Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chapter 33
Chapter 33
ELASTOGRAPHY
33. Elastography B) Shear-waves elastography (SWE) is a quantitative method that assesses the shear-
Roxana Șirli, Giovanna Ferraioli waves speed generated into the tissue by a mechanical stimulus, which is directly
applied on the skin, as in Transient Elastography (TE) or into the body by the push-
Keywords: elastography, stiffness, liver, thyroid, breast, prostate pulse of focused ultrasound beams, as in the ARFI based techniques, i.e. pSWE and
2D-SWE. pSWE evaluates the shear-waves speed at the focal point of the US beam, in
33.1. Basics of elastography a small and region of interest (ROI) of fixed size, whereas 2D-SWE is based on multiple
ARFI lines in a large field of view (FOV) that is usually user-adjustable.
Elasticity is an intrinsic physical property of materials and tissues: to deform when an
external force is applied upon them and to return to their original shape after removing
the force that caused the deformation. A complementary concept is stiffness, defined View enlarged image
as the resistance opposed by an elastic material to deformation.
In order to perform elasticity measurements, a mechanical excitation of the tissue is
needed. It can be obtained by manual compression (by hand or using cardiovascular
pulsations or respiratory motions), by electronically controlling the ultrasound transducer
to create focused acoustic radiation force impulse (ARFI) at a controlled depth (ARFI
imaging and shear wave elastography with ARFI-based techniques), or by external
mechanical vibrations. The mechanical excitation induces longitudinal deformation, Fig 33.1a
assessed by strain imaging or ARFI imaging, and shear-waves that propagate inside SE of the liver – Hitachi
the tissue, whose speed can be measured. Stiffer tissues show less longitudinal Aloka system. From F1
displacement and higher shear-waves’ speed. Elastography techniques are classified to F4 fibrosis stage, color
variation of the SE increases
by international guidelines according to the measured physical quantity, the excitation
- low strain regions
method, and the method used to display the measured quantity:
(LFI=1.68) in a patient with
F1
A) Strain elastography (SE) and ARFI imaging are based on the qualitative assessment
of the axial displacement. Strain elastography evaluates the percentage of displacement
induced into the tissue by a quasi-static force applied by manual compression (by hand View enlarged image
1
WFUMB Course Book 33. ELASTOGRAPHY
33.2. Liver elastography TE is considered failed if no valid shots can be obtained. TE is not feasible in patients
with ascites, while failed and unreliable measurements are mostly correlated with
SWE techniques have been accepted as a reliable substitute of liver biopsy in obesity. Three types of probes are available according to BMI: S probe for pediatric
several clinical scenarios. patients, M probe – normal weight patients and XL probe for obese.
Liver elastography is a highly reproducible method with a short learning curve,
however training is needed in order to obtain reliable results. Feasibility is also very
good, but variable for different systems and experience in ultrasound increases
feasibility, especially for 2D-SWE. View enlarged image
2
WFUMB Course Book 33. ELASTOGRAPHY
In patients with chronic viral hepatitis or NAFLD, the “rule of 4” has been proposed:
LS ≤ 5 kPa has high probability of being normal; LS < 9 kPa, in the absence of
other known clinical signs, rules out cACLD; values between 9 kPa and 13 kPa are
suggestive of cACLD but may need further tests for confirmation; and values > 13
kPa are highly suggestive of cACLD. There is a probability of clinically significant portal
hypertension with LS values > 17 kPa, but additional tests may be required. In some
patients with NAFLD, the cut-off values for cACLD may be lower and follow-up or
additional testing in those with values between 7 and 9 kPa is recommended. Using
these cutoffs each manufacturer’s technique will have its own sensitivity and specificity.
3
WFUMB Course Book 33. ELASTOGRAPHY
Fig 33.7
Fig 33.5 LS measurement by pSWE
pSWE measurement of LS technique from Hitachi. Ten
by ElastPQ technique from measurements made, their
Philips. Measurement value median value is 1.71 m/s
5.82 kPa (8.75 kPa)
Fig 33.8
2D-SWE measurement by
the Aixplorer (Supersonic
Fig 33.6 Imagine) system in a patient
LS measurement by with cirrhosis. Mean LS
S-Shearwave Imaging value inside the ROI is 13.8
technique from Samsung- kPa. Measurement made in
Medison. Measurement the most homogeneous area
value is 4.4 kPa of the elastogram
4
WFUMB Course Book 33. ELASTOGRAPHY
Fig 33.9
LS measurement by Fig 33.11
2D-SWE from General 2D-SWE measurement of
Electric in a patient with LS by ElastQ technique
cirrhosis. Mean LS value from Philips. Measurements
inside the ROI is 13.8 kPa. made in the most
Measurement made in the homogeneous areas.
most homogeneous area of Left side of the image:
the elastogram confidence map.
Fig 33.10
LS measurement by
2D-SWE from General
Electric in a patient with
cirrhosis. Left side of the
image – confidence map. Fig 33.12
Right side of the image – 2D-SWE measurement of
elasticity map. Measurement LS by S-Shearwave Imaging
made in the most technique from Samsung-
homogeneous area Medison.
5
WFUMB Course Book 33. ELASTOGRAPHY
Cancer nodules are stiffer than the normal surrounding tissue and the stiffening
process begins in the early cancer stages. Both strain (SE) and shear-waves
elastography (SWE) techniques can be used for breast assessment. In order to
Fig 33.13 obtain reliable elastographic measurements a good gray-scale US image of the
LS measurement by lesion is mandatory, and the probe should be maintained perpendicularly on the
2D-SWE from Mindray. skin. SE compression technique for each elastography system should be known
Left side of the image – and applied. The ROI should include various tissue types (fat, glandular tissue,
reliability map. Right side of muscle) and the lesion should account for maximum ¼ of the ROI.
the image – elasticity map.
Measurement made in the
33.3.1 Strain elastography (SE) for breast nodules assessment
most homogeneous area,
The Tsukuba score is a five-point scale based on the colors (balance of green and
mean value in the ROI 8.05
kPa blue) inside the tumor and the surrounding tissue, a higher score being associated
with malignancy (Fig 33.15). Tsukuba score had 86.5% sensitivity, 89.9% specificity,
and 88.3% accuracy for differentiating benign vs. malignant breast nodules.
EI/B ratio, width ratio, length ratio assessment started from the observation that the
elastogram of benign lesions is smaller than the corresponding B-mode image that
of malignant lesions is larger. In a multicenter trial, the EI/B-mode ratio criterion of
<1.0 as benign and ≥1.0 as malignant had 99% sensitivity and 87% specificity in
differentiating benign vs. malignant breast lesions.
Lesion to fat ratio (LFR) compares the strain in the breast mass to the one in
subcutaneous fat. Reported cut-offs of 2.8 to 4.5 are used to rule-out and rule-in
malignant lesions, respectively (Fig 33.16 - 20).
View enlarged image
33.3.2. SWE measurement and imaging for breast nodules
Stiffness measurements should be used in addition to the Breast Imaging Reporting
and Data System (BI-RADS) classification. The maximum stiffness of the lesion
should be taken into consideration. Low stiffness values (< 20 kPa or <2.6 m/s) can
Fig 33.14 be used to rule-out malignancy, while high stiffness values (> 80 kPa or 5.2 m/s)
LS measurement by can be used to rule-in malignancy (Fig 33.21-22).
2D-SWE from Canon.
Left side of the image –
elastogram. Right side of Remember
the image – propagation
map. Measurement made in • Malignant breast nodules are stiffer than the surrounding tissue
the area with parallel lines, • Breast elastography should be used in addition to BI-RADS criteria for breast
mean value in the ROI 5.2 nodules
kPa
6
WFUMB Course Book 33. ELASTOGRAPHY
Fig 33.18
BIRADS 5 (high risk) nodule
in gray scale US: solid
Fig 33.16 pattern, intense hypoechoic,
BIRADS 3 (low risk) irregular margins, posterior
nodule in gray scale US: shadowing, infiltration,
solid pattern, hypoechoic, taller than wide shape. SE
regular margins, posterior (Hitachi) color code map 4 –
enhancement, oval shape. increased stiffness area that
SE (Hitachi) color code map equals the gray scale image.
1 – low stiffness. Strain ratio Strain ratio = 8.78 - Breast
= 0.99 – Fibroadenoma cancer
7
WFUMB Course Book 33. ELASTOGRAPHY
Fig 33.21
BIRADS 3 (low risk) nodule
in gray scale US: solid
Fig 33.19 pattern, hypoechoic, regular
BIRADS 3 (low risk) nodule shape, clear margins,
in gray scale US: solid oval shape, homogenous,
pattern, mild hypoechoic, no calcification, posterior
oval shape, clear margins, enhancement. 2D-SWE
no posterior phenomenon, (Mac 30 Aixplorer) color
oval shape, partially code map 1 – complete
inhomogeneous. SE low stiffness area. Mean
(Philips) color code map 32 elasticity 43 kPa –
– predominant low strain Fibroadenoma
8
WFUMB Course Book 33. ELASTOGRAPHY
Strain ratio (SR) is a semi-quantitative method that compares the ratio between
strain in adjacent tissue vs. thyroid nodule, either normal thyroid parenchyma
(parenchyma-to-nodule SR), or adjacent strap muscle (muscle-to-nodule SR) (Fig
33.24 - 26). There is no consensus on which cut-off to use. Caveat in non-papillary View enlarged image
thyroid carcinomas which can be soft and also in underlying Hashimoto disease
where the thyroid parenchyma is hard.
9
WFUMB Course Book 33. ELASTOGRAPHY
Fig 33.27
Low risk thyroid nodule in
Fig 33.25 gray scale US: solid pattern,
Intermediate risk thyroid oval shape, isoechoic, clear
nodule in gray scale US: margins, regular shape,
solid pattern, taller than no posterior phenomenon,
wide shape clear margins, cystic degeneration.
no calcification, no posterior 2D-SWE (Mac 30 Aixplorer)
phenomenon. SE (Hitachi color code 1 – low stiffness
Preirus) color code 3 – - reconfirmation of low risk
increased stiffness - risk category. Mean elasticity =
upgrade. Strain ratio = 4.5 14.9 kPa
10
WFUMB Course Book 33. ELASTOGRAPHY
Fig 33.29
SE of a hyperechoic
33.5. Prostate elastography prostate nodule. Stiffness
in the entire hyperechoic
nodule is hard, Kamoi score
Cancerous tissue in the prostate is stiffer (Fig 33.29) as compared with benign 5, prostate adenocarcinoma
tissue (Fig 33.30). US elastography improves prostate nodules characterization
but also cancer detection by disclosing lesions on the elasticity map not visible on
conventional trans-rectal US (TRUS) imaging or MRI.
Prostate elastography should be always performed after standard TRUS, with
minimal pre-compression, the FOV including the prostate capsule and periprostatic
tissues, excluding the bladder. The measurement box should be placed in the
center of FOV.
ratio index (normal prostate tissue vs. peak stiffest region in the lesion) can be
used for prostate nodule characterization.
TRSE can be used for target biopsy guidance in addition to systematic biopsies.
Addition of TRSE can improve staging of prostate cancer as compared to TRUS
alone, but it cannot exclude capsular or extracapsular extension.
11
WFUMB Course Book 33. ELASTOGRAPHY
Fig 33.31
2D-SWE of the prostate. Fig 33.32
Both measured values are Spleen stiffness
higher than 35 kPa. Biopsy measurement by pSWE
should be targeted in the (VTQ technique from
stiffer area (98 kPa) Siemens)
Remember
• Prostate cancer nodules are stiffer than the surrounding tissue
• Elastography should be used in addition to TRUS to increase diagnosis
accuracy
• Prostate elastography can be used for targeting biopsy guidance in addition to
systematic biopsies
View enlarged image
The best results of spleen elastography are for predicting portal hypertension (PH).
Spleen stiffness (SS) is correlated to hepatic vein portal gradient (HVPG), and has
an excellent diagnostic accuracy for predicting clinically significant PH, regardless
of the technique (AUROC 0.92). TE measurement of SS with a dedicated software
is superior to classic TE software for predicting significant esophageal varices.
Point SWE (Fig 33.32) and 2D-SWE (Fig 33.33) techniques have shown mixed Fig 33.33
results for predicting the presence and severity of esophageal varices. Spleen stiffness
Pancreas elastography (SE and SWE) can be done either by transabdominal approach measurement by 2D-SWE
or by ecoendoscopy. It can be used as an additional tool to characterize chronic (Aixplorer System from
pancreatitis, but it cannot differentiate focal pancreatitis from pancreatic tumors. Supersonic Imaging)
12
WFUMB Course Book 33. ELASTOGRAPHY
• Images of SE of the liver courtesy of Larisa Sandulescu from the University of • Barr RG, Cosgrove D, Brock M et al. WFUMB Guidelines and Recommendations
Medicine and Pharmacy form Craiova, Romania. on the Clinical Use of Ultrasound Elastography: Part 5. Prostate. Ultrasound
• Images of breast and thyroid elastography courtesy of Dana Stoian from the Med Biol. 2017 Jan;43(1):27-48.
“Victor Babes” University of Medicine and Pharmacy Timisoara, Romania. • Barr RG, Ferraioli G, Palmeri ML, et al. Elastography Assessment of Liver
• Images of prostate elastography courtesy of Sorin Dudea from the “Iuliu Fibrosis: Society of Radiologists in Ultrasound Consensus Conference
Hațieganu” University of Medicine and Pharmacy Cluj-Napoca, Romania Statement. Radiology. 2015;276(3):845-861.
• Barr RG, Nakashima K, Amy D, et al. WFUMB guidelines and recommendations
for clinical use of ultrasound elastography: Part 2: breast. Ultrasound Med Biol.
2015 May;41(5):1148-60.
• Barr RG, Wilson SR, Rubens D, Garcia-Tsao G, Ferraioli G. Update to the
Society of Radiologists in Ultrasound Liver Elastography Consensus Statement.
Radiology. 2020;296(2):263-274.
• Cosgrove D, Barr R, Bojunga J et al. WFUMB Guidelines and Recommendations
on the Clinical Use of Ultrasound Elastography: Part 4. Thyroid. Ultrasound
Med Biol. 2017 Jan;43(1):4-26.
• Dietrich CF, Bamber J, Berzigotti A et al. EFSUMB Guidelines and
Recommendations on the Clinical Use of Liver Ultrasound Elastography,
Update 2017. Ultraschall Med. 2017 Aug;38(4):e48.
• Ferraioli G, Filice C, Castera L et al. WFUMB guidelines and recommendations
for clinical use of ultrasound elastography: Part 3: liver. Ultrasound Med Biol.
2015 May;41(5):1161-79.
• Ferraioli G, Wong VW, Castera L, et al. Liver Ultrasound Elastography: An
Update to the World Federation for Ultrasound in Medicine and Biology
Guidelines and Recommendations. Ultrasound Med Biol. 2018;44(12):2419-
2440.
• Săftoiu A, Gilja OH, Sidhu PS et al.The EFSUMB Guidelines and
Recommendations for the Clinical Practice of Elastography in Non-Hepatic
Applications: Update 2018. Ultraschall Med. 2019 Aug;40(4):425-453.
• Shiina T, Nightingale KR, Palmeri ML et al. WFUMB guidelines and
recommendations for clinical use of ultrasound elastography: Part 1: basic
principles and terminology. Ultrasound Med Biol. 2015 May;41(5):1126-47.
13