Polarization Diversity Controllable Monopulse Antenna Array Design

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 7

Received 5 January 2023, accepted 17 January 2023, date of publication 19 January 2023, date of current version 24 January 2023.

Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/ACCESS.2023.3238105

Polarization Diversity Controllable Monopulse


Antenna Array Design
SAEID KARAMZADEH , (Member, IEEE)
Millimeter Wave Technologies, Intelligent Wireless System, Silicon Austria Labs (SAL), 4040 Linz, Austria
Electrical and Electronics Engineering Department, Faculty of Engineering and Natural Sciences, Bahçeşehir University, 34349 İstanbul, Turkey
e-mail: karamzadeh@itu.edu.tr

ABSTRACT The design of a compact and wideband circularly polarized (CP) Monopulse antenna is
presented. Firstly, the small-sized antenna element (13mm × 13mm), with the impedance bandwidth (BW)
of 80.5% (4.3-10.1 GHz) and axial ratio (AR) bandwidth of 48.1% (6-9.8 GHz), and the gain of 7.2 dBic is
designed. The array structure consists of two rat-race couplers; two metalized via holes that generate sum and
difference patterns, and four branch-line couplers for CP characteristic improvement. The proposed antenna
is capable of controlling CP diversity in both sum and difference beams. Additionally, with 50% BW and
25% 3-dB AR results and also with null-depth of less than −48 dB, it is a convenient design for tracking
purposes.

INDEX TERMS Wideband, circularly polarized, monopulse antenna, polarization diversity.

I. INTRODUCTION A linearly polarized Monopulse array fed by four rat-


Monopulse radars are a perfect choice for tracking and detect- races couplers which cope with sum and difference patterns
ing targets due to their capability of gathering the target in orthogonal radiation planes, is presented in [3]. A dual-
distance and angle information with high speed and accuracy polarized (CP and LP) Monopulse antenna is introduced
using a single pulse [1], [2], [3], [4], [5], [6], [7], [8], [9], [10], in [11]; it has 2 × 2 Microstrip patch antenna arrays with
[11], [12]. two ports. One of the ports provides the sum (6) pattern with
Many techniques to realize Monopulse array antennas have circular polarization, and by exciting another port, a differ-
been reported in recent years [1], [2], [3], [4], [5], [6], [7], ence (1) pattern in all linear polarizations is attained. In [12]
[8], [9], [10], [11], [12]. However, employing waveguide horn a 2 × 2 reconfigurable CP patch antennas using a switchable
antennas is a common way of realizing Monopulse antennas, Monopulse comparator network have been reported. The sum
but it suffers from large size and difficulty in instruction. and difference outputs are provided based on a reconfigurable
The challenge of solving this problem led to applying planar phase convertor. In [13], the SIW resonant cavity is used
structure antennas such as Microstrip and substrate integrated to realize a Monopulse comparator in which the sum and
waveguide (SIW) antennas in designing Monopulse radar [1], difference patterns are given when the feeding cavity operates
[2], [3], [4], [5], [6], [7], [8], [9], [10], [11], [12]. Circu- at two high-order modes (TE120 and TE210), respectively.
larly polarized (CP) antennas have unique features such as In this article, a CP Monopulse array antenna based on CP
the ability to reduce polarization mismatch resulting from features has been proposed.
the multipath interference of wave propagation and also the In most of the works which up to now have been reported,
ability to cross the ionosphere has been considered by many the Monopulse antennas are not capable of controlling CP
researchers in various applications [4], [9], [10], [11], [12], diversity in both sum and difference beams independently,
[13], [14], [15], [16], [17], [18], [19], [20], [21], [22]. and it is the main goal of this paper.
Applying this technique helps to increase operation BW in
the Monopulse antenna because the right-hand CP (RHCP)
The associate editor coordinating the review of this manuscript and and left-hand CP (LHCP) work independently. Therefore, the
approving it for publication was Giorgio Montisci . use of a transceiver at a common frequency band is possible.

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License. For more information, see https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
7078 VOLUME 11, 2023
S. Karamzadeh: Polarization Diversity Controllable Monopulse Antenna Array Design

To attain this goal, in the first step, a dual-port dual CP


antenna element is designed.
The proposed element controls the CP diversity by helping
input ports and based on this feature, the feed network to
achieve dual CP Monopulse has been designed. The proposed
feed network composes of two 180-degree rat-race couplers
which play a role as comparator section, and four 90-degree
branch line couplers to improve CP features, especially in
different beam states. Moreover, the proposed antenna has a
broadband impedance BW, 3-dB axial ratio, and high gain,
and also supports a good null depth of less than −48 and
−38dB for ports 1 and 2, respectively. The measured results
confirm the designed and simulated one. Compared to similar
studies in the literature, the presented antenna offers circular
polarization diversity control for the first time, in addition to
its size, bandwidth, and gain advantages.

II. ANTENNA ELEMENT


The configuration of the proposed antenna element is dis-
played in Figure 1 a. It consists of a three-layer of Rogers
4003 substrate with a thickness of 0.508mm and relative
permittivity of (εr ) 3.55 and tanδ of 0.002. The first layer
includes a 90-degree patch coupler isolated from the top
layers (radiation section) by a metallic ground layer. The
output signal from the first layer is transferred to the second
layer by two metalized holes. The details of the proposed
90-degree patch hybrid coupler are displayed in Figure 1 b.
The second layer of the antenna consists of a square patch
with four same-sized stubs; two adjoined subs receive a signal
from 90-degree patch coupler outputs in the first layer by
mentioned via holes. FIGURE 1. The configuration of the proposed antenna element, a) layered
view, and b) dimension details.
Indeed, the middle layer patch by exciting two equal ampli-
tude power while having a 90-degree phase difference pro-
vides E-field rotation and CP condition. The second layer
E-field distribution while exciting each of the input ports is
shown in Figure 2. As seen by stimulating each of ports 1
and 2, the E-field distribution rotated in a state of RH
(Figure 2a) or LH (Figure 2b), respectively. Moreover, the
second layer couple the energy to the upper patch in the
third layer. When the E-field is rotated in the second layer,
undoubtedly, it will rotate in the coupled layer, and conse-
quently, a CP condition on the upper layer will be observed.
The top layer of the antenna is composed of a simple square
patch which, in comparison with the second layer, has a larger
size. In Fact, this difference in size leads to generating other
resonances at the antenna. FIGURE 2. The second layer E-field distribution while exciting each of the
input ports a) Port 1 and b) Port 2. (at the frequency of 8GHz).
The simulated results of the scattering parameters of the
proposed antenna are displayed in Figure 3 a. The proposed
antenna covers a frequency region from 4.3 to 10.1 GHz for
both input ports. The isolation between input ports because of frequency 8GHz of port 1 and port 2 respectively. In these
using a 90-degree patch coupler in the whole frequency band figures, solid lines are RHCP, dash lines are LHCP, black lines
is less than −15dB. The simulated axial ratio and gain of the are ϕ = 0◦ , and grey lines are ϕ = 90◦ ).
proposed antenna for ports 1 and 2 are displayed in Fig. 3b. The intensity and phase distributions of the near-field of
As illustrated, the proposed antenna has an AR<3dB in fre- the proposed antenna at the frequency of 8GHz are displayed
quency from 6 to 9.8GHz and a maximum gain of 7.2dBic at in Fig. 4. The figure results confirm that the proposed antenna
9GHz. Fig. 3.c and 3.d show the normalized radiation at the elements provide a beam with a directive pattern and a

VOLUME 11, 2023 7079


S. Karamzadeh: Polarization Diversity Controllable Monopulse Antenna Array Design

Obviously, there is a trade-off between results, and with


increasing a parameter other one is possibly decreased.
In Table, despite some of the works having better impedance
BW and 3-dB AR [16] or higher gain [15], [17], and [21],
despite the smaller size, the proposed antenna with a com-
promise between results has better performance with all
parameters.

III. FEED NETWORK


The configuration of the dual CP Monopulse feed is depicted
in Fig. 5. As illustrated, the proposed feed network consists
of two 180-degree rat-race couplers as a comparator section.
Each rat-races output by a Microstrip feed line connected to a
branch line coupler. When each of the sum pattern ports (6)
is excited, the radiation input ports receive an equal amplitude
with phase differences of 0, 90, 180, and 270 degrees, leading
to a CP directive radiation pattern. Likewise, by stimulating
each of the different pattern ports (1), both rat-race cou-
pler hybrid output ports receive the same magnitude and
phase. These signals enter the branch line coupler inputs,
FIGURE 3. The simulated results of proposed antenna elements; a) S11 , and consequently, at output ports of the branch line coupler,
S22 , and S12 , b) the simulated gain and AR versus frequency, c) the an equal amplitude and 90-degree phase difference are gener-
normalized radiation for port 1, and d) the normalized radiation for port 2
(at frequency of 8GHz) (solid lines are RHCP and dash lines are LHCP, ated, which is a suitable condition for arising a 1×2 CP array.
black lines are ϕ = 0◦ and grey lines are ϕ = 90◦ ). Therefore, in different beam states, there is an independent
CP antenna array composed of 1 × 2 elements at each of the
output ports of the comparator (rat-race coupler), and it leads
to a CP difference beam.
As shown in Fig. 6, creating both inputs of sum and
difference in the same layer is impossible. The difference
beam ports by helping a metalized via hole are transferred
to another layer. The details and results of the proposed met-
alized hole are illustrated in Fig. 6 a and b, respectively. The
designed metalized via covers a frequency region from 4 to
11 with an insertion loss of less than −0.5dB entire operation
frequency.
The return and insertion losses of proposed feed networks
in two states of sum and differences in beam ports are dis-
played in Fig. 7 a to d, respectively. The phase balance
performance was also analyzed and the simulated result is
shown in Fig. 7 e. As displayed, there is an equal output
magnitude from 6.5 to 9.5GHz with a magnitude error of less
FIGURE 4. The intensity and phase distribution of near-field of the than ±1.5dB. Also, the return losses for all ports are less than
proposed antenna. a) the near E-field intensity by exciting port 1, b) the −10dB from 6 to 10GHz.
near-field intensity by exciting port 2, c) the near-field phase by exciting
port 1, and d) the near-field phase by exciting port 2 (at the frequency of The far-field radiation characteristics of the proposed
8GHz). monopulse antenna have been measured in an anechoic
antenna chamber. In the measurement setup, excited at port
6, the monopulse antenna radiates sum pattern in both
near-field rotation around the axis of the beam which proved H- and E-planes, and excited at port 1, the monopulse
by phase distribution. As displayed, by exciting each of antenna radiates difference patterns in H- and E-planes.
ports 1 and 2, an RHCP and LHCP are achieved, respectively. S parameters of the antenna were measured by ‘‘Rohde
A comparison table is displayed in Table 1 to have a fair schwarz ZNB 43’’ vector network. Regarding the axial ratio
justification between the proposed antenna and some recent measurement, a linear polarized horn antenna as the refer-
dual CP antennas. As seen, the proposed element antenna ence antenna connected to a signal generator was used as
with compact size, broadband impedance BW, and the 3-dB the transmitter. The proposed antenna (antenna under test
axial ratio is brilliant in comparison with other works. More- (AUT)) was connected to a spectrum analyzer positioned at
over, the proposed antenna supports a relatively high gain. a distance from the reference antenna. The reference antenna

7080 VOLUME 11, 2023


S. Karamzadeh: Polarization Diversity Controllable Monopulse Antenna Array Design

TABLE 1. The comparison between proposed dual CP antenna element with recent works.

FIGURE 6. The configuration and results of proposed metalized via hole.


a) dimension, and b) S11 and S12 .

FIGURE 5. The configuration and ports of the proposed feed network.


a) the layered view, and b) the top view.

FIGURE 7. The return and insertion losses of proposed feed network at


a) Port 61, b) Port 11, c) Port 62 and d) Port 12.
was rotated and the AUT measured the received power from
different angles. The picture of the prototype of the pro-
posed Monopulse antenna and measurement setup is given
in Figure 8. return losses proved that there is a good agreement between
them. The measured results show the proposed antenna cov-
IV. RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS ers a frequency region of 50% from 6 to 10GHz in sum
The results of the proposed Monopulse antenna are given in and difference beam states for each of the four input ports.
this section. The return losses of dual CP Monopulse antenna Obviously, the high isolation between the ports validates
in two states of sums and difference beams are illustrated the best placement of the rat-race couplers and via-coupling
in Fig. 9. The comparison between simulated and measured structure.

VOLUME 11, 2023 7081


S. Karamzadeh: Polarization Diversity Controllable Monopulse Antenna Array Design

FIGURE 11. The comparison between simulated and measured radiation


patterns in two states of sum and difference ports 62 and 12 at: a)7GHz,
and b)9GHz.

FIGURE 8. The prototype of the proposed Monopulse antenna top view


and bottom view (left) view, and measurement setup (right).

FIGURE 9. The comparison between simulated and measured return loss


for input ports. a) Simulated, and b) Measured.
FIGURE 12. The intensity and phase distributions of near-field of
proposed CP Monopulse array antenna at the frequency of 8GHz a) port
61, and b) port 11.

The intensity and phase distributions of the near-field of


the proposed CP Monopulse array antenna at the frequency
of 8GHz are displayed in Fig. 12 and 13. In Fig12a, with the
excitation of the 61, the intensity plot (top) shows a directive
pattern (as the red color shows the high intensity and the blue
color shows the low intensity), and in the phase distributions
FIGURE 10. The comparison between simulated and measured radiation
plot (down) as changing the degree from −180 (blue color)
patterns in two states of sum and difference ports 61 and 11 at: a)7GHz, to +180 (red color) is clockwise, shows that the rotation is
and b)9GHz. right-sided. Therefore, the proof of a directive pattern with
RHCP is illustrated in Fig. 12. By exciting the 11 port of the
antenna, the analogous manner can be seen according to the
The comparison between simulated and measured radia- intensity and phase distribution plots in Fig. 12 b(top), and
tion patterns in two states of sum and difference for each Fig. 12 b(down), respectively.
of sum and difference beam states are displayed in Figs. 9 Likewise, Fig. 13 shows that, by exciting ports 62 and 12,
and 10. As displayed in Fig 10 and 11, the proposed CP basis on the intensity and phase of near-field, the antenna
Monopulse antenna has a low side lobe level in sum patterns provides a directive pattern (Fig. 13 top) with the LHCP
which is an advantage. The null depth in difference beam 11 (Fig. 13 down).
at two frequencies of 7 and 9 GHz is less than −48dB, and it Also, by comparing Fig. 12-13a with Fig. 12-13b is proved
for difference beam 12 is less than −38dB at two frequencies that by stimulating ports 11 and 12, a different beam with
of 7 and 9 GHz. This −10dB for two differences 11 and RHCP and LHCP are generated, respectively.
12 are related to applying a feed network at another layer. The comparison between simulated and measured gain and
The sharp null depth lets the tracking radar system be more AR of the proposed array antenna for input ports versus
sensitive to minor target changes and helps detect even the frequency are displayed in Fig. 14 and 15. The measured
slightest changes in the target’s position. gain provides an average gain of 12.5dBic for port 61 and

7082 VOLUME 11, 2023


S. Karamzadeh: Polarization Diversity Controllable Monopulse Antenna Array Design

TABLE 2. The comparison between proposed dual CP monopulse array antenna with recent works.

FIGURE 14. The comparison between simulated and measured gain


versus frequency in two states of sum and difference: a) ports 61 and 11,
and b) ports 62 and 12.

FIGURE 13. The intensity and phase distributions of the near-field of the
proposed CP Monopulse array antenna at the frequency of 8GHz a) port
62, and b) port 12.

9.4dBic for port 11. Likewise, the average measured gain


is 12 dBic for port 62 and 9 dBic for port 12. The use of
metalized via a hole in the lower layer feed network leads to
a decrease in the gain of it in analogous with the upper layer. FIGURE 15. The comparison between simulated and measured AR versus
Moreover, because the upper feed network is sandwiched frequency in two states of sum and difference: a) ports 61 and 11, and
b) ports 62 and 12.
between two grounds has lower loss compared to the lower
feed. Undoubtedly, these affairs haven’t been effective on AR
results. The measured results illustrate a 3-dB AR BW in the proposed antenna. The proposed CP Monopulse antenna is
whole 7-9GHz for input ports. one of few Monopulse antennas that support circular polar-
Table 2 presents some state-of-the-art Monopulse array ization and moreover it is also the only antenna capable
antennas that have been illustrated and compared with the of changing CP diversity at all sum and difference ports.

VOLUME 11, 2023 7083


S. Karamzadeh: Polarization Diversity Controllable Monopulse Antenna Array Design

Additionally, It has a compact size, broadband impedance, [11] K.-B. Kim, B. C. Jung, and J.-M. Woo, ‘‘A compact dual-polarized (CP,
3-dB AR BW, a relatively high gain, and good null-depth. LP) with dual-feed microstrip patch array for target detection,’’ IEEE
Antennas Wireless Propag. Lett., vol. 19, no. 4, pp. 517–521, Apr. 2020,
doi: 10.1109/LAWP.2019.2961159.
V. CONCLUSION [12] H. C. Sun, X. Ge, W. He, and L. Y. Zhao, ‘‘A reconfigurable antenna with
In this work, a high-gain Monopulse Antenna with the capa- sum and difference patterns for WLAN access points,’’ IEEE Antennas
Wireless Propag. Lett., vol. 19, no. 7, pp. 1073–1077, Jul. 2020, doi:
bility of CP diversity control in both sum and difference 10.1109/LAWP.2020.2988690.
beams is proposed. The designed antenna has high impedance [13] T. M. Yang, Z. Q. Zhao, D. Q. Yang, X. F. Liu, and Q. H. Liu,
bandwidth, high axial ratio bandwidth, and low null depth. ‘‘A single-layer SIW slots array monopulse antenna excited by a dual-
mode resonator,’’ IEEE Access, vol. 7, pp. 131282–131288, 2019, doi:
Single-element antenna and array structure design and results 10.1109/ACCESS.2019.2940635.
have been presented. The measurement shows good agree- [14] A. Kumar and S. Raghavan, ‘‘Broadband dual-circularly polarised SIW
ment between the simulated and fabricated antenna results. cavity antenna using a stacked structure,’’ Electron. Lett., vol. 53, no. 17,
pp. 1171–1172, Sep. 2017.
[15] Z. C. Hao, X. Liu, and X. Huo, ‘‘Planar high-gain circularly polarized
ACKNOWLEDGMENT element antenna for array applications,’’ IEEE Trans. Antennas Propag.,
In memory of Vahid Rafiei (1986–2021); vol. 63, no. 5, pp. 1937–1948, May 2015, doi: 10.1109/TAP.2015.2402293.
[16] R. K. Saini and S. Dwari, ‘‘A broadband dual circularly polarized square
This work is dedicated to the Best Friend, a Hard Worker slot antenna,’’ IEEE Trans. Antennas Propag., vol. 64, no. 1, pp. 290–294,
Colleague, a Great Kind Person with an all-time positive Jan. 2016, doi: 10.1109/TAP.2015.2496118.
smile on his face, and an Outstanding Engineer and a [17] C. Zhang, X. Liang, X. Bai, J. Geng, and R. Jin, ‘‘A broadband dual
circularly polarized patch antenna with wide beamwidth,’’ IEEE Anten-
Researcher in microwave and antenna design. nas Wireless Propag. Lett., vol. 13, no. 4, pp. 1457–1460, 2014, doi:
10.1109/LAWP.2014.2333760.
REFERENCES [18] Z. Mousavi, P. Rezaei, and V. Rafii, ‘‘Single layer CPSSA array with
change polarization diversity in broadband application,’’ Int. J. RF Microw.
[1] Z. Sun, S. Liu, Z. Hu, W. He, X. Zheng, and Y. Yang, ‘‘A compact
Comput.-Aided Eng., vol. 27, no. 4, Dec. 2016, Art. no. e21075, doi:
dual linearly-polarized single-plane monopulse antenna array based on
10.1002/MMCE.21075.
SIW and strip-line feed,’’ IEEE Trans. Antennas Propag., vol. 70, no. 8,
[19] Z. Mousavirazi, V. Rafiei, and T. A. Denidni, ‘‘Beam-switching antenna
pp. 6732–6739, Aug. 2022, doi: 10.1109/TAP.2022.3161302.
array with dual-circular-polarized operation for Wimax applications,’’
[2] M. Faenzi, D. Gonzalez-Ovejero, G. Petraglia, G. D’Alterio, F. Pascariello, AEU Int. J. Electron. Commun., vol. 137, Jul. 2021, Art. no. 153796.
R. Vitiello, and S. Maci, ‘‘A metasurface radar monopulse antenna,’’ IEEE [20] X. Bai, X. Liang, M. Li, B. Zhou, J. Geng, and R. Jin, ‘‘Dual-
Trans. Antennas Propag., vol. 70, no. 4, pp. 2571–2579, Apr. 2022. circularly polarized conical-beam microstrip antenna,’’ IEEE
[3] S. A. Khatami, J. Meiguni, A. Amn-e Elahi, and P. Rezaei, ‘‘Compact via- Antennas Wireless Propag. Lett., vol. 14, pp. 482–485, 2015, doi:
coupling fed monopulse antenna with orthogonal tracking capability in 10.1109/LAWP.2014.2369515.
radiation pattern,’’ IEEE Antennas Wireless Propag. Lett., vol. 19, no. 8, [21] S. Karamzadeh, V. Rafiei, and H. Saygin, ‘‘Development and miniaturized
pp. 1443–1446, Aug. 2020, doi: 10.1109/LAWP.2020.3005023. of circularly polarization diversity at cavity backed SIW antenna for X-
[4] H. Gharibi and F. Hodjatkashani, ‘‘Design of a compact high-efficiency cir- band application,’’ Frequenz, vol. 73, nos. 9–10, 2019, pp. 317–320.
cularly polarized monopulse cavity-backed substrate integrated waveguide [22] G. Q. Luo and L. L. Sun, ‘‘A reconfigurable cavity backed antenna
antenna,’’ IEEE Trans. Antennas Propag., vol. 63, no. 9, pp. 4250–4256, for circular polarization diversity,’’ Microw. Opt. Technol. Lett., vol. 51,
Sep. 2015. pp. 1491–1493, Mar. 2009, doi: 10.1002/MOP.24393.
[5] S. Li, Q. Zhang, J. Li, H. Zhao, X. Yin, and M. Yang, ‘‘Monopulse
antenna based on singular spoof surface plasmon polariton structure for
angle measurement,’’ Electronics, vol. 9, no. 12, p. 2156, Dec. 2020, doi:
10.3390/ELECTRONICS9122156.
[6] J. Zhu, S. Liao, S. Li, and Q. Xue, ‘‘60 GHz substrate-integrated
waveguide-based monopulse slot antenna arrays,’’ IEEE Trans. Antennas SAEID KARAMZADEH (Member, IEEE) received
Propag., vol. 66, no. 9, pp. 4860–4865, Sep. 2018. the M.S. and Ph.D. degrees from the Department
[7] F. Cao, D. Yang, J. Pan, D. Geng, and H. Xiao, ‘‘A compact single-layer of Communication Systems, Satellite Commu-
substrate-integrated waveguide (SIW) monopulse slot antenna array,’’ nication and Remote Sensing Program, Istanbul
IEEE Antenna Wireless Propag. Lett., vol. 16, pp. 2755–2758, 2017.
Technical University, in 2013 and 2015, respec-
[8] W. Li, S. Liu, J. Deng, Z. Hu, and Z. Zhou, ‘‘A compact SIW monopulse
tively. He currently works as a Senior Scientist
antenna array based on microstrip feed,’’ IEEE Antennas Wireless Propag.
Lett., vol. 20, no. 1, pp. 93–97, Jan. 2021.
with the Intelligent Wireless Systems Division of
[9] Y. Gao, W. Jiang, W. Hu, Q. Wang, W. Zhang, and S. Gong, ‘‘A dual- Silicon Austria Labs, Millimeter Wave Technolo-
polarized 2-D monopulse antenna array for conical conformal applica- gies Unit, and also holds a Professorship (Asso-
tions,’’ IEEE Trans. Antennas Propag., vol. 69, no. 9, pp. 5479–5488, ciate Prof. Dr.) with the Electrical and Electronics
Sep. 2021. Engineering Department, Faculty of Engineering and Natural Sciences,
[10] J. Hu, Z.-C. Hao, Z.-W. Miao, and Q. Yuan, ‘‘Millimeter-wave wideband Bahçeşehir University. His research interests include remote sensing, radar,
circularly polarized monopulse antenna using the sequential rotation feed- microwave, and antenna design. He was a recipient of the award for the most
ing technique,’’ Int. J. RF Microw. Comput.-Aided Eng., vol. 29, no. 1, successful Ph.D. Thesis from Istanbul Technical University.
Jan. 2019, Art. no. e21489.

7084 VOLUME 11, 2023

You might also like