Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ji B Jjbqooï), "Bqbjioqjij
Ji B Jjbqooï), "Bqbjioqjij
0Ô"
Oifoo^Bo^Bob 'y^K^'[)?>ùcr)ù g^foco.l'g^o Iw^b^BuC ^icDf^'O 7)[)n^jfoo6ù (^o^ foofoo 36^>0)5ob bo^jbocn,
c>ioo>Bo,^Bob 'y'J3^'()?)o>or>.^ foù f)ofooa>6s:o coo^jjob'y'jjC l.V)^'^'^''^ ^■^Oîï^^^ (j^^îJO^G*^^^^ C rl^jB^^foBTîo
JI^B^JJBQOOÏ), (^roByp::^>7]o(3 (3îî^i.'osi^'Q?)a?>o oJBc^ '^^(^^Boc^'o NMl fo^|3oa>', 27-y B';'jb^>ob,^ to^
?)-Bo 5. ? ) n 6 0 S ^ n ,
?>-Bo i ^ . d-b^O^ObBO,
?)-Bo 3. J''<D(^ObO,
i-Bo Ô.-X JOObÔ.^,
?>-Bo 3. 'Q '-Jcîia^BO,
?)-Bo d. a''J6ô3O0(^tË)O,
i-Bo 8. '^JO'ai^bO,
i-Bo à. ^"^3^630^0,
J-Bo 6. 805^OJO,
i-Bo '^. JO^OôOGO,
j-Bo 3. (^na^bOBO,
j-Bo a. G^G6-B03(^ffi^C03b3^,
i-Bo ô . 356ô0(^y,
?>-Bo (0. a^cotlbôO,
?)-Bo J. Ô(^^5^5,
j-B a. s^O ?)n0r^-?>''JJO3OC0, (^Q ^obôc^^ôfofoob Bciù^^off^»^,
oBb^^^Op:^»^) (hc> ^05BB^(oôn(]?>oof) 1999 ^ ^ > o b 18 Bo>(^5^*> 24 oQBobb^ i:oo> 7 ojjsii^obb, ^.^Bfoo^^^b^
'B^jBpoQ^o ^c:)B.^ByBo, cofo3Qf[^0(3 Booc^i^b 1999 ^si^^'ob 7 n j j ^ o b b .
jr-oBoboob ojbrogR^ Bo';^oiocï)Q?>too> ^^^(^i] Bo^jB^^i^ 44-y foo> 4 8 - Q B'ybji^'gibù foci C ?0cJî^''-^^'^(3^''^*^'t)'
c^SfoB^>oa>05(3 b^«J3(oùR5a(r)B._-5 bo^b.sBo^C ^jtD^'oib bv>j(i-5^»^)a?)7j^>fo o';^(^iobj:onj(30C > (3Rf^ (■■'^t^f^O
BtoJBu^o B'^bg^o 46); Ro^a(o^>^Rc»Q(Sob B(r)6[jC ofo?>ob ^.^B^^(3b^j^o ^cofn^') BW^BQ^O 48-;) B^jbgi)'!)^')
Bn^(T)oa)[)?)po6. cnbro[]Bobo5 SJ^Ù ^ùB6(3b6toob BO'\)ÔRO O J ) D (^^C o-^VunOÔ^^^M^*^^ Bn.'iDjjycSô
2. 3 j - U n^-janli (lùft;'>-^'r)() 'Ryb^ii^MiU "fJyR^ij^ojR. «>^>jR'>(,^>> f*)''^ •^;j"19 R^ibsi^'o. h.-^lK^a.^r^imsi^'ci oi7jf>j(j(ic)Bo(^i3?>b Rvjii-'^^H
53
Bro3.')b'gb;j boîb[)^^>B\7()0](ob Bo;jfo ^jf^R^oRcjonb 3^-3 B';^bfi:^otr)C5 co6 B;j-6 B'gbp^ob l-^no 3''jBj(^o(r)
2. jooob^ob 3ùb'gb.'5jx>, b6b.'^3o)(oa)e^>o')b C )foroQ B(^JBQC OO f^ilï^E^'^B^jR^^o OÎ' 33-;) 3'gbsï^'ob B;]-3
(c?) "^'i^'^dô"^* '9abù?)ô3obo)co, (S-R8ù bj'je^'B'^BoS 506^(3b<^po.i, roroB b'^)fopo.b b^jBob Bf'}bB;]B,^'clo
8roB^^ojîi;';]fn?)ob BOJ^Q?)^^ fo^ j:oc)0>bc>b;]cj^0) ^i^Hf^J-^ô^' foro3;]Si^io(3 jx>0^0(3^2^:00 Bob oB5;]C ^;)b;)?)b
(f^a&f^^^^Bgob c>^(^i] BroJSQpoo B'gbff^o 30).
4. 1998 ^s^nob 1 Bro;j3?)3(^b N^ll rojBob ()o)p^^'8o 'B^b^ji^'ob 'cîaStï.'Oô' *^'^d9f^^ ^0"^ S^gb^^ob 3^-
5 3'^Rj(^ob Tî^b^cS^Bobùs:^, b^^JBj 5'-'C O''^3(3«^ b.blK"5B>^)(^a)^nb çoo^ 36c^6(5ùb, (^roB^p^oQ ex
officio ^l}^(^l}àoh bciboo) ^>3(^a)o^R3ài:o^ ?)-R ^ . - 3 . jfobg-^b, b-bo^C oùR^gcDob Bb(^o3 «^C nfi^'yp^»
BfobùB^fooojiï^'ab (jf^RG^RQoob 27-^ B'j^bjï^'ob B;]-2 "^"^Rjô^ f?*^ bùbùBù(^a)p^>rob (^3p)C !,v'>3oR(5"^
24-3 B ' g b ^ o b B3-4 3'gRdôo), i-R ci.'- 3osiI^fo«^*^^B^^ ~ bùbi-^B^c^cnSinrob 3{^3^opo3B5b, J-B 3.
3ùpi^>Bb — bcibùSùC ^œg^rob 3<^(33-<^*^3^oto3R(5^' fÇ*^ ^'^ ^- «^o'Sà^bb — b^^Qoob 30(33-<^<^3'bopo3R(5b
(jDB33B(3ob 27-3 B'^^bg^ob 83-3 -^"gRjô^ S^--'^ bôb^BùcfKnp^rob C 035Si^'C )83B(5ob 24-3 B';]bs^>ob
83-3 pooi 83-5 (à) '^'^RjÔB*^")- ^"C ?o 36K^ù5ob bb3ù ^33(^3^0 0JJ3R3R: (S-Ro 033(^.^(00 ^(^ù^(n, ?>-
Ro ç^^. jùojpmobRojà-Ro 3. 3'g(^iobo,a-Ro 3. o3'y(^BôBo,à-Bo 3. fj'^^^d^^^ib^j^-^^ ^- ^^J'^-^Rjojo,
j-Ro B. 33^030, à-Bo ^ . .53J:DO53BO, J-BO 3. (5nB6b3Bo, j-Bo B. Q0)(30)-Ro3rosnro3b3ù, i-Ro 5 .
3ùR(5o(^';3,?)-Bo 3. ^*33o5^o C ?-^ ?)-Ro 3. i^(^^'^à i^U^^^^i]^^^^'' 24-3 B'^bc:^>ob 83-3 3'gRJ(^o
s:o^ B3-IOO B'gbsii^ob 83-4 3';]6J5'^)- '938co5f^8'9o '33B(33Si^>3p^»Bo> 8nbc>8ù(n(DC i.'33^B^, ?)-RB6 5.
^^63^^(08 poo i-RB^i (^. Bc>(^';3b(^38,'93(33ùK^3b j-Ro 3ôp::;^>8o poc:) i-Ro c^»330(5bo,(^(oBK^3?)b6(3
bùjBob '333^0^008 ^ûBboK!^36'(^o 8nR6^o^^>3nàob Boi:]n3à6 6(^7 '3338^00000 ((^35P^'i33R(5ob 24-
3 B^^bK^-ob 83-5 ( i ) 3'3RJôo).
I c^^j^f)b(^(^i.'i(^';i'^""'^' 'c1jfîo7IjjE)o bo)bôf),-if6(n^'nb f^)^î^ti:!,''^R;j(^r)0 .^ yb^?iC )io,i j;(yii;,''"> oR bù;)f);]b, fo(')8;j^];^>nQ 71^[^,^B()^>o n'H'i
b,5b.'>n.ifM(ng^'rob \'nfî.^71;j 9^-9 oj-jrlob ().^^>Ô7)O 'fî;)b3^>,s8^tj (1994 ^j^^i^'ob 1 i'),')(^nt8?)yi^)n) y^i^ '^(■),'jU,*'^fî '^'''ÎI'''iU,'('J<'*Vl^*" '^^^
\''sinnb 31 nj(J|)r)n?»foùnj]nQ — Rbfig;;'0*40 of) bùjBj^Ab, foronjmjtSny Vl^^^ùfin^i^ic) O;JD OR bi'5bjc;^'n\Vo'J'3r')jà(ib \"n[iùôC ]Rsi^j(|),
fonf)^;^'Qàobo)jjobô(^ lo^-jHo o(^^ 01)0 b^jj^^'^i^-jA^ijinoi
54
i-Ro cl.-'O. s^COàQS^'O, b.^3c5(oo7S£^>3?>(oo3 bc>;]B3oo6 J:O33Ù(^5'^*^3^Ô"^ '3<g(^cobob Boioifo^opt^n^cj,
bo5^ôfo3ro b^JB3(nù b^BoRobgf^t^, -^ÔB^Ô^'
a(^F)33K^'3?)o.
5) 3roBoboob boib3ff^ooo:
?>-Ro ^. b36?>0.
h) 505BB(3b6jo3?)(TT>ob bcïb3si;nooo:
J-Bo a.-5. 3«!:)6'3-?)0f^B^(^^0, 36(^io*bob -^s:o3r)36(5'3(^os:o,-5B, -^C^B^^B^Ô*^-
Ô) 3ro3oboob b6b3fi:nooo:
bc:)bo>B6(îîoo^'ro8 ?>-B b36?)ob, J-B 36R*;;]-i3(^iRo>(^j:oob,b ÇOÙ i-B cofo?)3Sï^ob 3oB6(noo33?)o BroobBoR^.
9. 1991 ^^>ob 25 R(^38?)3(^b ?)-Bo b3^'B'jBo 36(^o%ob b6b5';]B(oro'r)o po663633b. B6b '3;J8S:D3^,
(^<^(^ 6Booo(3R3b ^(^8oBo33 J3^\')^5^,<^3RB6 i:o6 8obB6 B35(o?)6(oB6 j^oo^o7B6B, ?)-B36 b3g[:^>BY]BoB
55
6bbB6, (^(o3 tÇ(o8oBo33 33SiZ.*Bf?'^S*^0^*'^'-"^^ b6JBo6Ro 'j^(^ia)03(ooofO(S;)?)0 63637)o(o3(Sfo.^ (56Bb6(3Bji^o(r>
36^(ofo?)ob bYî3fo(o71o jç6 7J'-^<^3<'^* U^'^BB^'ôB*^*^" B(oB6\Vo^'3(o?)6 B6fo3(0(5o33?)()(n 36^(oro(S67)o.
10. 6-Bo b3ii];>3'^Ro 3(osi^'0(3067)o QJ636(508(03?)';'jC i^io "3*^ "^^^ ^T*c:^'ob 25 Bf0335roob b6sn.'^8(ob
(3b(oob R6b33(oo^6B 1991 ^o^>ob 28 B(03B?)(oob b6sno>8fob 7 b660068po3. opjO ^^630(x)b';^^>
0JB6 3fo^'0(30ob 8fob3oj^>33?)ob 803(0 b3oR-b3B(5-^J3Bobob bobbsi^'ob b686(ooosî;^ob b6563ooBo3cS(o
^^>336(0(56B3fiôoto6B (SDPJ93) ^xoio^BTJo.
U. (S-Bo b30i^'B'yBo 3o(033Si^>6fo s:oo503oa)b6 1991 ^pL;»nb 26 Bro38?)3(ob jioo^^'ob 12.40 ^or>.-j:o6B
1.30 \?(»--B^3 301^*0(30011 3o)b3g^33?>oli 803(0, (o(oB3o^>(j>6 \7'oB66snBfo35 86B '833^0^j00B^Bo
7Î30(56R6 116^036(00. sx)630(r)b3oli6 ^^6 li6li636(o()')i:i^'(ob b63R3?)'3o ^6(S(o';]R3?)ob ' 8 3 8 ^ 3 5 B6b
■^JroRjo^ 8^*03(00 '33(533'^- ( j o b o b 8(ob3(i^'33 050 b6b\7(06O]f0 tDùb86fo3?)ob 56R3oocrjoff^3?)6'3o
^'60336R6 36B 33(0^003(00!! b6636^B3(oa{oo'3o, ?)(oBfoo'8o, juosij^ob 3 b66a>b6 ^ 6 15 V'ZJ^^'^0-
b6b^(o6Y3(o jjoo>bB6f63?)ob (^6B30)03oo^'3?)ob b6B3tuo(3oBro ^6!i33B3?)73o 6cnBo'3R'gsi^>06 '838^0350:
„bo^>'3fîî^3 36(o(3b3R6 j'yoo';]ooco*l)3 s^6 b3C ^b3B^)o!i ^3380)00. b36^>3o tD6*l)06B3?)'3ff^o 6J3b".
13. 1991 \?si;>ob 27 B(033?>3(^!i iS-Bo b3pi^8'gRo f0603ooob6 iioojii^oli 11 b66oob6 co6 40 ^'3oo'b3.
Bobo b3K^6bff['6 2)'^3oo33si^33ob6b 3J0B86 6';]b5oRB6 '333^03^0 '33Bo'33B3?)0 56633006:
14. 1991 ^si^ob 28 Ro)33?>3(ob sT^of^>ob 9.30 ^a).-(336R 10.45 ^(x).-Bj:o3 j:o63oa)b3ob ^338^:035 <S-Bo
b3g^B';;]Bo 33K?63 ojB6 ô6Bf033c^»3<gp^>o 3J0B ^ ' g b ô o R o b 803(0, (00183^086(3 b633foo(3oRoi
(3Rooi6'3o 6inRo7)B6:
15. 1991 ^ ^ ' o b 29 R(03B?)3(oli foo^^>o!i 11 b66(r)li6 c^6 30 '?7j(''>'b3 56B8(3b6^3cS3p^o 5'^^(^('^33K,*Bc)^'
'^'d^'^ l]û^^ BC ^B^^ob, *bo)j^6STio 3(o6J(5o30)bob, 803(0. 86B, i-B b3Çi^>B';]Bob (r>bo)3Bob b6<J3';]B33^>T.)3,
56b(36 (^Bro?>6, (ooo8p[^>ob o')6B6b36jxn^(3, i-Bo b3f^>3^jBo 3(^i353B^o6b ^^680000^368^06 <go*^)03'^fo
86^'6i:ooi<S6bo>6R i:o,-,3,^3'3o(^S3?)oaK (3Bo)cS671o 8ooooaJ3&g^'o 0307:
„or)63ol) (5303o^>3?>o, !ioti;>';«)(^^3 10(0033 a)36^'0)6R, (0(0033 b3^;»'b3, b3(ob336^n'li3, ô'3Sî['<^BBf^C ?o!j
6(03*80, 0K0033 ?)6(o863b6 ^ 6 36(^(^5b3B6 B';'jb^''b3. 333u;'6 3b 6(03 B(5303R37jff^>06'.
56
16. oB633 ."^^^^'B^^ 'ô'-^f^^G^^''^^B*^B^" ^6(o6STi2joB3b 56Boi38o3?>3c^^o 3oob6B6(ooosi^'ob Ç0B67Ï3,
( 0 ( 0 8 3 ^ 8 6 ( 3 8 6 b ?)(o6c^>o ^ 6 b ^ < o b6B6(ooo6sïi^^6(o^3333è*3o, b6*8o*3o B6(o3(0(5o3';]^>o
Bo3ooo3(^3à3(Sob '33li6b3i 36RfoRBf0 3?>pT>oo?)ob f06Co^3336'3o ^ 6 60336R6 36(5oB(^i(o?)6'8o.
56B(oBdo3à3Ci,'o Booli686(oooKï>ob ^oB6*83 i-B b3iii;8YjRo!i 30(033^*0 ^6(of053Ro!i6b 3co!i686(ooof[^>3B
oo63obo 060(306503000 4^06607166 3(']oBo ^6(063(00, 36(ot)^>o!i !i6b686(^cofcnoob b6633K^6(300)
30o^>3^oob b6b636(o(y)^>(o-!i6B3^o(3oBoo 3d^'^3f^ô*^' (06a)6 56Bco333f^>06 ?)-Bo b3fii>B7]Bo,
„(o(oB3^^'0(3 r)0(oco6 (3*3^^6^^ B(o33(oto?)ob 0160066^)3 300^^^0(306*80 365oB(o(o6ob6b" f06 bb36
3(1(00, i-Bo 6?)s:o3^>B6^o^ 86^:00, (0(0835^00(3 ix)663633b 1991 \7^>ob 26 Roi3363(ob s:o6 (^(083^^*116(3
0B633 b686(O006Ki^i^6(0(.i^33336*80 3C;>3?>(Ofo6 6(06^*0.
,v- ^f^f^'tl^^a 9oo3fii> bb3'3f^b6 ÇD6 66(086336^3, 65(03^33 !i3(oooi'b'yf^>o hoç^'^("^^^ o)36çîi'36ob
6(03*80. ^6(oBro6j:o536b 3(^6o'^6j(5'g(^'3ff^ bog:o'y(o^3!i. (001500(0(3 686016b, 36Co(3b3R6 oo36c:i>'3o
9^ac?3Bff^*^^^ ^6'l)06636'3ff^o 6 j 3 b " .
57
— 0,5 b8-ob j:o,^'^)06R366 86(652336-^ 635^:^06 7J3666 3b6(63b;
— 88083 ^^3B6(5('^86 (5-3 bB), B(oC'ooo65^[>oi o33(6ob, 57Jffl,'B33(65oob ^oR6 3b6(63b, 33056b(5(607)51:^
6(63*80;
— *33bo366 86(65^3366 Ç)i}(^^oh 7)3666 Bb6(63li 556 3660b 50611066366 {5B<^^ob 7]3'^R*^
8b6(63b;
„^5b33B.S
58
B6b 6;J3b bb37j5ï:[*o!î (5*^'^^0f^7JK^'o !i6bo!i STO61>O663636O, (6(0851^360(3 8050367)511"o6 oB 5o(6(ob,
(6005031105(3 oB30)C 336(0506 36(5oB(6(o66*3o.
23. 1992 ^5i.':'ob 0)36;)C 6365*;;*8o 6oi6o5Rob tribunal de grande instance-h 3(^(037)(6657]f^^8
8oa)0(ï)366 Bob(36 3(600367)5100 3oi5ioo(3oob oRb33J(306b 3o)5ioo(30ob *33b6663o!io 3(ob35£:^336ob
5063oa7b3ob ai60i66'b3.
'1991 ^5o;*ob 25 6oi386(6ob b65ocî8(o!i, 5066b5io0736000, 8 b66a)b6 5:06 30 ^7)^1^3, C )38o b6b(57)8(6(ob.
Terminus Nord-oh,(]ùh^<:n})Ç^ùço, G are du Nord-wà^ 6b5ioff)b, 36(6oli*3o,oo<686-b63B6 5^506(337)51^86
3(05100(3035ïi;86 5068636(5oB(66. 8600 33SÇ3f^co66 30863363b 506 33^1^'b3 O6(66i:oob 5ii^7)p?,»3^o
3o)3665^o63b.
86li ^3385035, (66(3 800510066650 56BP)b(6o33b, (6o)B5iooli 5o(6fob6(3 333^^'^*33f^o, (66(3 568666506,
668(086(60033!^, b7)a>B6 3005100(3051086 5:060^30) 6330 (O630oob36.
59
Iib36 b6Bo 30151^*0(30351:^»0(3 ■^d(5'^7)*^^^iN ^GB*^^'-''' "^'(^503(60^)0 B6(n56Ro ^ 3 b 3 6 ' b 3 '8385056 506
B6V33?)oocO'^-
8600 '33803366311 O)oo6b'8o, (60783510"80(3 J65ÏOO 052506, 500 506B6BooJ3b. *3335035 ooS^'Bo 801830503b
b35ioo 506 7)oob(63b d65iob: „R6b3, '836 6b5^'6 boB5:o3c6c.b 560507R36".
36b "3385035 (66(3 B^tJ^'^B' o'^^^B"^'^ B * ^ ^ 8 & " ^ (6833000, 68 80052^*0(30351086 ■506B6'36(6506.
680b "3335035 ^6803366311 !ib36 oooo6b'8o 506 50683B7jj(6636 5068500b 50^5^036001, 007) 6(6
63510686(663503600500. 83 7)6(6o 300 J30. B6O) 666003b (0(6o l>6(6F)05io630 5o>6836, (^01850*360(3
7)33(^00367]51:^0 030) 56*bob (o(6 36(56(66 665io(oRo)6R. 860^1 5065^500186 86o87)5ii^3b, b(05ii^'0i
510^^88360 5^>66^'333li 3(6(00 B3(5(6o!i 801'8(0(^360(0 6380 (58^'(ÎB^*^^'^'^' ^^(^3510361)3(3 Y^B^^^'^^O'^B^*"
6(6 83(336, 686350(6(07)51:^*650, 8(33850636. '8385035 86O) 63(0()5O3b '33(6o(30 50^ Bobo 56330036001
60
50633871^(6636. (6oi503b6(3 3b 5o.^3o66b3, 563obo3 !i6b35ii*oi 50'-'> 37)o)b6(^o: „Bo5oooo, (073 56635063(0".
(601501(6(3 3<fjoj(6oi65oo, 8600 6(^ 7)36b(67)5io3!i B7);|6(66.
83 30(30, (600B, (66(3 '^^ff^''^ 5oo)b6(6ooo, 86510066 88083 8fob6!i336o6, 865(668 3335ii^'^'ï33f^o
bo36(6oo5io36. 83 bo6685o30511^3*80 5!?^33d33850366f63 68536(6 80033(601666.
8651:^6500066, (60083511:^0(3 ^5;^3V3C ^3, 5(^83510503607506 1991 ^5ii^o!i 25-26 506 26-27 6oo336(6ob
50680b b66O736*80.
7)03(6(obo Boib35io3 (050R63 835^1^00(506. 830)(63 5066b511^0036000 30-35 ^5ioob66, ^3(66 008360
^dB^-
61
(6o)503b6(3 510636(67)6500 (johifcïo, !ib37)5ii^>*!>3 83(53(06(0506 030^10373(60 86511^'.>50fo6ob 60*36360.
68368650, 8(6(0651038360 86^3!! 8!')350335TO(V)66!io)66 506363*30(63600).
25. 5063ooob3ob (o^']8ob B666\73(6o 5'^35^^^366 6(o6o56ob 3(6oo37)(6o)(61i 1992 ^'5ioob 2 5VBBB8^B^^^'
(60)501(6(3 N^B.92.016.5118/4 b636(6a)65i:^\76(6B(036ob 66Ç'o5i;*o.
6. b6568oo8o36o) b686(^ao65io^6(63oo366
30. 1993 ^51^'ob 27 63(6o5i;>b ^}-R86 86(608, 6oi6o5Rob tribuncd de grande instance-h 568(0880363511^86
Boo 11636(60751038, (60183511^b6(3 5063^*3(66 b6j33, 3(6(0367)511*0 3005^00(30011 06633^(300!! 5oo(63j(5oo(6b
3ob(36 7]oo(6B65io7)(6o o6b(5(67];)(3036o, 8o35::^>o) 33351^*6 li6^o(6(o 5;*foRob8o366 boB6(6(y)5u;*ob
5065:05360!! 8ol)Roo). 3fobb3636;)6ob C'6(65i^)536o!i 666005100)01 5050350 1993 ^50106 15 0360110
56606611503(66.
62
31. 1993 \7 5ii^'oli 9 o3Robb 3^0886 56(6R3(686, j - 6 36(6ob (ob(036ob b6037)833510%3, 6-60
11351037)60 b35io6b5io6 563oo0335^^06. 01630b 5oc)b3366'3o, (6(08350)0(^3 866 1993 ^511*06 21 o3Rob!i
^'6(66505oR6, 733850350 8(ob6%(63636o 66801636510066:
«5bB36^
33. 866 5668(3b6503635i;*o 1993 V5i;»ob 14 86obb 50630(nb6, 3db33(65o 506Ro73R6 1993 ^ . ^ o b 9
o36obb 506 b6835oo(3o6(o 3d^^"^B^ô"^ C ^'^^MB^'^ 3b6(6336b 56506b(36 1993 ^5ioob 15 b3;](53363(6b.
63
35. 1993 ^75i::^*o6 3 63^(53^***^*^^^ VB^'^^*'^'^' ^^^[\Çil!^(3 (S^^^'^B^'^^^'tfi'à^^^^ 'à^Tj^^'^^'^lfi'^ 36(6oliob
116633511^6(30(0 b6b686(6(y)5iO(ob 8360)3 5663(07]05io36ob o)63B5^5ooi86(63b, (60183511^»b6(3 7)6506
5663bo5ii^'6 5668(3b65o36511*ob 116633511*6(3000 b66o36(6o b6'3o'3o 66(63(o5o37)5ii'o 6o30)03(63636ob
'33b6b36 366(0685036511^'oo6o!i6 506 b636(6o)65io506(^5033336ob6o)3o!i 8115^^63(650360b \7066650B5035,
866 65060*866, (600B 050 6301160051:^*06 b35ii^»5^(obooi 5'^'^7)86507](^136 506 5066B65<^5 (6oi3 36b
3(05Ï:^>0(30351086 5D66'36(6506. 5663(3b6503635u;'36 B07J000016, (6(o8 li3B(ob!!36;)67)5i:;^'o ^3(^05ii^*ob
565I163R6B503 36R 6b333 6(3Ro)66 6(o6o5Rob liolib5ioo!! !i636(6005100b b6b6B6(6o)5ii^'(o!i 83(368353
566301030511,1360b 006385^50(086(631! 08 (37)500 80033(^(060!! 733b6b36, (66l56(3 050 5Ç'^3dBBf^SÇB^^'^^'^
3(05100(3o6'3o 365o8(6(o6ob6b.
38. b6Bo7^^65o;'6Joo 8b6(6336o 50603ooobR3R 1994 \î'5ii^ob 10 oo363(6365^,'b. 68633 505i?3b 03(0
5io6Ro'8R7]5o;>o 506866*86306 050365073036(3006 3(6(0(335O7)(66 8005100(3006 oB 3o)b35ii;*30i6
6B(ob6(3R(o665o, (6018351:^006 ^066650350356(3 0300 8086(60)7)51110 6-6 b35io87)6ob 6(665105^036360.
6-636 6351087)608 60005066 oioobo 300511*0(3035100 68(00(36(0. 3b3Ro 03363R: 6-60 366-63(666(650
^3(630, 6-Ro 3(6ob5('i73 b53i5S[;'3foo, 6-Ro 6(67)Roi 5(0503 506 6-60 365f^o6 37)(6oo5io5o.
42. 1994 ^"511*06 22 036066 66;j83 5063\7'3(66 J-6 73(66667)61*6 36(65i:^>o3(6-3(^o3365b, 33(6b65ii^ob
tribunal de grande instance-h oo6385^5D(oB6(6ob 8(06505051031!, (6(o835i^>o(3 b;)5ii^B85o36635ii>oi6506
8003510 !iobb5i^>o!i-b636(6o)5ii^36(^03 5680)80366!!.
64
43. 1994 ^5iI.'ob 8 653ob5c>!i 563(oB8o3635ii^'B6 8(06686(6(0511^38 3(oo(ob(036 8o!iO)3o!1
56800351)6366(0 6-6 b35io3';')Rob 00(6033 l!6835oo(3oRoi 50('^37)B3R5o 3(6(o3R7)51:^*0 3(0511^*0(300!
"^^^'^BdO"^^^ 63^50007. 735-^830660 50(037)83653^^0 B6b 1995 ^5i:^ob 12 63(6o5ii^b 5'-'535l)636
46. 1996 ^5ii^ob 5 o6636(6b b6335oo(3oRfo 3d^*'^B^Ô^* 5063653?>o(oo 36506 803(36 5:o6b336ob
8(011631)65036511*650. 1996 Ç5ii^ob 18 06636(611 ^6(680)505360511^ 5ï,^*'^63366^30 3do836 606(65008
'^B'^^Bô" Boob6l)(63636o 66300636511^066:
2. 86510650(066b, (60b oo6(o66l)3(3 F)03ob 6-60 b35ii;87)6o, 33(68(050, 5D6(653836b b6bo!i 36(^)(3b3R6
33(6ooo(66o5'^5ï:i^7)(^ 6(63730 '8338510^0 568003^^306 o)365ii^ob 50611066366, 865(668 335«^Boi(67j(^'boli
66 017)6506(3 8b350335100760b '333(30(636ob b7)6o3J5'i!)'^o b()335(^336ol!6 506 33o(^^)35o665ii^7)(6o
8386(66606 5068017)30510363511^0 3(6(o65io33()b 56(6506 0)36510113, 33(680750, 'ço66 <»3«i5iV^t)^B^*B'
(66083 66336510330 6508(063605100 6(6 6(6o!i, 6(6(3 '^'^0801(60506 (66083 6o*86Ro *33oBo'3R366
o)365iooli 665!oob36(6 56(6b(o6R, (66(3 5-^8(0^337)5100 o^']R36oo506 b6R5(68510030 506(653836001,
(600B B600 73(o(6ob 363*80(60 506^5oR503b. 56(6506 63ob6, 5^353RB^'^(3""^* 60*86360 0J66
65080)6360511^0 (0(65667)511^ 801'8511^0511^0066b(066 (6b5;:^>oo3b350 335iooi66 00(6033 01365101)3)
8036(60036000".
47. 1996 ^5ii^ob 6 o)363(6365i:^>b b6335oo(3o6o) 5o6b33B6 565063(36 6-6 b35io87]6ob, (60183^1^36(3
305033 3(6o)b35iii 8ob(36 6336366. 050 335i;'^3 -^^ÔB^GB^^^ 6(6651050363611 (ooibo 801511^0(3035100b
8o86(6(o, (60185103?)0(3 68000(3600. 1996 ^5ïoob 7 36(65b 3o)ob8o63b 83(0(63 b63o)365io6^o)
3b6(6ob, 6-R 365ioob, 6336366. 865008 5066b6b35io6 83b7)(03 3oo5100(303511*0, 6-60 6510331106
50. b7)aio 8005^00(30351110, (6o)83511^'(o6 ^'066650850356(3 6-6B6 b3^'87)Ro8 506 6-636 B65008
b66o3(636o 7330566311,33(68(050,6-60 .^3(630,6-Ro b53?*Sii^3f^o, 6-Ro 5(0(503,6-60 5ii.*B85i:i.'B^B"
506 6-60 ,^7)(601511^5" 5O6O30(obR3R 30(63351:^1033 56B(0(3b65036ob 5o(6oob 1997 ^^5ii^ob 10, 24 506
31 06636(6b, 28 o)363(636vo>li6 506 7 B6(65b. 360) 8o36(6oo 5060^301 568(080366 b65^6(6(o
8cob35io3(o6 803(6 56Rb(0(6(303511^367)50^0 86511;6500160!! 568(0, (6686(3 Ô'^f^<'^o^306 b(67)5o>o
6(6636(65obo6Ro)?)6 b687)7)60)!!60)3ob (636 505031)3 8350 b6o(yi. 6-6 33(^3ob, 6-6 b53à5iiJB<^ob,
i-6 50')(5*^3^^'-"^ Sî^^"^ ^'^ 87)(6(05io5o!i Bo36(6o), 65(63(033 5060^3(0 5680)80366 !i3j!>7)65io73(60
865ii;65oco6ob60)3ob, 665V'36o5i70 (6685036083 ^68^31)365100116 (O';') (0666B(o66\705i:^'oli 803(6.
65
51. 1998 \75o;ob 24 63(6o5ii^'b, 3(0511^10(303510(7)6 3b(6o5066 7)6(63007306 (7)365ii^b6l)(6oliooi, (6018510360(3
■^'^ÔB'^GB^^^B'^' (6O)8 6-6 6351087)606 5:^"^3*^3B*^^'^> 50(6016 0301 6(680)5106, 5630188036351036
8006686(6(051033 3Jb33(6565o 50660*366 3t']oBo 56(663(60. 36b 506336510^ 6-6 63511^37)606
66335:^*0(306(0 5!o(037)83653?>oli6 506 (36006360b '838(o\7'3366 506 506b336ob 5*^3300366 o36b(r)66
506363*^80(63600), 566680(60066 (07) 6(66 65080063R05100 5061)06636360 6(680051068 Bolso
506365o3(636ob 5o(6(ob, 1991 ^5ioob 25 60)3363(66, 5066b5ii^>o)36oo), !!65063(ob 8 b66oob6 506 30
^7)ool)3, 66 booB 6(6 6836(63650636 oboBo 56RB(3b650365i:^iob 6(66510503636!).
53. 1998 ^5i^>ob 4 036011b 5663(3b6503635o;b6 506 (ooob 8005100(303511;b *3oi(6ob 5063o(6ob3o(6366
5060^301. 6-636 b35ii;37j6o8 650^*3(66, 007) (66 (6005100 oo7636'36 000010037)51086 860056RB6 Bobo
36503(^(066*30 30073Roli 5o(6oob.
54. 3doB 56(6R3(6ob 506b33R6 V'^'^f?&B^*^^ ojR6 1998 ^5i:^*ob 3 O35!!:oobb. 3d'^'^B^Ô*^^ "^^*^ o(o:
(66(3 '^BB^B^'^ bo75oro37)(^ j8350(")636b, (66b6(3 650^3(6b 36(303R5o, 1993 ^^>ob 9 o3Bobb,
3ooBb506(6o 7^6;J5o5!06B Ç35ïoo^'65o-B6b33(6ob 73385035, 665'^f^3<^'35i!^o 5 3 ^ 0 " ^ 7)6(63017^0000
'^B^Bb" ^^^G 71'^<^yf^'0^^ ^--^ ^^(3 ^^^^Ô'd^i}^^^ ^ ^ ^ B^^ ^B^GB^*^ bo6685030511,*3b 7333733(6366".
„... 3(05ioo(30ob B(ob35ii;3(n6 803(6 TJ^^dÔB***^^^* 7)6(63(07)6 6(6 566b05107)51^16 086I13 335*^50
3050(63 860)o 80(00(0366 „865ii;ob 56301336366I);)", (60150366(3 6bo)(6(3035ii;365o636 5Ç<'^363366!>
66 o87j5i^'36o(o ^066650850350)661)3 50.-5300)63011 3(6o)(33b73o.
66
688350 b35ii;B7)Rob6 506 66503511;865^050 86500b 566(3b6503636'8(i (66083 3351^0510360116 017)
7337)b6668o)636ob 6(66(61136(066 686(6(05io36b o36b, (6018 obo6o 3b35o335*i;oo6673o 7)6506 80050(06.
56(650^ 680I16, oboBo 506b57)(^5:o366 b6335!oo(3o6oo 506b33R36oo) 506 685036650, \76(6B(065O536b
b63B6(6ob 8530(3367)5ii;366li b7)ooo 3o(6ob V^^^^'^'^^^'^^Bô' *^'^G 7)^^^*^ 5660b051:^*00b 30(63351^*0
oRb566(3oob b6b686(6o)5ii;(o8..."
67
650505170 «\']o)R506 b6J8oli 736;]5(^?*(^03 56(638(03636b, ^066850366(63 b6JB3'3o 6,^8350 b35ii;B7)6ob
Bo86(6(o 56Bboi(6(3035ii;367)5ii;o 865ii^i65oro6ob 6 J 5 B ^ * ^ ' f^(^85ii^>360(3, Bobo 8530336o(r), 7)6506
33*^51^'0730(30(65036 \76336650 66 66(666(6oi!iro665o, 0(6 03(0 56Rboo(6(3035iii367]5ii^'o 5o^^R6'36';35ioob
66503R63503 6R 7]'3';-)65i;;'005o 5ooRo)'367]5i;;*o!i 66503Rob 3(o83B5'3o.
60. oBoli 5066650536650, 033636 007) 6(66 8(051:^0(3006 3oob35ii;336o 500866*363360, bo!ib5ioob
b686(^0)510oil b6b636(6o)5i^'0)8 65060*866, (6008 „(o(6o 6(67)5100650 7)(6ooo3(6(r)b6^oB665o35035oo
6(657)83650 oj66 Ç*6(63oo5053Bo5iiio", 506 „3oo5ioo(30ob 3oob35io3oo6 803(6 3o(3387)5ii;o 800351:^*0
(6050 56B86(653?'3?'ob" ,,(605(605(0600)" 566bo5io36 5'^5ï;<^^33o5'^- 5:?'^7]'336 (66, (6(o8 ,,506505065100...,
[56B3(3b650365ii»ob6{r)3ob Bo33R36'y5u;>o] 506I706R36360 5-^801 ^337)51:^* ojR6 3oo5ioo306'3o
365oB(6(o6ob6b 6R 0J68503, 017) oBoli "8385035 8OI35![T>3 bRob 56R8635ii;oi66*3o", b6b636(6oi5i:^'(o3
8006R06, (6oo3 b68(0J65ii;6J0) 3b6(6336o!! 835035100066, 5î?^3'^3B^f^^^ 5o(6oib ^oR665oB5035oi66
563^0600, à(n 6(^ob b6336(^obo 6bbR6b 6(6b367)5ioo 500I106R36360; „7)37)b6668oi66", 0)7) 686b
1163(6010150 ,5^^016506 650505ii;o, l!63ooJ65ii;6Joo 3b6(63oo6 5663b6503636b *3(o(6ob 6(6 03(0
565068^33350 506, 11(05650650, „b68oiJ65ii;6Jo) Bb6(6336o 3(600660(6650 65O^3(65DR36 8073511136366";
836(60 35303367)511^1360b 6(6b36oi6ob *338o)b3336*3o3 30 „3oo5ioo3oob R36ob3o3(636 Boob35io33
36(65650 o(3ob, (6(o8 65006(6366 b 6 b 7) (633 511^* 06 506 686350(6(07)510650, (6007)51006
6(6651750367)510ob60)3ob 8075306R3600) Bobo '33335ii»6"; „6(6 6(6b36(o65:00 6(^3 3(6^)0
^ÔB'^GB^'îlSii.'B^'^' f6o7835ii;o(3 6506b57)(636506 086b, (6oi3 b68oo^^65!:o6^']oo 8b6(633636 8000510o36(6633b
3oo5ii;o(30ob 8oob35ii_'3oo6 ^^06665085035 b66o3(636ob *835'^R'^8503"-
68
6R6l)5067)(63?>o!i6oi3ob 506, '33!i6668ob65o, 7)3066(667)66 b63(oj65ii^'6j')(o b686(6(05ioob
!i6b636(6o)5ii;oob6oi3ob 8086(60030!! 7)735ll^3<^6.
65. 1999 ^5ii;ob 1 O35ii;obob 5666636000, (6008351003 800503b 1999 ^5^oob 20-21 86obob
3(ob33Rob '33850500B, (6o735ii;ob '335ï^35'^5î?'^35 f'l-Ro 83(630 560)63ob7)<i35ii;506, 33(6b65ioob
b66335io6(3ooi b6b686(60)510073 56636(6005106 3oo5ii;0303510360 b3J!i7)65107)(6o 865106500160b
6(6651050360b6oo3oli 6(66b6336(6olio 35303367)5io36ob 56B01, 865(668 oboRo 5068R6'36333665o
3R01 „865ii;65ooo6ob6 506 06(6650007 ^(60511:00060b Bo336366'3o 66 Bobo 56801336360b 87)^6(6000,
3oo5ii;o3oob 8(ob35io336ob 803(6 0)63066010 3^5ii,'503?>7)5ii;3?)3?)ob '33b(67)5ii;36ob6b 506 36R(oRo3(6o
BoliRob 56(63'33, (6686(3 568010^7306 37|'36oo6ob6oo3ob b(67)5ii;o 6(6636(650110660166 (636 50503113
R63510360 bRooo, b35ii;87)Rob b6J83'3o, boo5iofo (636 5:o5i:?3l73 9 B 5 ^ bRooo, 365oob b6j83*3o".
'33b6668ob65o, b6b6B6(6oi5ii;oo8 6-6 .53(63ob '837)736(6506 365oB(6oi66 003(068350 0)3001,
(60183511;006566 oob7)o)335o 0033 565063650506, 6-R 5oo5o3b6 506 6-R b53^5il,*3f^b — (ob7)o)835o
0)3000 565063650360(0, boo5ii;oi 6-R .37)(665ii;5b — 0001(68350 013000 365o3(6oo66 56506365036000.
b66335io630oi b6b636(6oi5iooo8, inter alia, 66301636510066 "83850350 800503360:
,,6(^0^01} (r)ùco?)ô%D
dàç^>ô^('o6ù>h(r)ô6 xp<V.\7^r)(^^3(?w
69
6351:;;'87)60660)3011 80336367)tïi^'o 506l)066360b 8fo(37)5170)66 011(^)50360)500 3(0511;0(306*80
365oB(6oo6ob 565(68351:1^1366110166 3(60)650.
1991 \75ii;ob 29 60)3863(66 3^08 3503(60!! 803(6 651*8(063605100 !i05io7)(65^3 B6(63b366 ;J7)077)0000113,
365'^i(^'^ b^oi(6b6l)(0366o J(60511^'(^066 86(6(31^366 ^*6(66ob 5«^!5^*3<^o3, B6(63b3R6 506 B6(65^33R6
J33oir66o5'^5i:^'7]f6o .^3865t'i36, bro5ioo7 '3385050)8'8o, 1991 ^5ii;o!! 2 5?3333?)3(6b, 3do8 Ro3075ob
803(6 650^^3(605100 b0511^'7)(65^^3 „o)365ii;36ob 0(65351703", '333b6663366 b3j2i^i87)6oli 803(6 R6b!i3636
506(653836b.
b365io3o!!6 506 o)63ob ÔB^B^^'B*^*^*' (6(03517361)33 807)000(0311 3^0886 67)b5o636 500 3do886
3503(608, 6b333 6836(6361! b35ii;87)6ob 5'-'563b6503636b, (6(o8 86b 00836000 oo)(6335o636 506
0)63*80 5687)5083600) 7)(653-^850636 b6566b, (6(083511*0(3 *33o85io3600506 63ob6oo5ioob b35io52robo
3070305Ï;IO3OI.
70
7)657*^ 65ooRo'3R(ob, (6(o8 568oo8o36o!!6 500 b080(600051^1 ^6(63(0360b '830500 ^5ii;ob 56R3635i7oi66'3o
6(6 3017305106 3(o3oo3367)5ii;o 85303367)511;366 68 3 5 3 0 3 3 6 0 b 506b6b667)o)365ii;65o. 3(ob6(6635io30)6
0653(636360 8Ro'33R35ioco3R65o 56Rbb363367)5ii|06. 0)668085033(67)5100 650^3(6360 3335176 oB
6(66li6o)6665oro 8oi33(6(o6o!!6, (6(08510361133 oboRo 807)0)0003650636, 6(6 ^6(680066361! (66083
3oB636365i:^>(o66b. --^5(63(033 7)6500 O5i;o6o'36o)b, (6008 01300)016 6351087)606 8R3517050 to'y .^303500
65030)3650 66(6300503360(0 36^(6ro66!i(066 506363730(6367)51:1^10 b6B6(6o)65io^6(68oo36ob6!i.
8b350335170)6ob 805086 6(6 7)6506 57*">53(^63!! ob 736^-1503, (6oo3 865oob6 506 b35i^i37)Ro!i,
06(08510360(3 86R63503 6(66!!5o(6(ob 3oot305i:['66 50080508(6367)51760, 0(6 733085103601500 3j(oB(05oo(o
3651^60 ob5(^f^oob 733(obl)3ob 3(66j5o3'^-
71
l)33(ob!!363i';')5i7*^'^ 733!i6668ob65o, Iiob6b5o33j (66*30(3 30)5170(300!! B(ob35i7336b 350366O) 6(665170,
lif67j5rr>oo5o 0*836(666. b6;]Bob 56R8bo5ii^>335i736 !i6b686(6oo5ioo)8 b^(o(665o 50665050B6, (6(o8
b6B6(6oo65io^0(68(0360b 5o(6o)b 36o) b b 3 6 6(667)3(60 5'^7]330)3?>o60), 017) 6(66 bo36(6(05100!!
506365ii^'36 b637](06(6 dB3503636(06R 5^16363*30(63600).
b ^ d 8 0 b V , b ( 6 8 n 0 6 . b BC OaObOOb VOB^'aO
66. 6-686 b35ïo37]Ro8 3ooBobo6b 1992 \/5ii;ob 28 C 7333863(6b Bo36(6o)6. 050 6000506 3(oR33R(3oob
B3-3 37)b5onob6 506 83-6 87)b5ii;ol! I-5170 37)Rj5ob 57■^'^^5^;3330b oi60)66l)3.
72
„^633(S65o". 8(063(600668 65706(66, (6018 b636(6oo65io^oc63(036o 835obB3565o b665(685ioo3o
0300 3f^633R30ob 83-6 87)b^*o!! I-5170 37)Rj5^^^ oo365ii;b6l)(6oboo7.
69. 56R8(3b6503635i786 bo)bo)36 b6b636(6oi5i7i(ob 3(06336(300!! B3-3 87)b5ioob6 576 B3-6 37)b5Hoo!i
1-5170 37)6j5o!i 5i?'^^57BBBB*^'^'^ ^'^i^bB^''^ ^'■^ b686(6o)5i7()66() 5763863(07305173606 8060^^366 41-
3 37)b5i7o!! 733b6668ob65o.
b5a6(6a)^Kjo
70. 5668(3b6503635ii;n 600)506, (600B 8015170306*30 365o8(6(o6oli6b Bob 8o36(6(o 566b01 (63035173-
67)5^786 8(083(607606 830000503686, 566680(60766 3c^633B3ooli 83-3 87)b5ioob 57^">(^5;^BBB'^- ^^
B7)b5ioob (06B6b865o,
73
Tomasi V.France (56663665110 ^^2850/87,1990 ^57?oli 13 B6(65ob 56506^; 33350511^» ;)66, DR 64,53.
128) 506 Ringeisen V. Austria (1971 ^5ioob 16 o35ii^iobob 56666360,63(606 6, N^ 13),(6(0851736*803
806637)57:1 oj66, (6oo3 '80506 b6b35018^0730036(6030 66*37)651736360!! 6(0517(0 b67)3b7)(6o 68(0o^7)(66
5666(3b65oob *83566ob 73385035 365ii^'333, 865(^68 3oiBobo6b 7)6576 5^^57^^B^BB"Ô'^^ 57'^'rJBB^^^Si?'^'^^"^
663oo)bo. 30)Bolio63 6(66 86(^5*^ '^^ ^^^"38*^ (O63obo 8(63(33503657)5^70 11686(60)65010, 6(668350
7)Ç3(6(o 8 3 5 0 3 , Mitap and Mhfthoplu-oh 66^83 3b36(05oo !i6B6(6oo65i7^6(68oo36ob
b665(685ioo3(o66b 570 6(66 83-3 87)b5ioob 11636(667)500) 57-^f^57333-'^6.
73. 30i3obo63 5066505066, (6008 6-686 6351737)608 7336b(67)5ioo 3(^63363006 35-3 87)b5ioob
8o700b0736360. 8obo33 00^8000, 56R83b650365170b 3530336360b b3(6oooli7)517016ob6 570
û36J5*^^^'^B" 56(638oi3636o506R 56b7)52oo 5o(6ooob b665(685ioo30o6ob 560)365o;>ob^o636ooo,
b35ii;o67)73517366b 6(6 807)5700 3335176 3o)l3o5o7)(6o 50(oRob8o366 5630080360b 50(6077)510050
5D6b(67)5io36ob BolïBoo).
74
56666360, b;)(6o6 6,1^^24,53. 22,3';')6^']5o 48,506 Akdivar and Others-oh !i6J83l)3 568(^5^"^^*^^'*"'
56B663B0, 53. 1210, 87)6^50 65). 68536(6650, 666036(60 b6!!686(6oo5i7oib ^066*83 '835'^6'^8503
7)6506 V'^^fï?ÔB^*' 6(61136001650 56B!i6bo5io33517050 B6oR(3, li6oi6B65oro 73o506 li6b35ii^'B\;07)(o;)6(6o3o
o)(656B(o!! ^7066*83, *3o5oo 3oBoi635o365i70)6o'3o 5065053605170 o3(0(^865107)(6o B(oo)boi3636o!i6
500 36500b '33!!6668ob65o (ob. b6;|83l73 Cardotv. France 199! ^5100!! 19 86(65!^ 568005-^6057;o
56666360, 63(606 6, N^200, 53. 18, 3^;36,']5o 34).
75
(ob. lj33(obb3R367)jii^'o VanOosterwiJck-oh 116^83173 56B0156R05100 5-^6^^6360,53. 17-18,87)6^50
35). 3b Ro'3B63b 086b, inter alia, (6(o8 !i6b686(6oo5i7oiB (6365i7';^(6o '33736b366 7)6506 Bob33b
6(60 B6(65(^ iÇ'^3B*^^* 7300(68651:07)(60 b6'37)651736360b 6(6b36(o66b '33b6663obo 63517'83833(635170
66 b35ii^» 3^0730) b b6B6(6 (051736(6 03 bob53B6'3o, 0(608350 1103(6(000 b636(6 0051736(6 03 500
3(05i;>o5o37)(6 3c^653jb5b, 116570(3 oboRo 3(0JB35O36b, ob333 (601501(63 56RB3b650365i7>36ob
80(6(0367)5^7 85050786(63(0666 (ob. l)3B(ob!!3R367)5ioo Akdivar and Others-oh hc:>^(^i]%[\
568(o5'^Ro5i7'o 56R66360, 53. 1211, 37)6,'](5o 69).
76
7 035x7^^^"' b3(6o6 6, N2I6I, 53. 34-35, 87)6^(50 88). !!6b636(6o)5i70) 8006633b, (601B 6-6 6351787)606
8(530336360, (601357:13603, (6(050)(6(3 I16B350030600 (36(^163605066 6666, b357:;o!!7)035i736ob6o)3ob
(36006057^10 0301, 567)016666(6506 506!>667)oo367)5io 1166036(611, 0301 56Rb637)(r)(636o(o 113(60001)7)511^*0,
(6(0501(63 11636(667)5000 736^53^^'-''^' "^^3 '33!i6668o!io 30(636011 b5'^5'i!)^^*"'"^^ 8086(6(03600).
83. 30o3oboo8 6000305170, (6008 bo835oo(3oRoi 360)6360 500 5:7'^b33636o, '335053605100 6(67)5170650
5068077)30503635170 b6335D03o6oo 3(66^'J5o3oob36ob 303(6, 807)0000036506 57v^(^53*^B^^^3 S?*^ ^'^*^'
065361107) (6 0066113.
r
84. 60503(657:^16650360!! 80)63(60066 (06306 3oB(obo5io3o'3o 5063(066bB6 3(oBoboo!i 803(6 7)6;](53?)ob
6R65i7ol)b.
77
85. 651753'^^'^0*^73^''^^^' b66o3(^)ob 6(61136001 866(^)311(066 8086(600360(0, 11673(66653010!!
8(063(601668 3o3(obo5i736'3o 65760*866, (6(o8 '^3(6 305033 0(6 0307 5o8(o5''^6o5i:!^io bo6(05i7(0(o
^'^^^iB^'^^'B^'^ 11036(667)500) b636(60)6517500(650333360b ooo(o66*^b3, bo)5ioo) 3015170(300!!
8(ob35i7336o b6(65365io(o65o63B 7)50666*36'y5i7(o6o!! 3(631)7)87)3000) 3**^63363006 83-6 B7)b5iooli
I-51710 8736^50!* '33b666Bo!i65o.
78
80(633511.' (005*30, l!olio36(6(05i7(^j 3(o8oboo!!6566 566bb36336o(o, 8006633!!, (6ooB b6^o(6oo6
566B6(653?>ob 5'^33oi3?>6 6-B 11351787)60!! 5'-'^63b65o36361)3, (6(08517360(3 6683500(306(0
5ool!336;)6oo7 0(6 8ôB^3^B^'-"^- *^9 (03057:1 bol)(6oboo), b6b636(6o)5io(»7 65760*86636, (6(o8 8(063(600668
8o8(obo5io3o'3o, 3(06(3365^60(6367)51700 (66 56R63b65oob 506*333665001661)3, ^6(68016505066
6(657)33653?>o 73*^dÔB^^^^ 113(6007177)517(^60b6 506 oB 5l)36o!i- 65i753(^R^^5*^'c]^'^^' <^*''>5*'^(^3
7JR500 Boob503b Bo(oo 351761107)036(306 3*'j6336(3oob B3-3 B7)b5ioo!i *33b666Bob65o. bb36367j5io
BoBo)6051730*30 80003(6(066 b65oo3(05o b5705oo b636(667)50(6 5061706636360b boB8o83!i 3J0B
56(663(606 83(0(63 5oo!!335obo (ob. ^7060850366(63 56R663R0, 87)6^50 31) 506 o)36m^'ob
^^"^BC^^'^f^^^^Ô"^*' Bd*^^ ?)06(65oob, 506b336o!i (ob. ^066357366(63 56666360b 87)6^50 46) 37)oiboo).
68536(0650, 8o7)b35oo305o oB 6(657)3365630ob6, (60183511^-0(3 68530(3366 b6VoR665o35o3507!i,
30063(60166!! 6(63 3(6(ob35ii; 6(6 5'^7)8f6oi53!i5B^'^'^ !!b36 7)6^53^0, (6008510361163 <^8530336b
6-Ro b;)5io87)Ro. b611686(600510fo b7)6bo5oo(67)5i7io Boib6l)(636ob b6booo 6576073663b, (6ro3 3!!
'ô'^dÔB^'^ 5^?*^5703^0510650 6600365100 (600500(63 bobb5i7oli b636(6o')5ioob b6b6B6(6(05ioro8, 56(6576
567)365o7)(636ob6 506 8b35733517(r>6ob 506^33000360!! 8530336ob6 (ob. ^066850366(63 56666360b
37)6j')53?>o 59-61), ob3 33(6b65ioob b66335i763ooo b6b686(600517(08, 56(6506 b3Jb7)65i77)(6o
805170500060bo (ob. ^060850366(63 50666360I) 87)6^50 65).
90. 007)836, b6!i636(60051000 3oo6R33b, (600B 6-R b35ii;B7)6ob 567)365o7)(636ob 736^5^ -^^
576853033^)7)5176, (665056R63 6(66510510366 86R b63360O5D 5306R 56633006, (6008 b6B35oo3oR(o
^08^(38^ c3f?8*^*^^* '338511;3600506 Bobo 57*^85303366 6R 7)6(6300736 (ob. ^'oR6850366(63 56R663Rob
37)Rj5o 54). 6b333, b6835oo3oRoo 5oob33Rob b0737)833511*1)3 0(6 5065050R506 80113170)6(6030
363*80(60 56R3(3b650365ioob b636(667]5ooo Bb35o33517(T)60b 5O6J33000366b6 506 o3 8oo35i73B36b
'3oo(^ob, (60085173603 8oob506 3005100306*30 365o3(6oo6ob6b (ob. ^066350366(63 56666360b
.IgG^-Jôo 46).
79
92. 3(^i8o!io68 660)36511^16, (6008 566B(3b6503635i736 506(653836ob '835035650 80051101 5061106636360,
05(630733 5660(36506 73ol)037)(6o 500 67)51003(60 5 B ' ^ B " ! ^ ^ - ^"^ !i357^iB7)Bob o^b(6oo), 3b 80033(6(060
65006(6360116 (07) 0603(0(686300!! 8050360!! 8ol)Boo7 56Bl)(66b 5666(0(6(303517506. 3078oboo!i
'33b35o7)5173600), 68536(60 8(083(6(066, 56Bboi(63035i736';35i7o b6b35io8^07)00b 3(6010 017) 8 3 5 0
3(ob35i7ob 803(6 500 57*^35303367)^10 b6835oo(3oBoo (36(06360(0, 03(0 01130)0 b3(6o(ol)7]5i70 576
b 6 b 5 o 3 0 b6bo6oioli, (600B 7)6576 33^511.*073030(6367)511^10301 ^6836650, b b 3 6 b686(6oo65io-
506(65033336ob, 33(68(050, 567)365o7)(636ob 7)3b6b36, (6(08351^11)33 807)010(036576 5663b6503635ioo,
6li(6o!! 568oooojBob 67)30517136517(060b 5'^f^3'33.
80
03Rolib, -^8536(6033 56Bbb363366b 633073611, (663 568(o85oo66(63oo6b I-5100 506 83-I6
87)b5i736o50 66:
S^tjrno 1
81
100. 663653^^(^'"^S^* *^*^8 3o^>,']36oi, \?066850366(63 b6jB373o 7)6506 50650506503!!: 6-R !!350i87)6ob6o>3oli
80336367)51^10 „5B*^B"^''^ "^^ Ô^^^^B*^" '*^B"85il'3f^6 (o*;;) 6(66 5660661)503(60)!! (6(05(^0(63 „!i665o3(^*'
563(6006 3(06336(30011 I-5170 B7)b5i7ob 860*3363511^1(060660)3011. b6b686(6o)5ii;ioi 80066336, (6(o8
61136367)51^10 „bo66!!5o33", 86563b65o „8o6o365i77)(6o !!ob6b5o3o!i6", ''^7)305i73à35i;io6 83-3
37)b5ii^»ob 568(033636o!i6(o3ob 116563606 *^r33736(65036o(oo b6bo6(ool! 5600365i7ob^o636oo); 3b
576801305036';;)51706 b6j8ob ;j3357;6 56(638(0366113, (6(0501(60(366 B(o33(6(o6ob 6665(6857^1030066,
8060 o)ol)037|(6o 576 !i7j57^»o3(6o '335035360, 1)00503(6(0 *333oob3336*8o 506116(66510367)511^10!!
b^']3bo, 66630, ^668(6(0351^1(0606 85050086(6;)oo66 576 6. '3.
101. 666686(6005010)8 650(63 566b057^17)517 Boi35i^> (605 116^83367)0 500063360, (6018 6505051710
,^^')(o6506 80)33(60166!!, (60)835010(3 *33o85i73607500 8boi5oi(057 ^6836650 3365iooç3030(6367)5ii^'03(o
(ob. li38oobb3B367)5i^i Aksoy-oh 1^6^831)3 5680)5-^6057^10 566663B0, 53. 2279, 37jBJ5*^ ^^4, 576
Aydsn-oh b6j33l)3 568(05-^6051^10 56R66360, 53. 1891-92, 3';')6j5B^" 83-84 570 86). 0)7)8(30, o8
'<3'^dÔ*^^ 500030511^106^063600), (6(oB 30R336300 ,,3(03605100 57(^37)836506, (6(08517011
053(^8(6356306 7)6506 B(ob5D3b 5:o5733'^R5i?35li'o 56(638(036360!! 37)oibooi" (ob. interalia, '83850350
5066636360: !!6;]83l)3 Tyrer V. the United Kingdom, 197H ^"51006 25 68(6051:^10, b3(6o6 6, 1^^26,53.
15-16,37)6^')5o 31; Soering-oh 66^83113,53. 40,37)BJ5o 102; 5^6 b6J83l)3 Loizidouv Turkey,\995
^5i;iob 23 86(65011 56B6B3B0, 63(606 6, 1^^310, 53. 26-27, '^7)Rdô^ ^^)' 666686(60057;00 30066336,
(6(o3 5^''(^B3B*(]^*^ d8B5Ç*'^<*'B«^o, (60185173603 ^o(6li7)52:^1*80 33-^517003030(6367)511^10 0300
„6(666506Bo6R7)(6 506 50636830(636352^1 30033(6016650" ,,^68360!)" b6^oR665o35O35005D, '8308510366
8(oB6365i:!_i'3o bb36536(^65o oj63b 33-^5170730(30(6367)5170. Ii6b636(6oi5i70o 08 6l)(6b 630oo6(636b,
(6(o3 6foo8o66ob 7)7)5i73?)6oo6 506 80(60(0650 0063067)03517366010 57'^33ob 117^3(600*30 -^7)30517363511;o,
860*83635170136650 865065170 b56R506(65ob 6(66360166 733b6663ob65o 8oioaiboo3b 7)03(600 57050
bo836(63b 5038003(^6507)51;'o 1161100565000360b 737)R50633657)(6o 570(6367)51:^1363606 57'^f^57B333?>ob
'33736b36ob6b.
82
105. 8(033871517*' 5'^*^B8*''^B^B^*'^'^^ 5680)850066(63, b6b636(601517(0 Boo6R33b, (6oo3 5668366-
50365100!) ^'06665085035 566b(0(63O3f7i367)5iî^i86 O3ol)037)(636 570 b7)5ioo3(6B6 86517050^0668, (60(3
5oRbo5io7)51700 800517ooRoo66'3o, B6!i „l!6b(^o3o" 5 B " B * ' ^ ' * ^ f?*-^ Ô'^^'^B'-'^ 80633B6, (6(0835^:^10(3
50611637)01(6367)510050 li3(6o(ol>7)5ii;o 500 bob5o3o 030). 08530(60 JB3500160 7)65^0 660(036517001!
\76836650 3(06336(300!! 83-3 87jb5i7ob 3ol7B36ol!60)3o!!.
„1. !!68oiJ65ii^'6joo 7)7)5173^6006 500 800305103(066006 ... 56Rb6l)503(6ob6b, 33357^^"^b 6J3b 7)735173^'^
... b6b636(6o)5io(ob 803(6 5oiRo3(67)5io 36506*30 ... B(ob83R6li3".
6. 56Rb6bo5iii335ioo 83(600)500
109. 00630b 8b(6o3, 80063(60066 807)010(036!!, (6008 li686(6o)6£i^i'y6(6Boo366 5060^3(0 1993 ^517011
15 86(65b, (6o7503!i63 bobb5i7oli b686(6(n5ioob !i66o36(6o 570 56R3b650366 b636(6(y)65io\?o(68(o-
366*30 b68co^65i76j(0 8b6(635o 66(6(03ob '33b6b36 *83566o5i7 0J66 568(08803635170 3(oli6-
36(6o)5ii;ob \7oR6'^83.
110. 3078obo68 6600365176, (60)8 11686(6(06517^76(68(0366 6(6 57-^^'33^7)517--^ 1993 'y5i7ob 15 86(65^^8503,
(6oo503b63 (635ob5^'-^306*3o 565-^(^57*^ 5-^R83b650365ioo!i 1166036(60.
114. 80163C 600663 65060*866, (6(o3 b6J83 oi63oboi6365o 6(6 03(0 56Bb637)oo(6367)5i7o bo(6o77)5ioob
b636(6(o5i736(6o3o oo365ii^»b6li(6obooi, 865(668 TJ-^dÔB*^"'^ 86517066 !i3(6oo7l)7)5ioo b6bo6ooo 570
6(6057:150367)5100 3o(636ob b5-^5L]^'*' 686(60)51736500 b636(6o)65i7Ç'6(68oi36ob b33(3065ii;7)r6o
5l)ooo ^6(686(6(r)36b, (66863 8obo 56b6B5(685i:^'03366 566680(60066. ^7*066850366(63 66^83*30
67)3051:^13657^1650 0J66 306637)5010 6(686R36ob 805:7366 !!6j8ob bb36 b6b6B6(6o)5i707b6003ob
5650633806 oo60o66l}3 „86(6oo5o>3b62^7)5l736ob 5^3(6003660 566boo(6303517360b00030b" b35oi3ooo3ob
5or63'33 (ob. bojB3l)3 Boddaert v. Belgium 1992 Ç'5oiob 12 oij5ooB63(6b 563oo56Rop7;o 56B6B3B0,
b3(6o6 6, N2235-50). (^63 '333b366 56fi83b650365i^iob b6,'J3035iob, 30)63(6(060 3(o6Rb3366 3oo8obo6b,
(6(o8 Bob !i-^d3*^'B^^^ •^'^ c!)'^8oi7)^^33306 b686(6oo657iÇ6(63oo36ob 56b665(685i703366.
84
o3 50(6(0!), (6o7503b6(3 b6^^B3 566obo5i736(0506 bb365oobb3o !!ob6B6(6oo57;(ob ^ o 6 6 ' 3 3 ,
b3g;iob7)735io366 57)51730150506350 0^(3301506. 1994 ^511^-06 22 o3Robob 73385035, (6(05O3b6(3
506o6o71R6 33(6!i65i7ob tribunal de grande instance-h''^à(]^(\()oii6;]i^o 8(ob686(6(05i73, 80063(600668
65706(66, (600B !i6j8o!! 56Rbo5i73673o 03(0 *83733(6b3636o, (66(3, Bobo toJ8o(o, 6(6 O3fo
56630(6006367)5100 8b(057i(05o 568008803635170 Booli6B6(6oo5i7ob 8ol)3l)Ooo.
115. 3oi3obo68 6600365176, (6(o3 !w^^']83 6(6 0300 566!i637)(o(6367)5ioo !io(6(o7j5ioob, 3o7)b3506365o
736J5B^O!I 3d^\^^38'^5l77)(^65o b3(600)1)7)510 0 b6lio6oiob6 506 b66oi511^1 (0(050 6(6651750367)5170
3o(636ob !!5--^57J^**^^*'^' BB^*^*^"^^' '^('^5i703oob 3(ob35i7336b 6(665170 357360)50600 !!636(6o765i7506(6-
i^MBBB^*^^^ 6650360*80 00630660)0 li68b6b7)(636(6o3o 8(0365i73oo636ob '33l!(67)5ii;36ob 5o(6(ob.
( 6 6 3 '333b366 b6b6B6(6o)5i70i b35ioob7)03517360b b6^']3035i7b, 3(o8obo63 65(630033 8oo66o6,
(6008 b 6 j 3 3 bb36506bb36536(665o boo(6303517503600576 566b6bo5ii^'335i7o 33(6o(05oob 56R863-
5l7(o66'3o. 3(6(00 3b(^03, 050 due diligence-ocn ^*6(6o86(6o)6 1994 ^ ç ^ o b 22 O3RO!I685D3, (6oo503b63
506oBo'3B6 33(6b65i7ob tribunal de grande instance-oh 568013803635170 8oob686(6(05i73, boo5i7oo,
8300(63 8b(6o3, 6(6b36oo6506 ■^5f^3œ33 83(0(63 33(60005003, (6oo3357;o3 33oob3336 33(6b65i7ob
568073803635170 8oo!!6B6(6oi5ioob 803(6 5680080360b ^6(6Boo366b, (6oo857;ob 5o(6o)b63, b35i7ob-
7)735103668 6(6 8005701 3335176 3ool7o5o7)(6o 570060680366 506 6(6 5680063517066 necessary
diligence, 560036517ob'ç06367)5170 7)6506 3007305100301 (66 6(6657;51036360b b3(6001117)5170 b6bo6oio
5D6 50(600, (6008351003 5630506 l)38oobb3B367)5ioo 8003517363605066.
85
118. Bob !'t35i7'oi 6(6b367)5i7o 3335ii,'6 85o3367)5ii^»36oli Bb350335i7(o66'3o 8050360(0, b6b636(6o)5i7(o
650536!!, (6o)8 B3-6 37)b5o;oli I-51710 37)Rj(^o(o 560)365i7ob\/oB36';35il^'o '5(oRo3(6'y5i7o 36506" 03(0
50500^0(663673 tT^'o.
„o)7) b6!i636(6(n5ioo7 5O665053Rb, (oooB 5060(65736 306336(^06 570 Bobo o),'|836o 506 (07) '33!i6663o!io
8o5oom^>o 635111*83833(635170 Bbo(6ob "30500 Ii6b35ii^'3^'oo)(036(6030 !i6B6(6(065ioo o857^'336 l)066ob
8boo5i7(05o 66\7 05iofo6(6o3o 666li5067)(636ob "33b6851^13657;0066b, b6b686(6o)5iofo, b6jo(6o)36oli
'333o)b3336'3o, 506l)6(665i7367)57;> 8b6(63b 660^36!! b686(607517066 5O63B63(07305i7366b".
6. l ) 0 6 6 o
86
6. oobo)3R-^ R0503(65106R5036*80 565063330b o)6oo66l)3
126. b6b6B6(6(r)5i:^Mo 3351763 6576o73R63b, (6(o3 4I-3 87)b5ioo 6(6 -^85io33b O7)f6o!i5oo^')(306li,
Boo50fob 6(6866366 63517*33833(635170 li6b35i78^o7)(o!! V*^^'^'^S^^^^B(5 (8--"5565i^ooo65o, ob. mutatis
mutandis, h.^l\c\i]%i] Saïdi v. France 1993 ^5ioo!i 20 !i3dÔB*^^B*^^^ 56Boo5'-^605170 56666360,63(606
6, N^261-5, 53. 57, 37)6j']5o 47 570 l}38oibb3R367)5i7o Remli-h 1^6^831)3 568(o5'^Ro5i7o 56666360,
53. 575, 53. 54).
127. 5-^R83b6503635ioo, dB*^*"^3^^B 57-^3(^57R('^?>ooo, 8oioooboi3b 203 814 73(6663!! Bob b6(6^36b6
506 ^6(68oo86505365iooi6ob6oo3ob 56^^37)517 506B6b6(62^36oo6B 8036(600360(0. 366 (066b6 '83850350
li6booo 56666^*05176: 90 450 ç3(6oR3o 33(6bo5ï7ob b6b686(6oo5i7oo36oboi3ob, boo5i!^io) 113 364
73(66R3o 3(^R3863oob oRbo57)(^3àob ^'066*83 b686(6oo657;^6(68oi36o!!6073ob, 08 00666361)3
66357^1360, (663 30)3obo68 506 !!6b686(6{05ii;(o8 8o6Ro^6 b636(6o)5i736(6o3o 506b36(636ob b6bo(o.
50. b67)(^63o
132. 56R83b650363ji7B6 807)010(06, (6078 B6b b6663(o 5^6(6080!! l!6boo) 0101(68350 8o5i70(oRo
73(66657)^10 73(^)66306 565D6b5oo 576B8'^EL''^ 3(6(0(0650)03050 500 36517-3651733 8601 ^06665785035
8086(6017)517 b636(6oo65i7^6(63o7366'3o bb36 8b*^^63(650367)511^' 80(636(066 3(600650. '33b6668o!i65o,
566B3b6503635ii^'86 !!O)b(036 b6b6B6(6(05i7(o!i, 5666636*80 57-^33''^63^^358^*^^'"^' (6(o8 4I-3 37)b5ioob
b6037)8335ii^'l)3 8060=^367)5170 (06666 56(0630117)7)501367)51710301 56506b6b65oo!i656B.
87
'837)6666807 oj63?)005O6 5663(3b65036517066(030b 3(oB336!!630ob 8060^366, inter alia,
6(66!i60)66650(0 80733(6(06066(030!!, (600835100(3 ^6(68(0650536b 3('^R83630ob 83-3 B7)b57;ob
fÇ'^*^''i<'3BB*^**' ^^'à^"^'i]^Pil]^ b6(6^36ob6 57.-^ ô^'^'vB'^lS^'*' 5oo6obo(6'^,36ob 7)l)(67)633enb63oio365o, (^7)
li6b35i7B\707)(o 0130(0(06 \7'6(6B(065053R5o-6 (6(05(0(63 5o36o5('^f^!i, 0113 3(635Do5('i(^b 63 oo66bob
Bo36(6o). (07)336 bb36367)5i7o oo6Bb36o 3(60)366301066566 56Rl!b3635036oo506, 66b636(60051^1(0
Boo6R33!i, (6o)3 6(668653(^0657^'7)(60 lio66ob 6R6li5oo7)(636ob 8ol)oRo 570 4I-3 B7)b5i7ob bo!!(^386
56(65fi7)365i;i65o 0J6366 b35i;>3(073O5i7»o, 007) 6630)0 11057)6(306 57-^8530350366. (07)336,
b6!!686(6o)5i7oob 6(66 6j3b o7)(6ob5ooj(306, 50630)66b3(o!! 63536(^ (y)boo366b (ob. inter alia,
b6j83l73 Philisv. Greece 1991 \/5i7ob 27 653o!i5('^!i 563(0(^6Bo5ii;o 56B663Bo,b3(6o6 6, N?209,
53. 27,37)6^']5o 79; 116^831)3 Allenet de Ribemont v. France 1996. \7 5ii^>ob 7 •^53ob5('ib 56800(^6605100
56R6B3R(i, Srohb^F^jd^do 1996-III, 53. 910, 87)fij5B<^o 18-19). 685036657, 3b b63ooobo 7)6576
ô'^^^^'^BOB^ b673(66R53(oob b35ioob7)7351;'3^*0b 57"^M*^BG*^^^^*-
Sî^TlGOTJb 80K?^^660(60
8(631)0503650
88