Professional Documents
Culture Documents
05 - Ballet Philippines - A Sociological History
05 - Ballet Philippines - A Sociological History
JOOEAN TAN
10
_.
class dance company with a unique political scene under the Marcoses, the
Filipino style. fund-raising was quite difficult. They were
doing so much fund raising them-
Elaborating on Imelda Marcos's com-
selves....You had [business] companies that
mitment to ballet, Alice Reyes concluded
said, we don't have this money because
that "she would seize the opportunity
when Imelda Marcos comes calling for a
...when we would have a big [guest] artist
check.... our budget is [limited]. I was
and take over.
always confronted with that."
"When Makarova, Natasha Makarova,
Nevertheless, Ballet Philippines
came-she was big-somebody told Imelda
thrived during this period. The company
that she was big and immediately, the
had built an extensive and varied repertoire
invitation came up ...she could stay in the
of classical ballet and modern dance along
·w palatial guestroom, cars were sent for her,
with its unique Filipino works. It was
you know, message at night, summons:
during this period that Ballet Philippines
come to a little intimate party for 300
established a reputation as a company
people."
" that had the ability to attract audiences
Alice Reyes would make it a point to worldwide, and artistic critics generally
include at least one of its Philippine works wrote glowingly about their perform-
, in the program-such as Amada or Itim ances. In effect this dance company had
Asu-of the performances with the guest become a cultural ambassador for the
artist for she wanted to demonstrate to the country (Logarta 1990), and thus indirectly
highly international audience just where provided social legitimacy for the Marcos
the company was in its own artistic regime in various parts of the globe.
development. Imelda Marcos would leave
It should be apparent that the success
by the back when Ballet Philippines
of Ballet Philippines needs to be
performed the Philippine works.
understood within the social, political, and
While being the resident company at economic context in which it emerged.
the CCP had its benefits such as free Imelda Marcos was a powerful patron
rehearsal and performance space, the who occupied a politically well-defined
company had to continuously engage in position asFirst Lady, and her husband was
fundraising for all other expenses. Ballet the most important politician in the
Philippines had to compete with other country. Under these circumstances, the
artistic groups for the same limited pool question arises as to how Ballet Philippines
, of resources. Having Imelda Marcos as was able to sustain a considerable degree
their patron undoubtedly helped. Yet, the of autonomy and was able to pursue its
fund raising activity of the Marcoses artistic goals with a minimum of political
would, of course, be given priority by the interference by the Marcoses.
contributors.
First, it should be recognized that
Alice Reyes elaborated on the problem Alice Reyes not only knew Imelda
of fund raising. "In those days, with the Marcos as a young woman but also had
11
•
,
developed an extensive social network all kinds of staff men to go to her box
with a wide range of influential persons one night and they had to say, "Madam,
within the Philippines. Thus, Alice Reyes's it is going to be an international
socialcapital undoubtedly aided the fund embarrassment if you don't let them go
raising efforts for the ballet company. because commitments have been made
Second, as mentioned earlier, Imelda and tickets had been sold. They must
Marcos did not have an active interest in go."
ballet as an artistic endeavor in its own
right. Rather her sponsorship provided That the members and supporters of
her with the opportunity to interact with Ballet Philippines seem to have understood
world-renowned artists (and celebrities) the paradoxes inherent in the patronage
from other nations. Her lack of interest afforded the ballet company by Imelda
in ballet as an art form also meant that Marcos is well expressed by Edna Vida:
she did not intervene in shaping the "We were so apolitical, right? We had to
artistic development of Ballet Philippines. be apolitical. First of all, we were always...
There was no hint of direct intervention accused of catering so much to Imelda
in specific ways in which this art form Marcos, which is one hundred percent not
was created: Third, the ballet's global true. We did cater to her because she was
activities and the artistic acclaim it it.. .Any snap of her fingers and she would
achieved gave the company considerable get what she was asking for. But she could
autonomy. As an instance when Imelda never dictate to us what she wanted."
Marcos wanted the ballet to remain in The Marcos regime in the Philippines
Manila for the Miss Universe pageant, the came to a rather abrupt end in 1986 as
international tour took precedence. Alice the country experienced a major political
Reyes explains: upheaval-an upheaval that was chronicled
by the world press in some detail. The
We had arranged for a 52-performance
1986 Revolution brought in the admin-
tour in Asia, starting from Australia and
istration of President Corazon Aquino,
then all over Asia. It was wonderful
.'
and it ushered in a new phase for Ballet
because we were able to get some
Philippines.
funding from the government. There
was [also] pressure on Philippines
Airlines to give us tickets. Of course NATIONALISTIC CONTENT
everything else was done on our own. The Aquino administration came to expect
But Imelda was having the Miss that Ballet Philippines would playa more
Universe [pageant] at the Folk Arts overt political role in fostering Filipino
Theater, and she did not want us to nationalism. This expectation was
leave. Because it was a dictatorship we explicitly laid out in a statement made in
had to have her okay. Just imagine what 1987by President Corazon Aquino during
stress that was...She was saying, "Why the 17th Anniversary Concert Season. She
are they going to leave, everybody is exhorted artists to "let the dance also
going to come here to perform." It took portray the artist as a Filipino who is
12
•
proud of his nation's history, people, and For the remainder of that season, the
heritage" (Logarta 1990). There was a performances staged by Ballet Philippines
nationalistic fervor in the country that was had distinctive Filipino themes. Aside from
not present before, and this fervor the performances of classical ballet works,
permeated every aspect of society as it the others included Portraits of the Filipina
swept through the nation. The arts were (Cultural Center of the Philippines 1987c),
only one of the outlets for the promul- and Siete Dolores and Ang Pilya (Cultural
gation of this nationalism. Edna Vida Center of the Philippines 1988). While
confirmed this trend. "This happened Ballet Philippines always presented a
13
•
What we have, then, especially in the were at the bottom of the priority list
early period of the Aquino revolution, is a for government [expenditures]. Every-
movement not only to glorify the body was busy supporting the
revolution but also to privilege various revolution and nobody was going to
sectors of Filipino society, including the give money to the arts.
folk traditions. By incorporating these
once marginal traditions into ballet, the It could be argued that there was
ballet demonstrated how these once stagnation in the arts at this time. The
marginal groups contributed to "high contradictory combination of a decline in
culture" and helped give expression to funding and the required support of
Filipino nationalism. nationalism in the Philippines at this
'.
time did not provide fertile ground for
It should be noted that Ballet the development of Ballet Philippines.
Philippines did playa "national" role This period also marked the beginning
during the Marcos era'. For example, the of what was to be a downturn in the
CCP Dance Company was part of a report fortunes of the company.
on Philippine Cultural Development on
behalf of President Ferdinand Marcos and PERSONALITY POLITICS
First Lady Imelda Marcos (Reyes, n.d.). In
this report Reyes outlined the objectives Following the demise of the Aquino
of the company, among which were "the regime, Ballet Philippines seems to have
expansion of a distinctly Filipino dance entered a third phase in its thirty-year
form" and the promotion of "the existence. In general, this encompassed
Philippine art and culture abroad." How- both the Ramos and the Estrada regimes
ever, during the Aquino era,' Ballet (until the time of the conclusion of my
Philippines was drawn more directly into research in mid-2000). During this period
the political fray, and the ballet company there has been a decline in the vitality of
was expected to advance a social and the company. When Fidel Ramos was
political agenda, particularly to further President, the First Lady, Amelita Ramos,
nationalism. became the patron of Ballet Philippines.
According to Edna Vida, the situation of
Although the Aquino administration the Ballet improved, but Amelita Ramos
expected Ballet Philippines, and the arts in did not promote "high culture" as did
general, to play a supportive role in Imelda Marcos.
fostering the emerging nationalism, the
arts, it should be emphasized, took a back At the time of the interviews, Ballet
seat with respect to almost all budgetary Philippines had shrunk to only twelve
considerations. This resulted in financial company members, two men and ten
and other problems for the ballet. Edna women, compared to more than thirty
Vida observed: when at full-strength. It has been
maintained at this strength for some time,
Cory's time and the following years although the company recently has had
were very difficult for us because we auditions, and now has eight apprentices
14
•
'. and two scholars (Ballet Philippines Philippines had become caught up in the
2001). Agnes Locsin describes the main political fray.
problems facing the company as a lack of
A third factor in the decline of Ballet
adequate funding and the departure of
Philippines is less evident from the
some dancers.
interviews, but nonetheless quite apparent.
The exodus of men has been an This is the fact that the ballet company
especially vexing problem. Agnes Locsin and other art forms associated with "high
sees the financial imperative as the main culture" have had to compete actively with
reason why men leave. The rising cost of the mass entertainment industry for
living effectively shrank the dancers' resources, for time, and for the public
salaries. It seems that many leave Ballet attention. The displacement of Ballet
15
••
(the founder of Ballet Philippines). Philippines no longer had the First Lady
.'
Although Imelda Marcos expected the as a patron. She had been, whatever her
company to cater to her whims, Ballet reasons, very committed to promoting this
Philippines had sufficient autonomy to type of cultural activity. Her sponsorship
accommodate them while continuing to resulted in high visibility for the company,
develop its own highly innovative and and it facilitated fund raising. The
independent artistic vision. endorsement by the First Lady meant
that the political and economic elite was
The second phase was ushered in by
more likely to be involved in supporting
the 1986 Revolution that brought the
ballet as an art form. When the patronage
Aquino administration into power. During
of Imelda Marcos vanished, the 'support
this time Ballet Philippines was given the
for the company dwindled over time.
role of promoting the nationalism that
the Revolution had engendered. However, The case of Ballet Philippines
little financial support was forthcoming underscores the difficulties of institution-
from the state. alizing personalistic patronage of the arts.
Institutionalization provides legitimacy for
The third phase has been one of
the funding by philanthropic or corporate
financial constraints, and the relative
groups or by the state. For a company like
decline of the company as an artistic force.
Ballet Philippines, which is located in a
Although the pattern may be reversed now
society where "high culture" has not been
that Denisa Reyes (sister of Alice Reyes)
given the legitimacy of institutionalization,
has become the artistic director of Ballet
personalistic patronage becomes a critical
Philippines, the effort to rebuild this
factor in its survival. However, person-
company is likely to encounter difficulties.
alistic patronage in developing societies is
The problem of paying dancers sufficient
likely to be transitory.
monies to support themselves will need to
be overcome if Ballet Philippines is to train Second, there was an ideological shift
and retain high quality dancers, especially in the nation as a result of the 1986
.'
male dancers. And this will require Revolution. This was supposedly a
considerable patronage by philanthropic democratizing revolution of "people
and corporate sponsors or by the state power" whereby, in the ideal, elitism of any
(Wulff 1998, 54). sort was no longer acceptable. This
realignment of the power structure
We shall elaborate somewhat on the
redefined the nation's priorities. This shift
factor of, personalistic patronage
from an authoritarian government to a
(associated with phase one), nationalistic
more democratic one focused national
ideology (which came to the force in
energy on redressing what were perceived
phase two), and the integration of the
as the inadequacies of the previous regime.
Philippines within the world market
The latter had done little or nothing to alle-
economy (which characterizes phase three).
viate the mass poverty that had plagued
First, when the Marcos regime was the country. This shift in focus, which
overthrown, "high culture" in the was fundamentally political in nature,
'.:
16
•
had repercussions not only for the itself competing with other groups for
economic agenda but also for all other diminished resources. The company was
sectors of society. unable to resist these incursions for very
long.
In the case of Ballet Philippines, the
ascent of the Aquino government called As Ballet Philippines entered its third
for more nationalistic themes in the phase, it was called to compete for
programs, However, the very concept of resources within the context of an
ballet carries with it connotations of increasingly global, market-driven economy
elitism. Zolberg (1996, 397), a sociologist, which includes a global entertainment
argues that given the association of the component that is capable of making
'.
fine arts with the elite, these activities considerable money even in a developing
seem out of keeping with democracy, nation. Ballet Philippine's problems in
While the ideological shift in the political attracting male dancers by paying them
climate in the Philippines pushed the arts sufficient salaries are symptomatic of this
in general to the background, Ballet situation. Undoubtedly new opportunities
• Philippines was possibly more affected for innovation are possible on the part of
than other art forms. the leadership of the ballet company
(including the support by the new monied
While the change in political elite of Southeast Asia), and these
ideology made it appropriate for other innovations are likely to bring about a
dance companies to challenge the revitalization of the ballet company. But
position of Ballet Philippines, it was the just how the ballet company will be
loss of Imelda Marcos's political reconstituted within the context of the
patronage that made this possible. Ballet world economy as well as the current
Philippines became susceptible to political structure of the Philippines is
struggles within the CCP itself and found difficult at the present time.
17
•
•
NOTES
. IAn earlier version of this paper was Father Jose Burgos' "La Loba Negra." It
presented at the World Dance Alliance- tells of the assassination of Spanish
Asia Pacific Dance Bridge. Singapore. 6- Governor General Bustamante who was
10 June 200l. a sworn enemy of the corruptors of the
Galleon Trade. The murder spurs a blood
I would like to thank Basilio Esteban
bath among the friars at the hands of the
S. Villaruz for his guidance as I was
vengeful widow with the .help of her
developing this project. I would also like
faithful servant, his son, and her daughter
to thank Gideon Sjoberg for his many
(Cultural Center of the Philippines 1980).
contributions. All errors and mis-
interpretations are, however, my own. 5Translation: "Review/Reconsider."
"The interview with Alice Reyes was 6Translation: "Homage to the Nation."
conducted on 11 August 2001 in Manila.
"Translation: "Now."
3See Appendix for synopsis.
"Translation: "You Begin."
"Itim-Asu (The Onyx Wolf) is a ballet of
Ms. Moreno's play which is based on
18
•
REFERENCES
19
•
•
APPENDIX
20