewers was calculated and approved. We
interview was determined in coordination with the participants. In considered transferability through providing a rich description of
this study, purposeful sampling method was used to select the eli- data collection, analysis processes, and findings. This method en-
gible participants. Accordingly, speaking Persian, having a bachelor's hances the applicability and generalizability of results in other si-
degree in nursing, having no hearing or speech problem, having ex- milar contexts.
perience of caring for patients with coronavirus, and willingness to Ethical principles observed by the researchers in this study in-
share personal experiences voluntarily and consciously were among cluded; obtaining an approval from the Institutional Review Board of
the criteria for entering the study. Tehran University of Medical Sciences (coded: IR.TUMS.MEDICI-
In qualitative research, the number of participants in the study is NE.REC.1399.629), obtaining informed consent from the participants
not predetermined and sampling continues until reaching data sa- before entering the study, giving participants the right to withdraw
turation, which was obtained in the present study after 14 interviews from the study at any time, maintaining anonymity and confidentiality
with nurses. In this study, semi‐structured and in‐depth interviews of information, and providing results to the participants at their
were used to collect information. To eliminate the researcher's bias request.
GHORBANI ET AL. | 3

3 | F I ND I NG S 3.2 | Prioritizing physiological needs

Sixteen nurses Participated in this study Nine participants were One of the common experiences of all nurses in caring for covid
female and seven were male with a mean age of 42 ± 3.1 years patients was negligence to address physiological needs.
and work experience of 18 ± 6.3 years. After data analysis, 301 “We could not eat easily. At that time, for example, we re-
primary codes were extracted. The main theme of this study was luctantly ate a fruit juice. For a simple sleep, we did not dare to lie on
the evolving support circle, and information were classified in our bed because we were scared of being infected with the virus. But
four main categories of self‐support in the midst of crisis, we had to eat and rest so we could continue.” (P4).
sheltered by family from distance, hospital influence in the As time went on and the importance of strengthening the im-
environment, and social support on both sides of infinity. mune system against covid‐19 became clear, nurses adopted stra-
The main categories consisted of 12 subclasses, which are tegies to improve their physical condition during and after the shift
described below (Table 1). at home.
“I remember at the first few days the children were not eating
anything from morning to noon due to the fear! But little by little they
3.1 | Self‐support in the midst of crisis get used to it. They began to bring fruit juices or snacks. It is very
difficult to breathe under these masks, and it makes the throat very
Various factors create stress during an outbreak of a disease, which dry, so we have to use more liquids. Of course, the conditions are
can endanger the physical and mental health of nurses. Ignoring difficult and we wash and disinfect our hands a lot.” (P5).
physiological needs, ambiguity caused by an unknown disease, and
lack of information about the new disease were the sources of stress.
In this study, self‐support was one of the most important methods of 3.3 | Creating a positive image of a vague future
coping with stress caused by Covid‐19 pandemic. Study participants
used a variety of coping methods such as prioritizing physiological Being at the forefront of fight against a new virus that is highly
needs, creating a positive perception of a vague future, adapting to transmissible and carries the risk of death, and also for which there is
stress over time, increasing information in response to the crisis, and no specific treatment, had created a confusing situation for nurses.
relying on divine help. “We did not know what was going to happen. We came to work and
saw they have provided some special clothing for us, which we had to
wear when taking care of patients infected with Covid‐19 dis-

T A B L E 1 Extracted main theme, categories and subcategories of ease.” (P2).


data analysis In the current situation, nurses tried to self‐regulate, think po-
sitively and provide a clear vision of the future to deal with the crisis.
Theme Main categories Subcategories
“We were afraid of where the world is going towards, but we
The evolving Self‐support in the Prioritizing physiological needs
could do nothing, so we tried to cheer each other up with positive
support circle midst of crisis
Creating positive image of a ideas and predictions.” (P4).
vague future

Adapting to stress over time

increasing information in 3.4 | Adapting to stress over time


response to the crisis

Relying on and believing in According to the participants' experiences, people's reaction to


divine help Covid‐19 has changed over time and people's sensitivity and fear of

Sheltered by family Parental support the disease has decreased.


from distance “Nothing special happened. Over time, the fear became much
Spouses: hesitant companions
less. The staff got to know the disease more and their stress level
Distanced loved ones decreased.” (P6).
Hospital influence Stressful hospital atmosphere
in the
Hospital support
environment
3.5 | Increasing information in response to the
Social support on Cyberspace: Is it poisoning the crisis
both sides of mind or increasing
infinity awareness?
One of the factors that cause stress and tension in dealing with a
People; from appreciation to
pandemic is the lack of accurate information about the disease. This
negligence
information requirement, especially at the beginning of a pandemic,
4 | GHORBANI ET AL.

forces the treatment team to obtain up‐to‐date information they “I wanted to resign because of my parents' health and stay at
need from scientific sources to care for patients. home and take care of them, but my father said you are a soldier
“Every day a lot of articles are published describing more com- and now your country is at war with the disease and needs
plicated things about the virus. Well, I read these articles every day. you.” (P4).
Almost every day, I am following the information provided by every
article in the WHO's website.” (P1).
3.9 | Spouse; a hesitant companion

3.6 | Relying on divine help According to the participants' experiences, the behavior of spouses
due to the fear, ignorance, and anxiety about the disease and the
Although increasing information, emphasis on physiological needs, spread of infection to the family was one of the factors that caused
and creating positive thinking have been identified as personal stra- stress in nurses.
tegies for coping with pandemic stress, participants had a special “When my husband heard that, the hospital I work in has become
place for spirituality in dealing with the pandemic. Reliance on God a referral center for Covid‐19, he completely separated himself from
and spirituality was one the strategies used by nurses in this study for us. He was in a complete stress.” (P13).
coping with stress. Even the spouses of some staff objected their work. This dis-
“I will observe the protocols as much as I can and leave the rest satisfaction doubled the stress for nurses.
to God.” (P14). “We had many cases among our colleagues, whose families,
“Patience and relying on God were the only factors that at least especially their husbands, called and objected. One or two persons
kept me going during that time and helped me to endure the situa- did not allow their spouses to come to work!” (P2).
tion.” (P1). Given the important role of the spouses, their support and
companionship was an important factor in encouraging and
strengthening the morale of nurses.
3.7 | Sheltered by family from distance “I used to come home and try to get some rest. My husband was
not doing house work before, and I had to do it by myself. But now,
In all participants in this study, the stress caused by the possibility of he will do all the works. I mean, he helps me a lot and let me rest. I am
family members becoming infected with Covid‐19 was much more comfortable at home, and he looks after me.” (P4).
pronounced than they themselves. Fear of injury to family members, “My spouse is trying to take care of me. For example, we do not
parents, spouses, or children, and sense of remorse that comes from eat anything for several hours in the shift and we come home we are
transferring the disease from hospital to family were the greatest hungry and thirsty. When I go home, I go to the bathroom and wash
stress experienced by the participants. In contrast, encouragement and disinfect my clothes for an hour, and when I come out I see my
and family support has had a positive effect on nurses' adaptation to husband has made carrot juice or tea for me. Well, that is something
stress. The family has been introduced as a strong and reliable in- that encourages you.” (P5).
stitution in helping nurses adapt to the job stress.

3.10 | Distanced loved ones


3.8 | Parental support
Fear and stress caused by possibility of transmitting the infection to
One of the causes of stress during the pandemic was the possibility children has caused the nurses to separate themselves from their
of being a carrier and the fear of infecting family members. Most children. In many cases, nurses had left their children with their
nurses distanced themselves from their families to protect them and parents or friends, and they themselves had been living in con-
minimized contact with them. On the contrary, this distance had valescent homes and hospitals while providing care for covid pa-
created tension and nostalgia in the nurses. tients. All these efforts had been made by them to reduce their
“The nurses were more concerned about their family than concerns about their children.
themselves and one of their requests was a place where they could “I have not seen my children for about a month. I left them at my
stay and do not go home! Some of them really did not go home for mother's house and I cannot go to see them at all. I think its better
two or three months. All they had was phone and video call. In short, that way.” (P3).
they were all mentally disturbed.” (P2). “Well, I was considering the family situation, that we have two
However, the support and encouragement of parents have been small children. If I get infected, what can I do to keep my kids away
the real incentive for healthcare workers in coping with existing from infection? That was when I sent my wife and children to her
stresses and providing the best possible care to patients with father's home and I stayed alone at home! That way I was more
Covid‐19. comfortable.” (P7).
GHORBANI ET AL. | 5

3.11 | Hospital influence on the environment “Anyway, the situation was critical and many colleagues had lost
themselves. They were scared, but the hospital management warned
Since hospitals are the main center for providing care during a pan- to punish those leave the work or do not turn up for work, instead of
demic, hospital staffs, especially nurses are most exposed to the trying to calm the staff down!” (P13).
stress of a pandemic, especially if the disease is unknown. On the one Resignation and leaving the service due to pandemic stress is one
hand, the hospital environment can cause stressors such as poor of the repeated behaviors in health care workers. These people cause
performance of managers, lack of equipment and facilities, and lack stress and anxiety and discourage other nurses due to the high stress
of experienced staff that leads to increased stress and tension in and tension they experience.
staff. On the other hand, by providing support programs and services “Some of them were highly stressed! They were very scared! This
such as adequate and quality equipment, proper management and fear and stress was passed on to us. In every shift they came, they
planning, we can reduce stress and increase the adaptation of nurses said that we wanted to give up.” (P14).
and hospital staff to the stress caused by the disease.

3.13 | Hospital support


3.12 | Stressful hospital atmosphere
Planning and implementing support measures by hospital managers
The care environment for the participants was a circle that included play a key role in reducing stress and tension in the hospital en-
managers, equipment, colleagues, patients and patients' families. vironment and promoting adaptation and relaxation of staff. Sup-
Each of these has a potential to be a source of tension during a portive measures such as providing a convalescent home, providing
pandemic. adequate and quality equipment, and managing, organizing and
In the experience of nurses, lack of personal protective equip- planning properly, as well as creating a healthy and happy atmo-
ment (PPE), poor quality of personal equipment, lack of proper gui- sphere for consulting and care provision are among them.
dance on how to use the equipment, and the existence of In hospitals that provide care for patients with Covid‐19, one of
discrimination in the distribution of PPE were among factors that the measures taken by the management is the creation of con-
caused stress for nurses. valescent home for staff. Recovery during off‐shift time is one of the
“They had made announcement that certain wards do not need ways to adapt to stress caused by covid pandemic.
to use full PPEs, or for instance, maintenance workers do not need to “I was afraid I would get sick myself. But after the introduction of
use N95 face mask. This is while the maintenance workers sometimes convalescent homes I was happy that I at least have somewhere to go.
have to work in ICU or covid wards to repair something. These things Some families have a negative view of us. For example, if someone in
caused some of the personnel to get infected.” (P7). the family became infected, we are the ones to blame.” (P15).
The medical environment always bears the challenge of man- Using personal equipment is one of the ways to protect against
power shortages. During a pandemic, due to the illnesses and resig- Covid‐19. Proper equipment was an important factor in reducing
nation of a large number of employees, the medical systems face a stress and adapting to pandemic situation in nurses.
greater challenge than before. This has leads to increased workload “Well, there were still some stressful situations, but when we
and doubles the stress in employees. wanted to take blood sample from the patient or inject a medicine,
“Eight patients, two of whom were intubated and required many we had no stress, because we had proper PPE.” (P4).
medications, needed at least three staffs that didn't had. The number The hospital managers are like the ships' captains, and at times of
of staff is very low.” (P3). turmoil and storm, all medical staff expect courageous support and
To make up for the shortage of staff in the wards, many nurses planning from managers. Timely presence of managers and supervisors
from other wards and hospitals volunteered to work with centers on the wards and departments, meeting the needs of employees and
that were caring for covid patients. Although this was a very good providing all requirements for the delivery of quality care in a safe
supportive measure, the unfamiliarity of volunteers with the condi- environment are some of the prerequisites for adapting to the stress
tions of covid ward has had its negative effects on creating tension caused by Covid‐19 pandemic. In this regard, one of the head nurses
for the staffs. who had management experience in the field of Covid‐19 stated.
“One time a nurse from another hospital came to help us. She “The first patient who came into the emergency room was a man.
was a good nurse, but she did not know our routines and did not He came to the nursing station and said that he has been told that he
know where the equipment was. She herself increased our has Covid‐19. The first thing I did was put on my personal protective
work (P1).” clothing and then began to do his admission work to reduce the fear
Another stressor is having the first experience of pandemic and of my colleagues.” (P5).
not having crisis management skills, which puts a lot of stress on staff, The resistance of colleagues in providing care and standing
the health care system and patients. Crisis management is an art that against the disease was the experience mentioned by the participants
requires sufficient knowledge, skills and experience. in adapting to the pandemic.
6 | GHORBANI ET AL.

“Some people were so stressed, that in every shift, they were 3.16 | People; from appreciation to negligence
saying they want to give up. but others talked to them and said it is
not a very good thing to quit your job when others are coming to According to the participants' experiences, people's reaction and
work. Also, since this disease is so transmittable, it is possible for all response to the treatment team during a pandemic varies from in-
of us to get infected even if we quit our job.” (P12). finite positive (appreciation, cooperation, and observance of health
Joy creation in times of crisis was one of the privileges im- protocols) to infinite negative (negligence). Negligence and non-
plemented in the hospitals that provided care for covid patients. observance of mandatory protocols in pandemic is one of the factors
Performing joyful programs, dancing, singing, and short plays were that facilitate disease spread and increase the stress level. The ap-
some of the strategies used to adapt to stress. These programs were preciation of clients has been effective in adapting to nurses' stress to
performed either spontaneously or under the supervision of hospital a large extent.
management and social work department. “Some people, even when one of their family members becomes
“A number of programs was coordinated by the hospital social infected and hospitalized, still refuse to wear a mask and do not
work department with music and theater groups, and were believe in social distancing. In general, they either hide the disease or
performed in the hospital yard for patients and their families. They do not take it seriously at all.” (P2).
were a kind of recreational activities for them to reduce their On the contrary, observation of appreciation and understanding
stress. Of course, they also had appositive effect on the staffs' by patients and companions was largely effective in reducing fatigue
stress.” (P7). and creating a good feeling in nurses. This understanding and support
was a factor in increasing cooperation between patients and their
companions.
3.14 | Social support on both sides of infinity “Perhaps 90% of the patients who were admitted just realized how
hard our work was and understood that we were working for them with
In times of crisis, movements and processes are formed in the society all our heart and soul. They all expressed that, they never thought our
that, in a positive direction, can facilitate education, awareness and job is such a hard work. And then they were appreciating us.” (P2).
support, or in a negative direction, can create more tensions and
stress such as spreading false and terrifying news and information.
Managing these processes and guiding them in the right direction is 4 | D IS CU SS IO N
an important factor in controlling critical situations and using positive
potentials. According to the participants' experiences, social support The aim of this study was to explain the nurses' experiences of stresses
in the pandemic is on two sides of infinity, which means that it is and coping mechanism with them in the care of patients with Covid‐19
either completely positive and effective or completely negative and disease. Based on the experiences of participants, the sources of stress
ineffective that causes more stress. included failure to address physiological needs, fear of a vague future,
lack of accurate and up‐to‐date information, fear of family infection, lack
of equipment or inadequate equipment, incorrect information in cy-
3.15 | Cyberspace: Is it poisoning the mind or berspace, unfamiliarity of volunteers with the principles of working in
increasing awareness? specialized wards, and negligence of people in society in observing
health protocols. In the study of Shanafelt et al.1 the sources of stress
The outbreak of Covid‐19 disease has revolutionized the way people included lack of access to equipment, exposure to coronavirus at work,
use the media, and perhaps made people realize the importance of transmission of infection to family, insufficient competence in providing
social media in today's world. The spread of coronavirus has allowed care to patient, and lack of access to up‐to‐date information. In Lee
people to communicate with messengers through cyberspace. It also et al.'s16 study, employees referred to the sense of interpersonal isola-
made it possible for students to communicate with their teachers and tion and fear of transmitting the virus to their relatives as the sources of
professors through online social networks, and allowed many cere- stress. The use of personal protective equipment also created high
monies and meetings to be held in cyberspace. It even forced people stress for them.
who were not so interested in online shopping to do most of their Participating nurses referred to ambiguity and fear of uncertain
shopping online. future as one of the reasons for their stress. In Mowbray17 study, fear
“Almost every day I follow the information that comes in. Getting of the unknown leads to more anxiety and this fear can lead to la-
information and training helps us to overcome the fear and beling, and discrimination. In response to this stress, increasing in-
stress.” (P12). formation, having faith and trusting in God have been some of the
However, while information is spreading through cyberspace, strategies used for coping with the stress by the participants. In a
false information is also spreading and creating stress. study conducted by Varasteh Moghaddam et al.18 the most common
“At the beginning of the pandemic, coronavirus was unknown adaptation mechanisms used by nurses included self‐confidence, in-
and there was not many information about it. Even a series of videos creasing knowledge and awareness, relying on abilities, and having
that became viral in cyberspace doubled the staffs' stress.” (P2). purpose in life.
GHORBANI ET AL. | 7

One of the sources of stress from the nurses' point of view was dealing with this disease. Although health workers have accepted
the spread of false information and rumors through the media and exposure to Covid‐19 as part of their professional life, it is not pos-
cyberspace. According to the findings of other studies, exposure to sible to provide quality care in crisis situations without the support
information through the media causes great stress in individuals.19,20 and consideration of employees' mental health. An accurate approach
In this regard, the media can use up‐to‐date and accurate information is recommended to be taken to predict, recognize and manage mental
from valid databases such as the Centers for Disease Control and harms or illness of healthcare worker, especially nurses, and it is vital
Prevention (CDC) and the World Health Organization (WHO). The to provide organizational, national and global measures to pro-
media can prevent the spread of false information and reduce stress tect them.
by emphasizing on developing vaccines and successful prevention
methods. Sharing the experiences of people who have successfully ACKNOWLEDGME NT S
recovered from Covid‐19 also helps to adapt to the stress. The authors would like to thank Tehran University of Medical
The nurses participating in the study used self‐support strategies Sciences, for their fiscal support. We also express our gratitude to the
and also the support of family, hospital, colleagues, media, and the nurses and colleagues for their cordial help. This research was
public to adapt to the stress caused by the pandemic. Lambert and financially supported by Vice‐Chancellor of Tehran University of
Lambert21 found that nurses in each country or work sector resort to Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran (Grant number: 99210048398).
different coping strategies to deal with stress. Lambert believed that
nurses in Asian countries often use emotional‐oriented coping methods CONFLIC T OF INTERESTS
and in Western countries, they mainly use problem‐oriented methods. The authors declare that there are no conflict of interests.
One of the limitations of present study was limiting the study
environment to hospitals affiliated to Tehran University of Medical A U T H O R S C O N T RI B U T I O N S
Sciences. However, maximum sampling variation was done. Alireza Nikbakht Nasrabdi, Mohammad Saleh Emran, Pegah
Matourypour, and Azam Ghorbani designed the project. Azam
Ghorbani, Ehsan Salehi, Mohammad Saleh Emran, and Pegah
4.1 | Recommendation Matourypour managed the project and collected all the interviews
and field notes. Alireza Nikbakht Nasrabdi, Mahboobeh Shali, Pegah
Further studies in other contexts and diverse treatment environ- Matourypour, and Azam Ghorbani analyzed the qualitative data.
ments (educational, privet, and governmental settings) are re- Azam Ghorbani, Mahboobeh Shali, and Pegah Matourypour were
commended. Such research could reveal valuable experiences of responsible for manuscript preparation. All authors contributed
other nurses, and the most efficient and effective coping skills that towards reviewing the paper before submission. The author(s) read
they used. The present study was conducted with a qualitative ap- and approved the final manuscript.
proach, so it's recommended to test the findings of this study by
quantitative approach and methods. DATA AVAILABILITY STATEMENT
The data that support the findings of this study are available from the
corresponding author upon reasonable request.
4.2 | Implications
ORC I D
Although healthcare workers have accepted exposure to Covid‐19 as Azam Ghorbani https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1240-745X
part of their profession, provision of quality care in crisis situations is not Mahboobeh Shali https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4094-8878
possible without supporting the healthcare workers and paying atten- Pegah Matourypour https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9476-0267
tion to their mental health. According to the results of this study, nursing Ehsan Salehi Morkani https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6474-2503
managers should carefully investigate and identify the causes of stress Mohammad Salehpoor Emran https://orcid.org/0000-0002-
and psychological strain that result from caring for patients with a new 3687-8347
pandemic disease in treatment settings. Then, to control these factors Alireza Nikbakht Nasrabadi https://orcid.org/0000-0002-
and minimize these tensions in different levels of nursing, they should 3970-4158
make appropriate policies and plans. Maintaining the health of nursing
staff in critical pandemic situations is vital. RE F ER EN CES
1. Shanafelt T, Ripp J, Trockel M. Understanding and addressing
sources of anxiety among health care professionals during the
COVID‐19 pandemic. JAMA. 2020;323:1‐2.
5 | C ONC LUS I ON
2. Sun N, Wei L, Shi S, Jiao D, Song R, Ma L. A qualitative study on the
psychological experience of caregivers of COVID‐19 patients. Am
Due to the global prevalence of Covid‐19 disease and its mortality J Infect Control. 2020;48(6):592‐598.
rate, health care workers are more likely than others to be exposed to 3. Chung B, Wong T, Suen E, Chung J. SARS: caring for patients in
psychological problems and stress as they are in the first line of Hong Kong. J Clin Nurs. 2005;14(5):7‐10
8 | GHORBANI ET AL.

4. Khalid I, Khalid T, Qabajah M, Barnard A, Qushmaq I. Healthcare 14. Holloway I, Galvin K. Qualitative Research in Nursing and Healthcare.
worker semotions, perceived stressors and coping strategies during 4th ed. Chichester, West Sussex, UK: Wiley‐Blackwell; 2016.
MERS‐CoV outbreak. Clin Med Res. 2016;14(1):7‐14. 15. Hsieh H, Shannon S. Three approaches to qualitative content ana-
5. Kim Y. Nurses' experiences of care for patients with Middle East lysis. Qual Health Res. 2005;15:1277‐1288.
respiratory syndrome— coronavirus in South Korea. Am J Infect 16. Lee S, Kang W, Cho A, Kim T, Park J. Psychological impact of the
Control. 2018;46(7):781‐787. 2015 MERS outbreak on hospital workers and quarantined hemo-
6. Liu C, Wang H, Zhou L. Sources and symptoms of stress among dialysis patients. Compr Psychiatry. 2018;87:123‐127.
nurses in the first Chinese anti‐Ebola medical team during the Sierra 17. Mowbray H. In Beijing, coronavirus 2019‐nCoV has created a siege
Leone aid mission: a qualitative study. Int J Nurs Sci. 2019;6(2): mentality. Br Med J. 2020;368:1‐2.
187‐191. 18. Varasteh‐mogaddam Y, Sadeg‐fard M, Mohammadi S. Stressors and
7. Honey M, Wang W. New Zealand nurses perceptions of caringfor coping strategies of psychiatric nurses in psychiatric wards. Iranian
patients with influenza A (H1N1). Nurs Crit Care. 2013;18(2):63‐69. J Psychiatric Nurs. 2013;1(3):54‐61(persian).
8. Nakakis K, Ouzouni C. Factors influencing stress and job satisfaction 19. Garfin D, Silver R, Holman E. The novel coronavirus (COVID‐2019)
of nurses working in psychiatric units: a Research review. Health Sci outbreak: amplification of public health consequences by media
J. 2008;2(4):183‐195. exposure. Health Psychol. 2020;39(5):355‐357.
9. Shakerinia A, Mohammadpour M. Relationship between job stress 20. Mertensa G, Gerritsenb L, Duijndama S, Saleminkb E, Engelhard I.
and resiliency with occupational burnout among nurses. Fear of the coronavirus (COVID‐19): predictors in an online study
J Kermanshah Univ Med Sci. 2010;14(2):161‐169(persian). conducted in March 2020. J Anxiety Disord. 2020;74:1‐8.
10. Toubaei S, Sahraeian A. Burnout and job satisfaction of nurses 21. Lambert V, Lambert C. Nurses workplace stressors and coping
working in internal, surgery, psychiatry burn and burn wards. strategies. Indian J Palliat Care. 2008;14(1):38‐44.
Gonabad Univ Med Sci J Ofogh‐E‐Danesh. 2006;4(12):40‐49(persian).
11. Gois C, Akiskal H, Akiskal K, Figueira M. Depressive temperament,
distress, psychological adjustment and depressive symptoms in type
2 diabetes. J Affect Disord. 2012;143(1–3):1‐4. How to cite this article: Ghorbani A, Shali M, Matourypour P,
12. Wang C, Hatzigianni M, Shahaeian A, Murray E, Harrison L. The Salehi E, Saleh Emran M, Nikbakht Nasrabdi A. Explaining
combined effects of teacher‐child and peer relationships on chil-
nurses' experience of stresses and coping mechanisms in
dren's social‐emotional adjustment. J Sch Psychol. 2016;59:1‐11.
13. Speziale SH, Carpenter DR. Qualitative Research in Nursing: Advan- coronavirus pandemic. Nursing Forum. 2021;1‐8.
cing the Humanistic Imperative. 5th ed. Philadelphia, PA: Lippincott https://doi.org/10.1111/nuf.12644
Williams & Wilkins; 2011.

You might also like