2004 The Portuguese Museums Network 8

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 8

Nordisk Museologi 2004 • 1, s.

85–92

85
The Portuguese Museums
Network
Clara Camacho

In the last three decades there has been a very significant rise in the number of museums
in Portugal. This movement has followed international trends within the museum
sector, but it has also assumed specific characteristics that are very much its own in
relation to the profound political and institutional transformations which took place in
the country following the institution of democracy on 25 April, 1974. Echoes of this
major political event were felt throughout the whole of society and resulted in a greater
involvement of local communities in the protection of heritage, which in turn led to the
birth of a large number of museums.

The current Portuguese museum gal between 1978 and 79) and Hugues de Vari-
scene ne (Director of the Franco-Portugais Institute
in Lisbon between 1983 and 84, who also took
From the second half of the 1970s the regene- part in several local museum initiatives).
ration of Portuguese museums was clearly This new surge of ideas had begun back in
stimulated by, amongst other factors, greater 1976 when the Portuguese Government asked
contact with events taking place in museums Unesco for specialist advice to help them re-
abroad. It was also influenced by New Museo- solve the main problems facing national mu-
logy, particularly after the hosting of the Inter- seums. The Unesco mission consisted in visits
national New Museology Workshop in Lisbon to museums and workshops for their profes-
in 1985. Between the end of the 1970s and sional staff, at the end of which two final re-
the mid 80s the changes occurring within Port- ports were produced containing a series of re-
uguese museology drew the attention of seve- commendations to the Portuguese Govern-
ral internationally respected museologists, such ment. Although it was impossible to implement
as Per-Uno Agren (coordinator of the Unesco these recommendations at the time, their im-
Mission in Portugal 1976 – 1979), Georges- pact on the professional museum community
Henri Rivière (who worked with the Secretary was highly significant. Whilst this circulation
of State for the Environment in a project to of ideas had important repercussions for the
create ecomuseums in national parks in Portu- transformation of the Portuguese museum sec-
Clara Camacho

86 tor, it was the political front and the changes and jurisdictions between the different levels
stemming from the institution of democracy of administration to be clearly specified or that
that played a pivotal role. The growth in the would have originated in a definition of the
number of new museums intensified, driven requirements needed for the creation of mu-
mainly by local government investment, at- seums. The situation was characterised, there-
tributable to the new framework of cultural de- fore, by a great deal of initiative on the part of
mocracy and the establishment of local and the different governing bodies (with particular
regional identities. Some of these new local emphasis on local government, but also pri-
museums have played a renovational role in vate institutions), by the circulation of new
shaping the museum panorama of today. ideas about museology and other relevant so-
Alongside the rise in local museums, at the cial changes. On the other hand, for a long time
end of the 1970s and beginning of the 1980s, global intervention from the state was non-ex-
the central government created several natio- istent, in terms of action policies, or legisla-
nal museums specialising in specific areas, such tion and its application. This was in contrast
as the National Costume Museum, the Natio- to other countries that were developing systems
nal Theatre and the National Tile Museum. for organisation and coordination between
In recent years private initiative has also play- museums in which specific legislation for the
ed an important role in the creation of mu- museum sector or the accreditation of museums
seums, in terms both of small local associations emerged as important instruments for the up-
and large foundations. The latter have been grading of this cultural area. Yet, Portugal fail-
directly related to important art collections, ed to develop any national system of coordi-
such as the internationally prestigious Gulben- nation or certification for its museums, during
kian Museum and the Serralves Museum of a period when elsewhere a movement for
Contemporary Art. change was taking place which was unprece-
In this brief introduction to Portuguese dented in the history of museology.
museums, one must also mention the role of
universities. They have been educating muse-
Creation of the Portuguese
ologists since the beginning of the 1990s, after
Museums Network
an interruption of several years in the courses
for museum curators. Since then this new ge- It was in this context that in 1991, under the
neration of professionals has gradually been Ministry of Culture, the Portuguese Museums
taking up jobs in museums; not yet in sufficient Institute was created, on the presumption that
quantities to make up for all the existing de- the management of museums should be entrus-
ficiencies, but enough to represent a crucial fac- ted to an agency set up to deal with the specific
tor for change in our museums. problems in this sector. However, during the
For many years the situation we have just first years of this institute’s existence, its work
described failed to meet with a comprehensive was almost exclusively with the national mu-
response in terms of national museum policies. seums that came under its jurisdiction, whose
Nor were there any concerted national museum difficult situation demanded a series of struc-
plans integrating different approaches and tural measures for their upgrading. It was only
lines of action that would have allowed powers at the end of the 1990s, therefore, that the Por-
The Portuguese Museums Network

tuguese Museums Institute was able to turn its In 2000 having received the results of this 87
attention to the museum sector in its entirety. survey, the Institute took the first concrete step
Thus in 1997, the law governing the Portuguese towards setting up a Museums Network. It cre-
Museums Institute outlined the proposal to cre- ated a Project Structure, under its domain, with
ate a Portuguese Museums Network to take the principle aim of studying and drawing up
immediate effect. This objective was also in line a blueprint for such a network. In taking this
with the policy of the Ministry of Culture which measure, the Institute paved the way for a first
had previously created a network for public global policy for the country’s museums.
libraries and a network for archives.
With the aim of acquiring a deeper knowl-
Three structural areas:
edge of the situation in preparation for this new
to inform, train and upgrade
project, the Portuguese Museums Institute, in
conjunction with the Cultural Activities Ob- At the end of the year 2000, beginning its work,
servatory (another agency under the Ministry the Project Structure team began by carrying
of Culture), carried out a Survey of Portuguese out a programming study. This study was bas-
museums. The study included 530 museums ed on an examination of the historical process
and was meant to provide a reliable profile of and the reality of Portuguese museums at the
the country’s museological reality. Among time, based on the data provided by the pre-
other aspects, the study was to highlight: the viously mentioned survey, within the context
very recent establishment of most museums; the of international contemporary museology. This
uneven geographical distribution, with massive initial document was widely debated in meet-
concentration along the coast, particularly in ings around the country. It resulted in a paper
the metropolitan areas of Lisbon and Porto, and published in March 2001, Programming Lines
a very sparse distribution in the interior; the for the Portuguese Museums Network (RPM –
large number of governing bodies, whether pub- Rede Portuguesa de Museus), which to date has
lic or private; the heterogeneous nature of their served as the blueprint for our work.
collections. The survey also revealed the prin- Thus, the RPM is presented as a system of
ciple shortcomings and needs, identified by mediation and coordination for museums and
directors and those in charge of the museums kindred institutions, aimed at promoting com-
which, in descending order, are the following: munication and sharing between them, in order
financial resources, staffing, premises, conser- to bring about the upgrading of museums in Port-
vation, restoration, training, computer equip- ugal. The wording expresses a concept of net-
ment, building maintenance, security and pub- work with a broad spectrum of content, em-
licity. bracing two dimensions that complement one
The data from this survey are continually another: i.e. the dimension of “information
updated by way of an ongoing study carried network” and that of “physical network”.
out by the Cultural Activities Observatory. This Taking this definition of “network”, outlined
provides us at any one moment with a diagno- above, and the results of the Museums Survey
sis of the existing situation, such as the num- as the main points of reference, three main
ber of “self-designated museums” which at pre- structural areas were defined for the Network:
sent exceeds eight hundred. Information, Training and Upgrading. These
Clara Camacho

88 areas have served as the anchor for specific pro- successful. Staying within this area, a documen-
grammes which were first developed on a re- tation centre specialising in museology was re-
gular basis from 2001 onwards. cently opened to the public. It is designed to
The area of Information included two main provide support for museum professionals, stu-
channels of dissemination: the website dents and teachers.
(www.rpmuseus-pt.org) and the quarterly In the area of Upgrading and the funding
newsletter. There is no museology journal in needed for this, the Museum Upgrading Sup-
Portugal and the only newsletters that exist be- port Programme was set up. This represents the
long to the Portuguese Association of Museo- Ministry for Culture’s first funding program-
logy and the Portuguese National Commission me directed to museums that are not depen-
of ICOM, written for their respective mem- dent on the central administration. It is divid-
bers. The interest prompted by the publica- ed into four main areas: museum program-
tion of the Network’s website and newsletter, ming; research and the study of collections;
of which ten issues have already been publish- preventive conservation; and communications
ed, is therefore understandable. Subjects cover- initiatives. Within this programme, and since
ed have included the dissemination of the Pro- 2001, 64 museums have received funding for
ject Structure action programme, as well as ar- 235 projects, totalling more than a million and
ticles on museological issues and news related a half Euros. A Museum Specialist Services
to activities promoted by museums which are Programme was also set up to provide specia-
part of the network. Other publications are list consultation in some fields. Preventive con-
planned within this area. These include a man- servation and museum architecture have so far
ual on museum programming, now in the fi- proven to be the areas most sought after.
nal stages of completion, and the preparation Much of the Portuguese Museums Network’s
of a revised version of data on Portuguese mu- daily activity is also taken up with the apprai-
seums, as a continuation of the 1998 survey. sal of funding applications to the Operational
The area of Training was mapped out accord- Cultural Programme for new museums or the
ing to the needs outlined by museum professio- renovation of existing museums. This is a Eu-
nals and the gaps that existed in relation to ropean Community funding programme with
initiatives set up by other Portuguese entities. specific applications in the area of culture, run
In reality, there has been no provision for on- by the Ministry for Culture. It is the job of the
going training for museum professionals, the Project Structure to complete the technical re-
promotion of initiatives for training and skills port on the museological significance of these
development being extremely rare. In contrast applications, which also provides it with ex-
to this is the growing role of universities offer- tensive practical knowledge concerning the
ing academic training for postgraduate degrees development of the museum panorama.
in Museology. Given this scenario, the RPM
began promoting a regular training program-
me. Between 2001 and 2003 twenty-four train-
ing courses have been organised, attended by
around five hundred participants. Judging from
the evaluations, this area has been extremely
The Portuguese Museums Network

Membership of the Portuguese cess of membership in the Network and to cor- 89


Museums Network: system of respond to the overall criteria expected of the
pre-accreditation respective candidacies: a) commitment to the
museum’s social function; b) observation of the
Throughout the whole process of the gradual need to preserve and enhance collections and
construction of the RPM special importance reserves; c) conditions of sustainability.
has been attributed to the voluntary member- As regards commitment to the social func-
ship of museums. This is based on a set of cri- tion of the museum, the intention is to ascer-
teria based on the major pillars which define tain clearly and in detail how the museum de-
the condition of a museum, adapted to the scale fines its objectives and its mission. There should
or size of the museum in question and appli- be a clear correspondence between these objec-
cable to the whole museum sector. As we know, tives and the way the museum operates, its plan
many of the entities calling themselves mu- of activities and regular initiatives to publicise
seums do not fulfil the criteria that this insti- its activities, as well as its connection to the com-
tution is committed to, although the concept munity and the target public that it serves.
of museum, as defined internationally by As regards exercising care in the preserva-
ICOM, varies from country to country. In our tion and enhancement of its collections, the
case, we chose from the very beginning, to museum should demonstrate a knowledge of
adopt ICOM’s definition in the process of de- the collections in its keeping in terms of
termining membership of the RPM, using it source, origins and identification. Equally, there
as a reference for the appraisal of applications. should be evidence of a commitment to the
The fundamental objective in appraising essential museological functions: research, con-
these proposals has consisted in verifying that servation, documentation, communication and
the candidates conform to the above-mention- education, specifying in each case the condi-
ed definition. In other words that they essen- tions available for this to be effected. The mu-
tially reflect and perform their functions ac- seum must provide an inventory of its collec-
cording to the definition and that they fulfill tion, show that it has taken the necessary
their respective social roles. In the initial stage, measures for its conservation and security and
the process was aimed at establishing and con- possesses adequate premises to achieve this.
solidating the RPM and its action program- As regards sustainability, the museum must
mes. At the same time the intention has been have a sufficient number of staff to properly
to test out the system of accreditation that will fulfil its functions. Ideally, this resource should
be incorporated into the future Museums Law. be inscribed within the museum’s own statutes
Without the prior existence of support and co- or that of its governing body. Equally, the bud-
ordination structures between museums it get or allocation of funds should be sufficient
would be premature to initiate a programme to cover its operational requirements and in
of accreditation that was not accompanied by proportion to the extent of its activities, its
a global policy for the museum sector, in ac- mission and its objectives.
cordance with the areas already mentioned. The process of joining the RPM began in
Based on these presuppositions, the following April 2001. It is open to all types of museums,
aspects are considered to be crucial for the pro- regardless of their governing bodies, the sub-
Clara Camacho

90 ject matter of their collections or their territo- Autonomous Regions of the Azores and Ma-
rial constituency. The documentation that ap- deira. The signing of joint protocols between
plicants are required to complete assumes a de- the Portuguese Museums Institute and the
gree of study and self-reflection on the perform- Governments of these Atlantic archipelagos has
ance of the respective museum, backed up by meant that, from its genesis, the RPM has in-
meetings, contacts and visits by the Project cluded the island territories.
Structure team. Given the historic context initially described,
it is easy to explain the predominance of mu-
nicipal museums within the Network. This cor-
The museums within the Network
responds to the current reality of the museum
The system began with an initial group of 28 sector and reflects their initiative in preparing
museums under the tutelage of the Portuguese applications. They represent a diverse range of
Museums Institute, to which were gradually museums and collections, which include mu-
added those museums which applied to join seums connected to the district such as the Seix-
the Network, in accordance with the require- al Ecomuseum and the Museum of Mértola;
ments laid down. It now consists of 114 mu- museums with special themes such as the Pot-
seums. The situation so far, already very signi- tery Museum, the Labour Museum, the Stone
ficant, allows us to make a summary analysis Museum and the Paper Museum; art museums
and description which, whilst referring to a such as the Amadeo Sousa Cardoso Municipal
micro-universe of museums, represents an im- Museum and archaeological museums such as
portant instrument for helping to define poli- the Vila Real Museum of Archaeology and
cies for the whole sector. Numismatics. However, museums with mixed
As regards administrative dependency, the collections predominate, especially in relation
museums within the Network are overwhelm- to archaeology, ethnography and art, with the
ingly public museums, amongst which those growing role of industrial heritage also visible,
dependent on local government predominate as indicated by e.g. the Portimão Municipal
(42%). Amongst those accountable to central Museum and the Gunpowder Museum.
government (30%), the most significant are the As regards the geographical distribution, the
28 museums governed by the Portuguese Mu- museums are located predominantly in the
seums Institute. These include national mu- north of the country (32%), followed by Lis-
seums such as the National Museum of bon (27%). This situation differs slightly from
Ancient Art, the National Museum of Archae- the distribution of museums in the country as
ology, the National Museum of Ethnology and a whole, where the region around the capital
the National Coach Museum. The number of has the highest concentration of museums, fol-
museums dependent on other ministries is still lowed by the north. The distribution of the
small. For the moment there are two universi- remainder of the museums corresponds to the
ty museums and one museum accountable to overall distribution of museums throughout
the Ministry of Defence. Portugal, as well as the present demographic
Of museums dependent on a regional ad- distribution in the country, which is mainly
ministration there are 14 which are governed concentrated along the coast.
by the Regional Cultural Departments of the In relation to collections held by these mu-
The Portuguese Museums Network

seums, there is a predominance of art collec- efficient from a strategic point of view, to be- 91
tions (30%), followed by ethnographic (11%), gin by carrying out a coherent programme of
archaeological (9%) and historical collections intervention based on the three main areas al-
(7%). Museums of science and technology are ready referred to (Information, Training, Up-
rare (5%), reflecting the interest of the Portu- grading). At the same time, we would begin
guese museums in this field. the construction of the Portuguese Museums
Regarding the age of the museums in the Network itself through the process of open and
Network, it should be stressed that just over voluntary membership for museums. Only af-
half of the museums were founded after 1974 ter fulfilling and testing these stages would it
(57%), with 29 founded during the last ten be opportune to proceed with the preparation
years, which confirms the relatively recent es- of a new legislative framework which could
tablishment of Portuguese museums. benefit from the experience acquired during
In this very brief description of the muse- these three years of work.
ums that currently make up the RPM, it is also Approval of membership of the RPM has,
important to mention some of the problems in our opinion, contributed to the upgrading
that have beset them. These problems have re- of museums not only directly through the tech-
sulted in the planning and implementation of nical and financial support, but also by help-
certain measures, and recommendations to the ing to create a greater awareness on the part of
respective governing bodies and their super- the respective governing bodies about making
vision. The main problems encountered available the resources for this upgrading. The
amongst the Network’s museums have been influence of the RPM is, therefore, clearly seen
related, above all, to their statutes and manage- in the clear statutory insertion of the museums
ment, particularly in terms of lack of qualified within the governing body required and motiv-
staff, which has affected the carrying out of ated by RPM. This has had repercussions in
museological functions, especially concerning the management of museums and in the appro-
documentation and conservation. priate allocation of human and financial re-
sources for operations and the total fulfilment
of all museological functions. These aspects are
Appraisal and perspectives for
contained within the recommendations made
continuity
in the evaluation report for museums apply-
In defining the conceptual grid and program- ing for membership, compliance with which
ming lines for the RPM it seemed to us essen- is assessed after one year’s membership.
tial that this project should be able to fill a “gap” The results of some of the RPM require-
that has existed for many years in Portuguese ments are also evident regarding the upgrading
museology. This was the result of omissions of museum staff. This is particularly true with
both in terms of the regulation of existing regard to incentives for training, seen for ex-
museums and the existence of any program- ample in the frequency of training program-
mes to coordinate and support them. Yet, it mes already mentioned, as well as in the use of
seemed to us that given the wide field of ac- staff specialised in different areas of museum
tion open to us and the present state of the work. Alongside the contribution made by the
sector, it would be more appropriate and more RPM’s specific support programmes (techni-
Clara Camacho

92 cal and financial support) for the realisation of The draft law establishes the procedure that
various upgrading projects for museums, the must be followed for the creation of new mu-
publicising of the museums’ activities and seums; it determines the need for trained per-
lines of work through the Newsletter and the sonnel, as well as the financial resources appro-
Site has shown increasingly encouraging results priate for the sustainability of the museum, it
amongst museums and their professionals. establishes a model of accreditation for mu-
Given their characteristics, it is hoped that seums, and lays down decentralised forms of
the RPM museums can strengthen and devel- technical support; it institutionalises the Port-
op their work and serve as examples of good uguese Museums Network and creates a new
practice for other museum-related initiatives. consultative agency under the direct control
In this sense, one of the main objectives has of the Ministry of Culture.
been fulfilled in that the RPM has been con- It is a text which reinforces the responsibili-
structed with respect to the intrinsic diversity ties of the state and private entities which own
of museum practices, it has identified and museums, just as it reinforces the responsibili-
addressed failings and it has been exigent in ties of the specialist teams who work within
relation to statutory and functional limitations. them, in a common search for new standards.
As already mentioned, instead of taking The participatory manner by which this paper
legislation as a starting point, the strategy we was drawn up, the expectation and interest that
adopted was to view the formulation of speci- its realisation has prompted and the wide con-
fic legislation and regulations for the museum sensus concerning the majority of its articles,
sector as the desirable end result of a process. clearly point to the urgency of approving this
On this basis, the first draft of a law for Portu- ground-breaking bill for the Portuguese mu-
guese museums was recently prepared, on the seum sector. At present, and following the
initiative of the Portuguese Museums Institute, approval of the Portuguese government, the
and with the support of a Working Group of proposal will go before the parliament.
museum professionals, including representa- Since 2000, the work of the Project Struc-
tives of the National Commission of ICOM ture has developed as a constant union between
and the Portuguese Association of Museology. the need for prerequisites, from which par-
The RPM Project Structure was fully involved ameters and quality standards for museums em-
with this work. anate and the need for action, inherent within
This comprehensive proposal will establish a policy of coordination and support and which
a legal framework for the museum sector. It contains the instruments needed to attain the
starts with a definition of the concept of mu- desired standards. This project constitutes an
seum, resulting from the work of the above- initial stage in a long journey which museums
mentioned group. This serves as the basis for and agencies working in the area of museology
the identification of museum functions and the must make together in order to improve the
regulation of a series of responsibilities associat- care of the country’s heritage in their guardian-
ed with their fulfilment. At a time when the ship and to improve their role in society.
concept of museum is being widely debated
internationally, this Portuguese proposal will Clara Camacho is coordinator of the RPM
certainly make a contribution to the issue. e-mail: coordenadora@rpmuseus-pt.org

You might also like