Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Today'S K-Wave Hurst'S Cyclic Analysis Identifying Cup Formations Early Interview Product Reviews
Today'S K-Wave Hurst'S Cyclic Analysis Identifying Cup Formations Early Interview Product Reviews
Today'S K-Wave Hurst'S Cyclic Analysis Identifying Cup Formations Early Interview Product Reviews
http://www.traders.com/
TODAY’S K-WAVE
What the future holds,
up to 2020 16
hurst’s cyclic
analysis
Almost forgotten, but
a gem nonetheless 24
identifying cup
formations early
A simple mechanical
recognition method 38
INTERVIEW
Tim Slater 50
PRODUCT REVIEWS
n WSJ iPad App
n MetaSwing 4
n NinjaTrader 7
Review stories from Keep your chart Choose from an extensive Find profitable chart patterns by clicking on indicators
your friends and live notes at your toolbox to draw directly on your and selecting “QuickSort.” Our servers do the work for
news from 40+ sources fingertips charts and receive realtime alerts you and return your charts neatly organized within 2
WINNER! when your trendlines get hit seconds
Best Training
Interactive Brokers has lower commission rates for larger volumes and comparable rates worldwide.
Interactive Brokers
The Professional’s Gateway to the World’s Markets
www.interactivebrokers.com
Interactive Brokers LLC is a member of NYSE, FINRA, SIPC. Supporting documentation for any claims and statistical information will be provided upon request.
* Rates were obtained on February 1, 2011 from each firm’s website. Some of the firms listed may have additional fees and some firms may reduce or waive
commissions or fees, depending on account activity or total account value.
[1] Barron’s is a registered trademark of Dow Jones & Company, Inc. Barron’s Margin Expands Regardless of Rate - October 19, 2009. Criteria included margin interest rate
data as of February 13, 2009 and October 6, 2009, on balances of $10,000 and $50,000.
[2] Low cost broker according to Barron’s How Barron’s Ranks 22 Leading Online Brokers - March 15, 2010, ranked Interactive Brokers with a 4.2 star rating for cost. Criteria
included Trade Experience, Trading Technology, Usability, Range of Offerings, Research Amenities, Portfolio Analysis & Report, Customer Service & Education, and Costs.
[3] For additional information, see our website at www.interactivebrokers.com/bestexecution.
[4] IB calculates the interest charged on margin loans using the applicable rates for each interest rate tier listed on its website. For additional information on margin
loan rates, see www.interactivebrokers.com/interest.
02IB11-357
These articles – and articles like them – n Cover art: David Goldin
TCA WM can be found online at www.traders.com
n Cover concept : Christine Morrison/David Goldin
Copyright © 2011 Technical Analysis, Inc. All rights reserved. Information in this publication must not be stored or reproduced in any form without written permission from the publisher. Technical Analysis of
Stocks & Commodities™ (ISSN 0738-3355) is published monthly with a Bonus Issue in March for $64.95 per year by Technical Analysis, Inc., 4757 California Ave. S.W., Seattle, WA 98116-4499. Periodicals
postage paid at Seattle, WA and at additional mailing offices. Postmaster: Send address changes to Technical Analysis of Stocks & Commodities™ 4757 California Ave. S.W., Seattle, WA 98116-4499 U.S.A.
Printed in the U.S.A.
IMPORTANT INFORMATION: *Based on Technical Analysis of Stocks & Commodities magazine Readers’ Choice awards (2003-2010); in each award category, results are based on the
company that receives the highest number of votes cast by the magazine’s subscribers over a fixed time period that ends shortly before announcement of the awards. No offer or solicitation
to buy or sell securities, securities derivatives or futures products of any kind, or any type of trading or investment advice, recommendation or strategy, is made, given or in any manner
endorsed by TradeStation Securities, Inc. or any of its affiliates. • Past performance, whether actual or indicated by historical tests of strategies, is no guarantee of future performance or
success. • Active trading is generally not appropriate for someone of limited resources, limited investment or trading experience, or low risk tolerance. • There is a risk of loss in futures
trading. Options and Security Futures trading is not suitable for all investors. • Trading foreign exchange carries a high level of risk and may not be suitable for all investors. There is a
possibility that you may sustain a loss equal to or greater than your entire investment; therefore, you should not invest or risk money that you cannot afford to lose. Please visit our website
for relevant risk disclosures. • System access and trade placement and execution may be delayed or fail due to market volatility and volume, quote delays, system and software errors,
Internet traffic, outages and other factors. • All proprietary technology in TradeStation is owned by TradeStation Technologies, Inc., an affiliate of TradeStation Securities, Inc. TradeStation
Securities is a member of NYSE, FINRA, NFA and SIPC. • © 2011 TradeStation Securities, Inc. All rights reserved.
H
EDITORIAL
EDITORIAL
editor@traders.com
editor@traders.com
Editor in Chief Jack K. Hutson
O
Editor in Chief Jack K. Hutson
Editor Jayanthi Gopalakrishnan
Editor Jayanthi Gopalakrishnan
ats off to Ibm’s Watson supercomputer
Managing Editor Elizabeth M.S. Flynn
Managing Editor Elizabeth M.S. Flynn for its
nce victory
again on the
we got TV showofJeop-
a reminder just
Production Manager Karen
ProductionManager KarenE.E.Wasserman
Wasserman ardy! I was interested in finding out if Watson
how sensitive the financial markets
Director Christine
ChristineMorrison
would
are. Weprevail, but I had reservations about
Art
Art Director Morrison saw a major selloff in the Japanese
Graphic Designer Wayne
GraphicDesigner SharonShaw
watching the show just because— I didn’t wanta
Yamanaka
Staff Writers
Editorial Dennis
Intern D. Peterson,
Emilie Rommel Bruce Faber
markets, which — as expected triggered
Webmaster Han J.David
Technical Writer Kim Penn to find out that a computer’s trivia knowledge
domino effect on markets throughout the
Contributing Dennis John
Staff WritersEditors Ehlers, Bruce Faber
D. Peterson,
Anthony W. Warren, Ph.D. was better than mine. Do the results of this
world. Add disappointing earnings numbers
game have any implications
and youofhave which way
Webmaster Han J. Kim
from US corporations a situa-
Contributing EditorsDon
ContributingWriters Bright,
John Thomas
Ehlers, KevinBulkowski,
Lund,
Martin
AnthonyPring, Barbara Ph.D.
W. Warren, Star
the world is heading? In this situationoff
tion that just got worse. So what started you as
Contributing Writers Don Bright, Thomas Bulkowski,
Martin Pring, Adrienne Toghraie have Watson, which uses a computer proces-
a strong year ended up correcting, and rather
OFFICE OF THE Publisher
sor to analyze
rapidly. I mustalladmit
possible
that outcomes,
although correc-versus
Publisher Jack K. Hutson
Manager Linda
Credit OFFICE OF Eades
THEGardner
PUBLISHER humans, who use their instincts towhen
tions are healthy for any market, try toyou
come haveupawith possible
2% drop, outcomes.
it gets And the
you thinking.
Industrial
PublisherEngineer Jason K. Hutson
Jack K. Hutson computer wins.
Prior to the Federal Reserve’s F OMC meeting, I usually take a look at the yield
Sean M. Moore
I think
curve. Atthe main reason
present, behindathis
it’s looking victory
little wasgiven
flat, and that Watson
that thedidn’t haveconsensus
general to confront
Project Engineer Linda
Credit Manager Eades Gardner
Accounting Assistant
Industrial Engineer Karen
Jason K. Moore
Hutson
Mary K. Sean
Project Engineer
Controller Hutson
M. Moore any of the emotions that we humans constantly have to. This gave Watson
is that the Fed is going to tighten at their January 31st meeting, I am a clear
concerned
Accounting Assistants Jane Leonard
Controller Advertising
Mary K. Hutson
advantage.
that the yield Incurve
the game
mayof heading in the
beJeopardy!, contestantofwho
the direction first
being hits theAnd
inverted. buzzer gets
if that
Sales
4757 California Ave. S.W. to
wererespond first. Humans
to happen, that would are not
more belikely
a good to sign
take for
a little
the longer to hit that
US economy. I’mbuzzer
not
Seattle, WA 98116-4499
ADVERTISING
1 206 938-0570
SALES
Fax Ave.
4757 California 1 206S.W.
938-1307 because
suggesting theythat
maywehave
are to givetoa little
going thoughta before
go through comingperiod.
recessionary up withBut their response.
given that
advert@traders.com
Seattle, WA 98116-4499
1 206 938-0570 Fax 1 206 938-1307
They may fear being incorrect or may not have full confidence in their response.
almost anything can happen, it doesn’t hurt to expect the worst. If nothing else,
National Sales Manager Edward W. Schramm
advert@traders.com
Advertising Sales Summer L. Davis
They
it helpscould have anyyour
to preserve number of emotions running through their heads before they
capital.
National Sales Manager Edward W. Schramm
Classified & Web Sales Chris J. Chrisman hit the buzzer. Doesn’t this remind you of trading? Don’t you have a ton of thoughts
running through your head before you hit that enter button?
Classified & Web Sales Chris J. Chrisman
Production Coordinator Karen Moore
So
T
Production Coordinator Karen Moore
Circulation
CIRCULATION with that in mind, you can see why it’s important to design a trading
Subscription
Subscription &
& Order
Order Service
Service 11 800
800 832-4642
832-4642
11 206
206 938-0570
938-0570 FaxFax 11 206
206 938-1307 system that gets you out of the market at the right time. When access to
he Watson victory
the tells us that a lot is possible
availablewith algorithms,This and those
938-1307
circ@traders.com
circ@traders.com the markets is easy, number of options increases. makes it
Manager Sean
Sean M.
M. Moore
important to be thorough with the different types of orders, front-end software,trad-
possibilities have spilled into the trading world. Aren’t the institutional
Subscription
Subscription Manager Moore
and
ers usingsystems
algorithms
that for
are their high-frequency trading? This could make the trad-
Subscription Sales Karen
Assistant Subscription Adams-Thomas,
Manager Sheila Peterson
Stacy Bagnall, Carmen Hale trading out there. Lee Leibfarth, in his article “The Automated
ing environment even more challenging for the retail trader. Even though it takes
Subscription Sales Agnes Dimaano, Tina Row
Daytrader” starting on page 22, addresses the various options that are available and
humans to create or develop the algorithms, the retail trader is not in a position to
Website
WEBSITE
http://www.traders.com
http://www.traders.com how you can take advantage of them.
Staff members
Staff members may may bebe emailed
emailed through
throughthe
theInternet
Internet compete against algorithmic traders. We will always be slower
But before getting to the stage of placing that trade, you need to understand the than the big play-
using first
first initial
initial plus
plus last
last name
name plus
plus@traders.com
using @traders.com
ers, andyou
market sometimes our strategies
are trading. You should may bejust
ablenot work
to do because
so after of thePaolo
reading tactics used by
Pezzutti’s
Authorization to photocopy items for internal or personal high-frequency traders.
“Understanding Market Structure.” The markets follow different behavior pat-
use,Authorization
granted
or the internto
use, or bytheTech
alphotocopy
or personal
nical or
internal Anal
usefor
items
ysis, Inc.use
personal
of internal
for users
specificorclients, is
personal
registclients,
of specific ered with is terns,
Butandthisyou
doesn’t
need mean that weifwill
to determine not be able
it is volatile, to trade.
trending, in aWe just range,
trading have tomoving
find a
the Copyby
granted
porting
right Clearance
Technical
Service, providedCenter
Center
Analysis,
that the(CCC)
(CCC)
Inc. for users
base fee
Transactional
registered with
of $1.00 per
Re-
copy,
way to trade that won’t be affected by the algorithmic
strongly in one direction, or moving but not with much momentum. trading world. Algorithmic
or high-frequency traderswhat
tradethe
forstructure
a very short-term timeisperiod. Most retailtotraders
the Copyright Clearance Transactional Report-
plus 50¢ perprovided
ing Service, page is thatpaidthe directly
base fee to CCC,
of $1.00 222perRosewood
copy, plus
Drive, Danvers, MA 01923.
directly Online:
to CCC,http://www.copyright.
Only when you know of the market will you be able apply
are not in a position to trade as quickly as that, so really, you have a large pool of
50¢ per page is paid 222 Rosewood Drive,
com. For MA
Danvers, those organ
01923. izations
Online: that have been grantedFor
http://www.copyright.com. a the correct trading technique. But that’s just the first step. You still have to have
photocopy license bythat
those organizations
has beenbyarranged.
license
CCC, a sep
have
The fee code
CCC, a separate system
arategranted
been
for users
systemaofphotocopy
payment
of the has
of payment Transac-
been
strategies from which to choose and a large pool of products
discipline, as you will find out after reading this month’s Technical Analysis of from which to trade.
tional Reporting
arranged. The feeServcode
ice is:for0738-3355/2011
users of the $1.00 + .50.
Transactional STOCKS
In the & grand scheme of things,
COMMODITIES interviewyou’re
withnot Kengoing
Tower. to be affected
Only much
then will youbybe
algorith-
able to
Reporting tions:is:USA: one year (13$1.00 issues) $64.95;
mic traders. A computer can only trade based on how it has been programmed to
Subscrip Service 0738-3355/2006 + .50.
Foreign surface mailUSA: add one $15 yearper year. Air mail: Europe
Subscriptions: (13 issues) $64.95; know when to exit.
add
copies
$25.50
Foreign
of
surface
most
per year;
mail add
past
else
issues
where
$15
of the
add $39
per year.
cur r ent
$25.50 per year; elsewhere add $39 per year. Single copies
per year.
Air mail:
year are
Europe Sinadd
avail
gle
able trade—that is, it is dependent on its inputs and processes to generate the desired
pre paid past
of most
format
at $8issues
(without
per copy.
copy.ads)
of thePrior
current
or years
years
yearare
from www.traders.com.
areavail able in
available book
prepaid
USAformat
funds
outputs. You have to do the same
Here’s things:
to smart select the inputs that will give you the
trading!
desired outputs.
at $8 per Prior are available in book
only. Washington
(without ads) or from statewww.traders.com.
residents add sales USAtax for their
funds only.
locale. VISA, MasterCard, AmEx, and
Washington state residents add 8.8% sales tax. VISA, Discover accepted.
Subscription
MasterCard,orders: AmEx, 1 800
and832-4642
Novus Discoveror 1 206 938-0570.
accepted.
Subscription
Technicalorders: Analysis Stocksor&1 206
1 800of832-4642 938-0570.™,
Commodities
TheTechnical
Traders’ Magazine™,
Analysis of S isTOCKS
prepared from information
& COMMODITIES ™
, The
believed
Traders’ to be reliable is
Magazine™, butprepared
not guaranteed by us witho
from information ut
be-
further
lieved verification,
to be reliable andbut doesnotnot purport toby
guaranteed be us
complete.
without
Opinions expressedand aredoes
subject notto revision without noti-
further verification, purport to be complete.
Jayanthi Gopalakrishnan,
Jayanthi Gopalakrishnan,
fication.
OpinionsWe are not are
expressed offer ing to buy
subject or sell without
to revision securities or
notifi-
commodities
cation. We are not offering to buy or sell securities or
discussed. Technical Anal y sis Inc., one or Editor
more
the
more
of its officers,
commodities
securities
discussed.
discussed
of its officers,
and authors
Technical may have aInc.,
Analysis
herein.may have a position in the
and authors
position
one or in
Editor
securities
The names of products
discussed herein. and services presented in this
magazine
The names are used only in an
of products andeditorial
services fashion,
presentedand in to this
the
benefit
magazineof the aretrademark
used onlyowner, with no intention
in an editorial fashion, and of infring-
to the
ing on trademark
benefit of the trademarkrights.owner, with no intention of infringing
on trademark rights.
+1104
+0603Opening
OpeningPositionnew.indd
Position 1 1 1/24/06, 9:48 AM 2/23/11 3:58:03 PM
Download today at www.ninjatrader.com/TASC USE IT FREE!
Significant
Significant performance improvements
Genetic
Genetic optimization & Monte Carlo analysis
Expanded
Expanded library of 3rd party indicators & strategies
FEATURED PARTNERS
Over 200 plus 3rd party add ons including: Available at hundreds of FCMs and
brokerages worldwide including:
READERS’ CHOICE AWARDS This is especially true when it comes to Authors Aleksey Gersimov and
Editor, corrective waves ABC. Alexander Ershov reply:
Where can I find the results Hgs We appreciate your practical questions and
of your Readers’ Choice hope our clarifications here and example
Awards, which I saw a refer- Author Koos van der Merwe replies: forecasts are of interest to readers.
ence to at your website? Thank you for your interest. You will find
Ahmet my latest article on K-waves in this issue, 1. In regard to your question about device
titled “Today’s K-Wave And Beyond.” A: Our model presupposes that device
The 2011 Readers’Choice Awards can be As for Elliott wave: I always look for A includes all the factors that influence
found in our 2011 Bonus Issue, which was simplicity. In fact, the February 2009 price formation. These factors include
mailed in February to all subscribers, issue of S&C contained my article on El- fundamental economic laws; signals
and which will continue to be mailed out liott wave theory, “Elliott Wave Theory, provided by trading systems; credit and
throughout the year to new subscribers. Simplified.” In this article (available tax cycles; natural cycles; and so on. The
The Readers’ Choice Awards are based from the store at Traders.com), I dem- proposed model — which is constructed
on the results of an online poll asking onstrate that if you look for complicated from an input signal, a device, and an
subscribers to vote for their favorite waves, you will likely be wrong. output signal — is only a convenient
products and services.—Editor My advice is to always stick to the visual image. In actuality, we are talking
first rule of Elliott wave theory: The about greater things.
KONDRATIEFF WAVE wave count must look right. I suggest We act on the premise that any complex
Editor, checking out my February 2009 article system should be studied as a whole. If
I was reading “Kondrati- for more on this. you try to separate the complex system
eff Wave Comeback” by into several simple systems and study
Koos van der Merwe in MARKET INSTRUMENT FUNCTION them separately, and then sum up the
the April 2010 S&C. I am Editor, simple systems into the complex one,
new to the K-wave theory Thank you to authors you end up with a completely different
but I am fascinated by it. It is also my Aleksey Gersimov and system. Thus, we can’t consider the laws
goal to achieve a better knowledge of Alexander Ershov for that form the market separately. All
Elliott wave theory. sharing their article and the factors, which influence the prices,
I was wondering if the author could ideas in “The Market constantly interact and influence each
explain his approach to counting waves. Instrument Function” in the December other as well. The instrument function
I can count simple and straightforward 2010 S&C. method makes it possible to analyze the
waves, but when it comes to patterns Here were some thoughts I came away market as a whole and not be concerned
like an inside day or three falling/rising with after reading the article: with what is the exact cause of each and
candlestick pattern, I get stuck. I have every market action.
been counting using pivot points (such • The idea that the way a price gets to
its current level is important and often 2. Regarding charting platforms: We
as explained by Thomas DeMark), but used MetaStock for producing our final
I run into confusion when the waves get overlooked.
results.
more complicated, as with extensions. • I liked that a person only needs to know
that the fundamental laws defining the 3. In regard to applying this model to
market exist, not figure them out. other markets such as commodities and
forex: We applied our instrument func-
I won’t pretend that I understand all tion method to gold, oil, and the Crb
the complex math that their article dis- index in practice, which we had success
played, but I did have a few questions with. We haven’t yet applied it to the forex
• Powerful browser-based
trading on any computer
• Streaming news and quotes
• Interactive charting and
customizable watch lists
800.343.3548
Fidelity.com/trading
Keep in mind that investing involves risk. The value of your investment will fluctuate over time and you may gain or lose money.
†
Offer valid only to new Fidelity customers opening a Fidelity Brokerage Services LLC retail account and funding it with at least $100,000 in
cash and/or eligible securities. See Fidelity.com/200trades for further details.
Screen shots are provided for illustrative purposes only and should not be used or construed as an offer to sell, a solicitation of an offer to buy, or a
recommendation for the security or particular trading strategy.
ActiveTraderPro.com is available to investors in households that place 120 or more stock, bond, or options trades in a rolling 12-month period.
System availability and response times may be subject to market conditions.
Fidelity Brokerage Services LLC, Member NYSE, SIPC. © 2011 FMR LLC. All rights reserved. 575067.1.0
In addition, the author biography at You are correct — it should have read Fvoii = Fvoii–1 + ((Vi + (OIi – OIi–1)) *
the end of the article should have stated “above.” Thank you for bringing this to ((Pi – Pi–1) / |Pi – Pi–1|))
that coauthor Alexander Ershov has been our attention.—Editor
studying the use of mathematical meth- which also can be written as:
ods for weak signal reception as applied Editor,
to stock market forecasting since 2005, The article “Investment Vs. Trading In Fvoii =
not since the early 1990s. Covered Call Writing” by Jay Kaeppel in Pi – P i–1
FVOI = FVOI i–1 + Vi + OI i – OI i–1 *
Aleksey Gersimov the February 2011 S&C was interesting i Pi – Pi–1
(avgerasimov@umail.ru) and thorough, but Kaeppel causes some
Alexander Ershov confusion in his comment in step 3 at the
Thus, the entire expression (Vi + (OIi –
(amershov@umail.ru) bottom of page 20 when he writes, “If
OIi–1) should be enclosed in parentheses,
an option expires, it will do so either in-
so that the whole result gets multiplied
MEASURING TRADING the-money (stock price below the strike
by ((Pi – Pi–1) / |Pi – Pi–1|).
SYSTEM PERFORMANCE price) or out-of-the-money (stock price
Otherwise, all charts and analyses
Editor, above the strike price).”
remain the same.
I found the article by Stephen Massel in According to Investopedia.com, the
Teresa Fernandez
the March 2011 S&C (“What Can You definition of “in-the-money” is when the (teresa.fernandez.wg72@
Expect, Mathematically?”) to be very option’s strike price is below the market wharton.upenn.edu)
informative. However, I had problems price of the underlying asset for a call
with the calculation for the ME (math- option, not above. By the same token, JANUARY 2011 EXCEL TRADERS’ TIP
ematical expectation) result for the “out-of-the-money” is when the option’s Editor,
sample scalping system. I got a result strike price is above the market price of In the January 2011 Traders’ Tip for
of 33 for this calculation, rather than the the underlying, not below. Excel, an error occurred in the formula
26 shown in the article. In addition, the But while I’m writing, let me say for column Q. Thus, I am providing a
point plotted on the chart seems to be that the articles in S&C are always replacement spreadsheet file for “Com-
off a bit. Did I misinterpret something thought-provoking, challenging, and bining Rsi with Rsi.xls.”
in the article? quite informative. As programmers and manufacturers
Jack Brennan Jim Kimes both know, there is nothing like a real,
live user to find the bugs in something
Author Stephen Massel replies: You, too, are correct. Thank you for you have built. My thanks to the readers
You are correct — the R/R ratio for pointing out these errors.—Editor who tried large smoothing numbers and
the scalp system should have been 0.8 let me know that something was slightly
instead of 0.9, yielding an ME of 26 [70 CALCULATION OF FVOI off on the charts in the original version
x 0.8 – (100–70)]. With an R/R ratio of Editor, of the spreadsheet.
0.9, it would indeed have an ME of 33. In my February 2011 article “Does Gold Ronald McAllister
Thanks for pointing it out. Still Have Room to Run?” in S&C, sev- (rpmaca_sprynet.com)
eral errors appeared as follows:
COVERED CALL WRITING Subscribers can download the corrected
1. The first sentence of the third bulleted spreadsheet file, “Combining Rsi with
Editor,
point on page 23, second column, should Rsi.xls,” from our website at www.Trad-
On page 13 of the February 2011 article,
have read: “When prices are falling but ers.com in the January 2011 Traders’
“Investment Vs. Trading In Covered Call
open interest is rising, add the change in Tips area at http://www.traders.com/
Writing,” author Jay Kaeppel writes, “If
open interest to today’s volume.” Documentation/FEEDbk_docs/2011/01/
the stock price is below the strike price
for a given call option at expiration, that 2. The first sentence of the fourth bulleted TradersTips.html (or use the search
option will be exercised and the option point on page 23, second column, should engine at Traders.com and type in “com-
seller called upon to deliver 100 shares of have read: “When both price and open bining rsi with rsi”).—Editor S&C
High volume
One of the first things a nov-
ice trader should look at when
considering a new instrument
is volume. In order to enter and
exit a market, there must be suf-
ficient buyers and sellers. Over
the course of the last few years,
the commodity markets have
undergone a dramatic change
in volume. Figure 1 shows that
the average yearly volume for
crude light, gold, platinum, and
silver markets has more than
quadrupled, with crude light
being the leader, jumping from
MARIO ZUCCA
50,000 contracts in 2006 to
almost 350,000 now.
As Figure 1 demonstrates,
Crude, Silver, Gold, And Platinum
Empowering Traders
N ew traders are often overwhelmed at the number of different instruments they could is not a market that the trader
trade. Should they trade stocks, indexes, exchange traded funds (Etfs), spot forex, or should consider trading.
12 • April 2011 • Technical Analysis of Stocks & Commodities
350000
500
300000
400
250000
CL CL
200000 GC 300 GC
PL PL
150000 SI SI
200
100000
100
50000
0 0
2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Figure 1: AVERAGE YEARLY VOLUME FOR COMMODITIES. The average yearly Figure 2: Average Yearly Tick Movement for Commodities. The com-
volume for crude light, gold, platinum, and silver markets has more than quadrupled, modities moved slightly less than the indexes through 2006.Then, in 2007,commodities
with crude light being the leader, jumping from 50,000 contracts to almost 350,000 gained an advantage over the indexes.
since 2006.
Average yearly tick movement for indexes Average yearly dollar movement for commodities
350 $5,000.00
$4,500.00
300
$4,000.00
250 $3,500.00
ES $3,000.00
200 CL
YM
$2,500.00 GC
NQ
150 PL
EMD $2,000.00
SI
TF
100 $1,500.00
$1,000.00
50
$500.00
0 $-
2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
FIGURE 3: Average Yearly Tick Movement for Indexes. The average FIGURE 4: Average Yearly DOLLAR Movement for COMMODITIES. Platinum
annual tick movement for crude light, gold, and platinum has been greater than the does not lead in dollar amounts. The leader when comparing dollar amounts is crude
average annual tick movement in most of the indexes. light, followed by silver, gold, and finally platinum.
$2,500.00
$2,000.00
ES
YM
$1,500.00
NQ
EMD
$1,000.00 TF
$500.00
$-
2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
FIGURE 5: Average Yearly Dollar Comparison for Indexes. We see that, dollar
for dollar, up until 2006, the indexes moved more. Again, as of 2007, the commodities began For more information circle No. 15
moving more, dollar for dollar. And, again, crude light is the leader of the pack.
substantially in both volume and tick per session. Therefore, if you are trad- Average volume by session time
movement since 2007, let us compare the ing crude light, during the US morning Asia London US AM US PM
commodity dollar movement with that of session, the average tick movement CL 1414 4744 44660 71680
the indexes. Figure 5 compares the average would be 217 ticks. Following the 10% Si 461 1228 9272 6174
yearly movement in dollars. Dollar for rule, the profit target would be 22 ticks. GC 2373 5656 36516 23022
dollar, up until 2006, the indexes moved Since we always use a risk–reward ratio PL 109 178 669 435
more. But as of 2007, the commodities of 1:2 (meaning for every dollar of risk
FIGURE 6: Average Volume by Session Time. As
began moving more. Once again, crude we gain two dollars), our stop would be you can see, crude light and gold have adequate volume
light is the leader of the pack. 22 divided by two or 11 ticks. during each of the sessions. However, the majority of
the volume is during the US session and even then,
The different You are now empowered platinum still has a very low volume average.
trading sessions The new trader can now begin trad-
Now that we have identified the tradables ing commodities with the following Average tick movement by session time
with adequate volume and movement on knowledge: Asia London US AM US PM
a daily basis, we can look at the volume n Commodities have increased in CL 76 126 217 279
and tick movement for the different volume since 2007. Si 36 49 100 78
sessions. Figure 6 shows the average GC 71 89 177 137
n Crude light, gold, and silver have suf-
volume for each four-hour session: Asia, PL 128 151 278 218
London, the US morning session, and the ficient volume for intraday trading.
US afternoon session. Crude light and n Platinum has insufficient volume FIGURE 7: Average Tick Movement by Ses-
gold have adequate volume during each for intraday trading. sion Time. If you are trading crude light, during the
US morning session, the average tick movement is 217
of the sessions. However, the majority of
n Commodities move more than the ticks. Following the 10% rule, the profit target would be
the volume is during the US session and
indexes in tick movement. 22 ticks. Since we always use a risk–reward of 1:2, our
even then, platinum still has a very low stop would be 22 divided by two or 11 ticks.
volume average. If a new trader planned n Platinum leads in tick movement.
on trading the Asian or London session, n Crude light leads in dollar move- currently trades futures, forex, indexes,
he or she would need to limit the markets ment, followed by silver and gold. and stocks.
to either crude or gold.
n Platinum has the least amount in
dollar movement. Suggested reading
What are your Mercer, Gail [2011]. “Empowering Trad-
potential profits? n The 10% rule works for 1:2 profit ers With The Russell 2000,” Technical
Since we have limited the potential targets and stop-losses. Analysis of Stocks & Commodities,
markets to crude light, silver, and gold, Volume 29: March.
we can calculate our potential profit tar- Gail Mercer is a trader, director, and _____ [2010]. “Looking At Other Mar-
gets. The 10% rule is one of the easiest instructor for tradershelpdesk.com, kets,” Technical Analysis of Stocks &
methods with which to do this. Simply and is known as an “indicator expert.” Commodities, Volume 28: May.
calculate the average tick value for the Mercer hosts a free live trading room ‡Microsoft Excel
session and then multiply by 10%. Figure where she teaches forex and index trad-
7 indicates the average tick movement ers how to approach the markets. She ‡See Editorial Resource Index S&C
IAU
L:10”
iShares
Gold Trust
iShares Gold Trust (“Trust”) has filed a registration statement (including a prospectus) with the SEC for the offering to which this communication
relates. Before you invest, you should read the prospectus and other documents the Trust has filed with the SEC for more complete information
about the issuer and this offering. You may get these documents for free by visiting www.iShares.com or EDGAR on the SEC website at
www.sec.gov. Alternatively, the Trust will arrange to send you the prospectus if you request it by calling toll-free 1-800-474-2737.
Investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal. The Trust is not an investment company registered under the Investment Company Act of
1940 or a commodity pool for purposes of the Commodity Exchange Act. Shares of the Trust are not subject to the same regulatory requirements
as mutual funds. Because shares of the Trust are created to reflect the price of the gold held by the Trust, less the Trust’s expenses and liabilities,
the market price of the shares will be as unpredictable as the price of gold has historically been. Brokerage commissions will reduce returns.
The price received upon the sale of the shares, which trade at market price, may be more or less than the value of the gold represented by them.
There is no guarantee an active trading market will develop for the shares, which may result in losses on your investment at the time of disposition
of your shares. For a more complete discussion of the risk factors relative to the Trust, carefully read the prospectus. The trustee’s arrangements
with the custodian contemplate that at the end of each business day there can be in the trust account as such custodian no gold in an unallocated
form. BlackRock Asset Management International Inc., an affiliate of BlackRock, Inc., is the sponsor of the Trust. ©2010 BlackRock Institutional
Trust Company, N.A. All rights reserved. iShares® is a registered trademark of BlackRock Institutional Trust Company, N.A. iS-3798-0111
Kondratieff A Go-Go
Today’s K-Wave
And Beyond
Trying to make sense of the markets is always been aware of them. However, there is no evidence
a challenge. Here’s an updated look at the that he ever tied his wave counts to the K-wave.
Kondratieff wave after 2010.
Using waves
But in all my long-term analyses, I do tie the K-
W
hen Nikolai Kondratieff developed his wave and the Elliott wave counts together, because
wave theory, he had never heard of tech- I believe that the K-wave identifies major lows and
nical analysis. He had also never met highs in any Elliott wave count. In my November
Ralph Elliott of Elliott wave theory fame, 2008 Stocks & Commodities article on the K-
a man who lived in the same generation wave, I explained the theory, and I have repeated the
that he did, a man who expressed in a book he had K-wave chart here in Figure 1 for you to study.
written about Latin America: “There is a reason for In that article, I also showed how a chart of the
everything and it is one’s duty
to discover it.” KONDRATIEFF WAVE COUNT (ORIGINAL)
In 1946, Ralph Elliott pub- Years in which panics have occurred and will occur again
lished Nature’s Law: The Secret 1927 18 1945 20 1965 16 1981
Figure 1: kondratieff wave charts. Here you see the standard Kondratieff wave chart going all the way back to the
by Koos van der Merwe, Cfp 1920s when Nikolai Kondratieff first wrote about it. I have projected it into the future to 2039.
1500.0
2016
10 8 9 1000.0
1989 1999 2007
500.0
0.00
Figure 2: monthly chart of the s&p 500. Here you see the K-wave overlaid on the chart of the S&P 500. The chart suggests that we can expect a minor top
in 2016 with a year of panic only occurring in 2019. The correction in 2016 may not be as dramatic as the 1999 correction, but you would get out of the market in 2019
06-938-1307 • email:
and goKMoore@Traders.com
to cash.
Standard & Poor’s 500 met the cyclical turning points as sug- last a long time.
PROOF #1
gested by the K-wave, allowing an approximate year for error. In my April 2010 S&C article, I noted that my Elliott wave
I presented an Elliott wave chart of the S&P 500 showing that a chart predictions of the November 2008 article were correct.
final C-wave was in the cards, with the K-wave suggesting the However, the bottom turning-point dates were earlier than the
low in 2012. ones predicted by the K-wave. This may have been because
Figure 2 is the chart updated as of November 3, 2010. I Kondratieff was an economist, and his forecast was designed
concluded that article by noting that Alan Greenspan, the former to predict economic expansion, recession, and depression,
Federal Reserve chairman, stated that the United States was not the movement of the stock market. It is my belief that in
in a recession and it would be a mild one, but that it would today’s world, allowances must be made not only for electronic
YYears of good times, high prices
trading but also the proliferation of hedge funds. If Kondratieff
Times to sell values of all kinds were alive today, would he change his forecast and charts?
We can only speculate.
NEW for 2011: BWT PRECISION AUTO TRADER - TRADE SMARTER, TRADE AUTOMATED I still firmly believe in the Kondratieff wave theory, and the
Stop Losing and Start Winning by Keeping Your Emotions in Check 100% Automated Entry
and Exit • Forex • Futures • ETF’s • Stocks • Ninja Trader • Muliti Charts • Tradestation outcome of the recent US elections, in which the Republicans
took control of the US House of Representatives, suggests
that the US economic recovery could now be in a stalemate
if the Republicans in Congress challenge President Obama’s
policies. This is why I see a slow recovery in my charts for
the coming six years, if not longer.
History, however, has always taught me that it is far easier
to conclude a reason for an event after the event than before
the event. To quote movie mogul Samuel Goldwyn, “It is
always difficult to forecast, especially the future.”
Figure 1 is my standard Kondratieff wave chart going all
the way back to 1927, when Nikolai Kondratieff first wrote
The Most Innovative Technical Analysis Tool Available Today about it. I have projected it into the future to 2039.
Blue Wave Trading: Often Imitated...Never Duplicated Figure 2 is a standard monthly chart of the S&P 500, with
www.bluewavetrading.com • 808-281-8391 the K-wave overlaid. Note how the K-wave called for the
For more information circle No. 24 major correction in 1999, noted as “Years in which panics have
18 • April 2011 • Technical Analysis of Stocks & Commodities
SOPHISTICATION
MEETS SIMPLICITY.
OPTIONS TRADING ON REDESIGNED
POWER E*TRADE PRO
Streaming Options
S:9.625”
Chains & Analytics
ETRADE.COM / 1-800-ETRADE-1
Important Note: Options involve risk and are not suitable for all investors. For more information, please read the Characteristics and Risks of Standardized
Options available by visiting etrade.com/optionsdisclosure, calling 1-800-ETRADE-1 or writing to E*TRADE Securities LLC, P.O. Box 1542, Merrifield, VA
22116-1542.
1. This offer applies only to new Power E*TRADE accounts opened with a minimum $2,000 deposit from an external bank or brokerage account. You will receive up to 500 trade
commissions for each stock or options trade executed within 60 days of the deposited funds clearing in the new account. You will pay $9.99 for your first 149 stock or options trades
and $7.99 thereafter up to 500 stock or options trades (plus 75¢ per options contract). Account must be funded within 60 days of account open. Credits for cash or securities will be
made based on deposits of new funds or securities from external accounts made within 45 days of account open, as follows: $250,000 or more will receive $500; $100,000-$249,999
will receive $250; $50,000-$99,999 will receive $100; $25,000-$49,999 will receive $50. Your account will be credited for trades and deposits within eight weeks. You will not receive
cash compensation for any unused free trade commissions. Excludes current E*TRADE Securities customers (except IRA accounts), E*TRADE Financial Corporation associates and
non-U.S. residents. This offer is not valid for IRAs, other retirement, business, trust or E*TRADE Bank accounts. New funds or securities must remain in the account (minus any
trading losses) for a minimum of 6 months or the credit may be surrendered. One promotion per customer and per linked account. E*TRADE Securities reserves the right to terminate
this offer at any time. Accounts must be opened by December 31, 2011, the offer expiration date.
2. CNBC streaming news and the CNBC logo are provided for informational purposes only under a license agreement with CNBC, Inc. Neither E*TRADE Financial nor any of its
affiliates are responsible for its content and no information presented constitutes a recommendation by E*TRADE Financial or its affiliates to buy, sell or hold any security, financial
product or instrument discussed therein or to engage in any specific investment activity.
Securities products and services are offered by E*TRADE Securities LLC, Member FINRA/SIPC.
System response and account access times may vary due to a variety of factors, including trading volumes, market conditions, system performance and other factors.
©2011 E*TRADE Financial Corporation. All rights reserved.
on Thursday, May 6,
1193.57 1193.57
1000 1000.0
741.02
2010, something Kon-
A
C
6 years
dratieff could never
500 500.0
have foreseen.
105
98.42
105
1976 to 86.45 in 1978 was a 12.16% correction. Figure
95 95
4 shows this U-shaped correction clearly.
What this means is that we could see a 12.16% cor-
85 86.45 85
Apr 1978
75 75
U-shaped correction
65 2½ years 65 The K-wave called for
60 60
a bottom in 2005, but
the index triggered a
FIGURE 4: The S&P 500 showing the 1977–79 U-shaped correction on a monthly
chart. We could see a 12.16% correction or a figure pretty close to this over the next two years, low in 2003.
once a high has been confirmed.
PREMIUM
FUTURES
TRADING
WITHOUT
THE PREMIUM.
TRADE FUTURES WITH A HIGH DEGREE OF CONFIDENCE.
NOT A HIGH PRICE.
FUTURES TRADING
NB:9.625”
SPECIALISTS
NO-FEE ACCESS TO
PRO-GRADE TT_TRADERß
FUTURES CONTRACTS
FOR 90 DAYS1
$2.99 THEREAFTER
ETRADE.COM / 1-877-553-8887
Important Note: Futures and options transactions are complex and carry a high degree of risk. They are intended for sophisticated investors and are not suitable for everyone.
For more information, please read the Characteristics and Risks of Standardized Options and the Risk Disclosure Statement for Futures and Options available by visiting
etrade.com/options and etrade.com/futures or by calling 1-877-553-8887.
1. The new account holder will be charged 99¢ (per side, per contract, plus exchange fees) futures commissions for each futures trade executed once a qualified account is opened and
funded and deposited funds have cleared. After the 90 day offer period, each futures trade is $2.99 (per side, per contract, plus exchange fees). This offer is not valid for IRAs, other
retirement, business, trust or E*TRADE Bank accounts. Excludes current E*TRADE Securities Futures customers, E*TRADE Financial Corporation associates and non-U.S. residents.
Offer only applies to new E*TRADE Futures Accounts opened with a $10,000 minimum deposit. Account holders must maintain minimum funding in all accounts ($10,000 minus any
trading losses) for at least six months or credit may be surrendered. Limit one new E*TRADE Futures account per customer. We reserve the right to terminate this offer at any time. In
addition to the $2.99 per contract per side commission, futures customers will be assessed certain fees including applicable futures exchange and NFA fees, as well as MF Global floor
brokerage charges for execution of non-electronically traded futures and futures options contracts. These fees are not established by E*TRADE Securities and will vary by exchange.
Securities and futures products and services offered by E*TRADE Securities LLC, Member FINRA/SIPC/NFA. Accounts carried by MF Global, an unaffiliated company.
TT_TRADER™ is a trademark of Trading Technologies International, Inc., an unaffiliated company.
System response and account access times may vary due to a variety of factors, including trading volumes, market conditions, system performance and other factors.
©2011 E*TRADE Financial Corporation. All rights reserved.
v iii
3 v 666.80
700.00
many stocks and make
5
C
600.00 a note in your trading
March 6, 2009
500.00 journal to be cautious
RSI 12, 7, 3 -100.00 as 2016 approaches, and
SELL ZONE
move totally to cash as
2019 approaches.
50.00
BUY ZONE 37.84
Finally, the ques-
tion of inflation always
0.00
AbleTrend 7.0
dust in my office closet. Only AbleTrend continues to
use AbleTrend be my primary trading tool. It truly helps me decide
what to trade, when to trade it and when to get out
• S&C Magazine Awards (Yearly 1997-2011) once I am in a trade. Integrated within AbleTrend is
• Objective Buy/Sell/Stop Signals an excellent Stop Loss and Profit Protect discipline. The
Remove Guesswork AbleTrend AutoScan feature enables me to quickly roll
through over 200 potential ETFs in less than 5 minutes
• Dynamic Intelligent Stops as I look for new trading opportunities.”
• Long-Term Back Testing Validates — Gary Wollert
Strategies (10+ years)
• Real-time Auto-Scan Uncovers the
Best Entries Instantly “The AbleTrend system is phenomenal, it is a relaxing
way to trade. I trade the ES, it shows me where to enter
• Money Management (MM) and where to place my stops Most days I place one or
• AbleSys Is a CTA Registered with two trades, today, one trade profit of 33 pt. on ES. Nice
CFTC Since 1995 for a 75 year old retired rancher. Thank you Ablesys.”
— Steve Lyons, UT
• FREE One-on-One Private
Consultation by Phone
Now Also Available for NinjaTrader
• Easy to Learn and Use
• A Must-Have for Building Personal Wealth
Ablesys Corp. • 20954 Corsair Blvd. • Hayward, CA 94545 • Tel: 510-265-1883 • Fax: 510-265-1993
Reader’s Choice Awards
1997-2011 in Stock Trading
THESE RESULTS ARE BASED ON SIMULATED OR HYPOTHETICAL PERFORMANCE RESULTS THAT HAVE CERTAIN INHERENT LIMITATIONS. UNLIKE THE RESULTS SHOWN IN AN System; Futures Trading System
ACTUAL PERFORMANCE RECORD, THESE RESULTS DO NOT REPRESENT ACTUAL TRADING. ALSO, BECAUSE THESE TRADES HAVE NOT ACTUALLY BEEN EXECUTED, THESE RE- & Option Trading System
SULTS MAY HAVE UNDER-OR OVER-COMPENSATED FOR THE IMPACT, IF ANY, OF CERTAIN MARKET FACTORS, SUCH AS LACK OF LIQUIDITY. SIMULATED OR HYPOTHETICAL
TRADING PROGRAMS IN GENERAL ARE ALSO SUBJECT TO THE FACT THAT THEY ARE DESIGNED WITH THE BENEFIT OF HINDSIGHT. NO REPRESENTATION IS BEING MADE THAT
ANY ACCOUNT WILL OR IS LIKELY TO ACHIEVE PROFITS OR LOSSES SIMILAR TO THESE BEING SHOWN. THE TESTIMONIAL MAY NOT BE REPRESENTATIVE OF THE EXPERIENCE OF
OTHER CLIENTS AND THE TESTIMONIAL IS NO GUARANTEE OF FUTURE PERFORMANCE OR SUCCESS. TECHNICAL ANALYSIS OF STOCKS & COMMODITIES LOGO AND CTA Firm
AWARD ARE TRADEMARKS OF TECHNICAL ANALYSIS, INC.
In
the 1970s, an American engineer named J.M. Hurst why isn’t it better known and more widely used by technical
published a thesis about why financial markets move analysts? There are two possible reasons:
the way they do. His expounded theory was the result of
n First,Hurst’s cyclic theory is not easy. While it is
many years of research, and it became known as Hurst’s
beautiful and elegant in its essence, it is not a simple
cyclic theory. Hurst claimed a 90% success rate trading
theory to understand or apply. The Cycles Course is
on the basis of his theory, and yet his work has remained
more than 1,500 pages long, and most people take
largely undiscovered and often misunderstood.
several months to work through it.
An almost-forgotten theory
n Second, although the theory presented in both the Profit
Hurst published two seminal works: The Profit Magic Of Stock
Transaction Timing, followed a few years later by a workshop- Magic book and the Cycles Course is the same, there
style course that was called the Cyclitec Cycles Course (now is a vitally important distinction between the analysis
Suggested reading
Hurst, J.M. [1970]. Profit Magic Of Stock Transaction Tim-
ing, Prentice-Hall. S&C
Big
is coming...
www.pfgbest.com/itsComing
there is a substantial risk of loss in trading commodity futures, options and off-exchange foreign currency products.Past
performance is not indicative of future results.
from a different angle — one that will help you realize the following major methods:
that there is a harmony among cycles, events, and market
n Descriptive statistics
behavior.
n Visual analysis of charts
by Arthur Zernov
n Trigonometric methods (centered simple moving aver-
Bars
at all? To answer these questions, I de-
cided to try a scientific approach with
an engineering twist. First, I employed
the nullification hypothesis: There are
MICROSOFT EXCEL
no cycles in market price data. Yes,
I denied there are cycles until proven
otherwise. If my hypothesis is correct, Amplitude in dB 6–9 3–6 0–3 Date
I won’t be able to detect cycles using
Figure 2: S&P 500 weekly spectrum (October 2009–September 2010). Here you can see the 16- to
the mathematical methods used in 17-week cycle. This translates into an 80- to 85-day cycle.
electronic engineering to detect sig-
nals. If the hypothesis is incorrect, then
these discrete time signal processing Spectrum
methods should work.
To verify this hypothesis I will use
a spectrum analyzer based on the one
described by Mesa Software’s John
Bars
Ehlers, a frequent Stocks & MARCH Com- 2011 • Technical Analysis of STOCKS & COMMODITIES magazine
modities author. For those who like
mathematics and engineeringPlease and contact Karen Moore with approval or changes:
are interested in learning how digital
signal processing works, I recommend
checking out Discrete-Time Signal phone: (206) 938-0570 • fax: 206-938-1307 • email: KMoore@Traders.com
Processing, listed in “Suggested read-
ing.” It is not the only book out there Amplitude in dB 6–9 3–6 0–3 Date
on this topic, but it is one I have kept FIGURE 3: S&P 500 daily spectrum (July 2010–September 2010). Here the 80-day cycle has been detected.
since my university days. Its period is identical to a 16-week cycle.
PROOF #1
Without going into details on the
internals of the spectrum analyzer, I will mention the one I
built had a high-pass filter for detrending, a low-pass filter for
smoothing, and bandpass for selecting the range of frequen-
cies (cycle periods) of interest. Ehlers wrote a comprehensive
article for traders on this topic.
I built the analyzer software using Visual Basic for applica-
StockSpotter.com VERSION
By John F. Ehlers
tion in Excel. I did so because I did not want to get stuck with
any trading platform limitations and peculiarities. The program
analyzes the data and plots relative strength and duration of the
detected cycle as a surface graph. The time progresses horizon-
tally and the cycle period is plotted along the vertical axis.
Taking the most current weekly price data for Standard & Actionable Trading Signals With Timing
Poor’s 500 and plotting data from October 2009 to September
All Results Are Tracked And Verifiable
10, 2010, I got the graph you see in Figure 2.
It is perfectly clear the cycle period with a duration of 16 to S&C readers PROMO CODE: TASC358
17 weeks has been detected and it has been fairly stable. If we
have a cycle of that duration, then it should translate into a cycle
of 80 to 85 days. To test this idea I took daily bar data and ran
it through the program (Figure 3). I got what I expected. For more information circle No. 16
Bars
4, the 16-week cycle was present in the
Tsx as well. The analyzer determined
that the larger cycle of about 22 weeks
became stronger than the 16-week one at
the beginning of August 2010. I interpret
this to mean we can rely on existence
Date Amplitude in dB 6–9 3–6 0–3
of cycles, but we cannot rely on their
FIGURE 4: TSX WEEKLY SPECTRUM (OCTOBER 2009–SEPTEMBER 2010). The 22-week cycle became strength. At certain points they weaken
dominant starting the second week of August 2010. and get replaced by others. To make
matters more complicated, even when
Spectrum a cycle is dominant, its period could vary. In other words,
cycles are not stationary.
The Tsx weekly spectrum you see in Figure 4 is a good example.
The period of the same cycle was fluctuating between 18 and 15
weeks. Or perhaps I should say that the sinusoidal approximation
of the cycle was interpreting the price data that way.
At MetaStock, we know that charting software needs to do more than just... well, chart. That’s why every version
of MetaStock includes the MetaStock Power Tools – a robust set of features that take technical analysis to a whole
new level. They include the MetaStock Explorertm which can scan a universe of securities to find the ones that fit
YOUR criteria, the MetaStock Expert Advisortm with its on-the-fly expert input, and the MetaStock System Testertm
that can back-test multiple securities against multiple systems. If this sounds like the sort of tools you want in
your trading arsenal, give us a call or click. We’ll give you a free 30-day trial*, including our world class Thomson
Reuters data. We’re pretty confident that once you get used to the power... you’re not going to want to give it up.
* Free trial requires valid credit card. Free trial does not include shipping and handling or exchange fees. This is neither a solicitation to buy or sell any type of financial instruments, nor intended as
investment recommendations. All investment trading involves multiple substantial risks of monetary loss. Don’t trade with money you can’t afford to lose. Trading is not suitable for everyone. Past
performance, whether indicated by actual or hypothetical results or testimonials are no guarantee of future performance or success. NO REPRESENTATION IS BEING MADE THAT ANY ACCOUNT
WILL OR IS LIKELY TO ACHIEVE PROFITS OR LOSSES SIMILAR TO THOSE SHOWN. IN FACT, THERE ARE FREQUENTLY SHARP DIFFERENCES BETWEEN HYPOTHETICAL PERFORMANCE
RESULTS OR TESTIMONIALS AND THE ACTUAL RESULTS SUBSEQUENTLY ACHIEVED BY ANY PARTICULAR TRADING PROGRAM. Furthermore, all internal and external computer and software
systems are not fail-safe. Have contingency plans in place for such occasions. Thomson Reuters assumes no responsibility for errors, inaccuracies, or omissions in these materials, nor shall it be
liable for any special, indirect, incidental, or consequential damages, including without limitation losses, lost revenue, or lost profits, that may result from reliance upon the information presented.
Bars
45 the end of 2007. Taking onto account that the cycle
top is 90 degrees (Figure 7), we can conclude that
this 8.8-year cycle top was about to be reached
or had already been reached, depending on how
much smoothing was applied.
39 Now let’s move the clock forward and see what
was going on in 2008. From Figure 8 you can see
6
8
/06
/07
/08
1/0
0/0
1/0
1/0
1/0
/30
/28
7/3
3/3
7/3
3/3
7/3
11
11
11
Amplitude in dB 6–9 3–6 0–3 months or 3.5 years. By the end of March 2008
FIGURE 8: S&P 500 MONTHLY CHART (2006–08). A new dominant cycle of 42 months became visible
its phase was 83 degrees. This suggested it was
from March 2008. By the end of March 2008 its phase was 83 degrees. This indicates that it was the last the last warning to exit the market if you had not
warning to exit the market. By the end of December the phase was 182 degrees. done it yet. By the end of December, its phase
progressed to 182 degrees.
analysis literature, so our 106-month cycle seems realistic. Of To remind you about what happened in 2007 and 2008 with
course, its estimated period would vary slightly, depending on the S&P 500, I included the candlestick weekly price chart
how the spectrum analyzer filters were tuned. (Figure 9). I also plotted simple moving averages of half and
It would be nice to know what phase that cycle was in by one-eighth of the cycle period. Since Sma is easy to under-
the end of 2007. Naturally, out of curiosity I think it would stand, this demonstrates that any basic Sma-based systems
be enlightening to establish whether the cycle was going to (crossovers or prices moving above/below) would warn you
about the dominant cycle going
down if the period was determined
correctly. The periods I took in this
example were 90 and 22 weeks:
MarketSmith® was designed to help you supplement “WOW! The integrated functionality is a great
your technical investment routine. All of the data you way to have all your information in one window.
need in one centralized location to help you generate better Compatibility with MAC is a big plus. Intuitive
ideas, analyze investments and make decisions confidently and easy to use.” – Joe V.
while saving time in the process. MarketSmith provides:
• Over 200 customizable search criteria screens that fi lter
through a database of over 10,000 stocks and funds.
GET 2 WEEKS PLUS COACHING
• Sophisticated idea generating reports, in-depth analysis,
and organizational list management features. FOR JUST $19.95
• Access to the O’Neil Database® – institutional quality data 800.452.4422 marketsmith.com/sc1
that is scrubbed and vetted by a team of over 50 highly
trained analysts.
• A seamlessly integrated online investment tool compatible
with Mac and PC.
Get the most out of your investment routine with the research T A K E C O N T R O L O F Y O U R I N V E S T M E N T L I F E.
power of MarketSmith.
©2011 MarketSmith, Incorporated. All rights reserved. MarketSmith® is a registered trademark of MarketSmith, Incorporated. The O’Neil Database ® and all data contained herein is
provided by William O’Neil + Co. Incorporated and is used by MarketSmith under license agreement.
Bars
42
the beginning of September 2010.
The spectrum in Figure 10 reveals that as of
the end of August 2010, the same 42-month 36
cycle is still dominant. Its period did not re-
/06
/07
/08
/09
0
1/0
0/0
1/0
1/0
1/0
1/0
1/0
1/1
0/1
/30
/30
/28
/30
ally change (41.48 months), and its calculated
7/3
3/3
7/3
3/3
7/3
3/3
7/3
3/3
7/3
11
11
11
11
phase is 31.2 degrees. Since I am using weekly Amplitude in dB 6–9 3–6 0–3
data now up until September 10, 2010, I will
calculate how this cycle looks on weekly bars. FIGURE 10: S&P 500 MONTHLY (JULY 2007–AUGUST 2010). As of the end of August 2010, the
Its period is 167 weeks and its phase is 63.7 42-month cycle is still dominant, which is the same dominant cycle as in spring 2008. Its calculated phase
degrees. To me, this is a sign of caution even
is 31.2 degrees.
STOCKCHARTS
now, we can plot Smas using this
new cycle and use it as a warning
line (Figure 11). FIGURE 11: WEEKLY CHART OF S&P 500 (2009–SEPTEMBER 2010) WITH 13- AND 53-WEEK SMA. Price action
The periods used are 53 and 13 is going above and below 53 weeks SMA. The crossover of the two moving averages occurred in July 2010.
weeks as half and one-eighth of
the cycle period. If you translate
this into days, which you probably already have, you will was just a peek through the keyhole, and it led to discovering
see these periods are almost identical to the commonly ac- why one of the most popular Sma combinations often works.
cepted 200- and 50-day Smas. The popularity of using these I hope you are intrigued now as I am.
two Smas in technical analysis is more understandable and
perceptible. Arthur Zernov is a private investor and technical analysis
consultant. He has been a member of the Market Technicians
Do cycles exist? Association (Mta) and the Canadian Society of Technical
I went through this exercise to falsify the initial nullification Analysts (Csta) since 2009. He can be reached at arthur_zer-
hypnosis, which is that there are no cycles in market price nov@yahoo.com.
data. But can we say for certain that cycles exist? Not yet.
But we can declare that the statement that they don’t exist is Suggested reading
incorrect. We also recognized that sinusoidal approximation Ehlers, John [2008]. “Measuring Cycle Periods,” Techni-
is a good method of looking at market data to identify peaks cal Analysis of Stocks & Commodities, Volume 26:
and troughs. This approximation produces cyclical sinusoids March.
that are not stationary. They can expand and contract in their Kirkpatrick, Charles D., and Julie R. Dahlquist [2006]. Techni-
periods, but what is more interesting is that their amplitudes cal Analysis: The Complete Resource For Financial Market
become stronger or weaker at certain times. Technicians, FT Press.
These observations open a door to an intriguing quest to Oppenheim, Alan V., and Ronald W. Schafer [1988]. Discrete-
understanding markets from a different angle — an angle of Time Signal Processing, Prentice Hall.
harmony among cycles, events, and market behavior. This ‡StockCharts ‡Microsoft Excel S&C
Speculating in silver holdings in Slv will likely be required Silver futures and options: Comex
I want to speculate in silver, but I don’t to pay interest to their brokerages for the (Commodity Exchange, a division of the
have the margin or the risk tolerance for borrowed shares. In addition, Etfs are Cme Group) requires a trader to have
futures. Is there a better way? only tradable about nine hours per day, $10,056 in his or her account to hold one
Speculation in silver is challenging but asset values are fluctuating for 24! full-sized silver futures contract over-
in many ways, and recent volatility has Determining market direction and night. If you aren’t familiar with silver
magnified the risks. There are essentially timing is difficult enough; adding interest futures, one contract represents 5,000
four ways to speculate in silver prices: charges makes it worse for traders. The troy ounces of silver and equals a $50
exchange traded funds (Etfs), foreign drawbacks of Etfs is in contrast to the profit or loss per penny of price move-
exchange, futures (including options advantages of trading silver futures. ment. In some months it isn’t uncommon
on futures), and bullion. However, there for silver to move $0.50 in a single trad-
are few I would feel comfortable recom- Silver in FX: US–based futures and forex ing session, and not many retail traders
mending to most retail traders, simply firms must register with the National are willing to stomach swings of $2,500
because they have certain drawbacks. Futures Association and due to recent ($50 x $0.50) per contract per day. As a
Nonetheless, I’d like to provide a quick regulation cannot provide clients with result, they look to the option market for
overview of the realities and allow you access to silver and gold via a forex ac- a venue in which to speculate.
to decide for yourself which might be count. In my opinion, if US regulators However, they may be better off look-
best for you. One thing is for sure: there have gone as far as to say these products ing elsewhere. Silver option traders face
is no such thing as easy money when it shouldn’t be offered to US clients by US such wide bid/ask spreads that it seems
comes to trading silver. brokerage firms (of course, traders can nearly impossible to profit. In addition
open overseas accounts), it’s probably to a liquidity problem, the options tend
Silver Etfs: The popularity of Etfs is best to steer clear. For an entire product to be overpriced, forcing long option
soaring, and along with it has come the to be eliminated, red flags are waving. traders to bet the farm, or settle on deep
advent of specialized Etfs aimed at hot out-of-the-money options.
commodity markets such as gold and Silver bullion: Owning “stuff” has its The solution? I like the idea of mini
silver. Some silver Etfs are made up of appeal. However, as a bullion holder you silver futures; they are one-fifth the size
silver mining companies rather than the will need space in your home or garage, of the original contract and allow the
shiny metal itself and subject to price or deal with storage and insurance fees. trader to speculate with a lower level of
changes tied to company, industry, or Many bullion dealers charge little in leverage. Each penny of price movement
market-specific risks. Thus, they aren’t commission for brokering the bullion is worth $10 to a mini futures trader, so
a pure speculation on silver prices. So deal, but they aren’t working for free. a 50-cent day would be equal to $500
unless your interest lies with the miners Bullion dealers charge investors a large — more tolerable than $2,500. And
themselves, this seems like a relatively bid and ask spread when buying or selling unlike Etfs, mini–silver futures traded
unappealing option for a silver trader. metals; I’ve seen the price vary by $2 or on the Nyse–Liffe exchange (the Cme
But there are silver Etfs based solely $3 per ounce from the assumed spot price Group version of mini silver is illiquid)
on the price of the metal, such as the or nearby futures price, which should be are available for trading nearly 22 hours
popular Slv; Slv shares are backed by figured into transaction costs. per day; there are no interest charges for
10 ounces of silver. Buy & hold investors So if an investor has to pay $30 per leverage or selling short, and there are
might find this to be a viable vehicle, but ounce for silver bullion but could buy certain tax advantages for those holding
those looking to speculate on the short it in a nearby expiring futures contract positions for less than a year. On the
side should look elsewhere. at $27, the dealer will come out ahead. other hand, futures are highly leveraged
Trading Slv from the short side Also, if you want to keep your silver vehicles and it is human nature for some
involves borrowing shares and paying on hand, you will pay a hefty shipping to overindulge in risk. Futures are not
interest to a brokerage firm to do so. and handling bill along with finding suitable for everyone.
Similarly, traders looking for leveraged storage space. S&C
Ptop
E “semi-cup.” The typical
Price
semi-cup formation is L4
like a completed cup cut
B C in half. This formation L3
has a distinct advantage
Figure 1: A textbook cup formation. This over an integrated cup: L2
is the typical cup formation.The price declines (seg-
ment A-B), lands low smoothly, and remains there
The price is relatively
for a while (segment B-C), and in the sequence it low and there is room L1
advances to where it was before the fall (segment for a prosperous upward Box
height
C-D), creating a cup-like formation. Often, it then movement (even when Pbot
falls back creating what is called “the handle of
the cup” (segment D-E) before moving on to new
the overall long-term B0 B1 B2 B3 B4
Box length
B5
Visualizing the semi-cup tion algorithm and the function f for MetaStock. In the second
In order to visualize a semi-cup formation, you will probably sidebar, “MetaStock Exploration for Semi-Cup Formation,”
need a curve. A curve that gives nice visual results is the graph you can see the code forPROOF
a MetaStock#4exploration that can
of the function: be used to scan a basket of tradables and identify the ones
who have formed a semi-cup.
f(t) = Min(ePtop, a(t–B5)10 + 0.98ePbot)
50 Examples
In Figures 3, 4, and 5 you can
see examples of the algorithm for
weekly charts. All three were found
18.990
using the MetaStock exploration
mentioned in weekly charts for
December 9, 2009. Figure 3 shows
a chart of Iac/InterActiveCorp
(Iaci) with a semi-cup curve
(parameter = 2). In Figure 4 the
Metastock
1.5
THE
STOCK
1.0
0.5
MARKET
The Wyckoff Method
Figure 6: semi-cup example in a daily chart. A MetaStock exploration in the daily chart revealed a nice
semi-cup formation for American Eagle Outfitters (gray shaded rectangle) on February 14, 1997. The semi-cup then
transformed into a cup and Amer gave an approximately 2,000% profit in the next two years.
45
Laboratory Corp N (daily) 35
25
20
15
10
Parameters
Tradable 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5
Safe and Secure since 1992 Abercrombie & Fit 66 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Bright Trading, LLC Amer Eagle Outfit 0 45 52 0 0 0 0 0
Apple Inc. 47 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Laboratory Corp N 0 147 212 0 0 0 0 0
Join hundreds of Bright Traders Worldwide!
Lamar Advertisa 82 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
• QUARTERLY TRAINING – register early! Urban Outfitters 83 126 0 0 0 0 0 0
• Free DON BRIGHT DINNER/WORKSHOPS Figure 9: results of a typical scan for semi-cups in a basket of us
stocks. Here is how the table of results from a typical scan for semi-cups looks like.
cHEcK OUT OUR WEBSITE fOR mORE INfO! The scan was performed for February 14, 1997, with MetaStock on daily charts of
US stocks using the code given in the sidebar “Semi-cup Exploration for MetaStock.
In this example, you can see that Laboratory Corp N has two semi-cups under way
Register early for our as of February 14, 1997. The duration of the first semi-cup is 147 bars (days) and
was identified using 2 as the parameter, while the duration of the second one is 212
NEW tRaiNiNg schEdulEs bars (days) and it was identified using 2.5 as the parameter.
Related reading
Kuhn, Gregory [1995]. “The Cup-With-
Handle Pattern,” Technical Analysis
of Stocks & Commodities, Volume
13: March.
Figure 10: possible implications of a semi-cup formation. A semi-cup Murphy, John J. [1986]. Technical
formation (red line) can either evolve into a cup or fail to do so. In the latter case it
is called “failed semi-cup” (black line). In the former case, the cup (with or without a Analysis Of The Futures Markets,
handle) either evolves into a strong bullish trend (blue line) or a “failed cup” (orange New York Institute of Finance.
line). In any case, if you decide to buy the tradable near the semi-cup lows (cyan O’Neil, William [1999]. 24 Essential
dot), you need to define clear technical targets and stop-loss levels. Lessons For Investment Success, McGraw-Hill.
_____[2002]. How To Make Money In Stocks, 3d ed.,
its internals or put additional conditions to concentrate only McGraw-Hill.
on the semi-cup formations of your preference. For example, Siligardos, Giorgos [2006]. “Identifying The Cup (With Or
you can add conditions about the trading volume between the Without The Handle),” Technical Analysis of Stocks &
early trending phase (from B0 to B2 in Figure 2) and the later Commodities, Volume 24: February.
round phase (from B2 to B5) of the formation. ‡MetaStock (Equis International)
You can also choose to be notified about a semi-cup
formation only when the latest closing price is close to the See the Subscriber Area at Traders.com for the code given in this
bottom of the formation to concentrate on cases where you article. See our Traders’ Tips section beginning on page 66 of this
could define a stop-loss order near your entry level. Finally, issue for additional code pertaining to this article. S&C
a serious enhancement would be to use
a recurring version of the algorithm
to increase its robustness. Recurring
formulas usually have a negative effect
on calculation speed, but many software
Magazines
programs offer external calculations via
dynamic linked library files that can Traders.com
help a great deal in terms of speed and Get the exact information
coding power. Articles you want online at the
Epilogue STOCKS & COMMODITIES
Often, the price of a stock falls, bottoms, Books
remains there for a while and eventually Online Store.
eases back up to where it was before the Software
fall, creating a cup-like formation. If the • PDF versions of past articles
overall market environment and/or the S&C Wear • Convenient credit-card transaction
fundamentals are supportive, the price
then surges to new highs; otherwise, the • File available for you to download as
price declines again. Hot Deals! soon as transaction is approved
The algorithm I presented here is • Prices start as low
suitable for both scenarios, since it Subscribe as $2.95
identifies the price at (or near) the bottom
• Full line of
of the cup. I believe it will be of great
interest and merit to all price-pattern Renew S&C products
followers. • Easy to start or
renew your
Giorgos Siligardos holds a doctorate in
TA09E2
subscriptions
mathematics and a market maker/trader
certificate from the Athens Derivatives
Exchange. He is a financial software
developer and scientific contributor in
http://store.traders.com
April 2011 • Technical Analysis of Stocks & Commodities • 45
It’s all in
the charts
Relying on candlestick patterns
meant that the trader believed
everything he needed to know
was in the price chart. This
meant that traders were con-
sidering the impact of weather
on the crop, the possibility of
disruptions in supply related
to war or epidemics, and any
other possible input to sup-
ply or demand. Economists
quantified this belief into the
efficient market hypothesis,
and the first precept of techni-
cal analysis — “Market action
discounts everything” — was
Nikki Morr
recognized as an idea worthy
of a Nobel prize.
From Art To Science Trends were a central theme
And Thrives
Dow theory. Technical analysis
is grounded in the idea that
trends exist and trend reversals
dictate a need to change the
ongoing investment strategy.
Professions are built on a body of knowledge and an underlying rationale that explains the Many indicators are designed
reasons behind the knowledge. Technical analysis is a professional undertaking, but little to identify the direction and
has been written about its foundational principles. strength of a trend, and most re-
search on technical analysis are
by Michael J. Carr, CMT, and Amber Hestla dedicated to the second precept,
To
“Prices move in trends.”
begin thinking about the philosophy of technical analysis, first of all, we must con- No investment methodology
sider why traders believe it works. The major textbooks in the field acknowledge would work if the third precept,
46 • April 2011 • Technical Analysis of Stocks & Commodities
“History repeats itself,” weren’t true. Long-term investors and irregular price movements that occur in smaller time dimen-
short-term traders attempt to find characteristics that worked sions. Prices can be thought of as a coastline on a map; they
in the past and assume they will work with some reliability in appear smooth on a globe, but that smoothness disappears as
the future. Candlestick traders noticed certain distinctive shapes the scale is refined.
that occurred over and over again. When point & figure charts Polish-born French mathematician Benoit Mandelbrot wrote
became popular, it did so because certain patterns proved to about this problem in a 1967 Science magazine article. It was
repeat themselves and these patterns offered clues to the future the first paper to introduce the concepts of fractal geometry.
direction of prices. The same was true about bar charts, as Of course, many technicians believe that markets are fractal,
repetitive patterns again proved to offer useful trading ideas. with Elliott wave proponents often claiming that fractals hold
These three concepts actually extend beyond technical the key to unlocking the mystery of future market movements.
analysis and are at the core of fundamental analysis as well. They usually define fractal to mean that market movements in
Markets discount what is known FEBRUARY 2010 • toTechnical
and allow investors Analysis
de- one time STOCKS
ofrelated
scale are & COMMODITIES
to moves magazine
in other time scales, usually
termine the fair value of a stock, or what it should be trading by a Fibonacci ratio. Technicians who make such statements
for. Sometimes the market will be wrong,
Please contactandKaren
the errors in probably
Moore haven’t or
with approval read much about fractal geometry.
changes:
the discounting process lead to investment opportunities.
When the error is recognized, the price will adjust to correct Richardson’s law
the mistake, and a new price phone:
trend will(206)
result.938-0570
This pattern•of
fax:Coastline
206-938-1307 • email:
measurements areKMoore@Traders.com
defined by Richardson’s law,
discounting and mispricing will occur over and over again, which states that the measured length was actually a function
and value investors who are patient will profit from it. of the measurement scale and defined by the relationship:
Essentially, what this says is that we can measure things law of stocks could be useful in predicting crashes.
better when we use more precise instruments. Mandelbrot’s Over the years, technical analysts have developed a body
conclusion is that irregular natural objects can be modeled of knowledge for the discipline. When the brilliant minds
using fractional relationships. The degree of the relationship who developed indicators consider why they should work in
differs based on the coastline, and in the markets, perhaps the light of the precepts, unlimited possibilities open for technical
degree of the relationship differs based upon the underlying analysis. It can lead to increased profitability and increased
fundamentals of the market. respectability. As technicians, we always focus on the practi-
While it is true that prices are set by buyers and sellers, cal, and this endeavor would be no different. Writing papers
motivations vary among the markets, and applying the same in the language of science can lead to acceptance in academia
2011 • Technicalfractal
Analysis of StockS
relationship would& becakin to expecting Richardson’s
ommoditieS and industry, creating higher-paying job opportunities.
constants to be the same for each coastline (they are not).
ntact Karen Moore with approval or changes: Going forward
Power law One problem in trying to apply strict mathematical rules to
312 • fax: 206-938-1307
6-938-0570 ext. Richardson’s law is similar to the• power lawKMoore@Traders.com
email: in that the latter the markets is that in some ways, markets offer an example
mathematical principle exists when the relationship between of the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. In quantum mechan-
the two variables can be explained by raising one to a power, ics, this principle notes that you can’t always measure two
as noted by the power stated (1-D) in Richardson’s law. Many things precisely. Measuring the speed of an electron alters
proof #1
things have been found to correspond to a power law, includ- its position, and you can’t define both with the same degree
ing the size of cities, the frequency of words in an article, and of precision at the same time. On a smaller scale, you can’t
even the structure of heartbeats in humans. measure market sentiment without having an impact on that
Incomes and other economic data follow a distribution sentiment once the results are released.
defined by a power law, which usually means that small val- This problem did not hold back the theoreticians of the
ues are common, and large values are relatively rare. Market early 20th century who were attempting to unlock the myster-
crashes, which are fairly rare events, follow this rule. Serious ies of the atom. Recognizing the nature of the problem and
research designed to identify the proper variables in the power discussing the theoretical underpinnings of price movement
may allow technical analysis to advance in the 21st century.
+
Stock Market Trends (W&A Publishing). He may be reached
® at marketstrategist@gmail.com.
Amber Hestla is an independent research analyst. Her work
has been featured in the Mta newsletter. She may be reached
at HestlaResearch@gmail.com.
Suggested reading
Caginalp, Gunduz, and Donald Balenovich [2003]. “A Theo-
Thank you for voting retical Foundation For Technical Analysis,” Journal of
NeuroShell Trader #1 Technical Analysis, Winter–Spring.
Mandelbrot, Benoit [1967]. “How Long Is The Coast Of
Artificial Intelligence Software Britain? Statistical Self-Similarity And Fractal Dimension,”
9 yeArS In A row! Science, May 5.
Just announced
New 6.0 & Power User versions
www.neuroShell.com
301.662.7950
S&C
What surprised
T im, how did you get interested The TI-59 wasn’t sophisticated enough me the most is the
in technical analysis? for what you had in mind. So what did number of individual
It had to have been back you do? traders who decided
when I was in graduate school. I had A friend called me out of the blue and
inherited a portfolio of securities, and I said, “Tim, we are going to buy you a
to leave their jobs to
started tracking them. Because I am visu- computer.” I said, “What for?” He said, trade on their own.
ally inclined, I began graphing them also. I “My wife won’t let me have one, and I
started doing some technical analysis then, know you’ll let me play with yours.” So I
and began using the computer at school at bought an Apple II. My rationale was that What did you do?
night to grind up some figures. Along the I was going to use it to keep my charts. I went to Loyola and asked the pro-
way, I found out a Merrill Lynch analyst fessor, whose name was Jim Schmit,
was working on technical analysis on the Is that what happened? if he would do some programming for
company’s mainframe at night when he I tried to do some programming, but me, and he said yes. We hired a couple
could get to the computer. I was intrigued I didn’t enjoy it. I didn’t have a knack of extra programmers, very, very good
by that. That was my first impression of for it. So I went back to the computer programmers, all students at Loyola, and
what computers could do. store, and I was asking the owner some put them in the playroom of my house.
questions, one of which was, “Is there They worked part-time at about $10 per
That would have been when computers any way to map the cursor to know hour or something. Within a two-year
were bigger than the size of a Starbucks what the value of a point beneath that period we had 56 employees, 27 of whom
coffee shop these days. cursor was?” He told me no, that the were programmers.
About this time there was a program- Apple didn’t have enough horsepower By that time, I had formed a partner-
mable calculator called a TI-59, which to do that. ship with Jim and we called the company
had a little tiny card that you could put There was a kid standing behind me CompuTrac. I had the majority of the
your formulas in. I was intrigued so I from Loyola University who overheard stock and he had a lesser amount, and we
bought one, and I spent about a year us, and he told me that he had a professor apportioned off some of the rest early on
working with it, and it wasn’t long before who had developed something he called to a few people early on whom I had met
I was keeping about 100 charts to track a “Super Chip” that he used for character at conferences. They were technicians
my stocks. It would take three hours a generation, and it probably had enough Jim Sibbet, Manning Stoller, and Walter
night to post all of them. It was sort of power to do what I wanted. Bressert; and Rick Redmond, who was
hard to keep up. a broker in Jackson, MS. They decided
50 • April 2011 • Technical Analysis of STOCKS & COMMODITIES
Immediate feedback!
• “NEW” Profitunity Pro Package
• Eight weeks of daily DVD lessons unheard of! It cost $800 out of the factory.
• Video Study Guide It would show four colors, run like the That’s right. Nowadays it is common
• Tutorial Manual blazes and do technical analysis. That was to patch your own program or to get an
• 1 Year FREE support
• Autogenic Training Audio CDs what it was designed for. It was a graphic update pretty quickly. In those days it
• Traders Tip Sheets & Order Pads color computer that would outperform a wasn’t. We had to send out a new disk
• Access to Members Only area $12,000 Intel at that point. for an update every time. We eventually
• Courses for Stocks, Futures & Forex
got around that by using our own small
Indicators Compatible with:
Sounds promising! server computer. I would not even call
• eSignal™ • CQG™ • MetaStock™ • TradeStation™
It was! I sold a thousand of these to it a server, really. It would only handle
858-756-0692 • PROFITUNITY.com Market Information. I sold another thou- two people at once. People could call
For more information circle No. 13 sand to Reuters, and another thousand to in and get updated, or get a patch. We
Knight-Ridder in London. It was at this were extremely early on the uses of the
point we decided to sell out to another Internet to offer updates for the users. We
to share the cost with us. It turned out company. I talked first to Reuters, who would send everybody an email notice
it was going to be considerable, so we came down with all their engineers and that a patch was available. That sounds
made the group a little bigger, ending tried to figure out what we were doing. humdrum now, but it was ahead of its
up with 30 members. Eventually, we Jim Schmidt was smart enough to throw time then.
offered it to the public so we didn’t have them a bunch of curves. Because they We did a lot of innovative things. I
to keep putting up money. That’s when thought they knew everything we were owe a lot to Jim Schmit and our pro-
we really took off. doing at that point, they dropped out. grammers for the programming side of
it. Jim was not interested in technical
What happened then? What did you end up doing? analysis. So I would push him to do the
So we got a huge loft that housed the I ended up selling the company to studies I wanted. I handled the sales.
programmers and the office staff. We Telerate. Telerate, of course, had offices On the simple Apple, we programmed a
realized that the Apple computers were all over the world at the time. We turned miniature version of a brokerage firm’s
insufficient for what I wanted to do, out two or three thousand of our comput- back office. We kept all the accounts.
which was to read a line tick by tick. We ers, and used those as the base platform. We kept multiple portfolios. We would
developed our own computer, and here Then when Ibm came out with their first balance them and give them summaries
again, Jim Schmit was the right man at model, Telerate decided for many reasons and do bookkeeping.
the right place. to switch to the Ibm system. So we had We also built testing into the original
to recode and recompile everything for system. That was built in very early,
Why is that? Ibm. where a person could build a system
Several years before that, he had given About this time I started holding con- and test it over a database of any length
one of his graduate students a project to ferences. From almost the beginning we they wanted to. When we were dealing
design a compact computer language. were holding domestic conferences for with these smaller computers, they had
Remember, in those days we didn’t our members. We had always been sort to do it in sections; they couldn’t do a
have much memory. We also didn’t have of a cooperative, emphasizing strong 10-year period. They had to break it up
much space for an operating system. He feedback on the part of the membership. into three-year blocks, and then carry
came up with a language that had less We never separated the programmers forward the results. That was quite an
than 14K of code operating system. It from the sales staff. They were always innovation too, but we were able to pull
was very small. As powerful, probably, close together so that when a customer it off. They didn’t move as fast as newer
as the Apple OS is on the iPhone these called in and complained about some- computers do now, but they essentially
days. However, it was fast. thing, the salesman could turn around did everything. And we had some very
Another graduate student was given a to somebody else who was a few steps smart programmers.
task that was equally interesting: Here’s away and say, “So-and-so programmed
a language — the one that the other stu- this. Let me let you talk to him.” We got Even after all these years, we still get
dent was designing — but we don’t have things done quickly. calls from time to time asking what
the chips yet to execute it. How would happened to Telerate.
the computer work? He spent two years Even now! Telerate for various reasons
designing the computer. lost a lot of space to Bloomberg, mainly
At that point we decided to build because Telerate charged for everything.
our own computer and marry those two You were charged for every little add-
concepts by the time the chip was ready. I on. The billing from Telerate got so
bought the first four chips for about $1,500 complicated that the big customers, the
per chip. We put the computer together large brokerage firms, the worldwide
and within weeks it was working. It was firms could not even understand their
52 • April 2011 • Technical Analysis of Stocks & Commodities
a product? like Wilder and Larry Williams. Larry Mark, Stan Ehrlich, Joe DiNapoli, and
No, but as I went along it just sort of called me and threatened to sue for my Mark Douglas were just a few. These
all fell into place. The only thing that use of his formula. I think it was about people have probably all written articles
I could add was that luck had a lot to the Williams’ %R. I told him that he for you.
do with it. Had that student not been published it, but he couldn’t copyright a
there that day at the computer store, I formula, but in my literature I was going Some of them certainly have.
would never have ended up meeting Jim to give him full credit. All I wanted to do, What it boils down to is that no mat-
Schmit and would have probably given I told him, was give people the tools they ter what tools you have, if you can’t get
up programming and gone back to doing needed that were already programmed. control of your emotions you are going
it by paper. Fortunately, he was the right Soon the originators realized I was being to blow yourself out of the water. Mark
person at the right place. straight with them. I was educating the Douglas may not be a technical analyst
public, and that their name had attribu- but he is dead-on correct that the psy-
It certainly inspired people to create tion with everything I did. chology of a trader is as important as
their own trading systems. Was that More often than not, they also became the tracing system. He turned out to be
your objective? speakers at our conferences. Over the a very good presenter. Technician and
Yes, I purposely inspired users to cre- years I used something like 183 speakers. researcher Nelson Freeburg is another
ate their own trading systems. I didn’t During the domestic conferences I would person who spoke at our conferences. He
dictate anything. I gave them a whole have as many as 30 or 35 speakers. We is a good researcher. There were many,
bunch of tools that had been in common would have five rooms with speakers many others who were also good.
use or that were well constructed. Think- going at any given time. There were Your publisher, Jack Hutson, pre-
ing back to J. Welles Wilder’s work, he some I would invite year after year. sented at a conference in Toronto. He
had a bunch of very good, well-thought- John Murphy was one. Walter Bressert was an early member of CompuTrac. He
out, programs. was another. Dick Arms, Gerald Appel, called me on a Saturday, and we spent
At the beginning, I ran afoul of a lot of Andrew Cardwell, Marc Chaikin, Dick two or three hours talking. He wanted
people who had published their works, Diamond, Barbara Diamond, Tom De- me to publish a newsletter on a regular
basis that would discuss what the studies
were, how to use them, their background,
and so on. At that point we were growing
very fast and I didn’t have the capacity to
take on an additional task so I told him if
he would do it I would give him our mail
list and I would do everything I could to
help him. He decided to do it and that’s
how your magazine got started.
…Coming soon!
by Wallace Wang
F
or many Wall Streeters, reading
The Wall Street Journal has
always been important for keep-
ing track of the latest financial news. In
an age where real-time stock quotes are
available over the Internet and financial
news stories change every few minutes,
however, the idea of relying on a physical
newspaper feels more and more anti-
quated every day. Fortunately, you can Figure 1: it’s all there. You can access the current day as well as a week’s worth of The Wall Street Journal.
avoid the drawbacks of carrying around
a physical newspaper and still enjoy the
editorial content of the Journal through to the print version of the Journal can Journal costs $6.99 a week, while the
the company’s free iPad app. get full access to the iPad version for a online version costs $2.99 a week.)
The Wall Street Journal iPad app is limited time. If you want complete access Besides allowing you access to all
free but limits access to roughly half of to the iPad version, you’ll have to pay content, paying for the iPad version also
all available stories. Paid subscribers $3.99 a week. (The print version of the lets you view the last seven days. So
you can not only read the full content of
today’s edition, but all the content of the
past week’s editions as well (Figure 1).
MARKET
the text can easily be enlarged or shrunk.
This ability means you can comfortably
read the Journal at any time.
While many people simply read the
The Wyckoff Method
version of the Journal they can buy at their
local newsstand, you might not realize
Figure 3: a more traditional structure. slightly different editions are published for
Menus can help you navigate between different sections the US, European, and Asian markets.
of the newspaper.
You could buy all three editions and
lug them around, or you could read all
three editions on your iPad without hav-
ing to carry anything extra. Just tap a
menu to choose which edition to read and
you’ll have access to slightly different
content targeted for a different market.
What makes the iPad version especially
useful is that it is never out of date. Buy
the print version of the Journal and all
the stories you see are already hours, if
Edited by Jack K. Hutson
not days old. Read the iPad version and 208 pages, 6x9 inches,
Figure 4: VIDEO CLIPS. Video clips focus on a specific
news story. These video clips act like watching a portion
as long as you have Internet access, you chart illustrations, indexed
of a regular newscast focused on just the information can read the latest stories as they appear, $14.95 plus shipping & handling.
ISBN: 0-938773-06-2
you want to know about. reducing the chance that you’ll be stuck
reading old news. Charting The Stock Market
describes and illustrates one of the
best pioneering technical analysis
Saving stories methods. This book takes the
If you found an interesting story in an reader step by step through the
ordinary print newspaper and wanted to Wyckoff method: first, the basic
keep it, you’d have to either photocopy principles; second, examples of the
it or clip it out of the paper, leaving a method applied to the bond market;
third, an outline of the steps to put
gaping hole that might slice another story the method to use. Details of the
in half on the other side. Wyckoff method covered in this
Fortunately, saving an interesting book include:
article on the iPad version does not ◆ Point & figure charting
Figure 5. CLIPPINGS. You can save a story within
mean you have to physically mangle ◆ Trends
the iPad app or by emailing a copy. the newspaper, rendering it impossible ◆ Relative strength and weakness
for use other than recycling. Just bring ◆ Stop orders
up a menu and you’ll have the choice ◆ Forecasting
Whereas the print version can only of saving the story or emailing a copy ◆ Wave charts & intraday
display static images to accompany an (Figure 5). Saved stories are accessible ◆ Group stock behavior
article, the iPad version can display either from the home screen of the Journal app, ◆ Stock selection criteria
fixed images or video clips. These clips allowing you to read them later at your ◆ Price/volume chart reading &
act like a portion of a regular newscast convenience (Figure 6). analysis
focused on just the information you want Since many people enjoy sharing ORDER TOLL-FREE: (800) 832-4642
to know about (Figure 4). articles they read, you can email a link ONLINE: Traders.com
Like any video clip, you can pause, to a particular story to a friend or to your or (206) 938-0570—24 hours
rewind, or fast forward while also seeing own computer so you can print out a copy
the total length of the clip. In addition, later if you wish.
you can expand the video so it fills the
entire iPad screen or watch it embedded Retrieving stock quotes
within the app. For years, one primary purpose of The 4757 California Ave. SW, Seattle, WA 98116 • 206 938-0570
One problem with print newspapers Wall Street Journal has been its extensive
April 2011 • Technical Analysis of Stocks & Commodities • 57
Does 1 + 1 = 2 or 1? For instance, a trader long an Ibm position. On the other hand, if I send a
Can I adjust a profitable long butterfly February 155/160/165 butterfly one time market order, I’m amazed at how often
prior to expiration and if so, how? Would (1 x ‑2 x 1) might decide later on to buy the average fill price is worse than the
it amount to being a smart approach for one February 160/165/170 butterfly. quoted market. Is there anything I can
this type of spread? The net position leaves the trader with do to help with this unwanted trend with
Good question. When dealing with a February 155/160/165/170 call condor my option positions?
open profits, it’s always important to (1 x ‑1 x ‑1 x 1). Part of your dilemma sounds like your
consider fresh alternative positioning Who would do this? A trader who still trading involvement has been in lesser- or
through the adjustment process. As far holds a range-bound technical opinion lighter-traded issues. One recommenda-
as executing goes, the simplest and a on shares but wishes to give the stock tion right off the bat would be to stick
perfectly reasonable adjustment would additional room either up or down (in this with more active and liquidly traded
be to lock in your profits by exiting the case, up) and is someone who might con- options. Believe it or not, they aren’t
long butterfly in full or partially. sider this type of adjustment worthwhile. always the same and not having both
A return on investment of 50% to 100% While the new position’s maximum risk conditions in place can be problematic
prior to expiration isn’t uncommon for a is increased and the maximum profit is when placing orders.
long butterfly. That’s impressive in some reduced, the probability of a profit is In general, sticking with stocks whose
ways, but the same profits will be a good increased, as they will have expanded front two-month contracts trade at least
deal less than the idealized maximum. the breakeven zone. several hundred calls and puts daily and
That can be annoying. But remember the Another possible adjustment would whose individual quoted markets show
old saying: “Don’t get mad, get even.” be to consider taking off one of the bid/ask spreads of no more than $0.05
Coupled with an appreciation for another verticals embedded in the butterfly if the to $0.15 wide for options under $3.00 is
old saying, “You get what you pay for,” technical opinion warrants such action. something to consider when trying to get
traders can redirect their focus and take For instance, in our Ibm illustration, if a fair fill in the market.
profits along the way rather than hold the trader had become bearish on shares, Another idea would be to look at
on for no good reason. selling the February 155/160 bull call conditional orders, which can be tied
This makes a good deal of sense as spread would leave the trader with one to either the stock or option price or
opposed to simply holding onto a paper February 160/165 bear call spread. both. What a conditional order does is
profit. Not only are butterflies generally This position, like the original but- hide your bid or offered contract from
slow to expand toward their maximum terfly, will also show its maximum loss the market maker who might otherwise
profit potential due to the razor-like (butterfly debit + bear vertical spread attempt to use your order flow to their
precision required of shares, it’s also an width – credit received “to close” bull advantage. From what I can tell about
unlikely outcome. Worse, those paper vertical) at expiration if shares con- your attempts at using limit orders,
gains could be quick to come undone tinue to rally above the long 165 strike. you seem to have a firsthand working
altogether. And while we may have However, the bear vertical will lock in knowledge of that concept.
“only” paid $0.40 or $0.50 to initiate its maximum profit potential if shares That said, conditional orders are main-
the butterfly, lots of small losses can hurt are below 160. tained by your broker’s internal trading
you over the long run. platform until certain conditions are
An alternative adjustment could be to Danged If I Do, Danged If I Don’t met, such as the option’s offer dropping
add another butterfly. In this case, though, I’ve had a consistent challenge involving to your hidden bid price. At that time,
one butterfly plus another doesn’t neces- the opening of option orders and getting your order is instantaneously put into
sarily add up to two butterflies. When a fills that I see as acceptable. With limit the marketplace to receive a fill at the
trader adds a second long fly, it’s typically orders, I feel as though my order never offered price.
designed to create an all-call or all-put gets executed until an unwanted move Contributing analysis by senior Optionetics
long condor by adding a wing to the old in the underlying stock occurs — and strategist Chris Tyler
fly’s center or middle strike. then, I’m less than excited about the S&C
MetaSwing 4
Northington Trading
9538 Alice McGinn Drive
Charlotte, NC 28277
Phone: 704 542-0156
Email: admin@metaswing.com
Twitter: @kirknorthington
Internet: www.metaswing.com
Product: MetaStock and TradeStation
add-on for volatility-based technical
analysis for traders of stocks, options,
and foreign exchange
Requirements: See Equis website
(needs MetaStock version 9.1 or
higher) or TradeStation website
Price: $99/month or $999/year
by Dennis D. Peterson
M
etaSwing is available as a set of
TradeStation EasyLanguage
and workspace files or as a Figure 1: chart of boeing (ba) using the metaswing 4.0 daily template. Blue and red arrows
MetaStock plug-in. MetaSwing uses identify potential changes in short-term price direction. Red and blue wavy lines are called N-bands and show high
and low price peaks and valleys based on historical volatility. Horizontal dashed red and blue lines show projected
historical price volatility as the basis for resistance and support and are based on the peaks and valleys of the two N-bands. Blue text identifies signals
building indicators. The previous review for possible entry. Two red and green ribbons below the price chart are trend indicators, while the two plots in the
of MetaSwing was for version 3.5, while subcharts at the bottom are trend-compensated overbought/oversold indicators.
this review covers version 4.
On the surface of it, not much has is new on the price portion of this chart the low price extremes are shown using
changed. Out of sight are the calculations are the words “buy” and “sell.” They are a wavy blue line and are referred to as
used to create two mechanical trading generated by one of the two mechanical N-bands. The horizontal dashed red and
systems. An attempt has been made to trading systems telling you it is time to blue lines are created by the peaks and
codify trading — that is, create a piece enter and exit a trade. What is also new are valleys of the two N-bands. Thus, the
of software reflecting the choices you revised and improved trend calculations N-bands represent current volatility ex-
make as a trader when using MetaSwing used for the green and red trend bands treme values, while the dashed horizontal
indicators. The beauty of doing this is shown below the price band. lines are projections forward. Because
that you can now trade this system over MetaSwing, as the name implies, is of MetaSwing’s fractal nature, these
various time frames, then collect and about swings and following a trend. But values are relative to the time frame of
analyze the outcome. of course what you want is an entry point the applied chart.
Before we examine the results, let at the beginning of the swing or trend. The Now that you can see how the blue
us first look at some of the MetaSwing approach followed by MetaSwing is to and red dashed horizontal lines are built,
indicators. use historical price volatility to find high note there are two extra pairs. That is
and low price extremes. The precedents because for the red high price peak and
MetaSwing templates for this approach can be found in option valley horizontal lines, another dashed
and indicators pricing, and for equities, the ability of Bol- line is added, one average true range
Using the M sw 4Daily template in linger bands to predict price change. (Atr) from each. The same thing is
MetaStock, you get a number of indica- Figure 1 may appear to be a bit busy, done for low price peak and valley lines.
tors on the price chart and four more in so I will explain what some of the pieces Why use Atr? Because you are looking
subcharts (Figure 1). Three additional are to make it easier to understand. Using for price extremes and prices that move
templates have been added for MetaSwing historical volatility, high price extremes outside of an Atr tend to revert to the
4, bringing the total up to eight. What are shown using a wavy red line, while mean. The red and blue dashed lines are
Suggested reading
Northington, Kirk [2009]. Volatility-
Based Technical Analysis, John Wiley
& Sons.
‡MetaSwing 4
Figure 4: Excerpt From Performance Report. The distribution analysis for both Adeo long and 123
long are covered in the report, and one page from the report is shown. What this page shows is that choosing
trades at random over an eight-year period of typical market behavior, within S&P 500 stocks, odds favor you’ll
make money. In fact, you stand a better chance of making 85% than you do of making ‑40%, but you should expect
13.3% — all of this without money management, complex stops, or the use of intraday data. S&C
Get a risk-free,
30-day trial of This new version brings the reliable, award-
eSignal, plus winning market data and charting software used
free weekly by thousands of traders into the next generation.
training.
The all-new eSignal helps you get better at what based charting for faster, self-defined analysis
you do best — turning opportunity into profit! � Hot Lists/Watch Lists — Scan for the best stocks,
eSignal has been completely redesigned from the select and apply your strategy and track your portfolio,
ground up — it’s faster, and the new design and all in one convenient view
functionality are exactly what you need to be a more � Trading integration, including money management
successful trader. planner and intelligent order placement —
Here’s just some of what you’ll discover: Automatically execute your trades with your choice of
� Out-of-the-Box Simplicity — Make better trades with broker, using preset multiple targets and stops
user-friendly software made for traders, by traders � Speed — Experience multi-core technology for the
� Advanced charting — Use drag-and-drop high-volume equity and derivatives markets
functionality, unlimited symbol overlays and other � Integrated Research Window — View powerful
enhancements designed for active traders company profiles, financials, earnings estimates,
� Full Customization — Format windows and work- analyst ratings, and so much more
spaces the way you need to see them; use object-
Call now to get your risk-free, 30-day trial*
and receive free weekly product training.
Award-Winning Products
The eSignal suite of products
has consistently been
800.435.1461
voted best by users worldwide www.eSignal.com/offer/sc
*All fees will be refunded to you, minus any taxes and applicable add-on service/exchange fees, if you cancel within the first 30 days of service. Call for details.
eSignal is a registered service mark of Interactive Data Corporation. x14338
NinjaTrader 7
NINJATRADER, LLC need to come up with various scenarios to of flexibility and is very user-friendly.
1236 Clarkson Street tackle different market conditions. Each chart is a free-floating window,
Denver, CO 80218 Judging by the features available in so there is no limit to the number of
Fax: 801 806-2591 NinjaTrader 7 (NT7), I assume the de- windows you can use. You can place
Internet: www.ninjatrader.com velopers created this product with trade charts of different time frames of the
Requirements: Window XP/ management as its focus. The product same instrument within one window.
Vista/7/2003; minimum screen has a very rich set of features aimed at When you do this, you’ll see that the data
resolution of 1024x768; minimum P4 making trading for scalpers, swing trad- along the horizontal axis is aligned with
processor or higher; Microsoft.Net ers, futures traders, currency traders, and the different time frames. This makes it
Framework 3.5; data provider equity traders more efficient. very easy to see the price relationships
Product: Trading software for the of the different charts.
active trader Installation and data You can also overlay charts with other
Price: Unlimited free version; payment Installation only took a few minutes. charts or indicators. In Figure 1 you can
plans vary for live trading. See website You need to enter a product license key. see a daily chart of the Nasdaq futures
NinjaTrader has partnered with several with the stochastic overlaid on it. What
by Jayanthi Gopalakrishnan datafeeds and brokerages. A complete is interesting here is that you can drag
list is available on the company’s web- and drop the indicator to determine the
Figure 1: charting features. The charting feature in NinjaTrader 7 is very flexible. You can overlay more than one chart, indicators on charts and indica-
tors on indicators.
Figure 1: TRADE
STATION, CUP FOR
MATION IDENTIFI
CATION INDICATOR.
Here is a daily chart of
CAK with the indicator
applied. The magenta Figure 2: BLOOMBERG, CUP FORMATION IDENTIFICATION INDICATOR. Shown
marker indicates that here is a chart of Laboratory Corp. (LH). In his article, Giorgos Siligardos shows a
all of the requirements chart of LH (Figure 7 in the article) that shows a shaded area where the semi-cup
for the _ cup have been would have formed and then failed. Here, we show LH ending in the area of the shaded
met on the bar that is box on the original chart, with the semi-cup forming before the point at which it failed
marked. to complete the cup formation.
Exiting a long position: For the test period 1/3/2000 to 1/6/2011, the average annual
• Use a trailing 25% exit, or return was 10.1% with a maximum drawdown of 25.6% on
• Protect 100% of a 15% or greater profit. 7/17/09 (see Figure 10). The drawdown was significantly
• Exit the next bar at the open using a market order. reduced by the addition of the simple market timing technique.
Although the average annual return was also reduced, the
Short positions were not tested. Sharpe ratio increased from 0.47 to 0.75, indicating a less
In Figure 9, I show the results of simulated trading on the risky approach.
Russell 1000 stocks, using the following parameters: The code and Eds file can be downloaded from www.
1. Maximum positions per day = 3 TradersEdgeSystems.com/traderstips.htm.
2. Maximum total positions allowed = 10 —Richard Denning
3. Choose weakest candidates using 32-bar Aiq relative info@TradersEdgeSystems.com
strength for AIQ Systems
F TRADERSSTUDIO: Identifying
Cup Formations Early
The TradersStudio code based on Giorgos F STRATASEARCH: Identifying Cup Formations Early
Siligardos’ article in this issue, “Identifying In “Identifying Cup Formations Early” in this issue, author
Cup Formations Early,” is shown at www. Giorgos Siligardos offers a nice premise. If cup formations
Traders.com. I devised a trading system us- can be identified early, prices will be relatively low and
ing 76 actively traded Nasdaq stocks to test the semi-cup stop-losses should be easy to set. There are, however, several
formation as an entry technique. The trading rules for the hoops one must go through to create a working system with
system are as follows: such an approach.
Although the semi-cup algorithm cannot be used for
• Using a daily time frame, enter a long position when a
backtesting, we ran a rather primitive backtest by identifying
semi-cup formation is first detected.
semi-cup formations six months prior. Then, after importing
• Enter the next bar at the open using a market order.
current prices, we were able to evaluate how frequently the
• Exit a long position after holding for 10 bars.
semi-cup formations led to a significant increase in prices in
Short positions were not tested. the following six months. In our tests, more than half of the
I used the EquitySizeEvenlyWithFilters trading plan to stocks did have significant price increases after signaling a
run a trading simulation. This trading plan comes with the semi-cup formation. Identifying when to exit those positions
TradersStudio software. I used the following parameters: was still an issue, since high volatility was often present, and
many stocks did not recover significantly during that time.
Session : parameter = 2, exitBars=10, startDte=0960102 Nevertheless, the early signal proved to be quite effective for
(01/02/1996)
those stocks matching the pattern correctly.
TradePlan: MaxPos=10,PerPeriod=80,
FilerType=0,PerPeriod=80 StrataSearch users can download a plug-in from the Shared
Area of the StrataSearch forum, allowing immediate access to
In Figure 11, I show the resulting equity curve, and in Figure
12, I show the resulting underwater equity curve. In the table in
Figure 13, I show the year-by-year returns for the system. The
total net profit for the period was $1,167,424 with a maximum
drawdown of $918,313 (59.5% on 11/20/2008).
The code can be downloaded from the TradersStudio website
at www.TradersStudio.com→ Traders Resources→ FreeCode
or www.TradersEdgeSystems.com/traderstips.htm.
—Richard Denning
info@TradersEdgeSystems.com
for TradersStudio
the semi-cup scan and charts (samples shown in Figures 14 Those who cannot access the library due to a firewall may
and 15). Users may also want to experiment with supportive paste the code (shown at www.Traders.com) into the Updata
trading rules that would provide early indications that the Custom editor and save it.
semi-cup is indeed turning into a full cup. A sample chart is shown in Figure 17.
—Pete Rast, Avarin Systems, Inc. —Updata Support team
www.StrataSearch.com support@updata.co.uk, www.updata.co.uk
The information in Traders’ Resource is the most accurate at the time of posting and is subject to change. Because the vendors posting to Traders’ Resource are responsible for their own listing, Technical Analysis, Inc. declines any and
all liability for any representations made by the businesses and individuals listed. Nor can Technical Analysis, Inc. endorse any business or individual listed on Traders’ Resource. Technical Analysis, Inc. makes no warranties, express
or implied, as to the accuracy and reliability of claims herein. You agree to release Technical Analysis, Inc., together with its respective employees, agents, officers, directors and shareholders, from any and all liability and obligations
whatsoever in connection with or arising from your use of Traders’ Resource. If at any time you are not happy with the information posted to Traders’ Resource or object to any material within Traders’ Resource, your sole remedy is to
cease using it. This list is updated frequently. If you are aware of a business that should be listed, please email us at Editor@Traders.com.
BROKERAGES Software
How to reach us
7 E*Trade 19 25 Jurik Research & Consulting 25 Subscriptions, address changes
etrade.com jurikres.com & back issues
For questions, address changes, or ordering
7 E*Trade 21 10 NinjaTrader, LLC 7 information for Technical Analysis of Stocks
etrade.com ninjatrader.com/tasc & Commodities, The Traders’ Magazine, or
4 MetaStock 33 Working Money, The Investors’Magazine, call
9 Fidelity 9 toll-free 800 832-4642 (800-Technical) or
fidelity.com/trading metastock.com/p-tasc 206 938-0570. Or e-mail us at circ@traders.
8 Interactive Brokers 3 19 Vector Vest 44 com. Or write to us at 4757 California Ave.
SW, Seattle, WA 98116-4499.
interactivebrokers.com vectorvest.com/sc Do your magazines arrive tattered and
1 PFG Best 29 20 Vector Vest 84 torn? Polybagging of magazines (domestic
delivery) is available for $6/year.
pfgbest.com/itscoming vectorvest.com/sc Single back issues from the current year
2 PFG Best 83 21 Ward Systems 48 (subject to availability) are $8 prepaid. Prior
neuroshell.com years are available as a complete library on
bestdirect.com/you
CD-Rom. Individual articles can be purchased
26 TradeStation 5 12 TC2000 2 from the Online Store at our website, Traders.
tradestation.com tc2000.com com.
29 MarketSmith 35 Editorial feedback
22 TD Ameritrade 27 We always want to know more about the needs
tdameritrade.com marketsmith.com/sc1 of our readers: What kinds of articles would
16 StockSpotter 31 you like to see more of? What do you find
useful? Address your written questions and
stockspotter.com comments to editor@traders.com or to: Editor,
courses/seminars 28 Sentient Trader 41 Stocks & Commodities, 4757 California
17 Bright Trading 44 sentienttrader.com Ave SW, Seattle, WA 98116-4499. Sorry, we
cannot perform research on individual finan-
stocktrading.com cial questions not related to this magazine and
13 Profitunity Trading Group 52 we cannot respond to all mail. Letters or emails
profitunity.com trading systems containing questions or information that other
readers may enjoy or that relate to our articles
24 Blue Wave Trading 18 or technical analysis topics may be published
BlueWaveTrading.com in our Letters to S&C column.
EXCHANGE TRADED FUND 23 OptionVue Systems 47
3 Blackrock/iShares/Bling 15 optionvuesystems.com
ishares.com/gold 15 Trading Concepts, Inc. 14 Editorial Resource Index
tradingconceptsinc.com
Product PAGE
LEGAL NOTICE Excel 12
27 Kinsella Media, LLC 53 websites Advanced GET 17
Sentient Trader 24
pimcocommoditieslitigation.com 14 Chartpattern 55 StockCharts 30
chartpattern.com MetaStock 38
1 PFG Best 29 WSJ iPad App 56
software MetaSwing 4 60
pfgbest.com/itscoming
5 AbleSys Corporation 23 NinjaTrader 7 64
11 StockCharts.com 51 TradeStation 66
ablesys.com
stockcharts.com Bloomberg 66
24 Blue Wave Trading 18
100 Stocks & Commodities 73 thinkorswim 67
BlueWaveTrading.com eSignal 67
traders.com
14 Chartpattern 54 Wealth-Lab 68
19 Vector Vest 44
chartpattern.com AmiBroker 68
vectorvest.com/sc AIQ 69
6 Interactive Data 63
20 Vector Vest 84 TradersStudio 70
advancedget.com/offer/sc
vectorvest.com/sc StrataSearch 70
NinjaTrader 71
To receive information on the products and services listed in the Editorial and Advertisers’ Indexes, go to: Traders.com/reader/ These Updata 71
indexes are published solely as a convenience. While every effort is made to maintain accuracy, last-minute changes may result in VT Trader 82
omissions or errors.
CLICK
To help our readers connect better with our advertisers, we have updated our reader
service process. Go to traders.com/reader/ and look for the alphabetized list of
our current monthly advertisers. Just follow the simple directions below and the
advertisers will get your requests the same day!
Click the box for each advertiser you’d like to hear from.
At the bottom of the list, click “continue” when finished.
or
Step 2: Simply fill out your name and address and click
“Send Request.” Your request will then be sent to the
advertisers you selected. And that’s it!
MAIL
T
rading liquidity is often over- very high volumes. The greatest number three-year period. Thus, all numbers in
looked as a key technical of dots indicates the greatest activity; this column have an equal dollar value.
measurement in the analysis futures with one or no dots show little Columns indicating percent margin
and selection of commodity activity and are therefore less desirable and effective percent margin provide
futures. The following explains how to for speculators. a helpful comparison for traders who
read the futures liquidity chart pub- Courtesy of CBOT wish to place their margin money ef-
lished by Technical Analysis of Stocks ficiently. The effective percent margin
& Commodities every month. is determined by dividing the margin
value ($) by the three-year price range of
Commodity futures contract dollar value, and then multiply-
The futures liquidity chart shown be- ing by one hundred.
low is intended to rank publicly traded
futures contracts in order of liquidity. Stocks
Relative contract liquidity is indicated Trading liquidity has a significant ef-
by the number of dots on the right-hand fect on the change in price of a secu-
side of the chart. rity. Theoretically, trading activity can
This liquidity ranking is produced by serve as a proxy for trading liquidity
multiplying contract point value times All futures listed are weighted equally and equals the total volume for a given
the maximum conceivable price motion under “contracts to trade for equal dol- period expressed as a percentage of the
(based on the past three years’ historical lar profit.” This is done by multiplying total number of shares outstanding. This
data) times the contract’s open interest contract value times the maximum pos- value can be thought of as the turnover
times a factor (usually 1 to 4) for low or sible change in price observed in the last rate of a firm’s shares outstanding.
visit TRADERS.COM
Online Store
Purchase articles, books,
software and more!
Free Trial Future turning dates JOIN TRADERS & INVESTORS WITH COMMON
INTERESTS AT UPCOMING WORLDWIDE EVENTS
Trade by Trade Live Action for S&P, Forex, Gold, Oil, Grains Commodity Futures Investing conference, seminars, exhibition
E-Mini’s, FOREX, Stocks, GOLD KeyTurningDates.com CommodityFuturesInvesting.com, TradersNightOut.com &
www.trendpro.com MeditativeInvestors.org. 850-FUTURES (850-388-8737)
got income?
Yes, You Can Cash In On Chaos! Certified
Chaos Traders Courses teach you how.
Learn to earn at http://moneytide.com?r=s
EMini MoonTide Hotline up 108 months in a row No Iron Condors • No Credit Spreads SOFTWARE
http://daytradingforecasts.com?r=s
www.ConsistentOptionsIncome.com
7 Profitable ETF Strategies
Real Time Stock Trading Signals
76% Average Win Rate, 2.62% Average Win,
83% Winners in 2010
Grow Your Trading Account with a Proven Strategy Trading Secrets? Requires only 5 minutes per day
www.PairTradeFinder.com ETFBandit.com
PersonalInvestorsHr.com
TRADING SYSTEMS
STOCKS - OPTIONS - FUTURES - FOREX
EDUCATIONAL SERVICES
500+ Trading Systems
Get a FREE options report from
on 1 Website
Market Taker Mentoring www.SystemRank.com
MarketTaker.com/freereport
April 2011 • Technical Analysis of STOCKS & COMMODITIES • 79
www.pfgbest.com
cal amount of money in the form of pip tions, including both proprietary plat-
markups, whether the customer makes forms and direct Api products. PfgBest
or loses money on a trade. As a result, created Typhoon as part of a strategy to
Fxcm earns consistent and transparent create and own technologies so clients
revenue per trade. are never at the mercy of vendors or S&C
Figure 19: VT TRADER, RSI WITH RSI SYSTEM. Here is a trading system on a
daily candle chart of the EUR/USD based on Peter Konner’s RSI with RSI system
described in his January 2011 article in S&C.
Figure 18: EXCEL, CUP FORMATION. This chart shows an example of a “good”
semi-cup as identified by the Excel program.
This leads me to the second feature I was able to add. By
using separate input and calculations worksheets, combined
interest from sources like Yahoo! Finance, then massage the with the Offset technique, I was able to add a very simple
data as appropriate for the “adjusted closes,” and place the “data windowing” capability on the calculations and chart
result into the workbook. worksheet. For additional details, see the Notes tab for the
In my previous Traders’ Tips for Excel, adding or chang- sections, “Calculation and chart worksheet usage” and “Play
ing data was a problem because the solution formulas were with it.” A sample chart output is shown in Figure 18.
coded on the same sheet and in the same rows as the input —Ron McAllister, EXCEL and VBA Programmer
data. Thus, the solution formulas were inextricably tied to the rpmac_xltt@sprynet.com
location of input data cells and to each other, and inserting
a new data row unavoidably screwed up these relationships
without necessarily producing any outward sign that some-
thing was broken.
In this month’s worksheet that I created, you may safely
F VT TRADER: COMBINING RSI WITH RSI
alter the input data because the calculations have been iso-
Our Traders’Tip this month is based on Peter Konner’s article in
lated from the input data using an input data sheet and a sepa-
the January 2011 issue of S&C, “Combining Rsi with Rsi.”
rate calculations sheet. You may freely add data rows to the
In the article, Konner describes a trading system using
InputPriceData worksheet at the top, bottom, or middle of
fast/slow Rsi indicators and fast/slow moving averages for
the data detail section. Or you may completely replace the
identifying potential longer-term trading opportunities with
data detail rows. Just observe the following caveats: 1) Make
the prevailing trend as well as potential shorter-term trading
a backup copy first. 2) Be sure you don’t disturb the location
opportunities against the prevailing trend. Konner only dis-
of the headings in row 10 of the input sheet or the computa-
cusses countertrend trading against prevailing downtrends;
tions in input sheet cells B7:C7. That is to say, do not insert
however, we have added an additional set of “quick buy/sell”
or delete rows of the input sheet between rows 1 and 10, in-
rules for countertrend trading against prevailing uptrends as
clusive. 3) Do update the symbol and company name in input
well. A sample chart is shown in Figure 19.
sheet cell B2 if you change securities (see the Notes tab for
We’ll be offering our modified version of Konner’s Rsi
additional details).
with Rsi trading system for download in our VT client fo-
The SemiCupCalcAndChart worksheet obtains its data
rums at http://forum.vtsystems.com along with hundreds of
from the input worksheet using Offset references relative to
other precoded and free trading systems. The specific trading
the headings in row 10 of the input sheet. For example, any
rules used by the trading system are explained in its Notes
cell on the calculations sheet that uses an Offset reference to
section. The VT Trader instructions for creating the trading
the input sheet of cell “B10+1 row” will always retrieve the
system are shown at www.Traders.com.
current contents of cell B11 (even if you just inserted three
To learn more about VT Trader, visit www.vtsystems.com.
rows above what was the previous row 11). Likewise, any for- —Chris Skidmore
mula using Offset reference cell “B10+4 rows” will now re- Visual Trading Systems, LLC
trieve the data that was in B11 before the rows were inserted. 212 871-1747, info@vtsystems.com, www.vtsystems.com
The data moved, but the Offset formula references did not.
S&C
There is a substantial risk of loss in trading commodity futures, options and off-exchange foreign currency products. Past performance is not indicative of future results.