Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Art Centre Silkeborg Bad 2009
Art Centre Silkeborg Bad 2009
2009
1
2 • Art Centre Silkeborg Bad 2009 •
An art exhibition with points of view
3
4 • Art Centre Silkeborg Bad 2009 •
Preface
An exciting aspect of art is its way of communicating across The initiative behind EXILE comes from a handful of Danish
national boundaries from person to person. artists with the common trait of being members of the ar-
tist union PRO. PRO has since 2002 developed a tradition
Furthermore, artists – in this case visual artists – under- of entering into international dialogues with colleagues.
stand how to use their very special sensitivity to visualising, This is done with the intention of challenging audience
in the broader sense, conditions of humanity and society self-perceptions as well as perceptions of contemporary
that are in need of our attention. Exhibition and catalogue society. The initiators have formed the project steering
present 35 Danish and foreign artists who contribute with group along with the Art Centre Silkeborg Bad.
new and recent works for the project.
We would like to extend our thanks to all those who have
The meeting with art creates to the spectator a mirror, a in one way or the other aided in realising the project, inclu-
possibility to reflect – perhaps something important has ding all participating artists, the authors of this catalogue,
been brought forward which is not yet conscious or which private businesses, embassies, anonymous contributors,
has not yet been put into words. This happens with the and funds who have provided financial support for the
countless means of expression in contemporary art, and project. Without such support, the project would not have
thus, the visitor will experience installation, film, painting, been realisable.
sculptural elements, photography, events etc. in both buil-
dings and the park area. With the exhibition concept of EXILE, it is our intention to
focus on an immediate and urgent problem to humanity.
The exhibition comprises the interpretations by visual ar- We have been looking forward to showing an exhibition
tists of the concept of ”exile” – the feeling of homelessness that acts in an international field, and to the Art Centre Sil-
and alienation – philosophically, politically, emotionally keborg Bad, the international dialogue is fully in line with
and/or existentially. Film and poetry in the exhibition and the purpose of the facility.
the texts of the catalogue draw lines to even more aspects
of the subject. A warm thanks to all the participating artists!
The steering group: Bodil Brems, Gunnar Bay, Bent Hedeby Sørensen, Gerda Thune Andersen, and Iben From
5
Index
5 Preface
Colophon 8 Tine Hind / Trafficking
10 Jimbut Jun Feng / Poems
EXILE is displayed from 16 May – 30 August 2009 14 Mohamed Aboulenaga / The Lion
16 Gunnar Bay / Artist in Exile
Editors:
The steering group 18 Kjetil Berge / Tatli Müzik (Sweet Music)
(Bodil Brems, Gunnar Bay, Bent Hedeby Sørensen, 20 Are Blytt and Per Kristian Nygård / Stealthiest State of Mind
Gerda Thune Andersen, and Iben From)
22 Bodil Brems / The EXILE Game
Graphic design: Gunnar Bay 24 Gerda Thune Andersen / No Place
Translation: Alex Høy 26 Else Marie Bukdahl / Emigrants
28 Gerda Thune Andersen, Marit Benthe Norheim
Proofreader: Iben From og Marie Strøm
and Moustafa Al Yassin / We are All in the Same Boat
Font: Myriad pro 34 Marit Benthe Norheim / CampingWomen
36 Nermin Durakovic / The Distance from and to
Print: www.silkeborg-bogtryk.dk
38 Nikos Giavropoulos / Self Exile
Publisher: 40 Jon Gislason / House on Iceland
Art Centre Silkeborg Bad • www.silkeborgbad.dk
Gjessøvej 40, 8600 Silkeborg. Phone: + 45 8681 6329 42 Smike Käszner / God and Darwin in Art
44 Karen Kjær Laursen / Sad Rain
© Copyright: Art Centre Silkeborg Bad, authors and artists
46 Sverre Raffnsøe / The Exile of Art
Support: 48 Nina Kleivan and Pernelle Maegaard / Travel Agency Wunderschön
The exhibition has received support from
50 Matthias Köster / Gravestone in Paris
the Danish Art Council Visual Arts Committee, 52 Kirsten Lampert / Mixed media on paper
the Danish Art Council International Visual Arts Committee,
56 Iben From / Silkeborg Bad and refugees
Royal Norwegian Embassy, Copenhagen, 58 Gunnar Saietz / G. Zaienz, The Exile Artist
the Municipality of Silkeborg, the Art Centre Silkeborg Bad,
60 Cornelia Schleime / Paintings
artist group PRO and anonymous contributors 62 Jeanette Land Schou / Buddies - They Always Find a Way & The Turn
64 Vicky Steptoe / Story of Ida
66 Bent Hedeby Sørensen / No Name
ISBN 87-91252-32-6 70 Le Pont Gallery, Syria, presenting the following
photographers from the Middle East:
Issa Touma-Nazem Jawish-Eman Ebraheem-Hassan Alsoud-Ayham Dib
72 Kim Wendt / The Exile Within
74 Ralf Ziervogel / The Exile of Thoughts
76 Karsten Vogel / Alienated
78 Ritu Sarin and Tenzing Sonam / Documentary film
80 Facts about the artists and individual sponsors
7
Tine Hind TRAFFICKING
...Danish artist, born 1953
9
Jimbut Jun Feng Three poems
...Danish poet, born in China 1965
there is a draught
there is a draught in her flat I always tease about one thing and another
the neighbour makes his perverted noise but a flower is always this one and only
she has travelled to another country it sometimes stands in her window frame
I checked my mails under its shadow, we sink in a deep of the spring
then I water the flowers in her window frame
then I walk out of the door I drag my anxiety with me in and out
I have a feeling of loss worrying about her in another country
in which a deep and dark floodtide runs
I get home I live but on the other side it must be my home
in another city there is a draught in my flat
I checked my mails
then I sit and imagine another country there is a draught in the very middle of the time
in which the green prospers everywhere on the mountain I feel her heaviness under my eyebrow
and in the field but she is in another country
yes, over there I will look at the one and only flower, and I will say I see a good picture work against a bad
that it is good and beautiful on purpose or without purpose
and deserves the best in the world I read the news of the day in the newspaper
I think that she reads the news of the day in the newspaper
the drops of water on the window and the dim light from the street lights
for it is from something faraway
from a story from another time
where my memory meets yours
where our dreams overlap each other
and our date is made
11
Elsinore . . . . .
my tale is transient
I have a different urban childhood which has never been here
slightly more grey and remote
it is washed away at the same time
as my girlfriend says to me that she is wet because it has rained
I see an old man yawn on the other side of the street
13
Mohamed Aboulenaga The Lion
...Egyptian artist, born 1960
Installation with the temporary studio/ le top, seat, and seat back. They probably
work station of an exiled artist. will not stay that long, then.
one or more flat screens placed next to more hell. From tolerated to intolerable.
one another, one looping images of a Also sections with eyes to underline the
window, opened slightly and acting as a aspect of observation/surveillance.
window to freedom, whereas the other
shows a film collage of televised news The subjects take their points of departu-
reels. re in the word EXILE and associated con-
cepts. It has been attempted to illustrate
This underlines the impression of capti- feelings like deficiency, anger, frustration,
vity afforded by a temporary residence. resignation, gallows humour, envy,
There are objets trouvée, objets realité, a hate, sorrow, waiting, torture, per-
surveillance camera. secution, and parts of expressions
such as: where to go?, tolerable
The Exile Furniture has been fashioned stay, speculating day and night, I die
in such a way that it remains a kind ges- a little bit every day, no-man’s-land,
ture but has a form that demonstrates a life on standby, why?, enough!
something quite different. For example HOPE. Single. Using complete or
Welcome to Exile, Please Sit Down, Have part sentences with inserts of eyes
a Nice Day, etc. – written in screws in tab- (staring, inquisitive, accusing). ”Exile-Chair”, 2009, modification with screws on VICODUO-chair
”WHY”, 2008/2009, painting with broken glass frame ”EXILE”, 2008, painting with nails in the frame
”The EXILE Game” has 3 elements which in an aesthetic form offer 6 persons. A die is cast for identity, i.e. ”young man” or ”parents with
the spectator the possibility of making some ethical choices. A form two children”. The identity will influence on the action. One moves in
through which something can be learned unawares about the possibi- the game by casting the die. Throughout the whole game there will be
lities that fate or chance bring to people: threats, as told by refugees and the press. Personal moral standards will
be challenged by possibilities of choice. Rules and consequence are
A Painting, a Game, Videos. tacked on to the squares, so that the passive spectator can experience
the game, just with a lower emotional involvement than the partici-
1. Paintings of human shapes moving across a surface, moving away pants. The objective is to reach ”destination”.
from something towards something undefined.
3. Two videos. One with stills and video recordings from different
2. A game ”The Exile Game” of approximately 180 x 130 cm stands. The homes and the other one with wars and catastrophes, an eternal thre-
game is also a sculpture in 3 dimensions. It can be played by up to at, a human condition?
”Home”
”War”
23
Gerda Thune Andersen NO PLACE
...Danish artist, born 1932
The NO PLACE sculpture series has its point of departure in a series of bronze sculptures that I created 2002-2004.
For this series, I worked with dissolving man-made constructions and what I call the coexistence of chaotic and stable areas.
The name METASTASES came about because I imagined an internal or external uncontrolled organism that metastasises in or on
a crystalline form, i.e. the houses, making them dissolve, disintegrate, break down, erode, or overgrow into a state of collapse.
25
Emigrants General examples of artistic interpretations of the difficult conditions of exile
Emigrant visual art interpretation of their own fate and shocked by the meeting with a relentless theocratic rule,
their struggle for human rights and on her return to the US, she was confronted with the
anxieties and up rootedness of many Iranian immigrants.
They often felt at home neither in the US nor in Iran.
Through centuries, visual artists have had to flee because To begin with, Shirin Neshat worked with the frozen move-
the ruling regimes in their countries of residence objected ment of photographic images. Later, she used primarily the
fiercely to either the message conveyed in their art or the living image series of film. She would often use big screens
means of expression they used. We all remember how the placed in a closed square room, allowing the spectator to
Nazis and the Communists persecuted and often even kil- experience the work without many disturbances and to
led those visual artists who did not faithfully and loyally become drawn completely into her very expressive image
visualize the dominant objectives and ideals. Expressio- space. In many cases, she herself played the woman who
nism and abstract art were, for example, both prohibited. experiences the pain of being forced to living in a foreign
At all times and all over the world, dictators have feared country. After years of living in another country, she has
that the uncompromising nature of visual artists and their come to know the consequences of exile.
undaunted struggle for freedom would undermine their
regimes. Generally, most of her works have a point of departure in
her own Iranian Islamic background which she embraces
Several unwanted artists managed to flee, however. In with much love, but which she also criticises indirectly
some cases, living in another country became a very dif- with a very delicate and almost fleeting poetry. She has
ficult destiny that would often make it hard for them to experienced both alienation and longing for home in the
work in those new and quite hospitable countries. In other West, but equally, she has experienced considerable arti-
cases, anxieties and the feeling of being a stranger would stic freedom. Several Islamic countries prohibit women
gradually be pushed aside and replaced by an impression from working in the public space. In the space of cognition
of liberation and joy of being allowed the possibility of that she had the opportunity of creating in her filmic works
creating the works that were not to see the light of day at in the US, she uncovers not only the painful conditions of
home. exile but also the oppression that takes place in her home
county – particularly towards women. She thus points in-
Such a fate was to befall Shirin Neshat, who was born in directly at universal human values and a hope of mutual
Iran in 1957 under the reign of the Shah. In 1973, she tra- understanding and respect that will support cooperation
velled to the US in order to educate herself as an artist. In and common ground and create equality between men,
1979, the Iranian revolution began, barring Iranians with women, and races in those countries where such equality
residence in the US from re-entering the country. She is not yet to be found.
could, however, visit her home country in 1990. She was
27
Gerda Thune Andersen • Moustafa Al Yassin • Marit Benthe Norheim
We are All in the Same Boat
– a cooperative project with the boat and
mirrors as shared metaphors
”The passport is merely a piece of paper. When you travel, you Moustafa Al Yassin.
have to take your proper passport with you, namely your soul. A small wooden boat has been sawed into two parts with
This will open everything for you.” lots of salt between the parts. Salt consists of chemical
(Quote from Moustafa Al Yassin’s father from before Moustafa left Syria as a compounds that are themselves toxic. Together, they are,
political refugee 21 years ago.) however, essential. In Arabic culture, salt symbolises family,
and visitors are given salt and bread.
”A ship has the same symbolic meaning as a bridge – they ena- – This means that the guest can feel safe and consider him-
ble access to another world.” or herself as an equal. From the ceiling hangs a reflection
”The mirror image is the manifested and timely world and of the boat shape fashioned from spoons. The spoons also
man’s knowledge about himself.” symbolise safety and home; being that it is the first tool
(From Symbol Lex., J.C. Cooper) used by a mother to feed her child. In Syria, every child
gets its own spoon with its name on it.
Gerda Thune Andersen. The floor is covered in shattered mirrors, allowing the spec-
The general idea refers to the boat refugees seen daily in tator to see him- or herself in crooked and twisted angles.
the media. Refugees denied on every border as if they did An adjoining room holds poetry in writing and film.
not exist. The installation describes the sea journey, the The words are read by Moustafa himself in beautiful and
dream of new horizons, and the hope of reaching a safe melodic Arabic – that remains audible even as one enters
port. The boats have been folded from newspapers from the rooms to the two female artists.
all over the world in all manner of languages. The news-
papers have information on boat refugees, perished or
turned away. The armada of boats sails afloat a giant wave ”I dive as a bird – no matter if air or water
down through the room where they collide with the invi- And I sail as a sword – no matter if vertical or horisontal”
sible wall that will not let them pass. On the other side of (Moustafa Al Yassin)
the glass wall, we stand as witnesses. A fragmented mirror
reveals us as we observe.
29
Moustafa Al Yassin DANCING IN THE RHYTHM OF THE RED CROSS
...Syrian poet, living in Finland, born 1962
31
Marit Benthe Norheim Woman’s Boat
...Norwegian artist, born 1960
The sculpture, Woman’s Boat in process, has been modelled directly in concrete.
The boat consists of a woman opening her womb, and men are on the way out of or into her.
She enjoys, yields, gives birth, and provides sustenance – or is used/abused.
From the ceiling over the sculpture hangs a mirror.
33
Marit Benthe Norheim CampingWomen
...Norwegian artist, born 1960
– a rolling sculptural installation by Marit Benthe Norheim
with incorporated music by composer Geir Johnson.
The project was created for the European Capital of Culture Stavanger2008.
The supporting idea and at the same time the inner rein- The caravans are moveable, arrive behind individual cars,
forcement for the concrete sculptures are functioning ca- and have been on a constant tour of the European Capital
ravans. Each of the women sculpture torsos grow from the of Culture Stavanger2008 region for 8 months. They have
roof, making the caravan appear as the skirt of the sculptu- visited approximately 40 towns during this period.
re. Spectators can enter the 4 m tall caravan women which
are the Refugee, the Bride, Maria the Protector, the Siren, In May 2009, they travel in Iceland on to the Reykjavik Art
and CampingMama. The inner spaces have been prepared Festival. After that, they will visit EXILE at the Art Centre
in various ways – several of them with participation of vari- Silkeborg Bad. They will be here from June 15th - July 8th
ous population groups. The refugee caravan, for example, 2009.
is filled with porcelain reliefs about fleeing – made by
children and refugee women in cooperation.
In the meaning of ”living in another country”, exile can be defi- ces and changing factors, like empty holes filling and constantly
ned as the simple relocation from a locale-specific context. The re-filling with whatever accumulates from a passing stream? The
involuntary connotations of ’fleetingness’ does, however, have a same question, confirming the ambiguous character of culture,
negative ring to it, just as putting the distance separating ’the diversifies the conceptual framework of the concept of exile and
banished’ from a country into words in itself leads the thoughts thus also questions what defines the boundary between excep-
towards a consensus concept, attaching to the linking to a place tions and the normal conditions? If the condition brought upon
of origin a degree of ’normality’, whereas the exile condition is ’the refugee’ is that of anomaly and exception, will it then neces-
similarly shrouded by an anomaly. Thus, the concept of exile una- sarily be released on returning home through (re)establishing
voidably links itself to the state from which exile takes over; to the well-known everyday practices and materialistic surroundings
image against which exile is reflected. on returning to the ’origins’? Or is the meeting between ’the ba-
As exemplified by artistic installations and museum institutions, nished’ and new places, practices, and experiences ultimately in-
the life and cognitive practice of a human being must be con- dependent of this release, in that human identification in all its
sidered in connection with its immediate physical surroundings rootlessness will adapt according to the new conditions?
and material context. It is the greater picture and complexity of Arguments speak against culture being based on either pure
these conditions that combine to form the basis of what we refer variability or firmly established structures. Just as the work of
to as culture. Within a human conceptual framework, this means art should be construed in relation to the context in which it is
that the locale-related character of the exile concept cannot avo- created, cultural means of expression must primarily find their
id touching upon subjects such as identity and belonging. Thus, comprehension frames in relation to the social practise of which
the distance of the exile is very much linked to mental processes; they form part. The basic condition of exile as well as cultural pro-
it expresses the distance to a home(country), to ones origins, to cesses of ’normality’ are thus to be found in the reproduction: In
a social context. Thus, the complexity of the concept is equally a constant process where interaction between existing precondi-
underlined by the fact that it becomes clear that the materiali- tions and changing factors translate into a transformation. What
stic and objectified appearances of culture provides an entry for materialises in the light of reproduction is a fundamental creative
diving into those processes of cognition that are initiated to the force that sheds a light of existentialism on the state of exile.
individual when the state of exile comes into force. A creative process, constantly developing constructions that are
As cultural forms of presentation, objects and materialistic ex- close to reality and value-laden. This way of thinking does not
pressions are at the same time a medium of and a result of a necessarily render superfluous the nature of exile as an excep-
social practice. But do we, with these manifestations, have to do tional state, but questions primarily the distinction as opposed
with imprints from fixed shapes, with the traces of fixed structu- to normality.
res that change their appearance purely cosmetically according
to the sediment in which they are placed? Or are the visible ma-
nifestations before our eyes remnants of a plethora of coinciden- Marie Krag
BA in European Ethnology
”TALK”
41
Smike Käszner God and Darwin in Art
...Danish artist, born 1966
These days, about 6 months after the arrival of the fi- As it may be known, happiness is a relative concept. It is And what is left when private funds have left art?
nance crisis, the media have room for another subject. not only about being rich – it is about being richer than The religious approach to art. The approach that now
It is the 200th birthday of Charles Darwin. others. The neighbour can mimic all of your purchases spreads as relentlessly as did America when she disco-
and perhaps even surpass them. All aside from one; vered that she was the only remaining superpower.
Those two phenomena can be linked through the your art purchase. This has to be classic unique art with
claim that the finance crisis was brought about by a the direct impression of the artist. There is only the one It is conceivable that the religious approach to art
liberalism that bases its legitimacy on a cynical social copy, and it is yours. will naturally fill the vacuum left by the Darwinian ap-
Darwinian mindset – as opposed to a ”humane” and proach. This, however, also carries with it the risk of
religious mindset. With the Darwinian approach, art is cultivated and dissolving art. It is inherent in the religious approach
purchased singularly as a means of demonstrating that it continuously seeks to expand the space of art
What if we also turn to Darwin and God in an attempt capacity – like the peacock does with its tail feathers. in order to enlarge the space in which interpretation is
at explaining what the finance crisis will mean to Da- Through considerable ”resource wastefulness”, one possible and responsiveness can be established. Or, to
nish art? demonstrates one’s own capacity. So the more costly put it differently, art risks being dissolved in the world.
the art, the better the art. If one was to say something
The divine way to art about art, the words of the priesthood could be re- Everything can become art. It has been like that since
The religious take on art is one of elevating art to a kind peated. This is, however, more or less unimportant. Duchamp turned a urinal into a work of art. This does,
of surrogate religion with a view to contributing to the When one looks at the work of art, it is actually a mirror however, not mean that art can become everything.
need of the contemporary individual to find a meaning – one sees one’s own successful self. There is a difference – as Ad Reinhardt put it in a few
and reduce complexity. As with any other religion, in- words: ”Art is Art. Everything else is everything else”.
terpretation is controlled by priesthood. The members It seems that the higher the level of wealth, the big-
of this priesthood have the special disposition required ger the need for art. Several years of global financial If one can even partly buy into this outlined chain of
to identify the elatedness of art. Here, the priesthood growth has created an immense need for placing a va- events, it is not difficult to advocate the development
are facilitators and interpreters, i.e. primarily art histo- lue on art. Even the Gulf State Arabs, whose financial of an extremely diversified and alternative art scene –
rians. world has not suffered as much because their religion as a counterweight. As a catalyst of other events. Then,
forbids interest on lending, have embraced the means it is about looking into art as an opposition to the
The art in question must be open to interpretation. The of art and are now purchasing western masterpieces priesthood that wants out of art. Dissolution.
artists have not defined the work beforehand or other- with the same eagerness as demonstrated by the Ame-
wise closed it to the priesthood. The art has very much ricans when they purchased art in a war-torn Europe As a consequence, another thematic is conceivable,
information (unclear pheno-condition) or the oppo- in the wake of the first world war. They even purchase namely that of intentionality. When art seeks out into
site – very sparse information (clear pheno-condition). license agreements from ”cathedrals” like the Lou- the world and becomes, in both gesture and contents,
Simplified; expressive and abstract art opposed to mi- vre and the Guggenheim in order to ensure that their indistinguishable from the world, art will no longer be
nimalistic and conceptual art. new acquisitions have appropriate and legitimate sur- a question of context but one of intentionality.
roundings.
The natural way to art Where art in the 20th century was a question of con-
Opposed to the religious approach is the Darwinian The remaining approach to art text, it will possibly be a question of intentionality in
approach to art. As with religious approach, this is Back to Denmark, however, and back to a more down- the 21st.
often a question of creating a cult around the artist. to-earth level where we see costly art being thrown
This, however, is the extent of any similarities. With the overboard as the crisis spreads and its impact reaches
Darwinian approach, art serves a specific and tangible increasingly higher levels. Demonstrating capacity can Smike Käszner. Copenhagen 15 February 2009
purpose: the tail of the peacock. no longer be afforded like before.
Sad Rain
physical mental space
the suitcase
an
endless sad rain
film strip
of
photographic
series multiples
metaphor
of
departing / arriving
limbo-state
in
physical-mental fragility
the suitcase
as
hidden spaces
hides, fills
and
things reach back
comfort
time
of unpredictability.
”Little book — and I won’t hinder you — go on to the city without me:
Alas for me, because your master is not allowed to go!
Go, but in shabby clothes! – as a messenger from a unfortunate banished”
Ovid: Sorrows (34 BC-17 AD)
The celebrated author of The Loves and Transformations, vion, and disappearance. By an absence of belonging to my
Ovid, spent the last 9 years of his life abroad on the Black Sea home and perhaps also by a fear of disappearing from and
shore, banished on the order of Emperor Augustus from the to the others to an extent that eventually makes me invisible
Rome he loved so much. While constantly complaining and and forgotten – makes me approach destruction.
begging to be allowed back, he sent home, for lack of any-
thing better, his poems in the form of small letters that would Before his physical banishment, it was obvious that Ovid was
ideally let him be present and be heard in some form or other not unquestionably at home at the centre of politics and po-
in the cultural centre where he did, in his own opinion, right- wer. He claims to have been banished not only due to a perso-
fully belong. nal ”faux pas” on which he elaborates no further, but as much
due to what he refers to as ”carmen” or a poem. Most likely,
As can be seen from the painting by Delacroix, Ovid’s stay with the cause was primarily the work The Loves, a handbook in
the Scythians is a classic example of exile that has fascinated which he mocked the emperor and the moral restoration of
us ever since – along with several others, of course. the era; perhaps equally and more generally, the banishment
was brought about by the fact that the poet had, throughout
On the face of it, exile is the state in which people find them- his works and his entire life, to considerable extents pursued
selves when they have, for whatever reason, been forced to poetry, its demands, and its successes as opposed to morality
stay outside their own country without having let go their ties and its obligation, power and its appropriateness, political
to their own country. and social order and their stability.
Thus, exile also means that I am placed in a peculiar interim Everything points to a closely knit connection between art
state. The former, relatively matter-of-factly linguistic, cultural, and exile that is also manifested thematically in the Exile ex-
familiar, and social bonds have been lost to me, but I still carry hibition at the Art Centre Silkeborg Bad. The connection is,
them and the longing for them with me in my new context however, somewhat deeper than the mere theme. Art holds
without them being replaced by something else. The coun- its own obligation, and it carries with it a departure from the
try I am in presently thereby receives a status of temporary world as we know it towards something else; a departure
non-country, a kind of Limbo for me to pass through, a mild meaning that art is often in conflict with dominant morality,
preamble to Hell, where my soul is not necessarily put through executive powers, and the establishment. How often this has
other ordeals or torments than being primarily depressed and been the case is, among other things, apparent from the pa-
out of tune, considering that it is plagued by absence, obli- pal Index on forbidden books that was updated until 1966.
This means that art can also require and carry with it a self-
imposed of self-chosen exile in which one distances oneself
from factors that are obviously obligatory – often as a part
of an effort to not only make this more fluent, but equally in
an effort to create a means of becoming more present to one-
self.
Eugène DELACROIX (1798 - 1863): Ovid among the Scythians, 1859. Oil on canvas. 87.6 x 130.2 cm.
Whether I produce or consume art, part of art’s ability to fa- NG6262. Bought, 1956. Signed and dated. (Photo The National Gallery, London)
scinate could be that I have the opportunity of becoming my
own exile. I have the opportunity of actively choosing the pe-
culiar interim state, the mild hell in which the surroundings
The poet Ovid is shown in exile after being banished from Rome by the Em-
and the very obvious obligations dwindle and become absent
peror Augustus in AD 8 to the Black Sea port of Tomis in south east Romania,
until a continual, dream-like, and suggestive transformation
where he probably died ten years later. According to classical writers, the na-
becomes present, allowing the world to be reborn. Once I
tive Scythians fed on the milk of mares, and in the right foreground of this
have been in this exile of art and carried through this small re-
painting Delacroix has depicted a mare being milked.
bellion, I would, like Odysseus, like to tell about what I gained
from the journey.
Delacroix had first painted this subject in 1844 as part of the decorations for
the ceiling of the Library of the Palais Bourbon in Paris. Many of the figures
Anyway, about 2,000 years ago Ovid sent the poems that
designed for that site reappear in this later canvas.
were later to form part of Sorrows and Letters from the Black
Sea back to Rome individually. He sent them as short letters
to tell of his exile, his art, and his rebellion. And this meant
that his art and the story of his exile have survived the exile
since then.
Sverre Raffnsøe
Professor of Philosophy, Copenhagen Business School
47
Nina Maria Kleivan • Pernelle Maegaard TRAVEL AGENCY WUNDERSCHÖN
...Danish artists, born resp. 1960 and 1952
It is a Russian based exile story with the portrait of the ”Hans Bellmer” gravestone in Paris, another important
”Heine” gravestone in Paris, an important famous Ger- avant-garde exiliant of the 30s. I visited the gravestones
man exilian, and a different story with the portrait of the personally.
51
Kirsten Lampert
...German artist, born 1959
53
A LOCAL STORY ABOUT PEOPLE IN EXILE Silkeborg Bad and refugees
Artists from near and far have come to show their art at the old tic Sea to Denmark and to other parts of Germany. They would
spa. They may be far from home physically or figuratively, seeking often have spent arduous weeks in refugee convoys that would
a platform for their messages to meet people and turn regular sometimes be the target of bombing raids. Several refugee ships
ways of thinking a bit around. The object is to create a space for were torpedoed in the Baltic Sea, and countless lives were lost.
different expressions and thoughts. One immense disaster was the loss of 9,343 lives when the Wil-
helm Gustloff was torpedoed and sunk within one hour in severe
Before 1998 when the grounds became an art centre, the locati- freezing conditions on 30 January 1945.
on had a diverse history. Originally built as a health spa, it housed
people who were, either of their own choosing or due to medical Migration carried with it many inherent dangers; disease and
ordination, in need of a pause from their everyday life – an exile starvation were commonplace. A total of two million Germans
of sorts. A combination of elements today referred to as luxury are thought to have been evacuated. 250,000 of them went to
vacation, wellness, and refuge. The spa function was the pre- Denmark, among them 50,000 children and more women than
vailing activity over a period of exactly a hundred years. 1983 saw men. As the potential magnitude of these civilian refugee exodu-
the closing of the facility, as the form of spa ”vacations” on which ses became clear, Denmark was officially told to house them. At
it based were no longer in tune with the times, and people had first, they were housed in the southern part of Jutland and at Bal-
developed other travelling habits. tic Sea ports. Silkeborg began receiving its share of refugees on
15 March 1945, and more than 4,000 were housed all over town.
During a period following the second world war, Silkeborg Bad Occupied Denmark did not respond with undivided enthusiasm;
housed German civilian refugees in their involuntary exile. Even illegal leaflets claimed among other things that this was a ”wea-
today, ageing Germans appear in search of their roots. They pon of pity” now put into play by the Germans, and the Danish
might have spent time here at the camp in their youth. One Ger- Freedom Council advocated refusal of medical care to those in
man visitor even claimed to have been born here. Most likely, he distress! Food rationing spurred criminal behaviour internally
is not the only one. After all, the refugees stayed here for over two among the refugees and towards Danish store-owners, and ten-
years. Before that, the occupational forces had used the area as a sions ran high. Guard units were established. Many refugees pe-
military headquarters from 1943-45. rished abroad due to among other things contagious diseases,
which can be seen today at the cemetery where 308 are buried.
The German civilians had fled their country following the Russian
ingression from the east into Germany which meant that people As early as in May-June 1945, even before the area had been clea-
were driven out. Some fled on foot, others via ship across the Bal- red from German occupational remnants, the first refugees were
55
The Silkeborg Asylum Centre was housed on several addresses in The residences were run partly with local labour and based on
the mid-1980s. Some refugees actually resided at the Silkeborg the principle that the refugees were to handle their own house-
Bad past the four week period. This address was the last to be keeping. A newspaper article from September 1992 gives an im-
cancelled as an asylum centre. The introductory school at the Sil- pression of life at the centre and the thoughts of three refugees:
keborg Bad closed in June 1987. The construction plans of the A farm worker from Montenegro explained that he ran away from
private investor were also dropped, but by then both the Refugee military service, his parents, and his brothers in order to avoid kil-
Council and the fitness centre had already vacated the premises. ling Croats, and that his family had no options where they came
from. Now, he would like to provide for his son’s education in
Only five years later, in January of 1992, world political events Denmark. Another man from a town in Bosnia had experien-
meant that Denmark would again receive streams of refugees. ced and participated in the war against the federal army in his
In Silkeborg, this meant new visitors at the Gudenå Kurbad and own town where both sides saw heavy casualties. He described
Silkeborg Bad. Danish Red Cross first established a temporary how the family lost their houses and his auto garage. The actual
residence at Gudenå Kurbad where 160 refugees from Iraq and escape with his wife and three children took place by car, and
former Yugoslavia were housed in 67 rooms. It had not yet been they experienced among other things gunfire exchanges on the
determined if the refugees would be granted asylum or not. Only border to Croatia. Later, they became aware that many other re-
those who were granted asylum were ”passed on” for integration fugees on their way through the country had been killed in a sta-
via the Danish Refugee Council. Nina Koch, division head at the dium there. They managed to find shelter with relatives in Croatia
Directorate for Foreigners, was pleased with the beautiful sur- before using a two-day German transit visa to get to Denmark.
roundings of the centre. Asylum-seekers are often under consi- Other family members had arrived in Vejle a few months earlier.
derable pressure due to the experiences from which they fled The man also explained that the different backgrounds of the re-
and due to the uncertainty surrounding their future. fugees caused internal friction at the asylum centre.
In late August that same year, somewhat over a hundred refugees A Bosnian woman from Sarajevo explained how she paid Serbs to
from Serbia, Macedonia, Kosovo, and Bosnia arrived at Silkeborg be able to flee on her own with her two children in order to bring
Bad, where the Red Cross was also in charge of arrangements and them to safety, and how she had for a while not heard from her
operations. The number of lodgers then rose to 149 persons (64 husband who had remained there.
of them children) in a matter of a few weeks.
Refugee families and individuals worked together on housekee-
ping, shared refrigerators etc. People were very talkative, some
57
Gunnar Saietz G. Zaienz,The Exile Artist
...Danish artist, born 1936
The wind had been blowing heavily from the southwest for weeks, His story was harrowing: The Rumanian mafia, one of the most
and the low December sun hit the South Sealand beach where I powerful and cruel organisations of Eastern Europe, pursued him
happened to be one afternoon. Coincidence wanted something because of his numerous attempts at exposing its top leaders.
from me, however. As so often before, I saw some bottles in the His wife and four children were being held hostage and survived
sand at my feet – I recognised the characteristic apple juice bottle only because he sent away money, in complete secrecy, of cour-
with its big opening. Strangely, the openings had been carefully se, to his brother-in-law in Bucharest, who managed, with equal
corked, and there was some rolled-up paper inside the bottles. secrecy, to bribe the changing guards. Now, however, things had
Messages in bottles! In the course of about half an hour, I found gone terribly wrong. If the mafia would not receive a substantial
over a hundred. amount within 2 months, his wife and children would be killed!
Mr. S. had no chance of procuring such funds... hence these calls
I brought them home, of course, and with ever increasing ama- for help per bottled message!
zement I emptied out their contents. It turned out to be small
paintings: Portraits, sceneries, surreal visions, and on the back a I decided at once to try to help him, and the displaying at Sil-
disturbing message about the painter and his situation. The pain- keborg Bad is the first attempt. Several auctioning houses have
tings were excellent, very original, and deeply committed, but also offered support. I have combined some of the paintings in
the message on the back was a bit of a shock to me as I gradually groups, whereas others will be sold separately and can be taken
managed to ”decipher” it. It was hand-written in a combination of along anytime during the exhibition.
Danish, French, Italian, and some fully incomprehensible words. I
did understand, however, that he was a Roma from Rumania, that (PS: Beware of very imaginative collectors who call on behalf of refu-
he had fled Bucharest four years ago, and that he worked illegally gees. Particularly if their names are as strange as mine!)
at an apple plantation on a small Danish island. Oddly, his name
was almost identical to mine, and I would not be surprised if we
were somehow related.
59
Cornelia Schleime
...German artist, born 1953
”Und sie galoppieren weiter”, 2001, Diptych, acrylic, asphalt varnish, shellac on linen, each part 145 x 120 cm.
61
Jeanette Land Schou Buddies - They Always Find a Way & The Turn (video)
...Danish artist, living in Sweden, born 1958
The proportions are at stake. Both with respect to the actual figures
in the room and with respect to the meaning layer. The photo series
attempts to make this more concrete; being a stranger in the world
and the attempt at getting to know it. The images have been set in
scene like a cartoon, albeit without text bubbles.
67
Issa Touma•Nazem Jawish•Hassan Alsoud•Eman Ebraheem•Ayham Dib
...Five photographers from the Middle East - presented by the Le Pont Gallery, Syria
In the Middle East, we don’t need to leave our homeland in Politically, I belong to a generation who grew up with one
order to be in exile, because we are exiled in several ways. government, one president, and have never tasted demo-
Mostly, it is our inability to live within our essence. cracy in any way. We can not practice or participate in our
We pretend to have a healthy family life, yet there is distan- own political issues. The only ones concerned are also exi-
ce between the members. led in their high and fancy towers.
We also pretend to have a warm social life, yet, in reality,
are miles away from each other. As citizens of the Middle East, we start to draw our own
We can’t express our points of view clearly; We can’t see red lines, predicting that this is what the superior power
clearly.. wants. We can only express our outrageous matters when
Trust is almost vanished among people. the problem concerns another nation, when it’s another
We claim that we are living in Utopia. society’s problem.
The media is very optimistic about everything. One cannot
even hear about a car accident in the daily news. It is as The 3rd participant is Hassan Alsoud, whose photos tell a
if everything bad and harsh only happens outside of our story about a poor family living primitively in the middle
borders. of the new city. They live in a limited space without basic
services like electricity and water. They are so impoveris-
In the photos of the participants, we will see a different hed that they have to sell old bread to make an income.
truth: pictures of workers who labors for more than 12 Their children so affected by their lifestyle that they faced
hours daily, with no time for outside interests, hobbies, va- problems fitting in, and are alienated in school..
cations, or even to enjoy the simple pleasures life offers.
The 1st participant, Nazem Jawish has not had a vacation The last participant is Ayham Dib, whose photos represent
in 15 years. He had to live with 250 other workers in the the mentality of the ghetto in the modern sense, the men-
exile that is called The Factory. Those workers do not be- tality of the people who want to fit in among the rest and
long to the perfect Utopian society. are ready to give their voices away only for the sake of so-
cializing. Still they are haunted with the fear of what their
Another example is Eman Ebraheem. As a veiled lady, her futures’ hold. They want belonging, yet can’t obtain it. Such
self portraits are very daring and erotic. They represent the people give up their individuality in order to survive within
big gap she feels deep inside- the huge space that lies bet- their surroundings. As time passes, they realize they have
ween the way she lives, acts, and reacts in society and the been transformed into individuals far different than whom
way she experiences life within the thick walls of her own they essentially are, causing disturbance in their character
room. Like so many other women, Eman is torn between and eventually injuries to their souls.
her family and the pressures of the society surrounding
her. She doesn’t belong to either. This is Eman’s exile. Issa Touma (Le Pont Gallery)
69
Hassan Alsoud, Iraqi, born 1984
71
Kim Wendt The Exile Within
...Danish artist, born 1970
Kim Wendt
”One Song”, 2008, mixed media. Installationview: Backstage, 11th floor, Haus Eden,
(One Song Bar), Contemporary Arts Alliance and Deutsche Guggenheim, Berlin 2008
75
Karsten Vogel Alienated A musical composition for EXILE
...Danish musician and composer, born 1943
Exile 2009
Karsten Vogel
Camera: Ritu Sarin and Tenzing Sonam; music: Techung; March 2009 marks the 50th anniversary of the takeover of
written, edited and narrated by: Tenzing Sonam. Partly Tibet by Communist China and the flight into exile of the
funded by the Lawrie Group plc, UK Dalai Lama and nearly 100,000 of his countrymen. Today,
the Tibetan diasporas is spread out across the world, and
A Stranger in my Native Land is the poignant and personal actively upholds its traditions and culture, even as they
account of Tenzing Sonam’s first-ever visit to his homeland. come under increasing threat in their own land. What
From the far reaches of Amdo Province, where Tibetans does Tibet mean for the exile Tibetans, most of whom
have lost their language, to Lhasa, the heart of the country, have never seen their country?
the film captures his meetings with long-lost relatives and A Tibet of the Mind is part of a larger work that examines
conveys a sense of the desperation of Tibet as a country the current Tibet situation and the Dalai Lama’s dilemma
under occupation. in trying to resolve it through peaceful means. In this
piece, several exile Tibetans, old and young, and including
the Dalai Lama, speak directly to camera about the first
thing that comes to their mind when they think about
Tibet. The results are frank, moving, surprising and chal-
lenging in unexpected ways.
Vicky Steptoe.
Postal address: Niels Bohrs Allé 26, 2860 Søborg, Denmark.
E-mail: vickysteptoe@gmail.com • www.steptoe.dk
Phone: (+45) 39 69 69 48.
81
Project managers: Individual sponsors - warm thanks to:
Bent Hedeby Sørensen SR-Reklamefotografi ApS, 8600 Silkeborg, Phone: +45 86 81 16 22:
Nina Kleivan - Pernelle Maegaard SAD RAIN by Karen Kjær Laursen, p. 44
Mohamed Aboulenaga
Issa Touma KODA:
Kim Wendt Original music composition by Bent Hesselmann to Gunnar Saietz’s project, p. 58
Karen Kjær Laursen The National Workshops for Arts and Crafts, Gl. Dok:
Are Blytt - Per Kristian Nygård
Workshopsfacilities for Bent Hedeby Sørensen (Photoassistant: Kristina Schrøder), p. 66
Matthias Köster
Kirsten Lampert
Cornelia Schleime
ISBN 87-91252-32-6
84 • Art Centre Silkeborg Bad 2009 •