Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Cog Retraining in LD
Cog Retraining in LD
Cog Retraining in LD
net/publication/273766354
Malhotra S., Rajender G., Sharma V. and Singh T.B. (2009): Efficacy of
cognitive Retraining, Techniques in children with learning Disability: Delhi
Psychiatry Journal 12:100-106.
CITATIONS READS
0 841
1 author:
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Media , Mental Health & Society : My current project on which Iam working actively. View project
Effect of smoking and cotton dust exposure on lung function View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Tej Bahadur Singh on 20 March 2015.
Original Article
Efficacy of Cognitive Retraining
Techniques in Children with Learning Disability
Shahzadi Malhotra*, G. Rajender**, Vibha Sharma*, T.B.Singh*
*Department of Clinical Psychology, Institute of Human Behaviour and Allied Sciences (IHBAS),
Dilshad Garden,Delhi and **Department of Psychiatry, UCMS & G.T.B. Hospital, Dilshad Garden, Delhi,
University of Delhi
Abstract
Background :Cognitive Retraining(CR) is known to help in reattainment of cognitive abilities
following brain injury.Due to high cerebral plasticity in children,CR can perhaps also be used
to ameliorate known cognitive deficits in children with learning disability. Objectives: To study
the efficacy of cognitive retraining techniques for enhancing cognitive skills and scholastic
performance in children with learning disability. Sample & Methods: Pre and Post experimental
design study was carried out with thirty children(between eight to ten years of age), with
diagnosis of mixed disorder of scholastic skills(ICD-10). Each subject was given 36 hours of
manualized CR package over 18weeks, consisting of activities for sustained attention,visuospatial
skills,visual memory;and verbal learning and memory.Pre and post intervention assessment;
was done using NIMHANS Index for Specific Learning Disability,Grade Level Assessment
Device(GLAD) and Rey’s Auditory Verbal Learning Test(AVLT).SPSS version12.0 was used for
descriptive and analytical statistical analysis. Results:Highly significant improvement was noted
in total verbal learning, delayed verbal recall,visuo-spatial skills and mathematics(p>0.01).Also,
there was significant improvement in sustained attention(time taken and errors),visual memory
and immediate verbal recall(p>0.05). Conclusion:Manualized cognitive retraining over thirty
six hours can help to partially remediate cognitive deficits in children with learning disability
and improve their scholastic performance. The findings have implications for future educational
curricula aiming at improved academic performance stemming from an enhanced skill base
rather than from just educational based interventions.
Keywords: Cognitive retraining,Learning disability
stroke, tumor, or a head injury). These methods if one uses cognitive retraining techniques with
typically involve massed practice and drill them ,it is highly likely that these techniques would
approaches, along with other psychologically based enhance the cognitive functioning of children and
intervention methods. The two key elements of any thus, potentially enhance their academic perfor-
cognitive retraining programme are:- repetition to mance. This would further have a profound impact
make the skill automatic, and appropriate reinforce- on education. In addition, improved academic
ment. The neuro-cognitive domains which are performance stemming from an enhanced skill base
considered for retraining include- arousal and (e.g., improved attentional skills, improved
orientation, attention and concentration, memory, deductive and inductive reasoning, ability to
visual and spatial perceptual abilities, language and manipulate numbers and concepts, etc.) rather than
verbal skills, executive functions (reasoning, from just educational based interventions would
planning, organization, problem solving), life skills appear a more desirable avenue as the child would
and social skills. Each identified skill is retrained actually “own” the skills to acquire knowledge and
using sequentially increasing graded practice of prevent “Matthew effect”.11
activities using the method of saturation cueing There are very few studies which have studied
followed by generalization. It makes use of the the effects of cognitive retraining interventions in
person’s stronger capacities to bolster the weaker children with learning disability12,13.These studies
ones. The process continues with diminishing have restricted to retraining in one or two cognitive
degrees of assistance. domains. Most Indian studies have restricted their
A number of cognitive retraining methods have interests to psychosocial concomitants of learning
been utilized, most of which use specially designed disability14,15,16. There are almost no reported Indian
computer software, and are called computer assisted studies which have studied the above effects of CR
cognitive rehabilitation (CACR). The empirical in learning disorder. This study is an attempt in this
evidence for CACR seems to indicate a potential direction.
for improving cognitive function6. The widespread
Aims And Objectives
use of computer assisted cognitive retraining
procedures is largely because the computers allow To study the efficacy of cognitive retraining
accurate timing of stimulus presentation. Further, techniques for enhancing cognitive skills and
it is possible to regulate time of stimulus presenta- scholastic performance in children with learning
tion based on individual’s performance. However, disability.
the drawback of these programmes is their rigidity Material and Methods
which may be incongruent with patient’s need. The
floor and ceiling level along with the task content Sample:
are relatively fixed. Further, the cost of cognitive A pre and post experimental design study was
retraining soft wares is another major limitation. carried out with a sample of 30 children with
Manualized retraining programmes overcome these diagnosis of Mixed Disorder of Scholastic Skills
limitations though at the cost of precision. However, (ICD-10) were recruited. These children between
found no difference in outcome between computer ages 6 to 10 years were studying in English medium
assisted and manualized cognitive retraining schools in Delhi in Grade 1st to 4th and were
programs which are more suited in Indian context7. reported to be having difficulties in school perfor-
Neuropsychological studies, structural and mance. The diagnosis was confirmed using
functional imaging as well as electrophysiological psychometric assessments. All children in the
studies provide evidence for central nervous system sample had average level of intellectual function-
dysfunction in learning disabilities 8,9,10 .The ing, were attending school regularly and without
literature on cognitive retraining strongly purports any study breaks. Children having any physical
that cognitive retraining is an effective therapeutic disability, subnormal level of intellectual function-
module for enhancing cognitive skills. Considering ing, any sensory impairments, children from single
high cerebral plasticity in children and the relation parent families or those having any other
between cognitive skills and academic performance, developmental disorder other than lear ning
Delhi Psychiatry Journal 2009; 12:(1) © Delhi Psychiatric Society 101
DELHI PSYCHIATRY JOURNAL Vol. 12 No.1 APRIL 2009
disability / any other neurological / psychiatric / or design test consists of 9 blocks (cubes) each
any other major medical illness were excluded from with two red sides, two white sides and two
the study. sides-half red and half white-divided
diagonally. The block design test has a test
Tools:
retest reliability of 0.77 and split half
These children were assessed using the reliability of 0.87.
following: Benton Visual Retention Test21 to assess
• NIMHANS Index for Specific Learning visual memory and visual perception. The
Disability: 17 comprises of Malin’s test provides a clinical and research
Intelligence Scale for Indian Children instrument with which to assess visual
(MISIC), Digit Vigilance Test, Bender perception, visual memory, and visuo
Gestalt Test, Test of Visuo-Motor Integra- constructive abilities. Interscorer agree-
tion, Auditory Memory Test, Benton Visual ment with respect to total scores on the
Retention Test along with tests of Academic BVRT Administration A is approx 0.94.
Performance that include reading, writing, • Indian Adaptation of Rey’s Auditory
arithmetic, spelling and comprehension. Verbal Learning Test22 was used to
For the present study, the Tests for measure verbal memory. The test is an
Academic Performance of this battery were individually administered test and gives a
replaced by GLAD. measure of immediate memory, acquisition
• Grade Level Assessment Device (GLAD) of new learning, retention, primacy, and
for Children with Learning Problems in recency effects, susceptibility to proactive
Schools18 to assess scholastic performance. and retroactive interference. This test has
The GLAD assesses the level of academic been found to be sensitive to the defects of
performance in three basic subjects viz. specific, clinically relevant components of
Hindi, English and Mathematics, in primary the process of verbal learning and memory.
school children while systematically This test has shown moderate test-retest
making an observation of the processing reliability over one year interval. Most
pattern in the child. The test- retest reliable measures are total number of words
reliability of GLAD ranges from 0.68 for learned over the five learning trials (r=
Grade IV to 0.99 for grade III. Its Criterion 0.77). RAVLT correlates moderately well
validity ranges from 0.74 to 0.89. with other measures such as the California
For assessment of targeted cognitive skills at Verbal Learning Test.
pre intervention and post intervention, the following
tests of the NIMHANS SLD Index were utilized: Intervention Techniques Used
Digit Vigilance Test 19 was used for Activities in areas of attention, memory and
assessment of sustained attention. This test visuo-spatial abilities were adapted from various
is also a measure of accurate visual scann- cognitive r ehabilitation therapy software
ing and activation and inhibition of a rapid programmes like PSCogRehab95, Challenge of the
response. The test consists of numbers 1 to Mind23 and used in manualized forms. Activities
9 randomly ordered and placed in 50 rows used for attention involved both visual and auditory
on a page having 30 digits per row. The modality and involved various adaptations of
subject has to focus on target digits amongst cancellation tasks, vigilance tasks, discrimination
other distracter digits. The test gives two in the presence of distr acters, continuous
scores (a) the time taken to complete the performance tasks, scanning tasks, and mazes.
test and (b) Error Score-Sum total of the Activities that targeted memory again involved both
number of omissions and the number of auditory and visual modalities. These activities
commissions. included various verbal recall tasks, with increasing
Block Design Test20 for assessment of level of complexity, Chinese whispers, design
visuo-constructive abilities. The block recall, pattern recall, sequential verbal recall, visual
102 Delhi Psychiatry Journal 2009; 12:(1) © Delhi Psychiatric Society
APRIL 2009 DELHI PSYCHIATRY JOURNAL Vol. 12 No.1
spatial recall and encoding activities. For enhancing tests were re-administered.
visuo spatial skills the activities included visual
Analysis
copying tasks, various levels of substitution tasks,
spatial grids and sequencing activities. The data thus collected following the above
design and procedure was interpreted using mean
Procedure and standard deviation and compared through t-test
Children and parents were educated about the using SPSS version 12.0.
nature and procedure of the study. The children were
Results
enrolled for the study after obtaining parental
consent. All the activities that were to be used in The mean age of the sample was 8.2 years (SD
order of administration, including each program’s 0.68). The majority of the sample comprised of boys
description, mater ial requirements, set up, and the mean number of educational years for the
instructions to students, response inputs, were sample was 5.2 years (SD= 0.86). Tables 1 and 2
compiled. The first few sessions were devoted to show the mean and SD for pre intervention and post
baseline assessments of children. All the baseline intervention conditions along with t- values.
assessments were done individually. After the pre Table 1 shows the pre and post intervention
intervention assessments, the participants began the mean scores for the sample along with the obtained
retraining sessions, which were to be administered t- values for all the cognitive domains. The table
twice a week, over eighteen weeks. Of these 36 reveals that the t-values were significant for
sessions, 20 were individual sessions while 16 were attention (both time taken and errors), visual
group sessions. Each session lasted for one hour. memory, and immediate verbal recall (p <0.05).
Unlike cognitive retraining with brain injured The values were highly significant (p <0.01) for
patients, the students were moved on to the next delayed recall, total learning and visuo spatial skills.
lesson regardless of mastery of goals on the lesson. Further, the study of the mean scores reveals that
However, high scores obtained by individual the sample performed better on all the targeted
students were appreciated during sessions where cognitive skills in post intervention condition
participants could see them as reinforcement. After The scholastic performance of children- both
the completion of the 36-lesson program, all the pre and post intervention and the t-values thus
obtained by their comparison are shown in Table largely included activities in the basic cognitive
2.. The obtained t-values were found to be highly skills of attention, visual memory, verbal memory
significant for Mathematics (p<0.01) but were not and visuospatial skills. Based on Piaget’s Cognitive
significant for Hindi and English. In addition Development Theory these activities with graded
to the t-values, considering the pre and post difficulty level were included and were associated
intervention mean scores it is implied that post with all the three levels: concrete, semi concrete
intervention, study group has shown improvement and abstract.
on Mathematics. From the results section, it is observed that
cognitive retraining produced significant enhance-
Discussion
ment in the targeted cognitive skills of children
Cognitive Retraining techniques (CRT) have (Table 1). With respect to attention, there is a
been reported to produce improvement in patients significant reduction in the time taken to complete
of traumatic brain injury24. Also CRT has been used the task and number of errors committed. It was
with patients of schizophrenia25, epilepsy 26, and also observed that there was a reduction in both the
substance abuse27 and have been found to be useful. number of omissions (indicative of visual scanning)
The present study was the first of its kind in India as well as commissions(indicator of response
in which efficacy of CRT was studied in children inhibition). Thus, with retraining both visual
with learning disability and its impact on school scanning and response inhibition improved. Gains
performance was assessed. in performance on test of visual memory and visuo
In the recent years, the children with Specific spatial skills have also been observed. There has
Developmental Disorder of Scholastic Skills have been significant enhancement in all three measured
been implicated to have impairment in neuro- aspects of verbal memory. This implies that either
biological pathways. For example, in dyslexia, the the consolidation process has improved or/ and
functional imaging studies have implicated the interference processes have decreased with this
anterior network (inferior frontal gyrus) and the two training package. Bracy et al. used computerized
posterior networks of parieto temporal (word cognitive skills training program which focused on
analysis) and the visual word form area (occipito training attentional, executive, visuospatial and
temporal) 28. The present authors have studied problem solving skills in 12 to 14 year old children
children with mixed disorder of scholastic skills as and reported a significant increase in intellectual
they are expected to have impairment in many functioning (p< .01)30. Also, studies have reported
neurocognitive domains and associated neuro- significant improvement in attention after 10
biological pathways, which were specifically training sessions by using Computer Assisted
targeted using CRT. There is evidence from studies Instruction (CAI) approach for enhancing attention
that impairment in cognitive and scholastic skills in elementary school children31. Review of these
lead to impairment in scholastic performance. For Cognitive Retraining Therapies32 have stressed on
instance, it has been reported that attention and techniques that are geared toward improving visual
memory to play a crucial role in information scanning and ‘retraining’ of patients to attend to
processing29 . A strong association has been the neglected field as the mainstay of these
reported among reading speed and accuracy, teacher therapies.
rated scholastic assessment; attention span and Further, in the post intervention condition, there
visual reaction time. have been significant improvements in children’s
Hence probably by targeting these cognitive performance on mathematics. However, there have
domains using CRT one can enhance the scholastic been no significant gains in the two language
performance of these children and can also prevent subjects (Table 2). It is known that in addition to
Matthew effect 11. In this study subjects were given deficits in cognitive skills, children with learning
36 sessions of manualized cognitive retraining over disability also have difficulty in understanding
a period of 18 weeks and were then followed up phonetic sounds and sound blending which play a
after a period of 6 months. This manualized very important role in r eading and writing
cognitive retraining module developed for the study processes, and are the building blocks of languages
104 Delhi Psychiatry Journal 2008; 12:(1) © Delhi Psychiatric Society
APRIL 2009 DELHI PSYCHIATRY JOURNAL Vol. 12 No.1