Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Support: Landscape Architecture Magazine
Support: Landscape Architecture Magazine
LIFE
SUPPORT
Open space plans to revive
New York City’s public housing
YAMADA HOUSE
Preservation gaps imperil
a designer’s legacy
WELLNESS CHECK
A critical history of health
and landscape
THUNDERHEAD
Public City’s 3D printer
works overtime
Series 3 - 28 x 31 Planter, Shown in Greystone
The Beauty of Authenticity
variety of materials.
We combine the design vision and production skills of hands-on craftspeople with the
very latest in manufacturing technology to create amazing, high-quality products –
products that would have previously been unimaginable and unachievable.
We call this unique approach “Modern Craft Manufacturing,” and it’s just one of the ways
we’re setting the standard for innovation and quality in the world of outdoor design.
36
MARCH 2023
10 INSIDE
14 LETTERS
16 LAND MATTERS
118 ADVERTISER INDEX
119 ADVERTISERS BY PRODUCT CATEGORY
FOREGROUND
22 NOW Timothy A. Schuler, Editor
Urban canopies in Cambridge, Massachusetts, will need
36 PRESERVATION
Honor Roll by Timothy A. Schuler
When the influential landscape architect Joseph Yamada’s
house in San Diego went up for historic listing, everything
was there but the landscape.
95
80
NANCY OWENS STUDIO, TOP; FROUKJE RIENKS, CENTER; VICTOR GRUEN PAPERS, AMERICAN HERITAGE CENTER, UNIVERSITY OF WYOMING, BOTTOM
FEATURES
56 Bet the House by Zach Mortice
New York City’s public housing was once a visionary project
that combined architecture and landscape in humane and
practical ways, but years of systemic disinvestment scuttled
that dream. A new landscape master plan for the New York
City Housing Authority by Grain Collective and Nancy Owens
Studio looks to kick-start a transformation long overdue.
THE BACK
94
80 Designing Upward by Jennifer Reut
The key to a flourishing public space in Amsterdam is found
below, according to BiodiverCITY: A Matter of Vital Soil!
132 BACKSTORY
Without 3D-printed models, Public City might never have
figured out how to build Thunderhead, a memorial to those
affected by the LGBT Purge in Canada.
PATTERN
SPOTLIGHT:
RAIN
RADIUS GRATE
Material/Finish: Cast Iron/Baked-on-oil
LA: Berger Partnership
Design: NBBJ Seattle
Project: Alaska Airlines “The Hub”
TRENCH GRATE
ARCHITECTURE
Emily O’Mahoney, FASLA
mobrien@asla.org
PRESIDENT-ELECT
ADVERTISING SALES SuLin Kotowicz, FASLA
MAGAZINE 202-216-2325
SALES MANAGER
IMMEDIATE PAST PRESIDENT
Eugenia Martin, FASLA
LAF REPRESENTATIVES
Kofi Boone, FASLA
Barbara Deutsch, FASLA
PARLIAMENTARIAN
Susan Jacobson, FASLA
www.forms-surfaces.com
LAM /
INSIDE
CONTRIBUTORS
GOT A STORY?
At LAM, we don’t know what we don’t know.
If you have a story, project, obsession, or
simply an area of interest you’d like to see
covered, tell us! Send it to lam@asla.org.
Earthscape is your single source for designing and building custom wood play
structures. We collaborate with you to bring the impossible to life and create info@earthscapeplay.com | 1.877.269.2972
Kafka Granite delivers some of North America’s most spectacular natural stone
from the earth’s surface to dream homes, parks, and commercial properties.
Add a lifetime of durability and beauty to your landscape project with Kafka’s:
Sawn Cut Drywall
Thermal Flagstone
Sawn Edging
Thermal-Top Steps
Treads
Caps and Coping
kafkagranite.com
Natural Stone. Groundbreaking Solutions. 800-852-7415
LAM /
LETTERS
THE HARM OF “PRETENDIANS”
A s the January issue of LAM that
includes my article “Here in
Spirit” was finding its way into your
vincing evidence that LeClaire has no Karen Ann Hoffman, a renowned
Indigenous heritage. Oneida bead artist, went on to point
out that “real damage is done by
mailbox, I received some distressing Over the past several years LeClaire has ‘pretendians.’ Opportunity is stolen,
information that I must share about worked on Indigenous-centered proj- causes are damaged, and communi-
the artist Kay LeClaire, who presented ects and in positions including a resi- ties are shaken.” LeClaire has since
themselves as nibiiwakamigkwe, part dency at the University of Wisconsin– stated that they have removed them-
of the throat-singing duo Taiqaa// Madison claiming they were of Onei- selves from all community spaces, CLARIFICATION
Ambe Omaa. LeClaire misrepre- da, Ojibwe (Anishinaabe), Métis, and positions, projects, and grants and In the December 2022 Now ar-
sented their ethnicity and fabricated Cuban ancestry. After allegations [of will not seek new ones, but has not ticle “Jacksonville Steps Ahead,”
their identity. An anonymous online falsehood] came to light, in a news ar- as yet apologized. I recognize that the two renderings on page 34
research specialist has provided con- ticle in the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel LeClaire’s deception has caused pain are credited solely to Groundwork
on January 11, 2023, the school said it to individuals and harm to Indig- Jacksonville. The images should
had cut all ties with LeClaire and that enous communities, and I am sorry have been credited to SCAPE and
WHAT WE DON’T KNOW “there is a long and painful history of that the article may have unwittingly Groundwork Jacksonville.
of the labor laws in the United resource-guzzling plants that only closer to nature.
Arab Emirates (UAE), we have hurt the environment (“Feeling the
all heard of the labor deaths, low Pinch in Palm Beach,” LAM, Janu- We should be working with the town
wages, and poor working condi- ary). I used to be proud of being a to better their legislation. Instead of
tions in neighboring Qatar for landscape architect in Palm Beach rallying “the local landscape archi-
the 2022 World Cup. According County, but when I see the same re- tecture community—against it,” we
to the U.S. State Department and petitive designs using cheap nonna- should give in to the inevitable: You
Amnesty International, the UAE tive plants applied to all situations, it can’t fight Mother Nature and win.
has a history of human rights is- is hard to defend the profession. I too believe that using only native
sues. If this article was vetted for plants as recognized by the Institute
these issues, I would have pre- When I graduated from landscape for Regional Conservation for the
ferred to hear more about its im- architecture school in the 1980s, we 33480 zip code is too narrow a selec-
pact on social equity and healthy were taught to be stewards of the tion of available plants. Furthermore,
construction practices to better land. That is why I went into the pro- it does not take into account our
understand the project. fession. It is time for the landscape changing climate or urban landscape.
architects in Palm Beach to realize
BRETT ANDERSON, ASLA their actions are having a detrimen- CLINT OSTER, ASLA
PHOENIX
tal effect on our environment. I be- BOCA RATON, FLORIDA
1.800.609.6066
shadesystemsinc.com/arc-cantilever
Manufacturer of :
Architectural Paving Stones Veneer Stone
Wind Uplift System Retaining Wall Block
Permeable Pavers Architectural Block
WWW.NITTERHOUSEMASONRY.COM
3,800
CUSTOM COLORS
AND COUNTING
TERRAZZO GRANITE
COLLECTION COLLECTION
SAN DIEGO
landscape at the
Joseph and Elizabeth
Yamada House, in
PRESERVATION, page 36.
COMPACTION
SOIL CONDITION
• Texture
• Aggregation
• pH
• Organic Matter
SALTS/DEICERS
TR AFFIC
/DIS T UR
B A NC E
REED HILDERBRAND
RIGHT
The illustrated guide
was designed
to be printed and
taken into the field.
BELOW
To guide the city’s where something’s going to take care of it in the printed [the guide] as little books that they can take
investments, Reed end,” he explains. “Oftentimes, it’s the critters and in the truck,” says Eric Kramer, FASLA, a principal
Hilderbrand split
diseases that people can see. But those critters and at Reed Hilderbrand.
Cambridge into soil
management zones diseases wouldn’t have had the opportunity to at-
based on factors tack the tree had it not been predisposed to stress Using the Cambridge Urban Soils Index, an as-
correlated with by some soil condition.” sessment based on Scharenbroch’s research but
tree health. customized for the Massachusetts municipality,
To give foresters in Cambridge, Massachusetts, the field guide instructs foresters in how to evalu-
a tool to easily evaluate and mitigate common ate soil based on factors such as color, texture,
soil issues, Reed Hilderbrand and a team of soil pH, and salinity. Depending how the soil scores
scientists, including Scharenbroch, developed in each area, different remediation tactics are
the Cambridge Soils Management Field Guide. An recommended. For instance, if the concentration
outgrowth of Cambridge’s Urban Forest Master of soluble salt exceeds 500 microsiemens per
Plan, the field guide provides a methodology centimeter, crews are directed to flush the tree pit
for quickly assessing the quality of the soil with two and a half gallons of water per square
anywhere in the city, along with best man- foot daily and add compost until the concentration
agement practices for addressing com- reaches an acceptable level.
mon problems. “The whole goal was
to be super practical. We literally Although the guide is specific to Cambridge, the
strategies are applicable to other urban environ-
ments, and Kramer sees potential in a tool that
would let cities develop their own urban soils
indexes. The hurdle, he says, is that most people
assume soil requires advanced knowledge. “One
of the issues that freaks people out is they’re like,
REED HILDERBRAND
LEFT
A view of the
original Children’s
Pavilion with
rhododendron
beds, circa 1921.
Still, the event raises questions about At the same time, Keith says, cities and the con-
the efficacy of so-called cool pave- sultants they rely on should think of cool pave-
ment applications, especially when ment as one in a suite of strategies, some of
combined with the discovery, in which, including vehicle electrification, could bet-
2019, that at least some of the solar ter combat the heat island effect while also curb-
energy reflected by them is absorbed ing carbon emissions. (Waste heat from gasoline
by pedestrians. That year, research- or diesel vehicles is a significant contributor to
ers from Arizona State University urban heat islands.) “Looking at the whole suite
compared conventional and reflec- of heat mitigation strategies is really important,”
tive pavement in Los Angeles and Keith says. “With all of the money that’s been
found that while the coatings suc- approved by the federal government [for climate
cessfully lowered the road’s surface resilience], I think this is a really good opportunity
temperature, they increased the ra- for cities to look holistically at all of the climate
diant temperature—what a person risks that they’re facing, including heat.”
Your
CREATION
Our
TEAMWORK
Our team of Commercial Design
Consultants are ready to support
your next unit paving project
from start to finish.
UNILOCK.COM | 1-800-UNILOCK
FOREGROUND /NOW
A STAR
ON THE
HORIZON
INDIGENOUS LANDSCAPE
DESIGNER TIM LEHMAN
HELPS MOVE A MASTER PLAN
A fter Native Americans occupied Fort Lawton—
today part of Seattle’s Discovery Park—in
a peaceful protest in the early 1970s, the city
center offers events, Indigenous art,
programs on teaching traditional
medicine, social and community
AND A MISSION FORWARD. negotiated a long-term leaseback of 20 acres of services, and an indoor–outdoor
BY LISA OWENS VIANI the 534-acre site with the United Indians of All preschool.
Tribes Foundation. “The land was supposed to
be given back to the local tribe from which it In 2021, Tim Lehman, a landscape
Powerful Customizable High Wind Rating GFCI Protected Brilliant LED Qi Wireless &
Solar Array Color & Design & Self-Ballasted Outlets Lighting Fast Charging USB
ROAD
PARKING
KNOWN VEGETATION
CONTOUR LINES
TRAILS
PONDS
SACRED SPACES
SPACES FOR CAMAS GROWING
AND HARVESTING
SMOKE PIT
N
SPACES FOR INVASIVE REMOVAL
AND TRAIL IMPROVEMENTS
SPACE FOR PLANTER BOXES
ABOVE The most meaningful development, he says, has recent workshop, cedar was used to
Tim Lehman’s master been working with Jernigan and other communi- make a chest rub.
plan for the site ty members to restore the surrounding wetlands
identifies the locations
and forest. “I get to help steward the land our “It’s been an honor to learn more
of sacred and invasive
plant species. ancestors fought hard for,” says Lehman, who is about the plant medicines,” Pinkham
also a lecturer in the University of Washington’s says. “I want to hand that knowledge
landscape architecture program. down to the next generation.”
Over the past two years, Lehman and members For tribal members, all plants are
of the local Indigenous community, along with understood to be relatives, Jernigan
groups such as the Green Seattle Partnership, explains, and a great deal of thought
have removed thousands of invasive yellow flag goes into where each species should
irises from wetland areas and replaced them with be planted and why. “We ask, does this
native ferns, as well as camas and wapato bulbs, plant relative naturally inhabit this
important traditional foods. More than 10,000 space? Where will it thrive, under what
plants, including salal berry, elderberry, and salm- conditions, and who does this plant
onberry, and trees including willow and alder, need to be coplanted with?” As the sea-
have been planted around the ponds or as part of sons and the climate change, she says,
a foraging forest and medicinal garden. Shanoa community members learn more
Pinkham, the Yahowt foods and lands restoration about caring for the land, lessons that
TIM LEHMAN
coordinator with Na’ah Illahee, says many of the are passed on to the children attend-
plants have anti-inflammatory properties; at a ing preschool at Daybreak Star.
HONOR
ROLL
DISCOVER THE
COLLECTION
FOREGROUND /PRESERVATION
far as she could tell, Wu and Lee gen- oral history produced by the Cultural
uinely wanted to “understand their Landscape Foundation that during
role in conserving the property in the the 1950s through the 1970s, “if you
future. They want to be stewards of were going to do a project in town,
the resource, which is rare.” you wanted Joe Yamada.”
TM
LEFT
The house’s plant
palette was influenced
by Joe Yamada’s mentor
and partner, Harriett
Wimmer.
der Criterion A, as a property that re- the source material is often missing TERSECTION BETWEEN THE BUILT AND NATU-
RAL ENVIRONMENTS. HE LIVES IN THE KANSAS
flects “special elements of the city’s, the female component because they
FLINT HILLS.
a community’s, or a neighborhood’s were overlooked at the time.”
r
Discove
u r u n iq ue
o
q u i p m ent
Play E
Lunia !
. 90 Years of Experience
522/523 | DUMOR.COM | 800.598.4018
PLAY PLANETARIUM
Experts in Play. Sport. Park.
We consult, collaborate, design and
construct with independence,
innovation, and passion.
SPECPLAY.COM V E R S AT I L E - I N C L U S I V E - S .T. E . M . - P L AY
PLAY IN THE NIGHT SKY MAX FALL HEIGHT: 8’ 10”
CLIMB THROUGH ASTEROIDS NUMBER OF USERS: 49
EXPLORE CONSTELLATIONS AGE GROUP: 5-12
LEARN OUTSIDE USE ZONE: 28’ X 28’
FOREGROUND /
GOODS EDITED BY LAURIE A. SHUSTER
PARTING
WAYS
WALLS AND FENCES THAT
ADD PANACHE TO PARTITIONS.
SUBMIT
DO YOU HAVE A NEW PRODUCT
THAT YOU WOULD LIKE
TO SEE IN GOODS?
SUBMIT YOUR MATERIALS TO
LAMGOODS@ASLA.ORG.
SF HAIGHT
© CARL STAHL, TOP; COURTESY IRON AGE DESIGNS, BOTTOM
Richmond Barthé in
the courtyard of the
Kingsborough public
housing development,
page 56.
OPEN SPACES
Early Childhood Playground
Destination Multigenerational
Playground
Adventure Fitness
Sports Courts and
Regular Fitness
Entry Plaza
Planting Area
Passive Green Space
Tenant Garden
Water Feature
CIRCULATION
Parking Area with
Green Infrastructure
Primary Circulation
with Special Paving
Secondary Circulation
Property Line
PROGRAMMING
1 Urban Farm and BBQ Area
2 Outdoor Stage
3 Gateway Plaza
4 Farmers’ Market/Event Space
5 Promenade
6 Stepped Seat Ramp
1 Fitness Circuit 1/5 mile
Released in October 2021, NYCHA’s Open Space Private sector intervention is necessary because,
N
Masterplan is the work of two landscape architec- as Delma Palma, NYCHA’s deputy director of
ture firms: Grain Collective and Nancy Owens design services, says, “We’re working every day to
Studio. Together the firms surveyed 133 NYCHA keep the buildings standing.” Driven by shrinking
campuses and plotted broad landscape reorgani- federal support for NYCHA—down 18 percent
zations for each. NYCHA translated this plan into from 2001 to 2017—the agency currently has
a succinct YouTube video that explains the effort a $40 billion maintenance backlog, and a 2017
to public housing residents; the video earned a physical needs assessment uncovered capital
2022 ASLA Professional Honor Award in Com- needs of $870 million for NYCHA grounds alone. COURTESY GRAIN COLLECTIVE
munications. The master plan is a fundraising
tool, giving charitable private-sector actors and The survey data collected by Grain Collective
nonprofits a budget road map to re-envisioning (available in an ArcGIS map online) is key to advo-
2,400 acres of NYCHA properties, where 1 in 16 cating for what NYCHA needs. “Having that data
New Yorkers (more than 500,000) live, nearly 90 is not something that’s typical of public housing or
percent of them Black or Hispanic. of these lower-income communities,” Palma says.
On the ground, across all five boroughs, what the ers to guide circulation through space, and few
two firms found were monotonous landscapes landscape signals that differentiate spaces for
During our visit to the Van Dyke NYCHA devel- enough to dilute any intuitive understanding of
opment in Brownsville, Brooklyn, it takes Owens an axial plan. From the interior of the complex,
a bit to get her bearings. She’s been there before, orienting views of the street are blocked by build-
but after 74 surveys, things tend to blend together. ings. “We’re used to integrating spatially and
“There’s not an identity, a differentiation of char- programmatically, but everything is just plopped
acter,” she says. Landscapes in these places are [down],” Owens says. Her constant refrain is: “It
usually “a couple of trees around a new boiler just needs good designers.” Her plans for this
building.” complex include a skatepark, nature fitness area,
and adult fitness areas.
There are landmarks, like the sunken basketball
NANCY OWENS STUDIO
court and community center on the 23-building, Conversely, about two miles northwest of Van
22-acre campus spread over three blocks. But Dyke, there’s an NYCHA campus with a strong
buildings seem to simply run into each other, landscape identity. An axial promenade domi-
with no landscape features guiding transitions. nates the west side of the Kingsborough de-
The campus is largely symmetrical, yet offset just velopment, built in 1941, tying together about
ABOVE half of its 16 six-story apartment buildings. The The open space master plan project began in
The Kingsborough promenade is lined by a loose allée and terminates March 2020, just as COVID-19 locked the city
public housing at a spectacular Works Progress Administration– down, which limited public input. But the firms
development features era sculptural frieze by Richmond Barthé titled did speak with property managers and tenant
a strong axial plan that
Nancy Owens Studio
Exodus and Dance. But the opposite side of the association presidents. For Grain Collective, the
used to guide its frieze is a forlorn asphalt courtyard cradled by sudden worldwide focus on public health made
concept design. a U-shaped building. Owens’s plans suggest a connection to another way these landscapes
converting the promenade terminus to an ovular were letting NYCHA residents down. Early in
round that fronts the Barthé frieze with a perfor- the pandemic, areas of central Brooklyn and
mance area. the South Bronx with high numbers of NYCHA
properties had some of the highest rates of and install green infrastructure that can reduce
COVID-19 infection, on top of already high levels heat island effects and absorb stormwater. For
of asthma, obesity, and type 2 diabetes often seen Belski, a key question is, “How can we integrate
in low-income communities. In July 2020 alone, the amenity needs of the demographics that are
5 percent of people in these areas tested positive living there without taking away from this amaz-
for COVID-19. This told the Grain Collective ing natural respite that has evolved because his-
founding principal Runit Chhaya, ASLA, that torically we didn’t trust people to access their own
residents “did not have good open spaces to go landscapes?” Given the vitrine-like role fences and
out to, and they were stuck in their apartments,” barriers have played in fostering the growth of
he says. “In a morbid way [the pandemic] fueled the mature flora on campuses, NYCHA develop-
NANCY OWENS STUDIO
the momentum for this project.” ments are a “museum of trees,” she says.
Climate resilience is a vital part of the plan too, The firms’ research revealed that teen girls and
and includes recommendations to reduce imper- seniors often feel left out of NYCHA landscapes,
vious surfaces, expand biodiversity with plantings, leaving them bored and isolated, respectively.
KINGSBOROUGH
EXISTING DESIGN
KINGSBOROUGH
CONCEPT DESIGN
NANCY OWENS STUDIO
“We spent so much time walking around [ask- The most challenging sites for Owens are often
ing], ‘Where are the teen girls? What are they the smallest ones, such as Stuyvesant Gardens in
gonna do?’” Belski says. If they’re too old for nearby Bedford-Stuyvesant. It’s a low-rise, scat-
playgrounds, parents of younger kids might look tered site NYCHA complex on two separate long
askance if they hang around. But “being a teen and narrow blocks, occupying some six acres of
is all about seeing and being seen,” she says. The land. The landscape here is a narrow strip, mostly
master plan proposes “providing these gathering populated by six repetitive playgrounds on top of
spaces for them that are highly visible, so that they fraying rubber tiles. Across this strip, from one
have the protection of the eyes of the community; building to the next, five layers of fencing box
they’re well-lit, but they feel like a space created out trees, patches of grass, and the playgrounds,
N for them.” Examples are terraced stair seating and delineating every transition in the landscape. It
stages. Seniors need seating areas integrated with doesn’t seem surprising that none of the play-
other programs and activities. grounds are being used.
By chance, we meet a local activist and communi- in NYCHA housing just a few blocks away, at the
ty organizer, Bruce Green, who came to Stuyves- Eleanor Roosevelt NYCHA campus. And true to
ant Gardens that day to organize an antiviolence Owens’s evaluations, he says those landscapes
rally after a child was shot there a few days before. prized durability over fun. But he remembers early
As police mill around in the background, he says, on there was enough room for a baseball game in
“I thought you might have been grief counselors.” front of this building—until more fencing came
It’s a reminder that the landscape design security in. “At that point, you would pretty much have to
measures (such as broader sight lines and im- take your game to a local park,” he says.
proved lighting) Owens is thinking through have
ABOVE ramifications beyond creating more inviting street
Green wants to see more skateparks and adult
Nancy Owens Studio’s frontages, though they are unable to alter the fitness equipment in NYCHA housing, which
NANCY OWENS STUDIO
NYCHA is also looking for private dollars to fund As the areas surrounding NYCHA properties
landscape improvements and ongoing mainte- are gentrified, an open space master plan that
nance. So what’s in it for the donors? “I don’t calls for “destination” parks that would draw
know that we owe them anything,” Palma says. “A people from across the neighborhood might not
lot of the private parties that we’re working with be embraced by tenants. For Chhaya, it’s easy to
see this investment as very necessary and a part of understand why “not everybody has bought into
the social justice movement. Our asset continues the larger idea of connecting this public housing
to remain public.” to the larger city grid.” But he’s willing to take the
OPPOSITE
The Kingsborough
concept design creates
a public amphitheater
and focal point
surrounding Barthé’s
sculptural frieze.
NTED NTED
PATE PATE
3/8” BASE WITH FLAPS 3/32” 3/8” BASE WITH FLAPS 5/32”
A
M
DE T A
IN I
ppa@progressprofiles.com GET IT ON
to your scene.
Turn your walls from lean to green. With greenscreen®
wall-mounted trellis systems, you can transform any blank
vertical surface into a green façade of living art. Whether
it’s developing a brand new project or retrofitting an
existing building, our trellis panels are built to adjust to
all types of surfaces, from entryways, windows and
courtyards to bare building walls—so you can change
the everyday in a way that’s thoughtful, cost-efficient
and sustainable.
IRONSMITH’s Paver-Grate ® allows you to design over –instead of around— tree areas for
optimized planting, tree health and pedestrian comfort. An excellent choice for urban areas.
Paver-Grate® tree grates can be specified in standard or custom sizes with or without
opening’s. Trim rings and integrated tree grates available in multiple styles.
For more information about all IRONSMITH products visit us online at,
www.ironsmith.biz or call, 760-776-5077.
THE BACK
TERRY EVANS, “PLATTE RIVER, NEBRASKA,” 1990; SHELDON ART ASSOCIATION; THE HOME GROUND COLLECTION: GIFT OF THE ARTIST IN HONOR OF BARRY LOPEZ
LUJIA ZHU
THEODOOR HEIJERMAN
ALESSANDRA RICCETTI
CHONG YAO
NO
GREEN
PILL
THE TOPOGRAPHY OF WELLNESS:
HOW HEALTH AND DISEASE SHAPED
THE AMERICAN LANDSCAPE
BY SARA JENSEN CARR; CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA:
UNIVERSITY OF VIRGINIA PRESS, 2021; 288 PAGES, $34.50.
REVIEWED BY POLLYANNA RHEE
the task was now to improve one’s own self and free
the body from disease. These ideas informed critics
during the midcentury era of urban renewal, such
as when Architectural Forum published an article in
1951 titled “Slum Surgery in St. Louis” and included
photographs of blighted and so-called obsolete
districts that threatened to spread across the city.
In Victor Gruen’s 1964 The Heart of Our Cities, he
considered the urban core to be a heart and advocated
RIGHT for the revival of the garden city to repair this “tired
Biological analogies
proliferated in
heart.” Like a human body, a city could have its diseases
discussions about cities and pathologies in the form of blight surgically removed.
VICTOR GRUEN PAPERS, AMERICAN HERITAGE CENTER, UNIVERSITY OF WYOMING, TOP; PUBLIC DOMAIN, SAN FRANCISCO PUBLIC LIBRARY, BOTTOM
in the 20th century,
leading some to view This limited perspective resulted in the minimization of so-
them as living cells. cial and cultural considerations. Writing in 1984, Kevin Lynch
found the use of medical terminology problematic because it
BELOW
Urban renewal
reassured people “living outside the city that their health would
proponents believed be preserved by stopping the contagion of blight.”
in rescuing so-called intervention or design could be a straightforward solution
blighted and If there is one overarching assumption, or perhaps aspira- to the problem of health without regard for social, political,
diseased cities. tion, in these projects over time, it is the idea that a single or ideological context. Currently popular interventions such
as incorporating landscape views in health care settings, tree
planting programs, and smart cities designed with active liv-
ability in mind contain aspects of this assumption. This was
the case even as the Centers for Disease Control began to ad-
dress “social determinants of health” in the 1980s and 1990s.
Carr looks especially at research linking rising obesity rates,
increased stress, and the rise of hypertension to low-density
sprawl and life oriented around the car. But vilifying sprawl
and offering an alternative could also take a neo-traditionalist
or even regressive turn.
PUBLIC DOMAIN, CENTERS FOR DISEASE CONTROL, LEFT; COURTESY GROUNDWORK LAWRENCE AND AMERICAN PLANNING ASSOCIATION’S SUSTAINABLE COMMUNITIES DIVISION, RIGHT
Near the book’s conclusion, Carr includes a rallying cry
for landscape architects. She acknowledges that landscape
architecture “is often victim to value engineering or dis-
missed as a decorative art.” But it can also create a path to
reconnect the design and planning of cities with public
of modernist cities, Carr contends that the trio “uncritically health in mind. Landscape architects can reclaim their role
doubled down” on “defining their superior traditionalism as by envisioning a more expansive and politically engaged
European” or from the antebellum South. Since early in the set of tasks. Confronting intertwined issues of sprawl-
21st century, Duany and Plater-Zyberk have focused on post- ing development, climate change, spatial inequities, and
Hurricane Katrina recovery projects in Biloxi, Mississippi, chronic disease transcends the traditional boundaries of
and New Orleans, stressing the healthful attributes of New the profession. Nevertheless, embracing these challenges
Urbanist designs, positions that have not avoided controversy is a necessity. Instead of a solutions-minded focus, the es-
and charges that their nostalgic designs are accomplices to sential takeaway here is the need to shift the perspective on
displacement of New Orleans’s Black population. health and wellness and its relationship to landscapes if we
are to have a more equitable society. Although landscape
TOP LEFT Health, Carr acknowledges, is a term with “value judgments, architects may find the chapters in the second half most
The federal hierarchies, and blind assumptions that speak as much helpful for their focus on contemporary activities, Carr also
government now
about power and privilege as they do about well-being.” admonishes landscape architects to consider the possibility
markets wellness
by encouraging Writing in the context of the COVID-19 outbreak in spring that design practitioners have been “compliant in a system
walkability in cities. 2020, Carr concludes that ultimately there is “no green pill” that exacerbates social inequity.” Landscape architects are
that solves everything. But she notes that fact doesn’t keep political actors whether or not they want to be. Recognizing
TOP RIGHT urban critics such as Joel Kotkin from vindicating Southern that fact means examining the assumptions behind health,
A proposal for California’s sprawling landscape of single-family homes as cities, and design and understanding that the choices we
green streets in
vital for minimizing virus exposures. Very often solutions make are anything but neutral.
Massachusetts links
environmental quality are oriented toward bettering or justifying the lives of those
with an individual’s who are already comfortable rather than toward more equi- POLLYANNA RHEE IS AN ASSISTANT PROFESSOR OF LANDSCAPE ARCHITEC-
quality of life. table approaches. TURE AT THE UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS URBANA–CHAMPAIGN.
Each year the ASLA Student Awards gives us a glimpse into the future of the profession. Award
recipients receive featured coverage in Landscape Architecture Magazine, the magazine of
ASLA, and in many other design and construction industry and general-interest media. Award
recipients and their advisors will be honored at the awards presentation ceremony during the
ASLA Conference on Landscape Architecture in Minneapolis, MN, October 27-30, 2023.
Must be ASLA student member. Student Members can join for Free!
Entry Fee: $65 + $65 for additional entries
Categories: General Design | Residental Design | Analysis & Planning | Research | Urban Design
Communications| Student Collaboration| Student Community Service
BOOKS
OF INTEREST
COLLABORATIVE STRATEGIES
OFFER HOPE TO NATURE
AND THE PLANET.
Epic in both scope and size, Way Across 16 essays, Metadesigning ar-
Beyond Bigness presents design re- THE STORY OF FLOWERS gues that an interdisciplinary, collab-
search on three watersheds: the Me- AND HOW THEY CHANGED orative approach is necessary to tackle
kong, Mississippi, and Rhine river THE WAY WE LIVE the simultaneous crises—climatic,
basins. These are huge territories BY NOEL KINGSBURY; LONDON: economic, and social—facing the
united by shared challenges of water LAURENCE KING PUBLISHING, 2023; planet in our Anthropocene era. The
216 PAGES, $29.99.
infrastructure, including manage- book doesn’t shy away from urgency,
ment across borders and accelerated stressing that the Earth is in trouble
flooding due to climate change. The The garden designer Noel Kings- and designers need to use their agen-
architect Derek Hoeferlin, Affiliate bury, known for his collaborations cy in what may feel like end-times.
ASLA, organizes the book around a with Piet Oudolf, carefully indexes The contribution by the landscape
trio of methodologically based chap- 100 blooms, each accompanied by architect and urban designer Chuck
ters: “Appreciate + Analyze,” “Specu- meticulous illustrations by Charlotte Ware, ASLA, “Towards Synergistic
late + Synthesize,” “Collaborate + Day that evoke 18th-century botani- Performance in Design,” uses case
Catalyze.” The first two sections are cal etchings. True to the title, The studies to highlight how landscape
packed with contributor essays, pre- Story of Flowers provides insight into architecture affects economic and
cise analytical drawings, and field- the idea that flowers are so much community development, environ-
work photography, while the latter more than their beauty. They are mental health, and culture.
gives space to the more intimate role currency, medicine, and the object
of community engagement. of cultural myth. While cultivated
beds may require tending, Kings-
bury argues that there is reciprocity:
As we care for flowers, they, in turn,
change us.
101 accredited landscape architecture degree Flip the page for details on some
programs to choose from across the United LAAB-accredited programs.
States.
American University of Beirut Oklahoma State University University of Illinois
Arizona State University Pennsylvania State University University of Kentucky
Auburn University Polytechnic University of Puerto Rico, flip University of Maryland
Ball State University for more info University of Massachusetts
Boston Architectural College, flip for more Purdue University University of Michigan
info Rhode Island School of Design University of Minnesota
California Polytechnic State University Rutgers University University of Nebraska
California State Polytechnic University South Dakota State University University of Nevada, Las Vegas
City College of New York State University of New York University of New Mexico
Clemson University Temple University University of Oklahoma
Colorado State University Texas A & M University, flip for more info University of Oregon, flip for more info
Cornell University Texas Tech University University of Pennsylvania
Delaware Valley University Thomas Jefferson University University of Rhode Island
Florida International University Universidad Ana G. Mendez University of Southern California
Harvard University University of Arizona University of Tennessee
Illinois Institute of Technology University of Arkansas University of Texas at Arlington
Iowa State University, flip for more info University of California, Berkeley, flip for University of Texas at Austin
Kansas State University more info University of Virginia
Kent State University University of California, Davis University of Washington
Louisiana State University University of Cincinnati University of Wisconsin
Michigan State University University of Colorado Denver Utah State University
Mississippi State University University of Connecticut Virginia Tech
Morgan State University University of Delaware Washington State University
North Carolina A & T State University University of Florida Washington University in St. Louis, flip for
North Carolina State University University of Georgia, flip for more info more info
North Dakota State University University of Hawaii West Virginia University
Ohio State University University of Idaho
Scan the QR code to learn more about landscape architecture education and career development.
Creating diversity
through design.
Aerial view of proposed redevelopment, Fore River Shipyard, Quincy, MA, incorporating landscape
urbanism strategies prioritizing climate resiliency within a commercial development addressing the
needs of local residential communities.
LANDSCAPE
DESIGN THE FUTURE ARCHITECTURE
DREAM BIG
Aesthetic design
Interface Inc. Headquarters, Atlanta GA | architect: Perkins & Will | photographer: ©Nick Merrick
TWITTER
@HuntcoSupply
INSTAGRAM
@Huntco
BIKE LOCKERS &
BURNSIDE BIKE CORRAL
MULTNOMAH UNIVERSITY LEARN MORE AT HUNTCO.COM
bringing families
together
1-877-255-3146
solusdecor.com info@solusdecor.com
Atomizing Systems
If your client wants more than an ordinary retaining wall, select VERSA-LOK. No other wall system gives you the same combination of aesthetics,
installation ease and performance. To find out why landscape architects prefer VERSA-LOK, call (800) 770-4525 or visit versa-lok.com.
EasiSetBuildings.com 540.439.8911
FAST • ECONOMICAL • VERSATILE • DURABLE • SECURE • REDUCE LABOR COSTS
DRIVABLE GRASS®
A Permeable and Flexible Concrete Paving System
w w w. s o i l r e t e n t i o n . c o m
8 0 0 - 3 4 6 - 7 9 9 5
ASLA
Discover
Landscape
Architecture
Activity Books
ASLA’s Discover Landscape
Architecture Activity Books
for kids, teens, and adults
were designed by ASLA
members to inspire and
teach anyone interested
in landscape architecture
and the built environment.
Download the free activity
books now! The Finishing Touch
asla.org/activitybooks to Every Landscape ™
www.D rift r oses .com | F in d a w h ol es al e gr o w e r n ea r y ou : 1 - 80 0 - 45 7- 1 85 9
Login at https://my.asla.org/Account
Watch: tclf.org/courageous
Watch: tclf.org/activism
ASLA Climate Action Plan 202-898-2444 120 Most Dependable Fountains 800-552-6331 114 Ernst Conservation Seeds 800-873-3321 123
ASLA EXPO Promotion 202-216-2326 130-131 Paloform 888-823-8883 2 Spring Meadow Nursery Inc. 800-633-8859 7
ASLA Student Awards 202-216-2331 101 Solus Décor, Inc. 877-255-3146 111 (Proven Winners)
Landscape Architecture Foundation 202-331-7070 121 Star Roses and Plants 800-457-1859 115
Kingsley Bate, Ltd. 703-361-7000 11, 128 Columbia Cascade Company 800-547-1940 125, 127
Cell-Tek Geosynthetics, LLC 410-721-4844 126 PARKS AND RECREATION Doty & Sons Concrete Products 800-233-3907 122
Iron Age Designs 206-276-0925 6, 122 APE Studio c/o Richter Spielgeräte 212-213-6694 43 DuMor, Inc. 800-598-4018 47, 126
Ironsmith, Inc. 800-338-4766 78, 124 BCI Burke Co. Inc. 920-921-9220 54 Equiparc 800-363-9264 35, 125
EDUCATION Berliner 864-627-1092 45, 126 Huntco Supply, LLC 503-224-8700 111
ASLA LAAB/Institutes of Higher Education 202-898-2444 103 Columbia Cascade Company 800-547-1940 123, C4 Landscape Forms 800-430-6205 3, 15
Boston Architectural College 617-585-0100 104 Earthscape 877-269-2972 12, 122 Madrax 800-448-7931 39
Iowa State University 515-294-6743 105 Gyms For Dogs - 800-931-1462 125 Maglin Site Furniture Inc. 800-716-5506 19
Sam Fox School of Design & Visual Arts 314-935-6200 109 Natural Dog Park Products Petersen Concrete Leisure Products 800-832-7383 116
Texas A&M University 979-458-0628 106 Landscape Structures, Inc. 888-438-6574 23, 124 Salsbury Industries 800-624-5269 53, 128
UC Berkeley College 510-642-2963 108 Specified Play Equipment Co. (SPEC) 800-475-1071 48 Sitecraft 800-221-1448 29
Universidad Politecnica de Puerto Rico 787-622-8000 108 PAVING/SURFACING/MASONRY STONE/METALS Sunbolt 267-419-8496 33
University of Georgia College 706-542-4704 107 Hanover Architectural Products, Inc. 717-637-0500 20 Thomas Steele 800-448-7931 127
of Environment & Design Invisible Structures, Inc. 303-395-1803 49 Via Seating 800-433-6614 115
University of Oregon 541-510-1490 109 Kafka Granite LLC 715-316-2792 13, 128 Victor Stanley, Inc. 301-855-8300 124, C3
FENCES/GATES/WALLS Pine Hall Brick Co., Inc. 800-334-8689 27, 126 STRUCTURES
LEGI/Outerspace Landscape Furnishings 858-729-3888 128 Progress Profiles America, Inc. 973-584-2650 77 Easi-Set Buildings 800-547-4045 114
LOCINOX USA 877-562-4669 110 Soil Retention Products 760-966-6090 114 Gothic Arch Greenhouses 251-471-5238 116
Versa-Lok Retaining Wall System 800-770-4525 112, 127 Solistone 800-758-2119 126 MODSTREET 970-422-8400 113
Wallace Perimeter Security 866-300-1110 116 Stepstone, Inc. 800-572-9029 99 Shade Systems, Inc. 800-609-6066 17
Bison Innovative Products by UCP 888-412-4766 110 David Harber Ltd. 312-895-1586 74
Sure-Loc Aluminum Edging 800-787-3562 126 Green Theory Design Inc. 604-475-7002 41, 125
HADDONSTONE 866-733-8225 77
DECORATIVE DRAIN
GRATES
C A L L TO DAY !
800-233-3907
CUSTOM
CURVED
BENCHES
DOTYCONCRETE.COM
QUALITY PRODUCTS SINCE 1948
https://ernstseed.co/adLAM
215-541-4330
800-873-3321 CAM PAN IA www.campaniainternational.com
sales@ernstseed.com
PPRROOJ JE EC CT T D DI VI V
I SI ISOONN
projects@campaniainternational.com
Embankment
Slide Chutes
www.TimberForm.com
®
www.forms-surfaces.com
T H E S T E L L A O F S U N N E™ C O L L E C T I O N
SMART DESIGN
Built to withstand the forces of EQUALS
wind, rain and changing tastes. SMART PLAY
Leadership by design
Lexington
www.ironsmith.biz 800-338-4766
Create an
experience...
sales@GymsForDogs.com
www.TimberForm.com
®
800-931-1562
Cloverwood
Playground goes Art Gallery!
www.berliner-playequipment.com
LEGACY
STAMPED PAVERS
Perfect for
historic districts,
streetscapes
& universities
(336) 721-7514
GET INSPIRED
BY OUR CATALOG
PROFESSIONAL
PRACTICE CycLoops
®
Arch
TM
NETWORKS
www.TimberForm.com
®
www.asla.org/PPN.aspx
ELEVATE YOUR
LANDSCAPE
with Natural Stone Hardscapes
by Kafka Granite
Sawn Cut Drywall
Sawn Edging
Thermal-Top Steps
Treads
Thermal Flagstone Caps & Coping
KINGSLEY BATE
TM
Cedarwood Playground;
Waltham MA ELEGANT OUTDOOR FURNITURE
Carolyn Cooney & Associates
Trim: 2’ x 4.5’
Landscape Architects
SUPPLIERS ARE
ESSENTIAL TO THE
CLIMATE ACTION PLAN
The challenges of climate change require
solutions from landscape architects and
their suppliers. Now is the time to learn,
analyze, rethink – and innovate.
BY RUSS KL ET TK E
Executive Summary
▶ The Climate Action Plan is a The plan (found at www.asla.org/climateactionplan. the world over, steadfastly works to reduce the
business opportunity for the aspx) was written by ASLA’s Climate Action Plan embodied carbon of his projects. But because
Task Force and Advisory Group to provide a most manufacturers have yet to do a full life cycle
profession and industry.
framework for how this is to be achieved. Included analysis (LCA) and provide an environmental
in it are key points that hit home with landscape product declaration (EPD), he and his colleagues
▶ Low- and zero-carbon sourcing, architecture’s industry partners: devise other solutions as best they can.
manufacturing, and shipping
• The goal is a drawdown of carbon, achieving Regardless of company size, progress can be
are key.
zero embodied and operational emissions and made
increased carbon sequestration by the year
▶ ASLA is helping industry partners 2040; this requires full participation across Hardy provides an example of a project near
navigate this transformational the entire supply chain. Athens, Greece, where a decommissioned airport is
• The plan envisions greater economic success being redeveloped into the Ellinikon Metropolitan
process.
for landscape architecture firms and product Park. There, solutions include upcycling old
manufacturers, with increased demand for runway pavement into a crushed aggregate road
W
hen the Climate Action Plan (CAP) was zero-emissions products. base. They also source stone and plants from nearby
unveiled at the ASLA 2022 Conference on • The CAP puts equity at the center of climate quarries and nurseries. But he hopes that standards
Landscape Architecture in San Francisco, action and builds on the ASLA Racial Equity – such as ISO 12020 and ISO 14044 – will soon be
it wasn’t simply something a handful of people Plan of Action. commonplace among product providers across
devised in a vacuum. It came after a survey of 563 • The Biden-Harris Administration recently the board.
landscape architects in 2021 – and an “Open Letter announced $25 billion to advance nature-
on Climate Action” signed by scores of activist based solutions to climate change. Already two companies have invested considerable
landscape architecture students in 2019 – sent a resources to assess their embodied carbon.
strong message that climate is front and center Landscape architect Chris Hardy, ASLA, RLA, CA, Norway-based Vestre, as previously reported here
in their work. It matters to their clients as much LEED AP+ND, a senior associate landscape architect (March 2022), has met several standards (including
as them. at Sasaki (Boston), like landscape architects ASTM E1991-05) that are more commonly required
ASLA SPONSORED CONTENT
and principal landscape architect. For Thunder- Albert McLeod and the performance artists Shawna
head, the winning competition design for the Dempsey and Lorri Millan, who collaborated over many
2SLGBTQI+ National Monument in Ottawa, the iterations to develop a series of thunderhead forms.
concept was rooted in the prairie landscape and The 30-foot-high cylinder with disco ball–clad interior
the experience of both dread and celebration that a space will glitter and fragment the light.
Celebrating 60 years, Victor Stanley designs, engineers and manufactures timeless site furnishings so you can bring
communities to life. Our Stella of Sunne collection features a classic, minimalist look inspired by Scandinavian design
™
aesthetics. Its eased edges and clean lines transform any environment into a comfortable and inviting space.