Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A Comparative Analysis of Classified Loans and Their Provisions of Islamic and Conventional Banks in Bangladesh
A Comparative Analysis of Classified Loans and Their Provisions of Islamic and Conventional Banks in Bangladesh
Abstract
This study aims to assess classified loans and provisions for classified loans of conventional and Islami (shariah
based) banks of Bangladesh. The study applies both exploratory and multiple cross sectional (descriptive)
research design. The study is wholly based on secondary data expressed in quantitative way. Sample size of
the study is twenty-nine private commercial banks (PCBs) among which twenty-four banks are being operated
through conventional style of banking and five banks are being operated by Islami- shariah. Convenient and
purposive sampling technique was employed to choose representative samples. The study initially explored
the classified loans and provisions for classified loans of each selected banks and a separate ratio analysis was
made for twenty-four conventional banks and also for five shariah based banks respectively. For ratio analysis
five years’ data of each bank has been counted from of 2014 to 2018.The study found that Islami-shariah based
banks are better in loan maintenance than those of conventional Banks in Bangladesh. This study recommends
that classified loan management is necessary for sound development of banking sector, moreover development
of overall economic condition of a country.
Keywords: Classified Loan, Provisions for loans, Islami Shariah Based Banks, Conventional Banks.
1.0 Introduction
Loan classification is a process of assessing loan portfolios and assigning loans to categories or grades based on
the perceived risk and other relevant characteristics of the loans. It is also defined as accumulating or arranging
of loans and advances according to unclassified, sub-standard, doubtful and bad or loss. Provision against loan
is a strategy that banks adopt keeping money in order to prevent possible loan loss. It means keeping aside
predetermined money from the current year profit against possible loan losses. Bangladesh Bank emphasizes that
0.04
0.03
0.02
0.01
0
2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
Year
0.08
0.06
0.04
0.02
0
2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
Year
Chart 2: Average of ratio of classified loan of Conventional Banks
From the above table and chart it is observed that average ratio of classified loan of all conventional banks are
6.69% of total loan of 24 banks in 2014, 6.44 % of total loan of 24 banks in 2015, 6.66% of total loan of 24 banks
in 2016, 6.98% of total loan of 24 banks in 2017 and 8.31% of total loan of 24 banks in 2018. Over the last five
years the ratio is always above the 6%. The reason is that the ratio of classified loan of Basic Bank is huge that
is always above 50% over the last five years. From the table we also see that the ratio of classified loan of other
conventional banks is quite satisfactory, while the ratio of classified loan of basic bank is highly unsatisfactory.
Therefore, it has negative impact in the loan management of conventional banking industry of Bangladesh.
5.3: Comparison of classified loan between Islami banks and conventional banks
Table-3: Comparison of classified loan between Islami Banks and Conventional Banks
Particulars Years
2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
Average ratio of classified loans of Islamic banks 4.64% 4.57% 4.18% 4.01% 4.84%
Average ratio of classified loans of Conventional banks 6.69% 6.44% 6.66% 6.98% 8.31%
8.00%
7.00%
6.00%
Average ratio of classified
5.00%
loans of Islamic banks
4.00% Average ratio of classified
loans of Conventional banks
3.00%
2.00%
1.00%
0.00%
2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
Figure 01: Comparison of classified loan between Islami banks and conventional banks
From the above table and figure it is found that ratio of classified loan to total loan of conventional banks is above
6.20% over the last five years, which was quite unsatisfactory. On the other hand, we see that ratio of classified
loan to total loan of Islami shariah based Banks i is below 5% over the last five years, which was quite satisfactory.
Islami Banks are more effective and efficient in loan recovery than those of conventional banks in Bangladesh.
5.4: Analysis of provisions on loan of Islami banks
Table-4: Average of provisions for loan of Isiami Banks (Amount in Millions)
Year 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
Al-ArafaIslami Bank 2457 3190 3940 4819 5837
EXIM Bank Limited 3505 5797 7204 8732 10741
FSIBL 2955 3809 5086 7105 9349
Islami Bank Limited 13016 13463 14913 19938 23957
ShahjalalIslami Bank Limited 3049 2631 2327 2581 3820
Social Islami Bank Limited 3042 3494 4460 6360 8211
Total 28024 32384 37930 49535 61915
Average 4671 5397 6322 8256 10319
Source: Annual reports (2014-2018)
Average of Provision for Loan
10000
5000
0
2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
Year
Chart 4: Average of Provision for Loan of Islami Banks
8000
6000
4000
2000
0
2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
Year
Chart 5: Average of Provisions for Loan of Conventional Banks
12000
10000
Average of Provision for
8000 loans of Islamic banks
Average of Provision for
6000
loans of Conventional banks
4000
2000
0
2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
Figure 02: Compared provision against loan between Islami Shariah Based banks and conventional banks
From the above table and figure it is observed that there is a little bit difference in the trend of provision against
loan over the last five years for both Islami shariah based banks and conventional banks of Bangladesh. Loan
provision of Islami sharia based banks were higher than those of conventional banks in 2015, 2015, and 2017 but
in 2016 and 2018, the scenario is quite opposite. Overall provision against loans are increasing over the last five
years and it is true for both banking systems. Overall Islami Shariah based banks kept musch provision against loan
than those of conventional banks. From one perspective it a positive sign and form another perspective it is a
negative sign for any banking industry. By maintaining higher amount of provision the banks can recover their loss
form loan, and reduces the credit risk. But the problem is the banks can’t use that amount of money for earning
profit. Therefore, the profitability of the banks reduces.
From the above results and discussion, following hypotheses are supported and rejected
respectively.
H1: Islami Shariah based banks are doing better in collecting, managing and maintaining of Supported
classified loan than those of conventional banks.
H2: Conventional banks are doing better in collecting, managing and maintaining of classified loan Rejected
than those of Islami Shariah Based Banks.
H3: Islami Shariah based banks are doing better in protecting classified loans by keeping high Supported
provision for Classified loans.
H4: Conventional banks are doing better in protecting classified loans and loans by keeping high Rejected
provision for Classified loans.
References
Adhikary, B., K. (2006).”Nonperforming Loans in the Banking Sector of Bangladesh: Realities and Challenges”. Journal of BIBM, Bangladesh. Vol (vi, No.1).
Adhikary, B., K. (2008). “Impacts of laws related to settlements of NPLs of Commercial Banks in Bangladesh”. Journal of BIBM, Bangladesh, vol ix,
No.1.
Baral, J.,K. (2005).”Health check-up of commercial banks in the framework of CAMEL: A case study of joint venture banks in Nepal”. J. Nepalese
Bus. Stud., 2(1): 41-55.
Bonin, P., Huang, John., Yiping. (2001), “Dealing with the Bad Loans of the Chinese Banks,” Journal of Asian Economics, vol (12),197-214.
Islam, Tazul. (2012). “Factors Influencing Loan Classification of BHBFC- An Evaluation”. Bangladesh Res. Pub. J. 7(2): 201-211.
Muniappan, G., P. (2002). “The NPA Overhang- Magnitude, Solutions, Legal Reforms.” Paper presented at CII Banking Summit, Mumbai, April:
25-26. Unpublished.
Reza, Hassan. (1997). “Efficiency Through Competition: Comparison of Commercial Banks”. Journal of Business Studies, Faculty of Commerce,
Dhaka University, vol. 16(1), pp. 113-130.
Press Release: Circulars of Banking Regulation and Policy Department, Bangladesh Bank
Banking Regulation and Policy Department. (2006, June 05). Circular Number 01, Bangladesh Bank, Bangladesh.
Banking Regulation and Policy Department. (2006, June 05). Circular number 05, Bangladesh Bank, Bangladesh.
Banking Regulation and Policy Department. (2012, June 14). Circular number 07, Bangladesh Bank, Bangladesh.
Banking Regulation and Policy Department. (2012, September 23). Circular number 14, Bangladesh Bank, Bangladesh.
Banking Regulation and Policy Department. (2012, December 27). Circular number 19, Bangladesh Bank, Bangladesh.