Petcha Kucha Article

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 6

ACTIVE LEARNING TO IMPROVE PRESENTATION SKILLS: THE USE OF

PECHA KUCHA IN UNDERGRADUATE SALES MANAGEMENT CLASSES


Robert E. McDonald and Joseph M. Derby

Recruiters seek candidates with certain business skills that are not developed in the typical lecture-
based classroom. Instead, active-learning techniques have been shown to be effective in honing
these skills. One skill that is particularly important in sales careers is the ability to make a powerful
and effective presentation. To help students develop strong presentation skills, two sections of an
undergraduate sales management course included an exercise in which students make a presenta-
tion using a Pecha Kucha format. Active-learning exercises like this promote both thinking and
doing, and improve student engagement. The expectation is that the exercise will not only improve
presentation skills, but also content knowledge. The effectiveness of the format is assessed through
instructor observation, pre- and postpresentation student surveys, student reection papers, and
examination.
Downloaded by [Deviprasad K] at 20:44 10 April 2015

Beyond the discipline-specic knowledge that students develop professional skills through creative exploration
learn in college, corporate recruiters look for students of course materials. This approach requires students to
who have a variety of valued skills (McDaniel & use higher order thinking processes such as analysis,
White, 1993). One skill that is particularly important synthesis, and evaluation of the course content (Hunt
for students who pursue a sales career is the ability to & Laverie, 2004). Active-learning studies conducted in
make an effective presentation. To address this need, business school settings indicate that they facilitate
marketing educators are placing more emphasis student learning (Auster & Wylie, 2006). In the context
on developing communication skills (Young & of sales courses, research supports the proposition that
Murphy, 2003). Active learning is one pedagogy that active learning teaching strategies facilitate student
has been used successfully to improve these valuable learning (Bowers & Summey, 1983; McDonald, 2006).
skills (Hunt & Laverie, 2004). Active learning is “any A new approach for developing student communica-
strategy that involves students in doing things and tion skills is the Pecha Kucha method (Beyer, 2011).
thinking about the things they are doing” (Bonwell & Pecha Kucha, Japanese for “chit chat” and sometimes
Eison, 1991). Active learning is effective because “stu- referred to as “lightening talk,” is a highly disciplined
dents are simply more likely to internalize, understand, presentation structure in which 20 slides are presented
and remember material learned through active engage- at a rate of 20 seconds per slide, limiting the overall
ment in the learning process” (Bonwell & presentation time to 6 minutes and 40 seconds. A key
Sutherland, 1996). Such experiential learning empha- difference between Pecha Kucha presentations and
sizes active student-centered learning, with the profes- standard PowerPoint presentations is the use of pic-
sor’s role not as an expert but rather as a facilitator for tures and graphics on the slides to supplement com-
encouraging learning through participatory experience munication of ideas rather than bullet-point text,
(Hunt & Laverie, 2004). Experiential learning facilitates charts, and graphs. In a Pecha Kucha presentation,
student involvement beyond being passive listeners. the presenter is challenged to marry the visual images
Rather, students engage in activities that actively on the slides with his or her verbal presentation
(Klentzin, Paladino, Johnston, & Devine, 2010).
Whereas traditional presentation styles often involve
Robert E. McDonald (Ph.D., University of Connecticut), cluttered slides with an excessive amount of content, in
United Supermarkets Professor of Marketing, Rawls Pecha Kucha, slides are simple and interesting, serving
College of Business, Texas Tech University, Lubbock, TX,
as a helpful background on which to deliver the pre-
bob.mcdonald@ttu.edu.
sentation. At times, using slides that are overloaded
Joseph M. Derby (Ph.D., Texas Tech University), Assistant
Professor, College of Business, James Madison University, with textual information, presenters resort to turning
Harrisonburg, VA, derbyjm@jmu.edu. their backs on the audience and reading their slides in

Marketing Education Review, vol. 25, no. 1 (spring 2015), pp. 21–25.
Copyright Ó 2015 Society for Marketing Advances
ISSN: 1052–8008 (print) / ISSN 2153–9987 (online)
DOI: 10.1080/10528008.2015.999593
22 Marketing Education Review

what has derisively become known as “PowerPoint school-related activities, the instructor created the sche-
Karaoke.” Using Pecha Kucha requires that the presen- dule by randomly assigning students to one of the four
ter know the material well enough to present without presentation days. Topic assignments were sent one
the crutch of the slides. Instead, the presenter faces the week in advance. To ensure success, active-learning
audience and genuinely engages them. Presented pedagogies utilize reective exercises to solidify learn-
images are the distilled essence of the point being cov- ing (Kolb, 1984). As part of the assignment, students
ered during the 20 seconds it is viewed. In this way, the were asked to write a brief paper reecting on their
images enhance the audience’s understanding, rather Pecha Kucha experience within one week of the pre-
than compete for its attention. sentation. To help students prepare for the assignment,
Recent studies indicate that the Pecha Kucha the instructor e-mailed a list of links to help students
method provides learning and skill development learn about the Pecha Kucha technique. Some of these
advantages over standard PowerPoint presentations. links led to YouTube videos on the subject. The instruc-
Beyer (2011) found in a psychology class setting that tor presented the assignment using the technique to
the fast-paced Pecha Kucha presentation style was rated serve as an example. Prior to giving specic assignment
higher than standard PowerPoint presentations for instructions, we surveyed students to assess their per-
visual, presenter eye contact, and overall presentation ceptions of Pecha Kucha.
quality. Similarly, Levin and Peterson (2013) found A parallel survey was conducted after all students
from their study of an M.B.A. marketing class that completed their presentations. Students in our program
Downloaded by [Deviprasad K] at 20:44 10 April 2015

students rated a Pecha Kucha group presentation have extensive presentation experience. Many of the
assignment as the most satisfying of the six assign- faculty use active-learning pedagogies, often requiring
ments for the course. In this paper, we extend this students to present case analyses, marketing plans, or
work and examine both qualitative and quantitative course content. Yet the unique format of the Pecha
assessments of using Pecha Kucha. Kucha assignment created some anxiety. As a result,
the instructor noted an increase in the number of stu-
dent e-mails and ofce hour visits by students seeking
THE PECHA KUCHA ASSIGNMENT reassurance that they were on the right track. Beyond
the anxiety, students reported spending at least twice,
In an attempt to engage students, improve their pre-
and as much as four times, the time and effort prepar-
sentation skills, and increase their content learning, the
ing and practicing for the Pecha Kucha presentation as
instructor introduced a Pecha Kucha presentation
for a typical presentation in other classes.
requirement to the syllabus of an undergraduate sales
management course. The innovation was rst applied
in the fall semester of 2012 in a class of 60 students and Execution
then again during the spring 2014 semester in a class of
To minimize the amount of class time used for setup
42 students. The same instructor taught both sections.
between presentations, students were required to e-
The presentations were made during four separate class
mail their presentation slides to the instructor a mini-
periods during each semester. The presentations were
mum of 24 hours in advance. To ensure that the pre-
used as a review for each exam covering topics such as
sentation met the time requirement, students were
territory design, job descriptions, motivation, and sales
instructed to automate their slide show to advance
contests. To allow for 10 to 15 presentations in a single
every 20 seconds. Students were encouraged to time
class period, and to make the assignment more man-
their presentations to make sure the automation
ageable for undergraduate students, the format was
worked. The instructor advised the students that to be
modied to include only 10 slides, reducing presenta-
successful, they needed to practice the presentation to
tion times in half to 3 minutes and 20 seconds.
the point where they could deliver it without relying
on note cards.
Preparation Prior to class, the instructor loaded the presentation
les on the classroom computer and opened each so
Early in the semester, after asking students to report each student could begin presenting within seconds of
any absences anticipated during the semester for reaching the podium. Even so, instructors using this
Spring 2015 23

technique need to allow time to transition from stu- majority presented without extensive reliance on
dent to student. Since each presentation is exactly 3 notes. Students seem to enjoy the exercise and were
minutes and 20 seconds, the instructor can accurately excited about making their presentations. A number of
estimate the amount of time needed in each class. For students commented on the unexpected amount of
10 presentations, the instructor should allow 40 to 45 work to condense a topic into 10 slides. Some of the
minutes, and for 15, an hour to an hour and 5 minutes. presenters read their presentations from a script despite
the instructor’s admonition not to do so and the qual-
ity of their presentations suffered. They had difculty
Assessing the Assignment holding the attention of the class audience. Students
The assignment was assessed in multiple ways: pre- and who knew their subject matter well and practiced their
postpresentation student surveys, qualitative grading of presentations demonstrated exceptional presentation
each presentation, content analysis of reection papers, skills, condently presenting the material like profes-
and quantitative comparison of examination perfor- sionals. Many students used business-related cartoons
mance. The instructor rated the presenters using a grad- in their slides to get their point across. Many used slides
ing rubric that measures accuracy of content, clarity of featuring scenes from popular movies or television
presentation, quality of slides, quality of presentation shows (The Ofce was a common source), as well as
(with or without notes), creativity, and interest gener- celebrity images. Overall, the slides were highly crea-
ated. In addition, each student’s reection paper tive. Some of the best slides appeared to have been
Downloaded by [Deviprasad K] at 20:44 10 April 2015

further informed the instructor’s assessment. With created by students rather than just cutting and pasting
few exceptions, the presentations were impressive. pictures that more or less captured the idea.
The instructor judged that one presentation in each
class was better than the instructor’s example presenta- Reection Papers
tion. Most exceeded the instructor’s expectations. In
fall 2012, nearly 68 percent of the class received grades Student reection was guided by a series of questions
of A and 20 percent received Bs. There were also Cs (5 provided by the instructor. Most students reported that
percent), Ds (3 percent), and two Fs (3 percent). The they enjoyed their presentations and that they learned
poor grades were for presentations that were judged to the presented material better than if they had studied it.
have been thrown together at the last minute without Nearly all said that they would prepare much more the
proper preparation and practice. In the spring 2014 next time they presented using Pecha Kucha, including
class, 69 percent received a grade of A, 26 percent the student who practiced 25 times. Staying on track was
received a B, and two (5 percent) failed. In this class, reported as a benet of using this technique. Another
the Fs were for failure to make the presentation. In surprising benet was that the pace and need to know
both classes, students unavoidably missed their sched- the material greatly reduced ller syllables such as “um.”
uled presentations, one for a child-care emergency and A large number of students related learning about them-
the other for a job interview. Fortunately, both were selves as presenters, such as the need for control or the
scheduled early enough that the instructor could ability to present condently. Self-awareness is com-
reschedule them for the nal presentation day. Had monly reported in reection exercises.
these emergencies arisen for students scheduled for
the last day, a makeup would not be possible and an Quantitative Analysis
alternative assignment would have to be found.
Student Surveys

RESULTS Comparing before-and-after surveys in the spring 2014


class, only ve items were signicant. Students enjoyed
Qualitative Analysis their presentation more than they thought they would (p
Instructor Observations < 0.01) and thought that presenting in this style helped
them better understand the course (p < 0.10). After using
Nearly all students met the exacting time requirements. the technique, students reported higher responses regard-
Although most students were clearly nervous, the ing whether they would use Pecha Kucha after the course
24 Marketing Education Review

(p < 0.05), and that it would help them in their selling valuable skills sought by businesses. Although the assign-
careers (p < 0.10). Students also reported that watching ment did not affect student performance on examina-
their classmates present helped them to better prepare for tions, other assessments indicate that this was a valuable
exams than they had anticipated in the pre-presentation exercise. In particular, students believed that they learned
survey (p < 0.05). from the experience, the instructor observed skilled and
even professional-level presentations, and corporate
representatives have expressed interest in the technique.
Examination Performance Use of the Pecha Kucha assignment is not limited to
Analysis of performance on examinations did not yield sales management courses but could easily be adopted in
support for the idea that this assignment would improve any class that incorporates student presentations, under-
course content learning. Scores on exams immediately graduate or graduate. For example, students in a marketing
following a student’s presentation were not signicantly research course might present the results of a study con-
different compared with scores on the other three exams ducted as a class activity. In a promotions class, students
in the semester. Furthermore, examination scores in the might present communication options or a strategy.
two sections that used Pecha Kucha presentations were
not signicantly different from exam scores in other sec- CONCLUSIONS
tions of sales management taught by the same instructor
without Pecha Kucha and using similar examinations. Pecha Kucha presentations appear to be well suited for
Downloaded by [Deviprasad K] at 20:44 10 April 2015

teaching sales management concepts. The short dura-


tion of the presentations is a good t for larger classes.
Anecdotal Evidence More importantly, it forces students to distill the pre-
sentation subject to its essence to deliver it in a brief
After using Pecha Kucha in the fall 2012 semester, the
and interesting manner. Students favorably perceive
instructor discovered anecdotal evidence that Pecha
the exercise of preparing and delivering the presenta-
Kucha skills are indeed valued by recruiters. In fact,
tion in this style. Although in our study we nd no
some use them in their sales training programs. First,
quantitative support that the Pecha Kucha format
the two students with the highest Pecha Kucha grades
improves content understanding and retention, it
in the fall 2012 semester were hired by the same
does appear to sharpen presentation skills.
Fortune 500 Company. When corporate trainers dis-
covered that one of them had Pecha Kucha experience,
she was asked to consult on the development of the REFERENCES
company’s own Pecha Kucha training program. Auster, E. R., & Wylie, K. K. (2006). Creating active learning in
Second, during a conference with a Fortune 100 the classroom: A systematic approach. Journal of
company that was intended to encourage them to Management Education, 30(April), 333–353.
recruit at the instructor’s college, one of the human Beyer, A. M. (2011). Improving student presentations: Pecha
Kucha and just plain PowerPoint. Teaching of Psychology,
resources managers mentioned that their new salespeo- 38(April), 122–126.
ple were taught Pecha Kucha near the end of the two- Bonwell, C. C., & Eison, J. A. (1991). Active learning: Creating
year training period. The instructor then explained that excitement in the classroom. ASHE-ERIC Higher Education
this technique was taught in the undergraduate sales Reports. Washington, DC.
———, C. C., & Sutherland, T. E. (1996). The active learning
management class. The company representative
continuum: Choosing activities to engage students in the
expressed surprise and excitement, and committed to classroom. New Directions for Teaching and Learning, 67-
recruit at the school. Company representatives (Fall), 3–16.
attended the college’s career fair a month later. Bowers, M., & Summey, J. H. (1983). A curriculum for perso-
nal sales training in an academic setting. Journal of
Marketing Education, 5(1), 11–15.
Hunt, S. D., & Laverie, D. A. (2004). Experiential learning and
DISCUSSION the Hunt-Vitell theory of ethics: Teaching marketing
ethics by integrating theory and practice. Marketing
Active-learning techniques such as Pecha Kucha can Education Review, 14(Fall), 1–14.
increase student involvement in a course in general and Klentzin, J. C., Bounds Paladino, E., Johnston, B., & Devine,
specically help students to develop important and C. (2010). Pecha Kucha: Using “lightening talk” in
Spring 2015 25

university instruction. Reference Services Review, 38(1), majors: An assessment by company recruiters.
158–167. Marketing Education Review, 3(Fall), 9–16.
Kolb, D. (1984). Experiential learning: Experience as the source of McDonald, R. E. (2006). Videotaped role play exercises in
learning. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall. large sales management classes. Journal for Advancement
Levin, M. A., & Peterson, L. T. (2013). Use of Pecha Kucha in of Marketing Education, 8(Summer), 32–37.
marketing students’ presentations. Marketing Education Young, M. R., & Murphy, J. W. (2003). Integrating commu-
Review, 23(Spring), 59–63. nication skills into the marketing curriculum: A
McDaniel, S. W., & White, J. C. (1993). The quality of the case study. Journal of Marketing Education, 25(April),
academic preparation of undergraduate marketing 57–70.
Downloaded by [Deviprasad K] at 20:44 10 April 2015
Copyright of Marketing Education Review is the property of M.E. Sharpe Inc. and its content
may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright
holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for
individual use.

You might also like