1

.- DIVISION BENCH )
(
MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL : NAGPUR BENCH
BEFORE THE HON’BLE SHREE BHAGWAN : VICE-CHAIRMAN &
THE HON’BLE SHRI M.A. LOVEKAR ; MEMBER ( J )
(“COURT HALL A”) (TIME – 11:00 A.M.) (DATE –10.04.2023)
ORDER MATTERS

1 O.A.521/14 C.R.Awasthi State & Ors. Promotion For reply to

With Adv.R.S.Khobragade, P.O. for R/1 to 5. amended
Mrs. S.R.Khobragade portion
P.P. Dalai, R/6
2 O.A.522/14 Sheikh Juned Akhtar State & Ors. Promotion For reply to
With Adv.R.S.Khobragade, amended
P.O. for R/1 to 5. portion
Mrs. S.R.Khobragade
R.D. Lokhande, R/6,
P.P. Dalai,R/7.
3 O.A.523/14 Deepak O. Dhande State & Ors. Promotion For reply to
With Adv.R.S.Khobragade, amended
P.O. for R/1 to 5. portion
Mrs.S.R. .Khobragade
P.P. Dalai, R/6
4 O.A.524/14 A.V.Shiwale State & Ors. Promotion For reply
Adv. R.S.Khobragade, to amended
P.O. for R/1 to 4. portion
Mrs. S.R. Khobragade
R.D. Lokhande,
R/5,P.P.Dalai, R/6
5 R.A.21/22 in S.R. Dahikar State & 3 Ors. R.A. For Reply
O.A.930/17 Adv.N.S. Warulkar P.O.

6 C.A.109/20 & V.S.Raut State & 4 Ors. Appointment 1.For

159/23 in P.O. Amendment.
Adv.G.G. Bade,
O.A.207/18 2.For
P.P. Khaparde Amendment

7 O.A.345/20 L.S.Mapari State & Another Seniority list For Reply.

Adv.N.R. & P.O. Objection:-
Mrs.K.N.Saboo Paging has not
been done
properly.
8 C.A.158/21 in Ku.S.S.Rahate State & 4 Ors. Seniority list and For
O.A.St.915/21 P.O. correction of Date of condonation of
Adv.A.P.Tathod
Birth. delay.
For Reply.
Objection:-
Pg. Nos. 27, 29,
36, 38 & 40 are
not legible.
9 O.A.153/22 R.D.Jadhav, State & 3 Ors. Promotion with For Reply
P.O. deemed date of
Adv.Y.P.Kaslikar
promotion
10 O.A.649/22 N.M. Tonpe State & 3 Ors. Promotion For reply
Adv.N.J. Patil P.O.

11 C.A.147/23 in V.N. Gabhane State & 2 Ors. Dismissal from For Early
O.A.669/22( C ) P.O. service & Hearing
Adv.S.S. Mohod,
suspension
Ku.J.S.Mohod
 2

12 O.A.731/22( C ) H. Khan State & 2 Ors. Appear for the For Reply
Adv.I.A. Fidvi, P.O. interview
Y.N.Sambre
13 C.A.123/3 in S.G. Deshmukh State & 4 Ors. Appointment 1.For
O.A.770/22 P.O. Amendment
Adv.S.S. Patil 2.For Reply
14 O.A.1184/22( C ) S.M. Kawati State & Ano. Seniority list For Reply
Adv.D.M. Kakani, G.K. P.O.
Bhusari
15 O.A.1227/22 N.B. Gattuwar State & 2 Ors. Promotion Await service
Adv.C.N. Deshpande P.O. of R/2 & 3.
16 C.A.51/23 in S.K. Bhivgade State & Ano. Seniority list For
O.A.St.257/23 P.O. Condonation of
Adv. A.C. delay.
Dharmadhikari, R.P. For Reply in
Jog C.A.
17 Cont. Pet. 13/2023 Suresh G. Annapure State & Ano. C.P. For reply.
In O.A.896/2021 Adv. D. P. Dapurkar P.O.
18 O.A.73/23 A.A. Chirmade State & 3 Ors. Selection list & For Reply
P.O. appointment
Adv.P.B. Patil
19 O.A.113/23 K.R. Tapi & ano. State Promotion For Reply
Adv.A.S. Deshpande, P.O.
R. Kavimandaan, M.R.
Kavimandan
20 O.A.126/23 P.M. Giri State & 2 Ors Challenging D.E. & For Reply
P.O. Punishment
Adv.Y.P. Kaslikar
Reduction of pay
scale
21 O.A.127/23 M.S. Patekar State & 2 Ors Challenging D.E. For Reply
Adv.Y.P. Kaslikar P.O.

22 O.A.154/23 Dr. D. L. Mankar State & 3 Ors.. Challenging charge For reply.
P.O. sheet and DE
Adv.B. Kulkarni, S.
Pande
23 O.A.256/23 S.B. Jadhao State & 2 Ors. Seeking promotion For Reply
Adv. N.R. Saboo, K.N. P.O.
Saboo
ADMISSIOIN MATTERS

1 O.A.58/20 ( C ) A.G.Dalal State & 4 Ors. Challenging G.R.

P.O. dated 21/12/2019
with Adv.Ms.P.Rane &
condition No. 1 (b)
Ms.P.Kale
2 O.A.59/20( C ) D.V.Ninawe State & 4 Ors. Challenging G.R.
P.O. dated 21/12/2019
with Adv.Ms.P.Rane &
condition No. 1 (b)
P.Kale
3 O.A.60/20( C ) G.W.Welekar State & 4 Ors. Challenging G.R.
P.O. dated 21/12/2019
with Adv.Ms.P.Rane &
condition No. 1 (b)
P.Kale
4 O.A.61/20( C ) N.K.Gokhe State & 4 Ors. Challenging G.R.
P.O. dated 21/12/2019
with Adv.Ms.P.Rane &
condition No. 1 (b)
P.Kale
 3

5 O.A.62/20( C ) Sau.U.R.Sorte State & 3 Ors. Challenging G.R.

P.O. dated 21/12/2019
with Adv.Ms.P.Rane &
condition No. 1(b)
P.Kale
6 O.A.63/20 V.V.Kolhe State & 4 Ors. Challenging G.R.
P.O. dated 21/12/2019
with Adv.Ms.P.Rane &
condition No. 1 (b)
P.Kale
7 O.A.90/20 ( C ) S.S.Dharmik State & Another Appointment on
P.O. temporary basis for
with Adv.S.N.Gaikwad
11 months/
protection of service
8 O.A.117/2020( C ) P.D.Taikar State & 3 Ors. Challenging order
P.O. dtd. 28.12.2019 for
with Adv.Preeti Rane &
Appointment of 11
Punam Kale
months period
9 O.A.212/20( C ) P.S.Headoo State & 3 Ors. Challenging G.R.
P.O. dated 21.12.2019
with Adv.P.Rane & P.Kale
and order dated
27.12.2019
10 O.A.213/20( C ) Ku.R.D. Wagh State & 3 Ors. Challenging order
with Sau.R.G.Ingle P.O. dated 11.03.2020
Adv.P.Rane
11 O.A.288/20( C ) M.Y.Bajirao State & 3 Ors. Challenging G.R.
P.O.
with Adv.Preeti Rane

12 O.A.750/20( C ) S.K.Sapkal State & 2 Ors. Challenging order

P.O. dtd.11/03/2020 for
Adv.Preeti Rane & temporary
P.A.Teni appointment of 11
months
13 O.A.1232/22 M.S. Gajbhiye State & 4 Ors. Promotion
P.O.
Adv. R.V. & N.R.
Shiralkar,A.Motlag
14 O.A.310/23 ( C ) S.V. Bobade State & 5 Ors. D.E. Object.
P.O. Pages 57 & 58
Adv.R.M. Fating
not legible.
15 C.P.46/22 in B.D. Wagh State & 3 Ors. C.P.
O.A.284/10 Adv.R.D. Hajare,K.M. P.O.
Joshi
16 O.A.323/23 ( C ) S.S. Ingale State & 3 Ors. Appointment/Selecti New O.A.
P.O. on Process Object.
Adv. J.R. Kidilay
Pages 21,35 &
37 not legible.
17 O.A.324/23 S.G. Shejal State & 3 Ors. Appointment/Selecti New O.A.
P.O. on Process Object.
Adv. J.R. Kidilay
Pages 31,33 to
35 & 37 not
legible.
HEARING PARTY MATTERS

1 O.A.621/17 ( C) D.R.Hunge State & 2 Ors. Time bound

P.O. promotion
Adv.S.M.Khan
 4

2 O.A.917/17 A.B.Potdukhe State & 2 Ors. Promotion

With Adv.Y.P.Kaslikar P.O.
3 O.A.918/17 J.B.Bondre State & 2 Ors. Promotion
Adv.Y.P.Kaslikar P.O.
4 O.A. 974/2017 S.P. Chahande State & 5 Ors. Regularisation of
Adv. N.S. Warulkar P.O. promotion

5 O.A.1007/18 S.E.Rajguru State & 185 Ors. Selection Process For Direction
With Adv.S.C.Deshmukh P.O. for R-1 to 3.
Adv.P.S. &
C.A.36/21
Mrs.K.P.Wathore, for R-5,
6, 8 to 12, 14 to 17.
Adv. D.M.Kakani &
G.K.Bhusari for R-19 to
21,23,24,25,28,29,31,
32,33,35,36,37,41,51,52,
54,55,57,66to69,71to73,
75to84,86to88,90,91,
94,96 to 100,104, 108 to
110,113,115to118,123,
125,128,129,132,133,
135to137,139,140,143
to145,147to152,154, 155
Private Respondents for
R-4, 7, 18, 22, 26, 34, 38,
40, 42 to 45, 48, 50, 56,
59 to 65, 70, 74, 89, 93,
95, 101, 102, 105, 106,
111, 112, 114, 121, 122,
124, 126, 127, 130, 131,
138, 141, 146, 153, 156
to 161, 163 to 207, 209
to 215, 217 to 223, 225,
226, 228 to 233, 235, 237
to 240, 242 to 260, 262
to 265.
6 O.A.97/19 M.S.Bhusari State & 3 Ors. Compulsory Objection:-
P.O. retirement Pg.Nos.34 & 45
With Adv.S.P.Palshikar,
G.N.Khanzode, are not legible.
Mrs.P.T.Joshi &
G.C.Khond
7 O.A.98/19 B.T.Gedam State & 3 Ors. Compulsory Objection:-
P.O. retirement Pg.Nos.35,36&
Adv.G.N.Khanzode,
Mrs.P.T.Joshi & 48 are not
G.C.Khond legible.

8 O.A.655/20 L.K. Khandare State & 10 Ors. Challenging

Adv.D.I. Charlewar seniority/
P.O. for R/1 & 2.
promotion
Adv.M.A. Sable for R/3
& 4.
9 O.A.78/21 A.M.Dhote & 3Ors. State & 5 Ors. Voluntary
P.O. for R-1 to 5. retirement &
Adv.S.R.Dambhare,
Shri A.S.Gautam, R-6. appointment on
Ms.P.A.Sahu &
compassionate
C.D.Rohankar
ground
 5

10 O.A.864/22 R.G. Kore State & 2 Ors. Selection process

Adv.R.V. & N.R. P.O. for R/1 & 2.
Shiralkar, A. Motlog Shri D.A. Kshirsagar-
R/3
11 O.A.951/22 A.S. Bhapkar State & 3 Ors. Accelerated
Adv.R.V. Shiralkar P.O. promotion

12 O.A.1134/22 ( C ) G.B. Lambade State & 2 Ors. D.E. & Chargesheet

P.O.
Adv.R.V. & N.R.
Shiralkar
13 O.A.248/23 A.M. Randive State & 3 Ors. Compulsory
P.O. retirement
Adv.G.G. Bade, P.P.
Khaparde

skt I/c Deputy Registrar,

Checked by:- Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal,
Nagpur
 6

(SINGLE BENCH)
MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL : NAGPUR BENCH : NAGPUR
BEFORE THE HON’BLE SHRI JUSTICE M.G. GIRATKAR : VICE-CHAIRMAN
(“COURT HALL B”) (TIME –11.00 A.M.) (DATE –10.04.2023)

ORDER MATTERS

1 O.A. 66/2019 D.V. Adhau State & 2 Ors. Recovery For reply.
Adv. N.R., Mrs. K.N. P.O.
Saboo, Mrs. K. Dhole
2 O.A.172/19 D.G. Bais State & 3 Ors. Suspension For reply
P.O. allowance &
Adv.S.B. Tiwari, A.K.
increment
Sharma
3 O.A.936/20 S.C. Gaikwad State & 4 Ors. Time bound For Reply
P.O. promotion
Adv. P.V. Thakre
4 O.A.529/21 K.B. Chormale & 7 Ors. State & 4 Ors. Time bound For Reply
P.O. promotion Object.:Pages
Adv. S.N. Gaikwad
17 & 33 not
legible.
5 O.A.531/21 P.C. Dongre & 5 Ors. State & 3 Ors. Time bound For reply
Adv.S.N. Gaikwad P.O. promotion
6 C.A.202/21 in Smt. S.A. Maraskar & State & Ano. Compassionate For Jt. O.A.
O.A. 565/2021 Ano. P.O. ground appointment For reply.
Adv. V.B. Bhise
7 O.A.645/22 M.T. Malewar & 10 State & 3 Ors. Time bound Await service to
Ors. P.O. promotion R/2 to 4.
Adv.P.S. Kshirsagar
8 O.A.740/22 ( C ) P.N. Moharkar State & 3 Ors. Stoppage of C.F. applicant
Adv. A.A. Mankar P.O. increments & has not filed
suspension service affidavit
of R/2 to 4.
9 O.A.783/22 ( C ) J.M. Rathod State & 5 Ors. Pensionary benefits For Reply
P.O.
Adv.A.R. Chavhan
10 O.A.913/22 P.L. Ladke State & 2 Ors. Pension & For Reply
Adv. B. Kulkarni, P.O. retirement
benefits.
S. Pande
11 C.A.496/22 in H..A. Gajbhiye State & 2 Ors. Stoppage of For Direction
0.A.998/22 ( C ) Adv.N.S.Warulkar P.O. increments. & For Reply
Recovery
12 O.A.1005/22 ( C ) R.N. Dhane State & 2 Ors. Medical For Reply
P.O. reimbursement
Adv. R.V. & N.R.
Shiralkar, A. Motolag
13 O.A.1027/22 R.G. Khedikar State & 2 Ors. Time bound For Reply
Adv. R.M. Fating P.O. promotion, pay
fixation & all
pensionary benefits
14 O.A.1063/22 P.S. Koytade & 9 Ors. State & 3 Ors. National pension For Reply to R/1, 2
Adv. N.B. Rathod, P.O. scheme & 4.
N. Gwalwansh,
A.S.Uikey
 7

15 C.A.102/23 in G.J. Dukare State & 2 Ors. Annual Increment For Condonation
0.A.1070/22 Adv. B.Kulkarni, P.O.
of delay
S. Pande
16 C.A.23/23 in D.K. Shende State & 5 Ors. Pension For
O.A. St. No.123/23 P.O. Condonation of
Adv.Mrs.S.D. Anjankar,
Mrs. P.P. Khaprikar
delay.
For Reply in C.A
17 O.A.19/23 R.S. Chaudhary State & 2 Ors. Suspension C.F. applicant
Adv.R.V. & N.R. P.O. has not filed
Shiralkar, A. Motlag service
affidavit of
R/2 & 3.
18 O.A.35/23 N.P. Jadhao & ano. State & 2 Ors. Absorption For Reply
P.O. (Vanmazoor)
Adv.N.R. Saboo,
N. Dhoot, A.Barahate
19 O.A.49/23 V.V. Patil State & 2 Ors. Transfer For Reply
Adv.R.V. Shiralkar
P.O.
20 O.A.104/23 S.B. Shukla & 21 Ors. State & 2 Ors. Increment For Reply
Adv. S.N. Gaikwad P.O.

21 O.A.112/23 P.D. Chinchkhede State & 4 Ors. Retirement benefits For Reply
P.O. and interest on
Adv.G.N. Khanzode,
delayed payment
P. Joshi, A. Thool
State & 2 Ors. Transfer For Reply
22 O.A.194/23 S.C. Kanojiya
P.O.
Adv.R.V. Shiaralkar,
A.Motlag
O.A.200/23 State & 3 Ors. Arrears of Pay and Await service to
23 R.B. Manekar R/2 to 4.
P.O. retirement benefits.
Adv. A.P. Sadavarte
24 O.A.206/23 B.R. Thite State & Ano. Absorption/
For Reply
Adv. S.P. Palshikar P.O. Confirmation
O.A214/23 State & 3 Ors. Suspension For Reply
25 K..S. Vaidya
Adv. J.B. Kasat, P.O.
V. Dahat
26 O.A.261/23 P.U. Borkar State & 2 Ors. Allow to join the For Reply
Adv.D.M. Kakani, G.K. P.O. duty at transferred
Bhusari place
27 0.A.386/22 G.V. Chopde State & 3 Ors. Suspension period treat For Reply
Adv.A.P. Sadavarte P.O. as duty period.
HEARING PARTY MATTERS

1 O.A.829/11 D.O.Jadhav & Another State & 2 Ors. Pay Scale High Court
P.O. Direction.
Adv.S.U.Bhuyar &
Amol Mardikar
2 O.A. 682/2017 S.A. Ukey State & 3 Ors. Absorption
Adv. P.C., V.P. P.O.
Marpakwar, D.P.
Karnik
3 O.A. 747/18 R.P.Kadu State & 2 Ors. Regularization /
Adv.N.R.&Mrs. P.O. Absorption
With K.N.Saboo
 8

4 O.A. 748/18 B.H.Rathod State & 2 Ors. Regularization /

P.O. Absorption
With Adv.N.R.&Mrs.
K.N.Saboo
5 O.A. 749/18 A.D.Pawar State & 2 Ors. Regularization / For Early
P.O. Absorption Hearing
With C.A.416/22 Adv.N.R.&Mrs.
With K.N.Saboo

6 O.A. 750/18 A.D.Mujmule State & 2 Ors. Regularization /

P.O. Absorption
With Adv.N.R.&Mrs.
K.N.Saboo
7 O.A. 752/18 A.B.Ingole State & 2 Ors. Regularization /
P.O. Absorption
With Adv.N.R.&Mrs.
K.N.Saboo
8 O.A. 755/18 S.D.Bhagat State & 2 Ors. Regularization /
P.O. Absorption
Adv.N.R.&Mrs.
K.N.Saboo
9 0.A.760/18 S.S.S. Rehman State & 2 Ors. Challenging
Adv.S.N. Gaikwad P.O. dismissing of
review and seeking
regularisation the
service with gratuity
back wages

10 O.A.187/19 D.S.Kapse & Another State & 2 Ors. Absorption

P.O.
Adv.N.R. &
Mrs.K.N.Saboo
11 O.A.553/19 M.U.Bhagat State & 4 Ors. Dem date of
P.O. for R/1 to 3. promotion
Adv.A.S.Shukla &
G.S.Kidambi V.L. Paraskar,R/4
S.N. Karnewar,R/5
12 O.A. 20/20 S.A. S.Sorathiya State & 2 Ors. Recovery
Adv. P.V., V.P. Thakre, P.O.
A.Y. Pardhi
13 O.A.51/20 Dr.V.B. Aswar State & 3 Ors. Regularisation/
Adv.V.G. Wankhede, P.O. Continuation in
A.V. Wankhede service.
14 O.A.736/20 S.B. Sharma State & 2 Ors. Recovery from
P.O. pension
Adv. S.M. Khan
15 O.A. 901/20 ( C ) S.S. Khan State & 3 Ors. Recovery &
P.O. suspension
Adv.S.M. Khan
16 O.A.803/21 M.F.Mohd.Jafar State & Ors. Time bound
P.O. for R/1 promotion
Adv.R.M. Fating
Adv.H.D. Marathe for
R/2 to 4.
17 O.A.491/22 S.S. Shendre State & 4 Ors. Recovery
Adv.S.D. Chande,N.T. P.O.
Jichakar
 9

18 O.A.713/22 ( C ) D.W. Dehankar State & Ano. Pension

Adv.B. Kulkarni, P.O.
S. Pande
19 O.A.925/22 K.A. Wankhade & 2 State & 2 Ors. Payment of leave
Ors. P.O. period with interest
Adv. A.A. Mardikar,
A.V. Shrivastava
20 O.A.933/22 S.G. Butoliya State & 2 Ors. Increment
Adv.B. Kulkarni, P.O.
S. Pande
21 O.A.943/22 I.S. R. Shah State & 3 Ors. Salary
Adv.S.R. Charpe P.O.

SKT I/c Deputy Registrar,

Checked by:- Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal,
Nagpur
 10

(DIVISION BENCH)
MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL : NAGPUR BENCH : NAGPUR
BEFORE THE HON’BLE SHRI SHREE BHAGWAN : VICE-CHAIRMAN &
THE HON’BLE SHRI JUSTICE M.G. GIRATKAR : VICE-CHAIRMAN

(“COURT HALL A ” (TIME – AFTER REGULAR DIVISION BENCH MATTERS OVER OF)( DATE –10.04.2023)

ORDER MATTER

1 M.C.A.41/22 in N.D. Katkade State & 2 Ors. C.P. For non-

C.P.04/22 in P.O. compliance of
Adv.G.N. Khanzode,
O.A.330/21 order dt.18/4/22
Mrs.P.T. Joshi & 23/03/23
P.H.
HEARING PARTY MATTER

1 O.A.918/21 Dr.N.G.Raut State & 8 Ors. Recruitment/ For Amendment

P.O. for R/1 to 4. Advertisement
With Adv.V.G.Bhamburkar
Adv. R. Joshi, A. Naik, M.
C.A.136/23 Deo , R.Deo for R/7 to 9
S.V. Joshi, R/5
S.R. Bijwe, R/6

SKT I/c Deputy Registrar,

Checked by:- Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal,
Nagpur
11
12