Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Influence of Light-Curing Intensity On Color Stability and Microhardness of Composite Resins
Influence of Light-Curing Intensity On Color Stability and Microhardness of Composite Resins
Influence of Light-Curing Intensity On Color Stability and Microhardness of Composite Resins
Henrico Badaoui Strazzi-Sahyon, DDS, MS1 One of the most important advanc-
Eduardo Passos Rocha, DDS, MS, PhD1 es in restorative procedures was the
Wirley Gonçalves Assunção, DDS, MS, PhD1 improvement of the method used
Paulo Henrique dos Santos, DDS, MS, PhD1 for polymerization of resin materi-
als. A high degree of composite
polymerization is essential to ensure
The purpose of this study was to evaluate the intensity of light-curing units and optimal physical and mechanical
its relationship with the color stability and microhardness of composite resins properties and compatibility with
with different shades subjected to a thermocycling procedure. Eighty blocks biologic structures.1 For the light-
(5.0 × 2.0 mm) of TPH Spectrum composite resin (Dentsply Sirona) were produced
curing materials, this is dependent
and distributed into four groups according to the light-curing units (EC 450, ECEL;
Valo, Ultradent) and color of the resin material (A3; C3) (n = 20). Within each group, on the correct application of the
color stability was measured on half the sample (n = 10) using a UV-2450 visible UV photopolymerizing light. The de-
spectrophotometer (Shimadzu), and Knoop hardness was measured on the other gree of conversion of a resin com-
half (n = 10) using an HMV 2000 microhardness tester (Shimadzu) before and after posite is defined as the percentage
thermocycling (12,000 cycles, 5ºC and 55ºC). Mann-Whitney test was performed of reacted C=C bonds of the mono-
on the color stability data; the microhardness data were analyzed using a three-way
mer molecules.1 The residual uncon-
analysis of variance (ANOVA) and Tukey test (α = .05). The ANOVA results showed
that thermocycling, distinct light intensity, and different colors of resin materials verted methacrylate groups present
influenced the microhardness of the composite resins, which was evidenced by a cytotoxic risk, and their solubility
the A3 composite resin light-cured with a Valo polywave showing higher hardness might cause the formation of micro-
values. There was no statistical difference in the color stability of the A3 composite gaps and the occurrence of second-
resin; however, the C3 composite resin light-cured with an EC 450 singlewave ary caries, as well as wear resistance,
light-curing unit showed higher color alteration values. In general, the Valo
color alteration, decreased mechan-
polywave light-curing unit imparted better mechanical property and color stability
to both shades of the composite resins. The different shades of resin material ical proprieties, and an increased
influenced the hardness of the composite resins. Therefore, the light intensity water sorption into the resin matrix.1
of the light-curing units should be evaluated and monitored, as the amount The factors influencing the degree
of light intensity will interfere in the quality and longevity of resin restorations. of conversion include the resin ma-
Int J Periodontics Restorative Dent 2020;40:129–134. doi: 10.11607/prd.4437 terial composition,2,3 as well as the
shade and degree of translucency
of these materials, type of photo-
initiator,4 type and power density of
light-curing unit, curing time, light
Department of Dental Materials and Prosthodontics, Araçatuba School of Dentistry,
1
guide tip positioning, light wave-
São Paulo State University (UNESP), Araçatuba – São Paulo, Brazil.
length, and light intensity.5,6
Correspondence to: Prof Paulo Henrique dos Santos, Department of Dental With technologic advance-
Materials and Prosthodontics, Araçatuba School of Dentistry – UNESP, ments, new versions of light-curing
Rua José Bonifácio, 1193, 16015-050 Araçatuba, SP-BRAZIL.
Fax: +5518 36363245. Email: paulo.santos@unesp.br
units have been introduced in den-
tistry, such as single-wave and poly-
Submitted April 24, 2019; accepted July 31, 2019.
©2020 by Quintessence Publishing Co Inc. wave light-emitting diodes (LEDs),
© 2019 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY.
NO PART MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
130
whose emission spectrum of the Materials and Methods Valo-A3 Group: Twenty A3-
first generation is narrower than that shade microhybrid TPH Spectrum
of the halogen light-curing unit, with Light-Intensity Measurement (Dentsply Sirona) resin blocks were
an emission spectrum similar to the produced using a metallic matrix
spectrum of camphorquinone, the In this study, the light intensities (5.0-mm diameter, 2.0-mm thick-
most-used photoinitiator in resin ma- of 40 light-curing units were mea- ness). The composite resin was in-
terials.7–10 Single-wave and polywave sured. The study was approved serted using a Thompson spatula
light-curing units range from 2,000 by the Research and Ethics Com- (Quinelato). The resin was covered
up to 3,200 mW/cm2; single-wave mittee of the Araçatuba School of with a transparent polyester filmstrip
LEDs emit a single wavelength emis- Dentistry, São Paulo State Univer- and a glass microscope slide to flat-
sion peak,11 which is different than sity (#50715215.9.0000.5420). One ten the material and prevent bub-
polywave units that emit a multiple- calibrated examiner (H.B.S.S.) per- ble formation. Finally, the samples
wavelength emission, polymerizing formed all measurements. An RD7 were light cured using a Valo poly-
camphorquinone and other types ECEL radiometer was used to mea- wave light-curing unit (Ultradent),
of photoinitiators,12 such as ivocerin sure the light intensity of light-curing 1,431 mW/cm2 for 40 seconds.
and phenylpropanedione.13 How- units. The sensor in the radiometer Valo-C3 Group: In this group,
ever, studies have shown that not all determines the surface of the fiber the same procedure was performed
light-curing units in dental practices optic tip on the polymerization unit as as described for the previous group;
emit a sufficient intensity to ensure well as its light power. The irradiance however, the C3 shade TPH com-
adequate polymerization of resin is calculated by dividing the light posite resin (Dentsply Sirona) was
material. This unsatisfactory light power and surface of the light guide used.
intensity can be caused by various tip by the means of an integrated EC 450-A3 Group: In this group,
factors, such as contamination of microprocessor. The measurements the same procedure was performed
the light guide, damage to the fiber were performed by pressing the as reported for the first group; how-
optic bundle, reduced light output light guide directly onto the sensor ever, the photoactivation of the
after repeated sterilizations, and and reading the irradiance values in composite resin was performed
dwindling battery power.1 mW/cm2 from the screen at the start using the EC 450 single-wave light-
This study aimed to evaluate and after 40 seconds of illumination, curing unit (ECEL) with a light inten-
the influence of different intensi- which comprised one measurement. sity of 101 mW/cm2 for 40 seconds.
ties of light-curing units and distinct Three measurements were obtained EC 450-C3 Group: In this group,
shades of the composite resin on for each light-curing unit, and sub- the same procedure was performed
the color stability and microhard- sequently, the arithmetic mean was as described for the previous group;
ness of resin materials. The null calculated. The light-curing units however, the C3 shade TPH com-
hypotheses tested were that (1) the that showed lower and higher values posite resin (Dentsply Sirona) was
different intensities of light-curing of light intensity were used for the used.
units would not promote a signifi- experimental groups. All samples were stored in
cant difference in the color stability 37ºC for 24 hours in light-protected
and microhardness of the compos- containers. Forty specimens were
ite resins; (2) the different shades Specimen Preparation separated to evaluate the color sta-
would not influence the color sta- bility (n = 10 per group), and forty
bility and microhardness of resin Eighty specimens were divided into were used to analyze the microhard-
materials; and (3) thermal aging four experimental groups (n = 20 ness (n = 10 per group).
would not cause a significant dif- per group) according to the shades
ference in the microhardness of the of the composite resins and light-
composite resins. curing units.
© 2019 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY.
NO PART MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
131
© 2019 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY.
NO PART MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
132
© 2019 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY.
NO PART MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
133
as the filler and polymeric matrix re- intensity indicators during the life- is recommended in order to ensure
fractive index, monomer type, filler time of the light-curing units. Some the quality and longevity of resin
type, and filler content, can interfere factors could influence the power restorations.
with the light transmittance of the density and affect the resin-based
composite resin.21 materials properties, including pos-
In a previous study, Reges sible contamination and several Acknowledgments
et al reported significantly lower sterilizations of the light guide, dwin-
Knoop hardness values for a darker dling battery power, distance of the The authors declare no conflicts of interest.
resin material than for other, light- light guide to the restoration, and
er shades.26 The selected shades composition of the material itself.1,28
differed substantially in light- Some limiting factors of this References
transmission properties. The diver- study should be considered, such as
sity in the shade of the composite the use of only one composite resin. 1. Tongtaksin A, Leevailoj C. Battery charge
affects the stability of light intensity
resin was expected to affect the po- Because this was an in vitro study,
from light-emitting diode light-curing
lymerization extent and mechanical the relationship between the re- units. Oper Dent 2017;42:497–504.
properties of the cured material.27 sults at the laboratory level to those 2. Sideridou I, Tserki V, Papanastasiou G.
Effect of chemical structure on degree
Therefore, the loss of energy could of the clinical condition should be of conversion in light-cured dimethac-
be related to the light absorption evaluated, as the in vitro studies rylate-based dental resins. Biomaterials
2002;23:1819–1829.
by the resin matrix and the light cannot simulate the actual condition
3. Halvorson RH, Erickson RL, Davidson
dispersion by the composite resin of the oral cavity. Therefore, future CL. The effect of filler and silane content
filler and opacifiers, attenuating the studies are required to inform pro- on conversion of resin-based compos-
ite. Dent Mater 2003;19:327–333.
light intensity and its effectiveness fessionals to frequently monitor the 4. Musanje L, Ferracane JL, Sakaguchi RL.
of the monomer polymerization as intensity of the light-curing unit in Determination of the optimal photoiniti-
ator concentration in dental composites
depth increases.21 The pigments in order to promote satisfactory oral
based on essential material properties.
darker shades of resin-based ma- rehabilitations. Dent Mater 2009;25:994–1000.
terials might absorb light, reducing 5. Alkhudhairy F. Wear resistance of bulk-
fill composite resin restorative materi-
its penetration along the depth of als polymerized under different curing
the restorative material.26 A great- Conclusions intensities. J Contemp Dent Pract 2017;
18:39–43.
er intensity of light energy and/or
6. Price RB, Whalen JM, Price TB, Felix
lengthy duration could be consid- Based on the methodology and re- CM, Fahey J. The effect of specimen
ered to excite the camphorquinone sults obtained in this study, it can be temperature on the polymerization of
a resin-composite. Dent Mater 2011;27:
in the darker resin materials,28 ob- concluded that the Valo polywave 983–989.
taining a similar polymerization po- light-curing unit provided better 7. Schneider LF, Pfeifer CS, Consani S,
Prahl SA, Ferracane JL. Influence of pho-
tential as that of the lighter shades.25 color stability and microhardness
toinitiator type on the rate of polymer-
Thus, based on the results of of the composite resins compared ization, degree of conversion, hardness
this study, light intensity is a rel- to EC 450 single-wave light-curing and yellowing of dental resin compos-
ites. Dent Mater 2008;24:1169–1177.
evant factor in the polymerization unit. The C3 shade showed lower 8. AlQahtani MQ, AlShaafi MM, Price RB.
of resin materials, influencing the hardness values than the A3 shade Effects of single-peak vs polywave light-
emitting diode curing lights on the po-
chromatic stability and hardness of when polymerized with EC 450
lymerization of resin cement. J Adhes
these composites. Clinically, in order light-curing unit. Thermocycling Dent 2013;15:547–551.
to ensure the quality and longev- was able to decrease the hardness 9. Lovell LG, Lu H, Elliott JE, Stansbury JW,
Bowman CN. The effect of cure rate on
ity of the restorations, it is essential for both shades of the resin mate- the mechanical properties of dental res-
to use light-curing units with stable rial polymerized with both light- ins. Dent Mater 2001;17:504–511.
light intensity, monitoring it by using curing units. The regular evaluation
radiometry or manufacturers’ light- of the intensity of light-curing units
© 2019 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY.
NO PART MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
134
10. Schneider LF, Cavalcante LM, Prahl 17. Borges GA, Agarwal P, Miranzi BA, Platt 24. Kiomarsi N, Saburian P, Chiniforush N,
SA, Pfeifer CS, Ferracane JL. Curing JA, Valentino TA, dos Santos PH. Influ- Karazifard MJ, Hashemikamangar SS.
efficiency of dental resin composites ence of different ceramics on resin ce- Effect of thermocycling and surface
formulated with camphorquinone or ment Knoop Hardness Number. Oper treatment on repair bond strength of
trimethylbenzoyl-diphenyl-phosphine Dent 2008;33:622–628. composite. J Clin Exp Dent 2017;9:
oxide. Dent Mater 2012;28:392–397. 18. Rueggeberg FA, Caughman WF, Curtis e945–e951.
11. Jung H, Friedl KH, Hiller KA, Furch H, JW Jr. Effect of light intensity and expo- 25. Strazzi Sahyon HB, Chimanski A,
Bernhart S, Schmalz G. Polymeriza- sure duration on cure of resin compos- Yoshimura HN, Dos Santos PH. Effect
tion efficiency of different photocuring ite. Oper Dent 1994;19:26–32. of previous photoactivation of the ad-
units through ceramic discs. Oper Dent 19. Fonseca AS, Labruna Moreira AD, de hesive system on the color stability and
2006;31:68–77. Albuquerque PP, de Menezes LR, Pfeifer mechanical properties of resin compo-
12. Watanabe H, Kazama R, Asai T, et al. CS, Schneider LF. Effect of monomer nents in ceramic laminate veneer luting.
Efficiency of dual-cured resin cement po- type on the CC degree of conversion, J Prosthet Dent 2018;120:631.
lymerization induced by high-intensity water sorption and solubility, and color 26. Reges RV, Costa AR, Correr AB, et
LED curing units through ceramic mate- stability of model dental composites. al. Effect of light-curing units, post-
rial. Oper Dent 2015;40:153–162. Dent Mater 2017;33:394–401. cured time and shade of resin ce-
13. Sun GJ, Chae KH. Properties of 20. Oliveira DC, Souza-Júnior EJ, Prieto LT, ment on Knoop Hardness. Braz Dent J
2,3-butanedione and 1-phenyl-1,2- Coppini EK, Maia RR, Paulillo LA. Color 2009;20:410–413.
propanedione as new photosensitizers stability and polymerization behavior of 27. Juloski J, Goracci C, Tsintsadze N, et al.
for visible light cured dental resin com- direct esthetic restorations. J Esthet Re- Influence of luting agent translucency
posites. Polymer 2000;41:6205–6212. stor Dent 2014;26:288–295. on fiber post retention. Eur J Oral Sci
14. Moda MD, Godas AGL, Fernandes JC, 21. Guiraldo RD, Consani S, Consani RL, 2015;123:116–121.
et al. Comparison of different polishing Berger SB, Mendes WB, Sinhoreti MA. 28. Tanthanuch S, Kukiattrakoon B. The
methods on the surface roughness of Light energy transmission through com- effect of curing time by conventional
microhybrid, microfill, and nanofill com- posite influenced by material shades. quartz tungsten halogens and new
posite resins. J Investig Clin Dent 2018. Bull Tokyo Dent Coll 2009;50:183–190. light-emitting diodes light curing units
Epub ahead of print. 22. Sedrez-Porto JA, Münchow EA, Cenci on degree of conversion and microhard-
15. Catelan A, Suzuki TYU, Becker F Jr, Briso MS, Pereira-Cenci T. Translucency and ness of a nanohybrid resin composite.
ALF, Dos Santos PH. Influence of surface color stability of resin composite and J Conserv Dent 2019;22:196–200.
sealing on color stability and roughness dental adhesives as modeling liquids—
of composite submitted to ultraviolet- A one-year evaluation. Braz Oral Res
accelerated aging. J Investig Clin Dent 2017;31:e54.
2017. Epub ahead of print. 23. Ozcan M, Barbosa SH, Melo RM,
16. Sahyon HBS, Guedes APA, Godas AGL, Galhano GA, Bottino MA. Effect of
Suzuki TYU, Briso ALF, Dos Santos PH. surface conditioning methods on the
Effect of fluoride-releasing adhesive microtensile bond strength of resin com-
systems in control of dental enamel posite to composite after aging condi-
hardness subjected to acid challenge. tions. Dent Mater 2007;23:1276–1282.
Arch Health Invest 2017;6:192–196.
© 2019 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY.
NO PART MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.