Comparirative chart For Technical Proposal Evaluation sheet for Preparation

1.Experience (Per
2.Methodology
experience 2 marks)

Company Name

Specific Experience (10

Methodology (40 Marks)
Marks)

SDC Engineering Service 4 36

P. Ltd

Concept Architect and

4 38
Designs P.ltd

Jaarsa Engineering
6 37
Consultancy P. Ltd

CV Evaluation of SDC
Scoring Criteria

Professional Key Maximum Specific

Education
Personnel Marks Experience

Urban Planner/Tourism
Expert
15 3 2
/Team Leader

Sociologist 5 1 2

Geotech/Geology 5 1 1

GIS Expert 5 1 2

Civil Engineer 5 1 1
Architect 5 1 1

Environmentalist 5 1 1

Survyeor 5 1 1
Total Marks obtained 50

CV Evaluation of Thrive
Scoring Criteria

Professional Key Maximum Specific

Education
Personnel Marks Experience

Urban Planner/Tourism
Expert
15 3 2
/Team Leader

Sociologist 5 1 2

Geotech/Geology 5 1 1

GIS Expert 5 1 2
Civil Engineer 5 1 1
Architect 5 1 1
Environmentalist 5 1
Survyeor 5 1 1
Total Marks obtained 50

CV Evalua
Scoring Criteria

Specific
Professional Key Maximum
Education Experience (10
Personnel Marks
Marks)

Urban Planner/Tourism
Expert
15 3 2
/Team Leader

Sociologist 5 1 2
Geotech/Geology 5 1

GIS Expert 5 1 2
Civil Engineer 5 1 1
Architect 5 1 1
Environmentalist 5 1
Survyeor 5 1 1
Total Marks obtained 50
valuation sheet for Preparation of Tourism Masterplan of Siranchowk Rural Municipality

Total Marks
2.Methodology CV
without CV

Total without Different sheet for

Methodology (40 Marks)
(1+2) each company

36 40 48

38 42 48

37 43 45

CV Evaluation of SDC Engineering Service P. Ltd

Marks Obtained

Marks
Marks for Marks for
Education required Obtained by
Education specific Exp
the consultant

Master’s degree in
Urban/Tourism 3 10 13

Master’s degree in
Sociology 1 4 5

Masters in Geology/
1 4 5 SDC Engineering Service P.
Geotech
Master’s degree in GIS
1 4 5

Bchelor in Civil 1 4 5
Bachelor in Architect 1 4 5

Masters in Environment 1 4 5

Diploma in Civil 1 4 5
48

CV Evaluation of Thrive Engineering Consultancy P. Ltd

Marks Obtained

Marks
Marks for Marks for
Education required Obtained by
Education specific Exp
the consultant

Master’s degree in
Urban/Tourism 3 10 13

Master’s degree in
Sociology 1 4 5
Concept Architect and Designs
Masters in Geology/
1 4 5
Geotech
Master’s degree in GIS
1 4 5
Bchelor in Civil 1 4 5
Bachelor in Architect 1 4 5
Masters in Environment 1 4 5
Diploma in Civil 1 4 5
48

CV Evaluation of Platform
Marks Obtained

Marks
Marks for Marks for
Education required Obtained by
Education specific Exp
the consultant

Master’s degree in
Urban/Tourism 3 10 13

Master’s degree in
Sociology 1 4 5 Jaarsa Engineering Consultancy
 Jaarsa Engineering Consultancy

Masters in Geology/
1 4 5
Geotech
Master’s degree in GIS
1 3 4
Bchelor in Civil 1 4 5
Bachelor in Architect 1 4 5
Masters in Environment 1 3 4
Diploma in Civil 1 3 4
45
owk Rural Municipality, Gorkha

Total (Each
company should Total Converted
score minimun 80 amount into 80 as
marks out of 100 QCBS (80:20)
for financial
evaluation

Total marks out of Marks convrted to

100 80 ( Total obtained
marks*0.8)

88 70.4

90 72

88 70.4

SDC Engineering Service P. Ltd

 Concept Architect and Designs P.ltd

Jaarsa Engineering Consultancy P. Ltd

 Financial Bid Evaluation
Lowest bid amount is calculated as 100 points
Lowest Bid amount 1,495,000.00
Obtained
SN Company Name Bid price with VAT point

1 1,496,000.00 1.00
SDC Engineering Service P. Ltd
2 Concept Architect and Designs P.ltd 1,495,000.00 1.00
3 Jaarsa Engineering Consultancy P. Ltd 1,497,000.00 1.00
Total QCBS Calculated as 80:20 (Technical :Finincial)
SN Company Technical Financial Total
SDC Engineering Service P. Ltd
1 70.4 19.99 90.39

Concept Architect and Designs P.ltd

2 72 20.00 92.00

Jaarsa Engineering Consultancy P. Ltd

3 70.4 19.97 90.37

Prepared By Checked By Approv

Sub Engineer Civil Engineer Chief Administ

00 points

Converted to 20 points as evaluated

QCBS

19.99

20.00
19.97
cal :Finincial)
Ranking

2nd

1st

3rd

Approved By

Chief Administrative officer