Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Issues and Concerns of Intimate Partner Relationship of Devadasi Sex Workers in The Rural North Karnataka, India
Issues and Concerns of Intimate Partner Relationship of Devadasi Sex Workers in The Rural North Karnataka, India
*Additional Professor,
Department of Psychiatric Social Wo,
NIMHANS.
janardhannimhans@gmail.com
**Ph.D Scholar,
NIMHANS.
muthurajupsw@gmail.com
***Ph.D Scholar,
NIMHANS.
manjulab.manju@gmail.com
Abstract
The objective of the present study is to understand the issues and concerns of intimate partner
relationship of Devadasi sex workers. Literature suggests that Devadasi sex workers are being in an
intimate relationship and been victims of the violence and looses power for condom negotiation.
Condom use within intimate relationships is often seen as a sign of infidelity and fosters mistrust
which could affect longevity, trust and intimacy within partnerships. Data were gathered through
in-person interviews during the field visit. Using qualitative data from Devadasi sex workers and
their intimate male partners in Bagalkot District, Karnataka, India, we examined both partners’
perspectives to understand the quality and dynamics of these relationships. Devadasi sex workers
and their intimate partners define their relationships as ‘like marriage’ which reduced their
motivation to use condoms. Violence from their intimate partner is very common in their
relationship. Devadasi sex workers do feel being abused, but accept it as they feel mentally secured
and recognition, as they have a regular visitor to their home. Devadasi sex workers accept the
violence from their intimate partner as a symbol of love. Couple-based interventions may be more
251
Navaneetham et al. (2017). Asian Journal of Research in Social Sciences and Humanities,
Vol. 7, No.6, pp. 251-260.
effective than individual-based interventions in promoting safer sex behaviours within intimate
relationships.
Keywords: Devadasi Sex worker, Intimate partner, Intimate partner relationship, sex work,
partner violence.
Introduction
The subject of sex work evokes strong and immediate emotional reactions from public, primarily
because of the low respect attached, stigma, sexuality, human rights issue, and sex trade. Previously
Devadasi’s, temple servants, artists, and started satisfying the biological needs of the priest, in the
modern world Devadasi practice sex work or dhandha in their homes or small lodges and brothels
in the rural settings (Blanchard et al., 2005, Vimochana, 1985). Devadasi the word derived from the
Sanskrit words ‘deva’(God)and ‘dasi’ (servant or slave), Devadasi’s were women and girls
dedicated through marriage to different Gods and Goddesses, a system that originated in South
India around the 6th century A.D. (Dasgupta, 2000; Tarachand, 1991). After their dedication they
became the wives of the deities and performed various temple duties, including cleaning the
premises, gods ornaments, items in the temples, dancing for deities in the festivals, and delivering
prayers and food to Gods, all of which were sacred forms of worship (Kersenboom,1987; Orr,
2000). As wives of deities, Devadasi’s never attained the socially and morally stigmatized status of
widowhood, and this was the primary reason for their auspiciousness (Marglin,1985). Along with
possessing ritually significant social positions, many Devadasi’s learned to read and write, an
opportunity not afforded to otherwomen (Evans, 1998). Some women also received large tracts of
land and material wealth from admirers, from which they made donations to temples for the upkeep
of buildings and to support particular ceremonies (Nair, 1994; Orr, 2000).
Another role performed by Devadasi’s was the provision of sexual services to male temple
attendants, priests, and men who could be regarded as patrons or clients. While sex work was not
their sole profession and most women had one or two patrons during their lifetime, religious and
political developments over several centuries produced a situation where more women were
engaged in this aspect of ritual service (Orr, 2000). Within religious worship and practice,
Devadasi’s started practicing sex work, started satisfying the biological needs of kings, priests, and
wealthy landowners which became the part of the Devadasi tradition.
252
Navaneetham et al. (2017). Asian Journal of Research in Social Sciences and Humanities,
Vol. 7, No.6, pp. 251-260.
neighbors. Some travel to larger rural centers to conduct dhandha in small-scale brothels, which
usually consist of 1–2 girls in a home within an identifiable sex work area under the watch of a
madam or ‘Gharwalli’, who customarily takes half of the girls’ earnings (O’Neil et al., 2004).
During the process of their sex work, they will be developing an intimate relationship with one of
their customer; they would start misusing them, some time would take their money, abuse them
economically, physical, socially, and psychologically.
Global literature on female sex workers suggests that many female sex workers do
develop intimate relationship with one of their customers, and they lose power of negotiation for
safe sex practices. Safe sex practice is often viewed as infidelity and fosters mistrust which could
affect the longevity, trust and intimacy within partnerships. Research studies on issues of FSWs
shows that they are subjected to social exclusion. Sex workers are also subjected to psychosocial
vulnerabilities, including exposure to childhood physical abuse, childhood sexual abuse,
interpersonal violence in adulthood and substance uses (Burnette et al 2008).
In India, the national AIDS control program has identified FSWs and their clients as two
priority groups for HIV prevention interventions. The focus of such interventions are mainly
providing HIV prevention education through peer educators combined with free condom
distribution and treatment for STIs (NACO, 2007). There is an urgent need for capacitating the
counsellors to shift their focus from condom counselling to deal with the problems of the sex
workers, so that their quality of life can be enhanced, and their rights get respected, recognized and
supported for their fulfilment. The study was conducted in the area of Bijapur and Bagalkot with
mentoring the counsellors working with the female sex workers, the programme was supported by
Karnataka Health Promotion Trust, a National NGO.
The present article targets the needs of counselors while working with the sex workers and
their intimate partners. Building the capacities of the counsellors so that their skilled enough in
dealing with the issues of violence, identifying mental health problems among sex worker,
empowering them to realized their rights, stop getting exploited by their intimate partners, able to
understand the boundaries in relationship. The present article deals with understanding the needs
and issues of female sex workers, violence experienced from their intimate partners, so that the
counselors skills can be capacitated to deal with the above mentioned problems of the sex workers.
Methodology:
The present study aimed at identifying the needs and issues of female sex worker in the context of
their relationship with the intimate partners. During the field visits, Key Informant Interview was
also held with the female sex workers to understand their needs and issues with their intimate
partners. The interviews were recorded in the form of field visit reports. All the field visit reports of
8 months been used for generating data for the present study. Voices were identified from the field
visit reports, similar voices were grouped under each theme. Phenomenological analysis was used
for the current study.
253
Navaneetham et al. (2017). Asian Journal of Research in Social Sciences and Humanities,
Vol. 7, No.6, pp. 251-260.
Results
All the 10 female sex workers were in the age range of 30- 50 years. All of them were from
Devadasi community. Most of them (100%) had intimate partners and majority of them experience
violence from their intimate partners. All of them have not completed their schooling. All the
female sex workers got married to the gods before they attained puberty.
Female sex workers were interviewed individually in their village with the prior consent in order to
understand the needs of the female sex workers and to understand their relationship with the
intimate partner violence. Counselling services were provided to the Devadasi women, and
continued home visits were also provided by the field staff to ensure their wellbeing.
Mrs V ‘If I ask my intimate partner to use condom he gets angry and questions that if you are not
practicing sex work why you are forcing me to use condom?’
Mrs X ‘intimate partner treats me as his property, he does not get satisfied using condoms, so
wanted to have sex without condoms’
Mrs T ‘intimate partner is like my unwed husband, but does not take care of my family needs, to
meet my economic needs, I do practice sex work, but my intimate partner feels that I should be
loyal to him’
Mrs B says ‘my intimate partner is like my husband, do I need to negotiate with him for condom
use?..... but I do not know whether he has many more women in his life, apart from his legally wed
wife’
Being loyal is something expected by all sex workers and their intimate partners. Participants
reported that their intimate partner treat them as their wives but do not have legal sanction for their
relationship. They view this relationship as more like husband and wife relationship (without legal
santity), so they find it difficult to negotiate for condom use with their intimate partners.
254
Navaneetham et al. (2017). Asian Journal of Research in Social Sciences and Humanities,
Vol. 7, No.6, pp. 251-260.
Mrs V ‘Intimate partner does not pay for sex nor takes care of my needs’
Mrs L ‘being in sex work, it is common to get physically abused by our customer, same thing is
done by the intimate partner’
Mrs T says ‘Intimate Partner suspects me of continuing sex work, gets angry and beats me,
sometimes takes away my money’
Even though the relationship is governed by violence, devadasi sex workers does not view it as
problem as they feel secured and their emotional needs been addressed by their intimate partners.
Often it is difficult to understand why does Devadasi sex worker continue such relationship which
has governed by violence?
Mrs X says ‘I like him, so would entertain him, need to bare the violence as I like him’
Mrs H ‘ Intimate partner likes me and my company, he visits regularly even though he is married
and having children, at times he uses his power to get his work done’.
Mrs B ‘in our village, husbands beats their wives, in my life intimate partner is like my husband, it
is okay to be beaten some times’
Devadasi sex worker view their relations hip as more like husband and wife without legal santity,
as they accept the violence associated with the relationship. As their intimate partners are full
filling their desire to have a ‘husband’ they bare the violence. Violence has been viewed as more a
expression of love from their liked ones. They respect and entertain their intimate partners because
their psychological needs getting addressed by regular visits from their intimate partners.
255
Navaneetham et al. (2017). Asian Journal of Research in Social Sciences and Humanities,
Vol. 7, No.6, pp. 251-260.
Mrs V ‘Intimate partner fought with me and didn’t turn up, continued sex work and got an intimate
partner. After few months first IP came and assured me to take care. Do not know what to do…..’
Mrs B ‘ it is very common for us to breakup with intimate partners, sometimes they would come
back, sometimes new customers become intimate partner’
Mrs L says ‘do not know when customer becomes our intimate partner....., look forward to be with
them, when he stop coming, do not understand what to do and why did he stop coming’
Mrs K ‘sometimes under the influence of alcohol we do not know why did we fight, it would
escalated so much that he would stop visiting, maybe I was too rude with him..... ended up with
separation’
Most Devadasi Sex workers wanted to main relationship with the intimate partners for addressing
their psychological need of security and experiencing of ‘being as wives’. Separation leads to
feeling sad and they would miss their intimate partner and look forward for their companionship,
compromise and continue the relationship with the intimate partners.
Discussion
Most of the female sex workers were Devadasi’s and engaged in sex work for their livelihood.
After abolition of the devadasi system, lost the religious and legal recognition, and many continued
their sex trade. In their sex trade they do develop or get attracted with some of their customers, and
get involved more and become their intimate partner. Most Devadasi Female sex workers did
mention financial needs as the main reason for them in entering sex work. (Datar 1992). Female sex
workers migrate to cities like Mumbai and Pune, where avibrant sex industry been practiced in the
red light areas and, has more economic perspectives for their earning. In fact, reports from both
northern Karnataka and Mumbai suggest that substantial migration of FSWs occur sfrom rural
Karnataka to Mumbai (Mukhopadhyay 1995).
Devadasi’s from their intimate partner’s faces problems such as lack of trust, conflicts,
communication difficulties, use of condom related issues, uncertainty about permanence of
relationship, unhealthy boundaries, violence and unplanned separations and new intimate
relationship. Relationship issues have significant impact on life of Devadasi’s and needs attention
for their wellbeing. Devadasi being in sex trade are undergoing many problems from society such
as stigma, discrimination, HIV/ STI health problems, economic problems, addiction, poor physical
and mental health , Housing, Money, debt and finance related issues, Coercion and violence ,
Criminalisation, lack of education etc. The current study highlights that violence has been part of
256
Navaneetham et al. (2017). Asian Journal of Research in Social Sciences and Humanities,
Vol. 7, No.6, pp. 251-260.
their sex work, violence been accepted by most of the women as they like and love their intimate
partner. Violence among sex workers have been studied extensively. The influence and severity of
violence works as a driving force for sex work involvement (Cusick and Berney, 2005). Sex
workers interviewed reported experiences of physical, sexual and verbal violence during childhood,
past experiences of abuse were said to compound feelings of worthlessness as said by Bindel et al
(2012). Physical, sexual and verbal violence are common experiences for many sex workers. Many
studies have reported that violence is a prominent feature in the lives of sex workers (Spice 2007).
A study by Bindel et al. (2012), found that two-thirds of the sex workers they interviewed
experienced violence, whilst another study by Sanders-McDonagh and Neville (2012, 2016) claims
that many sex workers have experienced increasing levels of violence and complained of
harassment by police and from their intimate partners.
A growing body of evidence suggests that couple-based interventions may be more effective than
individual-based interventions in promoting safer sex behaviours within intimate relationships (El-
Bassel et al., 2002; Syvertsen et al., 2012). It provides couples with an opportunity to learn and
practise new communication and negotiation skills together (Syvertsen et al., 2013). Women who
engage in sex work in southern India continue to be at high risk for HIV infection through
heterosexual transmission (Arora, Cyriac, & Jha, 2004).
A recent study in three districts of Karnataka found that 82% of female sex workers reported
condom use with paying clients, but only 10% reported condom use with intimate partners (Deering
et al., 2011b). A study of clients of female sex workers in brothels in Pune (Maharashtra), which
has a large number of migrant sex workers from northern Karnataka (Banandur et al., 2012), found
a number of long-term relationships (‘rakhel’) between sex workers and male partners.
Approximately half of the non-rakhel males reported ‘always using condoms’, compared to only
10% of men in rakhel relationships (Bhattacharya, 2004).
The relationships between the Devadasi women and their intimate partners are quite complex. They
compare their relationships to those of married couples in terms of power dynamics and decision-
making. Few female sex workers mentioned that Devadasis mentioned money, suspicions of
unfaithfulness, lack of interest in family matters and male partners’ alcohol use as important
reasons for disagreements. All female respondents said that having an intimate partner has given
them social status and increased their sense of security. Originally, these relationships may have
formed for money and sexual pleasure. However, over time and with the growth of love, affection
and concern for each other, they may begin to think of their relationship as equivalent to that of
husband and wife. For this reason, Devadasi women may hide their sex work practice from their
intimate partner and men may not accept their partner’s practice of sex work.
Devadasis and most of their intimate partners define their relationships differently from commercial
sex encounters. In most cases, participants consider themselves as husband and wife, and resist
behaviours that could undermine that relationship. Many Devadasi’s and other sex workers express
the belief that suggesting condom use to a person implies infidelity and mistrust (Balaiah et al,
2005; d’Cruz-Grote, 1996; Shah et al, 2011; Varma et al, 2010).
257
Navaneetham et al. (2017). Asian Journal of Research in Social Sciences and Humanities,
Vol. 7, No.6, pp. 251-260.
Limitations
Devadasi sex worker were the participants of the study and therefore the results cannot be
generalised to female sex worker community as a whole. With the changing society, the
experiences and perceptions of Devadasi’s and their male partners may also change over period of
time. So, our results apply to the particular moment in time in which people were interviewed. This
study did not explore other important factors like their early child hood experience, their future
plans, their old age etc,. More extensive, in-depth studies are needed to understand more about the
complexities of relationships between Devadasis and their intimate partners under varying
circumstances, in different kinds of communities.
Conclusion
It is a well known fact that sex workers live on the margins of society as their work lacks legal and
moral approval. Most of the Devadasi female sex workers in Karnataka are from the lower castes,
and are often poor, and uneducated. Violence was identified as a key concern for the sex workers
and often accepts in their relationship. There is an urgent need for developing interventions model
for the counsellors and equip them to deal with the relationship issues of Devadasi sex workers.
The counsellors need to shift their focus from pre test, post test, condom counselling to that of
providing supportive counselling services for women to deal with their intimate partners.
References
Arora, P., Cyriac, A., & Jha, P. (2004). India’s HIV-1 epidemic. Canadian Medical Association
Journal, 171, 1337–1338.
Balaiah, D., Naik, D. D., Ghule, M., & Tapase, P. (2005). Determinants of spacing contraceptive
use among couples in Mumbai: A male perspective. Journal of Biosocial Science, 37,
689–704.
Banandur, P., Ramanaik, S., Manhart, L. E., Buzdugan, R., Mahapatra, B., Isac, S., … Blanchard, J.
F. (2012). Understanding out-migration among female sex workers in South India.
Sexually Transmitted Diseases, 39, 776–783.
Blanchard, J., O’Neil, J., Ramesh, B. M., Bhattacharjee, P.,Orchard, T., & Moses, S. (2005).
Understanding the socialand cultural contexts of female sex workers in Karnataka,India:
Implications for prevention of HIV infection. Journalof Infectious Diseases, 191 (Suppl.1),
S139–S146.
Bhattacharya, S. (2004). Brothels and brothel clients in Pune City. In R. K. Varma, P. J. Pelto, S. L.
Schensul, & A. Joshi (Ed.), Sexuality in the time of AIDS: Contemporary perspectives
from communities in India (pp. 177–194). New Delhi: Sage.
Bindel, J. Brown, L. Easton, H. Matthews, R. and Reynolds, L. (2012) Breaking down the barriers:
A study of how women exit prostitution. London: Eaves and London South Bank
University.
258
Navaneetham et al. (2017). Asian Journal of Research in Social Sciences and Humanities,
Vol. 7, No.6, pp. 251-260.
Blanchard, J. F., O’Neil, J., Ramesh, B. M., Bhattacharjee, P., Orchard, T., & Moses, S. (2005).
Understanding the social and cultural contexts of female sex workers in Karnataka, India:
Implications for prevention of HIV infection. Journal of Infectious Diseases, 191(Suppl 1).
Burnette ML, Lucas E, Ilgen M, Frayne SM, Mayo J, WeitlaufJCPrevalence and health correlates
of prostitution among patients entering treatment for substance use disorders.Arch Gen
Psychiatry. 2008 Mar; 65(3):337-44.
Chakraborthy, K. (2000). Women as Devadasis Origin and Growth of the Devadasi Profession.
New Delhi: Deep & Deep Publications, Ltd., Pvt.
Cusick, L., & Berney, L. (2005). Prioritizing punitive responses over public health: commentary on
the Home Office consultation document Paying the Price. Critical Social Policy, 25(4),
596-606.
d’Cruz-Grote, D. (1996). Prevention of HIV infection in developing countries. Lancet, 348, 1071–
1074.
Dasgupta, N., (2000). The female slaves of God. In C. M.Agrawal (Ed.), Nari: Facets of Indian
Womanhood (vol. II)(pp. 150–163). New Delhi: Indian Publishers’ Distributors
Datar C. Reform or new form of patriarchy? Devadasis in the border region of Maharashtra and
Karnataka. Indian J SocWork 1992; 53:81–91.
Deering, K. N., Boily, M. C., Lowndes, C. M., Shoveller, J., Tyndall, M. W., Vickerman, P.,
…Alary, M. (2011b). A dose-response relationship between exposure to a large-scale HIV
preventive intervention and consistent condom use with different sexual partners of female
sex workers in southern India. BMC Public Health, 11
El-Bassel, N., Witte, S., Bilbert, L., Sormanti, M., Moreno, C., Pereira, L., … Steinglass, P.
(2002).HIV prevention for intimate couples: A relationship-based model. Families,
Systems, & Health, 19, 379–395.
Giri, V. M. (1999). Kanya. Exploitation of little angels. New Delhi: Gyan Publishing House.
Marglin, F. (1985). Wives of the God-King. The rituals of the Devadasis of Puri. New Delhi:
Oxford University Press.
259
Navaneetham et al. (2017). Asian Journal of Research in Social Sciences and Humanities,
Vol. 7, No.6, pp. 251-260.
Nair, J. (1994). The Devadasi, dharma and the state. Economic and Political Weekly, 10,
3157–3167.
National AIDS Control Organization (NACO), "Targetted Interventions among core groups under
NACP III: operational guidelines (volume 1)", NACO, Department of AIDS Control,
Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Government of India, New Delhi, 2007
O’Neil, J., Orchard, T., Swarankar, R. C., Blanchard, J. F., Gurav, K., & Moses, S. (2004).
Dhandha, dharma and disease: Traditional sex work and HIV/AIDS in rural India. Social
Science & Medicine, 59, 851–860.
Orr, L. (2000). Donors, devotees, and daughters of God. Temple women in Medieval Tamilnadu.
New York: Oxford UniversityPress.
Sanders-McDonagh, E. and Neville, L. (2012) Women’s Open Space Project Evaluation: Final
Report. London: New Horizon Youth Centre.
Shah, C., Solanki, V., & Mehta, H. B. (2011). Attitudes of adolescent girls towards contraceptive
methods. Australasian Medical Journal, 4(1), 43–48.
Spice, W. (2007) Management of sex workers and other high-risk groups. Occupational Medicine.
57: 322-328.
Syvertsen, J. L., Robertson, A. M., Abramovitz, D., Rangel, M. G., Martinez, G., Patterson, T.
L.,… Strathdee, S. A. (2012). Study protocol for the recruitment of female sex workers
and theirnon-commercial partners into couple-based HIV research. BMC Public Health,
12, 136. doi:10.1186/1471-2458-12-136
Syvertsen, J. L., Robertson, A. M., Palinkas, L. A., Rangel, M. G., Martinez, G., & Strathdee, S.
A.(2013). ‘Where sex ends and emotions begin’: Love and HIV risk among female sex
workers and their intimate, non-commercial partners along the Mexico-US border.
Culture, Health & Sexuality, 15, 540–554. doi:10.1080/13691058.2013.773381
Tarachand, K. C. (1991). Devadasi custom. Rural social structure and flesh markets. New Delhi:
Reliance Publishing House.
Varma, S. C. P., Callahan, C., Reich, W., & Cottler, L. B. (2010). Perceptions of HIV risk among
monogamous wives of alcoholic men in south India: A qualitative study. Journal of
Women’s Health, 19, 816–821.
Vimochana (1985). Devadasi (An euphemism for Prostitution).Uplift her from the morass of social
mire. Give her Dignity.Belgaum, Karnataka.
260