Professional Documents
Culture Documents
02 - 1 Design of Weir - Subsurface Analysis
02 - 1 Design of Weir - Subsurface Analysis
Chapter 2_1
Design of Diversion Head works
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING Interaction aspects of water resources
WATER DEMAND- amount (Q/time), quality parameter
Large scale water diversion scheme Small scale water diversion scheme
P1 >> P2
a) Without shutter b) With shutter
Weir
pond pond
level level Shutter
Shutter
P =P2 P2
P Crest
Level
P1
P1=0
P1 << P2
a) Without crest b) With crest
Barrage
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Barrage
Weir
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Types Weirs
Basic layout of a
diversion structure
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Design of Weir
Failure by Piping:
• The seepage water increases porosity of the soil by
progressive removal of soil from beneath foundation.
Design of Weir
Design of Weir
Design of Weir
Design of Weir
Design of Weir
• If HL the total head loss between the upstream and the down
stream, and L is the length of creep, then the loss of head per
unit of creep length (i.e. HL/L ) is called the hydraulic gradient.
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Design of Weir
Design of Weir
L = CH
Design of Weir
ii) Safety against uplift pressure:
• The water seeping below the structure exerts an uplift pressure
on the floor of the structure.
• Ordinates of the H.G. line above the bottom of the floor
represent the residual uplift of water head at each point.
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Design of Weir
Design of Weir
• For equilibrium :
γw h’ = (γw G)t
• Subtracting t on both sides, we get :
h’- t = t(G - 1)
t = (h’-t )/(G-1) = h/(G-1)
Where,
(h’-t) = h is the ordinate of the H.G. line above the top
of the floor.
G= the submerged specific gravity of floor material.
• The thickness obtained by the above formula is generally
increased by 33% for factor of safety.
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Design of Weir
Note:
• Thickness of the floor designed by the above formula only for
the downstream floor.
Final Note:
Bligh’s theory is quite simple and convenient. Many of earlier
structures (the periods b/n 1910 to 1925) were designed based on
this theory. It is now used for the design of small structures or for
preliminary design of large structures.
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Design of Weir
Design of Weir
Design of Weir
Safety against piping:
• To ensure safety against piping to this theory:
L = C1 H H/L = 1/C1 H/L < 1/C1
Where, H is the head causing flow, and C1 is Lane’s creep
coefficient.
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Design of Weir
Example 1. The figure shown below shows a hydraulic structure
built on fine sand (C=15, C1=8.5), determine
a) Whether the percolation gradient is safe
b) Uplift pressure at point A, B and C at distance of 15, 25
and 35m from the upstream end
c) Thickness of the floor at these points .
Use Bligh's and Lane’s theories
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Design of Weir
Design of Weir
Solution (Lane’s theory):
a) Creep length
L = 2x6+1/3*35+2x8=39.67m
Hydraulic gradient i =H/L 4/39.7
1/9.92<1/8.5 ….safe
b) Uplift pressure head
at point A = 4-1/9.92 (2*6+15/3) = 2.29m
at point B = 4-1/9.92 (2*6+25/3) = 1.95m
at point C = 4-1/9.92 (2*6+35/3) = 1.61m
c) Thickness of the floor, t = 4/3(h/G-1)
at point A = 4/3*(2.29/2.24-1)= 2.46m
at point B = 4/3*(1.95/2.24-1)= 2.10m
at point C = 4/3*(1.61/2.24-1)= 1.73m
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Example 2:
Design of Weir
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Solution:
Design of Weir
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Design of Weir
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Design of Weir
Hint: Use the following table to calculate the uplift pressure
ordinate for each ordinate points.
Percolated Using Bligh’s Principle, CB Using Lane’s Principle, CL
length (L) (actual)=15.45 (actual)=7.88
Point
Horiz., Vert., Head lost ∑∆h Ordinate Head lost ∑∆h Ordinate
m m =∆L/CB level, m =∆L/CB level, m
1
2
3
.
.
.
13
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Design of Weir
Design of a vertical drop weir on Bligh's theory:
• Design of pucca floor and apron
L = CH
t = 1.33 (h/(G-1))
• Down stream pucca floor (L2) - empirical formula
L2 = 2.21 C(HL/13)½ for weirs having crest shutter
L2 = 2.21 C(HL/10)½ for weirs having no crest shutter
Where, HL = the total head loss;
L2 = the length of d/s pucca floor
L2 + L3 = 18 C(HL/13 * q/75)½ for weirs having crest shutter
L2 + L3 = 18 C(HL/10 * q/75)½ for weirs having no crest shutter
Design of Weir
Design of Weir
Design of weir wall:
Bligh has further given certain empirical formula for the design
of weir wall.
The base width of weir wall:
B = (H + d)/G
Where, B = base width of weir wall
H = height of weir body wall
d = h +Afflux
h = Depth attained over the crest during maximum
flow
G = Specific gravity of floor material.
The crest width :
Design of Weir
Example 3:
• Design a weir on a soil made up of coarse grained sand using
Bligh’s theory. The necessary data are as follows:
• Height of weir body wall, H =2.50m
• Height of falling shutters fixed on the crest of the weir =
1.0m
• Bligh’s creep coefficient, C = 12
• Depth attained over the crest during maximum flow, h =
2.00m
• Afflux caused at the obstruction = 0.75m
• Sp. gravity of the material, G = 2.25
• The u/s face of the weir is kept vertical
•
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Design of Weir
Solution:
The base width of body wall is given by formula:
B = (H + d)/G (Note: d = h + Afflux)
= [2.50+(2.00+0.75)]/ 2.25
= 3.50m
The crest width is given by:
a = 0.552 (H + d) = 0.552 (2.5 + 2.75)
= 1.79m
Creep length is given by:
L = C*HL (Note: HL = H+ height of shutter)
= 12*(2.50+1.00)
= 42m
Length of apron on the d/s side is given by:
L2 = 2.21C HL/13 = 2.21*12* 3.5/13
= 13.75m
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Design of Weir
Length of apron on the u/s side is:
L1 = L – (B+L2) = 42 – (3.50+13.75) = 24.75m
Design of Weir
Devices for increasing creep length:
• Cutoffs –
• are concrete made and used where impervious materials
can be reached and where boulders prevent the use of
sheet piling.
• Also used for stability of the structure against sliding.
• Sheet piles –
• Are interlocking steel sections used under the apron.
• Common depth of steel piles is 5 to 8 m but available up
to 20m.
• Should not be driven to a depth less than 2.5 to 3m for
economic reasons.
• Most economic position of sheet piles is at the u/s end of
the floor with a desirable depth of 10 to 20% of floor
length.
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Design of Weir
Design of Weir
1m
2.5m
0.30m
0.80m
5m 6m
Design of Weir
c) Khosla’s theory
• Currently, important hydraulic structures are designed based on
this theory.
• It is a method based on the principle of flow nets.
• The steady seepage of water does not creep along the bottom
contour of weir floor as stated by Bligh, but moves along a set
of stream lines .
High Low
Pressure Pressure
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Design of Weir
• Each streamline is at different potential along its path.
• The streamlines along with lines which connect them at equal
potential are represented by orthogonal set of curves called
flow net diagram.
Design of Weir
Design of Weir
i) Safety against piping
• The seepage water exerts a force at each point in the
direction of flow and tangent to the stream lines.
• This force (F) has an upward component from the point
where the stream turns upward.
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Design of Weir
• For the soil grain to remain stable, the upward components of
this force should be counterbalanced by the submerged
weight of the soil grain.
• This has the maximum disturbing tendency at the exit end ,
because the direction of this force at the exit point is
vertically upward, and full force act as its upward
components.
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Design of Weir
• The disturbing force at any point is proportional to the gradient
of pressure of water at that point (dp/dl).
Design of Weir
Design of Weir
Design of Weir
• Therefore, under critical condition, the critical exit gradient
is equal to:
(1-n)(G-1)
• For most of the river sands, G = 2.56 and n = 0.4 the value of
critical exit gradient is approximately equal to 1.
• Hence, an exit gradient equal to 1/4 to 1/5 of the critical
gradient is assumed for safety. It means that an exit gradient
equal to 1/4 to 1/5 has to be provided for keeping the
structure safe against piping.
• Piping failure start only when the exit gradient is unsafe for
subsoil on which the weir is founded.
• It is therefore absolutely necessary to have a reasonable deep
vertical cutoff at the downstream end of the d/s weir floor to
prevent undermining.
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Design of Weir
Table: Values of Khosla’s safe exit gradient for different types of soil
H 1
GE
d
Where,
H = Maximum seepage head
d = d/s cutoff depth
1 1 2
in which b / d
2
b = total floor length
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Design of Weir
ii) Safety against uplift - Method of Independent Variables:
• It is a method used to find uplift pressure at the key points in
a barrage or a weir foundation.
Key points: Junction points of the floor & pile lines, and
depressed floor bottom corners.
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Design of Weir
Design of Weir
Analytical Solution:
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Design of Weir
Example 1: Find the pressure at the key points for the structure
Below (sheet pile on the u/s)
E1 = 100%
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Design of Weir
Example 2: Find the pressure at the key points for the structure
below (sheet pile on the d/s)
C = 0%
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Design of Weir
Example 3: Find the pressure at the key points for the structure
below (No sheet pile)
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Design of Weir
Example 4: Find the pressure at the key points for the structure
below (Sheet pile in the middle)
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Design of Weir
Design of Weir
Dd D
C 19
b' b
Where,
b’ = distance b/n the two piles
b = Total length of the floor
D = depth of pile whose effect is to be considered
d = depth of pile on which the effect is considered
Take –ve for front water flow direction oriented keypoints &
+ve for backside oriented key points.
Design of Weir
2. Correction for thickness of the floor
• The standard is negligible thickness.
• To correct, take proportional pressure percentage
difference b/n pile bottom and floor top surface
proportional with the floor thickness.
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Design of Weir
3. Correction for slope
• Take the following correction factor:
bs
C s C
b'
Where, bs = horizontal length of slope; b = distance b/n two
piles that the sloping floor is located in.
• Use +ve for down slope and -ve for upslope.
• Applied only for key points, located at start or end of slope
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Design of Weir
1 1 2
5.28
2
1 2
E cos 1
0.287 29%
1 1
D cos1 0.199 20%
C 100 E 71%
1
and D 100 D 80%
1
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Design of Weir...
Design of Weir...
1 1 1 2 1 1 1 2
2 2 2 2
4.875 1 1.968
2 2
1 1
E 2 E cos1 1 0.708 70.8%
1
D D cos1 1 0.632 63.2%
2
1 1
C C cos1 1 0.564 56.4%
2
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Design of Weir...
Dd D
C 19 1.88% (Ve)
b' b
Design of Weir...
Dd D
C 19 2.89% ( Ve )
b' b
Design of Weir...
Design of Weir...
1 2
E 3 E cos1 0.37 37%
1 1
D 3 D cos1 0.254 25.4%
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Design of Weir...
Design of Weir...
Summary:
Design of Weir...
Exit Gradient(GE):
Let water be headed up to pond level (RL =158.0m)
H 1
GE
Where, d
H – Maximum seepage head =158.0-152.0 = 6m
d – d/s cutoff depth = 152.0-141.7= 10.3m
b – total floor length = 57m
α=b/d=57/10.3= 5.53
1 1 5.532
3.31
2
H 1 6 1
GE 0.105 1 / 9.53
d 10.3 3.31
Hence, the exit gradient is 0.105. i.e., 1 in 9.53 which is very
much safe.
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Assignment 5.
Develop a program on a spreadsheet for subsurface design of
weir/barrage using Khosla‟s method.
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Assignment 6
Develop a program on a spreadsheet for subsurface design of
weir/barrage using Khosla‟s method.
Answer:
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Assignment 7
Using Khosla’s method, determine the uplift pressures (at points E,
D, C, E1, D1) and exit gradient. Assume floor thickness of 1m.
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
Thank You
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING