Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Today: Wartime Secret Unlocked
Today: Wartime Secret Unlocked
theprovince.com
thE-list
LIVE MUSIC
great things to do
CLUB GIG
the phrase launching party, so anyone curious about electro swing and thus is planning to attend will be on the ground floor of a new regular event. Swing implies big band orchestration from the 40s but electro says electronica with synthesizers, turntables and such. Put the two together and a heavy dance rhythm probably is the result. With Sweetpea Swing Band, VanDolls Burlesque swing show and DJ Rudy & DJ Eliazer. When: 9 p.m. Tickets: $12
Sarahs Key, based on a novel by Tatiana de Rosnay, is a drama about an american journalist (Kristin Scott Thomas) who discovers a disturbing secret about the Holocaust in France in 1942. HUGO PRODUCTIONS
Movie review
Sarahs Key
Warning: PG: No advisory. 103 minutes Grade: BTheatres, showtimes, B10-B11
LIVE MUSIC
CLUB GIG
While The Province does its best to provide accurate event information, please be sure to reconfirm. Thank you.
The Holocaust drama Sarahs Key is something like the Anne Frank story in reverse: In France in 1942, a Jewish family in the Marais district of Paris is arrested and taken away. Before they are, 10-year-old Sarah (Melusine Mayance) locks her younger brother in a secret closet in the bedroom and promises to come back for him. She carries with her the small key that will open it, but she is on the road to Auschwitz. That is half the story of Sarahs Key, and it comes with the harrowing intensity of such tragic war stories: people rounded up by cruel officials, locked in a transit camp (the Velodrome dHiver in Paris, where thousands of Jews were in fact kept with little food or water for days after the infamous Vel dHiv roundup), separated from their families, shipped to concentration camps. They had it coming to them, a woman yells from a window across the street from the velodrome, as hundreds of men, women and children yellow stars stitched to their chests are forced inside. The guards, by the way, are not Nazi soldiers, but gendarmes. Among other things, Sarahs Key is about the complicity of France in the Holocaust. And meanwhile, the clock is ticking away on Sarahs young brother, locked in a closet at home. The other half of the story takes place
in the present day. Julia (Kristin Scott Thomas), an American journalist who has married a French architect named Bertrand (Frederic Pierrot, her co-star in Ive Loved You So Long), is doing a magazine story on the Holocaust. She and Bertrand are about to renovate the Marais district apartment, a place that has belonged to his family for 60 years. Theyve lived there since the war, in fact. Based on a novel by Tatiana de Rosnay, Sarahs Key is a drama that is at once powerful in its depictions of wartime cruelty wrenching scenes of families being forcibly separated in transit camps, or of mothers trying to throw food through barbed wire to their children held on the other side and contrived in the melodrama of its secrets. Julias investigations lead her into the past, a murky country at the best of times. It was wartime, people say, and even Julia is led to ask, How do you know what you would have done? A witness to the 1942 roundup says, What could we do anyway? Call the
police? and her point would be stronger if we didnt suspect that shes the same woman who yelled from the window across from the velodrome. Director Gilles Paquet-Brenner (Walled In) moves between the 1940s and today, but it is always Sarahs story that is most compelling, helped along by the performance of young French actress Melusine Mayance, who gives the girl a mature intelligence that is heartbreaking in the circumstances. But the key she carries weighs down both her character and the plot: It becomes one of those clunky movie symbols that defy realism. As our stand-in as witness to the horrors, Scott Thomas is reliably clearheaded (and her French is impeccable), but the addition of marital complications and an improbable bunch of inlaws people who have a secret stash of letters that explain the past, but that they have never looked at, for instance take the film into melodrama. Sarahs Key does succeed in bringing the Holocaust into the present day. Julias life is saturated in guilt it feels like residue thats left when the blame melts even as the film leaves the wartime scenes, turning away from its worst excesses, and becomes instead a mystery about what happened to one person. We keep watching, even as we become more distant from her, and maybe thats the point.
jstone@postmedia.com canada.com/stonereport