Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A Forensic Evaluation of Impalement Injuries - Medicine, Science and The Law by Byard, Roger W (2018)
A Forensic Evaluation of Impalement Injuries - Medicine, Science and The Law by Byard, Roger W (2018)
Roger W Byard1,2
Abstract
Impalement injuries transfix a victim in an inescapable or helpless position. A study was undertaken at Forensic Science
SA from 2002 to 2016 of all impalement deaths. There were six vehicle accidents (M:F¼5:1; age 14–67 years, average age
38.5 years) involving impalements with a tree branch (n¼2; groin and chest), a metal pipe (n¼2; leg and head), a metal
bridge railing (groin) and a metal fence post (chest). Two cases (both males, aged 47 and 18 years) had slipped on fences/
gates, with impalements of the ankle and groin. A case of suicide (male, aged 80 years) was impaled through the head on
a bolt fixed to the floor. A homicide case (male, aged 27 years) involved impalement through the chest by a spear from a
spear gun. In certain cases (e.g. with anogenital injuries), differentiating accidental from inflicted impalement injuries may
be difficult. In equivocal cases, adequate scene evaluations with photographic documentation are required prior to
autopsy, ideally with the object available for examination.
Keywords
Impalement, vehicle crash, industrial, sexual, autoerotic, child abuse
Introduction
that is, to impale is to ‘fix in an inescapable or helpless
Deaths due to impalement are rarely encountered in position’.1 This would be in keeping with the earliest
most medico-legal practices. To determine the range records of impalement which described the torture of
of injuries and situations that may result in lethal or captives by skewering their bodies on pointed stakes
near-lethal impalement, the literature was reviewed. (Figure 1).3,4
Although most reported cases have been associated Thus, although it can be said that ‘impalement is the
with survival after surgical correction, they have been penetration of an organism by an object such as a
included in this review, as most were potentially lethal, stake, pole, spear or hook, by complete perforation
and they also serve to demonstrate the range of injuries of the central body mass’,5 transfixion and immobilisa-
that may be encountered. In addition, a search of the tion are also important components. Clinical defini-
files at Forensic Science SA (FSSA), Adelaide, tions have ranged from transfixing a body cavity or
Australia, over a 15-year period was also conducted extremity by a rigid object of variable size,6 to having
for specific cases where deaths had been attributed to a foreign body penetrate and embed in a body part
impalement. with the object still remaining in the wound,7 to
being suspended by the impaling object.8 Although
Definitions some definitions specify that impalement must only
involve the torso, well-documented cases have been
One of the difficulties that arises with diagnosing
impalement deaths is in trying to determine to what
exactly ‘impalement’ refers. For example, a number
of definitions consider that to impale is merely to 1
Forensic Science SA, Australia
pierce with something pointed.1 This of course would 2
School of Medicine, The University of Adelaide, Australia
include very superficial knife or needle wounds which
are certainly not usually considered impalements in Corresponding author:
Roger W. Byard, Discipline of Anatomy and Pathology, Level 3, Medical
forensic settings. Others use terminology that better School North Building, The University of Adelaide, Frome Road,
fits with historical records and contemporary practice Adelaide, 5005, SA, Australia.
by requiring that a sharp object transfixes the victim,2 Email: roger.byard@sa.gov.au
2 Medicine, Science and the Law 0(0)
Results
Ten cases were identified involving six vehicle acci-
dents, two falls on fences, one suicide and one
homicide.
The six vehicle accident cases were between 14 and
67 years of age (average age ¼ 38.5 years). In four
cases, the decedent was the driver of a vehicle, one
was a pedestrian and one was the rider of a motorcycle.
Deaths were due to multiple injuries in three cases,
chest impalement in two cases and head impalement
in one case. Impalements involved a metal pipe from Figure 3. An X-ray of the case shown in Figure 2,
an oncoming truck in the right leg (driver in car; demonstrating the depth of penetration into the left thigh.
Byard 3
Discussion
The majority of impalement injuries in civilian practice
result from vehicle crashes or accidents at construction
sites. Three general categories have been proposed to
include those associated with (1) vehicle collisions, (2)
sexually motivated activities in the anogenital region
and (3) falls.13 An alternate classification proposes Figure 5. The spear shaft in Figure 4 grooved the under surface
type 1 injuries where a body impacts with a stationary of the spleen (a) (arrow) and then penetrated the colon,
pancreas, aorta, liver, diaphragm and right lung before the tip
object, such as a fall at a building site or ejection from embedded in the intercostal muscles of the right chest wall (b)
a vehicle, and type 2 when a moving object penetrates a (arrow).
stationary body, when, for example, an object intrudes
into a vehicle cabin.14 Both of these types were present
in the current series. The resultant injuries may Survival has been documented after quite major
have elements of both blunt and sharp force trauma impalement injuries. An important part of treatment
with considerable tissue destruction as well as organ at the scene is not to remove the penetrating object,
penetration.6
as this may result in catastrophic haemorrhage.
This was documented by Bill in 1862 when he noted
that arrows should be left in situ, as they tended to
tamponade vascular injuries by plugging wounds.15,16
For this reason, it is standard medical practice to cut
off excessive lengths of the intruding object to facilitate
transfer to hospital in those who have survived the
event, while leaving the impacted part in situ.6
Another of the problems with impalement by large
foreign objects is that they may carry fragments of
clothing, organic material and soil into the depths of
wounds (Figure 6), thus exacerbating the risk of serious
infection from contaminated material in survivors.13,17
With lethal cases, the penetrating object has often
Figure 4. The shaft of a spear protruding from the left lower been removed from the body, and so assessment of
chest wall (arrow). the nature of the injury at autopsy relies upon a clear
4 Medicine, Science and the Law 0(0)
Industrial
One of the most well-known and earliest documented
industrial impalements was that of Phineas Gage, a 25-
year-old railway foreman who had a 3 cm diameter
iron bar blown through his left frontal lobe when
explosives that he was tamping into a hole prematurely
detonated.30 Falls from platforms or ladders at con-
struction/work sites are a more common occurrence,
resulting in death or serious injuries, often from
impalement on metal concrete reinforcing rods or
steel bars.31–33 If a piece of work equipment such as a
screwdriver has been landed on during a fall, it is pos-
Figure 7. Although there was no impaling object present at sible that this may have been tidied up by co-workers
autopsy, scene photographs clearly show the impacted vehicle
against a tree with broken lower branches, one of which had
who may not recognise the significance of the object for
impaled the driver’s chest. determining the cause of a penetrating injury.34
bladder, mesentery and omentum.38,39 Homicides with device to impale the head under a weight. The latter
impalement may also have a sexual focus. reflects a high degree of premeditation.12 Whether sui-
cidal insertion of a chopstick into the bladder through
Homicides the penis represents impalement or penetration with
perforation is arguable.50
Sexual attacks have included cases with impalements to
the perineum utilising objects such as sharp sticks or
billiard cues that have caused lethal or potentially
Non-industrial accidents
lethal abdominal and thoracic injuries.40,41 Insertion Impalement injuries may also occur in individuals who
of a segment of metal pipe into the rectum which may have jumped from a height such as from a burning
passed through the intestine and lodged in the right building, or fallen from a building, and landed on
kidney in a 21-year-old man caused death in combina- objects such as tree branches.17 This is not only an
tion with ligature strangulation.42 Objects such as issue for humans, as there is a ‘high rise’ syndrome
broom or mop handles may be forcefully inserted used to describe injuries sustained by animals who
into victims’ rectums; such a case involved a 39-year- fall or jump from a height of two stories or more.
old man who survived injuries to his rectum, dome of Three cats have been reported with impalement injuries
the bladder, mesentery, liver and right lung.41 to the chest and abdomen following falls onto spiked
Other types of assaults resulting in impalements metal railings.51 Impalements may occur during sport
involve a wide range of weapons including spears and if a competitor is hit by a javelin, or in an individual
arrows, as was demonstrated in a case from the FSSA who has jumped over tubular metal crossbars.52
files of the 27-year-old male who was shot through the Skateboarding at speed may also be associated with
chest with a spear gun. Spears and arrows are, howev- scroto-abdominal impalement.53
er, very rare weapons of assault in Western countries, Other situations where impalements may occur are
being found more often in traditional tribal communi- in slipping while crossing over gates or fences, both
ties.43 When they are utilised, mechanisms may involve potential causes of vascular, bladder or organ inju-
incised/stab wounds from the sharpened spear/arrow- ries.54–56 Falls onto stakes holding up potted plants
heads, rather than deep impalement.7,44 On occasion, and onto broken chairs or chair legs have also resulted
an object such as a curtain rod may be thrown as a in craniofacial and abdominal impalements.57,58
spear and cause lethal head impalement.45
Sharp garden implements such as rakes have been Miscellaneous
embedded in victim’s faces.46 A blunt object being used Impalement may be a feature of animal attacks. For
to beat a victim may also then be used to impale him or example, the typical goring injury inflicted by large
her if it breaks during the assault. Such was the case of horned animals such as water buffalo and bulls may
an assault with a golf club which broke, resulting in the involve transfixion of the limbs, inguinal and perineal
shaft being used to impale the face and neck.47 regions, often with damage to the femoral vessels.59 In
aquatic environments, needlefish are long slender fish
Suicides with elongated pointed jaws that have caused severe
Suicides do not often involve impalement unless this penetrating injuries of the limbs, head and neck, abdo-
has occurred inadvertently following a jump from a men and chest, which have been rarely associated with
height. However, even when present, impalement may death.60 Puncturing of the chest by a stingray spine
be unrelated to the lethal mechanism. An example of may be lethal. However, it is more of a penetrating
this was a 51-year-old man found hanging in a psychi- than an impaling injury, although spines may reach
atric facility. Although a broom handle that he had up to 37 cm in length.61,62
inserted into his rectum prior to death had passed An unusual case of chronic impalement with a knit-
ting needle has been reported in a 72-year-old woman
into the peritoneal cavity, the absence of significant
who had used the needle 33 years earlier to induce
haemorrhage or organ damage excluded this as a con-
an abortion. The 18 cm long metal needle had
tributor to the lethal episode.48 A similar case involved
migrated to cause a thoracoabdominal transdiaphrag-
a 29-year-old man who was excluded from the present
matic fistula.63
study who died of accidental hanging during autoerotic
activity. He also had a broom handle which had perfo-
rated his rectum, but that was not associated with any Issues with children
significant haemorrhage. Children are at a higher risk of certain types of impale-
Rarely suicides may involve firing crossbow bolts ment injuries that are not usually found in adults.
into the head,49 or more elaborate construction of a Specifically, impalement of the soft palate and
6 Medicine, Science and the Law 0(0)
fractured humerus after blunt trauma. Ann Thorac Surg 41. Boyd JS. Impalement injuries of the rectum. Ulst Med J
2008;86:1029. 1955;24:123–128.
22. Wrightson WR, Conn CA and Franklin GA. Cardiac 42. Ho LC, El Shafei H, Barr J, et al. Rectal impalement
impalement from a rib after blunt trauma Am Surg injury through the pelvis, abdomen and thorax. Ann R
2007;73:485–487. Coll Surg Engl 2012;94:e201–e203.
23. Patetsios P, Priovolos S, Slesinger TL, et al. Lacerations 43. Omond KJ, Charlwood C and Byard RW. Customary
of the left ventricle from rib fractures after blunt trauma. law, traditional punishment and death in the Anangu
J Trauma 2000;49:771–773. Pitjantjatjara Yankunytjatjara (APY) Lands of Central
24. Olds K, Byard RW and Langlois NEI. Injuries associated Australia. Forensic Sci Med Pathol 2016;12:527–529.
with resuscitation – an overview. J Forensic Leg Med 44. Ugwu BT, Yiltok SJ, Dakum NK, et al. An unusual chest
2015;33:39–43. impalement. West Afr J Med 1998;17:55–57.
25. Doughty K, Tubbs RS, Wellons JC, et al. An unusual 45. Byard RW, Koszyca B and James R. Crossbow suicide:
case of impalement of the cranium in a child. J Trauma mechanisms of injury and neuropathologic findings. Am
2005;58:1290–1293. J Forensic Med Pathol 1999;20:347–353.
26. Ekong CEU and Gabriel YH. Unusual head trauma by a 46. Diggs CA. Suicidal transurethral perforation of the blad-
rearview mirror. J Trauma 1980;20:422–423. der. Am J Forensic Med Pathol 1986;7:169–171.
27. Papadopoulos M, McCurrach F and Carlisle I. Orbital 47. Eppley BL. Craniofacial impalement injury: a rake in the
impalement by steering wheel lock. Aust NZ J face. J Craniofac Surg 2002;13:35–37.
Ophthalmol 1994;22:278–279. 48. Torre C and Varetto L. A case of murder by impalement.
28. Nozawa H, Watanabe K, Suzuki O, et al. An unusual Z Rechtsmed 1983;91:83–84.
death due to impalement of a gear stick into the brain 49. Lauterbach A, Hausmann R and Betz P. Fatal impale-
stem through the nasal cavity: a case report. Med Sci Law ment injury of the head due to a curtain rail. Int J Leg
2005;45;176–178. Med 2006;120:380–382.
29. Yokosuka T, Kobayashi T, Fujiogi M, et al. An unusual 50. Byard RW. Causes and mechanisms of death in
case of thoracic impalement injury with severe pleural fatal water buffalo attacks. J Forensic Sci
adhesion. Gen Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 2015;63:298–301. 2017;62;934–936.
30. Evans RJ and Richmond JM. An unusual death due to 51. Clark JJ and Ho HC. Two cases of penetrating abdom-
screwdriver impalement. A case report. Am J Forensic
inal injury from needlefish impalement. J Emerg Med
Med Pathol 1996;17:70–72.
2012;43:428–430.
31. Karger B, Teige K and Bajanowski T. Bizarre impale-
52. Orr CJ, Clark MA, Hawley DA, et al. Fatal anorectal
ment fatalities – where is the implement? J Forensic Sci
injuries: a series of four cases. J Forensic Sci
2002;47:389–391.
1995;40:219–221.
32. Kennedy D, Becher R, LaFerte R, et al. Transvaginal
53. Byard RW, Eitzen DA and James R. Unusual fatal mech-
intra-abdominal impalement injury. South Med J
anisms in nonasphyxial autoerotic death. Am J Forensic
1992;85:217–218.
33. Moncure M, Konie JA, Kretzer AB, et al. Survival fol- Med Pathol 2000;21:65–68.
lowing rectal impalement through the pelvic, abdominal, 54. Watson JM and Goldstein LJ. Golf club shaft impale-
and thoracic cavities: a case report. Case Rep Med ment: case report of a zone III neck injury. J Trauma
2009;2009:361829. 1996;41:1036–1038.
34. Elam AL and Ray VG. Sexually related trauma: a review. 55. Byramji A, Gilbert JD and Byard RW. Fatal retrophar-
Ann Emerg Med 1986;15:576–584. yngeal abscess – a possible marker of inflicted injury in
35. Pratschke KM and Kirby BM. High rise syndrome with infancy and early childhood. Forensic Sci Med Pathol
impalement in three cats. J Small Anim Pract 2009;5:302–306.
2002;43:261–264. 56. Kim KT and Seo PW. A case of severe thoracoabdominal
36. Carragher AM, Sulaiman SK and Panesar KJS. Scroto- impalement by a steel bar. Kor J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg
abdominal impalement injury in a skateboard rider. 2016;49:481–484.
J Emerg Med 1990;8:419–421. 57. Kolahdouzan M, Rezaee MT and Shahabi S.
37. Kelly IP, Attwood SEA, Quilan W, et al. The manage- Impalement thoracoabdominal trauma secondary to fall-
ment of impalement injury. Injury 1995;26:191–193. ing on metallic (iron) bars: an extremely rare and unique
38. Morrow KS and Clevenger FW. Oropharyngeal case. Arch Trauma Res 2016;5:e18330.
impalement on a wrought iron fence. South Med J 58. Grossi A, Mezzacapo B, Biagi G, et al. Impalement
1993;86:1306–1309. wound of the chest. Thorax 1981;36:952–953.
39. Perdekamp MG, Weisser H-J, Pollak S, et al. Intracranial 59. Beiler HA, Zachariou Z and Daum R. Impalement and
impalement with entrance site in the mandibular region: anorectal injuries in childhood: a retrospective study of
postmortem elucidation of an accidental fall on a wooden 12 cases. J Pediatr Surg 1998;33:1287–1291.
plant stick. Forensic Sci Int 2011;209:e35–40. 60. Meyer PK. Stingray injuries. Wild Environ Med
40. G€older SK, Friess H, Shafighi M, et al. A chair leg 1997;8:24–28.
as the rare cause of a transabdominal impalement 61. Parra MW, Costantini EN, Rodas EB, et al. Surviving a
with duodenal and pancreatic involvement. J Trauma transfixing cardiac injury caused by a stingray barb.
2001;51:164–167. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 2010;139:e115–e116.
8 Medicine, Science and the Law 0(0)
62. Byard RW. Accidents. In: Sudden death in the young. 69. Younessi OJ and Alcaino EA. Impalement injuries of the
3rd ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2010, oral cavity in children: a case report and survey of the
p.58. literature. Int J Paediatr Dent 2007;17:66–71.
63. Jone JS. An unusual case of impalement injury to the 70. Uchino H, Kuriyama A, Kimura K, et al. Accidental
urinary bladder. Urology 2000;55:949. oropharyngeal impalement injury in children: a report
64. Pop M and Suciu BA. Chronic impalement – case report of two cases. J Emerg Trauma Shock 2015;18:115–118.
of a knitting needle 33 years’ ascension. J Cardiothorac 71. Grisoni ER, Hahn E, Marsh E, et al. Pediatric perineal
Surg 2016;11:112. impalement injuries. J Pediatr Surg 2000;35:702–704.
65. Hellmann JR, Shott SR and Gootee MJ. Impalement 72. Roth€amel T, Bürger D, Debertin AS, et al. Vaginorectal
injuries of the palate in children: review of 131 cases. impalement injury in a 2-year-old child – caused
Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol 1993;26:157–163. by sexual abuse or an accident? Forensic Sci Int
66. Soose RJ, Simons JP and Mandell DL. Evaluation and 2001;119:330–333.
management of pediatric oropharyngeal trauma. Arch 73. Sugar NF and Feldman KW. Perineal impalements in
Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2006;132:446–451. children. Distinguishing accident from abuse. Pediatr
67. Chauhan N, Guillemaud J and El-Hakim H. Two pat- Emerg Care 2007;23:605–616.
terns of impalement injury to the oral cavity: report of 74. Byard RW and Blumbergs P. Foreign body penetration
four cases and review of the literature. Int J Pediatr of the fontanelle – mechanisms and manner of death. Am
Otorhinolaryngol 2006;70:1479–1483. J Forensic Med Pathol 2011;32:197–199.
68. Umibe A, Omura K, Hachisu T, et al. Life-threatening 75. Napier F, Fountain-Polley S and Kallapa C. Images in
injury caused by complete impalement of a toothbrush: a paediatrics: ironing board impalement. Arch Dis Child
case report. Dent Trauma 2017;33:317–320. 2007;92:758.