Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 22

NFPA1081 Standard Additional NFPA Standards

Inc ipie nt Indust ria l Fire B riga de Me mbe r 5.2.1 * Exti ngui sh i nci pi ent fi res, NFPA 600 Standard on Industri al Fi re Bri gades N FPA
gi ven an i nci pi ent fi re and a sel ecti on of portabl e fi re extingui shers, so that the 921 Gui de to Fi re and Expl osi on Investi gati ons
correct exti ngui sher i s chosen, the fire i s compl etel y exti ngui shed, proper
extingui sher-handling techniques are followed, and the area of ori gi n and fi re cause
evi dence are preserved. 5 .3.1 * Attack an i ncipient stage fi re, gi ven a handli ne Knowledge Objectives
flowi ng up to 473 L/mi n (125 gpm), appropri ate equi pment, and a fi re si tuati on, so
After compl eti ng thi s chapter, you will be abl e to:
that the fi re i s approached safel y, exposures are protected, the spread of fire i s
• Descri be the rol e and rel ationshi p of the bri gade member to cri mi nal
stopped, agent appli cati on i s effecti ve, the fi re i s exti ngui shed, and the area of investi gators and insurance i nvesti ga tors.
ori gi n and fi re cause evi dence are preserved. • Di fferenti ate acci dental fi res from i ncendi ary fi res.
(B) Requi si te Skill s. The abili ty to recogni ze i nherent hazards related to the • Descri be the poi nt of ori gi n.
materi al 's confi gurati on; operate handli nes; prevent water hammers when shut ting • Define the chai n of custody.
down nozzl es; open, close, and adj ust nozzl e fl ow; advance charged and • Descri be demonstrati ve, di rect, and ci rcumstanti al evi dence.
uncharged hose; extend handli nes; operate handli nes; eval uate and modify water • Descri be techni ques for preservi ng fi re cause evi dence.
appli cati on for maxi mum penetration; asse ss patterns for ori gi n determi nati on; • Descri be the observati ons bri gade members shoul d make duri ng
and eval uate for complete exti ngui shment. fireground operati ons.
• Descri be the steps needed to secure a property.
• Expl ai n the i mportance of protecti ng a fi re scene.
A dv a nc ed Ext e rior Indust ria l Fire B riga de Me mbe r 6.2 .6 O verhaul a fi re
scene, gi ven personal protecti ve equi pment, a handli ne, hand tool s, a fl ashli ght,
and an assi gnment, so that structural i ntegri ty i s not compromi sed, all hi dden fi res
are di scovered, fi re cause evi dence i s preserved, and the fi re i s extingui shed.
Skills Objectives
There are no skill s obj ecti ves for thi s chapter.
(A) Requi site Knowl edge. Types of fi re handlines and water appli cati on devi ces
most effecti ve for overhaul , water appli cati on methods for exti ngui shment that
limi t water damage, types of tool s and methods used to expose hi dden fi re,
dangers associ ated with overhaul , obvi ous si gns of area of ori gi n or si gns of
arson, and reasons for protecti on of fi re scene.
(B) Requi si te Skill s. The abili ty to depl oy and operate a handli ne, expose voi d
spaces wi thout compromi si ng structural i ntegrity, appl y water for maxi mum
effecti veness, expose and exti ngui sh hi dden fires, recogni ze and preserve
obvi ous si gns of area of ori gi n and fi re cause, and eval uate for compl ete
extingui shment.

Int erior St ruc t ura l Indust ria l Fire B riga de M e mbe r 7.2 .4* Overhaul a fi re
scene, gi ven personal protecti ve equi pment, attack li ne, hand tool s, a fl ashli ght,
and an assi gnment, so that structural i ntegrity i s not compromi sed, all hi dden fi res
are di scovered, fi re cause evi dence i s preserved, and the fi re i s extingui shed.
(A) Requi si te Knowl edge. Types of fi re handli nes and appli cati on devi ces most
effecti ve for overhaul, appli cati on methods for exti ngui shi ng agents that li mit
damage, types of tool s and methods used to expose hi dden fi re, dangers associ
ated wi th overhaul , obvious si gns of area of ori gi n and si gns of arson, and
reasons for protecti on of fi re scene.
(B) Requi site Skill s. The abili ty to depl oy and operate handli nes, expose voi d
spaces wi thout compromi si ng structural i ntegrity, appl y exti ngui shi ng agents for
maxi mum effecti veness, expose and extingui sh hidden fi res, recogni ze and
preserve obvi ous si gns of area of origi n and fi re cause, and eval uate for com
pl ete exti ngui shme nt.
Your industrial plant has just undergone a major reconstruction effort to modernize some of the
older equipment and part of the building that was built in the late 1960s. The area has a lot of
electrical and hydraulic equipment that had been replaced with new up-to-date equipment. You
are working an afternoon shift and about 7:00 pm you hear the fire alarm going off and the PA
stating there is a fire in the prefab area.

You respond and find that the fire is around one of the new pieces of equipment and appears to
be very intense. You grab a fire extinguisher and attempt to control the fire. At that point the fire
protection system is activated and the sprinkler system begins to control the fire.

The brigade leader asks you to make an initial assessment of the possible cause of the fire. It
appears that the main electrical service line has a section missing and there is heavy damage in
the area where it connects to the machine. The hydraulic lines in this area are also damaged and
could have added fuel to the fire.
1. What will the plant safety officer ask you about your observations?
2. Did you see anything that points to the cause of the fire?
3. What evidence at the scene would need to be protected?

Introduction Who Conducts Fire Investigations?


Brigade members usually arrive at a fire scene before a trained In most jurisdictions, a city or state official (fire marshal) has a
fire investigator arrives. This means that brigade members are legal responsibility to determine the causes of fires. So me fire
able to observe important signs and patterns that the investi- brigades may ask an investigator whether a person fro m the
gators can use in determin ing how and where the fire started. brigade can be assigned to assist in or observe the inves -
By identifying and preserving possible evidence, as well as tigation process. Where the cause of the fire is determined
recalling and report ing objective findings, brigade members not to be arson, many industrial facilit ies will conduct a root
provide essential assistance to fire investigators. In so me cause analysis to determine the cause.
cases, the observations and actions of brigade members could Typically, fire brigade leaders init iate fire cause investi-
be significant in apprehending and convict ing arsonists. gations and then tu rn the materials and info rmat ion iden -
Fire brigades determine the causes of fires so they can take tified th roug h th is invest igat io n over to insu rance
steps to prevent future fires . For examp le, a fire b rigade representatives or plant safety officers. If criminal act ivity is
might develop an education p rogram to reduce accidental suspected, the appropriate official responsible fo r investi-
fires. A series of fires could point to a product defect, such as a gations will be contacted. If the cause of the fire is obvious
design error in a ch imney flue or the improper installation of and accidental, the fire brigade leader wou ld usually be
chimney flues. Identifying fires that were intentionally set responsible for gathering the in format ion and filing the
could lead to the arrest of the person responsible. necessary repo rts. If the cause cannot be determin ed or
Brigade members must understand the basic princip les of appears to be suspicious, the fire b rigade leader should
fire investigation and participate in this impo rtant depart - summon an investigato r.
mental responsibility. Fire cause determination is often diffi-
cult , because impo rtant ev idence can be consu med by the Investigation Authority
fire o r destroyed during fire suppression operations or during An arson invest igation must determine not on ly the cause
salvage and overhaul. Investigators must rely on brigade and origin of the fire, but also who was responsible for start-
members to observe, capture, and retain in format ion, as well in g it an d wh at s eq u en ce o f ev ents led u p t o it .
as to preserve evidence until it can be examined . Ev idence Determinat ion o f cause and o rigin is a s mall but important
that is lost can never be rep laced. step in the overall investigation. To p rove that a crime took
Fire C a use D eter mi nati on 755

Brigade Member Tips Insurance companies often investigate fires to determine


the validity of a claim or to identify factors that might help pre-
Fire invest igations involv e m uch m ore than sim ply determining what vent future fires. The cost of an investigation is more than offset
caused the fire, where it started, and whether it was accidental or by the savings the company would realize by identifying a
incendiary (intentionally set ). Many fire inv estigations also examine fraudulent claim. So me insurance companies have their own
many ot her aspects of a fire incident. investigators, while others retain independent investigators.
If the fire res ults in injuries or fatalities, the invest igation often will These outside investigators often have valuable experience and
examine ev ery factor that could have contributed to or prevented thos e can provide technical support to determine the cause of a fire.
losses. In a fire that c aus es millions of dollars in dam age, a w hole
range of factors could c ont ribute t o the large loss. Investigators could
examine the construction and contents of the building to determine Causes of Fires
whet her fire and building c odes were f ol lowed, if the built-in fire
protection systems functioned properly, or w hat lessons could be Every fire has a cause, which the fire investigator tries to
applied t o am ending codes or ins pection procedures. A fire uncover. A cause and origin investigation determines where,
investigation can teach many lessons, even if the specific cause and why, and how the fire orig inated. So me fires have simp le
origin are never det ermined. causes th at are easily ident ified and understood; oth ers
The NFPA inv estigates major incidents around the world to identify result fro m a co mplex set of circu mstances that must be
factors that contributed to an unus ual num ber of deaths or wide spread
examined carefully to determine what actually happened. In
property dam age. The NFPA us es this information to am end its codes
and standards to help av oid fut ure cat astrophes. some cases, the cause of a fire will never be determined with
absolute certainty.
Basically, every fire has a starting point where ignition
occurs and fuel begins to burn. This location is the point of
origin of the fire. At the point of origin, an ignition source
co mes into contact with a fuel supp ly , such as a lighted
place, investigators must establish a link fro m the fire to the match touching a piece of paper. The cause of the fire is the
cause and origin and eliminate any other possible cause. part icu lar set o f circu mst ances that b rought the ign ition
Whether the fire invest igators have po lice po wers and can source into contact with the fuel.
conduct a criminal investigation depends on state and local Fires resu lt when a competent ig niti on s ource and a
laws. In some jurisdictions, fire investigators may have police fuel co me together long enough to ignite. A co mpetent ign i-
powers du ring fire inv estigat ions . In other areas, police tion source must have enough heat energy to ignite the fuel
officers are trained as fire investigators. Sometimes fire and must be in contact with the fuel until the fuel reaches its
investigators determine the cause and origin , and turn the ignit ion temperature, wh ich cou ld be a fract ion of a second
investigation over to a law en forcement agency if the fire is to hours, days, or weeks.
determined to be intentionally set. In other ju risdict ions, fire A fire can be caused by an act or by an omission. Igniting a
brigade and po lice depart ment personnel wo rk together piece of paper with a match is an act. Working in the area and
throughout the investigation. not observing the p roper protective measures to ensure the
heat is not trans mitted to co mbustib le parts and allo w ing
Investigation Assistance them to heat and ignite co mbustibles is considered an
Most fire org an izat ions , fire brig ades, and gov ern ment omission. Leav ing a weed bu rner o r propane to rch unat -
agencies have limit ed t ime, personnel, and resou rces for tended would be considered an omission. The cause of a fire
fire investigations. A state fire marshal or similar authority can also be classified as either incend iary or accidental.
may have an investigations unit that concentrates on major Arson, wh ich is the malicious bu rn ing o f on e's o wn o r
incidents and supports local investigators on s maller fires. another's property with a criminal intent, is an incendi ary
Because these inv estigato rs cannot always reach the fire fire. Acci dental fires do not involve a criminal or malicious
scene quickly, the local fire brigade must be prepared to intent, even if they are caused by hu man error or careless -
conduct a tho rough preliminary investig ation and to pro tect ness. Falling asleep with a lit cigarette wou ld be considered
the scene and p reserve ev idence. an accidental cause. Emptying an ashtray into a wastepaper
Federal resources are also available for major investiga- basket would be considered an accidental cause.
tions. The U.S. Bureau o f A lcohol, Tobacco and Firearms Investigators should always consider a fire to have an
(ATF) has individual agents who can assist local jurisdictions undetermined cause until the specific cause is established.
with fire investigations. The ATF also has response teams The evidence fro m both incendiary and accidental fires can
across the count ry that respond to larg e-scale incidents. be very similar. Untrained indiv iduals should not attempt to
Each of these teams has about 15 agents and equipment that categorize fires as either incendiary or accidental. Brigade
ranges from simple tools for digging out a fire scene to members are responsible for helping to identify and preserve
laser-surveying devices fo r fu lly docu menting the scene. possible ev idence for the fire investigator to examine.
75G I N D U S T R I A L F I R E B R I G A D E : P R I N C I P L E S AN D P R A C T I C E

Fire Cause Statistics every trace of evidence. Investigators will classify these fires
as having an undetermined cause, rather than use a "best
Most structure fires occur in residential occupancies; ho me
guess." For examp le, low temperatu re ignit ion can occur
fires represent 73% of all structure fires. The 10 leading causes
when wood is subjected to low heat , such as that generated
of structure fires in industrial propert ies, averaged over the
by steam pipes or incandescent light bulbs, for a long period of
years 1999 to 2002, are shown in (Table 26-1).
time. Gradually, the wood can deteriorate and eventually
Accidental Fire Causes ignite. If the fire destroys the building, the point of orig in
would be d ifficu lt to ident ify . In an industrial sett ing, a
Accident al fires have hund reds o f poss ib le causes and
mach ine part that is not lubricated or that is wearing out
invo lve mu lt ip le facto rs and circu mstan ces. The most
might cause heavy damage and ignite other co mbustible
impo rtant reason for invest ig at ing and d etermin ing the
material. The ev idence might be consumed, making a cause
causes of accidental fires is to prevent future fires. To reduce
determination d ifficult.
the number o f fires, efforts must concentrate on the most fre-
quent causes and those involving the greatest risks of death, Incendiary Fire Causes
inju ry, and property damage.
People may set fires for several reasons and in many different
Most fires, fire deaths, and injuries occur in residential
ways. The same type of cause and origin investigation is
occup ancies. The most co mmo n ly repo rt ed accidental
needed to identify where and ho w the fire started. W ith
causes of fire in these occupancies involve smoking, cooking,
incendiary fires, it is particu larly important to ru le out pos -
heating equip ment, and electrical equip ment. These statistics
sible accidental causes to prove beyond doubt that the fire
provide a foundation for fire p revention and public education
was deliberately set.
efforts. Additional analysis can provide more specific
A fire caused by arson requires a second phase of inves -
information. For instance, fires caused by electrical
tigation to identify the person responsible. A ll of the ev i-
equipment can be d ivided into four g roups: those caused by
dence relating to the cause of the fire must be handled in a
wo rn -out o r d efect iv e equ ip ment , by imp roper use of
way that ensures it would be ad missible as ev idence in a
approved equipment, by defective installat ions, and by other
criminal trial. A trained, qualified fire investigator should
accidents. A p roper, thorough investigation of an elect rical
always be called to determine the cause of any fire that may
fire would identify and classify the specific cause within one
have been deliberately set.
of these groups. Industrial settings have many varied possible
Arson and the facto rs that cou ld ind icate an incendiary
causes. Each may need to be considered .
fire cause are discussed in more detail later in this chapter. A
For examp le, wo rn-out or defective electrical equ ip ment
fire might be set at an industrial facility for several reasons. A
would include deterio rating 50-year-old wiring circuits or a
mot ive is often needed to p rove what happened. This will be
computer circuit board with an internal defect. Other
discussed later. A fire may be set in order to get off shift early
worn-out equ ip ment that might still be in use includes
or to make a po int to the supervisors that things are unsafe.
electrical motors, switches, appliances, and extension cords.
Properly used and maintained equ ip ment that has been
tested and listed by a recognized laboratory rarely causes a Determining the Cause and Origin of a Fire
fire, but should be rep laced when it wears out.
A systemat ic analysis is needed to determine the cause and
Placing a portable heater too close to flammable materials
orig in of a fire. The investigator must determine where the
or using a toaster oven to heat a container of flammab le g lue
fire started and ho w it was ignited . The investigator must
are examp les of the improper use of elect rical equ ipment.
look at the s ituation ob ject ively to be sure that the evidence
Defect ive installations are those not acceptable under
is conv incing and fu lly exp lains the situ at ion . If there is
electrical codes or printed instructions, such as using a
more than one possible exp lanat ion fo r the observat ions,
light-duty extension co rd to connect a heavy-duty app liance
each possibility must be considered. The cause cannot be
to a wall outlet.
determined with abso lute certainty unt il all alternat ive
Some electrical fires result from an accidental misuse or
exp lanat ions have been ru led out .
oversight, such as unintentionally leaving a cooking appliance
turned on. The improper maintenance of the machinery might Identifying the Point of Origin
be the cause of the fire. Natural events can also cause accidental
One of the first steps in a fire investigation is identifying the
electrical fires, such as when a tree falls on a wire. A fire caused
point of origin. At this location, the investigator can look for
by an electrical overload or a short circuit can start wherever
clues indicat ing the specific cause of the fire.
there is electricity, such as in the electrical panel, fuses, fuse
The investigation process usually begins with an exami-
boxes, circuit breakers, wiring, and appliances.
nation o f the bu ild ing's ext erio r. The investig ator should
So met imes it may be d ifficu lt o r impossible to identify
lo o k fo r ind icat ions t hat th e fire o rig inated ou ts id e t he
the specific source o f ign it ion because the fire destroyed
fire C a us e De ter mi na ti on 757

Table 26-1 Leading Causes of Structure Fires in Industrial and


Manufacturing Properties 2000-2004 Annual Averages
Cause Fires Civilian Civilian Direct
Deaths Injuries Property Da mage
(in M ill io ns)

Shop tools and industrial 1,790 (15%) 2 (12%) 145 (40%) $83.4 (11%)
equipment excluding torc hes,
burners or s oldering irons
Heating equipm ent fires 1,430 (12%) 3 (15%) 40 (11%) $48.5 (6%)
Identified heating equipment 580 (5%) 2 (12%) 22 (6%) $44.6 (6%)
Confined heating equipment 850 (7%) 1 (3%) 18 (5%) $3. 9 (1%)
Electric al distribution and 640 (5%) 3 (15%) 14 (4%) $42.8 (6%)
lighting equipm ent
Cooking equipm ent fires 400 (3%) 0 (0%) 2 (0%) $16.2 (2%)
Identified c ooking equipm ent 50 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) $10.5 (1%)
Confined cooking fire 340 (3%) 0 (0%) 2 (0%) $5.8 (1%)
Expos ure to other fire 380 (3%) 0 (0%) 5 (1%) $11.6 (2%)
Intentional 380 (3%) 0 (0%) 3 (1%) $16.9 (2%)
Torc h, burner or s oldering iron 320 (3%) 1 (8%) 12 (3%) $10.4 (1%)
Confined comm ercial 220 (2%) 0 (0%) 3 (1%) $0.7 (0%)
compactor fire
Spontaneous combustion or 210 (2%) 1 (9%) 2 (1%) $14.0 (2%)
chemic al reaction
Confined fire inv olving 200 (2%) 0 (0%) 5 (1%) $3.1 (0%)
incinerator overload or
malfunction
Sm oking m aterials (i. e., light ed 180 (2%) 0 (0%) 1 (0%) $3.9 (1%)
tobacc o products)
Contained tras h or rubbis h fire 1,060 (9%) 0 (0%) 4 (1%) $0.5 (0%)

Note: T hese are the leading caus es, obtained from t he following list: intentional (from the NFIR S field "c ause"); play ing wit h fire (from fact or contributing t o
ignition); confined heating (including confined chimney and confined fuel burner or boiler fires), confined cooking, confined comm ercial c om pact or, confined
fire involving incinerat or overload or malfunction, and contained tras h or rubbish from incident type; identified heating, identified c ook ing, clot hes dry er or
was her, torc h (including burner and s oldering iron), electrical distribution and lighting equipm ent, medic al equipm ent, and e lectronic, offic e or entertainm ent
equipment (from eq uipm ent inv olv ed in ignition); smoking m aterials, candles, lightning, and s pontaneous combustion or c hemical reaction (from h eat sourc e).
The statistics on sm oking m aterials and candles include a proportional share of fires in w hic h the heat source w as hea t from an unc lassified open flam e or
smoking m aterial. Exposure fires include fires w ith an ex pos ure num ber greater than zero, as w ell as fires identified by heat sourc e or factor contributing to
ignition w hen no equipm ent was inv olved in ignition and the fires w ere not int entionally set. Bec aus e c ont ained tras h or rubbish fires are a sc enario without
caus al inf orm ation on heat sourc e, equipm ent inv olv ed, or factor contributing to ignition, they are show n at the bottom of the table if they account for at least
2% of the fires. Cas ual inf ormation is not routinely collect ed for these incidents. T he s am e fire can be list ed under m ultiple causes, bas ed on m ultiple dat a
elements. Details on handling of unknow ns, partial unk nowns, and other unders pecified c odes m ay be found in the Appendix.
Thes e are national estimat es of fires reported to U.S. municipal fire depart ments and so exclude fires reported only to Feder al or state agencies or indus trial fire
brigades. Thes e national estimat es are projections bas ed on the detailed inf orm ation collected in Version 5.0 of NFIRS. Casua lty and loss projec tions c an be
heavily influenc ed by the inclusion or exclusion of one unus ually s erious fire. Fires are rounded to the nearest ten, civilian deat hs and injuries are rounded to
the nearest one, and direct property dam age is rounded to the nearest hundred thousand dollars. Property damage has not been adjusted for inflation.

Source: NFIRS and NFPA survey.


758 I N D U S T R I A L F I R E B R I G A D E : P R I N C I P L E S A N D P R A C T I C E

(Figure 26 -1) D epth of char. (Figure 26-2) Oft en the point of a V-patt ern is near or at the point of
origin.

build ing befo re loo king inside, and shou ld s ize -up the room or area where the damage is most severe. Because heat
build ing to identify important informat ion. The overall size, rises, the flow of heated gases from a fire will almost always
construction, layout, and occupancy of the bu ild ing should be up and out fro m the po int o f orig in. Th is upward, out ward
be noted, as well as the extent of damage that is visible from flo w can usually be recognized , even when all o f the
the exterio r. The investigator should look fo r any openings build ing's cont ents were invo lved in th e fire. Often th e
th at mig ht h ave created d rafts th at in flu enced th e fire point of o rigin is found d irect ly belo w the most damaged
spread and shou ld examine the cond it ion o f outside ut ili- area on the ceiling, where the heat of the fire was most
ties, such as the elect rical po wer connection and gas meter. concentrated.
The search for indications to the point of orig in contin ues A charred V-pattern on a wall ind icates that fire spread
inside the building, beginn ing with the area of lightest up and out fro m so meth ing at the base o f the V The b est
damage to the area of heaviest damage. Th is is probably the place to start looking for a specific fire cause in a room with a
area that was burning for the longest time; areas with less V-pattern on the wall, a p ile of charred debris at the base of
damage were p robably not as involved in the fire, or were the y and minimal damage to the other contents is in the p ile
involved for shorter periods. of debris ( Figure 26-2).
Where process or manufacturing equip ment is involved, An experienced fire investigator kno ws that many fac -
the investigation may focus on process control systems. A tors can influence burn patterns, includ ing vent ilation , fire
failure in level control alarms, bypass piping, relief valves, suppression efforts , and the burn ing materials themselves.
and other control devices may be either a contributing cause A V-patt ern on a wall co u ld ind icate that th ere was an
or a d irect cause of a fire or exp losion. easily ign ited and intensely burning fuel source at that loca-
The depth of char can be used to help determine how tion. It might also indicate that something fell fro m a higher
long a fire burned in a particular location (A Figure 26-1). The level and burned on the floor.
depth of char is related to how long the surface of a material An inverted V-pattern on a wall cou ld ind icate that a
was exposed to the fire, fro m the time of ignition to the time of flammab le liqu id was used along the base of the wall to set
extinguishment. An area that burned for only a few minutes the fire intentionally. A fire burning across a wide area at the
would have mostly surface damage and a shallo w depth o f floor level can funnel into a thermal colu mn as it rises, cre-
char. Materials that burned for longer periods will show evi- ating the inverted V-pattern.
dence of charring deeper into their cores. Charring is usually Once the investigator identifies the exact or appro ximate
deepest at the point of origin; however, flammable liquids and locat ion of the po int of orig in, the search fo r indications of a
combustible materials in other locations can also leave heavy specific cause can begin. The investigator must determine
charring. The area with the deepest char is not necessarily the wh at h appened at that locat ion to cause th e fire. Th is
point of origin. invo lv es ident ify ing both th e sou rce o f ign it ion and the
Burn patterns and smoke residue can be help ful in iden - fuels that were involved. The investigator must u ltimately
tifying the area of origin, but again are not conclusive. Burn d et ermin e ho w th e sou rce o f ign it ion and fuel came
patterns and d amag e will o ften sp read out ward fro m th e together, either accidentally or intentionally.
Fire Ca use D eter mi nati on 759

structures, and associated control systems to determine the


cause or point of origin.
When you find possible ev idence, stop so the investigator
can examine it in place. It is the investigator's job to doc-
u ment, photograph, and remove any potential ev id ence,
whether o r not it supports the suspected cause.
To determine the cause and origin of a fire, the investigator
must evaluate all potential causes for the fire. The process of
eliminating possible alternative causes and documenting the
reasons for rejecting them is as impo rtant as properly
document ing the ult imate cause of the fire.
For examp le, if the fire started in a cafeteria, potential
causes could include:
• The stove
(Figure 26-3) F ire inv estigators systematically dig through the debris of a fire • All of the electrical appliances
to search for evidence. • Light fixtures
• Smoking materials
• Cleaning supplies
Digging Out
After the investigator identifies the area of origin, brigade
Evidence
memb ers cou ld b e as ked to assist in d igg ing out the fire Ev idence refers to all of the in formation gathered and used
scene. "Digging out" is a term used to describe the process of by an in vest igato r in d etermin ing the cause o f a fire.
carefully looking for evidence within the debris. So metimes Ev idence can be used in a legal process to establish a fact or
the entire fire scene must be closely examined to determine prove a point. To be ad missible in court, ev idence must be
the cause of the fire and gather ev idence. gathered and p rocessed under strict procedu res.
The fire investigator will take extensive photographs of Physi cal evi dence cons is ts o f it ems th at can b e
the fire scene as it first appears. Then, he or she will begin to observed, photographed , measured , collected , examined in
remove and inspect the debris, layer by layer, from the top of a laboratory, and presented in court to prove or demonstrate a
the pile down to the bottom. The type of evidence uncovered point (Figure 26-4 ). Fire investigators can gather physical
and its location in the layers of debris can provide important evi dence, such as a burn pattern on a wall o r an empty
indicat ions of how the fire orig inated and progressed. gasoline can, at the fire scene to exp lain how the fire started
Remov ing and inspecting the layers of debris enables the or to docu ment ho w it bu rn ed.
inv estig ato r to determine th e sequence in wh ich items Trace or transfer evi dence is a minute quantity of phys-
burned, whether an item burned fro m the top down or fro m ical evidence that is conveyed from one place to another. For
the botto m up , and ho w long it bu rned . Did the fire start at a example, a suspect's clothing may contain the residue of the
lo w po int and bu rn up o r d id bu rn ing items fall do wn fro m same flammab le liquid found at the scene of a fire.
above and ignite combustible materials below? Did the fire
spread along the ceiling or along the floor? Is there a residue
of rags containing a flammable liquid under the fur niture?
Why are papers that should have been in a metal filing
cabinet stacked on the floor and partially burned?
Systemat ically digg ing th rough the d ebris oft en can
uncover the exact point of origin and cause of both accidental
and deliberate fires ( Figure 26-3 ). If circumstances or eye-
witness accounts indicate a deliberate fire, the investigator
may request that brigade members help examine the entire
area. Co mmon search methods include the "grid" search (also
known as the "double strip" search ) and the "strip" search .
The investigator will exp lain generally what to look fo r, how
to search, and what to do with any potential ev idence.
Where process equipment is involved, "digging out" may
invo lve the systemat ic removal o f p ip ing, valves , suppo rt

( Figure 26-4 ) Physic al evidence at a fire scene.


7G0 I N D U S T R I A L F I R E B R I G A D E : P R I N C I P L E S A N D P R A C T I C E

Demonstrati ve evi dence is anything that can be used to


validate a theory or to show how someth ing could have Brigade Member Tips
occurred. To demonstrate how a fire could spread, for exam- To avoid cont aminating evidence, fire investigat ors alw ays wash their
ple, an investigator may use a computer model of the burned tools between taking samples. This ensures that material from one piece
build ing. of evidence will not be unint ent ionally transferred to another piece.
Ev idence used in court can be considered either direct or Investigators also change their gloves eac h time the> take a sample of
circu mstantial. Direct evi dence includes facts that can be evidence and place evidence only in abs olut ely clean containers.
observed or reported first hand. Testimony fro m an eyewit - Before entering the fire scene, investigators often was h their boots to
ness who saw a person actually ignite a fire or a videotape keep from transporting any contamination into the fire scene.
fro m a security camera showing the person starting the fire
are examples of d irect ev idence. Direct evidence is rare in
arson cases, but eyewitnesses often can describe the circu m-
stances of an accidental fire.
Circumstantial evi dence is information that can be used
to prove a theory , based on facts that were observed first court and therefore worthy of preservation; that is the fire
hand. Fo r example, an investigation might show that gaso line investigator's decision. Your responsibility is to make sure
fro m a container found at the scene was used to start a fire. that potential ev idence is not destroyed or lost. Too much
Two d ifferent witnesses testify that the suspect purchased a evidence is better than too little, so no piece of potential evi-
container o f gasoline before the fire and walked away fro m dence should be considered insign ificant.
the fire scene without the container a few minutes before the If evidence could be damaged or destroyed during fire sup-
fire brigade arrived. Such circu mstantial ev idence clearly pression activities, cover it with a salvage cover or some other
places the suspect at the fire s ite with an ignit ion source at type of protection, such as a garbage can. Use barrier tapeto
the time the fire started . Fire investigato rs must often work keep others fro m accidentally walking through evidence
with circu mstantial ev idence to connect an arson suspect to a Before moving an object to protect it from damage, be sure that
fire. witnesses are present, that a location sketch is drawn, and that a
photograph is taken.
Preservation of Evidence Ev idence should not be contami nated, or altered from
Brigade members have a responsibility to preserve evidence its original state, in any way. Fire investigators use special
that could indicate the cause o r po int o f orig in o f a fire. containers to sto re ev id ence and p revent contamin at ion
Brigade members who discover something that could be evi- fro m any other products.
dence while digg ing out a fire scene or performing other
activit ies should leave it in p lace, make sure that no one Chain of Custody
int erferes with it o r t he su rrou nd ing area, and no t ify a To be ad missib le in a court o f law, physical ev idence must
brigade leader or fire investigator immediately. be hand led acco rd in g to cert ain p rescribed stan dards
Evidence is most often found during the salvage and over- Because the cause of the fire may not be known when evi-
haul phases of a fire. Salvage and overhaul should always be dence is first collected, all evidence should be handled
performed carefu lly and can often be delayed until an inves - according to the same p rocedure. In an incend iary o r arson
tigator has examined the scene. Do not move debris any more fire, evidence relating to the cause of the fire will probabl y
than is absolutely necessary and never discard debris until the have to be presented in court. The same is true fo r accidental
investigator gives approval. The fire investigator must decide fires, because lawsuits might be filed to claim or recover
whether th e ev idence is relevant , not the brigad e member. damages.
Brigade members at the scene are not in the position to Chain of custody (also known as chain of ev idence or
decide whether the evidence they find will be ad missible in chain of possession) is a legal term that describes the process
of maintain ing continuous possession and control of the

Brigade Member Tips evidence fro m the t ime it is discovered until it is presented in
court. Every step in the capture, movement, storage, and
examinat ion of the evidence must be properly docu mented.
Gas oline-pow ered tools and equipment, including saws and gener -
ators, are often used during firefighting operations. Gasoline from the For example, if a gasoline can is found in the debris of a sus -
equipment could contaminate the area and lead to an erroneous pected arson fire, docu mentat ion must record the person
assum ption that accelerants (m aterials us ed to initiat e or increas e the who found it, where and when it was found and under what
spread of fire) were us ed in the fire. Refuel such equipment outside the circu mstances. Photographs should be taken to show where it
investigation area to prev ent spilled fuel contamination. was found and what condit ion it was in . In cou rt, the
investigator must be ab le to show that the gas can presented is
the specific can that was found.
Fi r e Cause Deter mi nation 761

• Place evidence in appropriate containers to ensure


safety and prevent contamination. Unused paint cans
with lids that automatically seal when closed are the
best containers for transporting evidence. Glass mason
jars sealed with a sturdy sealing tape are appropriate
for transporting smaller quantities of materials. Plastic
containers and plastic bags should not be used for
evidence containing petroleu m products since it may
deteriorate the p lastic. Paper bags can be used for dry
clothing or metal articles, matches, or papers. Soak up
small quantities of liquids with either a cellulose
sponge or cotton batting. Protect part ially burned
paper and ash by placing them between layers of g lass
(assuming that small sheets or panes of glass are avail
(Figure 26-5) Evidence should rem ain where you find it until you can turn it able at the scene).
over to your brigade leader or the fire investigator. • Tag all ev idence at the fire scene. Evidence being
transported to the laborato ry should include a label
with the date, time, location, discoverer's name, and
The person who takes initial possession of the evidence witnesses' names.
must keep it under his or her personal control until it is turned • Record the t ime the evidence was found, where it was
over to another official. Each successive transfer of possession found, and the name of the person who found it. Keep
must be recorded. If evidence is stored, documentation must a reco rd of each person who handled the evidence.
indicate where and when it was placed in storage, whether the • Keep a constant watch on the ev idence until it can be
storage location was secure, and when it was removed. Often, stored in a secure locat ion. Ev idence that must be
evidence is maintained in a secured evidence locker to ensure moved tempo rarily should be put in a secure place
that only authorized personnel have access to it. accessible only to authorized personnel.
Everyone who had possession of the evidence must be • Preserve the chain o f custody in handling all the evi
able to attest that it has not been contaminated, damaged, or dence. A bro ken chain of custody may result in a
changed. If evidence is examined in a laboratory, the labora- court ru ling that the ev idence is inad missible.
tory t ests must be do cu mented . The d ocu ment at ion fo r On ly on e person shou ld b e responsib le for co llect ing
chain of custody must establish that the evidence was never and taking custody of all ev idence at a fire scene, no matter
out of the control of the responsible agency and that no one who d iscovers it. If so meone other than the assigned ev i-
could have tampered with it . dence collector must seize the ev idence, that person must
Brigade members are frequently the first lin k in the chain photograph, mark, and contain the ev idence properly and
of custody. The b rigade members responsibility in protect ing turn it over to the ev idence collector as soon as possible.
the integrity of the chain is relatively simp le: report The ev idence co llecto r must also do cu ment all ev id ence
everything to a fire brigade leader and disturb nothing need - that is co llected, including the date, time, and locat ion of
lessly. The indiv idual who finds the evidence should remain discov ery , the n ame o f th e finder, kno wn or suspected
with it until it is turned over to a brigade leader or to the fire nature o f the ev idence, and the ev idence nu mber fro m the
investigator (Figure 26-5). Remember that you could be evidence tag or label. A log of all photographs taken should
called as a witness to state that you are the brigade member also be reco rded at the scene.
who discovered this particular piece of evidence at the specific
location pictured .
Witnes ses
The fire investigator's standard operating procedures for Although brigade members do not interview witnesses, you
collecting and processing evidence generally include the fol- can identify potential witnesses to the investigator. People
lowing steps: who were on the scene when brigade members arrived could
• Take photographs of each piece of ev idence as it is have invaluable information about the fire. If a brigade mem-
found and collected. If possible, photograph the item ber learns something that might be related to the cause of the
as it was found, befo re it is moved o r d isturbed. fire, this informat ion should be passed on to a brigade leader
• On the fire scene, sketch, mark, and label the location or to the fire investigator.
of the ev idence. Sketch the scene as near to scale as Interviews with witnesses should be conducted by the
possible. fire investigator or by a police officer. If the fire investigator is
not on the scene or does not have the opportunity to inter view
the witness , obtain the person 's name, ad dress, and
VOICES OF EXPERIENCE
"The workplace fire may cause the company to
lose several hours or days of money-making
work, but the cause needs to be found to make
the wor kplace safe and deter a possible
arsonist."

I
t was night shift at a manufacturing plant when the announcer.:-, was made over the
PA for the fire brigade members to respond : fire in Area B. It was strange because
over the last four shifts the had been small fires or evidence of fires around the plant
that no one could figure : This was the first one this week and it was in an area that had
lots of fuel.
The week before there had been a small fire in the dumpster where the plants trash
normally dumped. The brigade leader thought it was just an accident, maybe
some:::—-hot placed in the trash before it had time to cool. According to a fire brigade
member. this didn't make sense because the trash was from an area where nothing was
hot.
The fire brigade members advised that when they made their way through the plant tc
Area B they saw workers leaving that area, and a haze was starting to filter into Area A At
the doorway they saw that there was active fire in the area of the boxing machin e and
some of the workers in Area B were starting to fight the fire. The fire brigade merr.-bers
took a handline toward the area on fire and started to attack the fire. A member observed
an area that was burning to the left that was not part of the larger fire. The member did
not think it was connected and was out of the way. This stuck in his mind, and it was
reported to the brigade leader when everything was under control.
With several members of the brigade on hand, the fire was brought under control. Th e
local fire department arrived and worked with the brigade to overhaul the scene. A
merr.-ber of the fire brigade advised the leader of the separate fire and stated that it
seemed strange, considering all of the fires that had taken place lately at the plant. The
leader requested that the members make a list of fires they knew had taken place in the
past few months.
The plant safety/risk manager arrived at the plant and started an investigation. The
brigade leader relayed the information about the other fires. A team member said that he
knew of at least three other fires in the plant over the last few months. Each one seemed
to have happened in an area where there was no real reason for it to have started.
The safety/risk manager and the FD investigator asked what had been seen. A member
told them about what they had seen as they approached that evening's fire. They said they
had seen a fire in the area of the doorway to the outside. It was small, but it was strange
because the mam fire was not spreading toward that area. The investigator asked the fire
brigade member to show him this fire area. Viewing the area made it clear to the
investigator that the fire had been started separately because it was well protected from
anything else starting the fire. This proved to be a critical piece of evidence in the inves -
tigation, showing that a person was setting several fires at the same time to confuse the
investigators and the fire brigade members.
During the overhaul of the main fire in Area B, inves tigation of the scene found that there was
a lot of what appeared to be trash stuffed into the pallets on the floor. This trash should not
have been there. The supervisor who worked the area was questioned about anyone who
would have been upset enough to stuff papers into that area.
The supervisor stated that he had problems with an employee who had been transferred to his
area the week before. This person did not produce like the other employees did and was always
having to be checked to make sure he was working. When he was confronted about his work,
he would say the supervisor was picking on him. When the fire was reported, one of the
brigade members who responded from outside said they saw this employee on the loading
dock, sitting there uninterested in what was going on.
A check of the other fires that had happened over the past few weeks showed they were all in
areas where this same person had worked, and from wh ich he had been moved or repri-
manded for poor work production. Each fire had been set using just the ordinary
combustibles that could have been found in the area or plant and an open flame. Every area
had nothing wrong with any of the equipment or other accidental sources of heat.
When confronted, he admitted that he had started the fires because he thought if the fire did
enough damage he would be able to leave. He also confessed to several fires away from the
plant.
The observations made during the response, attack, and overhaul are always important to the
investigation. The separate fire was critical because there was no reason for it. The papers
stuffed into the pallets were another suspicious clue. The fire a week before was just as out of
place because there was nothing from the area that could have started it. Protecting the scene
and providing the investigators with accurate observations are valuable to a thorough and
complete investigation. The fire brigade members are a valuable asset to the investigators
because brigade members are the eyes of the investigators until they are on the scene working
to find the cause of the fire. Without their observations, the fires would have continued and
could have eventually caused the loss of the plant and jobs.

Mike Dalton
Knox County Fire Investigation Unit
Knoxville, Tennessee
764 I N D U S T R I A L F I R E B R I G A D E : P R I N C I P L E S A N D P R A C T I C E

Brigade Member Tips Brigade Member Tips


Do not speculate on the caus e of the fire with or in front of bystanders. Jesting rem arks and jokes should never be made at the scene,
Spec ulation that is reported or printed tends to be treated as fact. because your comments could be overheard by the m edia.
----------------
„__.-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

telephone number and g ive it to the investigator. A witness cond it ions , an d rout e obst ruct ions . As t he incidentp ro -'
who leaves the scene without prov id ing this in fo rmat ion g ress es , p ay at tent ion to th ings th at do n ot mat ch yo u r
could be difficult o r impossible to locate later. expectations because they could help fire investigators deter-
Brigade members have a primary responsibility to save mine the orig in and cause of the fire.
lives and property. Until the fire is under contro l, b rigade
members must concentrate on fighting the fire, not investi- Time of Day
gating the cause. However, b rigade members should pay Time of day and type of occupancy can indicate the number
attention to the situat ion and make mental notes about any and type of people at an incident. Offices, warehouses, and
observations. Brigade members must tell the investigator maintenance shops are filled with people during the day and
about any odd o r unusual happenings. Info rmat ion, suspi- mostly empty at night. These same areas will most likely be
cions, or theories about the fire should be shared only with empty or have a s maller nu mber o f emp loyees during night
the fire investigator and only in private. shifts.
Do not make statements of accusation, personal opinion, As victims evacuate the area, b rigade members may be
or probab le cause to anyone other than the investigato r. able to note any that stand out, because their behavior and
Co mments that are overh eard by a bystander, a news demeano r are qu ite d ifferent.
reporter, o r others can impede the efforts of the fire investi-
gator to obtain co mplete and accurate info rmat ion. A wit- Weather Conditions
n ess t ry ing to be help fu l mig h t rep o rt an overheard No te whether the day is hot , co ld, clo udy , o r clear, and
comment as a personal observation . In th is way , inaccurate wh et her con d it ions in t he bu rn ing st ru ct u re mat ch th e
in fo rmat ion can gen erate a ru mo r that b eco mes a theo ry weath er. On a co ld day, windo ws sho u ld be closed; on a
and turns into a reported "fact" as it passes fro m person to hot day, the fu rnace should be o ff.
person. Lightning, heavy snow, ice, flooding, fog, or other haz-
Never make jesting remarks or jokes at the scene. Careless, ardous condit ions can help cover an arsonist's act iv it ies
unauthorized, or premature remarks could embarrass the com- because they delay the fire brigade's arrival and make a
pany or the fire brigade. Statements to news reporters about brigade members job mo re difficult. Because wind direction
the fire's cause should be made only by an official spokesperson and velocity help determine the natural path of fire spread,
after the fire investigator and ranking brigade leader have being aware o f these cond it ions will h elp you recognize
agreed to their accuracy and validity. Until then, "The fire is when a fire behaves in an unnatural way.
under investigation" is a sufficient reply to any questions con-
cerning the cause of the fire. Route Obstructions
Unusual traffic patterns or barriers blocking the route to the
Observations During scene may be early indications of a suspicious fire. Be sure to
note these and any other obstructions, such as barricades.
Fireground Operations downed cables, o r t rash containers (du mpsters) that cause
Although a b rigad e member's p rimary concern is saving delays.
lives and property, you will make observations and gather
info rmat ion as you perform your duties. What you observe Arrival and Size-Up
could be significant in the subsequent investigation of the Size-up operations can provide valuable information for fire
incident. The fo llowing sections will help you identify spe- investigators. Pay attention to the fire conditions, building
cific signs, patterns, and evidence during various fireground characteristics, and vehicles and people at or leaving the scene.
operations, fro m d ispatch and response to fire attack and
overhaul. Description of the Fire
Co mpare the d ispatcher's descript ion with the actual fire
Dispatch and Response conditions. If the fire has intensified dramatically in a short
During dispatch and response, form a mental image of the time, an accelerant cou ld hav e been used. Note whether
scene you expect to encounter. Note the time of day, weather flames are v isible or on ly smo ke. Also observe the quantity,
Fi r e Cause De ter mina tion 765

Brigade Member Safety Tips Brigade Member Tips


Safety is always the first and most important priority on the fireground. Photographs —whether taken by film or digital cameras—c an document
conditions before the arrival of fire inv estigators. How ever, specific
proc edures m ust be follow ed for the photographs to be admissible in
court as evidenc e. Follow your brigade's standard operating procedure
regarding picture taking.
color, and source of the smoke. Does the fire appear to be
burning in one p lace, o r in mu lt ip le locat ions?

Vehicles and People on the Scene


The appearance and behavior of people and vehicles at the Arsonists commonly draw the shades or cover windows and
scene of a fire can provide valuable clues. Do you recognize doors to delay the discovery of a fire. Gasoline cans, forcible
any bystanders from other fire scenes? Note the attitude and entry tools, and a damaged hydrant or sprinkler connection
dress of personnel and/or occupants of the bu ilding, as well might all suggest an intentionally set fire.
as other ind ividuals at the scene of a fire.
Anyone who seems out of p lace at a fire or someone who Entry
has been observed at several fires in various locations should As you prepare to enter the fire area, look for evidence of any
be reported to the investigator. So me arsonists are emotion - prio r entry , such as shoeprints lead ing into or out o f the
ally disturbed indiv iduals who receive personal satisfact ion structure or tracks fro m vehicle tires. Note whether the win -
in watch ing a "working" fire. So met imes inves tigators will dows and doo rs are intact , whether they are locked or
photograph the crowd at a fire scene, particu larly if there is a unlocked, and whether there are any unusual barriers limit-
series of similar fires, and look for the same faces at differ ent ing access to the structu re. Also note any signs o f fo rced
incidents. entry by others. If you see evidence of forced entry, ask your-
Most people at a fire scene are serious and intent on self if the forced entry likely occurred before the fire, or if it
watching the drama unfold (Figure 26-6). Someone who is could have been caused by brigade members gaining access
talking loud ly, laughing , o r making light of the s ituation to the structure.
should be considered suspicious. Fire investigators may also Forced ent ry could leave imp ressions of tools on the
want to know about someone who eagerly volunteered mu l- windows and doo rs. Cut o r torn edges o f wood, metal, or
tip le theo ries or too much info rmat ion . glass also may indicate forced entry. Investigators might be
able to det ermine wheth er the g lass had been b ro ken by
Unusual Items or Conditions heat or by mechanical means. Look for signs of a burglary;
Always note any unusual items or conditions about the prop - the fire may have been set to destroy evidence of another
erty, such as whether windows and doors are open or closed. crime.

Search and Rescue


As you enter the building to perform search and rescue or
interior fire suppression activities, consider the location and
extent of the fire. Separate or seeming ly unconnected fires
may indicate multip le points of origin and are often found at
arson scenes. The location and condition o f the building's
contents may also provide clues. Unusual building contents
or cond it ions—such as barriers in doo rs and windows, the
absence of inventory fro m a warehouse.
The team responsible for shutting o ff elect ric po wer to
the build ing should note whether the circu it breakers were
on or o ff when th ey arrived. The locat ion o f any peop le
found in the bu ild ing shou ld also b e noted .

Ventilation
The ventilation crew should note whether the windows and
doors were open or closed, locked o r un locked. They should
(Figure 26-6) M ost persons at a fire scene are intent on watching brigade also note the color and quantity of the smoke, as well as the
members at work. presence of any unusual odors.
766 I N D U S T R I A L F I R E B R I G A D E : P R I N C I P L E S A N D P R A C T I C E

Color of Smoke
Th e co lo r o f s mo ke o ft en in d icat es what is bu rn ing . Brigade Member Safety Tips
Unusual s mo ke migh t ind icate th at ad d it ional fu el was If you encount er an inc endiary device that has not ignited, notify your
added to the mi x. supervisor and others in the area immediately! Do not make any
attem pt to mov e it or dis able it.
Unus ual O dors
Self-contained breathing apparatus protects b rigade mem-
bers fro m hazardous fu mes and to xic odo rs. Ho wever,
somet imes an odo r is so strong that it can be detected en
route or linger after the fire has been extinguished. Fires
involv ing rubber drive belt and overheated light ballasts
Brigade Member Safety Tips
produce distinct ive, identifiab le odors familiar to exp eri - Sometimes, incendiary fires contain traps for fire fighter or brigade
enced b rigade members. Oth er co mmon odors familiar to members, such as steps that have been removed or holes in the floor,
deliberately covered. Be alert for this potential hazard.
brigade members includ e liqu id hyd rocarbons, solven ts,
and natural gas.
Odors often linger in the soil under a build ing without a
basement, particu larly if an accelerant has been used and if
the ground is wet. Concrete, brick, and plaster will all retain
vapors after a fire has been ext inguished. Incendiary devices can include unusual items in unlikely
places, such as a packet of matches tied to a bundle of com-
Effects of Ventil ati on on B urn Patterns
bustible fibers or attached to a mechanical device. Often,
Fire brigade ventilat ion operat ions can d ramat ically influ - incendiary devices fail to ignite or burn out without igniting
ence the behavior of a fire and alter burn patterns. For exam- other materials. Try to extinguish the fire without unduly
ple, if the ventilat ion crew opens a window or makes an disturbing any suspicious contents.
opening in the roof, the heat, s mo ke, and fire are likely to
move to ward th is open ing, creat ing new burn patt erns on Con di ti on of Fi re Al arm or S uppres s i on S ys tems
the walls, floors, and ceilings. Relay such information to the If the building is equipped with a fire alarm or fire suppression
fire invest igato r so that he o r she can co rrect ly int erp ret system, brigade members should examine it to see whether the
these patterns. system operated properly or was disabled. If the fire suppres -
sion system failed to work, the problem could be poor mainte-
Suppression nance or deliberate tampering. Notify the fire inspector of any
Fire behavio r, the presence o f incend iary dev ices (materials findings.
used to start a fire or cause an exp losion), obstacles encoun -
tered during fire suppression operations, and charring and Obs tacl es
burn patterns are among the factors that might help to deter - An arsonist may p lace obstacles to h inder the effo rts o f
mine the o rig in and cause of the b laze. brigade members. Note whether fu rniture or equ ip ment was
moved to b lock entry . A rsonists also may p rop open fire
B ehavi or of Fi re
doors, pull do wn p laster to expose the wood structure, o r
During the fire attack, observe the behavio r of the fire and punch holes in walls and ceilings to increase the rate of fire
how it reacts when an ext ingu ishing agent is applied. Look spread.
for unusual flame colors, sounds, or reactions. For examp le,
most flammab le liqu ids will float , cont inue to burn , and Contents
spread the fire when water is applied. Rekind les in the same Brigade memb ers invo lv ed in int erio r fire supp ress ion ,
area o r a flare -up when water is applied could indicate the like the memb ers of the search and rescue team, shou ld
presence of an accelerant. make not e of anyth ing unusual about th e contents o f the
building . The absence of personal items in an office may
Incendi ary De vi ces , Trai lers , and Accelerants
ind icate that th ey were removed and the fire was inten -
While fighting the fire, be aware of streamers or trailers t ionally set. Emp t y bo xes in a wareho use may belong
(combustible materials placed to spread the fire). Look for there, or they may ind icate that the valuable contents were
combustib le materials like wood, paper, or rags in unusual removed. If on ly one item or a part icu lar stock o f products
locations. Note containers of flammab le or co mbustible liq- burns, and there is no reasonable exp lanat ion for the fire,
uids no rmally not found in the type o f occupancy . Very arson cou ld be suspected. The fire investigato r will con sider
intense heat or rapid fire spread might indicate the use of an these factors with other ev idence before reach ing any
accelerant to increase the fire spread. conclusion.
Fi r e Caus e Deter mi nati on 767

Charring and Burn Patterns scattering debris need lessly. Thermal imag ing dev ices can
Charring in unusual p laces —like op en floo r space away be used to find hot spots without tearing apart the interior
fro m any likely accidental ignit ion source—could ind icate structure.
that the fire was deliberately set. Char on the underside of Watch for evidence that was shielded fro m the fire and is
doors or on the unders ide of a lo w horizontal surface, such lying beneath burned debris. For examp le, a wall clock may
as a tabletop, could indicate that there was a pool of flam- have fallen du ring the fire and been covered with debris. If
mab le liquid. the clock stopped approximately when the fire bro ke out, it
could be an important p iece o f ev idence.
Overhaul A fire investigator will always try to determine whether
During overhau l, the s mo ke and steam should begin to dis - the build ing contents were changed o r removed prio r to a
sipate, enabling both brigade members and fire investigators fire. If all of a business' computers are missing, the fire might
to get a better loo k at the surroundings. Brigade members have been set to conceal a theft.
should continu e to loo k for indicat ions of the signs, pat - A vehicle fire can start from an accidental electrical short
terns, and evidence previously discussed while conducting or fro m a co mbination of gasoline and matches placed in the
overhaul in a way that allo ws evidence to be identified and passenger compart ment. Signs of spilled fuel on the ground
preserved. The overhaul process, if not done carefully, can around a vehicle may be evidence of an intentional fire. Do
quickly destroy valuable ev idence. not move the vehicle without documenting this spilled fuel;
If possible, the investigator should take a good look at an the evidence will be lost.
area before overhau l b egins. Th e invest igator can often
quickly ident ify potential ev idence and can help d irect or Injuries and Fat alit ies
guide the overhaul operation so that it is properly preserved. Any fire that results in an in jury or fatality must be thor-
Ev idence located during overhaul should be left where it is oughly investigated and the fire scene documented. A search
found, untouched and undisturbed , unt il the investigator and rescue operation should never be compro mised, but it is
examines it. Ev idence that must be removed fro m the scene impo rtant to docu ment the location and posit ion o f any v ic-
should be properly ident ified, docu mented, photographed, tims, especially in relat ion to the fire and the exits.
packaged, and p laced in a secure locat ion. Cloth ing removed fro m any v ict im should be preserved
Fire suppression personnel and investigato rs must work as evidence. It may contain traces of flammable liquids, and
as a team to ensure that the fire is co mp letely extingu ished burn patterns can ind icate the fire flo w. If the clothing is
and properly overhau led , wh ile cont inually search ing fo r removed in the ambu lance or at the hospital, these person nel
and preserv ing signs, patterns, and ev idence. Taking pho - should be instructed to collect it and keep it as intact as
tographs du ring th is ph ase o f the fire operat ion is a good possible.
idea. Docu ment what may be ly ing under the v ict im's body
Be carefu l no t t o des t roy ev id en ce d u ring o verhau l (r after it is removed. Th is often is a protected area and may
Figure 26 -7). Avoid throwing materials into a p ile. Use reveal impo rtant evidence.
lo w-v e lo cit y h o s e st reams t o av o id b reak in g u p an d
Securing and Transferring the Property
A fire brigade member doesn't need to collect or move any
item that might be evidence. They might control the scene
but do not need to go beyond that point. Maintain ing site
integrity is crit ical to the fire investigation. The building and
premis es must be p roperly secu red and gu ard ed unt il the
fire investigator has finished gathering evidence and docu -
menting the fire scene. Otherwise, any effo rts to determine
the cause of a malicious or incendiary fire, no matter how
efficient or co mp lete, will be wasted.
If a fire investigator is not immediately availab le, the
premises should be guarded and maintained under the con -
tro l o f the fire b rigade o r secu rity unt il the investigat ion
takes place and all evidence is collected. In the interim, take
the following steps:
• Suspend salvage and overhaul, and secure the scene.
Keep nonessential personnel out of the area. Deny entry
(Figure 26-7) Be aware of the need to preserve evidence during ov erhaul. to all unauthorized and unnecessary persons.
768

Arsonists fall into several categories, with various explana- Preadolescent fire-starters do not venture far from
tions for their behavior. The fire service has identified two home, but this group does set most of the fires that involve
groups who are responsible for a large nu mber of fires: schools and churches. Preadolescents have motivat ions
pyromaniacs and juvenile fire -setters. Many other arsonists other than idle curiosity. The motivat ions of boys range
start fires for a wide range of mot ives. fro m spite to revenge and disruptive behavior. Girls usually
set less aggressive fires and are motivated by a need for
Pyromaniacs attention or in response to a particular stress, such as a test
A pyromaniac is a pathological fire-setter. Most are adult they don't want to take.
males, often loners. They are usually int roverted , polite The preadolescent usually does not use elaborate trailers
but timid, and have difficulty relat ing to other people. The or incendiary devices. They will use common, available
fires set by pyromaniacs have the following characteristics: accelerants such as gasoline, kerosene, or lighter flu id. The
• Fires are set in easily accessible locat ions, such as preadolescent often uses whatever materials are at hand
immed iately inside entrances, on basement stairs, in and on sit e, includ ing t rash container contents, l oose
trash bins, or on porches. papers, and rags. The fire will show a lack of p lanning,
• Fires are set in structures such as occupied resi preparat ion, and sophist icat ion, part icu larly if it was a
dences of all types, barns, and vacant bu ild ings. group effort.
• Accelerants are rarely used. The pyro maniac is The fires set by adolescents are similar to those set by
impulsive, so materials readily at hand are used. adults. Ado lescents have b etter access to t ransportat ion
• Each pyro man iac usually has a pattern, setting fires and can travel farther, so they have access to a wider variety
at the same t ime of day o r n ight, using the same of buildings. They also have many of the same motivations
method, and m similar locat ions. of adult fire -setters, such as revenge or attempts to hide
larceny, and they often use accelerants. Two-thirds of fires
Juvenile Fire-Setters set in vacant build ings are set by adolescents, but no class
Juvenile fire setters usually set fires in residential or co m- of prop erty is exempt fro m harm. Often a g reat amount o f
mercial structures, but they need to be considered in the vandalis m at the scene will be a clue that the fire was set
industrial setting as well. They may set fires along fences or by an adolescent.
the rear of buildings in remote areas. They may set them
simp ly fro m curiosity , but the culp rits may be juven iles Arsonist Motives
who have a grudge against a security guard and set the fire An arsonist is someone who deliberately sets a fire with
out of revenge. Listed below are the indicators that the fire criminal intent. Arsonists set all types of fires and have a
brigade member or leader should be aware of if they suspect range of motives. Male arsonists are usually motivated by
a juven ile has started a fire in an area o f a p lant. Juvenile profit, revenge, or vanity, and often use accelerants. In the
fire-setters are usually div ided into three groups according past, female fire-setters were seldom motivated by profit and
to age: 8 years old and under, 9 to 12 years old seldom used accelerants, but this seems to be changing
(preadolescent), and 13 to 17 years old (adolescent). There are six co mmon mot ives listed in NFPA 921. Guide
Pre-ado lescent and ado les cent fire -setters o ften exh ib it to Fire and Explosion Investigations. Each of the motives
the same personality traits as adult pyro maniacs: listed applies to an industrial setting and should be
introverted, d ifficu lty with interpersonal relat ionships, and considered if the fire appears to be incendiary. Even though
extreme po liteness when questioned. the listed items may apply to a residence, indiv iduals set
Children under 8 years o ld are seldo m criminally moti- fires fo r the same reasons in an industrial setting.
vated when they set fires; they usually are just curious and 1. Vandalis m
experimenting. Ch ildren o f this age do not really under- 2. Excitement
stand the danger of fire. They usually set fires in or near 3. Revenge
their ho mes or in nearby fields or vacant lots. They start 4. Crime concealment
fires with matches or by sticking co mbustible material into 5. Profit
equipment such as electric heaters that provide an ignition 6. Extremis m
source. The remains of matches, matchbo xes, or Arsonists who are motivated by excitement are rela -
match-books are often found at the po int o f o rigin . tively easy to apprehend because they usually have so me
Fire C ause D e t e r m i n a t i o n 769

ment fires includes fires started by a wou ld-be hero. The


Brigade Member Tips wou ld-b e hero can be either a d iscoverer or an assister.
The discoverer sets the fire, "discovers" it, and turns in the
Arson Facts alarm. The assister sets the fire, sometimes discovers it and
• Ars on is oft en called a "y oung m an' s crim e;" 54% of t hos e
arrested for arson are under the age of 18. reports it, and is always on hand to help or init iate fire
• Only about 2% of all incendiary or sus pected inc endiary fires lead extinguish ment.
to conviction. An unfortunate category of excitement arsonists is closely
• Arson is the leading caus e of property dam age in the U nited related to the would-be hero. These are fire fighters and
States, resulting in $1. 3 billion of property dam age annually. • One would-be fire fighters (persons who have tried to become fire
out of eight fire fat alities is due t o a fire start ed by ars on. fighters and failed) who intentionally start fires.
Revenge arsonists are often very careful, and make
detailed plans for setting the fire and escaping detection
afterwards. Arsonists motivated by revenge seldom consider
the extent of damage fire can inflict. Their intent is to harm a
particular person or group to get revenge for a perceived
injustice.
Arson for profit occurs because the arsonist will benefit
fro m the fire either d irect ly or ind irect ly. Fires that
Brigade Member Tips direct ly benefit the arsonist often involve businesses. The
business owner might set the fire or arrange to have it set, to
Serial A rson gain an insurance settlement that can be used to cover other
There are three types of serial (repetitiv e) ars on identified by financial needs. An increas ing prob lem connected with this
NFPA 921, Guide to Fire and Ex plosion Investigations: l. Serial
arson for pro fit is fraud. For examp le, a person may buy
arson inv olv es an off ender w ho sets t hree or m ore fires, wit h a
cooling-off period between fires. 2. Spree arson inv olves an and insure a property, only to burn it for the sole purpose of
ars onist who sets t hree or more fires at s eparate locations wit h defraud ing an insurance co mpany.
no emotional c ooling-off period between fires. 3. Mass arson The other type of profit arsonist sets a fire to benefit from
inv olv es an offender w ho sets three or more fires at t he sam e sit e another persons loss. Included in this mot ive category are:
or location during a limited period of time. • Insurance agents who want to sell more insurance to
the victi m's neighbors
• Contractors who want to secure a contract for
rebuild ing or wrecking or to get a salvage
• Co mpet itors who want to drive the v ict im out of
business
SOURCE: NFPA 921, Guide to Fire and Explosion Investigations, 2001
Edition, Section 19.4.8.2
• Owners of adjo in ing property who would like to
buy the property and expand their own hold ings
• Owners of nearby p roperty who want to prevent an
ident ifiab le connect ion with their t argets, such as a d is- occupancy change, such as the conversion of a
gruntled emp loyee to a co mpany. One category o f excite- building to a drug rehab ilitat ion center

• Photograph the fire scene extensively. Start fro m the possible. Protect t ire tracks or footprints by placing
area of least damage and work toward the area of possi bo xes over them to p revent dust accu mu lat ion. Use
ble origin . Take several pictures of the point of o rig in barricades to block off the area to further traffic. Rope
fro m various angles. Photograph any incendiary devices off areas surrounding plants, trailers, and devices, and
on the premises exactly where they were found. post a guard.
• If weather, traffic, or other factors could destroy the The p ropert y shou ld b e secu red by co rdo n ing o ff t he
evidence, take steps to preserve it in the best way area with fire - or police -line tape. A member of the brigade
770 I N D U S T R I A L F I R E B R I G A D E : P R I N C I P L E S AND P R A C T I C E

additional water damage. Board up and secure windows and


doors to prevent unauthorized ent ry.
Fire b rigades can secu re and prot ect the p remises in
several ways. Lock and guard gates if necessary, rope off
dangerous areas and mark them with signs. So me b rigades'
co mpan ies have cont racts with local co mpan ies that p ro vide
24-hou r board -up serv ices and so metimes h ire p rivate
security guards to secu re a p roperty after a fire (Figure 26-8
).
Eventually, when brigade operations are over, the prop -
erty will b e retu rned to operat ions as no rmal. Th is should
not be done, however, unt il the investig ation is co mplete
and all evidence is collected.

Incendiary Fires
( Figure 26-8) Some fire brigades have contracts with local companies that The term incendiary fires refers to all fires that were deliber-
provide 24-hour board-up service. ately started for malicious or criminal intent. In many juris-
dictions, arson has a narrower, specific legal defin ition. This
chapter uses arson to mean the malicious burn ing of p rop erty
security o r law enfo rcement agency should remain at the with criminal intent.
scene to ensure that no unauthorized persons cross the line. Brigade members must be aware of factors that could
Befo re leav ing the scene, make sure that the build ing is indicate an intent ionally set fire, to report any observations
properly secured, and no hazards to public safety exist. Shut to a brigade leader o r fire investigator, and to help protect
off all ut ilities and seal any open ings in the roof to p revent evidence.
Fi r e Cause Dete r mina tion 771

Indications of Arson flammable liquid spill. To prove arson, the fire investigator
must determine that a flammab le liquid was used and that
Arson fires have several d istinct, recognizab le patterns or
there is no explanation other than arson for the p resence of
indicat ions. Fo r examp le, a deliberate fire might have mu l- the flammab le liqu id.
tip le po ints of o rigin or mu lt iple simu ltaneous fires. An
Extensive burn damage on a floor's surface cou ld ind icate
arsonist will ign ite fires in different areas to create a large that a flammable liquid was poured and ign ited. Fo r examp le,
fire as qu ickly as possible and involve the ent ire bu ilding. a wood floor might have a pool-shaped burn pattern, or floor
Arsonists also use trailers made fro m co mbustible materials,
tiles could be d iscolored or blistered with an irregu lar burn
such as p aper, rags , cloth ing , cu rtains, kerosene -soaked pattern. On concrete and masonry floors, a flammab le liquid
rope or other fuels, to spread a fire. Trailers often leave dis - pattern is usually irregu lar with various shades of g ray to
tinctive char and/or burn patterns that investigators can use
black. Cracked and p itted concrete may also suggest
to trace the spread of a fire. flammab le liqu id use. Liquids flow to the low est level
An incendiary device is a device or mechanism, such as possible, so the evidence of pooled liquids could be visib le in
candles, timers, or electrical heaters that is used to start a fire or
corners and along the base of walls, where there might also
explosion. Many incendiary devices leave evidence, such as be lo w levels of charring.
metal parts, electrical co mponents, or mechanical devices, at So met imes the first indications o f a possib le arson fire
the point of origin. Often an arsonist will use more than one
are ent irely circu mstantial. A part icular fire could fit into a
incendiary device; sometimes, a failed incendiary device is pattern , such as a series o f fires in the same area, at about
found at the fire scene. If trailers were used, investigators may the same t ime on the same d ays of th e week. There might be
be able to trace the burn patterns back to an incendiary device.
a series of fires in the same location or on the same shift. A
Ev idence of a flammable liquid often indicates an incen- brigade member who notices a pattern o r a set of similar
diary fire but do es not necessarily establish arson as the circu mstances should immed iat ely repo rt the observ at ion
cause because there could be an accidental exp lanation fo r a
to a brigade leader o r a fire investigator.
Ars on T he m alic ious burning of one's ow n or anot her's property
wit h a c riminal int ent.
Ars onist A pers on w ho deliberat ely s ets a fire t o dest roy property
wit h c rim inal int ent.
Pres erv ing evidenc e as sists brigade m embers with t he prim ary
C hai n of c ust o dy A legal t erm us ed t o desc ribe t he paperw ork
goal of prev enting loss of liv es and property loss.
or doc um ent ation desc ribing the m ov em ent, storage, and c ust ody of
Fires are c aus ed by eit her inc endiary or acc ident al c aus es. evidenc e, such as t he rec ord of poss ess ion of a gas c an from a fire
Bas ic fire inv estigat ion includes loc at ing t he point of origin, scene.
determ ining t he fuel us ed, and identify ing t he ignition s ource. C ir c u msta nt ia l evi d e nce T h e m ea ns by w hic h alleged f ac t s
Fire investigation s hould be perf ormed by one of the f ollowing: are prov en by deduction or inferenc e from other f acts t hat w ere
trained fire brigade investigat ors, the f ire m ars hal's office, ins ur- obs erv ed first hand.
anc e com pany inv estigators, or a law enf orc em ent agency. C o mp e te nt i g n it i o n s o u rce A c om p et ent ignit ion s o urc e is
one t hat can ignit e a fuel under the existing c onditions at t he tim e of
Physical evidenc e must be pres erv ed by m aint aining an unbro -
the fire. It must have s ufficient heat and be in proxim ity to t he f uel
ken chain of c ust ody.
for s uffic ient tim e t o ignit e t he f uel.
The brigade m ember's role in fire inv estigation is t o identify and Co nta minate d A t erm us ed t o desc ribe ev idenc e t hat m ay hav e
pres erve poss ible ev idenc e unt il it c an be turned ov er t o a trained been alt ered from its original st ate.
fire inv est igat or. D e mo n str ati ve ev i de n ce T erm us e d t o des c ribe m at erials
The brigade m ember's role in identif ying and pres erving evidenc e us ed to dem onstrat e a t heory or ex plain an ev ent.
continues throughout t he fire suppression sequenc e, and De pth of c har T he t hic k ness of t he lay er of a m at erial t hat has
inc ludes the f ollowing f act ors: been c ons um ed by a fire. T he depth of char on wood c an be us ed to
o T im e of day, w eat her help det ermine the duration of a fire.
o People leaving t he sc ene D irect evi de nc e Ev idenc e t hat is report ed f irs t hand, s uc h as
o Ext ent of fire, num ber of loc ations of f ire stat em ents from an ey ewit ness who s aw or heard s om ething.
° Sec urit y of t he building Inc e nd iar y dev ice A dev ic e or m ec hanis m us ed t o st art a f ire
or ex plosion.
° Signs of propert y break -in
I nce n d i ar y f i res I nt ent io nally s et f ires .
o Vehicles or people in t he area
Mass arso n I nv olv es an off ender w ho s ets t hree or m ore f ires at the
o I ndic at ions of unus ual f ire sit uat ions
sam e s it e or loc ation during a lim it ed period of t im e. Phy sical
o U nus ual c olor of s m ok e evide nce I t em s t hat c an be obs erv ed, phot ographed, m eas ured,
o Position of window s and roof collected, ex amined in a laborat ory, and pres ented in c ourt to prove or
° T he react ion of t he fire during init ial att ack dem onst rat e a point.
o Abnorm al behavior of fire Poi nt of ori gin T he ex ac t loc ation w here a heat s ourc e and a fuel
o C ondition of t he building c ont ent s com e in c ont act w ith eac h ot her and a f ire begins.
° Need to coordinat e ov erhaul and evidence pres erv ation Pyr o ma nia c A pat hologic al fire -s ett er.
activ ities Serial ars o n A s eries of f ires s et by t he s am e off ender, wit h a
0
Need t o transf er res ponsibility of t he property from fire s up - cooling-off period bet w een fires.
pression pers onnel t o fire inv estigat ors Spre e ars on A s eries of fires st art ed by an ars onist w ho s ets three
o N eed t o s ec ure t he property or more fires at s eparate loc ations w ith no emot ional c ooling-off period
betw een fires.
Tr ace (tra n sfer) ev id e nce Ev idenc e of a m inut e qua nt it y t hat is
conv ey ed from one plac e t o anot her. Trailers C om bustible m at erial,
suc h as rolled rags, blank ets, and news papers or flamm able liquid,
us ed t o s pread fire f rom one point or area t o ot her point s or areas,
Acc eler ants M at erials, us ually f lam m able li quids, us ed t o initiate or oft en us ed in conjunction wit h an inc endiary devic e.
inc rease t he s pread of fire. Accide ntal fire s F ire c aus e c las sific at ion
U nd eter mi ne d C aus e c lass if ic ation t hat includes f ires f or w hic h
that inc ludes f ires with a proven c ause t hat does not inv olv e a
the caus e has not or c annot be prov en.
deliberat e hum an act.
On a third shift you hear the alert that a fire has been discovered in the fabrication
area of the plant. As you respond you notice smoke is spreading from that area and
you hear the water flow alarm for the sprinkler system. You go to the standpipe,
connect a hoseline, and advance it toward the equipment in the fire area.

You notice that the fire is still burning under the equipment. Flames are starting to melt
hydraulic lines on the machine and the fire is growing. As you advance your hose line and
extinguish the fire, you observe that the fire area was all underneath the equipment. You know from working
at the plant that this machine does not produce a lot of heat. You observe that there are tools and parts lying
nearby. You know from experience that a fire investigator will want to know what you have seen. You make
notes of your observations.

1. Based on your obs erv ations of t he fire area, w hat is t he 3. Onc e the fire sc ene is secured and t he area is s afe, the
m ost lik ely reason t he s prinkler s yst em didn't ext in guis h maintenanc e tec hnic ians as k if they can rem ov e their
the f ire? tools and parts. W hen c an t he t ools and parts be
A. The s prinkler s ystem malfunct ioned. rem oved?
B. The fire w as too hot f or the s prink ler syst em w at er A. Aft er y ou m ak e a list of t he t ools, parts, and their
flow t o extinguis h. loc ation.
C. The mac hinery acted as a shield and prev ent ed B. W hen t he f abric ation s hop foreman says it is ok ay
wat er f rom reac hing t he f ire. to do s o.
D. The fire involv ed a c ombust ible m et al. C. After you have t aken pict ures of the area.
D. After the fire inv estigat or releas es the sc ene.

2. W hy does the fire inv estigator remove and ins pect eac h 4. As y ou c ons ider t he c irc um st anc es of t his f ire, y ou
lay er of debris ? wonder if t he c ause w as intent ional. W ho s hould y ou
A. To determ ine how long it burned. share y our obs erv ations wit h?
B. To determ ine t he s equenc e in w hic h items burned. A. The f abric ation s hop supervis or.
C. To take fingerprints of t he m aterial that w as burned. B. Other brigade m em bers.
D. Bot h A and B. C. The fire inv estigat or.
D. The plant manager.

You might also like