Professional Documents
Culture Documents
VGB/BAW Standard Corrosion Protection For Offshore Wind Structures Part 2: Requirements For Corrosion Protection Systems
VGB/BAW Standard Corrosion Protection For Offshore Wind Structures Part 2: Requirements For Corrosion Protection Systems
VGB-S-021-02-2018-04-EN
VGB PowerTech - Public License Document - © 2018
Publisher:
VGB PowerTech e.V.
Publishing house:
VGB PowerTech Service GmbH
Verlag technisch-wissenschaftlicher Schriften
Deilbachtal 173, 45257 Essen, Germany
Preface
The growing number of wind turbines in Europe and the world raise new chal-
lenges to operators. To reduce the cost of installation and operation and to in-
crease operating reliability, a coordinated and joint analysis of operating experi-
ence is an absolute necessity. Apart from exchanging information and experi-
ence, the participating companies mainly strive to promote standardisation (best
practice). To this end, VGB PowerTech e.V. and Bundesanstalt für Wasserbau
(BAW – Federal Waterways Engineering and Research Institute) have decided
jointly to draw up a VGB/BAW Standard on corrosion protection for offshore
structures (e.g. offshore stations).
The aim of this standard is to ensure that the considerable investments in off-
shore structures are safeguarded by appropriate corrosion protection systems. In
this context, coating systems, for instance, are to protect the steel structures of
offshore units from corrosion damage, during their entire service life – which is
normally at least 25 years – and without requiring any expensive repair work.
Robust systems are therefore required which, while involving calculable manu-
facturing costs (CAPEX), can keep the operating costs (OPEX) at a predictable
and low level in the long term. Repair work at sea is to be avoided, as the cost of
such offshore repair work can exceed the cost of onshore repairs by a factor of
as much as 100.
VGB/BAW Standard VGB-S-021-02-2017-06-EN, published in June 2017, is re-
placed by the VGB/BAW Standard published in April 2018:
coating, and Part 4 the design, operation and monitoring of galvanic and im-
pressed-current protection systems. Parts 5 and 6 are currently in preparation
and will be concerned with the topics of coating system repair and in-service in-
spection and monitoring.
This VGB/BAW Standard is made available for use free of charge. It has been
written to the best of our knowledge, but cannot fully reflect the state of the art for
every conceivable case. Any liability, also for the factual presentation of the con-
tents, is excluded. Also, the users themselves are responsible for clarifying the
situation regarding patents and other property rights. The VGB/BAW Standard is
not in itself binding. Its application must be explicitly agreed between the con-
tracting parties.
Proposed changes can be sent to the email addresses vgb.standard@vgb.org
and info@baw.de. To enable unambiguous allocation of the contents, the sub-
ject line should contain a brief designation of the document concerned.
The following institutions and associations submitted comments on topics ad-
dressed by this standard, which were adopted in the process of editing this
standard:
Bundesamt für Seeschifffahrt und Hydrographie (BSH – German Maritime
and Hydrographic Agency), authority responsible for approving offshore
structures in Germany within the exclusive economic zone
Bundesverband Korrosionsschutz (BVK – Federal Association for Corrosion
Protection)
Verband der deutschen Lack- und Druckfarbenindustrie (VDL – German
Paint and Printing Ink Association)
Arbeitsgemeinschaft Offshore-Windenergie (AGOW – Offshore Wind Power
Consortium)
Fachausschuss für Korrosionsfragen (Committee for Corrosion Issues)
of Hafentechnische Gesellschaft (HTG-FAKOR)
DNV GL
WAB Windenergieagentur (WAB)
and other interested parties.
__________
A grey bar at the side indicates changes compared to the 2nd edition 2017.
Revised pages in this document: p. 6
Contents
1 General ...................................................................................................... 5
2 Scope......................................................................................................... 6
3 Corrosion protection systems................................................................. 7
3.1 Classification of corrosion protection systems ............................................ 7
3.2 General notes on the testing of corrosion protection systems .................... 8
3.3 Production of test panels ............................................................................ 8
4 Coating material analyses (wet sample) ............................................... 10
4.1 Coating material analysis (wet sample) .................................................... 10
4.2 Identity check on liquid coating material (fingerprint) ................................ 11
4.3 Identity check on cured coating material (fingerprint) ............................... 11
4.4 Details of the chemical composition of the components ........................... 12
1 General
Unprotected steel corrodes in the atmosphere, in water and in soil, possibly giv-
ing rise to damage. To avoid such corrosion damage, steel structures are pro-
tected so that they can withstand corrosion stresses during the required service
life, usually at least 25 years.
The offshore structures are exposed to strong corrosive influences over a long
period, while the conditions for maintenance and repair are poor. Along with cor-
rosion protection systems that must meet the highest demands, the idea of a cor-
rosion protection strategy must be taken into consideration. This means, among
other things, that the specific stresses in the various areas of offshore structures,
but also the co-operation of several methods of protection, e.g. coatings, duplex
systems (passive corrosion protection), cathodic protection (active corrosion pro-
tection) and corrosion allowance (see DIN 50929-3 Supplement 1) in submerged
areas, must also be taken into consideration.
This standard is concerned with offshore structures made of steel. In its various
parts it takes into account all essential factors having significance for appropriate
corrosion protection.
Project owners, ordering parties/principals, planners, advisors, firms carrying out
corrosion protection measures, supervisory personnel for corrosion protection
work and manufacturers of coating systems require state-of-the-art information
on corrosion protection through corrosion protection systems, in condensed form,
to protect steel structures effectively against corrosion. Such information must be
as complete as possible and unambiguous and easy to understand as well so
that complications and misunderstandings are avoided between the parties in-
volved in carrying out the protective measures.
In regard to the minimum requirements for corrosion protection concepts, refer-
ence is made to the BSH Standard “Mindestanforderungen an die konstruktive
Ausführung von Offshore-Bauwerken in der ausschließlichen Wirtschaftszone
(AWZ)” (Minimum requirements for the design of offshore structures within the
exclusive economic zone) as amended from time to time.
This standard defines additional requirements supplementing the standards and
VGB PowerTech - Public License Document - © 2018
2 Scope
This standard, “Corrosion Protection for Offshore Wind Structures - Part 2: Re-
quirements for Corrosion Protection Systems”, specifies the requirements for ini-
tial coatings of offshore structures exposed to water and atmosphere as defined
in Part 1 "General", Chapter 2 Scope.
This standard "Corrosion Protection of Offshore Structures for the Use of Wind
Energy - Part 2: Requirements for Corrosion Protection Systems" describes the
requirements for the initial application of passive corrosion protection of the fol-
lowing corrosion protection systems:
coating systems and
duplex systems.
VGB PowerTech - Public License Document - © 2018
Table 1a: Minimum number of coats (MNOC) and nominal dry film thickness (NDFT) required for the
coating system if no sprayed zinc coating/hot dip galvanized zinc coating is provided.
- Seabed
1 - Underwater zone (UWZ) 1 600
external and internal in each case
Table 1b: Minimum number of coats (MNOC) and nominal dry film thickness (NDFT) required for the
coating system if a thermally sprayed zinc coating/hot dip galvanized zinc coating is provided; sprayed zinc
coating incl. sealer or hot dip galvanized zinc coating, as the case may be, is not considered in the MNOC
and NDFT stated.
Note: Upon introduction of the 2nd edition of the VGB/BAW Standard, the Bundesanstalt für Wasserbau in
Karlsruhe is no longer a recognised test centre within the meaning of this standard.
The subjects of testing are the requirements laid down in chapters 4 and 5 of this
standard.
The test methods cover the following points:
coating material analyses,
tests after application of stress in the laboratory (Nos. 1 to 10) and
tests after application of stress in nature (No. 11).
The test certificates issued by the test centre serve to prove the suitability of the
corrosion protection systems.
VGB PowerTech - Public License Document - © 2018
The dimensions of the test panels to be used for the tests set out in chapter 5
hereinbelow are minimum dimensions; the specific dimensions are to be agreed
with the appointed test centre/laboratory.
Test panel preparation on unalloyed structural steel (e.g. S235) is performed by
blasting with the surface preparation grade B Sa 2½ (DIN EN ISO 8501-1). For
the blast-cleaned surface a medium roughness grade “medium G” as per DIN EN
ISO 8503-1 is required. For this purpose only angular abrasive (grit) is to be
used. Should other requirements be made of the roughness grade in the tech-
nical data sheet of the tested coating material, they must be taken into account.
The complete coating system is to be applied without intermediate weathering.
The details of the coating build-up shall be documented (as per Annex 2).
The film thicknesses specified in Annex 1, “Examples of suitable coating system
structures for each zone”, are to be understood as nominal film thicknesses
(NDFT) in accordance with DIN EN ISO 12944-5. The thicknesses of the individ-
ual coats and the overall coating system are measured according to ISO 19840.
If measured electronically, calibration takes place solely on a smooth surface.
The specified film thicknesses are defined as nominal dry film thickness. In diver-
gence from DIN EN ISO 12944-5 the following film thicknesses are permissible:
film thicknesses 50 µm: maximum 150 % of the nominal film thickness
film thicknesses > 50 µm: maximum 120 % of the nominal film thickness.
The minimum film thickness must be at least 80 % of the nominal film thickness,
the mean value at least 100 %.
The test panels are to be coated at room temperature (exception: hot spraying
systems). The application conditions shall be documented and signed by the ap-
plicator see Annex 3).
The test panels are conditioned for at least seven days in standard atmosphere
(23 °C/50 % relative humidity). Testing can start subsequent to this.
All test panels must be uniformly produced, i.e. at the same time with an identical
system build-up and application method. For laboratory testing, the panels are to
be coated on one side with the testing system, while the reverse side gets appro-
VGB PowerTech - Public License Document - © 2018
priate corrosion protection. For long-term exposure tests the test panels must be
coated on both sides with the testing system.
The viscosity and density according to DIN EN ISO 2811-1 are determined from
the individual components.
The following procedure is employed to examine the quantitative composition of
the individual components of the coating material:
The pigment or filler content is determined by weighing, after separation from
the resin, by means of centrifuging and drying in open air.
The percentage of volatile components (solvent content) of coating systems is
determined after initial weighing (after mixing), cured 24 h at room tempera-
10
10 mg
o Heating rate from 30 °C to 700 °C: 10 K/min in pure nitrogen
o Heating rate from 700 °C to 1,100 °C: 10 K/min in technical air
All FTIR spectra and HS-GC chromatograms, along with the results of thermo-
gravimetry, are to be attached.
11
12
Zone 2
Test/Rules Zone 1 Zone 3 Zone 4
No. (low water/
Stress zone (Seabed/UZ) (Atm. external) (Atm. internal)
tidal zone/SZ)
5 Salt spray test --- 2,160 h 1 [5] 2,160 h [5] 1,440 h [5]
The visual assessments must be made immediately after the end of the corrosive
stress.
The listed testing procedures are described below in chapters 5.1 to 5.11.
13
1 (seabed/UZ) /
Zones
2 (low water zone/tidal zone/SZ)
not less than 150 x 75 x 3 mm (sand-
wich method or one-side method with
Size of test panels reinforcement of reverse side)
not less than 150 x 75 x 5 mm (one-side
method)
Number of test panels 2 (one per test temperature)
Test requirements for the following tests are contained in the respective test de-
scription.
14
1 (seabed/UZ) /
Zones
2 (low water zone/tidal zone/SZ)
Drop height, drop mass 60 cm, 1 kg
15
16
Zone 1 (seabed/UZ)
Requirements/characteristics
17
18
19
Table 8: Test requirements for neutral salt spray (DIN EN ISO 9227).
Requirements/characteristics:
20
5.6 No. 6 – Cycle test (ageing resistance test according to ISO 20340;
where appropriate, ISO 12944-9)
Parallel to the longitudinal side at a distance of at least 30 mm from the edge, an
artificial scribe with a width of 2.0 mm and a length of 50 mm is mechanically ap-
plied (by milling). The duration of the test is 25 weeks (equal to 4,200 h). The
weekly rhythm is as follows:
three days, alternating every four hours, UVA radiation (= 340 nm; 60 3 °C)
and water condensation at 50 3 °C as per DIN EN ISO 11507
three days salt spray test as per DIN EN ISO 9227 (35 2 °C)
rinsing with demineralised water
one day dry storage at -20 2 °C.
After exposure the 3 test panels are to be subjected to 24-hour conditioning at
room temperature. The requirements to be met to pass the test, in respect of ad-
hesion, corrosion around the scribe and surface phenomena, are listed in Table
9. For corrosion around the scribe, 4 mm is defined as uniform limit value for all
systems.
Non-destructive tests are to be carried out immediately after exposure to the me-
dium has ended. Among other things, all damage criteria pursuant to DIN EN ISO
4628 such as blister, rust or crack formation, degree of flaking, embrittlement and
change in colour, etc. shall be recorded.
The loose and disbonded surface coating is removed with a suitable tool, and the
delamination and corrosion around the scribe are measured on the exposed sur-
face.
Testing for adhesion with an X-cut is carried out 1 hour (wet adhesion) and
24 hours (dry adhesion) after exposure to the medium has ended. To test for ad-
hesion with a pull-off test, the indenters are affixed 24 hours after exposure to the
medium has ended. The test is performed no later than 48 hours after exposure
to the medium has ended. Two out of three test panels must satisfy the require-
VGB PowerTech - Public License Document - © 2018
21
Requirements/characteristics:
22
Test
Potential
Test panel Preparation Use duration Medium
Ag/AgCl/KCltot.
in months
holiday on one
Nos. 1-3 CP -930 ±5 mV 9 Sea water
side
holiday on one Brackish
Nos. 4-6 CP -930 ±5 mV 15
side water
The test criteria for cathodic protection compatibility are listed in Table 11.
VGB PowerTech - Public License Document - © 2018
23
1 (seabed/UZ) /
Zones
2 (low water zone/tidal zone/SZ)
Number of test panels 6 (3 for sea water and 3 for brackish water)
Requirements/characteristics:
24
Requirements/characteristics:
25
1 (Seabed/UZ) /
Zones
2 (low water zone/tidal zone/SZ)
Duration of test 21 days
Demineralised water 2g
Requirements/characteristics
26
27
1 (Seabed/UZ) /
Zones
2 (low water zone/tidal zone/SZ)
Size of test panels not less than 300 x 200 x 4 mm
Requirements/characteristics:
28
The location must be chosen in such a way that the weathering area is as open
as possible. Undisturbed exposure to sunlight, surf, tides and spray are quality
characteristics in this respect.
Together with the coated test panels, standard specimens in accordance with
DIN EN ISO 9226 should also be exposed at the selected location and changed
annually in order to be able to document a progression of the stress intensity at
the location.
29
1 (Seabed/UZ) /
Zones
2 (low water zone/tidal zone/SZ)
Duration of test - 5 years
Recommended requirements/characteristics:
30
of degree of rusting
DIN EN ISO 4628-4 Paints and varnishes – Evaluation of degradation of coatings
– Designation of quantity and size of defects, and of intensi-
ty of uniform changes in appearance – Part 4: Assessment
of degree of cracking
DIN EN ISO 4628-5 Paints and varnishes – Evaluation of degradation of coatings
– Designation of quantity and size of defects, and of intensi-
ty of uniform changes in appearance – Part 5: Assessment
of degree of flaking
31
32
33
34
7 Literature
RWE-Spezifikation – Korrosionsschutz Stahlwasserbau, Ausgabe Februar 2013
– V2 (on request)
RWE-Spezifikation – Korrosionsschutz für fossil gefeuerte Kraftwerke, Atmo-
sphärischer Korrosionsschutz, Ausgabe September 2014 – V0 (on request)
Schröder, H. Th.: Abriebfestigkeiten der Korrosionsschutzbeschichtungen im
Stahlwasserbau, Werkstoffe und Korrosion 31, 866 (1980).
G. Binder, G.: Eignungsprüfung von Beschichtungsstoffen für den Stahlwasser-
bau – Langzeitauslagerung in natürlichen Gewässern,
Hansa 133 Nr. 2, 52-56 (1996).
Baumann, M.: Eignungsprüfungen von Beschichtungssystemen für den Stahl-
wasserbau – Kathodenschutzverträglichkeit von Beschichtungen,
Hansa 134, Nr. 2, 56–61 (1997).
VGB PowerTech - Public License Document - © 2018
35
8 Annexes
Annex 1: Examples of suitable coating system structures for each zone
Table 16: Coating system structures in Zone 1 (seabed and underwater).
1-01E 2K-EP-
1 50 2K-EP 1 550 2 600
Zn(R)
1-02E 2K-EP-
1 50 2K-EP 2 550 3 600
Zn(R)
1-03E 2K-EP-
1 50 2K-EP 3 550 4 600
Zn(R)
1-04E 2K-EP-
1 50-100 2K-EP 3 500-550 4 600
div.
1-08E 1K-
PUR- 1 50 1K-PUR 3 550 4 600
Zn(R)
1-09E x x x x x x x 600
VGB PowerTech - Public License Document - © 2018
36
Table 17: Coating system structures in Zone 2 (low water, tidal zone, splash zone).
2-09E x x x x x x x 600
VGB PowerTech - Public License Document - © 2018
37
3-03E 160-
2K-EP 1
2K-EP- 250
1 50-100 + + 3 360
div. +
2K-PUR 1
60-100
3-04E 210-
1K-PUR 1
1K-PUR- 250
1 50 + + 3 360
Zn(R) +
2K-PUR 1
60-100
3-05E 2 210-
1K-PUR
1K-PUR- 250
1 50 + + 4 360
Zn(R) +
2K-PUR 1 60-100
3-06E 140-
80-100 2K-EP 1
Zinc 180
1 + Sea- + + 2* 240 *
coating +
ler 2K-PUR 1
60-100
3-07E x x x x x x x 360/240
* without zinc coat and sealer
4-01E 2K-EP-
1 50 2K-EP 1 250 2 300
VGB PowerTech - Public License Document - © 2018
Zn(R)
4-02E 2K-EP-
1 50 2K-EP 2 250 3 300
Zn(R)
4-03E 2K-EP-
1 50-100 2K-EP 1 200-250 2 300
div.
4-04E 80-100
Zinc
1 + Seal- 2K-EP 2 200 2* 200 *
coating
er
4-05E x x x x x x x 300/200
* without zinc coat and sealer
38
Components: Binders:
39
Solvents (stating hazard class = Gfkl.) Solvents (stating hazard class = Gfkl.)
.............................. ....... Mass% , Gfkl. ......... .............................. .......... M.-% , Gfkl. .......
.............................. .......... M.-% , Gfkl. ......... .............................. .......... M.-% , Gfkl. .......
VGB PowerTech - Public License Document - © 2018
.............................. .......... M.-% , Gfkl. ......... .............................. .......... M.-% , Gfkl. .......
.............................. .......... M.-% , Gfkl. ......... .............................. .......... M.-% , Gfkl. .......
Enclosure of EU safety data sheet, technical data sheet is obligatory.
40
DFT
Drying conditions
Product names of indi- Batch [µm]
Application
vidual coating materials number Tem- Relat.
method
(material type) (colour) perature humidity Date
[°C] [%]
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Total film thickness
Application method:
AS: Airless spraying PS: Pneumatic spraying
Br: Brushing R: Roller coating
41
Legend:
Schweißdraht anlöten Ø 3-5 mm solder welding wire (diameter 3-5 mm) here
Verletzung scribe
42
CP stability x
7 (without colouring top 15 months I --- ---
coats)
43